Genome Analysis and Development of a Multiplex TaqMan Real-Time PCR for Specific Identification and Detection of Clavibacter michiganensis subsp. nebraskensis

TaqMan Real-Time PCR Assay for Specific Detection and Differentiation of Xanthomonas translucens pv. undulosa from Other Pathovars Targeting a Recombination Mediator Gene, recF

Bacterial leaf streak and black chaff diseases of wheat caused by Xanthomonas translucens pv. undulosa is becoming a major constraint to growers and trade since it is seedborne. Molecular tools for specific detection/differentiation of pv. undulosa are lacking. We report the development of a TaqMan real-time PCR for specific detection/identification of pv. undulosa targeting the recombination mediator gene (recF). Analysis of the complete recF (1,117 bp) sequences identified the gene as a reliable phylogenetic marker for identification of pv. undulosa, differentiating it from the other pathovars; recF-based sequence homology values among the 11 pathovars correlated well with genome-based DNA-DNA hybridization values. The discriminatory power of recF to differentiate pv. undulosa from the other pathovars is due to nucleotide polymorphic positions. We used these nucleotide polymorphisms to develop a TaqMan PCR for specific detection of pv. undulosa. The specificity of the assay was validated using 67 bacterial and fungal/oomycete strains. The selected primers and the double-quenched FAM-labeled TaqMan probe were specific for the detection of 11 pv. undulosa/secalis strains. The 56 strains of other X. translucens pathovars (n = 39) and non-Xanthomonas spp. (n = 17) did not exhibit any detectable fluorescence. Also, greenhouse-inoculated and naturally infected wheat leaf samples showed positive reactions for the presence of pv. undulosa DNA but not healthy control plants. The TaqMan assay reliably detected as low as 1-pg DNA amount and 10 colony forming units of the target pathogen per reaction. This TaqMan assay could be useful to regulatory agencies with economic benefits to wheat growers.

Unlocking a Mystery: Characterizing the First Appearance of Clavibacter nebraskensis in Mexican Cornfields

The Goss's wilt and leaf blight is a disease of maize (Zea mays) caused by Clavibacter nebraskensis, which was widespread in the last several years throughout the Midwest in the United States, south in Texas, and north to Canada. The bacterium is included within the high-risk list of quarantine pathogens by many plant protection organizations and countries including Mexico. Severe blight symptoms on maize plants were found in different provinces from Coahuila and Tlaxcala, Mexico, in 2012 and 2021, respectively. Twenty bacterial isolates with morphology similar to C. nebraskensis were obtained from the diseased maize leaves. The isolates were confirmed by phenotypic tests and 16S rRNA and gyrB sequencing. Two strains were tested for pathogenicity tests on seven hybrid sweet corn cultivars available in Mexico, and the most sensitive cultivar was tested for all the strains to fulfill Koch's postulates. The phylogenetic reconstruction based on two single loci reveals a remarkable clustering of Mexican strains to American strains reported approximately 50 years ago. The presence of this pathogen represents a risk and a significant challenge for plant protection strategies in Mexico and maize diversity.

Clavibacter nebraskensis causing Goss's wilt of maize: Five decades of detaining the enemy in the New World

Goss's bacterial wilt and leaf blight of maize (Zea mays) caused by the gram-positive coryneform bacterium Clavibacter nebraskensis is an economically important disease in North America. C. nebraskensis is included within the high-risk list of quarantine pathogens by several plant protection organizations (EPPO code: CORBMI), hence it is under strict quarantine control around the world. The causal agent was reported for the first time on maize in Nebraska (USA) in 1969. After an outbreak during the 1970s, prevalence of the disease decreased in the 1980s to the early 2000s, before the disease resurged causing a serious threat to maize production in North America. The re-emergence of Goss's wilt in the corn belt of the United States led to several novel achievements in understanding the pathogen biology and disease control. In this review, we provide an updated overview of the pathogen taxonomy, biology, and epidemiology as well as management strategies of Goss's wilt disease. First, a taxonomic history of the pathogen is provided followed by symptomology and host range, genetic diversity, and pathogenicity mechanisms of the bacterium. Then, utility of high-throughput molecular approaches in the precise detection and identification of the pathogen and the management strategies of the disease are explained. Finally, we highlight the role of integrated pest management strategies to combat the risk of Goss's wilt in the 21st century maize industry.

DISEASE SYMPTOMS

Large (2-15 cm) tan to grey elongated oval lesions with wavy, irregular water-soaked margins on the leaves. The lesions often start at the leaf tip or are associated with wounding caused by hail or wind damage. Small (1 mm in diameter), dark, discontinuous water-soaked spots, known as "freckles", can be observed in the periphery of lesions. When backlit, the freckles appear translucent. Early infection (prior to growth stage V6) may become systemic and cause seedlings to wilt, wither, and die. Coalescence of lesions results in leaf blighting.

HOST RANGE

Maize (Zea mays) is the only economic host of the pathogen. A number of Poaceae species are reported to act as secondary hosts for C. nebraskensis.

TAXONOMIC STATUS OF THE PATHOGEN

Class: Actinobacteria; Order: Micrococcales; Family: Microbacteriaceae; Genus: Clavibacter; Species: Clavibacter nebraskensis.

SYNONYMS

Corynebacterium nebraskense (Schuster, 1970) Vidaver & Mandel 1974; Corynebacterium michiganense pv. nebraskense (Vidaver & Mandel 1974) Dye & Kemp 1977; Corynebacterium michiganense subsp. nebraskense (Vidaver & Mandel 1974) Carlson & Vidaver 1982; Clavibacter michiganense subsp. nebraskense (Vidaver & Mandel 1974) Davis et al. 1984; Clavibacter michiganensis subsp. nebraskensis (Vidaver & Mandel 1974) Davis et al. 1984.

TYPE MATERIALS

ATCC 27794^T ; CFBP 2405^T ; ICMP 3298^T ; LMG 3700^T ; NCPPB 2581^T .

MICROBIOLOGICAL PROPERTIES

Cells are gram-positive, orange-pigmented, pleomorphic club- or rod-shaped, nonspore-forming, nonmotile, and without flagella, approximately 0.5 × 1-2.0 μm.

DISTRIBUTION

The pathogen is restricted to Canada and the United States.

PHYTOSANITARY CATEGORIZATION

EPPO code CORBNE.

Improved multiplex TaqMan qPCR assay with universal internal control offers reliable and accurate detection of Clavibacter michiganensis

AIM

Clavibacter michiganensis (Cm) is a seed-borne plant pathogen that significantly reduces tomato production worldwide. Due to repeated outbreaks and rapid spread of the disease, seeds/transplants need to be certified free of the pathogen before planting. To this end, we developed a multiplex TaqMan qPCR assay that can accurately detect Cm in infected samples.

METHODS AND RESULTS

A specific region of Cm (clvG gene) was selected for primer design using comparative genomics approach. A fully synthetic universal internal control (UIC) was also designed to detect PCR inhibitors and false-negative results in qPCRs. The Cm primers can be used alone or in a triplex TaqMan qPCR assay with UIC and previously described Clavibacter primers. The assay was specific for Cm and detected up to 10 fg of Cm DNA in sensitivity and spiked assays. Addition of the UIC did not change the specificity or sensitivity of the multiplex TaqMan qPCR assay.

CONCLUSION

The triplex TaqMan qPCR provides a specific and sensitive diagnostic assay for Cm.

SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF THE STUDY

This assay can be used for biosecurity surveillance, routine diagnostics, estimating bacterial titres in infected material and for epidemiological studies. The UIC is fully synthetic, efficiently amplified and multiplex compatible with any other qPCR assay.

MinION Nanopore-based detection of Clavibacter nebraskensis, the corn Goss's wilt pathogen, and bacteriomic profiling of necrotic lesions of naturally-infected leaf samples

The Goss’s bacterial wilt pathogen, Clavibacter nebraskensis, of corn is a candidate A1 quarantine organism; and its recent re-emergence and spread in the USA and Canada is a potential biothreat to the crop. We developed and tested an amplicon-based Nanopore detection system for C. nebraskensis (Cn), targeting a purine permease gene. The sensitivity (1 pg) of this system in mock bacterial communities (MBCs) spiked with serially diluted DNA of C. nebraskensis NCPPB 2581^T is comparable to that of real-time PCR. Average Nanopore reads increased exponentially from 125 (1pg) to about 6000 reads (1000 pg) after a 3-hr run-time, with 99.0% of the reads accurately assigned to C. nebraskensis. Three run-times were used to process control MBCs, Cn-spiked MBCs, diseased and healthy leaf samples. The mean Nanopore reads doubled as the run-time is increased from 3 to 6 hrs while from 6 to 12 hrs, a 20% increment was recorded in all treatments. Cn-spiked MBCs and diseased corn leaf samples averaged read counts of 5,100, 11,000 and 14,000 for the respective run-times, with 99.8% of the reads taxonomically identified as C. nebraskensis. The control MBCs and healthy leaf samples had 47 and 14 Nanopore reads, respectively. 16S rRNA bacteriomic profiles showed that Sphingomonas (22.7%) and Clavibacter (21.2%) were dominant in diseased samples while Pseudomonas had only 3.5% relative abundance. In non-symptomatic leaf samples, however, Pseudomonas (20.0%) was dominant with Clavibacter at 0.08% relative abundance. This discrepancy in Pseudomonas abundance in the samples was corroborated by qPCR using EvaGreen chemistry. Our work outlines a new useful tool for diagnosis of the Goss’s bacterial wilt disease; and provides the first insight on Pseudomonas community dynamics in necrotic leaf lesions.

Secretome Analysis of Clavibacter nebraskensis Strains Treated with Natural Xylem Sap In Vitro Predicts Involvement of Glycosyl Hydrolases and Proteases in Bacterial Aggressiveness

The Gram-positive bacterium Clavibacter nebraskensis (Cn) causes Goss's wilt and leaf blight on corn in the North American Central Plains with yield losses as high as 30%. Cn strains vary in aggressiveness on corn, with highly aggressive strains causing much more serious symptoms and damage to crops. Since Cn inhabits the host xylem, we investigated differences in the secreted proteomes of Cn strains to determine whether these could account for phenotypic differences in aggressiveness. Highly and a weakly aggressive Cn strains (Cn14-15-1 and DOAB232, respectively) were cultured, in vitro, in the xylem sap of corn (CXS; host) and tomato (TXS; non-host). The secretome of the Cn strains were extracted and processed, and a comparative bottom-up proteomics approach with liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry (LC-MS/MS) was used to determine their identities and concentration. Relative quantitation of peptides was based on precursor ion intensities to measure protein abundances. In total, 745 proteins were identified in xylem sap media. In CXS, a total of 658 and 396 proteins were identified in strains Cn14-5-1 and DOAB232, respectively. The unique and the differentially abundant proteins in the secretome of strain Cn14-5-1 were higher in either sap medium compared to DOAB232. These proteins were sorted using BLAST2GO and assigned to 12 cellular functional processes. Virulence factors, e.g., cellulase, β-glucosidase, β-galactosidase, chitinase, β-1,4-xylanase, and proteases were generally higher in abundance in the aggressive Cn isolate. This was corroborated by enzymatic activity assays of cellulase and protease in CXS. These proteins were either not detected or detected at significantly lower abundance levels in Cn strains grown in non-host xylem sap (tomato), suggesting potential factors involved in Cn-host (corn) interactions.

Comparative Genomics and Phylogenetic Analyses Suggest Several Novel Species within the Genus Clavibacter, Including Nonpathogenic Tomato-Associated Strains

Members of the genus Clavibacter are economically important bacterial plant pathogens infecting a set of diverse agricultural crops (e.g., alfalfa, corn, potato, tomato, and wheat). Tomato-associated Clavibacter sp. strains account for a great portion of the genetic diversity of the genus, and C. michiganensis sensu stricto (formerly C. michiganensis subsp. michiganensis), causing bacterial canker disease, is considered one of the most destructive seed-borne agents for the crop worldwide. However, current taxonomic descriptions of the genus do not reflect the existing diversity of the strains, resulting in unsatisfactory results in quarantine surveys for the pathogens. In this study, we used all the available genome sequences of Clavibacter sp. strains, including the type strains of newly described subspecies, to provide precise insight into the diversity of tomato-associated members of the genus and further clarify the taxonomic status of the strains using genotypic and phenotypic features. The results of phylogenetic analyses revealed the existence of nine hypothetical new species among the investigated strains. None of the three new subspecies (i.e., C. michiganensis subsp. californiensis, C. michiganensis subsp. chilensis, and C. michiganensis subsp. phaseoli) is included within the tomato-pathogenic C. michiganensis sensu stricto lineage. Although comparative genomics revealed the lack of chp and tomA pathogenicity determinant gene clusters in the nonpathogenic strains, a number of pathogenicity-related genes were noted to be present in all the strains regardless of their pathogenicity characteristics. Altogether, our results indicate a need for a formal taxonomic reconsideration of tomato-associated Clavibacter sp. strains to facilitate differentiation of the lineages in quarantine inspections.IMPORTANCE Clavibacter spp. are economically important bacterial plant pathogens infecting a set of diverse agricultural crops, such as alfalfa, corn, pepper, potato, tomato, and wheat. A number of plant-pathogenic members of the genus (e.g., C. michiganensis sensu stricto and C. sepedonicus, infecting tomato and potato plants, respectively) are included in the A2 (high-risk) list of quarantine pathogens by the European and Mediterranean Plant Protection Organization (EPPO). Although tomato-associated members of Clavibacter spp. account for a significant portion of the genetic diversity in the genus, only the strains belonging to C. michiganensis sensu stricto (formerly C. michiganensis subsp. michiganensis) cause bacterial canker disease of tomato and are subjected to the quarantine inspections. Hence, discrimination between the pathogenic and nonpathogenic Clavibacter sp. strains associated with tomato seeds and transplants plays a pivotal role in the accurate detection and cost-efficient management of the disease. On the other hand, detailed information on the genetic contents of different lineages of the genus would lead to the development of genome-informed specific detection techniques. In this study, we have provided an overview of the phylogenetic and genomic differences between the pathogenic and nonpathogenic tomato-associated Clavibacter sp. strains. We also noted that the taxonomic status of newly introduced subspecies of C. michiganensis (i.e., C. michiganensis subsp. californiensis, C. michiganensis subsp. chilensis, and C. michiganensis subsp. phaseoli) should be reconsidered.

Pathogenicity and a TaqMan Real-Time PCR for Specific Detection of Pantoea allii, a Bacterial Pathogen of Onions

Bacterial diseases of onion are reported to cause significant economic losses. Pantoea allii Brady, one of the pathogens causing the center rot on onions, has not yet been reported in Canada. We report the pathogenicity of P. allii on commercially available Canadian green onions (scallions). All P. allii-inoculated plants, irrespective of the inoculum concentration, exhibited typical leaf chlorotic discoloration on green onion leaves, which can reduce their marketability. Reisolation of P. allii from infected scallion tissues and reidentification by sequencing and phylogenetic analyses of the leuS gene suggest that the pathogen can survive in infected tissues 21 days after inoculation. This is the first report of P. allii as a potential pathogen of green onions. This study also reports the development and validation of a TaqMan real-time PCR assay targeting the leuS gene for reliable detection of P. allii in pure cultures and in planta. A 642-bp leuS gene fragment was targeted because it showed high nucleotide diversity and positively correlated with genome-based average nucleotide identity with respect to percent similarity index and identity of Pantoea species. The assay specificity was validated using 61 bacterial and fungal strains. Under optimal conditions, the selected primers and FAM-labeled TaqMan probe were specific for the detection of nine reference P. allii strains by real-time PCR. The 52 strains of other Pantoea spp. (n = 25), non-Pantoea spp. (n = 20), and fungi/oomycetes (n = 7) tested negative (no detectable fluorescence). Onion tissues spiked with P. allii, naturally infested onion bulbs, greenhouse infected green onion leaf samples, as well as an interlaboratory blind test were used to validate the assay specificity. The sensitivities of a 1-pg DNA concentration and 30 CFU are comparable to previously reported real-time PCR assays of other bacterial pathogens. The TaqMan real-time PCR assay developed in this study will facilitate reliable detection of P. allii and could be a useful tool for screening onion imports or exports for the presence of this pathogen.

Taxogenomics and Systematics of the Genus Pantoea

Members of the genus Pantoea are Gram-negative bacteria isolated from various environments. Taxonomic affiliation based on multilocus sequence analysis (MLSA) is used routinely for inferring accurate phylogeny and identification of bacterial species and genera. Partial sequences of five housekeeping genes (fusA, gyrB, leuS, rpoB, and pyrG) were extracted from 206 draft or complete genomes of Pantoea strains publicly available in databases and analyzed together with the representative sequences of the 25 validly published Pantoea type strains to verify and assess their phylogenetic assignations. Of a total of 159 strains assigned to species level, 11.3% of the non-type strains were incorrectly assigned within suitable Pantoea species. The highest proportion of misidentified strains was recorded in Pantoea vagans, 8 out of 15 (53.3%) inaccurate assignations at the species level. One probable reason for this incorrect classification could be the method previously used for strain identification. Forty-seven (22.8%) genome sequences were from strains identified at the genus level only (Pantoea sp.). A combination of MLSA, average nucleotide identities [ANI and MuMmer-based ANI (ANIm)], tetranucleotide usage pattern (TETRA), and genome-based DNA-DNA hybridization (gDDH) data was used to accurately assign 25 of the 47 strains to validly published Pantoea species, while 17 strains could be assigned as putative novel species within the genus Pantoea. Four genomes designed as Pantoea sp. were identified as Mixta calida. Positive and significant correlation coefficients were computed between MLSA and all the indices derived from whole-genome sequences being proposed for species delimitation. gDDH exhibited the best correlation with MLSA while TETRA was the worst. Accurate species-level identification is key to a better understanding of bacterial diversity and evolution. The MLSA scheme used here could be instrumental to determine the correct taxonomic status of new whole-genome sequenced Pantoea strains, especially non-type strains, before depositing into public databases.

Development of a loop-mediated isothermal amplification assay for specific detection of all known subspecies of Clavibacter michiganensis

AIMS

Clavibacter michiganensis is an important bacterial plant pathogen that causes vast destruction to agriculturally important crops worldwide. Early detection is critical to evaluate disease progression and to implement efficient control measures to avoid serious epidemics. In this study, we developed a sensitive, specific and robust loop-mediated isothermal amplification (LAMP) assay for detection of all known subspecies of C. michiganensis.

METHODS AND RESULTS

Whole genome comparative genomics approach was taken to identify a unique and conserved region within all known subspecies of C. michiganensis. Primer specificity was evaluated in silico and with 64 bacterial strains included in inclusivity and exclusivity panels; no false positives or false negatives were detected. Both the sensitivity and spiked assay of the developed LAMP assay was 1 fg of the pathogen DNA per reaction. A 100% accuracy was observed when tested with infected plant samples.

CONCLUSIONS

The developed LAMP assay is simple, sensitive, robust and easy to perform using different detection platforms and chemistries.

SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF THE STUDY

The developed LAMP assay can detect all known subspecies of C. michiganensis. The LAMP process can be performed isothermally at 65°C and results can be visually assessed, which makes this technology a promising tool for monitoring the disease progression and for accurate pathogen detection at point-of-care.

Diversity of bacteria associated with corn roots inoculated with Canadian woodland soils, and description of Pseudomonas aylmerense sp. nov

Bacteria associated with corn roots inoculated with soils collected from the Canadian woodlands were isolated and characterized. Genus-level identification based on 16S rRNA sequence analysis classified the 161 isolates in 19 genera. The majority (64%) of the isolates were affiliated with the genus Pseudomonas. Further analysis of the Pseudomonas isolates based on BLASTn and rpoD-rpoB-gyrB concatenated gene phylogeny revealed three unique clusters that could not be assigned to known species. This study reports the taxonomic description of one of the distinct lineages represented by two strains (S1E40^T and S1E44) with P. lurida LMG 21995^T, P. costantinii LMG 22119^T, P. palleroniana LMG 23076^T, P. simiae CCUG 50988^T and P. extremorientalis LMG 19695^T as the closest taxa. Both strains showed low ANIm (<90%) and genome-based DNA-DNA hybridization (<50%) values, which unequivocally delineated the new strains from the closest relatives. These findings were supported by multilocus sequence analysis (MLSA) and DNA fingerprinting. In addition, growth characteristics and biochemical tests revealed patterns that differed from the related species. Strains S1E40^T and S1E44 are Gram-negative, aerobic, rod-shaped and motile by at least one flagellum; and grew optimally at 30 °C. The predominant polar lipid is phosphatidylethanolamine while the major respiratory quinone is ubiquinone-9. Based on phenotypic and genotypic data presented here, strains S1E40^T and S1E44 represent a novel species for which the name Pseudomonas aylmerense sp. nov. is proposed. The type strain is S1E40^T (= LMG 30784^T = DOAB 703^T = HAMI 3696^T) with a G + C content of 61.6%.

Genome analysis of two novel Pseudomonas strains exhibiting differential hypersensitivity reactions on tobacco seedlings reveals differences in nonflagellar T3SS organization and predicted effector proteins

Multilocus sequence analysis (MLSA) of two new biological control strains (S1E40 and S3E12) of Pseudomonas was performed to assess their taxonomic position relative to close lineages, and comparative genomics employed to investigate whether these strains differ in key genetic features involved in hypersensitivity responses (HRs). Strain S3E12, at high concentration, incites HRs on tobacco and corn plantlets while S1E40 does not. Phylogenies based on individual genes and 16S rRNA-gyrB-rpoB-rpoD concatenated sequence data show strains S1E40 and S3E12 clustering in distinct groups. Strain S3E12 consistently clustered with Pseudomonas marginalis, a bacterium causing soft rots on plant tissues. MLSA data suggest that strains S1E40 and S3E12 are novel genotypes. This is consistent with the data of genome-based DNA-DNA homology values that are below the proposed cutoff species boundary. Comparative genomics analysis of the two strains revealed major differences in the type III secretion systems (T3SS) as well as the predicted T3SS secreted effector proteins (T3Es). One nonflagellar (NF-T3SS) and two flagellar T3SSs (F-T3SS) clusters were identified in both strains. While F-T3SS clusters in both strains were relatively conserved, the NF-T3SS clusters differed in the number of core components present. The predicted T3Es also differed in the type and number of CDSs with both strains having unique predicted protease-related effectors. In addition, the T1SS organization of the S3E12 genome has protein-coding sequences (CDSs) encoding for key factors such as T1SS secreted agglutinin repeats-toxins (a group of cytolysins and cytotoxins), a membrane fusion protein (LapC), a T1SS ATPase of LssB family (LapB), and T1SS-associated transglutaminase-like cysteine proteinase (LapP). In contrast, strain S1E40 has all CDSs for the seven-gene operon (pelA-pelG) required for Pel biosynthesis but not S3E12, suggesting that biofilm formation in these strains is modulated differently. The data presented here provide an insight of the genome organization of these two phytobacterial strains.