Pseudorevertants of a lac promoter mutation reveal overlapping nascent promoters

Random sequences rapidly evolve into de novo promoters

How new functions arise de novo is a fundamental question in evolution. We studied de novo evolution of promoters in Escherichia coli by replacing the lac promoter with various random sequences of the same size (~100 bp) and evolving the cells in the presence of lactose. We find that ~60% of random sequences can evolve expression comparable to the wild-type with only one mutation, and that ~10% of random sequences can serve as active promoters even without evolution. Such a short mutational distance between random sequences and active promoters may improve the evolvability, yet may also lead to accidental promoters inside genes that interfere with normal expression. Indeed, our bioinformatic analyses indicate that E. coli was under selection to reduce accidental promoters inside genes by avoiding promoter-like sequences. We suggest that a low threshold for functionality balanced by selection against undesired targets can increase the evolvability by making new beneficial features more accessible.

Bacterial promoters initiate gene transcription and have distinct sequence features. Here, the authors show that random sequences that contain no information are just on the verge of functioning as promoters in Escherichia coli.

The sigma 70 subunit of RNA polymerase mediates a promoter-proximal pause at the lac promoter

The sigma(70) subunit of RNA polymerase plays an essential role in transcription initiation. In addition, sigma(70) has a critical regulatory role during transcription elongation at the bacteriophage lambda late promoter, lambda P(R'). At this promoter, sigma(70) mediates a pause in early elongation through contact with a DNA sequence element in the initially transcribed region that resembles a promoter -10 element. Here we provide evidence that sigma(70) also mediates a pause in early elongation at the lac promoter (plac). Like that at lambda P(R'), the pause at plac is facilitated by a sequence element in the initially transcribed region that resembles a promoter -10 element. Using biophysical analysis, we demonstrate that the pause-inducing sequence element at plac stabilizes the interaction between sigma(70) and the remainder of the transcription elongation complex. Bioinformatic analysis suggests that promoter-proximal sigma(70)-dependent pauses may play a role in the regulation of many bacterial promoters.

The sigma 70 subunit of RNA polymerase induces lacUV5 promoter-proximal pausing of transcription

The sigma(70) subunit of Escherichia coli RNA polymerase (RNAP) is a transcription initiation factor that can also be associated with RNAP during elongation. We provide biochemical evidence that sigma(70) induces a transcription pause at the lacUV5 promoter after RNAP has synthesized a 17-nucleotide transcript. The sigma(70)-dependent pausing requires an interaction between sigma(70) and a part of the lac repressor operator sequence resembling a promoter -10 consensus. The polysaccharide heparin triggers the release of sigma(70) from the paused complexes, supporting the view that during the transition from initiation to elongation the interactions between sigma(70) and core RNAP are weakened. We propose that the binding and retention of sigma(70) in elongation complexes are stabilized by its ability to form contacts with DNA of the transcription bubble. In addition, we suggest that the sigma(70) subunit in the elongation complex may provide a target for regulation of gene expression.

Dam- and OxyR-dependent phase variation of agn43: essential elements and evidence for a new role of DNA methylation

Phase variation of the outer membrane protein Ag43 in E. coli requires deoxyadenosine methylase (Dam) and OxyR. Previously, it was shown that OxyR is required for repression of the Ag43-encoding gene, agn43, and that Dam-dependent methylation of three GATC target sequences in the regulatory region abrogates OxyR binding. Here we report further characterization of agn43 transcription and its regulation. Transcription was initiated from a sigma(70)-dependent promoter at the G residue of the upstream GATC sequence. Template DNA and RNA polymerase were sufficient to obtain transcription in vitro, but DNA methylation enhanced the level of transcription. Analyses of transcription in vivo of agn'-lacZ with mutated Dam target sequences support this conclusion. Since methylation also abrogates OxyR binding, this indicates that methylation plays a dual role in facilitating agn43 transcription. In vitro transcription from an unmethylated template was repressed by OxyR(C199S), which resembles the reduced form of OxyR. Consistent with this and the role of Dam in OxyR binding, OxyR(C199S) protected from DNase I digestion the agn43 regulatory region from -16 to +42, which includes the three GATC sequences. Deletion analyses of the regulatory region showed that a 101-nucleotide region of the agn43 regulatory region containing the promoter and this OxyR binding region was sufficient for Dam- and OxyR-dependent phase variation

Escherichia coli strains that allow antibiotic-free plasmid selection and maintenance by repressor titration

We report the construction of two novel Escherichia coli strains (DH1lacdapD and DH1lacP2dapD) that facilitate the antibiotic-free selection and stable maintenance of recombinant plasmids in complex media. They contain the essential chromosomal gene, dapD, under the control of the lac operator/promoter. Unless supplemented with IPTG (which induces expression of dapD) or DAP, these cells lyse. However, when the strains are transformed with a multicopy plasmid containing the lac operator, the operator competitively titrates the LacI repressor and allows expression of dapD from the lac promoter. Thus transformants can be isolated and propagated simply by their ability to grow on any medium by repressor titration selection. No antibiotic resistance genes or other protein expressing sequences are required on the plasmid, and antibiotics are not necessary for plasmid selection, making these strains a valuable tool for therapeutic DNA and recombinant protein production. We describe the construction of these strains and demonstrate plasmid selection and maintenance by repressor titration, using the new pORT plasmid vectors designed to facilitate recombinant DNA exploitation.

Regulation of Pap phase variation. Lrp is sufficient for the establishment of the phase off pap DNA methylation pattern and repression of pap transcription in vitro

The pyelonephritis-associated pili (pap) operon in Escherichia coli is regulated by an epigenetic mechanism involving the formation of specific DNA methylation patterns characteristic of transcriptionally active (phase ON) and inactive (phase OFF) cells. The formation of pap DNA methylation patterns in vivo was previously shown to require the leucine-responsive regulatory protein (Lrp) and DNA adenine methylase (Dam). To monitor the binding of Lrp to pap DNA, an in vitro methylation protection assay was developed. Binding of Lrp to a Dam target site proximal to the papBA promoter (designated GATC(prox)) blocked methylation of this site and specifically repressed transcription. The DNA methylation pattern and transcription state are identical to those observed in vivo in phase OFF cells. To determine if binding of Lrp at GATC(prox) was necessary for repression of papBA transcription, we analyzed a pap mutation (pap-13) that reduced the affinity of Lrp for the GATC(prox) region. Binding of Lrp to pap-13 DNA was shifted to a promoter distal Dam target site (designated GATC(dist)). Lrp blocked methylation of GATC(dist) in the pap-13 mutant, but did not repress papBA transcription. Together, these results show that binding of Lrp to the GATC(prox) region is sufficient for the establishment of the phase OFF DNA methylation pattern and repression of papBA transcription.

Transcription of the Rhodobacter sphaeroides cycA P1 promoter by alternate RNA polymerase holoenzymes

These experiments sought to identify what form of RNA polymerase transcribes the P1 promoter for the Rhodobacter sphaeroides cytochrome c2 gene (cycA). In vitro, cycA P1 was recognized by an RNA polymerase holoenzyme fraction that transcribes several well-characterized Escherichia coli heat shock (sigma32) promoters. The in vivo effects of mutations flanking the transcription initiation site (+1) also suggested that cycA P1 was recognized by an RNA polymerase similar to E. coli Esigma32. Function of cycA P1 was not altered by mutations more than 35 bp upstream of position +1 or by alterations downstream of -7. A point mutation at position -34 that is towards the E. coli Esigma32 -35 consensus sequence (G34T) increased cycA P1 activity approximately 20-fold, while several mutations that reduced or abolished promoter function changed highly conserved bases in presumed -10 or -35 elements. In addition, cycA P1 function was retained in mutant promoters with a spacer region as short as 14 nucleotides. When either wild-type or G34T promoters were incubated with reconstituted RNA polymerase holoenzymes, cycA P1 transcription was observed only with samples containing either a 37-kDa subunit that is a member of the heat shock sigma factor family (Esigma37) or a 38-kDa subunit that also allows core RNA polymerase to recognize E. coli heat shock promoters (Esigma38). (R. K. Karls, J. Brooks, P. Rossmeissl, J. Luedke, and T. J. Donohue, J. Bacteriol. 180:10-19, 1998).

Transcriptional control of several aerobically induced cytochrome structural genes in Rhodobacter sphaeroides

To decipher how the synthesis of energy-transducing enzymes responds to environmental cues, the response of three Rhodobacter sphaeroides aerobic cytochrome gene promoters was analysed under different conditions. Two of these promoters are upstream of structural genes (ctaD and coxII) for individual subunits of the cytochrome aa3 respiratory complex. The third promoter is that for the cycFG operon, which encodes two c-type cytochromes of unknown function, cytochrome c554 and CycG. Primer extension analysis identified a single oxygen-responsive transcription start site for each gene. Utilizing operon fusions to Escherichia coli lacZ as a measure of promoter activity, transcription from the ctaD, coxII and cycFG promoters was approximately twofold higher when cells were grown at high (30%) oxygen tensions than under low (2%) oxygen or anaerobic (photosynthetic) conditions. Analysis of promoter function using specific host mutations indicated that loss of the R. sphaeroides FNR homologue, FnrL, causes a small, but reproducible, increase in cycFG and coxII transcription when cells are grown at 2% oxygen. However, neither the delta FnrL mutation nor alterations in sequences related to a consensus target site for the E. coli FNR protein increased function of any of these three promoters to that seen under aerobic conditions in wild-type cells. From this we conclude that FnrL is not solely responsible for reduced transcription of these three aerobic cytochrome genes under low oxygen or anaerobic conditions. When activity of these three promoters was monitored after cells were shifted from anaerobic (photosynthetic) conditions to a 30% oxygen atmosphere, it took several cell doublings for LacZ levels to increase to those found in steady-state 30% oxygen cultures. From these results, it appears that activity of these promoters is also regulated by a stable molecule whose synthesis or function responds slowly to the presence of high oxygen tensions.

The -45 region of the Escherichia coli lac promoter: CAP-dependent and CAP-independent transcription

The lactose (lac) operon promoter is positively regulated by the catabolite gene activator-cyclic AMP complex (CAP) that binds to the DNA located 61.5 bp upstream of the transcription start site. Between the CAP binding site and the core promoter sequence is a 13-bp sequence (from -38 to -50 [the -45 region]). The possible roles of the -45 region in determining the CAP-independent level of lac expression and in the CAP activation process were studied by isolating and characterizing random multisite mutations. Only a small percentage of mutants have dramatic effects on lac promoter activity. Among the mutations that did affect expression, a 26-fold range in lac promoter activity in vivo was observed in the CAP-independent activity. The highest level of CAP-independent lac expression (13-fold the level of the wild-type lac promoter) correlated with changes in the -40 to -45 sequence and required an intact RNA polymerase alpha subunit for in vitro expression, as expected for an upstream DNA recognition element. Mutant promoters varied in their ability to be stimulated by CAP in vivo, with levels ranging from 2-fold to the wild-type level of 22-fold. Only a change of twofold in responsiveness to CAP could be attributed to direct DNA sequence effects. The -40 to -45 sequence-dependent enhancement of promoter activity and CAP stimulation of promoter activity did not act additively. The mutant promoters also displayed other characteristics, such as the activation of nascent promoter-like activities overlapping lac P1 and, in one case, replicon-dependent changes in promoter activity.

RfaH enhances elongation of Escherichia coli hlyCABD mRNA

Escherichia coli hlyCABD operons encode the polypeptide component (Hly A) of an extracellular cytolytic toxin, as well as proteins required for its acylation (HlyC) and sec-independent secretion (HlyBD). Previous reports suggested that the E. coli protein RfaH is required for wild-type hemolysin expression, either by positively activating hly transcript initiation (M. J. A. Bailey, V. Koronakis, T. Schmoll, and C. Hughes, Mol. Microbiol. 6:1003-1012, 1992) or by promoting proper insertion of hemolysin export machinery in the E. coli outer membrane (C. Wandersman and S. Letoffe, Mol. Microbiol. 7:141-150, 1993). RfaH is also required for wild-type levels of mRNA transcribed from promoter-distal genes in the rfaQ-K, traY-Z, and rplK-rpoC gene clusters, suggesting that RfaH is a transcriptional antiterminator. We tested these models by analyzing the effects of rfaH mutations on hlyCABD mRNA synthesis and decay, HlyA protein levels, and hemolytic activity. The model system included a uropathogenic strain of E. coli harboring hlyCABD on the chromosome and E. coli K-12 transformed with the hlyCABD operon on a recombinant plasmid. Our results suggest that RfaH enhances hlyCABD transcript elongation, consistent with the model of RfaH involvement in transcriptional antitermination in E. coli. We also demonstrated that RfaH increases toxin efficacy. Modulation of hemolysin activity may be an indirect effect of RfaH-dependent E. coli outer membrane chemotype, which is consistent with the model of lipopolysaccharide involvement in hemolytic activity.

Altered (copy-up) forms of initiator protein pi suppress the point mutations inactivating the gamma origin of plasmid R6K

The R6K gamma origin core contains the P2 promoter, whose -10 and -35 hexamers overlap two of the seven binding sites for the R6K-encoded pi protein. Two mutations, P2-201 and P2-203, which lie within the -35 region of P2, are shown to confer a promoter-down phenotype. We demonstrate here that these mutations prevent replication of a gamma origin core plasmid. To determine whether or not the reduced promoter activity caused by these mutations is responsible for their effect on replication, we generated two new mutations (P2-245-6-7 and P2-246) in the -10 hexamer of the P2 promoter. Although these new mutations inhibit P2 activity as much as the P2-201 and P2-203 mutations, they do not prevent replication of the gamma origin core. Therefore, activity of the P2 promoter does not appear to be required for replication. We also show that the inability of the gamma origin to function in the presence of the P2-201 and P2-203 mutations is reversed by the hyperactive variants of pi protein called copy-up pi. This suppression occurs despite the fact that in vivo dimethyl sulfate methylation protection patterns of the gamma origin iterons are identical in cells producing wild-type pi and those producing copy-up pi variants. We discuss how the P2-201 and P2-203 mutations could inhibit replication of the gamma origin core and what mechanisms might allow the copy-up pi mutants to suppress this deficiency.

Organization and expression of the Rhodobacter sphaeroides cycFG operon

The Rhodobacter sphaeroides cycFG operon has been cloned, sequenced, and mapped to approximately coordinate 2500 of chromosome I. The cycF gene encodes cytochrome c554, a member of the class II family of soluble cytochrome c proteins. The cycF open reading frame includes a 20-amino acid extension at its N terminus which has not been detected in cytochrome c554. Antiserum against cytochrome c554 shows that this protein is localized to the periplasm of wild-type cells, which suggests that this N-terminal extension functions as a signal peptide. The predicted cycG gene product is a diheme cytochrome c with a subunit molecular mass of approximately 32 kDa. While a cytochrome with the properties predicted for CycG has not been reported for R. sphaeroides, we have tentatively identified this protein as a heme-staining polypeptide that is associated with membranes. CycG could have an overall structure similar to that of several other electron carriers, since the similarity between the predicted amino acid sequence of CycG and other multiheme cytochrome c proteins extends throughout the polypeptide. The cycFG transcript is approximately 1,500 nucleotides long and has a single 5' end 26 nucleotides upstream of the start of cycF translation. Expression of cycFG is regulated at the level of mRNA accumulation, since approximately fivefold-higher levels of both cycF-specific transcript and cytochrome c554 protein are detected in cell extracts from aerobic cultures in comparison with those from anaerobically grown cells. Although cytochrome c554 was detected under all growth conditions tested, the highest levels of this protein were found when cells generate energy via aerobic respiration.

In vitro transcription of pathogenesis-related genes by purified RNA polymerase from Staphylococcus aureus

The RNA polymerase (RNAP) holoenzyme of Staphylococcus aureus was purified by DNA affinity, gel filtration, and ion-exchange chromatography. This RNAP contained four major subunits with apparent molecular masses of 165, 130, 60, and 47 kDa. All four subunits of the RNAP were serologically related to the subunits of Escherichia coli E sigma 70 holoenzyme by Western immunoblot analysis. The 60-kDa subunit was subsequently isolated and found to react with a monoclonal antibody specific to the E. coli sigma 70 subunit. This sigma 70-related protein allowed E. coli core RNAP promoter-specific initiation and increased transcription by S. aureus RNAP that is unsaturated with sigma. We therefore suggest that this 60-kDa protein is a sigma factor. Purified S. aureus RNAP transcribed from the promoters of several important S. aureus virulence genes (sea, sec, hla, and agr P2) in vitro. The in vitro transcription start sites of the sea, sec, and agr P2 promoters, mapped by primer extension, were similar to those identified in vivo. The putative promoter hexamers of these three genes showed strong sequence similarity to the E. coli sigma 70 consensus promoter, and transcription by E sigma 70 from some of these promoters has been observed. Conversely, S. aureus RNAP does not transcribe from all E. coli sigma 70-dependent promoters. Taken together, our results indicate that the promoter sequences recognized by purified S. aureus RNAP are similar but not identical to those recognized by E. coli E sigma 70.

DNA sequence and transcriptional analysis of the tblA gene required for tabtoxin biosynthesis by Pseudomonas syringae

The tblA gene of Pseudomonas syringae is required for tabtoxin biosynthesis and is under the control of a regulatory gene, lemA. We have determined the nucleotide sequence of the tblA gene and identified the 5' end of the tblA gene transcript. The sequence of the tblA gene was identified to that of the recently reported open reading frame 1 gene of the tabA region of the BR2 chromosome. The open reading frame of the tblA gene potentially encodes a protein of 231 amino acids. mRNA from the tblA gene was detected at all phases of cells grown in minimal medium. This result is correlated with the constitutive production of tabtoxinine-beta-lactam (the biologically active part of the toxin) by P. syringae BR2R in minimal medium, as quantitated by a phenylisothiocyanate derivatization method.

The lactose operon-controlling elements: a complex paradigm

The lactose-controlling elements have been considered to be the simple paradigm of a cis-acting genetic regulatory system, containing a promoter whose activity is modulated by an operator and a catabolite gene activator protein (CAP)-binding site. The reality is considerably more complex. We now know that transcription is negatively regulated as a result of the repressor binding to three binding sites: the operator, a secondary repressor-binding site within the lacZ gene and a tertiary repressor-binding site upstream near lacI. In addition to the promoter, the lac-controlling elements contain five promoter-like elements. The physiological role, if any, of these promoter-like elements is not clear, although three of them can be activated by single base pair changes to give high levels of in vivo expression. Finally, the positive activator protein CAP has been found to bind to a secondary site which is coincident with the operator. No role has been identified for this secondary CAP-DNA complex.

delta-Aminolevulinate couples cycA transcription to changes in heme availability in Rhodobacter sphaeroides

In this paper, the response of the transcriptional control region of the Rhodobacter sphaeroides cytochrome c2 gene, cycA, to intermediates in heme biosynthesis was studied. To determine if cycA transcription was regulated by heme availability, several precursors or analogs of tetrapyrroles were tested. Addition of delta-aminolevulinate (ALA), the first committed intermediate in heme biosynthesis, was shown to inhibit cycA transcription initiation at both the upstream and downstream promoter regions. In addition, an ALA auxotroph, which can grow in the presence of high levels of ALA, showed a 5 to 7-fold reduction in steady-state transcription from cycA::lacZYA operon fusions. To identify genetic elements responsible for negative regulation by ALA, trans-acting mutants with increased expression of cycA were isolated that were resistant to growth inhibition by the heme analog cohemin. These cohemin-resistant mutants (Chr) have elevated levels of several cycA transcripts and they contain cycA transcripts that had not previously been detected in wild-type cells. In addition, cycA transcription in the Chr mutants continues after the addition of ALA. Finally, we found that Chr mutants have increased ALA synthase activity, suggesting that synthesis of cytochrome c2 and ALA synthase are controlled by a common gene product whose activity has been modified in these mutants. A model is presented to explain how changes in tetrapyrrole intermediates could provide an effective signal to control both cycA transcription and ALA synthase synthesis in R. sphaeroides.

An Escherichia coli rpoB mutation that inhibits transcription of catabolite-sensitive operons

The Escherichia coli rpoB636 mutant is defective in the transcription of lac and other catabolite-sensitive operons. The lac promoter variant, UV5, which is independent of cyclic AMP and the cyclic AMP receptor protein, CRP, was also defective in rpoB636 mutants. The activity of the lac UV5 promoter was restored to wild-type levels by deletion of cya (adenylate cyclase) or crp. Cyclic AMP and CRP apparently act as inhibitors of the rpoB636 RNA polymerase.

Translation initiation of IS50R read-through transcripts

IS50R (and Tn5) normally transposes at a low frequency, partly because cells containing this insertion sequence synthesize low levels of the transposase protein. Since the 5' end of the transposase gene is located next to the outer end of IS50R (and thus close to flanking host sequences), transposition into actively transcribed genes could result in the production of read-through transcripts that would encode the transposase. We have found that these read-through transcripts are made, but are translated poorly. We isolated mutations that increase translation initiation of transposase from read-through transcripts. Most of these mutations destabilize a potential RNA secondary structure in the ribosome binding site that could form in read-through transcripts, but not in normal transcripts. In vitro RNA secondary structure analysis has confirmed the predicted RNA secondary structure and the effects of mutations. We have shown that RNA secondary structure is the major factor limiting transposase expression from read-through transcripts.

Downstream deletion analysis of the lac promoter

We have generated a series of deletions in the downstream region of the lac promoter. The promoter activities of these mutations were compared by measuring the levels of beta-galactosidase gene expression in vivo. Our results show that deletion of downstream lac promoter sequences changes the promoter strength only two- to threefold. The effects of these deletions on transcription initiation site location were studied through primer extension assay of in vivo mRNAs. We found that the transcription start sites are primarily chosen as an approximate distance from the -10 region of the lac promoter; however, starts are sometimes manifested at a GAATT(C) sequence, which is identical to the wild-type preferred start site. lac promoter P2 and a newly identified promoter, P3, are transcribed in vivo at low levels. Catabolite activator protein complexed with cyclic AMP represses P2 and P3 expression in vivo. The secondary catabolite activator protein binding site plays at most a modest role in catabolite repression in vivo.

Evidence for two promoters for the cytochrome c2 gene (cycA) of Rhodobacter sphaeroides

Rhodobacter sphaeroides cytochrome c2 (cyt c2) is a periplasmic heme protein, encoded by cycA, that is required for photosynthetic growth and for one branch of the aerobic electron transport chain. cycA mRNA and cyt c2 are more abundant photosynthetically than aerobically. We report here that there are four cycA transcripts by high-resolution Northern (RNA) blot analysis, and we have mapped 10 5' ends by primer extension. Complementation of a cycA null mutant shows that there are at least two cycA promoters: one within 89 bp upstream of the translation initiation codon for a transcript beginning at -28, and at least one within 484 bp upstream for the remaining nine 5' ends. The 5' ends at -28 and -137 are more abundant in aerobically grown cells, while those at -38, -155, -250, and -300 are more abundant photosynthetically. DNA sequences with homology to the Escherichia coli sigma 70 consensus promoter sequence precede the 5' ends at -28 and -274, and there is weak homology upstream of the -82 and -250 ends.

Transcriptional regulation of the cytR repressor gene of Escherichia coli: autoregulation and positive control by the cAMP/CAP complex

The Escherichia coli cytR-encoded repressor protein (CytR) controls the expression of several genes involved in nucleoside and deoxynucleoside uptake and metabolism. The cytR promoter was identified by determining the transcriptional initiation site of the cytR gene. A chromosomal cytR-lacZ+ operon fusion was isolated and used to study the regulation of cytR. We show that cytR expression is negatively controlled by the CytR protein and positively affected by the cAMP/CAP complex. Footprinting studies with purified CAP protein revealed two CAP binding sites upstream of the cytR promoter. A previously described mutation (cytR*) in the cloned cytR gene, which results in the phenotypic suppression of a CytR operator mutation in the tsx P2 promoter, was analysed. DNA sequence analysis of the cytR* mutation revealed a G-C to an A-T base pair transition at position -34 bp relative to the translational initiation site of cytR. This point mutation activates a cryptic promoter that is stronger than the wild-type cytR promoter and leads to overproduction of the CytR repressor.