The ovulated ovum of the horse: cytology of nonfertilized ova to pronuclear stage ova

The Mare: A Pertinent Model for Human Assisted Reproductive Technologies?

Although there are large differences between horses and humans for reproductive anatomy, follicular dynamics, mono-ovulation, and embryo development kinetics until the blastocyst stage are similar. In contrast to humans, however, horses are seasonal animals and do not have a menstrual cycle. Moreover, horse implantation takes place 30 days later than in humans. In terms of artificial reproduction techniques (ART), oocytes are generally matured in vitro in horses because ovarian stimulation remains inefficient. This allows the collection of oocytes without hormonal treatments. In humans, in vivo matured oocytes are collected after ovarian stimulation. Subsequently, only intra-cytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) is performed in horses to produce embryos, whereas both in vitro fertilization and ICSI are applied in humans. Embryos are transferred only as blastocysts in horses. In contrast, four cells to blastocyst stage embryos are transferred in humans. Embryo and oocyte cryopreservation has been mastered in humans, but not completely in horses. Finally, both species share infertility concerns due to ageing and obesity. Thus, reciprocal knowledge could be gained through the comparative study of ART and infertility treatments both in woman and mare, even though the horse could not be used as a single model for human ART.

Lower blastocyst quality after conventional vs. Piezo ICSI in the horse reflects delayed sperm component remodeling and oocyte activation

PURPOSE

The aim of this study was to evaluate the differential effects of conventional and Piezo-driven ICSI on blastocyst development, and on sperm component remodeling and oocyte activation, in an equine model.

METHODS

In vitro-matured equine oocytes underwent conventional (Conv) or Piezo ICSI, the latter utilizing fluorocarbon ballast. Blastocyst development was compared between treatments to validate the model. Then, oocytes were fixed at 0, 6, or 18 h after injection, and stained for the sperm tail, acrosome, oocyte cortical granules, and chromatin. These parameters were compared between injection techniques and between sham-injected and sperm-injected oocytes among time periods.

RESULTS

Blastocyst rates were 39 and 40%. The nucleus number was lower, and the nuclear fragmentation rate was higher, in blastocysts produced by Conv. Cortical granule loss started at 0H after both sperm and sham injection. The acrosome was present at 0H in both ICSI treatments, and persisted to 18H in significantly more Conv than Piezo oocytes (72 vs. 21%). Sperm head area was unchanged at 6H in Conv but significantly increased at this time in Piezo; correspondingly, at 6H significantly more Conv than Piezo oocytes remained at MII (80 vs. 9.5%). Sham injection did not induce significant meiotic resumption.

CONCLUSIONS

These data show that Piezo ICSI is associated with more rapid sperm component remodeling and oocyte meiotic resumption after sperm injection than is conventional ICSI, and with higher embryo quality at the blastocyst stage. This suggests that there is value in exploring the Piezo technique, utilized with a non-toxic fluorocarbon ballast, for use in clinical human ICSI.

Use of Confocal Microscopy to Evaluate Equine Zygote Development After Sperm Injection of Oocytes Matured In Vivo or In Vitro

Confocal microscopy was used to image stages of equine zygote development, at timed intervals, after intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) of oocytes that were matured in vivo or in vitro. After fixation for 4, 6, 8, 12, or 16 h after ICSI, zygotes were incubated with α/β tubulin antibodies and human anticentromere antibody (CREST/ACA), washed, incubated in secondary antibodies, conjugated to either Alexa 488 or Alexa 647, and incubated with 561-Phalloidin and Hoechst 33258. An Olympus IX81 spinning disk confocal microscope was used for imaging. Data were analyzed using χ 2 and Fisher's exact tests. Minor differences in developmental phases were observed for oocytes matured in vivo or in vitro. Oocytes formed pronuclei earlier when matured in vivo (67% at 6 h and 80% at 8 h) than in vitro (13% at 6 and 8 h); 80% of oocytes matured in vitro formed pronuclei by 12 h. More (p=0.04) zygotes had atypical phenotypes, indicative of a failure of normal zygote development, when oocyte maturation occurred in vitro versus in vivo (30 and 11%, respectively). Some potential zygotes from oocytes matured in vivo had normal phenotypes, although development appeared to be delayed or arrested. Confocal microscopy provided a feasible method to assess equine zygote development using limited samples.

Fertilisation in the horse and paracrine signalling in the oviduct

The mammalian oviduct plays a crucial role in the preparation of gametes for fertilisation (transport and final maturation) and fertilisation itself. An increasing number of studies offers a comprehensive overview of the functions of the oviduct and its secretions, but this topic has had limited investigation in the horse. Limited data are available on the final oocyte maturation in the equine oviduct. However, in vitro and in vivo systems have been established to analyse the influence of equine oviduct epithelial cells (OEC) during maturation on the potential of oocytes for fertilisation and development. Most studies focus on the role of the oviduct in equine sperm function, such as spermatozoa transport, attachment to oviduct epithelium, viability, motility and capacitation. Moreover, some possible candidate molecules for sperm-oviducal interactions have been identified in the horse. Finally, the low efficiency of conventional in vitro fertilisation and the in vivo fertilisation of equine oocytes transferred into the oviduct of an inseminated mare predicted an influence of oviduct in equine fertilisation. Actually, in vivo and in vitro experiments demonstrated a role of the oviduct in equine fertilisation. Moreover, recent studies showed a beneficial effect of homologous and heterologous OEC on equine in vitro fertilisation, and some candidate molecules have been studied.

In vitro fertilization rate of horse oocytes with partially removed zonae

Frozen-thawed ejaculated stallion spermatozoa were preincubated for 3 h in BO medium containing 5 mM caffeine and then treated with 0.1 micro M calcium ionophore A23187 for 60 sec. Aliquots of the sperm suspension (final concentration 1-2 x 10(7)/ml) were added to the oocytes which had been matured in vitro for 32 h. In Experiment 1, there were 3 groups of oocytes; cumulus intact, denuded zona-intact, and zona-free. Cumulus cells were removed with 0.5% hyaluronidase and the zona pellucida with 0.1% protease. The oocytes were fixed 20 h after insemination with acetic acid:ethanol (1:3) and stained with 1% orcein. The sperm penetration rate of zona-free oocytes was 83%, whereas the sperm penetration rate was very low (1 to 3%) in the cumulus-enclosed or zona-intact oocytes. In Experiment 2, denuded zona-intact oocytes were placed in PBS supplemented with 10% fetal bovine serum 1 h before the end of in vitro maturation. The zona pellucida was micromanipulated with a metal microblade under x 100 magnification within 20 min of treatment with 0.3 M sucrose. For partial zona dissection, a slit in the zona pellucida was made. For partial zona removal, oocytes were transferred to protein-free PBS to fix the oocytes on the bottom of the Petri-dish and to remove a piece of the zona pellucida. Micromanipulated oocytes were subjected to in vitro fertilization as described above. Zona-intact and zona-free oocytes treated with sucrose solution for 20 min were used as controls. The penetration rates were 4 (2/57), 12 (7/58), 52 (31/60), and 86% (44/51) for zona-intact, partially zona dissected, partially zona removed, and zona-free oocytes, respectively. Proportions of oocytes with monospermic penetration were 100 (2/2), 57 (4/7), 58 (18/31), and 34% (15/44), respectively. In Experiment 3, sperm penetration and male pronucleus formation in the partially zona removed oocytes were examined at 2.5 to 20.0 h of insemination. Sperm penetration started 2.5 h post-insemination (22%, 11/49), and increased to 38% (21/55) at 5 h, to 46% (23/50) at 10 h, and to 56% (27/48) at 20 h. The transformation of sperm heads into male pronuclei was first observed 10 h post insemination. These results indicate that assisted fertilization techniques may be a useful tool for achieving fertilization and embryo production in vitro in horses.

Equine embryology: An inventory of unanswered questions

Carl Hartman's title of 47 years ago is invoked in tribute to his first recovery of a bovine embryo 30 years before that, and his legacy of an emphasis on the value of descriptive and comparative studies in reproductive biology. The horse's qualification as a farm animal has waned since those times but, in a conference understandably dominated by research in ruminants and pigs, there are lessons to be learned from some peculiarities of equine embryonic development. Morphological and physiological features of the conceptus and its interaction with its environment during the first month of pregnancy are described and discussed, with emphasis on conceptus expansion, experimental study of the capsule and its associated proteins, and steroid production and metabolism by the various tissues within the conceptus. It is also suggested that easy access to entire conceptuses at advanced stages of development in horses offers valuable opportunities for comparative investigation of early organogenesis and fetal membrane differentiation and, possibly, how they are affected by embryo manipulation in vitro.

Cytoskeleton and chromatin reorganization in horse oocytes following intracytoplasmic sperm injection: patterns associated with normal and defective fertilization

Intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) is the method of choice for fertilizing horse oocytes in vitro. Nevertheless, for reasons that are not yet clear, embryo development rates are low. The aims of this study were to examine cytoskeletal and chromatin reorganization in horse oocytes fertilized by ICSI or activated parthenogenetically. Additional oocytes were injected with a sperm labeled with a mitochondrion-specific vital dye to help identify the contribution of the sperm to zygotic structures, in particular the centrosome. Oocytes were fixed at set intervals after sperm injection and examined by confocal laser scanning microscopy. In unfertilized oocytes, microtubules were present only in the metaphase-arrested second meiotic spindle and the first polar body. After sperm injection, an aster of microtubules formed adjacent to the sperm head and subsequently enlarged such that at the time of pronucleus migration and apposition it filled the entire cytoplasm. During syngamy, the microtubule matrix reorganized to form a mitotic spindle on which the chromatin of both parents aligned. Finally, after nuclear and cellular cleavage were complete, the microtubule asters dispersed into the interphase daughter cells. Sham injection induced parthenogenetic activation of 76% of oocytes, marked by the formation of multiple cytoplasmic microtubular foci that later developed into a dense microtubule network surrounding the female pronucleus. The finding that a parthenote alone can produce a microtubule aster, whereas the aster invariably forms at the base of the sperm head during normal fertilization, indicates that both gametes contribute to the formation of the zygotic centrosome in the horse. Finally, 25% of sperm-injected oocytes failed to complete fertilization, mostly due to absence of oocyte activation (65%), which was often accompanied by failure of sperm decondensation. In conclusion, this study demonstrated that union of the parental genomes in horse zygotes is accompanied by a series of integrated cytoskeleton-mediated events, failure of which results in developmental arrest.

The effect of co-culture on the development of in vitro matured equine oocytes after intracytoplastic sperm injection

It is clear that, in the horse, there are many weak links in the process of in vitro embryo production; an optimal culture system for equine oocytes does not exist, and related data are conflicting. Therefore, the ability of 3 different culture systems to support embryonic development of ICSI horse oocytes was examined. Oocytes (n = 261) suitable for culture were collected from 55 ovaries and divided, according to cumulus morphology, into 2 categories: expanded cumulus and compacted cumulus. Oocytes with expanded and compacted cumulus were cultured for in vitro maturation in TCM 199 + 10% FCS + 0.1 iu/ml FSH/LH at 38.5 degrees C under 5% CO2 in air for 24 and 40 h, respectively. Oocytes (n = 149) reached metaphase II and were subjected to ICSI with frozen semen and then incubated in 3 different culture systems: A) TCM 199 + 10% FCS alone or B) on granulosa cell monolayer, C) SOF + MEM amino acids + 0.8% BSA. Cultural conditions were 39 degrees C and 5% CO2 in air for A and B, while a gas mixture (5% CO2, 5% O2, 90% N2) was used for C. The fertilisation rate was 32%. The cleavage rate in Group A was 74.4% (32/43); 18 embryos reached 2-6 cell stage, eight 8-16 cell, four 16-32 cell and two >32 cell. In Group B, the cleavage rate was 73.5% (36/49) with better results in embryonic development; 14 reached 2-6 cell stage, eighteen 8-16 cell, twelve 16-32 cell and five >32 cell. In Group C, the cleavage rate was significantly lower then in A and B; only 15 of 47 ICSI oocytes (39.1%) cleaved with maximum development to 2-6 cell stage. The remaining oocytes (68.1%) degenerated during culture. In conclusion, IVM horse oocytes can be fertilised in vitro with high efficiency with ICSI and co-culture systems showed to be superior in supporting in vitro embryo culture compared to simple ones. The identification of the factors beneficial to in vitro embryo development provided by the somatic cells could be important to optimise the embryo culture systems for equine embryos.

Increasing culture time from 48 to 96 or 144 hours increases the proportions of equine cumulus oocyte complexes with negative or fragmented nucleus morphology

The objective was to test the hypothesis that increasing equine oocyte culture time from 48 to 96 or 144 h increases nucleus maturation of equine oocytes. The hypothesis was not supported because condensed chromatin-stage oocytes decreased (P<0.01) from 33/126 (26.2%) at 48 h or 34/95 (35.8%) at 96 h to 11/117 (9.4%) at 144 h, and polar body-stage oocytes decreased (P<0.01) from 65/126 (51.6%) at 48 h to 25/95 (26.3%) at 96 h and (P<0.01) to 1/117 (0.9%) at 144 h. Negative (non-staining) oocytes increased (P<0.01) from 16/126 (12.7%) at 48 h or 15/95 (15.8%) at 96 h to 39/117 (33.3%) at 144 h. Fragmented oocytes (with and without fluorescent areas) increased (P<0.01) from 4/126 (3.2%) at 48 h to 20/95 (21.1%) at 96 h and increased again to 60/117 (51.3%) at 144 h. When fragmented oocytes having 1 fluorescent area were defined as condensed chromatin-stage and fragmented oocytes having 2 fluorescent areas were defined as polar body-stage, condensed chromatin-stage oocytes increased (P < 0.05) from 34/126 (27.0%) at 48 h to 38/95 (40.0%) at 96 h, but decreased (P<0.05) to 19/117 (16.2%) at 144 h. Polar body-stage oocytes decreased (P<0.01) from 66/126 (52.4%) at 48 h to 27/95 (28.4%) at 96 h and decreased again to 7/117 (6.0%) at 144 h. Fragmented oocytes without any fluorescent areas increased (P<0.01) from 2/126 (1.6%) at 48 h to 14/95 (14.7%) at 96 h and increased again to 46/117 (39.3%) at 144 h. Under the conditions of this experiment, the hypothesis that increasing the culture time of equine oocytes from 48 to 96 or 144 h would increase oocyte maturation was not supported. We propose that the culture system needs to be improved before this hypothesis can be adequately tested, because prolonged culture significantly increased the proportions of negative and fragmented equine oocytes.

Possible significance of cells within intraluminal collagen masses in equine oviducts

In addition to the unique feature of retention of unfertilized ova, the oviducts of mares frequently contain large intraluminal masses with a fibrillar component and some cells. The aim of this study was to identify the cells and examine their relationship to the extracellular components of these masses. Intraluminal masses were examined both in situ and flushed from the oviducts. The nature of the contained cells and their relationship to the fibrils were examined by light microscopy and by transmission and scanning electron microscopy. In some mares the large masses distended the oviduct, but neither loss of the oviductal epithelium nor damage to this epithelium was seen. Electron microscopy verified that the principal cellular component was fibroblasts, and that the fibrils were type I collagen. Collagen masses collected shortly after ovulation frequently contained viable fibroblasts with collagen fibrils associated with their cell surfaces and with surface clefts. Although such collagen masses were present in pregnant and nonpregnant mares, masses with viable fibroblasts were chronologically associated with recent ovulation. It was concluded that connective tissue drawn into the oviduct at ovulation is retained, and collagen synthesis continues at least for a few days. Although the fibroblasts eventually disintegrate, the collagen remains and may in some cases aggregate within the oviductal lumen to the extent that oviductal transport and embryonic viability could be affected.

Early embryonic development and evaluation of equine embryo viability

Tremendous progress has been made in the development of assisted reproductive techniques that may enhance the reproductive efficiency of the horse. However, techniques that involve the manipulation of oocytes and/or embryos may themselves be detrimental to embryo viability and subsequent development. Therefore, an objective method of assessing viability of embryos before and/or after oocyte/embryo manipulation is desirable. At this time, morphologic evaluation is the most widely used method of determining the viability of equine embryos. Although morphologic assessment of embryo quality will not always accurately predict the survival of individual embryos, it is very useful for predicting the survival of groups of embryos. Other tests that have been used to evaluate equine embryo viability include (1) development during culture in vitro; (2) quantitating metabolism of the fluorescent substrate fluorescein diacetate; (3) quantitating uptake of the fluorescent stain DAPI; and (4) quantitating embryo metabolism. Although these tests offer potential advantages over morphologic assessment alone, their current limitations have prevented their routine use for embryo evaluation. It is likely that as improvements are made in these evaluation methods, they may offer advantages for use alone or in combination to more accurately assess the viability of equine embryos.

Recovery rate and quality of embryos from mares inseminated after ovulation

The aim of this study was to evaluate the quality of embryos and their recovery rate from mares inseminated at different intervals after ovulation. Finnhorse and warmblood mares were inseminated with fresh semen 8 to 16 h, 16 to 24 h, or 24 to 32 h after ovulation. Control mares were inseminated before ovulation. Sixty-seven embryo flushings were performed between Days 7 and 9 after ovulation/insemination. Thirteen mares were not flushed, but their uteri were scanned for pregnancy on Days 14 to 16. Embryo recovery rates decreased as time from ovulation to insemination increased, although embryo quality remained normal as evaluated by morphological criteria and mitotic index. However, postovulatory insemination in this trial appeared to delay embryo development, since the embryos recovered from mares inseminated after ovulation were appreciably smaller and at an earlier stage of development than control embryos recovered from mares inseminated prior to ovulation. Part of this delay in embryo development in the postovulation group could be due to the time needed for sperm capacitation. In addition, as the time from ovulation to insemination increased, embryo development might have been further delayed by defects in the aging oocyte.

Structural and endocrine aspects of equine oocyte maturation in vivo

The objectives were to describe the ultrastructure of equine oocytes aspirated from small and preovulatory follicles, and to relate the ultrastructural features to follicle size and follicular fluid steroid concentrations. Mares were examined every second day by transrectal ultrasonography, and follicles measuring > 30 mm were aspirated (in vivo) using a 20-cm-long 12-gauge needle through the flank. Following slaughter, both large and small follicles were aspirated (in vitro) from six mares. The oocytes were isolated under a stereomicroscope and processed for transmission electron microscopy, and the follicular fluid was assayed for progesterone (P4) amd estradiol-17 beta (E2). A total of 29 oocytes (32% recovery rate) were aspirated in vivo, and 15 oocytes were recovered in vitro. According to the stage of nuclear maturation, the oocytes could be divided into the following six categories: 1) the central oocyte nucleus (CON) stage, 2) the peripheral spherical oocyte nucleus (PON-I) stage, 3) the peripheral flattened oocyte nucleus (PON-II) stage, 4) the oocyte nucleus breakdown (ONBD) stage, 5) the metaphase I (M-I) stage, and 6) the metaphase II (M-II) stage. The maturation of the preovulatory follicle was reflected by alterations in the follicular fluid concentrations of steroid hormones. E2 was high in all preovulatory follicles, whereas P4 concentration exhibited a 10-fold increase during follicle maturation, particularly associated with the progression from M-I- to M-II-stage oocytes. The nuclear oocyte maturation included flattening of the spherical oocyte nucleus, followed by increasing undulation of the nuclear envelope, formation of the metaphase plate of the first meiotic division, and, finally, the extrusion of the first polar body and the subsequent formation of the metaphase plate of the second meiotic division. The cytoplasmic oocyte maturation changes comprised breakdown of the intermediate junctions between the cumulus cell projections and the oolemma, enlargement of the perivitelline space, the formation and arrangement of a large number of cortical granules immediately beneath the oolemma, the rearrangement of mitochondria from a predominantly peripheral distribution to a more central or semilunar domain, and the rearrangement of membrane-bound vesicles and lipid droplets from an even distribution to an often semilunar domain, giving the ooplasm a polarized appearance. It is concluded that the final equine oocyte maturation includes a series of well-defined nuclear and cytoplasmic changes that are paralleled by an increase in P4 concentration in the follicular fluid, whereas E2 concentration remains constantly high.

Fine structure of equine oocytes matured in vitro for 15 hours

Transmission electron microscopy (TEM) was used to evaluate the fine structure of equine oocytes cultured in vitro. Oocytes obtained by follicular aspiration were cultured for either zero or 15 hr. After treatment oocytes were processed either by light microscopy (nuclear evaluation) or TEM (cytoplasmic evaluation). Those oocytes cultured for 15 hr were incubated in modified TCM 199 with 15% (v/v) mare serum (day of ovulation) at 39 +/- 0.2 degree C. Evaluation using TEM revealed that cortical granules were present in all oocytes. However, zero-time oocytes contained few cortical granules, and these were scattered throughout the cytoplasm, whereas 15 hr oocytes contained numerous cortical granules primarily found in very close proximity to the oolemma. Further ultrastructural analysis of both groups revealed organelle structure similar to that previously described for in vivo matured equine oocytes. Evaluation of nuclear maturity (lacmoid stain) showed that 15 hr of culture resulted in significant numbers of oocytes at metaphase II (8/17; 47%). These data demonstrate that oocytes cultured for 15 hr in modified TCM 199 with 15% mare serum (day of ovulation) are mature with respect to nuclear configuration and cortical granule migration and, therefore, would be appropriate candidates for in vitro fertilization.