Rational design of 'water-soluble' bacteriorhodopsin variants

Computational design of soluble and functional membrane protein analogues

De novo design of complex protein folds using solely computational means remains a substantial challenge1. Here we use a robust deep learning pipeline to design complex folds and soluble analogues of integral membrane proteins. Unique membrane topologies, such as those from G-protein-coupled receptors2, are not found in the soluble proteome, and we demonstrate that their structural features can be recapitulated in solution. Biophysical analyses demonstrate the high thermal stability of the designs, and experimental structures show remarkable design accuracy. The soluble analogues were functionalized with native structural motifs, as a proof of concept for bringing membrane protein functions to the soluble proteome, potentially enabling new approaches in drug discovery. In summary, we have designed complex protein topologies and enriched them with functionalities from membrane proteins, with high experimental success rates, leading to a de facto expansion of the functional soluble fold space.

Design of a water-soluble transmembrane receptor kinase with intact molecular function by QTY code

Membrane proteins are critical to biological processes and central to life sciences and modern medicine. However, membrane proteins are notoriously challenging to study, mainly owing to difficulties dictated by their highly hydrophobic nature. Previously, we reported QTY code, which is a simple method for designing water-soluble membrane proteins. Here, we apply QTY code to a transmembrane receptor, histidine kinase CpxA, to render it completely water-soluble. The designed CpxAQTY exhibits expected biophysical properties and highly preserved native molecular function, including the activities of (i) autokinase, (ii) phosphotransferase, (iii) phosphatase, and (iv) signaling receptor, involving a water-solubilized transmembrane domain. We probe the principles underlying the balance of structural stability and activity in the water-solubilized transmembrane domain. Computational approaches suggest that an extensive and dynamic hydrogen-bond network introduced by QTY code and its flexibility may play an important role. Our successful functional preservation further substantiates the robustness and comprehensiveness of QTY code.

Computational design of soluble functional analogues of integral membrane proteins

De novo design of complex protein folds using solely computational means remains a significant challenge. Here, we use a robust deep learning pipeline to design complex folds and soluble analogues of integral membrane proteins. Unique membrane topologies, such as those from GPCRs, are not found in the soluble proteome and we demonstrate that their structural features can be recapitulated in solution. Biophysical analyses reveal high thermal stability of the designs and experimental structures show remarkable design accuracy. The soluble analogues were functionalized with native structural motifs, standing as a proof-of-concept for bringing membrane protein functions to the soluble proteome, potentially enabling new approaches in drug discovery. In summary, we designed complex protein topologies and enriched them with functionalities from membrane proteins, with high experimental success rates, leading to a de facto expansion of the functional soluble fold space.

Protein Design: From the Aspect of Water Solubility and Stability

Water solubility and structural stability are key merits for proteins defined by the primary sequence and 3D-conformation. Their manipulation represents important aspects of the protein design field that relies on the accurate placement of amino acids and molecular interactions, guided by underlying physiochemical principles. Emulated designer proteins with well-defined properties both fuel the knowledge-base for more precise computational design models and are used in various biomedical and nanotechnological applications. The continuous developments in protein science, increasing computing power, new algorithms, and characterization techniques provide sophisticated toolkits for solubility design beyond guess work. In this review, we summarize recent advances in the protein design field with respect to water solubility and structural stability. After introducing fundamental design rules, we discuss the transmembrane protein solubilization and de novo transmembrane protein design. Traditional strategies to enhance protein solubility and structural stability are introduced. The designs of stable protein complexes and high-order assemblies are covered. Computational methodologies behind these endeavors, including structure prediction programs, machine learning algorithms, and specialty software dedicated to the evaluation of protein solubility and aggregation, are discussed. The findings and opportunities for Cryo-EM are presented. This review provides an overview of significant progress and prospects in accurate protein design for solubility and stability.

Development of a Method for Fast Assessment of Protein Solubility Based on Ultrasonic Dispersion and Differential Centrifugation Technology

Protein solubility is very important for protein crystallization, bioprocess development, and protein application. In this study, a method based on the stability of a protein dispersion system is proposed for fast assessment of protein solubility, which mainly involves ultrasonic dispersion, differential centrifugation, and spectral measurement (UDDCS) and curvature estimation. The appropriate ultrasonic time and centrifugal time were experimentally determined at first. The results show that the relationship between the standard deviation and the protein concentrations originally added accords with the modified exponential equation, and the corresponding concentration of the maximum curvature point is defined as the solubility of the protein. Lysozyme solubility data in NaCl aqueous solutions and zein solubility data in ethanol aqueous solutions are selected to verify the UDDCS method by comparing the data obtained by the UDDCS method and the results from references, and the results indicate that the UDDCS method is reliable, universal, and time-saving. Finally, measurements of zein solubility in NaOH solution and casein solubility in urea aqueous solution were conducted as test cases by the UDDCS method.

Hiding in plain sight: three chemically distinct α-helix types

Linus Pauling in 1950 published a three-dimensional model for a universal protein secondary structure motif which he initially called the alpha-spiral. Jack Dunitz, then a postdoc in Pauling's lab suggested to Pauling that the term helix is more accurate than spiral when describing the right-handed peptide and protein coiled structures. Pauling agreed, hence the rise of the alpha-helix, and, by extension, the ‘double helix’ structure of DNA. Although structural biologists and protein chemists are familiar with varying polar and apolar characters of amino acids in alpha-helices, to non-experts the three chemically distinct alpha-helix types classified here may hide in plain sight.

Enabling QTY Server for Designing Water-Soluble α-Helical Transmembrane Proteins

Membrane proteins, particularly those that are α-helical, such as transporters and G-protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs), have significant biological relevance. However, their expression and purification pose difficulties because of their poor water solubilities, which impedes progress in this field. The QTY method, a code-based protein-engineering approach, was recently developed to produce soluble transmembrane proteins. Here, we describe a comprehensive Web server built for QTY design and its relevance for in silico analyses. Typically, the simple design model is expected to require only 2 to 4 min of computer time, and the library design model requires 2 to 5 h, depending on the target protein size and the number of transmembrane helices. Detailed protocols for using the server with both the simple design and library design modules are provided. Methods for experiments following the QTY design are also included to facilitate the implementation of this approach. The design pipeline was further evaluated using microbial transmembrane proteins and structural alignment between the designed proteins and their origins by employing AlphaFold2. The results reveal that mutants generated by the developed pipeline were highly identical to their origins in terms of three-dimensional (3D) structures. In summary, the utilization of our Web server and associated protocols will enable QTY-based protein engineering to be implemented in a convenient, fast, accurate, and rational manner. The Protein Solubilizing Server (PSS) is publicly available at http://pss.sjtu.edu.cn. IMPORTANCE Water-soluble expression and purification are of considerable importance for protein identification and characterization. However, there has been a lack of an effective method for water-soluble expression of membrane proteins, which has severely hampered their studies. Here, an enabling comprehensive Web server, PSS, was developed for designing water-soluble mutants of α-helical membrane proteins, based on QTY design, a code-based protein-engineering approach. With microbial transmembrane proteins and GPCRs as examples, we systematically evaluated the server and demonstrated its successful performance. PSS is readily available for worldwide users as a Web-based tool, rendering QTY-based protein engineering convenient, efficient, accurate, and rational.

Phosphatidylserine Asymmetry Promotes the Membrane Insertion of a Transmembrane Helix

The plasma membrane (PM) contains an asymmetric distribution of lipids between the inner and outer bilayer leaflets. A lipid of special interest in eukaryotic membranes is the negatively charged phosphatidylserine (PS). In healthy cells, PS is actively sequestered to the inner leaflet of the PM, but PS redistributes to the outer leaflet when the cell is damaged or at the onset of apoptosis. However, the influence of PS asymmetry on membrane protein structure and folding are poorly understood. The pH low insertion peptide (pHLIP) adsorbs to the membrane surface at a neutral pH, but it inserts into the membrane at an acidic pH. We have previously observed that in symmetric vesicles, PS affects the membrane insertion of pHLIP by lowering the pH midpoint of insertion. Here, we studied the effect of PS asymmetry on the membrane interaction of pHLIP. We developed a modified protocol to create asymmetric vesicles containing PS and employed Annexin V labeled with an Alexa Fluor 568 fluorophore as a new probe to quantify PS asymmetry. We observed that the membrane insertion of pHLIP was promoted by the asymmetric distribution of negatively charged PS, which causes a surface charge difference between bilayer leaflets. Our results indicate that lipid asymmetry can modulate the formation of an α-helix on the membrane. A corollary is that model studies using symmetric bilayers to mimic the PM may fail to capture important aspects of protein-membrane interactions.

QTY code enables design of detergent-free chemokine receptors that retain ligand-binding activities

Structure and function studies of membrane proteins, particularly G protein-coupled receptors and multipass transmembrane proteins, require detergents. We have devised a simple tool, the QTY code (glutamine, threonine, and tyrosine), for designing hydrophobic domains to become water soluble without detergents. Here we report using the QTY code to systematically replace the hydrophobic amino acids leucine, valine, isoleucine, and phenylalanine in the seven transmembrane α-helices of CCR5, CXCR4, CCR10, and CXCR7. We show that QTY code-designed chemokine receptor variants retain their thermostabilities, α-helical structures, and ligand-binding activities in buffer and 50% human serum. CCR5QTY, CXCR4QTY, and CXCR7QTY also bind to HIV coat protein gp41-120. Despite substantial transmembrane domain changes, the detergent-free QTY variants maintain stable structures and retain their ligand-binding activities. We believe the QTY code will be useful for designing water-soluble variants of membrane proteins and other water-insoluble aggregated proteins.

Amino acid contribution to protein solubility: Asp, Glu, and Ser contribute more favorably than the other hydrophilic amino acids in RNase Sa

Poor protein solubility is a common problem in high-resolution structural studies, formulation of protein pharmaceuticals, and biochemical characterization of proteins. One popular strategy to improve protein solubility is to use site-directed mutagenesis to make hydrophobic to hydrophilic mutations on the protein surface. However, a systematic investigation of the relative contributions of all 20 amino acids to protein solubility has not been done. Here, 20 variants at the completely solvent-exposed position 76 of ribonuclease (RNase) Sa are made to compare the contributions of each amino acid. Stability measurements were also made for these variants, which occur at the i+1 position of a type II beta-turn. Solubility measurements in ammonium sulfate solutions were made at high positive net charge, low net charge, and high negative net charge. Surprisingly, there was a wide range of contributions to protein solubility even among the hydrophilic amino acids. The results suggest that aspartic acid, glutamic acid, and serine contribute significantly more favorably than the other hydrophilic amino acids especially at high net charge. Therefore, to increase protein solubility, asparagine, glutamine, or threonine should be replaced with aspartic acid, glutamic acid or serine.

Conversion of a mechanosensitive channel protein from a membrane-embedded to a water-soluble form by covalent modification with amphiphiles

Covalent modification of integral membrane proteins with amphiphiles may provide a general approach to the conversion of membrane proteins into water-soluble forms for biophysical and high-resolution structural studies. To test this approach, we mutated four surface residues of the pentameric Mycobacterium tuberculosis mechanosensitive channel of large conductance (MscL) to cysteine residues as anchors for amphiphile attachment. A series of modified ion channels with four amphiphile groups attached per channel subunit was prepared. One construct showed the highest water solubility to a concentration of up to 4mg/ml in the absence of detergent. This analog also formed native-like, alpha-helical homo-pentamers in the absence of detergent as judged by circular dichroism spectroscopy, size-exclusion chromatography and various light-scattering techniques. Proteins with longer, or shorter polymers attached, or proteins modified exclusively with polar cysteine-reactive small molecules, exhibited reduced to no solubility and higher-order aggregation. Electron microscopy revealed a homogeneous population of particles consistent with a pentameric channel. Solubilization of membrane proteins by covalent attachment of amphiphiles results in homogeneous particles that may prove useful for crystallization, solution NMR spectroscopy, and electron microscopy.

Computational design of water-soluble analogues of the potassium channel KcsA

Although the interiors of membrane and water-soluble proteins are similar in their physicochemical properties, membrane proteins differ in having larger fractions of hydrophobic residues on their exteriors. Thus, it should be possible to water-solubilize membrane proteins by mutating their lipid-contacting side chains to more polar groups. Here, a computational approach was used to generate water-soluble variants of the potassium channel KcsA. As a probe of the correctness of the fold, the proteins contain an agitoxin2 binding site from a mammalian homologue of the channel. The resulting proteins express in high yield in Escherichia coli and share the intended functional and structural properties with KcsA, including secondary structure, tetrameric quaternary structure, and tight specific binding to both agitoxin2 and a small molecule channel blocker.