ATP-hydrolyzing excitation state of the reconstituted alpha 3 beta 3 complex of ATP synthase from the thermophilic bacterium PS3: structural characteristics shown by time-resolved small-angle X-ray scattering with synchrotron radiation

The alpha/beta interfaces of alpha(1)beta(1), alpha(3)beta(3), and F1: domain motions and elastic energy stored during gamma rotation

ATP synthase (F(o)F(1)) consists of F(1) (ATP-driven motor) and F(o) (H(+)-driven motor). F(1) is a complex of alpha(3)beta(3)gammadeltaepsilon subunits, and gamma is the rotating cam in alpha(3)beta(3). Thermophilic F(1) (TF(1)) is exceptional in that it can be crystallized as a beta monomer and an alpha(3)beta(3) oligomer, and it is sufficiently stable to allow alphabeta refolding and reassembly of hybrid complexes containing 1, 2, and 3 modified alpha or beta. The nucleotide-dependent open-close conversion of conformation is an inherent property of an isolated beta and energy and signals are transferred through alpha/beta interfaces. The catalytic and noncatalytic interfaces of both mitochondrial F(1) (MF(1)) and TF(1) were analyzed by an atom search within the limits of 0.40 nm across the alphabeta interfaces. Seven (plus thermophilic loop in TF(1)) contact areas are located at both the catalytic and noncatalytic interfaces on the open beta form. The number of contact areas on closed beta increased to 11 and 9, respectively, in the catalytic and noncatalytic interfaces. The interfaces in the barrel domain are immobile. The torsional elastic strain applied through the mobile areas is concentrated in hinge residues and the P-loop in beta. The notion of elastic energy in F(o)F(1) has been revised. X-ray crystallography of F(1) is a static snap shot of one state and the elastic hypotheses are still inconsistent with the structure, dyamics, and kinetics of F(o)F(1). The domain motion and elastic energy in F(o)F(1) will be elucidated by time-resolved crystallography.

Biophysical studies on ATP synthase

The isolation of ATP synthase (F0F1) (82) and F0 (83) 34 years ago finally revealed that F0F1 is a motor composed of F0 (ion-motor, abc subunits) and F1 (ATP-motor, alpha 3 beta 3 gamma delta epsilon subunits) (Fig. 1). The single molecule videotape (4, 5, 65, 66) revealed that gamma epsilon axis of F1 rotates counterclockwise, proceeds by each 2 pi/3 step, and is driven by torque of 42 pN.nm (12) with nearly 100% efficiency (5) (Fig. 4). The motor is composed of a rotor (gamma epsilon-F0-c) and a stator (alpha 3 beta 3 delta-F0-ab), and the rotor is connected to a shaft (gamma epsilon). Since F0F1 is driven by delta microH+ (9, 10, 84), biophysical studies on stable TF0F1 (1, 7) are essential to elucidate the mechanism. These include nanomechanics (4, 5) (Fig. 4), crystallography (2, 3) (Figs. 2 and 3), NMR (51, 52), ESR (56), synchrotron analysis (3, 28), and electrophysiology (10, 25). The KmATP value of rotation is 0.8 microM, with the Vmax of 3.9 rps (5). This corresponds to the bi-site catalysis in proton transport by F0F1 (10, 70, 84). X-ray crystallography of MF1 (2) and the alpha 3 beta 3 oligomer of TF1 (3) (Fig. 2) together with mutation analyses revealed the role of residues in the rotation. The idea of elastic energy store is proposed in alpha 3 beta 3 gamma during the stepping time (up to a few sec) after the ATP binding. Biological studies have partially clarified the genetic and kinetic regulation of the rotation in MF1. Both theories (6, 7, 62, 64, 85) and the biological significance (17) of the intramolecular rotation of F0F1 await further studies, especially those of F0 and minor subunits.

Refolding of recombinant alpha and beta subunits of the Rhodospirillum rubrum F(0)F(1) ATP synthase into functional monomers that reconstitute an active alpha(1)beta(1)-dimer

The alpha subunit from the Rhodospirillum rubrum F(0)F(1) ATP synthase (RrF(1)alpha) was over-expressed in unc operon-deleted Escherichia coli strains under various growth conditions only in insoluble inclusion bodies. The functional refolding of urea-solubilized RrF(1)alpha was followed by measuring its ability to stimulate the restoration of ATP synthesis and hydrolysis in beta-less R. rubrum chromatophores reconstituted with pure native or recombinant RrF(1)beta [Nathanson, L. & Gromet-Elhanan, Z. (1998) J. Biol. Chem. 273, 10933-10938]. The refolding efficiency was found to increase with decreasing RrF(1)alpha concentrations and required high concentrations of MgATP, saturating approximately 60% when 50 microgram protein.mL(-1) were refolded in presence of 50 mM MgATP. Size-exclusion HPLC of such refolded RrF(1)alpha revealed a 50-60% decrease in its aggregated form and a parallel appearance of its monomeric peak. RrF(1)beta refolded under identical conditions appeared almost exclusively as a monomer. This procedure enabled the isolation of large amounts of a stable RrF(1)alpha monomer, which stimulated the restoration of ATP synthesis and hydrolysis much more efficiently than the refolded alpha mixture, and bound ATP and ADP in a Mg-dependent manner. Incubation of both RrF(1)alpha and beta monomers, which by themselves had no ATPase activity, resulted in a parallel appearance of activity and assembled alpha(1)beta(1)-dimers, but showed no formation of alpha(3)beta(3)-hexamers. The RrF(1)-alpha(1)beta(1)-ATPase activity was, however, very similar to the activity observed in isolated native chloroplast CF(1)-alpha(3)beta(3), indicating that these dimers contain only the catalytic nucleotide-binding site at their alpha/beta interface. Their inability to associate into an alpha(3)beta(3)-hexamer seems therefore to reflect a much lower stability of the noncatalytic RrF(1) alpha/beta interface.

Intramolecular rotation in ATP synthase: dynamic and crystallographic studies on thermophilic F1

A single molecule of ATP synthase (F0F1) is by itself a rotary motor, the smallest ever found, and this biomotor is driven by an electrochemical potential of H+ (delta microH+). F0F1 is composed of an ion-conducting portion (F0) and a catalytic portion (F1). The major breakthroughs in studies on the mechanochemical coupling have been the direct observation of the rotation of a stable alpha 3 beta 3 gamma complex of thermophilic F1 (TF1), and X-ray crystallography of the alpha 3 beta 3 gamma portion of mitochondrial F1 (MF1) and the alpha 3 beta 3 oligomer of TF1. This review focuses on the dynamics of TF1, demonstrated by a crucial experiment. The torque of the rotation was estimated to be 42 pN.nm from the delta microH+ and frictional force. Important unsolved problems are the crystallography of F0, elastic energy conversion, and the stator and rotor of this biomotor.

The crystal structure of the nucleotide-free alpha 3 beta 3 subcomplex of F1-ATPase from the thermophilic Bacillus PS3 is a symmetric trimer

BACKGROUND

F1-ATPase, an oligomeric assembly with subunit stoichiometry alpha 3 beta 3 gamma delta epsilon, is the catalytic component of the ATP synthase complex, which plays a central role in energy transduction in bacteria, chloroplasts and mitochondria. The crystal structure of bovine mitochondrial F1-ATPase displays a marked asymmetry in the conformation and nucleotide content of the catalytic beta subunits. The alpha 3 beta 3 subcomplex of F1-ATPase has been assembled from subunits of the moderately thermophilic Bacillus PS3 made in Escherichia coli, and the subcomplex is active but does not show the catalytic cooperativity of intact F1-ATPase. The structure of this subcomplex should provide new information on the conformational variability of F1-ATPase and may provide insights into the unusual catalytic mechanism employed by this enzyme.

RESULTS

The crystal structure of the nucleotide-free bacterial alpha 3 beta 3 subcomplex of F1-ATPase, determined at 3.2 A resolution, shows that the oligomer has exact threefold symmetry. The bacterial beta subunits adopt a conformation essentially identical to that of the nucleotide-free beta subunit in mitochondrial F1-ATPase; the alpha subunits have similar conformations in both structures.

CONCLUSIONS

The structures of the bacterial F1-ATPase alpha and beta subunits are very similar to their counterparts in the mitochondrial enzyme, suggesting a common catalytic mechanism. The study presented here allows an analysis of the different conformations adopted by the alpha and beta subunits and may ultimately further our understanding of this mechanism.

The ATP synthase--a splendid molecular machine

An X-ray structure of the F1 portion of the mitochondrial ATP synthase shows asymmetry and differences in nucleotide binding of the catalytic beta subunits that support the binding change mechanism with an internal rotation of the gamma subunit. Other structural and mutational probes of the F1 and F0 portions of the ATP synthase are reviewed, together with kinetic and other evaluations of catalytic site occupancy and behavior during hydrolysis or synthesis of ATP. Subunit function as related to proton translocation and rotational catalysis is considered. Physical demonstrations of the gamma subunit rotation have been achieved. The findings have implications for other enzymatic catalyses.

The energy transmission in ATP synthase: from the gamma-c rotor to the alpha 3 beta 3 oligomer fixed by OSCP-b stator via the beta DELSEED sequence

ATP synthase (F0F1) is driven by an electrochemical potential of H+ (delta microH+). F0F1 is composed of an ion-conducting portion (F0) and a catalytic portion (F1). The subunit composition of F1 is a alpha 3 beta 3 gamma delta epsilon. The active alpha 3 beta 3 oligomer, characterized by X-ray crystallography, has been obtained only from thermophilic F1 (TF1). We proposed in 1984 that ATP is released from the catalytic site (C site) by a conformational change induced by the beta DELSEED sequence via gamma delta epsilon-F0. In fact, cross-linking of beta DELSEED to gamma stopped the ATP-driven rotation of gamma in the center of alpha 3 beta 3. The torque of the rotation is estimated to be 420 pN x A from the delta microH+ and H(+)-current through F0F1. The angular velocity (omega) of gamma is the rate-limiting step, because delta microH+ increased the Vmax of H+ current through F0, but not the Km(ATP). The rotational unit of F0 (= ab2c10) is pi/5, while that in alpha 3 beta 3 is 2 pi/3. This difference is overcome by an analog-digital conversion via elasticity around beta DELSEED with a threshold to release ATP. The alpha beta distance at the C site is about 9.6 A (2,8-diN3-ATP), and tight Mg-ATP binding in alpha 3 beta 3 gamma was shown by ESR. The rotational relaxation of TF1 is too rapid (phi = 100 nsec), but the rate of AT(D)P-induced conformational change of alpha 3 beta 3 measured with a synchrotron is close to omega. The ATP bound between the P-loop and beta E188 is released by the shift of beta DELSEED from gamma RGL. Considering the viscosity resistance and inertia of the free rotor (gamma-c), there may be a stator containing OSCP (= delta of TF1) and F0-d to hold free rotation of alpha 3 beta 3.

Structural asymmetry of F1-ATPase caused by the gamma subunit generates a high affinity nucleotide binding site

The alpha 3 beta 3 gamma and alpha 3 beta 3 complexes of F1-ATPase from a thermophilic Bacillus PS3 were compared in terms of interaction with trinitrophenyl analogs of ATP and ADP (TNP-ATP and TNP-ADP) that differed from ATP and ADP and did not destabilize the alpha 3 beta 3 complex. The results of equilibrium dialysis show that the alpha 3 beta 3 gamma complex has a high affinity nucleotide binding site and several low affinity sites, whereas the alpha 3 beta 2 complex has only low affinity sites. This is also supported from analysis of spectral change induced by TNP-ADP, which in addition indicates that this high affinity site is located on the beta subunit. Single-site hydrolysis of substoichiometric amounts of TNP-ATP by the alpha 3 beta 3 gamma complex is accelerated by the chase addition of excess ATP, whereas that by the alpha 3 beta 3 complex is not. We further examined the complexes containing mutant beta subunits (Y341L, Y341A, and Y341C). Surprisingly, in spite of very weak affinity of the isolated mutant beta subunits to nucleotides (Odaka, M., Kaibara, C., Amano, T., Matsui, T., Muneyuki, E., Ogasawara, K, Yutani, K., and Yoshida, M. (1994) J. Biochem. (Tokyo) 115, 789-796), a high affinity TNP-ADP binding site is generated on the beta subunit in the mutant alpha 3 beta 3 gamma complexes where single-site TNP-ATP hydrolysis can occur. ATP concentrations required for the chase acceleration of the mutant complexes are higher than that of the wild-type complex. The mutant alpha 3 beta 3 complexes, on the contrary, catalyze single-site hydrolysis of TNP-ATP rather slowly, and there is no chase acceleration. Thus, the gamma subunit is responsible for the generation of a high affinity nucleotide binding site on the beta subunit in F1-ATPase where cooperative catalysis can proceed.