Effect of RNA secondary structure and modified bases on the inhibition of trypanosomatid protein synthesis in cell free extracts by antisense oligodeoxynucleotides

Modulation of RNA function by oligonucleotides recognizing RNA structure

Numerous RNA structures are responsible for regulatory processes either because they constitute a signal, like the hairpins or pseudoknots involved in ribosomal frameshifting, or because they are binding sites for proteins such as the trans-activating responsive RNA element of the human immunodeficiency virus whose binding to the viral protein Tat and cellular proteins allows full-length transcription of the retroviral genome. Selective ligands able to bind with high affinity to such RNA motifs may serve as tools for dissecting the molecular mechanisms in which they are involved. Such ligands might also constitute prototypes of therapeutic agents when RNA structures play a role in the expression of dysfunctional genes or in the multiplication of pathogens. Different classes of ligands (aminoglycosides, interacalating agents, peptides) are of interest to this aim. However, oligonucleotides deserve particular consideration. They have been extensively used in the frame of the antisense strategy. The apparent simplicity of this rational approach is, at first sight, very attractive. Indeed, numerous successful studies have been published describing the efficient inhibition of translation, splicing, or reverse transcription in cell-free systems, in cultured cells, or in vivo by oligomers complementary to an RNA region. However, RNA structures restrict the access of the target site to the antisense sequence: The competition between the intramolecular association of RNA regions weakens or even abolishes the antisense effect. Various possibilities have been developed to circumvent this limitation. This includes both rational and combinatorial strategies. High-affinity oligomers were designed to invade the RNA structure. Alternatively, triplex-forming oligonucleotides (TFO) and aptamers may recognize the folded RNA motif. Whereas the use of TFOs is rather limited owing to the strong sequence constraints for triple-helix formation, in vitro selection offers a way to explore vast oligoribo or oligodeoxyribo libraries to identify strong, selective oligonucleotide binders. The candidates (aptamers) selected against the TAR RNA element of HIV-1, which form stable loop-loop (kissing) complexes with the target, provide interesting examples of oligonucleotides recognizing a functional RNA structure through an important contribution of tertiary interactions.

Antisense effects of oligonucleotides complementary to the hairpin of the Leishmania mini-exon RNA

We investigated the binding and the translation inhibitory properties of hexadecamers complementary to the mini-exon sequence of the protozoan parasite Leishmania amazonensis. This targeted RNA region folds into a hairpin. Large differences were observed in the antisense properties of the different oligomers although their binding to RNA always requires the disruption of the stem region.

Antisense oligonucleotides containing modified bases inhibit in vitro translation of Leishmania amazonensis mRNAs by invading the mini-exon hairpin

Complementary oligodeoxynucleotides (ODNs) that contain 2-aminoadenine and 2-thiothymine interact weakly with each other but form stable hybrids with unmodified complements. These selectively binding complementary (SBC) agents can invade duplex DNA and hybridize to each strand (Kutyavin, I. V., Rhinehart, R. L., Lukhtanov, E. A., Gorn, V. V., Meyer, R. B., and Gamper, H. B. (1996) Biochemistry 35, 11170-11176). Antisense ODNs with similar properties should be less encumbered by RNA secondary structure. Here we show that SBC ODNs strand invade a hairpin in the mini-exon RNA of Leishmania amazonensis and that the resulting heteroduplexes are substrates for Escherichia coli RNase H. SBC ODNs either with phosphodiester or phosphorothioate backbones form more stable hybrids with RNA than normal base (NB) ODNs. Optimal binding was observed when the entire hairpin sequence was targeted. Translation of L. amazonensis mRNA in a cell-free extract was more efficiently inhibited by SBC ODNs complementary to the mini-exon hairpin than by the corresponding NB ODNs. Nonspecific protein binding in the cell-free extract by phosphorothioate SBC ODNs rendered them ineffective as antisense agents in vitro. SBC phosphorothioate ODNs displayed a modest but significant improvement of leishmanicidal properties compared with NB phosphorothioate ODNs.

Selective inhibition of cell-free translation by oligonucleotides targeted to a mRNA hairpin structure

Using an in vitro selection approach we have previously isolated oligodeoxy aptamers that can bind to a DNA hairpin structure without disrupting the double-stranded stem. We report here that these oligomers can bind to the RNA version of this hairpin, mostly through pairing with a designed 6 nt anchor. The part of the aptamer selected against the DNA hairpin did not increase stability of the RNA-aptamer complex. However, it contributed to the binding site for Escherichia coli RNase H, leading to very efficient cleavage of the target RNA. In addition, a 2'- O -methyloligoribonucleotide analogue of one selected sequence selectively blocked in vitro translation of luciferase in wheat germ extract by binding to the hairpin region inserted upstream of the initiation codon of the reporter gene. Therefore, non-complementary oligomers can exhibit antisense properties following hybridization with the target RNA. Our study also suggests that in vitro selection might provide a means to extend the repertoire of sequences that can be targetted by antisense oligonucleotides to structured RNA motifs of biological importance.

Perspectives in antisense therapeutics

Modulation of gene expression using oligonucleotides (oligos) is currently an area of intense activity, both from therapeutic, as well as research perspectives. To develop oligos as therapeutic agents, in addition to demonstrable biological activity, in vivo metabolic stability, tissue disposition and pharmacokinetics are important considerations. Oligodeoxynucleoside phosphorothioates are the first-generation antisense analogs that have been studied extensively, and are in clinical trials against a number of disease indications. In an effort to improve the antisense properties of these compounds, mixed-backbone oligos incorporating different chemical modifications have been synthesized and evaluated for antisense activity. The present review will provide an overview of the pharmacokinetics and toxicology following intravenous, intraperitoneal, subcutaneous and oral administration of mixed-backbone oligos as second-generation antisense therapeutics.

Inhibition of human TNF alpha and LT in cell-free extracts and in cell culture by antisense oligonucleotides

Antisense oligonucleotides (ODN), complementary to mRNA of human tumor necrosis factor alpha (TNF alpha) and lymphotoxin (LT) were tested for their ability to inhibit TNFs. TNFs production was studied in cell-free systems including wheat germ extract (WGE) and rabbit reticulocyte lysate (RRL). All ODN were effective in WGE at low concentration (0.2 microM), except those targeted to the 3' region of TNF alpha mRNA. A short ODN complementary to a common region between TNF alpha and LT inhibited both TNFs. In contrast, high ODN concentration (50 microM) was needed to inhibit LT mRNA translation in RRL, whereas no clear inhibition of TNF alpha was observed unless RNase H was added to the translation mixture. ODN effects on TNFs production by stimulated cell line in culture were also investigated. Three ODN-one located in the 5'-untranslated region, one spanning the AUG initiation codon and one downstream of this AUG-were the most effective sequences to decrease TNF alpha production. Two ODN targeted to the AUG initiation codon of LT were also able to inhibit its production. In conclusion we confirm the role of RNase H in cell free systems, and we found that there is no correlation between ODN efficiency in a cell-free system nor in cell culture. Efficient ODN could be used for in vitro investigation of the role of TNF alpha and LT in mechanism in which they are involved.

Targeting nucleic acid secondary structures by antisense oligonucleotides designed through in vitro selection

Using an in vitro selection approach, we have isolated oligonucleotides that can bind to a DNA hairpin structure. Complex formation of these oligonucleotides with the target hairpin involves some type of triple-stranded structure with noncanonical interaction, as indicated by bandshift assays and footprinting studies. The selected oligomers can block restriction endonuclease cleavage of the target hairpin in a sequence-specific manner. We demonstrate that in vitro selection can extend the antisense approach to functional targeting of secondary structure motifs. This could provide a basis for interfering with regulatory processes mediated by a variety of nucleic acid structures.

Double hairpin complexes allow accommodation of all four base pairs in triple helices containing both DNA and RNA strands

We investigated the binding of an antisense oligodeoxynucleotide to a stem-loop structure corresponding to the mini-exon sequence of the protozoan parasite Leishmania amazonensis. This oligomer was designed to anneal to the single-stranded region adjacent to the bottom of the hairpin and to fold back on itself, giving rise to a "double-hairpin" complex that involved a local triplex. This imposed the recognition, by the third strand, of a "purine" strand containing 6 interspersed pyrimidines out of 15 nucleic acid bases. The sequence of the complementary oligonucleotide was derived from the so-called pyrimidine motif; the third strand of the anti-mini-exon oligomer was parallel to the purine strand of the target. Electrophoretic mobility shift assays and footprinting studies demonstrated that such an antisense oligomer was able to bind to both the DNA and RNA versions of the Leishmania hairpin. These double hairpin complexes allowed the formation at pH 6.0 of a triple-stranded structure, despite the presence of 4 A:T*G and 2 G:C*T triplets out of 15.

Triplex-forming oligonucleotides trigger conformation changes of a target hairpin sequence

We used a DNA duplex formed between the 5' end of a 69mer (69T) and an 11mer (OL7) as a substrate for BamHI. The former oligonucleotide folds into a hairpin structure, the stem of which contains a stretch of pyrimidines in one strand and consequently a stretch of purines in the other strand. The oligomer 69T was used as a target for complementary oligodeoxypyrimidines made of 10 nt (OL1), 16 nt (OL5) or 26 nt (OL2) which can engage the same 10 pyrimidine-purine-pyrimidine triplets with the 69T hairpin stem. Although the binding site of OL7 did not overlap that of OL1, OL2 or OL5, the BamHI activity on 69T-OL7 complexes was drastically modified in the presence of these triplex-forming oligomers: OL1 abolished the cleavage by BamHI whereas OL5 and OL2 strongly increased it. Using footprinting assays and point-mutated oligonucleotides we demonstrated that these variations were due to different conformations of the 69T-OL7 complex induced by the binding of oligomers OL1, OL2 or OL5. Therefore, oligonucleotides can act as structural switchers, offering one additional mode for modulating gene expression.

Quinazoline-2,4(1H,3H)-dione as a substitute for thymine in triple-helix forming oligonucleotides: a reassessment

A major limitation in triple-helix formation arises from the weak energy of interaction between the third strand and the double-stranded target. We tried to increase the stacking interaction contribution within the third strand by extending the aromatic domain of thymine. We report here the use of 2,4-quinazolinedione as a substitute for thymine in the canonical TA*T triplet. The synthesis and the characterization of the quinazoline beta nucleoside Q and of its phosphoramidite derivative is described. Triple-helix- forming oligonucleotides incorporating Q have been prepared and their ability to form triplexes has been evaluated by UV-monitored thermal denaturation measurements. The introduction of one or multiple Q residues, either contiguous or remote from each other, slightly destabilized triple-stranded structures, whatever the nucleic acid base composition (pyrimidine or GT) of the third strand.

Targeting RNA structures by antisense oligonucleotides

The presence of folded regions in RNA competes with the binding of a complementary oligonucleotide, resulting in a weak antisense effect. Due to the key role played by a number of RNA structures in the natural regulation of gene expression it might be of interest to design antisense sequences able to selectively interact with such motifs in order to interfere with the biological processes they mediate. Different possibilities have been explored. A high affinity oligomer will disrupt the structure; if the target structure is solved one can take advantage of unpaired bases (bulges, loops) to minimize the thermodynamic cost of the binding. Alternatively, the folded structure can be accommodated within the complex via the formation of a local triple helix. Oligomers able to adapt to the RNA structure (aptamers) can be extracted by in vitro selection from randomly synthesized libraries comprising several billions of sequences.

Relative contribution of photo-addition, helper oligonucleotide and RNase H to the antisense effect of psoralen-oligonucleotide conjugates, on in vitro translation of Leishmania mRNAs

We investigated the properties of two antisense oligonucleotides, 11 alpha Pso and 14TMP, 11 and 14 nucleotides long, respectively, and conjugated to psoralen derivatives. These oligonucleotides were complementary to the mini-exon sequence of Leishmania amazonensis. Upon ultraviolet (UV) irradiation these oligomers were selectively cross-linked to DNA or RNA target sequences, either 14 or 35 nucleotides long. The yield of photo-addition was much lower on the longer targets than on the shorter ones, due to the presence of a hairpin structure. The co-addition of a helper oligonucleotide, whose binding site, on the 35-mer, was adjacent to that of the psoralen-derivatized antisense oligomer, improved the cross-linking efficiency. We then determined the effect of 14TMP on in vitro translation of Leishmania mRNA in cell-free extracts. Non-irradiated antisense oligonucleotide/mRNA complexes reduced the protein synthesis in wheat germ extract but not in rabbit reticulocyte lysate. Conversely, UV irradiation induced a 14TMP-dependent reduction of translation in reticulocyte lysate whereas the inhibition was not improved in the wheat germ extract. These results are discussed with respect to the involvement of RNase-H in the oligonucleotide-mediated effect on protein synthesis.

Gene transfer and antisense nucleic acid techniques

Attempts to suppress a harmful genetic trait by antisense means, or to restore a normal phenotype by gene transfer, attract much publicity. This is especially the case where clinical trials incorporating such methodologies have been initiated, such as antisense oligonucleotide therapies for some types of leukaemia, antisense gene-transfer therapy for a form of lung cancer, and gene-transfer therapies for adenosine deaminase deficiency, severe combined immunodeficiency disease, and various forms of cancer including brain tumours and melanoma. However, translation of laboratory success into treatment or control of disease is unlikely to be straightforward. Here, Nick Miller and Richard Vile summarize the rationale, problems and potential of such techniques as applied to parasitic disease.

The binding of an antisense oligonucleotide to a hairpin structure via triplex formation inhibits chemical and biological reactions

We have investigated the binding of a 26-mer antisense oligodeoxynucleotide to a 69-mer DNA hairpin with a 13 base pair stem, bearing an Rsa1 restriction site. The 5' part of the 26-mer annealed to a stretch of six purines at the bottom of the hairpin. The 3' part was designed to fold back to form a triplex with both the stem of the hairpin and with the sequence paired to its own 5' region. Using non-denaturing polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis, melting curves (Tm) and chemical footprinting, we were able to show the formation of a 'double-hairpin' complex between the 69-mer and the 26-mer antisense oligopyrimidines. The association was both sequence and pH-dependent. The formation of a double hairpin complex was shown to prevent the alkylation of the 69-mer DNA target by an oligonucleotide-nitrogen mustard conjugate and to selectively inhibit the action of Rsa1.

Antisense inhibition of AMEL translation demonstrates supramolecular controls for enamel HAP crystal growth during embryonic mouse molar development

During tooth development, enamel organ epithelial cells express a tissue-specific gene product (amelogenin) which presumably functions to control calcium hydroxyapatite crystal growth patterns during enamel biomineralization. The present studies were designed to test the hypothesis that amelogenin as a supramolecular aggregate regulates crystal growth during enamel biomineralization. Antisense oligodeoxynucleotide strategy was used in a simple organ culture system to inhibit amelogenin translation. Under these experimental conditions, antisense treatment prior to and during amelogenin expression resulted in inhibition of amelogenin translation products within immunoprecipitated [35S]methionine metabolically labeled proteins. To determine the efficiency of antisense treatment in this model system, digoxigenin-labeled oligodeoxynucleotides were observed to diffuse throughout the tooth explants including the target ameloblast cells within 24 hours. Ultrastructural analyses of amelogenin supramolecular assembly as electron-dense stippled materials in antisense treated cultures demonstrated dysmorphology of the extracellular enamel matrix with a significant reduction in crystal length and width. We conclude that secreted extracellular proteins form a supramolecular aggregate, which controls both the orientation and dimensions of enamel crystal formation during tooth development.

9-Aminoellipticine-derivatized alpha- and beta-oligodeoxyribonucleotides targeted to the cap of beta-globin mRNA: hybridization to natural and engineered mRNA, inhibition of translation, and improved effect of tandem chains

We studied the duplex stability and the antimessenger activity of 9-aminoellipticine-5'-functionalized alpha- and beta-anomeric DNA sequences complementary to the first 14 nucleotides of the rabbit beta-globin mRNA. The duplex formed by the beta-conjugate with the natural mRNA target possessed a marginally better stability to that of the duplex formed by the unfunctionalized compound, as measured by the thermal elution. The alpha-conjugate did not anneal to native mRNA, possibly due to the interference of the 9-aminoellipticine with the cap structure and, unlike the beta-adduct, was practically inactive as inhibitor of translation in a cell-free system. However, it did hybridize to an RNA construction containing the beta-globin mRNA plus an additional 50 bases in 5'. Surprisingly, translation from this construction was inhibited by the alpha-species in spite of the nonvicinity of the target to the cap. Both alpha and beta conjugates hybridized to a DNA 14-mer of the same sequence as that targeted onto the mRNA. Thermal denaturation and fluorescence spectroscopy showed that the drug brought no considerable stabilization to the duplex, the linker presumably being unfavorable to intercalation. An increased stability of the complex and a higher inhibitory effect on cell-free beta-globin translation were obtained with two contiguous beta-oligomers of which one was functionalized.

Inhibition of translation initiation by antisense oligonucleotides via an RNase-H independent mechanism

We have used alpha-oligomers as antisense oligonucleotides complementary to three different sequences of the rabbit beta-globin mRNA: a region adjacent to the cap site, a region spanning the AUG initiation codon or a sequence in the coding region. These alpha-oligonucleotides were synthesized either with a free 5' OH group or linked to an acridine derivative. The effect of these oligonucleotides on mRNA translation was investigated in cell-free extracts and in Xenopus oocytes. In rabbit reticulocyte lysate and in wheat germ extracts oligomers targeted to the cap site and the initiation codon reduced beta-globin synthesis in a dose-dependent manner, whereas the target mRNA remained intact. The anti-cap alpha-oligomer was even more efficient that its beta-counterpart in rabbit reticulocyte lysate. In contrast, only the alpha-oligomer, linked to the acridine derivative, complementary to the cap region displayed significant antisense properties in Xenopus oocytes. Therefore initiation of translation can be arrested by oligonucleotide/RNA hybrids which are not substrates for RNase-H.