The crystal structure analysis of d(CGCGAASSCGCG)2, a synthetic DNA dodecamer duplex containing four 4'-thio-2'-deoxythymidine nucleotides

Influence of Sugar Modifications on the Nucleoside Conformation and Oligonucleotide Stability: A Critical Review

Ribofuranose sugar conformation plays an important role in the structure and dynamics of functional nucleic acids such as siRNAs, AONs, aptamers, miRNAs, etc. To improve their therapeutic potential, several chemical modifications have been introduced into the sugar moiety over the years. The stability of the oligonucleotide duplexes as well as the formation of stable and functional protein-oligonucleotide complexes are dictated by the conformation and dynamics of the sugar moiety. In this review, we systematically categorise various ribofuranose sugar modifications employed in DNAs and RNAs so far. We discuss different stereoelectronic effects imparted by different substituents on the sugar ring and how these effects control sugar puckering. Using this data, it would be possible to predict the precise use of chemical modifications and design novel sugar-modified nucleosides for therapeutic oligonucleotides that can improve their physicochemical properties.

Impact of modified ribose sugars on nucleic acid conformation and function

The modification of the ribofuranose in nucleic acids is a widespread method of manipulating the activity of nucleic acids. These alterations, however, impact the local conformation and chemical reactivity of the sugar. Changes in the conformation and dynamics of the sugar moiety alter the local and potentially global structure and plasticity of nucleic acids, which in turn contributes to recognition, binding of ligands and enzymatic activity of proteins. This review article introduces the conformational properties of the (deoxy)ribofuranose ring and then explores sugar modifications and how they impact local and global structure and dynamics in nucleic acids.

4′-Thio-5-Ethyl-2′-Deoxyuridine5′-Triphosphate (TEDUTP): Synthesis and Substrate Properties in DNA-Synthesizing Systems

An efficient synthesis of the 5′-phosphate and 5′-triphosphate of a 4′-thio-2′-deoxynucleoside is described for the first time. The 5′-triphosphate of the antiherpesvirus agent 4′-thio-5-ethyl-2′-deoxyuridine (TEDU) has been shown to be a good substrate for human placental DNA polymerase α, calf thymus terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase, and the reverse transcriptases of human immunodeficiency virus and avian myeloblastosis virus. As it is known that TEDU is a substrate only for herpesvirus-encoded thymidine kinases and not the cellular kinases, it is likely that the utilization of TEDUTP by DNA-synthesizing enzymes results in the selective toxicity seen in vitro in herpesvirus-infected cells.

Crystallographic studies of chemically modified nucleic acids: a backward glance

Chemically modified nucleic acids (CNAs) are widely explored as antisense oligonucleotide or small interfering RNA (siRNA) candidates for therapeutic applications. CNAs are also of interest in diagnostics, high-throughput genomics and target validation, nanotechnology and as model systems in investigations directed at a better understanding of the etiology of nucleic acid structure, as well as the physicochemical and pairing properties of DNA and RNA, and for probing protein-nucleic acid interactions. In this article, we review research conducted in our laboratory over the past two decades with a focus on crystal-structure analyses of CNAs and artificial pairing systems. We highlight key insights into issues ranging from conformational distortions as a consequence of modification to the modulation of pairing strength, and RNA affinity by stereoelectronic effects and hydration. Although crystal structures have only been determined for a subset of the large number of modifications that were synthesized and analyzed in the oligonucleotide context to date, they have yielded guiding principles for the design of new analogs with tailor-made properties, including pairing specificity, nuclease resistance, and cellular uptake. And, perhaps less obviously, crystallographic studies of CNAs and synthetic pairing systems have shed light on fundamental aspects of DNA and RNA structure and function that would not have been disclosed by investigations solely focused on the natural nucleic acids.

Unexpected A-form formation of 4'-thioDNA in solution, revealed by NMR, and the implications as to the mechanism of nuclease resistance

Fully modified 4′-thioDNA, an oligonucleotide only comprising 2′-deoxy-4′-thionucleosides, exhibited resistance to an endonuclease, in addition to preferable hybridization with RNA. Therefore, 4′-thioDNA is promising for application as a functional oligonucleotide. Fully modified 4′-thioDNA was found to behave like an RNA molecule, but no details of its structure beyond the results of circular dichroism analysis are available. Here, we have determined the structure of fully modified 4′-thioDNA with the sequence of d(CGCGAATTCGCG) by NMR. Most sugars take on the C3′-endo conformation. The major groove is narrow and deep, while the minor groove is wide and shallow. Thus, fully modified 4′-thioDNA takes on the A-form characteristic of RNA, both locally and globally. The only structure reported for 4′-thioDNA showed that partially modified 4′-thioDNA that contained some 2′-deoxy-4′-thionucleosides took on the B-form in the crystalline form. We have determined the structure of 4′-thioDNA in solution for the first time, and demonstrated unexpected differences between the two structures. The origin of the formation of the A-form is discussed. The remarkable biochemical properties reported for fully modified 4′-thioDNA, including nuclease-resistance, are rationalized in the light of the elucidated structure.

Influence of the incorporation of a cyclohexenyl nucleic acid (CeNA) residue onto the sequence d(CGCGAATTCGCG)

Cyclohexene nucleic acids (CeNA), which are characterized by the presence of a cyclohexene moiety instead of a natural (deoxy)ribose sugar, are known to increase the thermal and enzymatic stability when incorporated in RNA oligonucleotides. As it has been demonstrated that even a single cyclohexenyl nucleoside, when incorporated in an oligonucleotide, can have a profound effect on the biological activity of the oligonucleotide, further research is warranted to study the complex of such oligonucleotides with target proteins. In order to analyse the influence of CeNA residues onto the helix conformation and hydration of natural nucleic acid structures, a cyclohexenyl-adenine building block (xAr) was incorporated into the Dickerson sequence CGCGA(xAr)TTCGCG. The crystal structure of this sequence determined to a resolution of 1.90 A. The global helix belongs to the B-type family and shows a water spine, which is partially broken up by the apolar cyclohexene residue. The cyclohexene ring adopts the (2)E-conformation allowing a better incorporation of the residue in the dodecamer sequence. The crystal packing is stabilized by cobalt hexamine residues and belongs to space group P222(1), never before reported for nucleic acids.

Synthesis and properties of 4'-ThioDNA: unexpected RNA-like behavior of 4'-ThioDNA

The synthesis and properties of fully modified 4′-thioDNAs, oligonucleotides consisting of 2′-deoxy-4′-thionucleosides, were examined. In addition to the known literature properties (preferable hybridization with RNA and resistance to endonuclease hydrolysis), we also observed higher resistance of 4′-thioDNA to 3′-exonuclease cleavage. Furthermore, we found that fully modified 4′-thioDNAs behaved like RNA molecules in their hybridization properties and structural aspect, at least in the case of the 4′-thioDNA duplex. This observation was confirmed by experiments using groove binders, in which a 4′-thioDNA duplex interacts with an RNA major groove binder, lividomycin A, but not with DNA groove binders, to give an increase in its thermal stability. Since a 4′-thioDNA duplex competitively inhibited the hydrolysis of an RNA duplex by RNase V₁, it was not only the physical properties but also this biological data suggested that a 4′-thioDNA duplex has an RNA-like structure.

Syntheses of 4'-thioribonucleosides and thermodynamic stability and crystal structure of RNA oligomers with incorporated 4'-thiocytosine

A facile synthetic route for the 4'-thioribonucleoside building block (4'S)N (N = U, C, A and G) with the ribose O4' replaced by sulfur is presented. Conversion of l-lyxose to 1,5-di-O-acetyl-2,3-di-O-benzoyl-4-thio-d-ribofuranose was achieved via an efficient four-step synthesis with high yield. Conversion of the thiosugar into the four ribonucleoside phosphoramidite building blocks was accomplished with additional four steps in each case. Incorporation of 4'-thiocytidines into oligoribonucleotides improved the thermal stability of the corresponding duplexes by approximately 1 degrees C per modification, irrespective of whether the strand contained a single modification or a consecutive stretch of (4'S)C residues. The gain in thermodynamic stability is comparable to that observed with oligoribonucleotides containing 2'-O-methylated residues. To establish potential conformational changes in RNA as a result of the 4'-thio modification and to better understand the origins of the observed stability changes, the crystal structure of the oligonucleotide 5'-r(CC(4'S)CCGGGG) was determined and analyzed using the previously solved structure of the native RNA octamer as a reference. The two 4'-thioriboses adopt conformations that are very similar to the C3'-endo pucker observed for the corresponding sugars in the native duplex. Subtle changes in the local geometry of the modified duplex are mostly due to the larger radius of sulfur compared to oxygen or appear to be lattice-induced. The significantly increased RNA affinity of 4'-thio-modified RNA relative to RNA, and the relatively minor conformational changes caused by the modification render this nucleic acid analog an interesting candidate for in vitro and in vivo applications, including use in RNA interference (RNAi), antisense, ribozyme, decoy and aptamer technologies.

Incorporation of OSI-7836 into DNA of Calu-6 and H460 xenograft tumors

OSI-7836 (4'-thio-beta-D-arabinofuranosylcytosine) is a novel nucleoside analog in phase I clinical development for the treatment of cancer. As with other nucleoside analogs, the proposed mechanism of action involves phosphorylation to the triphosphate form followed by incorporation into cellular DNA, leading to cell death. This hypothesis has been examined by measuring and comparing the incorporation of ara-C, OSI-7836, and gemcitabine (dFdC) into DNA of cultured cells and by investigating the role of deoxycytidine kinase in OSI-7836 toxicity. We report here additional studies in which the role of cell cycling on OSI-7836 toxicity was investigated and incorporation of OSI-7836 into DNA of xenograft tumors measured. The role of the cell cycle was examined by comparing the toxicity of OSI-7836 in A549 NSCLC cells that were either in log phase growth or had reached confluence. A novel validated LC-MS/MS assay was developed to quantify the concentrations of OSI-7836 in DNA from Calu-6 and H460 human tumor xenografts in mice. Results showed that apoptosis induced by OSI-7836 was markedly greater in cycling cells than in confluent non-cycling cells despite only a modest increase in intracellular OSI-7836 triphosphate concentration. The LC-MS/MS assay developed to measure OSI-7836 incorporation into DNA had an on-column detection limit of 0.25 fmol, a quantification limit of 0.5 fmol, and a sensitivity of approximately 0.1 pmol OSI-7836/micromol dThy. Concentrations of OSI-7836 in splenic DNA (0.4 pmol OSI-7836/micromol dThy) averaged fivefold less than the average concentration in Calu-6 and H460 xenograft DNA (3.0 pmol OSI-7836/micromol dThy) following a 400 mg/kg dose of OSI-7836. Concentrations of OSI-7836 in Calu-6 tumor DNA isolated 24 h following a dose of 400, 1000, or 1600 mg OSI-7836/kg were approximately 1.3, 1 and 1.3 pmol OSI-7836/micromol dThy, respectively. Concentrations of OSI-7836 in DNA from H460 and Calu-6 xenografts did not appear to increase during repeated administration of 400 mg OSI-7836/kg on days 1, 4, 7, and 10. The majority of OSI-7836 in DNA from Calu-6 and H460 tumors of mice dosed with 1600 mg/kg was located at internal nucleotide linkages, similar to dFdC and ara-C. In conclusion, cell cycling studies supported the hypothesis that OSI-7836 cytotoxicity is dependent upon DNA synthesis. A validated LC-MS/MS assay was developed that could quantify OSI-7836 in DNA from tissues. The assay was used to show that OSI-7836 was incorporated in internal linkages in tumor DNA in a manner that was dose-independent at the doses tested and did not appear to accumulate during repeated dosing. The results suggest that if DNA incorporation is a toxic event, the relationships between administered dose, DNA incorporation, and toxicity are complex.

The conformational study of two carbocyclic nucleosides: why carbocyclic nucleic acids (CarNAs) form more stable duplexes with RNA than DNA does

Replacement of the furanose moiety of DNA with a cyclopentane ring produces a modified sugar analogue: Carbocyclic nucleic acid (CarNA). UV melting-temperature experiments demonstrate that the incorporation of 2'-deoxycarbaguanosine ((c)G) and 2'-deoxyaristeromycin ((c)A) of carbocyclic nucleosides into a DNA strand increases the stability of the CarNA/RNA hybrid. Circular Dichroism (CD) study indicates that the CarNA/RNA hybrid adopts an A-like conformation. To elucidate the molecular basis of the increased stability of the CarNA/RNA, the conformation of (c)G and (c)A were examined by (1)H NMR conformational analysis of (3)J(HH) coupling constants and ab initio molecular orbital (MO) calculations. These results show that the populations of N-type of (c)G and (c)A are higher than those of dG and dA, respectively, at different temperatures [For example, 37% (N%) of (c)G vs. 28%of dG, 36% (N%) of (c)A vs. 25% of dA at 278 K], which suggest that the cyclopentane rings of (c)G and (c)A prefer the N-type conformation in two-state N-S pseudorotional equilibrium in comparison with the furanose rings of dG and dA. The DeltaH degrees of (c)G (DeltaH degrees = - 0.43 kcal mol(-1)) and (c)A (DeltaH degrees = - 0.41kcal mol(-1)) are lower than that of dG (dG = - 1.8 kcal mol(-1)) and dA (dA = - 1.0 kcal mol(-1)), respectively, which suggest that the gauche effect in the (c)A and (c)G driving N-S pseudorotional equilibrium to S-type is reduced by replacement of the 4'-oxygen by a CH(2) group. These results suggest that the preferred N-type of the (c)G and (c)A leads to the A-like conformation, which contributes to the stability of CarNA/RNA hybrid.

Crystal studies of B-DNA: the answers and the questions

The history of DNA crystallography is reviewed and is followed by discussion of the methods used for structure determination. The features of B-DNA molecular and crystal structures are described.

Mechanistic link between DNA methyltransferases and DNA repair enzymes by base flipping

Rotation of a DNA nucleotide out of the double helix and into a protein binding pocket ("base flipping") was first observed in the structure of a DNA methyltransferase. There is now evidence that a variety of proteins, particularly DNA repair enzymes, use base flipping in their interactions with DNA. Though the mechanisms for base movement into extrahelical positions are still unclear, the focus of this review is how base recognition is modulated by the stringency of binding to the extrahelical base(s) or sugar moiety.

DNA containing 4'-thio-2'-deoxycytidine inhibits methylation by HhaI methyltransferase

4'-Thio-2'-deoxycytidine was synthesized as a 5'- protected phosphoramidite compatible with solid phase DNA synthesis. When incorporated as the target cytosine (C*) in the GC*GC recognition sequence for the DNA methyltransferase M. HhaI, methyl transfer was strongly inhibited. In contrast, these same oligonucleotides were normal substrates for the cognate restriction endonuclease R. HhaI and its isoschizomer R. Hin P1I. M. HhaI was able to bind both 4'-thio-modified DNA and unmodified DNA to equivalent extents under equilibrium conditions. However, the presence of 4'-thio-2'-deoxycytidine decreased the half-life of the complex by >10-fold. The crystal structure of a ternary complex of M. HhaI, AdoMet and DNA containing 4'-thio-2'-deoxycytidine was solved at 2.05 A resolution with a crystallographic R-factor of 0.186 and R-free of 0.231. The structure is not grossly different from previously solved ternary complexes containing M. HhaI, DNA and AdoHcy. The difference electron density suggests partial methylation at C5 of the flipped target 4'-thio-2'-deoxycytidine. The inhibitory effect of the 4'sulfur atom on enzymatic activity may be traced to perturbation of a step in the methylation reaction after DNA binding but prior to methyl transfer. This inhibitory effect can be partially overcome after a considerably long time in the crystal environment where the packing prevents complex dissociation and the target is accurately positioned within the active site.

Construction of double-helical DNA structures based on dinucleotide building blocks

We present a new method for building full 3-D structures of DNA sequences. A database of the conformational properties of dinucleotide steps has been compiled using X-ray crystal structures of oligonucleotides. The protocol uses these dinucleotides as building blocks to generate three dimensional structures of any required sequence in any required conformation.

Unusual DNA conformations

DNA is on the move across conformational space. Duplexes diversity and, joined by triplexes, quadruplexes, loops, bulges and multiarmed junctions, open the route to a bewildering array of increasingly complex conformations. In addition to this structural growth, DNA has come under increasing scrutiny thanks to the development of chemical and physical techniques for deforming its conformation and probing its properties. These investigations help us to learn more about the mechanics and the activity of this remarkably versatile macromolecule.

Specific binding by EcoRV endonuclease to its DNA recognition site GATATC

Restriction endonuclease EcoRV has been reported to be unable to distinguish its specific DNA site, GATATC, from non-specific DNA sites in the absence of the catalytic cofactor Mg2+, and thus to exercise sequence specificity solely in the catalytic step. In contrast, we show here that under appropriate conditions of pH and salt concentration, specific complexes with oligonucleotides containing the GATATC site can be detected by either filter-binding or gel-retardation. Equilibrium binding constants (K(A)) are easily measured by both direct equilibrium and equilibrium-competition methods. The preference for "specific" over "non-specific" binding at pH 7 in the absence of divalent cations is about 1000-fold (per mole of oligonucleotide) or 12,000-fold (per mole of binding sites). Ethylation-interference footprinting shows that the "specific" complex includes strong contacts to the phosphate groups GpApTpApTC. Specific DNA binding is strongly pH-dependent, decreasing about 15-fold for each increase of one pH unit above pH 6, but non-specific binding is not; thus, binding specificity decreases with increasing pH. Gel retardation and filter-binding at pH < or = 7 yield essentially identical values of K(A) for specific-site binding, but at pH > 7 gel retardation significantly underestimates K(A). Specific-site binding is stimulated about 700-fold by Ca2+ (not a cofactor for cleavage), but with non-cleavable 3'-phosphorothiolate and 4'-thiodeoxyribose derivatives whose response to Ca2+ is similar to that of the parent oligonucleotide, Mg2+ stimulates binding only fourfold and twofold, respectively. Thus, binding specificity is not dramatically enhanced by Mg2+. Taking into account discrimination in binding and in the first-order rate constant for phosphodiester bond scission, the overall discrimination exercised against the incorrect site GTTATC is about 10(7)-fold. EcoRV endonuclease is thus not a "new paradigm" for site-specific interaction without binding specificity, but like other type II restriction endonucleases achieves sequence specificity by discriminating both in DNA binding and in catalysis.

Electrostatics and hydration at the homeodomain-DNA interface: chemical probes of an interfacial water cavity

Electrostatics and hydration of a homeodomain-DNA complex are dissected by chemical modification. Selective neutralization of phosphate charges by methylphosphonate substitution demonstrates the differential importance of short- and long-range electrostatic interactions. Whereas the footprint of direct contacts is in accord with crystal structures, interference is also observed at non-contacted sites. Such sites adjoin a novel interfacial water cavity in the major groove. Non-contacted phosphodiester groups in the cavity are proposed to contribute to long-range ordering of an extended protein-water-DNA interface. Use of isolated S(p) and R(p) methylphosphonate diastereomers demonstrates that interference at this extended interface is stereoselective and charge-independent. Attenuation of protein binding presumably reflects groove-specific reorganization of bound water. Surprisingly, such attenuation can exceed that due to neutralization of a direct phosphate-side-chain salt bridge. These results support the hypothesis that hydration of an interfacial cavity functions as a non-covalent extension of the DNA surface. Stereo-specific interrogation of bound water by chemical synthesis provides a general method to assess the coupling between solvation and DNA recognition.

Investigation of some properties of oligodeoxynucleotides containing 4'-thio-2'-deoxynucleotides: duplex hybridization and nuclease sensitivity

The thermal stabilities of the duplexes formed between 4'-thio-modified oligodeoxynucleotides and their DNA and RNA complementary strands were determined and compared with those of the corresponding unmodified oligodeoxynucleotides. A 16mer oligodeoxynucleotide containing 10 contiguous 4'-thiothymidylate modifications formed a less stable duplex with the DNA target (deltaTm/modification -1.0 degrees C) than the corresponding unmodified oligodeoxynucleotide. However, when the same oligodeoxynucleotide was bound to the corresponding RNA target, a small increase in Tm was observed (deltaTm/modification +0.16 degrees C) when compared with the unmodified duplex. A study to identify the specificity of an oligodeoxynucleotide containing a 4'-thiothymidylate modification when forming a duplex with DNA or RNA containing a single mismatch opposite the modification found the resulting Tms to be almost identical to the wild-type duplexes, demonstrating that the 4'-thio-modification in oligodeoxynucleotides has no deleterious effect on specificity. The nuclease stability of 4'-thio-modified oligodeoxynucleotides was examined using snake venom phosphodiesterase (SVPD) and nuclease S1. No significant resistance to degradation by the exonuclease SVPD was observed when compared with the corresponding unmodified oligodeoxynucleotide. However, 4'-thio-modified oligodeoxynucleotides were found to be highly resistant to degradation by the endonuclease S1. It was also demonstrated that 4'-thio-modified oligodeoxynucleotides elicit Escherichia coli RNase H hydrolysis of the RNA target only at high enzyme concentration.