Oligoribonucleotide circularization by 'template-mediated' ligation with T4 RNA ligase: synthesis of circular hammerhead ribozymes

Circular RNAs: Novel Players in Cancer Mechanisms and Therapeutic Strategies

Circular RNAs (circRNAs) are a novel class of noncoding RNAs that have emerged as pivotal players in gene regulation. Our understanding of circRNAs has greatly expanded over the last decade, with studies elucidating their biology and exploring their therapeutic applications. In this review, we provide an overview of the current understanding of circRNA biogenesis, outline their mechanisms of action in cancer, and assess their clinical potential as biomarkers. Furthermore, we discuss circRNAs as a potential therapeutic strategy, including recent advances in circRNA production and translation, along with proof-of-concept preclinical studies of cancer vaccines.

In Vitro Transcribed RNA-Based Platform Vaccines: Past, Present, and Future

mRNA was discovered in 1961, but it was not used as a vaccine until after three decades. Recently, the development of mRNA vaccine technology gained great impetus from the pursuit of vaccines against COVID-19. To improve the properties of RNA vaccines, and primarily their circulation time, self-amplifying mRNA and trans-amplifying mRNA were developed. A separate branch of mRNA technology is circular RNA vaccines, which were developed with the discovery of the possibility of translation on their protein matrix. Circular RNA has several advantages over mRNA vaccines and is considered a fairly promising platform, as is trans-amplifying mRNA. This review presents an overview of the mRNA platform and a critical discussion of the more modern self-amplifying mRNA, trans-amplifying mRNA, and circular RNA platforms created on its basis. Finally, the main features, advantages, and disadvantages of each of the presented mRNA platforms are discussed. This discussion will facilitate the decision-making process in selecting the most appropriate platform for creating RNA vaccines against cancer or viral diseases.

Circular RNA vaccine in disease prevention and treatment

CircRNAs are a class of single-stranded RNAs with covalently linked head-to-tail topology. In the decades since its initial discovery, their biogenesis, regulation, and function have rapidly disclosed, permitting a better understanding and adoption of them as new tools for medical applications. With the development of biotechnology and molecular medicine, artificial circRNAs have been engineered as a novel class of vaccines for disease treatment and prevention. Unlike the linear mRNA vaccine which applications were limited by its instability, inefficiency, and innate immunogenicity, circRNA vaccine which incorporate internal ribosome entry sites (IRESs) and open reading frame (ORF) provides an improved approach to RNA-based vaccination with safety, stability, simplicity of manufacture, and scalability. However, circRNA vaccines are at an early stage, and their optimization, delivery and applications require further development and evaluation. In this review, we comprehensively describe circRNA vaccine, including their history and superiority. We also summarize and discuss the current methodological research for circRNA vaccine preparation, including their design, synthesis, and purification. Finally, we highlight the delivery options of circRNA vaccine and its potential applications in diseases treatment and prevention. Considering their unique high stability, low immunogenicity, protein/peptide-coding capacity and special closed-loop construction, circRNA vaccine, and circRNA-based therapeutic platforms may have superior application prospects in a broad range of diseases.

Tactics targeting circular mRNA biosynthesis

Faced with the development of mRNA technology in the field of medicine and vaccine, circular mRNA (circmRNA) becomes a strong alternative to mRNA for its circular secondary structure and higher stability. At present, the synthesis of circmRNAs has been realized by ligating linear mRNA precursors and is limited by poor efficiency. To solve this challenge, this study started with ribozyme catalysis and enzymatic reaction to explore different circmRNA biosynthesis strategies. In terms of ribozyme method, by screening different group I intron self-splicing system sequences, the sequence from thymidylate synthase (Td) gene of phage T4 showed the highest ligation efficiency. In terms of enzyme method, with the help of 20-bp homologous arm, T4 Rnl 2 was determined as the ligation method with the highest ligation efficiency. By comparing the two ligation methods, the expression level of circmRNA ligated by T4 Rnl 2 was 86% higher than that ligated by Td ribozyme. Based on these ligation methods, the screening results of internal ribosome entry site (IRES) sequences showed that mud crab dicistrovirus IRES was an IRES sequence with high ribosome binding ability and could be widely used in circmRNAs for efficient and stable translation in mammalian cells. These results should provide positive guidance for the industrial production of circmRNAs and the development of mRNA vaccines. Eventually, circmRNAs could widely function in the field of biomedicine.

Pros and Cons of In Vitro Methods for Circular RNA Preparation

mRNA is gaining success as a new therapeutic agent and vaccine. However, mRNA has limitations in stability. To overcome the shortcomings of mRNA, circular RNA is emerging as a new modality. In this review, several current methods of manufacturing circular RNA in vitro are introduced and their advantages and disadvantages are reviewed. Furthermore, this study discusses which fields and directions of research and development are needed for the increase in the efficacy and productivity of circular RNA as a therapeutic agent and vaccine formulation.

Phospho-RNA sequencing with circAID-p-seq

Most RNA footprinting approaches that require ribonuclease cleavage generate RNA fragments bearing a phosphate or cyclic phosphate group at their 3′ end. Unfortunately, current library preparation protocols rely only on a 3′ hydroxyl group for adaptor ligation or poly-A tailing. Here, we developed circAID-p-seq, a PCR-free library preparation for selective 3′ phospho-RNA sequencing. As a proof of concept, we applied circAID-p-seq to ribosome profiling, which is based on sequencing of RNA fragments protected by ribosomes after endonuclease digestion. CircAID-p-seq, combined with the dedicated computational pipeline circAidMe, facilitates accurate, fast and highly efficient sequencing of phospho-RNA fragments from eukaryotic cells and tissues. We used circAID-p-seq to portray ribosome occupancy in transcripts, providing a versatile and PCR-free strategy to possibly unravel any endogenous 3′-phospho RNA molecules.

The design and synthesis of circular RNAs

Circular RNAs (circRNAs) are a novel class of RNAs distinguished by their single-stranded, covalently-closed topology. Although initially perceived as rare byproducts of aberrant splicing, circRNAs are now recognized as ubiquitously expressed and functionally significant. These discoveries have led to a growing need for ways to model circRNAs in living cells to advance our understanding of their biogenesis, regulation, and function, and to adopt them as new technologies for application within research and medicine. In this review, we provide an updated summary of approaches used to produce circRNAs in vitro and in vivo, the latter of which has grown considerably in recent years. Given increased interest in the unique functions carried out by individual circRNAs, we further dedicate a section on how to customize synthesized circRNAs for specific biological roles. We focus on the most common applications, including designing circRNAs for protein delivery, to target miRNAs and proteins, to act as fluorescent reporters, and to modulate cellular immunity.

Circular RNA: Biosynthesis in vitro

Circular RNA (circRNA) is a unique type of noncoding RNA molecule. Compared with traditional linear RNA, circRNA is a covalently closed circle produced by a process called backsplicing. CircRNA is abundant in many cells and has rich functions in cells, such as acting as miRNA sponge, protein sponge, protein scaffold, and mRNA regulator. With the continuous development of circRNA study, circRNA has also played an important role in medical applications, including circRNA vaccines and gene therapy. In this review, we illustrate the synthesis of circRNAs in vitro. We focus on biological ligation methods, such as enzymatic ligation from the bacteriophage T4 and ribozyme method. In addition, we summarize the current challenges in the design, synthesis, application, and production of circRNAs, and propose possible solutions in the future. CircRNA is expected to play an essential role in basic research and medical applications.

Preferential production of RNA rings by T4 RNA ligase 2 without any splint through rational design of precursor strand

Rings of single-stranded RNA are promising for many practical applications, but the methods to prepare them in preparative scale have never been established. Previously, RNA circularization was achieved by T4 RNA ligase 2 (Rnl2, a dsRNA ligase) using splints, but the yield was low due to concurrent intermolecular polymerization. Here, various functional RNAs (siRNA, miRNA, ribozyme, etc.) are dominantly converted by Rnl2 to the rings without significant limitations in sizes and sequences. The key is to design a precursor RNA, which is highly activated for the efficient circularization without any splint. First, secondary structure of target RNA ring is simulated by Mfold, and then hypothetically cut at one site so that a few intramolecular base pairs are formed at the terminal. Simply by treating this RNA with Rnl2, the target ring was selectively and efficiently produced. Unexpectedly, circular RNA can be obtained in high yield (>90%), even when only 2 bp form in the 3'-OH side and no full match base pair forms in the 5'-phosphate side. Formation of polymeric by-products was further suppressed by diluting conventional Rnl2 buffer to abnormally low concentrations. Even at high-RNA concentrations (e.g. 50 μM), enormously high selectivity (>95%) was accomplished.

XNA ligation using T4 DNA ligase in crowding conditions

T4 DNA ligase is capable of ligating 2'OMe-RNA duplexes, HNA, LNA and FANA mixed sequences in the presence of 10% w/v PEG8000 and 3 M betaine. The enzymatic joining of oligonucleotides containing multiple consecutive XNA nucleotides at the ligation site has not been reported before.

In vitro circularization of RNA

Over the past 2 decades, different types of circular RNAs have been discovered in all kingdoms of life, and apparently, those circular species are more abundant than previously thought. Apart from circRNAs in viroids and viruses, circular transcripts have been discovered in rodents more than 20 y ago and recently have been reported to be abundant in many organisms including humans. Their exact function remains still unknown, although one may expect extensive functional studies to follow the currently dominant research into identification and discovery of circRNA by sophisticated sequencing techniques and bioinformatics. Functional studies require models and as such methods for preparation of circRNA in vitro. Here, we will review current protocols for RNA circularization and discuss future prospects in the field.

RNA circularization strategies in vivo and in vitro

In the plenitude of naturally occurring RNAs, circular RNAs (circRNAs) and their biological role were underestimated for years. However, circRNAs are ubiquitous in all domains of life, including eukaryotes, archaea, bacteria and viruses, where they can fulfill diverse biological functions. Some of those functions, as for example playing a role in the life cycle of viral and viroid genomes or in the maturation of tRNA genes, have been elucidated; other putative functions still remain elusive. Due to the resistance to exonucleases, circRNAs are promising tools for in vivo application as aptamers, trans-cleaving ribozymes or siRNAs. How are circRNAs generated in vivo and what approaches do exist to produce ring-shaped RNAs in vitro? In this review we illustrate the occurrence and mechanisms of RNA circularization in vivo, survey methods for the generation of circRNA in vitro and provide appropriate protocols.

Identification and remediation of biases in the activity of RNA ligases in small-RNA deep sequencing

Deep sequencing of small RNAs (sRNA-seq) is now the gold standard for small RNA profiling and discovery. Biases in sRNA-seq have been reported, but their etiology remains unidentified. Through a comprehensive series of sRNA-seq experiments, we establish that the predominant cause of the bias is the RNA ligases. We further demonstrate that RNA ligases have strong sequence-specific biases which distort the small RNA profiles considerably. We have devised a pooled adapter strategy to overcome this bias, and validated the method through data derived from microarray and qPCR. In light of our findings, published small RNA profiles, as well as barcoding strategies using adapter-end modifications, may need to be revisited. Importantly, by providing a wide spectrum of substrate for the ligase, the pooled-adapter strategy developed here provides a means to overcome issues of bias, and generate more accurate small RNA profiles.

RNA labeling, conjugation and ligation

Advances in RNA nanotechnology will depend on the ability to manipulate, probe the structure and engineer the function of RNA with high precision. This article reviews current abilities to incorporate site-specific labels or to conjugate other useful molecules to RNA either directly or indirectly through post-synthetic labeling methodologies that have enabled a broader understanding of RNA structure and function. Readily applicable modifications to RNA can range from isotopic labels and fluorescent or other molecular probes to protein, lipid, glycoside or nucleic acid conjugates that can be introduced using combinations of synthetic chemistry, enzymatic incorporation and various conjugation chemistries. These labels, conjugations and ligations to RNA are quintessential for further investigation and applications of RNA as they enable the visualization, structural elucidation, localization, and biodistribution of modified RNA.

miR-ID: a novel, circularization-based platform for detection of microRNAs

MicroRNAs (miRNAs) are important regulators of gene expression and have great potential as biomarkers, prognostic indicators, and therapeutic targets. Determining the expression patterns of these molecules is essential for elucidating their biogenesis, regulation, relation to disease, and response to therapy. Although PCR-based assays are commonly used for expression profiling of miRNAs, the small size, sequence heterogeneity, and (in some cases) end modifications of miRNAs constrain the performance of existing PCR methods. Here we introduce miR-ID, a novel method that avoids these constraints while providing superior sensitivity and sequence specificity at a lower cost. It also has the unique ability to differentiate unmodified small RNAs from those carrying 2'-OMe groups at their 3'-ends while detecting both forms. miR-ID is comprised of the following steps: (1) circularization of the miRNA by a ligase; (2) reverse transcription of the circularized miRNA (RTC), producing tandem repeats of a DNA sequence complementary to the miRNA; and (3) qPCR amplification of segments of this multimeric cDNA using 5'-overlapping primers and a nonspecific dye such as SYBR Green. No chemically modified probes (e.g., TaqMan) or primers (e.g., LNA) are required. The circular RNA and multimeric cDNA templates provide unmatched flexibility in the positioning of primers, which may include straddling the boundaries between these repetitive miRNA sequences. miR-ID is based on new findings that are themselves of general interest, including reverse transcription of small RNA circles and the use of 5'-overlapping primers for detection of repetitive sequences by qPCR.

Discovery and characterization of a thermostable bacteriophage RNA ligase homologous to T4 RNA ligase 1

Thermophilic viruses represent a novel source of genetic material and enzymes with great potential for use in biotechnology. We have isolated a number of thermophilic viruses from geothermal areas in Iceland, and by combining high throughput genome sequencing and state of the art bioinformatics we have identified a number of genes with potential use in biotechnology. We have also demonstrated the existence of thermostable counterparts of previously known bacteriophage enzymes. Here we describe a thermostable RNA ligase 1 from the thermophilic bacteriophage RM378 that infects the thermophilic eubacterium Rhodothermus marinus. The RM378 RNA ligase 1 has a temperature optimum of 60-64 degrees C and it ligates both RNA and single-stranded DNA. Its thermostability and ability to work under conditions of high temperature where nucleic acid secondary structures are removed makes it an ideal enzyme for RNA ligase-mediated rapid amplification of cDNA ends (RLM-RACE), and other RNA and DNA ligation applications.

Addition of non-genomically encoded nucleotides to the 3'-terminus of maize mitochondrial mRNAs: truncated rps12 mRNAs frequently terminate with CCA

The 3'-termini of maize mitochondrial RNAs were characterized by ligation of an anchor oligonucleotide, reverse transcription and amplification. DNA sequence analysis of cDNA clones for tRNA(Ser) and 18S rRNA confirmed the expected 3'-terminal nucleotides and demonstrated the accuracy and fidelity of the protocol. Analysis of cDNAs for rps12, cox2 and atp9 indicated that non-genomically encoded nucleotides were present at the 3'-terminus. rps12 cDNAs exhibited the highest degree of modification, with 94% of 35 cDNA clones analyzed containing one to four non-genomically encoded C or A residues; 83% of these cDNAs terminated with the trinucleotide CCA. DNA sequence and transcript mapping analyses demonstrated that four positions exhibited modified 3'-termini within a small region of the 3' flank of rps12 transcripts. These transcript termini represented low abundance, truncated forms of rps12 mRNAs which may be intermediates in degradation. cox2 mRNAs are also modified at a truncated position. Sixty percent of the cox2 cDNAs were modified with 1-5 nt that most frequently included A and C residues, but also included a few G and T residues. Non-genomically encoded nucleotides were detected in 27% of the atp9 cDNAs as a single C or A residue.

Y-ligation: an efficient method for ligating single-stranded DNAs and RNAs with T4 RNA ligase

Very efficient ligation of oligodeoxyribonucleotides was attained through a simple molecular construct, which is composed of one stem and two branches (Y-shape), with use of T4 RNA ligase. Single-stranded DNAs (naturally, RNAs also) of more than 100 nucleotides (even 800 nts) were considerably ligated, approximately as theoretically expected. Owing to the molecular construct adopted, such a tiny amount of ligation products could be amplified to a sufficient amount by PCR and then recovered as single-stranded DNAs. This advantage of being amplifiable is shown to be useful for both combinatorial chemistry and evolutionary molecular engineering, which deal with a pool of diversity molecules.

Novel configurations of the hammerhead ribozyme: increased activity and reduced magnesium ion requirement

The hammerhead ribozyme is one of the smallest of known catalytic RNAs. Its structure and mechanism have been examined using a broad range of approaches. Recently, crystal structures of the hammerhead have been reported. Within the crystal the hammerhead exists in a Y-shaped configuration in which helices I and II form the adjacent upper arms, while helix III forms the lower leg of the Y. Based on these findings, hammerheads in which helix I and II are constrained to remain adjacent and roughly parallel are expected to be catalytically active. We have examined this possibility with two novel hammerhead configurations, circular and circular/hairpin. These circular and circular/hairpin hammerhead ribozymes possess activity comparable to, and in some cases even greater than, non-constrained hammerheads. Since these novel ribozymes are constrained into a closed, and active conformation, they offer advantages for structure/function studies. Additionally, these novel ribozymes will be adventitious for antisense mediated gene inhibition, since they possess increased activity and a reduced requirement for magnesium ion, and are expected to be more resistant to nuclease degradation.