L-DNAs as potential antimessenger oligonucleotides: a reassessment

Interrogation of mirror-image l-RNA-protein interactions reveals key mechanisms of single-stranded G-rich l-RNA cytotoxicity and a potential mitigation strategy

l-Oligonucleotides (ONs), the synthetic enantiomers of native d-nucleic acids, are being increasingly utilized in the development of diverse biomedical technologies, including molecular imaging tools, diagnostic biosensors, and aptamer-based therapeutics. Nevertheless, our understanding of how l-ONs behave in living systems falls far short of native d-ONs. In particular, despite the potential for an abundant l-ON-protein interactome, the extent to which l-ONs bind to endogenous proteins and the consequences of these interactions are unknown, posing a major hurdle towards engineering functional l-ONs with predictable intracellular behaviours. Towards closing this knowledge gap, we now report the first l-ON-protein interactome, revealing that a wide-range of nuclear proteins have the potential to bind l-RNA. Importantly, by focusing our study on cytotoxic single-stranded G-rich l-RNA sequences, our data reveal key protein interactions that contribute to the cytotoxicity of these sequences. Furthermore, we show that introducing 2'-O-methyl modifications into single-stranded G-rich l-RNA can decrease its cytotoxicity through reducing l-RNA-protein interactions, thereby demonstrating that a well-established strategy for mitigating the cytotoxic effects of antisense ONs may translate across the chiral mirror. Overall, these findings greatly deepen our understanding of the intracellular behavior of l-ONs and provide valuable guidance for the future development of safe and effective l-ON-based biomedical technologies.

Cross-chiral exponential amplification of an RNA enzyme

An RNA ligase ribozyme that catalyzes the joining of RNA molecules of the opposite chiral handedness was optimized for the ability to synthesize its own enantiomer from two component fragments. The mirror-image D- and L-ligases operate in concert to provide a system for cross-chiral replication, whereby they catalyze each other's synthesis and undergo mutual amplification at constant temperature, with apparent exponential growth and a doubling time of about 1 h. Neither the D- nor the L-RNA components alone can achieve autocatalytic self-replication. Cross-chiral exponential amplification can be continued indefinitely through a serial-transfer process that provides an ongoing supply of the component D- and L-substrates. Unlike the familiar paradigm of semiconservative nucleic acid replication that relies on Watson-Crick pairing between complementary strands, cross-chiral replication relies on tertiary interactions between structured nucleic acids "across the mirror." There are few examples, outside of biology, of autocatalytic self-replication systems that undergo exponential amplification and there are no prior examples, in either biological or chemical systems, of cross-chiral replication enabling exponential amplification.

L-DNA-Based Melt Analysis Enables Within-Sample Validation of PCR Products

The melt analysis feature in most real-time polymerase chain reaction (PCR) instruments is a simple method for determining if expected or unexpected products are present. High-resolution melt (HRM) analysis seeks to improve the precision of melt temperature measurements for better PCR product sequence characterization. In the area of tuberculosis (TB) drug susceptibility screening, sequencing has shown that a single base change can be sufficient to make a first-line TB drug ineffective. In this study, a reagent-based calibration strategy based on synthetic left-handed (L)-DNA, designated LHRM, was developed to confirm validation of a PCR product with single base resolution. To test this approach, a constant amount of a double-stranded L-DNA melt comparator was added to each sample and used as a within-sample melt standard. The performance of LHRM and standard HRM was used to classify PCR products as drug-susceptible or not drug-susceptible with a test bed of nine synthetic katG variants, each containing single or multiple base mutations that are known to confer resistance to the first-line TB drug isoniazid (INH). LHRM achieved comparable classification to standard HRM relying only on within-sample melt differences between L-DNA and the unknown PCR product. Using a state-of-the-art calibrated instrument and multiple sample classification analysis, standard HRM was performed at 66.7% sensitivity and 98.8% specificity. Single sample analysis incorporating L-DNA for reagent-based calibration into every sample maintained high performance at 77.8% sensitivity and 98.7% specificity. LHRM shows promise as a high-resolution single sample method for validating PCR products in applications where the expected sequence is known.

Probing the Conformational Restraints of DNA Damage Recognition with β-L-Nucleotides

The DNA building blocks 2'-deoxynucleotides are enantiomeric, with their natural β-D-configuration dictated by the sugar moiety. Their synthetic β-L-enantiomers (βLdNs) can be used to obtain L-DNA, which, when fully substituted, is resistant to nucleases and is finding use in many biosensing and nanotechnology applications. However, much less is known about the enzymatic recognition and processing of individual βLdNs embedded in D-DNA. Here, we address the template properties of βLdNs for several DNA polymerases and the ability of base excision repair enzymes to remove these modifications from DNA. The Klenow fragment was fully blocked by βLdNs, whereas DNA polymerase κ bypassed them in an error-free manner. Phage RB69 DNA polymerase and DNA polymerase β treated βLdNs as non-instructive but the latter enzyme shifted towards error-free incorporation on a gapped DNA substrate. DNA glycosylases and AP endonucleases did not process βLdNs. DNA glycosylases sensitive to the base opposite their cognate lesions also did not recognize βLdNs as a correct pairing partner. Nevertheless, when placed in a reporter plasmid, pyrimidine βLdNs were resistant to repair in human cells, whereas purine βLdNs appear to be partly repaired. Overall, βLdNs are unique modifications that are mostly non-instructive but have dual non-instructive/instructive properties in special cases.

Development of nucleic acid medicines based on chemical technology

Oligonucleotide-based therapeutics have attracted attention as an emerging modality that includes the modulation of genes and their binding proteins related to diseases, allowing us to take action on previously undruggable targets. Since the late 2010s, the number of oligonucleotide medicines approved for clinical uses has dramatically increased. Various chemistry-based technologies have been developed to improve the therapeutic properties of oligonucleotides, such as chemical modification, conjugation, and nanoparticle formation, which can increase nuclease resistance, enhance affinity and selectivity to target sites, suppress off-target effects, and improve pharmacokinetic properties. Similar strategies employing modified nucleobases and lipid nanoparticles have been used for developing coronavirus disease 2019 mRNA vaccines. In this review, we provide an overview of the development of chemistry-based technologies aimed at using nucleic acids for developing therapeutics over the past several decades, with a specific emphasis on the structural design and functionality of chemical modification strategies.

Inverse In Vitro Selection Enables Comprehensive Analysis of Cross-Chiral L-Aptamer Interactions

Aptamers composed of mirror-image L-(deoxy)ribose nucleic acids, referred to as L-aptamers, are a promising class of RNA-binding reagents. Yet, the selectivity of cross-chiral interactions between L-aptamers and their RNA targets remain poorly characterized, limiting the potential utility of this approach for applications in biological systems. Herein, we carried out the first comprehensive analysis of cross-chiral L-aptamer selectivity using a newly developed "inverse" in vitro selection approach that exploits the genetic nature of the D-RNA ligand. By employing a library of more than a million target-derived sequences, we determined the RNA sequence and structural preference of a model L-aptamer and revealed previously unidentified and potentially broad off-target RNA binding behaviors. These results provide valuable information for assessing the likelihood and consequences of potential off-target interactions and reveal strategies to mitigate these effects. Thus, inverse in vitro selection provides several opportunities to advance L-aptamer technology.

Anomeric DNA Strand Displacement with α-D Oligonucleotides as Invaders and Ethidium Bromide as Fluorescence Sensor for Duplexes with α/β-, β/β- and α/α-D Configuration

DNA strand displacement is a technique to exchange one strand of a double stranded DNA by another strand (invader). It is an isothermal, enzyme free method driven by single stranded overhangs (toeholds) and is employed in DNA amplification, mismatch detection and nanotechnology. We discovered that anomeric (α/β) DNA can be used for heterochiral strand displacement. Homochiral DNA in β-D configuration was transformed to heterochiral DNA in α-D/β-D configuration and further to homochiral DNA with both strands in α-D configuration. Single stranded α-D DNA acts as invader. Herein, new anomeric displacement systems with and without toeholds were designed. Due to their resistance against enzymatic degradation, the systems are applicable to living cells. The light-up intercalator ethidium bromide is used as fluorescence sensor to follow the progress of displacement. Anomeric DNA displacement shows benefits over canonical DNA in view of toehold free displacement and simple detection by ethidium bromide.

Cross-Chiral, RNA-Catalyzed Exponential Amplification of RNA

Informational macromolecules in biology are composed of subunits of a single handedness, d-nucleotides in nucleic acids and l-amino acids in proteins. Although this chiral uniformity may be expedient, it is not a chemical necessity, as demonstrated by the recent example of an RNA enzyme that catalyzes the RNA-templated polymerization of RNA molecules of the opposite handedness. This reaction, when carried out iteratively, can provide the basis for exponential amplification of RNA molecules and the information they contain. By carrying out thermal cycling, analogous to the polymerase chain reaction, and supplying oligonucleotide building blocks that comprise both the functional strand of RNA and its complement, cross-chiral exponential amplification was achieved. This process was used to amplify the l-RNA form of the hammerhead ribozyme, catalyzed by the d-RNA form of the polymerase. The resulting l-hammerhead exhibits the expected activity in cleaving a corresponding l-RNA substrate. Exponential amplification was also carried out within individual droplets of a water-in-oil emulsion. The ability to amplify enantio-RNAs, both in bulk solution and within compartments, provides a means to evolve cross-chiral RNA polymerases based on the function of the RNAs they produce.

Mass Spectrometry of Nucleic Acid Noncovalent Complexes

Nucleic acids have been among the first targets for antitumor drugs and antibiotics. With the unveiling of new biological roles in regulation of gene expression, specific DNA and RNA structures have become very attractive targets, especially when the corresponding proteins are undruggable. Biophysical assays to assess target structure as well as ligand binding stoichiometry, affinity, specificity, and binding modes are part of the drug development process. Mass spectrometry offers unique advantages as a biophysical method owing to its ability to distinguish each stoichiometry present in a mixture. In addition, advanced mass spectrometry approaches (reactive probing, fragmentation techniques, ion mobility spectrometry, ion spectroscopy) provide more detailed information on the complexes. Here, we review the fundamentals of mass spectrometry and all its particularities when studying noncovalent nucleic acid structures, and then review what has been learned thanks to mass spectrometry on nucleic acid structures, self-assemblies (e.g., duplexes or G-quadruplexes), and their complexes with ligands.

Integration of chemically modified nucleotides with DNA strand displacement reactions for applications in living systems

Watson-Crick base pairing rules provide a powerful approach for engineering DNA-based nanodevices with programmable and predictable behaviors. In particular, DNA strand displacement reactions have enabled the development of an impressive repertoire of molecular devices with complex functionalities. By relying on DNA to function, dynamic strand displacement devices represent powerful tools for the interrogation and manipulation of biological systems. Yet, implementation in living systems has been a slow process due to several persistent challenges, including nuclease degradation. To circumvent these issues, researchers are increasingly turning to chemically modified nucleotides as a means to increase device performance and reliability within harsh biological environments. In this review, we summarize recent progress toward the integration of chemically modified nucleotides with DNA strand displacement reactions, highlighting key successes in the development of robust systems and devices that operate in living cells and in vivo. We discuss the advantages and disadvantages of commonly employed modifications as they pertain to DNA strand displacement, as well as considerations that must be taken into account when applying modified oligonucleotide to living cells. Finally, we explore how chemically modified nucleotides fit into the broader goal of bringing dynamic DNA nanotechnology into the cell, and the challenges that remain. This article is categorized under: Diagnostic Tools > In Vivo Nanodiagnostics and Imaging Nanotechnology Approaches to Biology > Nanoscale Systems in Biology Diagnostic Tools > Biosensing.

Anomeric and Enantiomeric 2'-Deoxycytidines: Base Pair Stability in the Absence and Presence of Silver Ions

Dodecamer duplex DNA containing anomeric (α/β-d) and enantiomeric (β-l/β-d) 2'-deoxycytidine mismatches was studied with respect to base pair stability in the absence and presence of silver ions. Stable duplexes with silver-mediated cytosine-cytosine pairs were formed by all anomeric and enantiomeric combinations. Stability changes were observed depending on the composition of the mismatches. Most strikingly, the new silver-mediated base pair of anomeric α-d-dC with enantiomeric β-l-dC is superior to the well-noted β-d/β-d-dC pair in terms of stability. CD spectra were used to follow global helical changes of DNA structure.

Kinetics of heterochiral strand displacement from PNA-DNA heteroduplexes

Dynamic DNA nanodevices represent powerful tools for the interrogation and manipulation of biological systems. Yet, implementation remains challenging due to nuclease degradation and other cellular factors. Use of l-DNA, the nuclease resistant enantiomer of native d-DNA, provides a promising solution. On this basis, we recently developed a strand displacement methodology, referred to as ‘heterochiral’ strand displacement, that enables robust l-DNA nanodevices to be sequence-specifically interfaced with endogenous d-nucleic acids. However, the underlying reaction – strand displacement from PNA–DNA heteroduplexes – remains poorly characterized, limiting design capabilities. Herein, we characterize the kinetics of strand displacement from PNA–DNA heteroduplexes and show that reaction rates can be predictably tuned based on several common design parameters, including toehold length and mismatches. Moreover, we investigate the impact of nucleic acid stereochemistry on reaction kinetics and thermodynamics, revealing important insights into the biophysical mechanisms of heterochiral strand displacement. Importantly, we show that strand displacement from PNA–DNA heteroduplexes is compatible with RNA inputs, the most common nucleic acid target for intracellular applications. Overall, this work greatly improves the understanding of heterochiral strand displacement reactions and will be useful in the rational design and optimization of l-DNA nanodevices that operate at the interface with biology.

Direct Comparison of d-DNA and l-DNA Strand-Displacement Reactions in Living Mammalian Cells

To overcome technical challenges associated with the use of DNA strand-displacement circuits in vivo, including degradation by cellular nucleases, researchers are increasingly turning to bio-orthogonal l-DNA. Although enhanced stability and improved performance of l-DNA-based circuits within living cells are often implied, direct experimental evidence has not been provided. Herein, we directly compare the functional stability and kinetics of d-DNA and l-DNA strand-displacement in live cells for the first time. We show that l-DNA strand-displacement reaction systems have minimal "leak", fast reaction kinetics, and prolonged stability inside living cells as compared to conventional d-DNA. Furthermore, using "heterochiral" strand-displacement, we demonstrate that biostable l-DNA reaction components can be easily interfaced with native DNA inside cells. Overall, our results strongly support the broader adoption of l-DNA in the field of DNA molecular circuitry, especially for in vivo applications.

The model structure of the hammerhead ribozyme formed by RNAs of reciprocal chirality

RNA-based tools are frequently used to modulate gene expression in living cells. However, the stability and effectiveness of such RNA-based tools is limited by cellular nuclease activity. One way to increase RNA’s resistance to nucleases is to replace its D-ribose backbone with L-ribose isomers. This modification changes chirality of an entire RNA molecule to L-form giving it more chance of survival when introduced into cells. Recently, we have described the activity of left-handed hammerhead ribozyme (L-Rz, L-HH) that can specifically hydrolyse RNA with the opposite chirality at a predetermined location. To understand the structural background of the RNA specific cleavage in a heterochiral complex, we used circular dichroism (CD) and nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy as well as performed molecular modelling and dynamics simulations of homo- and heterochiral RNA complexes. The active ribozyme-target heterochiral complex showed a mixed chirality as well as low field imino proton NMR signals. We modelled the 3D structures of the oligoribonucleotides with their ribozyme counterparts of reciprocal chirality. L- or D-ribozyme formed a stable, homochiral helix 2, and two short double heterochiral helixes 1 and 3 of D- or L-RNA strand thorough irregular Watson–Crick base pairs. The formation of the heterochiral complexes is supported by the result of simulation molecular dynamics. These new observations suggest that L-catalytic nucleic acids can be used as tools in translational biology and diagnostics.

l-DNA Duplex Formation as a Bioorthogonal Information Channel in Nucleic Acid-Based Surface Patterning

Photolithographic in situ synthesis of nucleic acids enables extremely high oligonucleotide sequence density as well as complex surface patterning and combined spatial and molecular information encoding. No longer limited to DNA synthesis, the technique allows for total control of both chemical and Cartesian space organization on surfaces, suggesting that hybridization patterns can be used to encode, display or encrypt informative signals on multiple chemically orthogonal levels. Nevertheless, cross-hybridization reduces the available sequence space and limits information density. Here we introduce an additional, fully independent information channel in surface patterning with in situ l-DNA synthesis. The bioorthogonality of mirror-image DNA duplex formation prevents both cross-hybridization on chimeric l-/d-DNA microarrays and also results in enzymatic orthogonality, such as nuclease-proof DNA-based signatures on the surface. We show how chimeric l-/d-DNA hybridization can be used to create informative surface patterns including QR codes, highly counterfeiting resistant authenticity watermarks, and concealed messages within high-density d-DNA microarrays.

Heterochiral DNA with Complementary Strands with α-d and β-d Configurations: Hydrogen-Bonded and Silver-Mediated Base Pairs with Impact of 7-Deazapurines Replacing Purines

Heterochiral DNA with hydrogen-bonded and silver-mediated base pairs have been constructed using complementary strands with nucleosides with α-d or β-d configuration. Anomeric phosphoramidites were employed to assemble the oligonucleotides. According to the Tm values and thermodynamic data, the duplex stability of the heterochiral duplexes was similar to that of homochiral DNA, but mismatch discrimination was better in heterochiral DNA. Replacement of purines by 7-deazapurines resulted in stable parallel duplexes, thereby confirming Watson-Crick-type base pairing. When cytosine was facing cytosine, thymine or adenine residues, duplex DNA formed silver-mediated base pairs in the presence of silver ions. Although the CD spectra of single strands with α-d configuration display mirror-like shapes to those with the β-d configuration, the CD spectra of the hydrogen-bonded duplexes and those with a limited number of silver pairs show a B-type double helix almost indistinguishable from natural DNA. Nonmelting silver ion-DNA complexes with entirely different CD spectra were generated when the number of silver ions was equal to the number of base pairs.

RNA-Catalyzed Cross-Chiral Polymerization of RNA

Biology relies almost exclusively on homochiral building blocks to drive the processes of life. Yet cross-chiral interactions can occur between macromolecules of the opposite handedness, including a previously described polymerase ribozyme that catalyzes the template-directed synthesis of enantio-RNA. The present study sought to optimize and generalize this activity, employing in vitro evolution to select cross-chiral polymerases that use either mono- or trinucleotide substrates that are activated as the 5'-triphosphate. There was only modest improvement of the former activity, but dramatic improvement of the latter, which enables the trinucleotide polymerase to react 10²-10³-fold faster than its ancestor and to accept substrates with all possible sequence combinations. The evolved ribozyme can assemble long RNAs from a mixture of trinucleotide building blocks, including a two-fragment form of the ancestral polymerase ribozyme. Further improvement of this activity could enable the generalized cross-chiral replication of RNA, which would establish a new paradigm for the chemical basis of Darwinian evolution.

In vitro selection of l-DNA aptamers that bind a structured d-RNA molecule

The development of structure-specific RNA binding reagents remains a central challenge in RNA biochemistry and drug discovery. Previously, we showed in vitro selection techniques could be used to evolve l-RNA aptamers that bind tightly to structured d-RNAs. However, whether similar RNA-binding properties can be achieved using aptamers composed of l-DNA, which has several practical advantages compared to l-RNA, remains unknown. Here, we report the discovery and characterization of the first l-DNA aptamers against a structured RNA molecule, precursor microRNA-155, thereby establishing the capacity of DNA and RNA molecules of the opposite handedness to form tight and specific ‘cross-chiral’ interactions with each other. l-DNA aptamers bind pre-miR-155 with low nanomolar affinity and high selectivity despite the inability of l-DNA to interact with native d-RNA via Watson–Crick base pairing. Furthermore, l-DNA aptamers inhibit Dicer-mediated processing of pre-miRNA-155. The sequence and structure of l-DNA aptamers are distinct from previously reported l-RNA aptamers against pre-miR-155, indicating that l-DNA and l-RNA interact with the same RNA sequence through unique modes of recognition. Overall, this work demonstrates that l-DNA may be pursued as an alternative to l-RNA for the generation of RNA-binding aptamers, providing a robust and practical approach for targeting structured RNAs.

l-DNA-Based Catalytic Hairpin Assembly Circuit

Isothermal, enzyme-free amplification methods based on DNA strand-displacement reactions show great promise for applications in biosensing and disease diagnostics but operating such systems within biological environments remains extremely challenging due to the susceptibility of DNA to nuclease degradation. Here, we report a catalytic hairpin assembly (CHA) circuit constructed from nuclease-resistant l-DNA that is capable of unimpeded signal amplification in the presence of 10% fetal bovine serum (FBS). The superior biostability of the l-DNA CHA circuit relative to its native d-DNA counterpart was clearly demonstrated through a direct comparison of the two systems (d versus l) under various conditions. Importantly, we show that the l-CHA circuit can be sequence-specifically interfaced with an endogenous d-nucleic acid biomarker via an achiral peptide nucleic acid (PNA) intermediary, enabling catalytic detection of the target in FBS. Overall, this work establishes a blueprint for the detection of low-abundance nucleic acids in harsh biological environments and provides further impetus for the construction of DNA nanotechnology using l-oligonucleotides.

Promiscuous Ribozymes and Their Proposed Role in Prebiotic Evolution

The ability of enzymes, including ribozymes, to catalyze side reactions is believed to be essential to the evolution of novel biochemical activities. It has been speculated that the earliest ribozymes, whose emergence marked the origin of life, were low in activity but high in promiscuity, and that these early ribozymes gave rise to specialized descendants with higher activity and specificity. Here, we review the concepts related to promiscuity and examine several cases of highly promiscuous ribozymes. We consider the evidence bearing on the question of whether de novo ribozymes would be quantitatively more promiscuous than later evolved ribozymes or protein enzymes. We suggest that while de novo ribozymes appear to be promiscuous in general, they are not obviously more promiscuous than more highly evolved or active sequences. Promiscuity is a trait whose value would depend on selective pressures, even during prebiotic evolution.

Heterochiral DNA Strand-Displacement Based on Chimeric d/l-Oligonucleotides

Heterochiral DNA strand-displacement reactions enable sequence-specific interfacing of oligonucleotide enantiomers, making it possible to interface native d-nucleic acids with molecular circuits built using nuclease-resistant l-DNA. To date, all heterochiral reactions have relied on peptide nucleic acid (PNA), which places potential limits on the scope and utility of this approach. Herein, we now report heterochiral strand-displacement in the absence of PNA, instead utilizing chimeric d/l-DNA complexes to interface oligonucleotides of the opposite chirality. We show that these strand-displacement reactions can be easily integrated into multicomponent heterochiral circuits, are compatible with both DNA and RNA inputs, and can be engineered to function in serum-supplemented medium. We anticipate that these new reactions will lead to a wider application of heterochiral strand-displacement, especially in the design of biocompatible nucleic acid circuits that can reliably operate within living systems.

Effects of metal ions on thermal stabilities of DNA duplexes containing homo- and heterochiral mismatched base pairs: comparison of internal and terminal substitutions

The effects of metal ions on the stabilities of duplexes containing a _D-homochiral and heterochiral mismatched base pairs were studied. In some duplexes containing an internal mismatched base pair, significant stabilization by Hg^II and Ag^I ions was observed. While, in duplexes containing a terminal mismatched base pair, only the duplexes containing T-T and _LT-T mispairs were significantly stabilized by Hg^II ions, and the stabilities of the duplexes containing T-T and _LT-T mispairs exceeded those of the corresponding homochiral matched duplex. The results suggest that the formation of homo- and heterochiral T-Hg^II-T base pairs at duplex termini would be useful for the thermal and enzymatic stabilization of DNA-based nanodevice.

Heterochiral Nucleic Acid Circuits

The programmability of DNA/RNA-based molecular circuits provides numerous opportunities in the field of synthetic biology. However, the stability of nucleic acids remains a major concern when performing complex computations in biological environments. Our solution to this problem is L-(deoxy)ribose nucleic acids (L-DNA/RNA), which are mirror images (i.e. enantiomers) of natural D-nucleotides. L-oligonucleotides have the same physical and chemical properties as their natural counterparts, yet they are completely invisible to the stereospecific environment of biology. We recently reported a novel strand-displacement methodology for transferring sequence information between oligonucleotide enantiomers (which are incapable of base pairing with each other), enabling bio-orthogonal L-DNA/RNA circuits to be easily interfaced with living systems. In this perspective, we summarize these so-called "heterochiral" circuits, provide a viewpoint on their potential applications in synthetic biology, and discuss key problems that must be solved before achieving the ultimate goal of engineering complex and reliable functionality.

Mirror-Image Oligonucleotides: History and Emerging Applications

As chiral molecules, naturally occurring d-oligonucleotides have enantiomers, l-DNA and l-RNA, which are comprised of l-(deoxy)ribose sugars. These mirror-image oligonucleotides have the same physical and chemical properties as that of their native d-counterparts, yet are highly orthogonal to the stereospecific environment of biology. Consequently, l-oligonucleotides are resistant to nuclease degradation and many of the off-target interactions that plague traditional d-oligonucleotide-based technologies; thus making them ideal for biomedical applications. Despite a flurry of interest during the early 1990s, the inability of d- and l-oligonucleotides to form contiguous Watson-Crick base pairs with each other has ultimately led to the perception that l-oligonucleotides have only limited utility. Recently, however, scientists have begun to uncover novel strategies to harness the bio-orthogonality of l-oligonucleotides, while overcoming (and even exploiting) their inability to Watson-Crick base pair with the natural polymer. Herein, a brief history of l-oligonucleotide research is presented and emerging l-oligonucleotide-based technologies, as well as their applications in research and therapy, are presented.

An l-RNA Aptamer with Expanded Chemical Functionality that Inhibits MicroRNA Biogenesis

To facilitate isolation of l-aptamers with novel RNA-binding properties, we employed a cationic nucleotide, 5-aminoallyluridine, during the mirror image in vitro selection process. Through this effort, we identified a modified l-RNA aptamer (MlRA) capable of binding oncogenic precursor microRNA 19a (pre-miR-19a) with exceptional affinity, and we showed that cationic modification is absolutely critical for binding. Furthermore, formation of the MlRA-pre-miR-19a complex inhibited Dicer-mediated cleavage of the pre-miR, thus blocking formation of the mature functional microRNA. The MlRA reported here not only represents the first l-aptamer to be evolved by using modified nucleotides but also the first modified aptamer (of any type) to be selected against a structured RNA target. Our results demonstrate that functionalized l-aptamers, which are intrinsically nuclease-resistant, provide an attractive approach for developing robust RNA-binding reagents.

Adaptive PCR Based on Hybridization Sensing of Mirror-Image l-DNA

Polymerase chain reaction (PCR) is dependent on two key hybridization events during each cycle of amplification, primer annealing and product melting. To ensure that these hybridization events occur, current PCR approaches rely on temperature set points and reaction contents that are optimized and maintained using rigid thermal cycling programs and stringent sample preparation procedures. This report describes a fundamentally simpler and more robust PCR design that dynamically controls thermal cycling by more directly monitoring the two key hybridization events during the reaction. This is achieved by optically sensing the annealing and melting of mirror-image l-DNA analogs of the reaction's primers and targets. Because the properties of l-DNA enantiomers parallel those of natural d-DNAs, the l-DNA reagents indicate the cycling conditions required for effective primer annealing and product melting during each cycle without interfering with the reaction. This hybridization-sensing approach adapts in real time to variations in reaction contents and conditions that impact primer annealing and product melting and eliminates the requirement for thermal calibrations and cycling programs. Adaptive PCR is demonstrated to amplify DNA targets with high efficiency and specificity under both controlled conditions and conditions that are known to cause traditional PCR to fail. The advantages of this approach promise to make PCR-based nucleic acid analysis simpler, more robust, and more accessible outside of well-controlled laboratory settings.

Thermodynamic Features of Structural Motifs Formed by β-L-RNA

This is the first report to provide comprehensive thermodynamic and structural data concerning duplex, hairpin, quadruplex and i-motif structures in β-L-RNA series. Herein we confirm that, within the limits of experimental error, the thermodynamic stability of enantiomeric structural motifs is the same as that of naturally occurring D-RNA counterparts. In addition, formation of D-RNA/L-RNA heterochiral duplexes is also observed; however, their thermodynamic stability is significantly reduced in reference to homochiral D-RNA duplexes. The presence of three locked nucleic acid (LNA) residues within the D-RNA strand diminishes the negative effect of the enantiomeric, complementary L-RNA strand in the formation of heterochiral RNA duplexes. Similar behavior is also observed for heterochiral LNA-2'-O-methyl-D-RNA/L-RNA duplexes. The formation of heterochiral duplexes was confirmed by 1H NMR spectroscopy. The CD curves of homochiral L-RNA structural motifs are always reversed, whereas CD curves of heterochiral duplexes present individual features dependent on the composition of chiral strands.

Specific Inhibition of MicroRNA Processing Using L-RNA Aptamers

In vitro selection was used to obtain l-RNA aptamers that bind the distal stem-loop of various precursor microRNAs (pre-miRs). These l-aptamers, termed "aptamiRs", bind their corresponding pre-miR target through highly specific tertiary interactions rather than Watson-Crick pairing. Formation of a pre-miR-aptamiR complex inhibits Dicer-mediated processing of the pre-miR, which is required to form the mature functional microRNA. One of the aptamiRs, which was selected to bind oncogenic pre-miR-155, inhibits Dicer processing under simulated physiological conditions, with an IC50 of 87 nM. Given that l-RNAs are intrinsically resistant to nuclease degradation, these results suggest that aptamiRs might be pursued as a new class of miR inhibitors.

Chirality- and sequence-selective successive self-sorting via specific homo- and complementary-duplex formations

Self-recognition and self-discrimination within complex mixtures are of fundamental importance in biological systems, which entirely rely on the preprogrammed monomer sequences and homochirality of biological macromolecules. Here we report artificial chirality- and sequence-selective successive self-sorting of chiral dimeric strands bearing carboxylic acid or amidine groups joined by chiral amide linkers with different sequences through homo- and complementary-duplex formations. A mixture of carboxylic acid dimers linked by racemic-1,2-cyclohexane bis-amides with different amide sequences (NHCO or CONH) self-associate to form homoduplexes in a completely sequence-selective way, the structures of which are different from each other depending on the linker amide sequences. The further addition of an enantiopure amide-linked amidine dimer to a mixture of the racemic carboxylic acid dimers resulted in the formation of a single optically pure complementary duplex with a 100% diastereoselectivity and complete sequence specificity stabilized by the amidinium–carboxylate salt bridges, leading to the perfect chirality- and sequence-selective duplex formation.

The recognition and self-sorting of chiral molecules is a vital feature of many biomolecules. Here, the authors report chirality- and sequence-specific self-sorting of organic strands containing carboxylic acid or amidine groups, leading to selective duplex formation.

An Efficient Catalytic DNA that Cleaves L-RNA

Many DNAzymes have been isolated from synthetic DNA pools to cleave natural RNA (D-RNA) substrates and some have been utilized for the design of aptazyme biosensors for bioanalytical applications. Even though these biosensors perform well in simple sample matrices, they do not function effectively in complex biological samples due to ubiquitous RNases that can efficiently cleave D-RNA substrates. To overcome this issue, we set out to develop DNAzymes that cleave L-RNA, the enantiomer of D-RNA, which is known to be completely resistant to RNases. Through in vitro selection we isolated three L-RNA-cleaving DNAzymes from a random-sequence DNA pool. The most active DNAzyme exhibits a catalytic rate constant ~3 min^-1 and has a structure that contains a kissing loop, a structural motif that has never been observed with D-RNA-cleaving DNAzymes. Furthermore we have used this DNAzyme and a well-known ATP-binding DNA aptamer to construct an aptazyme sensor and demonstrated that this biosensor can achieve ATP detection in biological samples that contain RNases. The current work lays the foundation for exploring RNA-cleaving DNAzymes for engineering biosensors that are compatible with complex biological samples.

Stereospecificity of oligonucleotide interactions revisited: no evidence for heterochiral hybridization and ribozyme/DNAzyme activity

A major challenge for the application of RNA- or DNA-oligonucleotides in biotechnology and molecular medicine is their susceptibility to abundant nucleases. One intriguing possibility to tackle this problem is the use of mirror-image (l-)oligonucleotides. For aptamers, this concept has successfully been applied to even develop therapeutic agents, so-called Spiegelmers. However, for technologies depending on RNA/RNA or RNA/DNA hybridization, like antisense or RNA interference, it has not been possible to use mirror-image oligonucleotides because Watson-Crick base pairing of complementary strands is (thought to be) stereospecific. Many scientists consider this a general principle if not a dogma. A recent publication proposing heterochiral Watson-Crick base pairing and sequence-specific hydrolysis of natural RNA by mirror-image ribozymes or DNAzymes (and vice versa) prompted us to systematically revisit the stereospecificity of oligonucleotides hybridization and catalytic activity. Using hyperchromicity measurements we demonstrate that hybridization only occurs among homochiral anti-parallel complementary oligonucleotide strands. As expected, achiral PNA hybridizes to RNA and DNA irrespective of their chirality. In functional assays we could not confirm an alleged heterochiral hydrolytic activity of ribozymes or DNAzymes. Our results confirm a strict stereospecificity of oligonucleotide hybridization and clearly argue against the possibility to use mirror-image oligonucleotides for gene silencing or antisense applications.

A cross-chiral RNA polymerase ribozyme

Thirty years ago it was shown that the non-enzymatic, template-directed polymerization of activated mononucleotides proceeds readily in a homochiral system, but is severely inhibited by the presence of the opposing enantiomer.¹ This finding poses a severe challenge for the spontaneous emergence of RNA-based life, and has led to the suggestion that either RNA was preceded by some other genetic polymer that is not subject to chiral inhibition² or chiral symmetry was broken through chemical processes prior to the origin of RNA-based life.^3,4 Once an RNA enzyme arose that could catalyze the polymerization of RNA, it would have been possible to distinguish among the two enantiomers, enabling RNA replication and RNA-based evolution to occur. It is commonly thought that the earliest RNA polymerase and its substrates would have been of the same handedness, but this is not necessarily the case. Replicating D-and L-RNA molecules may have emerged together, based on the ability of structured RNAs of one handedness to catalyze the templated polymerization of activated mononucleotides of the opposite handedness. Such a cross-chiral RNA polymerase has now been developed using in vitro evolution. The D-RNA enzyme, consisting of 83 nucleotides, catalyzes the joining of L-mono- or oligonucleotide substrates on a complementary L-RNA template, and similarly for the L-enzyme with D-substrates and a D-template. Chiral inhibition is avoided because the 10⁶-fold rate acceleration of the enzyme only pertains to cross-chiral substrates. The enzyme's activity is sufficient to generate full-length copies of its enantiomer through the templated joining of 11 component oligonucleotides.

Spiegelzymes® mirror-image hammerhead ribozymes and mirror-image DNAzymes, an alternative to siRNAs and microRNAs to cleave mRNAs in vivo?

With the discovery of small non-coding RNA (ncRNA) molecules as regulators for cellular processes, it became intriguing to develop technologies by which these regulators can be applied in molecular biology and molecular medicine. The application of ncRNAs has significantly increased our knowledge about the regulation and functions of a number of proteins in the cell. It is surprising that similar successes in applying these small ncRNAs in biotechnology and molecular medicine have so far been very limited. The reasons for these observations may lie in the high complexity in which these RNA regulators function in the cells and problems with their delivery, stability and specificity. Recently, we have described mirror-image hammerhead ribozymes and DNAzymes (Spiegelzymes®) which can sequence-specifically hydrolyse mirror-image nucleic acids, such as our mirror-image aptamers (Spiegelmers) discovered earlier. In this paper, we show for the first time that Spiegelzymes are capable of recognising complementary enantiomeric substrates (D-nucleic acids), and that they efficiently hydrolyse them at submillimolar magnesium concentrations and at physiologically relevant conditions. The Spiegelzymes are very stable in human sera, and do not require any protein factors for their function. They have the additional advantages of being non-toxic and non-immunogenic. The Spiegelzymes can be used for RNA silencing and also as therapeutic and diagnostic tools in medicine. We performed extensive three-dimensional molecular modelling experiments with mirror-image hammerhead ribozymes and DNAzymes interacting with D-RNA targets. We propose a model in which L/D-double helix structures can be formed by natural Watson-Crick base pairs, but where the nucleosides of one of the two strands will occur in an anticlinal conformation. Interestingly enough, the duplexes (L-RNA/D-RNA and L-DNA/D-RNA) in these models can show either right- or left-handedness. This is a very new observation, suggesting that molecular symmetry of enantiomeric nucleic acids is broken down.

Binding of a structured D-RNA molecule by an L-RNA aptamer

An L-RNA aptamer was developed that binds the natural D-form of the HIV-1 trans-activation responsive (TAR) RNA. The aptamer initially was obtained as a D-aptamer against L-TAR RNA through in vitro selection. Then the corresponding L-aptamer was prepared by chemical synthesis and used to bind the desired target. The L-aptamer binds D-TAR RNA with a Kd of 100 nM. It binds D-TAR exclusively at the six-nucleotide distal loop, but does so through tertiary interactions rather than simple Watson-Crick pairing. This complex is the first example of two nucleic acids molecules of opposing chirality that interact through a mode of binding other than primary structure. Binding of the L-aptamer to D-TAR RNA inhibits formation of the Tat-TAR ribonucleoprotein complex that is essential for TAR function. This suggests that L-aptamers, which are intrinsically resistant to degradation by ribonucleases, might be pursued as an alternative to antisense oligonucleotides to target structured RNAs of biological or therapeutic interest.

Thermal stability of oligodeoxynucleotide duplexes containing l-deoxynucleotide at termini

The effects of substituting l-deoxynucleotide for d-deoxynucleotide at duplex termini were evaluated and the terminal substitutions were found to show much less effects on duplex destabilization and to show a similar tendency in base pairing selectivity, compared with internal chiral substitutions.

Propagation of chirality in mixtures of natural and enantiomeric DNA oligomers

Concentrated solutions of ultrashort duplex-forming DNA oligomers may develop various forms of liquid crystal ordering among which is the chiral nematic phase, characterized by a macroscopic helical precession of molecular orientation. The specifics of how chirality propagates from the molecular to the mesoscale is still unclear, both in general and in the case of DNA-based liquid crystals. We have here investigated the onset of nematic ordering and its chiral character in mixtures of natural D-DNA oligomers forming right-handed duplex helices and of mirror symmetric (L-DNA) molecules, forming left-handed helices. Since the nematic ordering of DNA duplexes is mediated by their end-to-end aggregation into linear columns, by controlling the terminals of both enantiomers we could study the propagation of chirality in solutions where the D and L species form mixtures of homochiral columns, and in solutions of heterochiral columns. The two systems behave in markedly different fashion. By adopting a simple model based on nearest-neighbor interactions, we account for the different observed dependence of the chirality of these two systems on the enantiomeric ratio.

Exploring the role of chirality in nucleic acid recognition

The study of the base-pairing properties of nucleic acids with sugar moieties in the backbone belonging to the L-series (β-L-DNA, β-L-RNA, and their analogs) are reviewed. The major structural factors underlying the formation of stable heterochiral complexes obtained by incorporation of modified nucleotides into natural duplexes, or by hybridization between homochiral strands of opposite sense of chirality are highlighted. In addition, the perspective use of L-nucleic acids as candidates for various therapeutic applications, or as tools for both synthetic biology and etiology-oriented investigations on the structure and stereochemistry of natural nucleic acids is discussed.

Base recognition by l-nucleotides in heterochiral DNA

An l-nucleotide residue in heterochiral oligodeoxynucleotides possesses base pairing selectivity with different effects of the neighboring bases.

A mirror-image tetramolecular DNA quadruplex

L-DNA, the mirror image of natural DNA forms structures of opposite chirality. We demonstrate here that a short guanine rich L-DNA strand forms a tetramolecular quadruplex with the same properties as a D-DNA strand of identical sequence, besides an inverted circular dichroism spectra. L- and D-strands self exclude when mixed together, showing that the controlled parallel self-assembly of different G-rich strands can be obtained through L-DNA use.

Superior structure stability and selectivity of hairpin nucleic acid probes with an L-DNA stem

Hairpin nucleic acid probes have been highly useful in many areas, especially for intracellular and in vitro nucleic acid detection. The success of these probes can be attributed to the ease with which their conformational change upon target binding can be coupled to a variety of signal transduction mechanisms. However, false-positive signals arise from the opening of the hairpin due mainly to thermal fluctuations and stem invasions. Stem invasions occur when the stem interacts with its complementary sequence and are especially problematic in complex biological samples. To address the problem of stem invasions in hairpin probes, we have created a modified molecular beacon that incorporates unnatural enantiomeric l-DNA in the stem and natural d-DNA or 2′-O-Me-modified RNA in the loop. l-DNA has the same physical characteristics as d-DNA except that l-DNA cannot form stable duplexes with d-DNA. Here we show that incorporating l-DNA into the stem region of a molecular beacon reduces intra- and intermolecular stem invasions, increases the melting temperature, improves selectivity to its target, and leads to enhanced bio-stability. Our results suggest that l-DNA is useful for designing functional nucleic acid probes especially for biological applications.

Utilising the left-helical conformation of L-DNA for analysing different marker types on a single universal microarray platform

L-DNA is the perfect mirror-image form of the naturally occurring d-conformation of DNA. Therefore, L-DNA duplexes have the same physical characteristics in terms of solubility, duplex stability and selectivity as D-DNA but form a left-helical double-helix. Because of its chiral difference, L-DNA does not bind to its naturally occurring D-DNA counterpart, however. We analysed some of the properties that are typical for L-DNA. For all the differences, L-DNA is chemically compatible with the D-form of DNA, so that chimeric molecules can be synthesized. We take advantage of the characteristics of L-DNA toward the establishment of a universal microarray that permits the analysis of different kinds of molecular diagnostic information in a single experiment on a single platform, in various combinations. Typical results for the measurement of transcript level variations, genotypic differences and DNA–protein interactions are presented. However, on the basis of the characteristic features of L-DNA, also other applications of this molecule type are discussed.

Molecular beacons with a homo-DNA stem: improving target selectivity

Molecular beacons (MBs) are stem–loop DNA probes used for identifying and reporting the presence and localization of nucleic acid targets in vitro and in vivo via target-dependent dequenching of fluorescence. A drawback of conventional MB design is present in the stem sequence that is necessary to keep the MBs in a closed conformation in the absence of a target, but that can participate in target binding in the open (target-on) conformation, giving rise to the possibility of false-positive results. In order to circumvent these problems, we designed MBs in which the stem was replaced by an orthogonal DNA analog that does not cross-pair with natural nucleic acids. Homo-DNA seemed to be specially suited, as it forms stable adenine-adenine base pairs of the reversed Hoogsteen type, potentially reducing the number of necessary building blocks for stem design to one. We found that MBs in which the stem part was replaced by homo-adenylate residues can easily be synthesized using conventional automated DNA synthesis. As conventional MBs, such hybrid MBs show cooperative hairpin to coil transitions in the absence of a DNA target, indicating stable homo-DNA base pair formation in the closed conformation. Furthermore, our results show that the homo-adenylate stem is excluded from DNA target binding, which leads to a significant increase in target binding selectivity.

Thermodynamic Analysis of Duplex Formation of the Heterochiral DNA with L-Deoxyadenosine

An L-DNA, the mirror-image isomer of natural DNA, has extraordinary nuclease resistance, and thus the molecules should be promising reagents for many applications, such as antisense technology. However, little is known about the structural and thermodynamic properties of DNAs with this modified nucleotide. In this study, we prepared the L-nucleotide (L-dA) and introduced it into oligodeoxyribonucleotides to assess the ability of the L-nucleotide as a functional molecule for many applications based on the DNA hybridization. Two decamers with an L-dA at the center were synthesized and duplexes with the complementary DNA strand were applied to structural and thermodynamic analyses. The structural study by CD spectra showed that the structures of both modified "L/D-D" duplexes were the typical B-form. This result suggests that the global structure of DNA was not collapsed by the introduction of an L-DNA. Thermodynamic parameters (deltaH degrees, deltaS degrees, and deltaG degrees 37) of the duplex formation, determined by UV melting experiments, indicated that the both duplexes were destabilized at about 2.5 to 3.0 kcal mol(-1) by the introduced L-dA, mainly due to an unfavorable enthalpic effect. In conjunction with information by other researchers, these results suggest that the L-DNA affect on the duplex structure and the stability vary locally; thus, the thermodynamic stability of modified L/D-D duplexes should be predictable by the nearest-neighbor thermodynamic parameters.