Severity of Scab and its Effects on Fruit Weight in Mechanically Hedge-Pruned and Topped Pecan Trees

A Comparison of a Standard Radial Airflow and a Double Volute-Generated Focused Airflow Air Blast Sprayer to Control Scab in Tall Pecan Trees

Pecan (Carya illinoinensis) is a valuable crop in the southern United States. Scab (caused by Venturia effusa) is a major biotic constraint to pecan production in the southeastern region and requires 10 to 15 or more fungicide applications for control. Spray application relies on large standard radial airflow air blast sprayers (SSs). Some SSs have been adapted to include a volute on one side to project spray higher into the canopy because of a decline in coverage with height. A grower-designed and engineered double volute-generated focused airflow air blast sprayer (DVS) was assessed for scab control and spray coverage compared with an SS. Over three seasons, on foliage and fruit, scab control was either equal to or superior using the DVS sprayer. On mature fruit, in 2017, scab severity on the control was 9.07%, on the DVS it was 0.19%, and on the SS it was 0.24%; in 2018 severity was 84.4, 18.4, and 29.1%, respectively; and in 2019 it was 32.7, 7.0, and 11.6%, respectively. There were no discernable gradients in scab severity with tree height with either sprayer in 2017, but in 2018 the difference was significant, with the DVS having a shallower gradient, and in 2019 the DVS slope was numerically less steep compared with the SS. Mature fruit weight was significantly greater on trees treated using the DVS compared with the SS in 2017 and 2018 but was not different in 2019. Spray coverage studies showed that the DVS sprayer had significantly more coverage at heights >13.8 m (up to 19.0 m), ranging from 18.4 to 14.1%, compared with coverage using the SS, which ranged from 7.9 to 2.9%. The slope in decline of spray coverage with height was significantly shallower with the DVS sprayer, and spray profiles reflected these differences. Disease control was improved overall when using the DVS, and the DVS provided greater spray coverage at heights >13.8 m when compared with the SS sprayer. The DVS design may offer economical, superior scab control in pecan orchards where trees are >13.8 m tall.

Effect of Tractor Speed and Spray Application Volume on Severity of Scab and Fruit Weight at Different Heights in the Canopy of Tall Pecan Trees

Scab (caused by Venturia effusa) is the most important yield-limiting disease of pecan in the southeastern USA. On susceptible cultivars, the disease is managed using fungicides, but spray coverage is an issue in tall trees. In four experiments, we used an air-blast sprayer to compare scab severity on fruit at 5.0 to 15.0 m height in trees receiving the same dose of fungicide at 468, 935, and 1,871 liter/ha at 2.4 and 3.2 km/h (in two additional experiments fungicides were applied at 4.0 km/h at 470 liter/ha, 4.0 km/h at 940 liter/ha and 4.0 km/h at 1,100 liter/ha). An air-blast sprayer was used for the applications, which included typical recommended active ingredients (a.i.). Nozzles were selected to provide similar proportions of spray to the upper and lower canopy. The treatments (or subsets thereof) were repeated in 2015 to 2017 on cv. Schley and in 2017, 2019, and 2020 on cv. Desirable. All treatments reduced scab compared with the control. Overall, there was no consistent difference among the treatments for severity of scab on foliage, immature fruit, or mature fruit at any height in the canopy up to 15.0 m (maximum height sampled). Fungicide applied at 2.4 or 3.2 km/h at 470 liter/ha was as effective at reducing disease as were the higher volumes (sometimes more so). The scab epidemic severity affected control efficacy. Estimated cost and water savings based on faster speed and lower volume were considerable. These preliminary observations indicate no single volume or speed was consistently superior to control scab; this suggests that, in most seasons, low volumes (higher concentration of a.i.) may be similarly efficacious as high volumes (lower concentration of a.i.) for controlling scab in tall pecan trees and offer greater resource use efficiency.

Effect of Tractor Speed and Spray Application Volume on Spray Coverage at Different Heights in the Canopy of Tall Pecan Trees

Scab (caused by Venturia effusa) is the most important disease of pecan in the southeastern U.S.A. The yield losses in susceptible cultivars, combined with costs of control, amount to tens of millions of dollars annually. It is known that fungicide coverage from air-blast sprayers declines with height in the canopy, and conversely, disease severity increases. But how application volume (liter/ha) and speed (km/h) affect spray coverage at different heights is unknown. Coverage was quantified using Kromekote cards (CTI Paper USA, Sun Prairie, WI) and Vision Pink dye (GarrCo Products, Converse, IN) at heights of 5.0, 7.5, 10.0, 12.5, and 15.0 m in pecan canopies. An orchard air-blast sprayer was operated at 2.4 and 3.2 km/h applying 468, 935, or 1,871 liters/ha. Nozzles were selected to provide proportionally similar volumes to the upper and lower canopy positions at set speeds. Speeds tested did not affect spray coverage consistently. However, greater volumes resulted in significantly greater spray coverage, but most of that increase was at heights ≤12.5 m. Although there were significant differences among volumes applied at 12.5 m, differences were numerically small. Card orientation had a profound effect on spray coverage at heights ≤12.5 m, with most spray being detected on the cards facing horizontally downward, and least on those facing vertically backward. The study demonstrates that higher volumes result in more coverage, but the effect declines rapidly with height. If disease control achieved with 470 liters/ha is no different (or is more efficacious) compared with >470 liters/ha and is the same at higher speeds (3.2 km/h), savings may be possible in terms of operating time and equipment costs.

The Effect of Tractor Speed and Canopy Position on Fungicide Spray Deposition and Peach Scab Incidence and Severity

Peach scab, caused by Venturia carpophila, is a damaging disease of peach in the southeastern United States. Thus, fungicides are applied to reduce peach scab. Tractor speed was investigated as a variable affecting spray deposition and disease control in relation to volume applied. In experiments in 2015 and 2016, trees were sprayed with fungicide to control scab at petal fall to 1% shuck split and at shuck split to 10% shuck off. Speeds were 3.2, 4.8, and 6.4 kph resulting in 1,403, 935, and 701 liters/ha, respectively, with the dose of active ingredient (a.i.) per ha kept constant. Deposition declined for all speeds with later spray dates. There was a negative linear relationship between tractor speed and spray coverage on three of four dates the experiment was repeated. Tractor speed (different volumes, equal doses) affected peach scab. In 2015 and 2016, mean incidence at 3.2, 4.8, and 6.4 kph was 68.6, 59.2, and 38.3%, and 64.2, 53.0, and 40.4% of fruit scabbed, respectively. Effect of speed on lesion number per fruit depended on year: in 2015, lesions per fruit were reduced at 6.4 kph compared with 3.2 and 4.8 kph but were not different in 2016. Control trees had fewer lesions per fruit high in the canopy, but there was little effect of sample height in fungicide-treated trees. Concentration of a.i. in lower volumes applied at higher speed may provide some benefit in reducing incidence of peach scab, but there appeared to be less effect on severity.

A Comparison of Ground-Based Air-Blast Sprayer and Aircraft Application of Fungicides to Manage Scab in Tall Pecan Trees

Pecan scab (caused by Venturia effusa) is a destructive disease of pecan in the southeastern United States. Susceptible cultivars must be sprayed with fungicide every 10 to 21 days to ensure yield and kernel quality. Fungicide is most often applied using large orchard air-blast sprayers. Pecan trees grow tall, and air-blast sprays result in a gradient in spray deposition and consequently of scab. Aerial fungicide application is also practiced. Disease distribution and spray deposition of the two methods have not been compared but will provide information aiding decisions on spray application methods. We compared air-blast, aerial, and air-blast + aerial applications for efficacy controlling scab at five heights in the canopy of 25-m cultivar Schley pecan trees. There was a negative relationship between scab severity and height in control trees, a positive linear relationship with height in air-blast treated trees, and a generally negative linear relationship between scab severity and height in aerially treated trees. Air-blast + aerial treatments resulted in low severity of scab at all heights. Spray deposition on water-sensitive cards indicated a declining gradient with height using an air-blast sprayer, whereas aerial applications resulted in a low deposition at all sample heights. Air-blast sprays tended to result in less good control at heights >12.5 m, and aerially treated trees at ≤7.5 m. The results provide insight into the efficacy and advantages of these methods for applying fungicide to control scab in tall pecan trees; further research is needed to better understand the impact of frequency and timing of these two methods.

Disease Incidence-Severity Relationships on Leaflets, Leaves, and Fruit in the Pecan-Venturia effusa Pathosystem

The most destructive disease of pecan in the southeastern United States is scab, caused by Venturia effusa. Incidence (I)-severity (S) relationships have not previously been characterized in this pathosystem, but incidence measures can save time and should have higher accuracy compared with estimates of severity. Ten scab-susceptible cultivars and seedling trees were assessed for I and S of scab on fruit (1,972 trees) and foliage (compound leaves and leaflets, 1,129 trees) between 2010 and 2014. Samples were assessed on a tree basis, and sample size ranged from 10 to 100 specimens per tree. The range in mean I and S was different depending on the organ (fruit I = 0 to 100%, S = 0 to 100%; compound leaves and leaflets, I = 0 to 100%, S = 0-10.1%, respectively). However, mean I could be 100% at a mean S < 2.0% for fruit, compound leaves, and leaflets. Both I and S data were transformed by complementary log-log prior to linear regression analysis. A linear regression model described the relationship between transformed I and S per tree for fruit (P ≤ 0.0001, R² = 0.61), compound leaves (P ≤ 0.0001, R² = 0.82), and leaflets (P ≤ 0.0001, R² = 0.91) for all cultivars. The regression analysis showed significant effects of cultivar and year on the relationship between I and S; therefore, separate analyses were performed for each cultivar and year. Back-transformed predicted severity values showed that the differences among cultivars and years were negligible at severity <80%, and were generally numerically small at severity >80%. The observation that low severity persists until a high incidence of scab is achieved may limit the ability of incidence data to clearly differentiate treatment effects, even when based on the CLL transformation. But if found to be effective, and if used, it would reduce the labor requirements and result in more accurate data being obtained, as incidence estimates do not tend to suffer from the same subjective biases as do visual estimates of severity.