DNA binding and phasing analyses of Tn5 transposase and a monomeric variant

G-quadruplex landscape and its regulation revealed by a new antibody capture method

Our understanding of DNA G-quadruplexes (G4s) from in vitro studies has been complemented by genome-wide G4 landscapes from cultured cells. Conventionally, the formation of G4s is accepted to depend on G-repeats such that they form tetrads. However, genome-wide G4s characterized through high-throughput sequencing suggest that these structures form at a large number of regions with no such canonical G4-forming signatures. Many G4-binding proteins have been described with no evidence for any protein that binds to and stabilizes G4s. It remains unknown what fraction of G4s formed in human cells are protein-bound. The G4-chromatin immunoprecipitation (G4-ChIP) method hitherto employed to describe G4 landscapes preferentially reports G4s that get crosslinked to proteins in their proximity. Our current understanding of the G4 landscape is biased against representation of G4s which escape crosslinking as they are not stabilized by protein-binding and presumably transient. We report a protocol that captures G4s from the cells efficiently without any bias as well as eliminates the detection of G4s formed artifactually on crosslinked sheared chromatin post-fixation. We discover that G4s form sparingly at SINEs. An application of this method shows that depletion of a repeat-binding protein CGGBP1 enhances net G4 capture at CGGBP1-dependent CTCF-binding sites and regions of sharp interstrand G/C-skew transitions. Thus, we present an improved method for G4 landscape determination and by applying it we show that sequence property-specific constraints of the nuclear environment mitigate G4 formation.

A Novel Next-Generation Sequencing and Analysis Platform to Assess the Identity of Recombinant Adeno-Associated Viral Preparations from Viral DNA Extracts

Recombinant adeno-associated virus (rAAV) vectors are increasingly popular gene delivery tools in biological systems. They are safe and lead to high-level, long-term transgene expression. rAAV are available in multiple serotypes, natural or engineered, which enable targeting to a wide array of tissues and cell types. In addition, rAAVs are relatively easily produced in a well-equipped lab or obtained from a viral vector core facility. Unfortunately, there is no standardization of quality control assays beyond titering and purity assessments. Next-generation sequencing (NGS) can be used to identify rAAV preparations. Because the rAAV genome is single stranded, previous studies have assumed that rAAV genomes must be converted to double strands before NGS. We demonstrate that rAAV DNA extracts exist primarily as double-stranded species. We hypothesize that these molecules form from the natural base pairing of complementary [+] and [−] strands after DNA extraction and show that rAAV DNA extracts are sufficient templates for downstream NGS without the labor-intensive double-stranding step. Here, we provide a detailed protocol for the simple and rapid NGS of rAAV genomes from DNA extracts. With this protocol, users can quickly confirm the identity of an rAAV preparation and detect the presence of contaminating rAAV DNA. In addition, we share custom Python scripts that allow users to accurately determine the serotype and detect Cre-independent DNA recombination events in rAAV containing Lox sites within minutes. We have used these scripts to analyze more than 100 rAAV preparations. Although we focused on the detection of cross-contaminating rAAV DNA and recombination events, our Python scripts can be customized to detect other sequences or events, such as reverse packaging of plasmid backbone or DNA from the packaging cell line. We find that the NGS of rAAV DNA extracts, termed viral genome sequencing, is a simple and powerful method for rAAV validation.

Transposons Tn 10 and Tn 5

The study of the bacterial transposons Tn 10 and Tn 5 has provided a wealth of information regarding steps in nonreplicative DNA transposition, transpososome dynamics and structure, as well as mechanisms employed to regulate transposition. The focus of ongoing research on these transposons is mainly on host regulation and the use of the Tn 10 antisense system as a platform to develop riboregulators for applications in synthetic biology. Over the past decade two new regulators of both Tn 10 and Tn 5 transposition have been identified, namely H-NS and Hfq proteins. These are both global regulators of gene expression in enteric bacteria with functions linked to stress-response pathways and virulence and potentially could link the Tn 10 and Tn 5 systems (and thus the transfer of antibiotic resistance genes) to environmental cues. Work summarized here is consistent with the H-NS protein working directly on transposition complexes to upregulate both Tn 10 and Tn 5 transposition. In contrast, evidence is discussed that is consistent with Hfq working at the level of transposase expression to downregulate both systems. With regard to Tn 10 and synthetic biology, some recent work that incorporates the Tn 10 antisense RNA into both transcriptional and translational riboswitches is summarized.

Transposase-transposase interactions in MOS1 complexes: a biochemical approach

Transposases are proteins that have assumed the mobility of class II transposable elements. In order to map the interfaces involved in transposase-transposase interactions, we have taken advantage of 12 transposase mutants that impair mariner transposase-transposase interactions taking place during transposition. Our data indicate that transposase-transposase interactions regulating Mos1 transposition are sophisticated and result from (i) active MOS1 dimerization through the first HTH of the N-terminal domain, which leads to inverted terminal repeat (ITR) binding; (ii) inactive dimerization carried by part of the C-terminal domain, which prevents ITR binding; and (iii) oligomerization. Inactive dimers are nonpermissive in organizing complexes that produce ITR binding, but the interfaces (or interactions) supplied in this state could play a role in the various rearrangements needed during transposition. Oligomerization is probably not due to a specific MOS1 domain, but rather the result of nonspecific interactions resulting from incorrect folding of the protein. Our data also suggest that the MOS1 catalytic domain is a main actor in the overall organization of MOS1, thus playing a role in MOS1 oligomerization. Finally, we propose that MOS1 behaves as predicted by the pre-equilibrium existing model, whereby proteins are found to exist simultaneously in populations with diverse conformations, monomers and active and inactive dimers for MOS1. We were able to identify several MOS1 mutants that modify this pre-existing equilibrium. According to their properties, some of these mutants will be useful tools to break down the remaining gaps in our understanding of mariner transposition.

The global bacterial regulator H-NS promotes transpososome formation and transposition in the Tn5 system

The histone-like nucleoid structuring protein (H-NS) is an important regulator of stress response and virulence genes in gram-negative bacteria. In addition to binding regulatory regions of genes in a structure-specific manner, H-NS also binds in a structure-specific manner to sites in the Tn10 transpososome, allowing it to act as a positive regulator of Tn10 transposition. This is the only example to date of H-NS regulating a transposition system by interacting directly with the transposition machinery. In general, transposition complexes tend to include segments of deformed DNA and given the capacity of H-NS to bind such structures, and the results from the Tn10 system, we asked if H-NS might regulate another transposition system (Tn5) by directly binding the transposition machinery. We show in the current work that H-NS does bind Tn5 transposition complexes and use hydroxyl radical footprinting to characterize the H-NS interaction with the Tn5 transpososome. We also show that H-NS can promote Tn5 transpososome formation in vitro, which correlates with the Tn5 system showing a dependence on H-NS for transposition in vivo. Taken together the results suggest that H-NS might play an important role in the regulation of many different bacterial transposition systems and thereby contribute directly to lateral gene transfer.

piggyBac can bypass DNA synthesis during cut and paste transposition

DNA synthesis is considered a defining feature in the movement of transposable elements. In determining the mechanism of piggyBac transposition, an insect transposon that is being increasingly used for genome manipulation in a variety of systems including mammalian cells, we have found that DNA synthesis can be avoided during piggyBac transposition, both at the donor site following transposon excision and at the insertion site following transposon integration. We demonstrate that piggyBac transposon excision occurs through the formation of transient hairpins on the transposon ends and that piggyBac target joining occurs by the direct attack of the 3'OH transposon ends on to the target DNA. This is the same strategy for target joining used by the members of DDE superfamily of transposases and retroviral integrases. Analysis of mutant piggyBac transposases in vitro and in vivo using a piggyBac transposition system we have established in Saccharomyces cerevisiae suggests that piggyBac transposase is a member of the DDE superfamily of recombinases, an unanticipated result because of the lack of sequence similarity between piggyBac and DDE family of recombinases.

Tn5 synaptic complex formation: role of transposase residue W450

A series of Tn5 transposases (Tnp's) with mutations at the conserved amino acid position W450, which was structurally predicted to be important for synapsis, have been generated and characterized. This study demonstrates that W450 is involved in hydrophobic (and possibly aromatic) contacts within the Tnp monomer that negatively regulate synaptic complex formation.

A bifunctional DNA binding region in Tn5 transposase

Tn5 transposition is a complicated process that requires the formation of a highly ordered protein-DNA structure, a synaptic complex, to catalyse the movement of a sequence of DNA (transposon) into a target DNA. Much is known about the structure of the synaptic complex and the positioning of protein-DNA contacts, although many protein-DNA contacts remain largely unstudied. In particular, there is little evidence for the positioning of donor DNA and target DNA. In this communication, we describe the isolation and analysis of mutant transposases that have, for the first time, provided genetic and biochemical evidence for the stage-specific positioning of both donor and target DNAs within the synaptic complex. Furthermore, we have provided evidence that some of the amino acids that contact donor DNA also contact target DNA, and therefore suggest that these amino acids help define a bifunctional DNA binding region responsible for these two transposase-DNA binding events.

Base-flipping dynamics in a DNA hairpin processing reaction

Many enzymes that repair or modify bases in double-stranded DNA gain access to their substrates by base flipping. Although crystal structures provide stunning snap shots, biochemical approaches addressing the dynamics have proven difficult, particularly in complicated multi-step reactions. Here, we use protein-DNA crosslinking and potassium permanganate reactivity to explore the base-flipping step in Tn5 transposition. We present a model to suggest that base flipping is driven by a combination of factors including DNA bending and the intrusion of a probe residue. The forces are postulated to act early in the reaction to create a state of tension, relieved by base flipping after cleavage of the first strand of DNA at the transposon end. Elimination of the probe residue retards the kinetics of nicking and reduces base flipping by 50%. Unexpectedly, the probe residue is even more important during the hairpin resolution step. Overall, base flipping is pivotal to the hairpin processing reaction because it performs two opposite but closely related functions. On one hand it disrupts the double helix, providing the necessary strand separation and steric freedom. While on the other, transposase appears to position the second DNA strand in the active site for cleavage using the flipped base as a handle.

Defining characteristics of Tn5 Transposase non-specific DNA binding

While non-specific DNA plays a role in target localization for many recombinases, transcription factors and restriction enzymes, the importance of non-specific DNA interactions for transposases has not been investigated. Here, we discuss non-specific DNA-Tn5 Transposase (Tnp) interactions and suggest how they stabilize the Tnp and modulate Tnp localization of the 19 bp Tnp recognition end sequences (ESes). DNA protection assays indicate that full-length Tnp interacts efficiently with supercoiled DNA that does not contain ESes. These interactions significantly prolong the lifetime of Tnp, in vitro. The balance between non-specific DNA bound and free Tnp is affected by DNA topology, yet, intermolecular transfer of active Tnp occurs with both supercoiled and linear non-specific DNA. Experiments with substrates of varying lengths show that Tn5 Tnp can utilize non-specific DNA to facilitate localization of an intramolecular ES over distances less than 464 bp. Finally, synaptic complex formation is inhibited in the presence of increasing concentrations of supercoiled and linear pUC19. These experiments strongly suggest that Tn5 Tnp has a robust non-specific DNA binding activity, that non-specific DNA modulates ES sequence localization within the global DNA, most likely through a direct transfer mechanism, and that non-specific DNA binding may play a role in the cis bias manifested by Tn5 transposition.

The transpososome: control of transposition at the level of catalysis

Studies of several transposable genetic elements have pinpointed the importance of the transpososome, a nucleoprotein complex involving the transposon ends and a transposon-encoded enzyme--the transposase--as a key in regulating transposition. Transpososomes provide a precise architecture within which the chemical reactions involved in transposon displacement occur. Data are accumulating that suggest they are dynamic and undergo staged conformational changes to accommodate different steps in the transposition pathway. This has been underpinned by recent results obtained particularly with Tn5, Tn10 and bacteriophage Mu.

Topological measurement of an A-tract bend angle: effect of magnesium

Sequences of four to six adenine residues, termed A-tracts, have been shown to produce curvature in the DNA double helix. A-tracts have been used extensively as reference standards to quantify bending induced by other sequences as well as by DNA binding proteins when they bind to their sites. However, the ability of an A-tract to serve as such a standard is hampered by the wide variation of values reported for the amount of bend conferred by an A-tract. One experimental condition that differs in these studies is the presence of divalent cation. To evaluate this effect, a new application of a topological method, termed rotational variant analysis, is used here to measure for the first time the effect of the presence of magnesium ion on the bend angle conferred by an A-tract. This method, which has the unique ability to measure a bend angle in the presence or absence of magnesium ion, demonstrates that magnesium ion markedly increases the bend angle. For example, when measured in a commonly used gel electrophoretic buffer, the bend angle conferred by a tract of six adenine residues increases from about 7 degrees in the absence of magnesium ion to 19 degrees in the presence of 3.9 mM magnesium ion. This quantitative demonstration of substantial magnesium ion dependence has several important implications. First, it explains discrepancies among bend values reported in various previous studies, particularly those employing gel electrophoretic versus other solution methods. In addition, these findings necessitate substantial revisions of the conclusions in a large number of studies that have used A-tract DNA as the bend angle reference standard in comparison measurements. Finally, any such future studies employing this comparison methodology will need to use the same sequence analyzed in the original measurements as well as replicate the original measurement conditions (e.g. ionic composition and temperature).

DNA sequence bias during Tn5 transposition

Transposition is one of the primary mechanisms causing genome instability. This phenomenon is mechanistically related to other DNA rearrangements such as V(D)J recombination and retroviral DNA integration. In the Tn5 system, only one protein, the transposase (Tnp), is required for all of the catalytic steps involved in transposon movement. The complexity involved in moving multiple DNA strands within one active site suggests that, in addition to the specific contacts maintained between Tnp and its recognition sequence, Tnp also interacts with the flanking DNA sequence. Here, we demonstrate that Tnp interacts with the donor DNA region. Tnp protects the donor DNA from DNase I digestion, suggesting that Tnp is in contact with, or otherwise distorts, the donor DNA during synapsis. In addition, changes in the donor DNA sequence within this region alter the affinity of Tnp for DNA by eightfold during synapsis. In vitro selection for more stable synaptic complexes reveals an A/T sequence bias for this region. We further show that certain donor DNA sequences, which favor synapsis, also appear to serve as hot spots for strand transfer. The TTATA donor sequence represents the best site. Most surprising is the fact that this sequence is found within the Tnp recognition sequence. Preference for insertion into a site within the Tnp recognition sequence would effectively inactivate one copy of the element and form clusters of the Tn5 transposon. In addition, the fact that several donor DNA sequences, which favor synapsis, appear to serve as hot spots for transposon insertion suggest that similar criteria may exist for Tnp-donor DNA and Tnp-target DNA interactions.

Tn5 as a model for understanding DNA transposition

Tn5 is an excellent model system for understanding the molecular basis of DNA-mediated transposition. Mechanistic information has come from genetic and biochemical investigations of the transposase and its interactions with the recognition DNA sequences at the ends of the transposon. More recently, molecular structure analyses of catalytically active transposase; transposon DNA complexes have provided us with unprecedented insights into this transposition system. Transposase initiates transposition by forming a dimeric transposase, transposon DNA complex. In the context of this complex, the transposase then catalyses four phosphoryl transfer reactions (DNA nicking, DNA hairpin formation, hairpin resolution and strand transfer into target DNA) resulting in the integration of the transposon into its new DNA site. The studies that elucidated these steps also provided important insights into the integration of retroviral genomes into host DNA and the immune system V(D)J joining process. This review will describe the structures and steps involved in Tn5 transposition and point out a biologically important although surprising characteristic of the wild-type Tn5 transposase. Transposase is a very inactive protein. An inactive transposase protein ensures the survival of the host and thus the survival of Tn5.

Evidence for "unseen" transposase--DNA contacts

In this study, evidence of novel, important interactions between a hyperactive Tn5 transposon recognition end sequence and hyperactive Tn5 transposase (Tnp) are presented. A hyperactive Tn5 end sequence, the mosaic end (ME), was isolated previously. The ME and a wild-type end sequence, the outside end (OE), differ at only three positions, yet transposition on the ME is tenfold higher than on the OE in vivo. Also, transposition on the ME is much more efficient than transposition on the OE in vitro. Here, we show that the decreased activity observed for the OE is caused by a defect in paired ends complex (PEC) formation resulting from the orientation of the A-T base-pair at position 4 of this end. Efficient PEC formation requires an interaction between the C5-methyl group (C5-Me) on the non-transferred strand thymine base at position 4 (T4) and Tnp. PEC formation on nicked substrates is much less affected by the orientation of the A-T base-pair at position 4, indicating that the C5-Me group is important only for steps preceding nicking. A recently determined co-crystal structure of Tn5 Tnp with the ME is discussed and a model explaining possible roles for the base-pair at position 4 is explored.

Functional characterization of arginine 30, lysine 40, and arginine 62 in Tn5 transposase

Three N-terminal basic residues of Tn5 transposase, which are associated with proteolytic cleavages by Escherichia coli proteinases, were mutated to glutamine residues with the goal of producing more stable transposase molecules. Mutation of either arginine 30 or arginine 62 to glutamine produced transposase molecules that were more stable toward E. coli proteinases than the parent hyperactive Tn5 transposase, however, they were inactive in vivo. In vitro analysis revealed these mutants were inactive, because both Arg(30) and Arg(62) are required for formation of the paired ends complexes when the transposon is attached to the donor backbone. These results suggest Arg(30) and Arg(62) play critical roles in DNA binding and/or synaptic complex formation. Mutation of lysine 40 to glutamine did not increase the overall stability of the transposase to E. coli proteinases. This mutant transposase was only about 1% as active as the parent hyperactive transposase in vivo; however, it retained nearly full activity in vitro. These results suggest that lysine 40 is important for a step in the transposition mechanism that is bypassed in the in vitro assay system, such as the removal of the transposase molecule from DNA following strand transfer.

Determinants for hairpin formation in Tn10 transposition

Tn10 transposition involves the formation of a hairpin intermediate at the transposon termini. Here we show that hairpin formation exhibits more stringent DNA sequence requirements at the terminal two base pairs than either transpososome assembly or first strand nicking. We also observe a significant DNA distortion at the terminal base pairs upon transpososome assembly by chemical nuclease footprinting. Interestingly, mutations at these positions do not necessarily inhibit the formation of the distortion. However, it remains a possibility that the inhibitory effect of these mutations is due to a defect in protein-DNA interactions subsequent to this deformation. Terminal base pair mutations also inhibited strand transfer, providing evidence that transposase interactions with the terminal residues on both 'transferred' and 'non-transferred' strands are important for hairpin formation. We also demonstrate that mutation of a highly conserved tyrosine residue that is a component of the YREK motif, Y285, results in a phenotype comparable to that of the terminal base pair mutations. In contrast, a mutation at another conserved position, W265, is shown to relax the specificity of the hairpin formation reaction.

Analysis of sequence-dependent curvature in matrix attachment regions

Sequence-dependent DNA conformations of matrix attachment regions (MARs) available in a database were calculated using the wedge model, and compared with randomly chosen genes, promoters, enhancers and transposons. The MARs had a longer bent part and higher angle/helical turn than the other regions. It is known that some MAR sequences have A-tracts that cause DNA bending, and we also found many A-tracts in examined MARs. Furthermore, non-random and clustered distribution of A-tracts shown here gave further evidence of the importance of A-tracts for MAR conformations. These results suggest that DNAs of MARs have a characteristic conformation instead of conserved sequence.

Characterization of a Tn5 pre-cleavage synaptic complex

Protein catalyzed DNA rearrangements typically require assembly of complex nucleoprotein structures. In transposition and integration reactions, these structures, termed synaptic complexes, are mandatory for catalysis. We characterize the Tn5 pre-cleavage synaptic complex, the simplest transposition complex described to date. We identified this complex by gel retardation assay using short, linear fragments and have shown that it contains a dimer of transposase, two DNA molecules, and is competent for DNA cleavage in the presence of Mg(2+). We also used hydroxyl radical footprinting and interference techniques to delineate the protein-DNA contacts made in the Tn5 synaptic and monomer complexes. All positions (except position 1) of the end sequence are contacted by transposase in the synaptic complex. We have determined that positions 2-5 of the end sequence are specifically required for synaptic complex formation as they are not required for monomer complex formation. In addition, in the synaptic complex, there is a strong, local distortion centered around position 1 which likely facilitates cleavage.

Three-dimensional structure of the Tn5 synaptic complex transposition intermediate

Genomic evolution has been profoundly influenced by DNA transposition, a process whereby defined DNA segments move freely about the genome. Transposition is mediated by transposases, and similar events are catalyzed by retroviral integrases such as human immunodeficiency virus-1 (HIV-1) integrase. Understanding how these proteins interact with DNA is central to understanding the molecular basis of transposition. We report the three-dimensional structure of prokaryotic Tn5 transposase complexed with Tn5 transposon end DNA determined to 2.3 angstrom resolution. The molecular assembly is dimeric, where each double-stranded DNA molecule is bound by both protein subunits, orienting the transposon ends into the active sites. This structure provides a molecular framework for understanding many aspects of transposition, including the binding of transposon end DNA by one subunit and cleavage by a second, cleavage of two strands of DNA by a single active site via a hairpin intermediate, and strand transfer into target DNA.

Tn5: A molecular window on transposition

DNA transposition is an underlying process involved in the remodeling of genomes in all types of organisms. We analyze the multiple steps in cut-and-paste transposition using the bacterial transposon Tn5 as a model. This system is particularly illuminating because of the existence of structural, genetic, and biochemical information regarding the two participating specific macromolecules: the transposase and the 19-bp sequences that define the ends of the transposon. However, most of the insights should be of general interest because of similarities to other transposition-like systems such as HIV-1 DNA integration into the host genome.

Factors affecting transposition of the Himar1 mariner transposon in vitro

Mariner family transposable elements are widespread in animals, but their regulation is poorly understood, partly because only two are known to be functional. These are particular copies of the Dmmar1 element from Drosophila mauritiana, for example, Mos1, and the consensus sequence of the Himar1 element from the horn fly, Haematobia irritans. An in vitro transposition system was refined to investigate several parameters that influence the transposition of Himar1. Transposition products accumulated linearly over a period of 6 hr. Transposition frequency increased with temperature and was dependent on Mg2+ concentration. Transposition frequency peaked over a narrow range of transposase concentration. The decline at higher concentrations, a phenomenon observed in vivo with Mos1, supports the suggestion that mariners may be regulated in part by "overproduction inhibition." Transposition frequency decreased exponentially with increasing transposon size and was affected by the sequence of the flanking DNA of the donor site. A noticeable bias in target site usage suggests a preference for insertion into bent or bendable DNA sequences rather than any specific nucleotide sequences beyond the TA target site.

Determinants of the position of a Flp-induced DNA bend

The Flp site-specific recombinase from Saccharomyces cerevisiae induces DNA bending upon interaction with the Flp recognition target (FRT) site. The minimal FRT site is comprised of two inverted binding elements which flank a central core region. Binding of a single monomer of Flp to DNA induces a DNA bend of 60 degrees. The position of this bend differed depending on whether the substrate contained a single binding element or a two-element FRT site. In the present work we tested and disproved a model in which a single Flp monomer interacts with both symmetry elements of a single FRT site. Likewise, we showed that a model in which a Flp monomer dissociates from a singly occupied FRT site and reassociates with the unbound element of another singly occupied FRT site during electrophoresis, does not account for the apparent shift in the position of the bend centre. It seems that the movement of a Flp monomer between the a and b elements of one FRT site during electrophoresis accounts for this anomaly. The position of the DNA bend resulting from the association of a Flp monomer with the FRT site is also influenced by the DNA sequences flanking the site. We conclude that attempts to measure the bend centre of a complex of one Flp molecule bound to a DNA containing two binding elements give misleading results. The position of the bend is more accurately measured in the presence of a single binding element.

Tn5 transposase mutants that alter DNA binding specificity

Tn5 transposase (Tnp) binds to Tn5 and IS50 end inverted repeats, the outside end (OE) and the inside end (IE), to initiate transposition. We report the isolation of four Tnp mutants (YH41, TP47, EK54 and EV54) that increase the OE-mediated transposition frequency and enhance the binding affinity of Tnp for OE DNA. In addition, two of the Tnp mutants (TP47 and EK54) appear to be change-of-specificity mutants, since they alter the recognition of OE versus IE relative to the wild-type Tnp. EK54 enhances OE recognition but decreases IE recognition. TP47 enhances both OE and IE recognition but with a much greater enhancement for IE than for OE. This change-of-specificity effect of TP47 is observed only when TP47 Tnp is synthesized in cis to the DNA that contains the ends. We propose that Lys54 makes a favorable interaction with an OE-specific nucleotide pair(s), while Pro47 may cause a more favorable interaction with an IE-specific nucleotide pair(s) than it does with the corresponding OE-specific nucleotide pair(s). A model to explain the preference of TP47 Tnp for the IE in cis but not in trans is proposed.