Functional characterization of Caenorhabditis elegans DNA topoisomerase IIIalpha

Replication-associated formation and repair of human topoisomerase IIIα cleavage complexes

Topoisomerase IIIα (TOP3A) belongs to the conserved Type IA family of DNA topoisomerases. Here we report that human TOP3A is associated with DNA replication forks and that a "self-trapping" TOP3A mutant (TOP3A-R364W) generates cellular TOP3A DNA cleavage complexes (TOP3Accs). We show that trapped TOP3Accs that interfere with replication, induce DNA damage and genome instability. To elucidate how TOP3Accs are repaired, we explored the role of Spartan (SPRTN), the metalloprotease associated with DNA replication, which digests proteins forming DNA-protein crosslinks (DPCs). We find that SPRTN-deficient cells show elevated TOP3Accs, whereas overexpression of SPRTN lowers cellular TOP3Accs. SPRTN is deubiquitinated and epistatic with TDP2 in response to TOP3Accs. In addition, we found that MRE11 can excise TOP3Accs, and that cell cycle determines the preference for the SPRTN-TDP2 vs. the ATM-MRE11 pathways, in S vs. G2, respectively. Our study highlights the prevalence of TOP3Accs repair mechanisms to ensure normal DNA replication.

Endogenous localization of TOP-2 in C. elegans using a C-terminal GFP-tag

To investigate the dynamic localization of Topoisomerase II in live C. elegans we have generated a C-terminally GFP-tagged version of TOP-2 at the endogenous locus. We found that TOP-2::GFP localizes in a similar pattern to the previously published TOP-2::3XFLAG strain and does not disrupt the meiotic chromosome segregation functions of this enzyme.

Different functional roles of RTR complex factors in DNA repair and meiosis in Arabidopsis and tomato

The RTR (RecQ/Top3/Rmi1) complex has been elucidated as essential for ensuring genome stability in eukaryotes. Fundamental for the dissolution of Holliday junction (HJ)-like recombination intermediates, the factors have been shown to play further, partly distinct roles in DNA repair and homologous recombination. Across all kingdoms, disruption of this complex results in characteristic phenotypes including hyper-recombination and sensitivity to genotoxins. The type IA topoisomerase TOP3α has been shown as essential for viability in various animals. In contrast, in the model plant species Arabidopsis, the top3α mutant is viable. rmi1 mutants are deficient in the repair of DNA damage. Moreover, as opposed to other eukaryotes, TOP3α and RMI1 were found to be indispensable for proper meiotic progression, with mutants showing severe meiotic defects and sterility. We now established mutants of both TOP3α and RMI1 in tomato using CRISPR/Cas technology. Surprisingly, we found phenotypes that differed dramatically from those of Arabidopsis: the top3α mutants proved to be embryo-lethal, implying an essential role of the topoisomerase in tomato. In contrast, no defect in somatic DNA repair or meiosis was detectable for rmi1 mutants in tomato. This points to a differentiation of function of RTR complex partners between plant species. Our results indicate that there are relevant differences in the roles of basic factors involved in DNA repair and meiosis within dicotyledons, and thus should be taken as a note of caution when generalizing knowledge regarding basic biological processes obtained in the model plant Arabidopsis for the entire plant kingdom.

DNA topoisomerase 3 is required for efficient germ cell quality control

An important quality control mechanism eliminates meiocytes that have experienced recombination failure during meiosis. The culling of defective oocytes in Caenorhabditis elegans meiosis resembles late oocyte elimination in female mammals. Here we show that topoisomerase 3 depletion generates DNA lesions in both germline mitotic and meiotic compartments that are less capable of triggering p53 (cep-1)–dependent apoptosis, despite the activation of DNA damage and apoptosis signaling. Elimination of nonhomologous, alternative end joining and single strand annealing repair factors (CKU-70, CKU-80, POLQ-1, and XPF-1) can alleviate the apoptosis block. Remarkably, the ability of single mutants in the other members of the Bloom helicase-topoisomerase-RMI1 complex to elicit apoptosis is not compromised, and depletion of Bloom helicase in topoisomerase 3 mutants restores an effective apoptotic response. Therefore, uncontrolled Bloom helicase activity seems to direct DNA repair toward normally not used repair pathways, and this counteracts efficient apoptosis. This implicates an as-yet undescribed requirement for topoisomerase 3 in mounting an effective apoptotic response to ensure germ cell quality control.

The many lives of type IA topoisomerases

The double-helical structure of genomic DNA is both elegant and functional in that it serves both to protect vulnerable DNA bases and to facilitate DNA replication and compaction. However, these design advantages come at the cost of having to evolve and maintain a cellular machinery that can manipulate a long polymeric molecule that readily becomes topologically entangled whenever it has to be opened for translation, replication, or repair. If such a machinery fails to eliminate detrimental topological entanglements, utilization of the information stored in the DNA double helix is compromised. As a consequence, the use of B-form DNA as the carrier of genetic information must have co-evolved with a means to manipulate its complex topology. This duty is performed by DNA topoisomerases, which therefore are, unsurprisingly, ubiquitous in all kingdoms of life. In this review, we focus on how DNA topoisomerases catalyze their impressive range of DNA-conjuring tricks, with a particular emphasis on DNA topoisomerase III (TOP3). Once thought to be the most unremarkable of topoisomerases, the many lives of these type IA topoisomerases are now being progressively revealed. This research interest is driven by a realization that their substrate versatility and their ability to engage in intimate collaborations with translocases and other DNA-processing enzymes are far more extensive and impressive than was thought hitherto. This, coupled with the recent associations of TOP3s with developmental and neurological pathologies in humans, is clearly making us reconsider their undeserved reputation as being unexceptional enzymes.

Identification of Suppressors of top-2 Embryonic Lethality in Caenorhabditis elegans

Topoisomerase II is an enzyme with important roles in chromosome biology. This enzyme relieves supercoiling and DNA and RNA entanglements generated during mitosis. Recent studies have demonstrated that Topoisomerase II is also involved in the segregation of homologous chromosomes during the first meiotic division. However, the function and regulation of Topoisomerase II in meiosis has not been fully elucidated. Here, we conducted a genetic suppressor screen in Caenorhabditis elegans to identify putative genes that interact with topoisomerase II during meiosis. Using a temperature-sensitive allele of topoisomerase II, top-2(it7ts), we identified eleven suppressors of top-2-induced embryonic lethality. We used whole-genome sequencing and a combination of RNAi and CRISPR/Cas9 genome editing to identify and validate the responsible suppressor mutations. We found both recessive and dominant suppressing mutations that include one intragenic and 10 extragenic loci. The extragenic suppressors consist of a known Topoisomerase II-interacting protein and two novel interactors. We anticipate that further analysis of these suppressing mutations will provide new insights into the function of Topoisomerase II during meiosis.

The topoisomerase 3α zinc-finger domain T1 of Arabidopsis thaliana is required for targeting the enzyme activity to Holliday junction-like DNA repair intermediates

Topoisomerase 3α, a class I topoisomerase, consists of a TOPRIM domain, an active centre and a variable number of zinc-finger domains (ZFDs) at the C-terminus, in multicellular organisms. Whereas the functions of the TOPRIM domain and the active centre are known, the specific role of the ZFDs is still obscure. In contrast to mammals where a knockout of TOP3α leads to lethality, we found that CRISPR/Cas induced mutants in Arabidopsis are viable but show growth retardation and meiotic defects, which can be reversed by the expression of the complete protein. However, complementation with AtTOP3α missing either the TOPRIM-domain or carrying a mutation of the catalytic tyrosine of the active centre leads to embryo lethality. Surprisingly, this phenotype can be overcome by the simultaneous removal of the ZFDs from the protein. In combination with a mutation of the nuclease AtMUS81, the TOP3α knockout proved to be also embryo lethal. Here, expression of TOP3α without ZFDs, and in particular without the conserved ZFD T1, leads to only a partly complementation in root growth-in contrast to the complete protein, that restores root length to mus81-1 mutant level. Expressing the E. coli resolvase RusA in this background, which is able to process Holliday junction (HJ)-like recombination intermediates, we could rescue this root growth defect. Considering all these results, we conclude that the ZFD T1 is specifically required for targeting the topoisomerase activity to HJ like recombination intermediates to enable their processing. In the case of an inactivated enzyme, this leads to cell death due to the masking of these intermediates, hindering their resolution by MUS81.

Top3-Rmi1 DNA single-strand decatenase is integral to the formation and resolution of meiotic recombination intermediates

The topoisomerase III (Top3)-Rmi1 heterodimer, which catalyzes DNA single-strand passage, forms a conserved complex with the Bloom's helicase (BLM, Sgs1 in budding yeast). This complex has been proposed to regulate recombination by disassembling double Holliday junctions in a process called dissolution. Top3-Rmi1 has been suggested to act at the end of this process, resolving hemicatenanes produced by earlier BLM/Sgs1 activity. We show here that, to the contrary, Top3-Rmi1 acts in all meiotic recombination functions previously associated with Sgs1, most notably as an early recombination intermediate chaperone, promoting regulated crossover and noncrossover recombination and preventing aberrant recombination intermediate accumulation. In addition, we show that Top3-Rmi1 has important Sgs1-independent functions that ensure complete recombination intermediate resolution and chromosome segregation. These findings indicate that Top3-Rmi1 activity is important throughout recombination to resolve strand crossings that would otherwise impede progression through both early steps of pathway choice and late steps of intermediate resolution.

Multiple mechanisms limit meiotic crossovers: TOP3α and two BLM homologs antagonize crossovers in parallel to FANCM

Meiotic crossovers (COs) have two important roles, shuffling genetic information and ensuring proper chromosome segregation. Despite their importance and a large excess of precursors (i.e., DNA double-strand breaks, DSBs), the number of COs is tightly regulated, typically one to three per chromosome pair. The mechanisms ensuring that most DSBs are repaired as non-COs and the evolutionary forces imposing this constraint are poorly understood. Here we identified Topoisomerase3α (TOP3α) and the RECQ4 helicases--the Arabidopsis slow growth suppressor 1 (Sgs1)/Bloom syndrome protein (BLM) homologs--as major barriers to meiotic CO formation. First, the characterization of a specific TOP3α mutant allele revealed that, in addition to its role in DNA repair, this topoisomerase antagonizes CO formation. Further, we found that RECQ4A and RECQ4B constitute the strongest meiotic anti-CO activity identified to date, their concomitant depletion leading to a sixfold increase in CO frequency. In both top3α and recq4ab mutants, DSB number is unaffected, and extra COs arise from a normally minor pathway. Finally, both TOP3α and RECQ4A/B act independently of the previously identified anti-CO Fanconi anemia of complementation group M (FANCM) helicase. This finding shows that several parallel pathways actively limit CO formation and suggests that the RECQA/B and FANCM helicases prevent COs by processing different substrates. Despite a ninefold increase in CO frequency, chromosome segregation was unaffected. This finding supports the idea that CO number is restricted not because of mechanical constraints but likely because of the long-term costs of recombination. Furthermore, this work demonstrates how manipulating a few genes holds great promise for increasing recombination frequency in plant-breeding programs.

Topoisomerase 3alpha and RMI1 suppress somatic crossovers and are essential for resolution of meiotic recombination intermediates in Arabidopsis thaliana

Topoisomerases are enzymes with crucial functions in DNA metabolism. They are ubiquitously present in prokaryotes and eukaryotes and modify the steady-state level of DNA supercoiling. Biochemical analyses indicate that Topoisomerase 3α (TOP3α) functions together with a RecQ DNA helicase and a third partner, RMI1/BLAP75, in the resolution step of homologous recombination in a process called Holliday Junction dissolution in eukaryotes. Apart from that, little is known about the role of TOP3α in higher eukaryotes, as knockout mutants show early lethality or strong developmental defects. Using a hypomorphic insertion mutant of Arabidopsis thaliana (top3α-2), which is viable but completely sterile, we were able to define three different functions of the protein in mitosis and meiosis. The top3α-2 line exhibits fragmented chromosomes during mitosis and sensitivity to camptothecin, suggesting an important role in chromosome segregation partly overlapping with that of type IB topoisomerases. Furthermore, AtTOP3α, together with AtRECQ4A and AtRMI1, is involved in the suppression of crossover recombination in somatic cells as well as DNA repair in both mammals and A. thaliana. Surprisingly, AtTOP3α is also essential for meiosis. The phenotype of chromosome fragmentation, bridges, and telophase I arrest can be suppressed by AtSPO11 and AtRAD51 mutations, indicating that the protein is required for the resolution of recombination intermediates. As Atrmi1 mutants have a similar meiotic phenotype to Attop3α mutants, both proteins seem to be involved in a mechanism safeguarding the entangling of homologous chromosomes during meiosis. The requirement of AtTOP3α and AtRMI1 in a late step of meiotic recombination strongly hints at the possibility that the dissolution of double Holliday Junctions via a hemicatenane intermediate is indeed an indispensable step of meiotic recombination.

The topoisomerases of the class IA are present in all three eukaryotic kingdoms—plants, fungi, and animals—and are involved in DNA replication and DNA repair. During the course of their action, they introduce transient single-strand nicks into DNA. In higher eukaryotes, two different classes of the enzymes are present: TOP3α and TOP3β. TOP3α is essential, as disruption of its function usually results in lethality of the affected organism. Using a mutant of TOP3α that retains some activity, we show that the protein has multiple, different functions in the model plant A. thaliana. Besides its action in somatic cells, where it is required for mitosis as well as DNA repair, we demonstrate that TOP3α together with its protein partner RMI1 is essential for meiosis. Here, both proteins are involved in DNA recombination—the exchange of information between parental chromosomes. Disruption of either TOP3α or RMI1 leads to grave defects and an early termination of meiosis, resulting in the sterility of the mutant plants. Our detailed analysis indicates that both proteins are involved in a late step of meiotic recombination, in a mechanism that prevents entanglement of the parental chromosomes. Thus, meiotic recombination seems to be more complex than previously anticipated.

Topoisomerase IIIalpha and Bloom's helicase can resolve a mobile double Holliday junction substrate through convergent branch migration

It has long been suspected that a double Holliday junction (dHJ) could be resolved by a topoisomerase partnered with a helicase by convergent branch migration of the HJs. Genetic analysis of yeast TOP3 and SGS1 has lent considerable evidence to the notion that the protein products of these genes are involved in just such a process, although biochemical analysis of the metabolism of a dHJ has been hindered by the lack of a substrate that adequately replicates the endogenous structure. We have synthesized a dHJ substrate that recapitulates many of the features of an endogenous dHJ and represents a much earlier intermediate in the resolution pathway. Here, we show that Drosophila topoisomerase IIIalpha (Topo IIIalpha) and Blm (a homolog of Sgs1) are capable of resolving this substrate to non-cross-over products and that this activity is stimulated by replication protein A (RPA). We investigated the ability of other Drosophila topoisomerases to perform this reaction in concert with Blm and RPA and discovered that this resolution activity is unique to Topo IIIalpha. Examination of the mechanism of resolution reveals that Topo IIIalpha, Blm, and RPA resolve this substrate by convergent migration of the two HJs toward each other, collapsing the dHJ. This mechanism stands in contrast to classic resolvase activities that use a structure-specific endonuclease to cleave the HJs.

Yeast Rmi1/Nce4 controls genome stability as a subunit of the Sgs1-Top3 complex

Genome stability requires a set of RecQ-Top3 DNA helicase-topoisomerase complexes whose sole budding yeast homolog is encoded by SGS1-TOP3. RMI1/NCE4 was identified as a potential intermediate in the SGS1-TOP3 pathway, based on the observation that strains lacking any one of these genes require MUS81 and MMS4 for viability. This idea was tested by confirming that sgs1 and rmi1 mutants display the same spectrum of synthetic lethal interactions, including the requirements for SLX1, SLX4, SLX5, and SLX8, and by demonstrating that rmi1 mus81 synthetic lethality is dependent on homologous recombination. On their own, mutations in RMI1 result in phenotypes that mimic those of sgs1 or top3 strains including slow growth, hyperrecombination, DNA damage sensitivity, and reduced sporulation. And like top3 strains, most rmi1 phenotypes are suppressed by mutations in SGS1. We show that Rmi1 forms a heteromeric complex with Sgs1-Top3 in yeast and that these proteins interact directly in a recombinant system. The Rmi1-Top3 complex is stable in the absence of the Sgs1 helicase, but the loss of either Rmi1 or Top3 in yeast compromises its partner's interaction with Sgs1. Biochemical studies demonstrate that recombinant Rmi1 is a structure-specific DNA binding protein with a preference for cruciform structures. We propose that the DNA binding specificity of Rmi1 plays a role in targeting Sgs1-Top3 to appropriate substrates.

Caenorhabditis elegans UBC-2 functions with the anaphase-promoting complex but also has other activities

The anaphase-promoting complex or cyclosome (APC/C) is a multi-subunit ubiquitin ligase that regulates the eukaryotic cell cycle. APC/C belongs to the RING finger class of ubiquitin ligases that function by interacting with a ubiquitin-conjugating enzyme (Ubc), thus inciting the Ubc to transfer ubiquitin onto a target protein. Extensive studies with APC/C in other organisms have identified several possible Ubcs that might function as partners for APC/C. This report presents phenotypic and biochemical evidence showing that, in Caenorhabditis elegans, UBC-2 interacts specifically with the APC/C. This conclusion is based on three lines of evidence: first, the RNAi phenotype of ubc-2 is indistinguishable from RNAi phenotypes of APC/C subunits; second, RNAi of ubc-2 but not other Ubcs enhances the phenotype of hypomorphic APC/C mutants; third, purified UBC-2 and APC-11, the RING finger subunit of the APC/C, show robust ubiquitination activity in in vitro assays. APC-11 interaction is specific for UBC-2 as ubiquitination is not seen when APC-11 is combined other C. elegans Ubcs. As expected from the Ubc that functions with the APC/C, ubc-2(RNAi) produces metaphase blocks in both mitotic germ cells and in meiotic divisions of post-fertilization oocytes. In addition, ubc-2(RNAi) results in two germline phenotypes that appear to be unrelated to the APC/C: an expanded transition zone indicative of a pre-pachytene meiotic arrest and endo-reduplicated oocytes indicative of a problem in ovulation or oocyte-soma interactions.

Multiple genetic pathways involving the Caenorhabditis elegans Bloom's syndrome genes him-6, rad-51, and top-3 are needed to maintain genome stability in the germ line

Bloom's syndrome (BS) is an autosomal-recessive human disorder caused by mutations in the BS RecQ helicase and is associated with loss of genomic integrity and an increased incidence of cancer. We analyzed the mitotic and the meiotic roles of Caenorhabditis elegans him-6, which we show to encode the ortholog of the human BS gene. Mutations in him-6 result in an enhanced irradiation sensitivity, a partially defective S-phase checkpoint, and in reduced levels of DNA-damage induced apoptosis. Furthermore, him-6 mutants exhibit a decreased frequency of meiotic recombination that is probably due to a defect in the progression of crossover recombination. In mitotically proliferating germ cells, our genetic interaction studies, as well as the assessment of the number of double-strand breaks via RAD-51 foci, reveal a complex regulatory network that is different from the situation in yeast. Although the number of double-strand breaks in him-6 and top-3 single mutants is elevated, the combined depletion of him-6 and top-3 leads to mitotic catastrophe concomitant with a massive increase in the level of double-strand breaks, a phenotype that is completely suppressed by rad-51. him-6 and top-3 are thus needed to maintain low levels of double-strand breaks in normally proliferating germ cells, and both act in partial redundant pathways downstream of rad-51 to prevent mitotic catastrophy. Finally, we show that topoisomerase IIIalpha acts independently during a late stage of meiotic recombination.

Generation of double-stranded breaks in hypernegatively supercoiled DNA by Drosophila topoisomerase IIIbeta, a type IA enzyme

Drosophila topoisomerase (topo) IIIbeta is a member of the type IA family of DNA topoisomerases, which generates a single-stranded break to form a covalent complex with the 5'-end of DNA. We show here that a purified preparation of topo IIIbeta is able to convert a hypernegatively supercoiled substrate into primarily nicked, but also linear, DNA at enzyme/DNA molar ratios of 5:1 or greater. Although the optimal temperature for the relaxation activity is between 37 and 45 degrees C, maximal cleavage occurs between 23 and 30 degrees C, a temperature range that is more physiologically relevant for fruit flies. The cleavage products require protease treatment to enter the gel, they are stable over time, they are reversible, and they are not observed with a Y332F active site mutant, which further supports the idea that topo IIIbeta possesses an endonucleolytic cleavage activity. This cleavage activity appears to be specific for highly unwound, or single strand-containing substrates. Southern blot analysis of the cleavage products demonstrates that the topo IIIbeta cleavage activity is concentrated primarily in highly A/T-rich regions. These results suggest that topo IIIbeta may function as a reversible endonuclease in vivo by recognizing and cleaving/rejoining DNA structures with single-stranded character.

The gene expression and deficiency phenotypes of Cockayne syndrome B protein in Caenorhabditis elegans

The Caenorhabditis elegans Cockayne syndrome B protein homologue is encoded by 10 exons of the predicted open reading frame F53H4.1. The gene is expressed in germ cells and all somatic cells of the embryonic to adult stage. Although the gene expression was ubiquitous, its expression level was relatively higher in dividing cells and cells that play fundamental roles in essential physiological functions such as feeding, sensation, and reproduction. RNA interference of the gene hypersensitized C. elegans to UV radiation, as observed in enhanced germ cell proliferation arrest and apoptosis, and increased embryonic lethality, suggesting its role in nucleotide excision repair.

Coaction of DNA topoisomerase IIIalpha and a RecQ homologue during the germ-line mitosis in Caenorhabditis elegans

BACKGROUND

Among the four RecQ homologues predicted from the Caenorhabditis elegans genomic DNA sequence, T04A11.6 is most similar to Bloom syndrome's protein in humans. To investigate a possible interaction of the protein with topoisomerase IIIalpha (TOP3alpha), as observed between TOP3 and RecQ homologues in yeast and human, the top3alpha gene expression was suppressed by RNA interference (RNAi) in the him-6(e1104) C. elegans strain which is mutated in T04A11.6 (F. Mueller & C. Wicky, personal communication).

RESULTS

Germ cells in the gonads of the progeny him-6(e1104);top3alpha(RNAi) showed severe chromosomal abnormalities and were arrested during mitosis with a subsequent failure in meiotic entry. Most of the aberrant chromosomes were stained by the TUNEL assay but not by the SYTO12 dye, suggesting extensive DNA breaks not associated with apoptosis. The phenotypes in the germ cells of him-6(e1104);top3alpha(RNAi) were also observed in the progeny produced by double RNA interference of the top3alpha and him-6 gene expression, though at a reduced level. The over-expressed TOP3alpha and Him-6 proteins showed specific physical interaction in vitro, in agreement with the genetic interaction in C. elegans.

CONCLUSION

In C. elegans, TOP3alpha and the RecQ homologue (T04A11.6) contribute to genome stability during germ-line mitosis, probably by acting in a complex.

Mapping the DNA topoisomerase III binding domain of the Sgs1 DNA helicase

Several members of the RecQ family of DNA helicases are known to interact with DNA topoisomerase III (Top3). Here we show that the Saccharomyces cerevisiae Sgs1 and Top3 proteins physically interact in cell extracts and bind directly in vitro. Sgs1 and Top3 proteins coimmunoprecipitate from cell extracts under stringent conditions, indicating that Sgs1 and Top3 are present in a stable complex. The domain of Sgs1 which interacts with Top3 was identified by expressing Sgs1 truncations in yeast. The results indicate that the NH(2)-terminal 158 amino acids of Sgs1 are sufficient for the high affinity interaction between Sgs1 and Top3. In vitro assays using purified Top3 and NH(2)-terminal Sgs1 fragments demonstrate that at least part of the interaction is through direct protein-protein interactions with these 158 amino acids. Consistent with these physical data, we find that mutant phenotypes caused by a point mutation or small deletions in the Sgs1 NH(2) terminus can be suppressed by Top3 overexpression. We conclude that Sgs1 and Top3 form a tight complex in vivo and that the first 158 amino acids of Sgs1 are necessary and sufficient for this interaction. Thus, a primary role of the Sgs1 amino terminus is to mediate the Top3 interaction.