Membranous nephropathy in a patient with hereditary complete complement C4 deficiency

The role of complement in kidney disease

The complement cascade comprises soluble and cell surface proteins and is an important arm of the innate immune system. Once activated, the complement system rapidly generates large quantities of protein fragments that are potent mediators of inflammatory, vasoactive and metabolic responses. Although complement is crucial to host defence and homeostasis, its inappropriate or uncontrolled activation can also drive tissue injury. For example, the complement system has been known for more than 50 years to be activated by glomerular immune complexes and to contribute to autoimmune kidney disease. Notably, the latest research shows that complement is also activated in kidney diseases that are not traditionally thought of as immune-mediated, including haemolytic-uraemic syndrome, diabetic kidney disease and focal segmental glomerulosclerosis. Several complement-targeted drugs have been approved for the treatment of kidney disease, and additional anti-complement agents are being investigated in clinical trials. These drugs are categorically different from other immunosuppressive agents and target pathological processes that are not effectively inhibited by other classes of immunosuppressants. The development of these new drugs might therefore have considerable benefits in the treatment of kidney disease.

Deposition of the Membrane Attack Complex in Healthy and Diseased Human Kidneys

The membrane attack complex-also known as C5b-9-is the end-product of the classical, lectin, and alternative complement pathways. It is thought to play an important role in the pathogenesis of various kidney diseases by causing cellular injury and tissue inflammation, resulting in sclerosis and fibrosis. These deleterious effects are, consequently, targeted in the development of novel therapies that inhibit the formation of C5b-9, such as eculizumab. To clarify how C5b-9 contributes to kidney disease and to predict which patients benefit from such therapy, knowledge on deposition of C5b-9 in the kidney is essential. Because immunohistochemical staining of C5b-9 has not been routinely conducted and never been compared across studies, we provide a review of studies on deposition of C5b-9 in healthy and diseased human kidneys. We describe techniques to stain deposits and compare the occurrence of deposits in healthy kidneys and in a wide spectrum of kidney diseases, including hypertensive nephropathy, diabetic nephropathy, membranous nephropathy, IgA nephropathy, lupus nephritis, C3 glomerulopathy, and thrombotic microangiopathies such as the atypical hemolytic uremic syndrome, vasculitis, interstitial nephritis, acute tubular necrosis, kidney tumors, and rejection of kidney transplants. We summarize how these deposits are related with other histological lesions and clinical characteristics. We evaluate the prognostic relevance of these deposits in the light of possible treatment with complement inhibitors.

Alternative Pathway Dysregulation and the Conundrum of Complement Activation by IgG4 Immune Complexes in Membranous Nephropathy

Membranous nephropathy (MN), a major cause of nephrotic syndrome, is a non-inflammatory immune kidney disease mediated by IgG antibodies that form glomerular subepithelial immune complexes. In primary MN, autoantibodies target proteins expressed on the podocyte surface, often phospholipase A2 receptor (PLA2R1). Pathology is driven by complement activation, leading to podocyte injury and proteinuria. This article overviews the mechanisms of complement activation and regulation in MN, addressing the paradox that anti-PLA2R1 and other antibodies causing primary MN are predominantly (but not exclusively) IgG4, an IgG subclass that does not fix complement. Besides immune complexes, alterations of the glomerular basement membrane (GBM) in MN may lead to impaired regulation of the alternative pathway (AP). The AP amplifies complement activation on surfaces insufficiently protected by complement regulatory proteins. Whereas podocytes are protected by cell-bound regulators, the GBM must recruit plasma factor H, which inhibits the AP on host surfaces carrying certain polyanions, such as heparan sulfate (HS) chains. Because HS chains present in the normal GBM are lost in MN, we posit that the local complement regulation by factor H may be impaired as a result. Thus, the loss of GBM HS in MN creates a micro-environment that promotes local amplification of complement activation, which in turn may be initiated via the classical or lectin pathways by subsets of IgG in immune complexes. A detailed understanding of the mechanisms of complement activation and dysregulation in MN is important for designing more effective therapies.

The role of complement in membranous nephropathy

Membranous nephropathy (MN) describes a histopathologic pattern of injury marked by glomerular subepithelial immune deposits and collectively represents one of the most common causes of adult nephrotic syndrome. Studies in Heymann nephritis, an experimental model of MN, have established a paradigm in which these deposits locally activate complement to cause podocyte injury, culminating in cytoskeletal reorganization, loss of slit diaphragms, and proteinuria. There is much circumstantial evidence for a prominent role of complement in human MN because C3 and C5b-9 are found consistently within immune deposits. Secondary MN often shows the additional presence of C1q, implicating the classic pathway of complement activation. Primary MN, however, is IgG4-predominant and IgG4 is considered incapable of binding C1q and activating the complement pathway. Recent studies have identified the M-type phospholipase A2 receptor (PLA2R) as the major target antigen in primary MN. Early evidence hints that IgG4 anti-PLA2R autoantibodies can bind mannan-binding lectin and activate the lectin complement pathway. The identification of anti-PLA2R antibodies as likely participants in the pathogenesis of disease will allow focused investigation into the role of complement in MN. Definitive therapy for MN is immunosuppression, although future therapeutic agents that specifically target complement activation may represent an effective temporizing measure to forestall further glomerular injury.

Lack of increased prevalence of immunoregulatory disorders in hereditary angioedema due to C1-inhibitor deficiency

Hereditary angioedema due to deficiency of C1-INH (HAE-C1-INH) is associated with enhanced consumption of the early complement components, which may predispose for autoimmune disease. We assessed the prevalence of such disorders among HAE- C1-INH patients and their impact on the natural course of HAE-C1-INH. Clinical data and immunoserological parameters of 130 HAE-C1-INH and 174 non-C1-INH-deficient patients with angioedema were analyzed. In our study, the incidence of immunoregulatory disorders was 11.5% in the population of HAE-C1-INH patients and 5.2% among non-C1-INH-deficient controls with angioedema. Immunoserology screening revealed a greater prevalence of anticardiolipin IgM (p=0.0118) among HAE-C1-INH patients, than in those with non-C1-INH-deficient angioedema. We did not find higher prevalence of immunoregulatory disorders among our HAE-C1-INH patients. However, in patients with confirmed immunoregulatory disorders, the latter influenced both the severity of HAE-C1-INH and the effectiveness of its long-term management. Appropriate management of the immunoregulatory disease thus identified improves the symptoms of HAE-C1-INH.

Familial C4B deficiency and immune complex glomerulonephritis

Homozygous complement C4B deficiency is described in a Southern European young female patient with Membranoproliferative Glomerulonephritis (MPGN) type III characterized by renal biopsies with strong complement C4 and IgG deposits. Low C4 levels were independent of clinical evolution or type of immunosuppression and were found in three other family members without renal disease or infections. HLA typing revealed that the patient has homozygous A*02, Cw*06, B*50 at the class I region, and DRB1*08 and DQB1*03 at the class II region. Genotypic and phenotypic studies demonstrated that the patient has homozygous monomodular RCCX in the HLA class III region, with single long C4A genes coding for C4A3 and complete C4B deficiency. Her father, mother, son and niece have heterozygous C4B deficiency. The patient's deceased brother had a history of Henoch-Schönlein Purpura (HSP), an immune complex-mediated proliferative glomerulonephritis. These findings challenge the putative pathophysiological roles of C4A and C4B and underscore the need to perform functional assays, C4 allotyping and genotyping on patients with persistently low serum levels of a classical pathway complement component and glomerulopathy associated with immune deposits.

Kidney transplantation in patients suffering from hereditary complete complement C4 deficiency

Hereditary complete C4 deficiency (C4def) is a very rare condition that predisposes to immune complex disease and end-stage renal failure. Whether such patients should undergo renal transplantation is debated. The clinical outcome of five transplantations in three C4def patients is described. The first patient lost one allograft after 6 years because of chronic allograft rejection. Back on dialysis, he suffered from meningitis caused by Neisseria menigitidis and Aspergillus. One year after a second transplantation under alemtuzumab induction, he developed fulminant Kaposi's sarcoma and died. His sister is now 6 years post-transplantation without complications. The third patient lost his first graft after 3 years because of chronic allograft nephropathy and recurrence of glomerulonephritis. He has now been living with a second graft for over 9 years. He suffered from pneumonia, a generalized varicella infection and Hemophilis parainfluenzae bronchitis. Patients with complete C4def are at increased risk for infection after kidney transplantation. Under certain precautions and with judicious use of immunosuppression, good long-term results are achievable.

Experimental membranous nephropathy redux

Membranous nephropathy (MN) is a common cause of nephrotic syndrome in adults. Active and passive Heymann nephritis (HN) in rats are valuable experimental models because their features so closely resemble human MN. In HN, subepithelial immune deposits form in situ as a result of circulating antibodies. Complement activation leads to assembly of C5b-9 on glomerular epithelial cell (GEC) plasma membranes and is essential for sublethal GEC injury and the onset of proteinuria. This review revisits HN and focuses on areas of substantial progress in recent years. The response of the GEC to sublethal C5b-9 attack is not simply due to disruption of the plasma membrane but is due to the activation of specific signaling pathways. These include activation of protein kinases, phospholipases, cyclooxygenases, transcription factors, growth factors, NADPH oxidase, stress proteins, proteinases, and others. Ultimately, these signals impact on cell metabolic pathways and the structure/function of lipids and key proteins in the cytoskeleton and slit-diaphragm. Some signals affect GEC adversely. Thus C5b-9 induces partial dissolution of the actin cytoskeleton. There is a decline in nephrin expression, reduction in F-actin-bound nephrin, and loss of slit-diaphragm integrity. Other signals, such as endoplasmic reticulum stress, may limit complement-induced injury, or promote recovery. The extent of complement activation and GEC injury is dependent, in part, on complement-regulatory proteins, which act at early or late steps within the complement cascade. Identification of key steps in complement activation, the cellular signaling pathways, and the targets will facilitate therapeutic intervention in reversing GEC injury in human MN.

Contrasting roles of complement activation and its regulation in membranous nephropathy

The complement system is involved in defense against microorganisms, the processing of immune complexes and apoptotic debris, and the development of an appropriate immune response. Along with these physiologic effects, complement activation has the potential to result in tissue pathology. To limit this, various complement regulatory proteins (CRP) are present on host cells, including the glomerular podocyte. Experimental data from the Heymann nephritis (HN) rat model of human membranous nephropathy (MN) have shown that IgG antibodies in subepithelial immune deposits initiate complement activation and C5b-9-mediated damage of the overlying podocyte. Although IgG can activate the classical pathway, there also is evidence that alternative pathway activation occurs in MN, which could occur because of absent, dysfunctional, or inhibited podocyte CRP. Related to this are experimental data in HN showing the presence of antibodies that bind and inhibit podocyte CRP; although such antibodies have not been documented in human MN, a decrease in CR1 quantity on the podocyte has been observed. A s a result of a relative lack of CRP and the exposure of activating complement proteins to tubular cells, alternative complement pathway activation and C5b-9-mediated tubular injury can occur in MN and other proteinuric diseases. Overall, in a disease such as MN, the balance between complement regulation and activation is tipped toward its being activated. Therefore, a number of therapeutic approaches have been developed to counteract this, including recombinant forms of endogenous CRP and complement-inhibitory monoclonal antibodies. There is good reason to be optimistic that approaches to block complement activation will become viable therapy for human MN in the future.

Complete complement components C4A and C4B deficiencies in human kidney diseases and systemic lupus erythematosus

Although a heterozygous deficiency of either complement component C4A or C4B is common, and each has a frequency of approximately 20% in a Caucasian population, complete deficiencies of both C4A and C4B proteins are extremely rare. In this paper the clinical courses for seven complete C4 deficiency patients are described in detail, and the molecular defects for complete C4 deficiencies are elucidated. Three patients with homozygous HLA A24 Cw7 B38 DR13 had systemic lupus erythematosus, mesangial glomerulonephritis, and severe skin lesions or membranous nephropathy. Immunofixation, genomic restriction fragment length polymorphisms, and pulsed field gel electrophoresis experiments revealed the presence of monomodular RP-C4-CYP21-TNX (RCCX) modules, each containing a solitary, long C4A mutant gene. Sequencing of the mutant C4A genes revealed a 2-bp, GT deletion in exon 13 that leads to protein truncation. The other four patients with homozygous HLA A30 B18 DR7 had SLE, severe kidney disorders including mesangial or membranoproliferative glomerulonephritis, and/or Henoch Schoenlein purpura. Molecular genetic analyses revealed an unusual RCCX structure with two short C4B mutant genes, each followed by an intact gene for steroid 21-hydroxylase. Nine identical, intronic mutations were found in each mutant C4B. In particular, the 8127 g-->a mutation present at the donor site of intron 28 may cause an RNA splice defect. Analyses of 12 complete C4 deficiency patients revealed two hot spots of deleterious mutations: one is located at exon 13, the others within a 2.6-kb genomic region spanning exons 20-29. Screening of these mutations may facilitate epidemiologic studies of C4 in infectious, autoimmune, and kidney diseases.