De novo cytosine methylation in the differentiating macronucleus of the stichotrichous ciliate Stylonychia lemnae

Programmed genome rearrangements in ciliates

Ciliates are a highly divergent group of unicellular eukaryotes with separate somatic and germline genomes found in distinct dimorphic nuclei. This characteristic feature is tightly linked to extremely laborious developmentally regulated genome rearrangements in the development of a new somatic genome/nuclei following sex. The transformation from germline to soma genome involves massive DNA elimination mediated by non-coding RNAs, chromosome fragmentation, as well as DNA amplification. In this review, we discuss the similarities and differences in the genome reorganization processes of the model ciliates Paramecium and Tetrahymena (class Oligohymenophorea), and the distantly related Euplotes, Stylonychia, and Oxytricha (class Spirotrichea).

Determination of the presence of 5-methylcytosine in Paramecium tetraurelia

5-methylcytosine DNA methylation regulates gene expression and developmental programming in a broad range of eukaryotes. However, its presence and potential roles in ciliates, complex single-celled eukaryotes with germline-somatic genome specialization via nuclear dimorphism, are largely uncharted. While canonical cytosine methyltransferases have not been discovered in published ciliate genomes, recent studies performed in the stichotrichous ciliate Oxytricha trifallax suggest de novo cytosine methylation during macronuclear development. In this study, we applied bisulfite genome sequencing, DNA mass spectrometry and antibody-based fluorescence detection to investigate the presence of DNA methylation in Paramecium tetraurelia. While the antibody-based methods suggest cytosine methylation, DNA mass spectrometry and bisulfite sequencing reveal that levels are actually below the limit of detection. Our results suggest that Paramecium does not utilize 5-methylcytosine DNA methylation as an integral part of its epigenetic arsenal.

Programmed Genome Rearrangements in the Ciliate Oxytricha

The ciliate Oxytricha is a microbial eukaryote with two genomes, one of which experiences extensive genome remodeling during development. Each round of conjugation initiates a cascade of events that construct a transcriptionally active somatic genome from a scrambled germline genome, with considerable help from both long and small noncoding RNAs. This process of genome remodeling entails massive DNA deletion and reshuffling of remaining DNA segments to form functional genes from their interrupted and scrambled germline precursors. The use of Oxytricha as a model system provides an opportunity to study an exaggerated form of programmed genome rearrangement. Furthermore, studying the mechanisms that maintain nuclear dimorphism and mediate genome rearrangement has demonstrated a surprising plasticity and diversity of noncoding RNA pathways, with new roles that go beyond conventional gene silencing. Another aspect of ciliate genetics is their unorthodox patterns of RNA-mediated, epigenetic inheritance that rival Mendelian inheritance. This review takes the reader through the key experiments in a model eukaryote that led to fundamental discoveries in RNA biology and pushes the biological limits of DNA processing.

Beyond transcriptional silencing: is methylcytosine a widely conserved eukaryotic DNA elimination mechanism?

Methylation of cytosine DNA residues is a well-studied epigenetic modification with important roles in formation of heterochromatic regions of the genome, and also in tissue-specific repression of transcription. However, we recently found that the ciliate Oxytricha uses methylcytosine in a novel DNA elimination pathway important for programmed genome restructuring. Remarkably, mounting evidence suggests that methylcytosine can play a dual role in ciliates, repressing gene expression during some life-stages and directing DNA elimination in others. In this essay, I describe these recent advances in the DNA methylation field and discuss whether this unexpected novel role for methylcytosine in DNA elimination might be more widely conserved in eukaryotic biology, particularly in apoptotic pathways.

RNA-dependent genome processing during nuclear differentiation: the model systems of stichotrichous ciliates

We introduce ciliated protozoa, and more specifically the stichotrichous ciliates Oxytricha and Stylonychia, as biological model systems for the analysis of programmed DNA-reorganization processes during nuclear differentiation. These include DNA excision, DNA elimination, reordering of gene segments and specific gene amplification. We show that small nuclear RNAs specify DNA sequences to be excised or retained, but also discuss the need for a RNA template molecule derived from the parental nucleus for these processes. This RNA template guides reordering of gene segments to become functional genes and determines gene copy number in the differentiated nucleus. Since the template is derived from the parental macronucleus, gene reordering and DNA amplification are inherited in a non-Mendelian epigenetic manner.

Genomes on the edge: programmed genome instability in ciliates

Ciliates are an ancient and diverse group of microbial eukaryotes that have emerged as powerful models for RNA-mediated epigenetic inheritance. They possess extensive sets of both tiny and long noncoding RNAs that, together with a suite of proteins that includes transposases, orchestrate a broad cascade of genome rearrangements during somatic nuclear development. This Review emphasizes three important themes: the remarkable role of RNA in shaping genome structure, recent discoveries that unify many deeply diverged ciliate genetic systems, and a surprising evolutionary "sign change" in the role of small RNAs between major species groups.

A permissive chromatin structure is adopted prior to site-specific DNA demethylation of developmentally expressed genes involved in macronuclear differentiation

Background

DNA methylation and demethylation are important epigenetic regulatory mechanisms in eukaryotic cells and, so far, only partially understood. We exploit the minimalistic biological ciliate system to understand the crosstalk between DNA modification and chromatin structure. In the macronucleus of these cells, the DNA is fragmented into individual short DNA molecules, each representing a functional expression and replication unit. Therefore, long range epigenomic interaction can be excluded in this system.

Results

In the stichotrichous ciliate Stylonychia lemnae, cytosine methylation occurs in a small subset of macronuclear nanochromosomes expressed only during sexual reproduction. Methylation pattern shows similarity to that observed in fungi and Drosophila. Cytosine methylation correlates with gene activity and chromatin structure. Upon gene activation, cytosines become demethylated and a redistribution of histone post-translational modifications (PTMs) takes place. Evidence is presented that the formation of a permissive chromatin structure in the vicinity of the 5meCs precedes cytosine methylation and is probably a necessary prerequisite for their demethylation. Shortly after demethylation of cytosines occurs, the parental macronucleus degenerates, a new macronucleus is formed from a micronuclear derivative and the specific methylation pattern is transmitted from the germline micronucleus to the new macronucleus.

Conclusions

We show that very few, or even only one, discrete methylated cytosines are required to assign regulatory functions at a specific locus. Furthermore, evidence is provided that a permissive chromatin structure is probably a necessary prerequisite for the demethylation of specific cytosines. Our results allow us to propose a mechanistic model for the biological function of cytosine methylation in the ciliate cell and its regulation during the cell cycle.

Cytosine methylation and hydroxymethylation mark DNA for elimination in Oxytricha trifallax

BACKGROUND

Cytosine methylation of DNA is conserved across eukaryotes and plays important functional roles regulating gene expression during differentiation and development in animals, plants and fungi. Hydroxymethylation was recently identified as another epigenetic modification marking genes important for pluripotency in embryonic stem cells.

RESULTS

Here we describe de novo cytosine methylation and hydroxymethylation in the ciliate Oxytricha trifallax. These DNA modifications occur only during nuclear development and programmed genome rearrangement. We detect methylcytosine and hydroxymethylcytosine directly by high-resolution nano-flow UPLC mass spectrometry, and indirectly by immunofluorescence, methyl-DNA immunoprecipitation and bisulfite sequencing. We describe these modifications in three classes of eliminated DNA: germline-limited transposons and satellite repeats, aberrant DNA rearrangements, and DNA from the parental genome undergoing degradation. Methylation and hydroxymethylation generally occur on the same sequence elements, modifying cytosines in all sequence contexts. We show that the DNA methyltransferase-inhibiting drugs azacitidine and decitabine induce demethylation of both somatic and germline sequence elements during genome rearrangements, with consequent elevated levels of germline-limited repetitive elements in exconjugant cells.

CONCLUSIONS

These data strongly support a functional link between cytosine DNA methylation/hydroxymethylation and DNA elimination. We identify a motif strongly enriched in methylated/hydroxymethylated regions, and we propose that this motif recruits DNA modification machinery to specific chromosomes in the parental macronucleus. No recognizable methyltransferase enzyme has yet been described in O. trifallax, raising the possibility that it might employ a novel cytosine methylation machinery to mark DNA sequences for elimination during genome rearrangements.

What do unicellular organisms teach us about DNA methylation?

DNA methylation is an epigenetic hallmark that has been studied intensively in mammals and plants. However, knowledge of this phenomenon in unicellular organisms is scanty. Examining epigenetic regulation, and more specifically DNA methylation, in these organisms represents a unique opportunity to better understand their biology. The determination of their methylation status is often complicated by the presence of several differentiation stages in their life cycle. This article focuses on some recent advances that have revealed the unexpected nature of the epigenetic determinants present in protozoa. The role of the enigmatic DNA methyltransferase Dnmt2 in unicellular organisms is discussed.

Growth of the protozoan parasite Entamoeba histolytica in 5-azacytidine has limited effects on parasite gene expression

Background

In higher eukaryotes DNA methylation regulates important biological functions including silencing of gene expression and protection from adverse effects of retrotransposons. In the protozoan parasite Entamoeba histolytica, a DNA methyltransferase has been identified and treatment with 5-azacytidine (5-AzaC), a potent inhibitor of DNA methyltransferase, has been reported to attenuate parasite virulence. However, the overall extent of DNA methylation and its subsequent effects on global gene expression in this parasite are currently unknown.

Results

In order to identify the genome-wide effects of DNA methylation in E. histolytica, we used a short oligonucleotide microarray representing 9,435 genes (~95% of all annotated amebic genes) and compared the expression profile of E. histolytica HM-1:IMSS parasites with those treated with 23 μM 5-AzaC for up to one week. Overall, 2.1% of genes tested were transcriptionally modulated under these conditions. 68 genes were upregulated and 131 genes down regulated (2-fold change; p-value < 0.05). Sodium-bisulfite treatment and sequencing of genes indicated that there were at least two subsets of genes with genomic DNA methylation in E. histolytica: (i) genes that were endogenously silenced by genomic DNA methylation and for which 5-AzaC treatment induced transcriptional de-repression, and (ii) genes that have genomic DNA methylation, but which were not endogenously silenced by the methylation. We identified among the genes down regulated by 5-AzaC treatment a cysteine proteinase (2.m00545) and lysozyme (52.m00148) both of which have known roles in amebic pathogenesis. Decreased expression of these genes in the 5-AzaC treated E. histolytica may account in part for the parasites reduced cytolytic abilities.

Conclusion

This work represents the first genome-wide analysis of DNA-methylation in Entamoeba histolytica and indicates that DNA methylation has relatively limited effects on gene expression in this parasite.

New Insights into the Macronuclear Development in Ciliates

During macronuclear differentiation in ciliated protozoa, most amazing "DNA gymnastics" takes place, which includes DNA excision, DNA elimination, DNA reorganization, and DNA-specific amplification. Although the morphological events occurring during macronuclear development are well described, a detailed knowledge of the molecular mechanisms and the regulation of this differentiation process is still missing. However, recently several models have been proposed for the molecular regulation of macronuclear differentiation, but these models have yet to be verified experimentally. The scope of this review is to summarize recent discoveries in different ciliate species and to compare and discuss the different models proposed. Results obtained in these studies are not only relevant for our understanding of nuclear differentiation in ciliates, but also for cellular differentiation in eukaryotic organisms in general as well as for other disciplines such as bioinformatics and computational biology.

Pleiotropic phenotype in Entamoeba histolytica overexpressing DNA methyltransferase (Ehmeth)

The protozoan parasite Entamoeba histolytica expresses a cytosine-5 DNA methyltransferase (Ehmeth) that belongs to the Dnmt2 proteins family. The biological function of members of the Dnmt2 family is unknown. Constitutive overexpression of Ehmeth resulted in a pleiotropic phenotype that includes accumulation of multinucleated cells, upregulation of Heat shock protein 70 (HSP70) expression and resistance to oxidative stress. This pleiotropic phenotype suggests that Ehmeth plays an important role in the control of key cellular processes in the parasite.

Epigenetic and classical activation of Entamoeba histolytica heat shock protein 100 (EHsp100) expression

The protozoan parasite Entamoeba histolytica expresses a cytosine-5 DNA methyltransferase (Ehmeth) that belongs to the DNMT2 protein family. The biological function of members of this DNMT2 family is unknown. In the present study, the 5' region of E. histolytica heat shock protein 100 (5'EHsp100) was isolated by affinity chromatography with 5-methylcytosine antibodies as ligand. The methylation status of 5'EHsp100 was confirmed by sodium bisulfite sequencing. We showed that the expression of EHsp100 was induced by heat shock, 5-azacytidine (5-AzaC), an inhibitor of DNA methyltransferase and Trichostatin A (TSA), an inhibitor of histone deacetylase. The effect of TSA on EHsp100 expression was rapidly reversed by removing the drug from the culture. In contrast, EHsp100 expression was still detectable one month after removing 5-AzaC from the media. Whereas 5-AzaC and TSA caused demethylation in the promoter region of EHsp100, no demethylation was observed following heat shock. Remarkably, DNA that includes three putative heat shock elements identified in the promoter region of EHsp100 bound to a protein of 37kDa present in the nuclear fraction of heat-shocked trophozoites but absent in the nuclear fraction of 5-AzaC and TSA treated trophozoites. Our data suggest that EHsp100 expression can be regulated by both a classical and an epigenetic mechanism.

Entamoeba histolytica DNA methyltransferase (Ehmeth) is a nuclear matrix protein that binds EhMRS2, a DNA that includes a scaffold/matrix attachment region (S/MAR)

The protozoan parasite Entamoeba histolytica express a cytosine-5 DNA methyltransferase (Ehmeth) that belongs to the DNMT2 protein family. The biological function of members of this DNMT2 family is unknown. In the present study, we have demonstrated that Ehmeth is a nuclear matrix protein. Indeed, we showed by south-western analysis and yeast one-hybrid system that Ehmeth binds to EhMRS2, a DNA element which contains the eukaryotic consensus scaffold/matrix attachment regions (S/MAR) bipartite recognition sequences. S/MARs have been implicated in a variety of important functions, such as genome organization and gene expression. The methylation status of cytosine located within EhMRS2 was analyzed by bisulfite genomic sequencing. We observed the presence of methylated cytosine within the 3'-end of EhMRS2. These data provide the first evidence that a member of the DNMT2 family interacts with a S/MAR containing DNA element.

DNA-[Adenine] Methylation in Lower Eukaryotes

DNA methylation in lower eukaryotes, in contrast to vertebrates, can involve modification of adenine to N6-methyladenine (m6A). While DNA-[cytosine] methylation in higher eukaryotes has been implicated in many important cellular processes, the function(s) of DNA-[adenine] methylation in lower eukaryotes remains unknown. I have chosen to study the ciliate Tetrahymena thermophila as a model system, since this organism is known to contain m6A, but not m5C, in its macronuclear DNA. A BLAST analysis revealed an open reading frame (ORF) that appears to encode for the Tetrahymena DNA-[adenine] methyltransferase (MTase), based on the presence of motifs characteristic of the enzymes in prokaryotes. Possible biological roles for DNA-[adenine] methylation in Tetrahymena are discussed. Experiments to test these hypotheses have begun with the cloning of the gene. Orthologous ORFs are also present in three species of the malarial parasite Plasmodium. They are compared to one another and to the putative Tetrahymena DNA-[adenine] MTase. The gene from the human parasite P. falciparum has been cloned.