Involvement of the eyebrow fat pad in Graves' orbitopathy

The Arched Rainbow Brow in Thyroid Eye Disease

PURPOSE

To morphologically describe and mathematically quantify a novel clinical feature of thyroid eye disease (TED).

METHODS

A retrospective study was conducted of TED patients and age-sex-matched normal controls. The arched Rainbow Brow appearance in TED patients was determined by unanimous agreement of 3 oculoplastic surgeons. Eyebrow curvature was assessed by plotting 15 points along the eyebrow in ImageJ. The fourth-degree polynomial ( y = ax4 + bx3 + cx2 + dx + e ) was fitted to each eyebrow.

RESULTS

Two hundred seventy-one eyes were analyzed (200 TED and 71 age-sex-matched normal controls). A Rainbow Brow was identified in 42% of TED patients. A unilateral Rainbow Brow was seen in 15% of patients. The fourth-degree polynomial coefficients yielded significant differences between Rainbow Brow patients and age-sex-matched normal controls for the coefficients a, b, c , and d . Similar analysis of TED patients with and without a Rainbow Brow showed differences in coefficients a and b . Age >50 years ( p = 0.009) and the presence of brow fat expansion ( p < 0.001) were associated with the presence of a Rainbow Brow. Proptosis >24 mm showed a trend toward association with the presence of a Rainbow Brow ( p = 0.057). When considering the contribution of these features in a multivariable analysis, only brow fat expansion was a significant contributing factor ( p = 0.009).

CONCLUSIONS

The Rainbow Brow is a distinct entity in TED and is likely consequent to brow fat pad expansion. Patients with a Rainbow Brow have different eyebrow curvature as compared to both normal age-sex-matched controls and TED patients without a Rainbow Brow.

Thickness of Retro- and Sub-Orbicularis Oculi Fat in Thyroid Eye Disease: Comparison With Controls and Its Influential Factors

PURPOSE

To compare the thickness of the retro- and sub-orbicularis oculi fat (ROOF and SOOF) between patients with thyroid eye disease (TED) and controls via MRI and to determine factors influencing fat thickness.

METHODS

This retrospective, comparative, case-control study included 136 patients (272 sides) with TED and 50 control patients (50 sides). The thickness of the ROOF and SOOF was measured on the quasi-sagittal plane through the optic nerve (the central plane) and 6 mm lateral and medial to the central plane at the level through the superior orbital rim and at the level just below the orbital septum in the lower eyelid, respectively.

RESULTS

The ROOF and SOOF were thickest on the lateral plane (p < 0.050; Tukey Kramer post hoc test) and were significantly thicker in patients with TED than controls on all planes (p < 0.050; Student t test). Multivariate stepwise analysis showed that age, sex, clinical activity score, Hertel exophthalmometric values, and number of enlarged extraocular muscles are significant predictors of the ROOF and SOOF thickness in patients with TED (p < 0.050).

CONCLUSIONS

Patients with TED had thicker ROOF and SOOF on all planes than controls with various factors influencing the thickness. These results may be helpful in planning rehabilitative blepharoplasty with removal of the ROOF and SOOF for correction of eyelid fullness in TED.

Anatomical Study and Clinical Observation of Retro-orbicularis Oculi Fat (ROOF)

OBJECTIVE

To study the anatomical location of retro-orbicularis oculi fat (ROOF) in the upper eyelid and to investigate how ROOF affects the appearance of the upper eyelid.

METHODS

Twenty-eight Chinese hemifacial cadaver specimens were used (14 male cadavers; age range 52-82 years). In 28 hemifaces, the eyelids were dissected from the superficial to deep layers, and the appearance, location, extent, and surrounding tissue of ROOF were observed. Additionally, we observed the relationship between the upper eyelid morphology and ROOF of the upper eyelid in surgical patients who were treated in the plastic surgery department of Tongji Hospital affiliated with Huazhong University of Science and Technology in 2018.

RESULTS

ROOF is a type of fascia adipose tissue that is located in a fat compartment between the muscles (the orbicularis oculi and frontalis muscles) and the orbital septum/frontalis fascia. In patients with hypertrophic ROOF, the upper eyelid appears as a heavy eyelid and as a drooping eyelid. And in patients with atrophic ROOF, the upper eyelid appears as a sunken eyelid.

CONCLUSION

ROOF is located in the fat compartment between the orbicularis muscle and the orbital septum/frontalis fascia. ROOF covers the entire upper eyelid and appears thinner medially and thicker laterally. It is continuous with the fat under the frontalis muscle and affects the appearance of the upper eyelid. It represents an important factor in upper eyelid surgery.

NO LEVEL ASSIGNED

This journal requires that authors assign a level of evidence to each article. For a full description of these Evidence-Based Medicine ratings, please refer to the Table of Contents or the online Instructions to Authors www.springer.com/00266.

Simultaneous Aesthetic Eyelid Surgery and Orbital Decompression for Rehabilitation of Thyroid Eye Disease: The One-Stage Approach

BACKGROUND

Aesthetic rehabilitation of thyroid orbitopathy includes orbital decompression, correction of eyelid retraction, and aesthetic blepharoplasty, performed traditionally in separate stages.

OBJECTIVES

To report the results of orbital decompression surgery associated with aesthetic eyelid surgery in one stage for aesthetic rehabilitation of patients affected by thyroid eye disease.

METHODS

Retrospective, multicentric study including 40 consecutive patients, who underwent orbital decompression surgery associated with aesthetic eyelid surgery in two centers: Genova (group 1) + Buenos Aires (group 2). Surgical techniques are described in detail.

RESULTS

Mean patient age in the study group was 41.2, 85% of the patients were female, and minimum follow-up time was 12 months, with average follow up of 27 months. All patients underwent orbital decompression; at the same time, 26 patients (65%) underwent bilateral upper blepharoplasty and 32 patients (80%) underwent transconjunctival lower blepharoplasty. Associated upper eyelid procedures included 23 patients (58%) undergoing upper eyelid retraction repair, 9 patients (23%) undergoing associated inferior retractor recession, and 12 patients (30%) closed transcanthal lateral canthopexy. Seven patients (17%) needed strabismus surgery for the treatment of new-onset diplopia and none required further revision eyelid surgery.

CONCLUSIONS

Shorr and Seiff suggested 4 stages of surgical rehabilitation: (1) orbital decompression; (2) eye muscle surgery; (3) correction of eyelid retraction; and (4) removal of excess fat and skin. This is the first study to suggest single-stage aesthetic rehabilitation consisting of combined orbital decompression and aesthetic eyelid surgery. This approach has high patient satisfaction and significant reduction in direct and indirect healthcare costs.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE 4

Management of graves myopathy: Orbital imaging in thyroid-related orbitopathy

A broad understanding of the different imaging modalities used to assess the physiologic changes seen in Graves' orbitopathy complement clinical examination. Subtle applications of radiographic imaging techniques allow for a better understanding of the overall physiology of the orbit, quantify progression of disease, and differentiate it from orbital diseases with overlapping features. A nuanced approach to interpreting imaging features may allow us to delineate inactive from active thyroid eye disease, and advances within this field may arm clinicians with the ability to better predict and prevent dysthyroid optic neuropathy.

Complications and outcomes of grafting of posterior orbital fat into the lower lid-cheek junction during orbital decompression

PURPOSE

To report the complications of grafting of excised posterior orbital fat into the lower lid-cheek junction at the time of orbital decompression surgery.

METHODS

Retrospective review of consecutive patients undergoing orbital decompression combined with grafting of posterior orbital fat to the pre-malar and lateral canthal area (FG). A second group of consecutive patients undergoing orbital decompression but no orbital fat grafting (NoFG) were also studied as a form of comparative control. Standard patient data, including age, sex, visual acuity, degree of proptosis, operative details, diplopia or any other complications was collected. Independent assessment of pre- and post-operative photographs graded the lower lid-cheek junction.

RESULTS

Thirty-four orbits of 29 patients, of which 21 orbits underwent orbital decompression with orbital fat grafting (FG). There were no intraoperative complications, postoperative infections, or visual loss. Complications relating to fat grafting included prolonged swelling in 3 (17%) patients at 3 months, in 1 case lasting 6 months, lower lid lumps in 3 (17%), and fat seepage in 1 (6%). The FG group achieved a greater improvement in the appearance of the lower-lid-cheek junction at 12 months in comparison to NoFG. Mean grade improvement 1.24 ± 1.09 vs 0 ± 0.82 (p = 0.025). Median follow-up was 20 months (range 6-30 months).

CONCLUSION

Grafting of excised orbital fat during orbital decompression can improve the appearance of the lower lid-cheek junction in patients being treated for thyroid orbitopathy. However, 24% of patients will experience swelling and/or lumpiness requiring several months to settle or further fat excision.

Radiographic evidence of prominent retro and suborbicularis oculi fat in thyroid-associated orbitopathy

PURPOSE

To compare the radiological differences in retro-orbicularis oculi fat (ROOF) and suborbiculars oculi fat (SOOF) among patients with thyroid-associated orbitopathy (TAO) and normal subjects using computed tomography (CT).

METHODS

A retrospective analysis of orbital CTs was performed in 39 consecutive patients, who were imaged between October 2005 and June 2009. Bilateral orbital CTs of 16 patients with a final report significant for thyroid orbitopathy and 23 normal subjects were evaluated. All of the CTs consisted of 0.75 mm thick axial slices with 1.5 mm coronal reconstructions. Using the axial soft tissue windows, the ROOF and SOOF tissues were identified. The maximum ROOF thickness was measured perpendicular to the frontal bone, immediately superior to the supraorbital rim. Similarly, the maximum SOOF thickness was measured perpendicular to the zygomatic bone, immediately inferolateral to the infraorbital rim. The radiologist was blinded to the CT reports while conducting the measurements. Multivariable analysis of the two groups was then performed for comparison.

RESULTS

Seventy-eight ROOF and SOOF measurements were obtained from 16 TAO patients with and 23 patients without TAO. The female-to-male ratio was 6:1 in the TAO group and only 3:2 among the normal subjects. The mean axial ROOF thicknesses was 3.8 ± 1.9 for TAO patients and 2.8 ± 1.0 mm in patients without TAO, while the SOOF thickness was 4.4 ± 1.0 and 3.4 ± 1.0 mm in the 2 groups, respectively. To account for bilateral measurements, the mixed model analysis was used. After controlling for age, gender, and ethnicity, the mean TAO ROOF and SOOF thicknesses were 1.0 mm (p = 0.04) and 0.9 mm (p < 0.01) greater than the control group, respectively.

CONCLUSION

Retro-orbicularis oculi fat (ROOF) and suborbicularis oculi fat (SOOF) hypertrophy are two additional radiologic CT measurements that may be valuable in establishing the diagnosis of thyroid-associated orbitopathy.

High-resolution ultrasound as an effective and practical tool to analyze eyebrow profile expansion in thyroid-associated periorbitopathy

PURPOSE

Clinical, radiographic, and molecular studies have shown that patients with thyroid-associated orbitopathy exhibit volumetric expansion of eyebrow tissues. This clinicopathologic entity has been termed thyroid-associated periorbitopathy. The goal of this study was to determine whether high-resolution ultrasonography could be used to reliably quantify thyroid-associated periorbitopathy.

METHODS

Institutional review board approval was obtained. The internal case-control study consisted of 12 subjects with unilateral-asymmetric thyroid-associated orbitopathy. High-resolution ultrasonography using a 15-MHz probe (Logiq p6) was performed by a single operator. Measurements were obtained 0.5 cm cephalad to the superior orbital rim at the midpupillary sagittal level. For each subject and tissue layer thickness (total tissue, dermis fat, retro-orbicularis oculi fat), the measured values on the less affected side were subtracted from those on the more severely diseased side. Summary statistics were used to analyze results.

RESULTS

High-resolution ultrasonography effectively demonstrated asymmetric expansion of total eyebrow tissue (p < 0.0001) and retro-orbicularis oculi fat (p = 0.0003). No significant difference in dermis fat thickness was found between the 2 sides (p = 0.2). Hertel exophthalmometry measurements were statistically different between the 2 sides (p = 0.002).

CONCLUSIONS

This study demonstrates that high-resolution ultrasonography independently confirms previously published studies of retro-orbicularis oculi fat expansion in patients with thyroid-associated orbitopathy. Compared with CT, MRI, and tissue biopsy, high-resolution ultrasonography is a more practical and cost-effective way to quantify and track thyroid-associated periorbitopathy over time. With its potential for real-time tissue assessment, high-resolution ultrasonography may be best suited for future studies of the dynamic relationship between globe and periorbital structures.

Histopathology of brow fat in thyroid-associated orbitopathy

PURPOSE

We propose that brow enlargement seen in patients with thyroid-associated orbitopathy (TAO) occurs secondary to the autoimmune process in Graves disease and that the changes in brow fat are histologically identical to those seen in orbital fat.

METHODS

With informed consent, brow and orbital fat was obtained from patients with TAO and from patients with no significant past medical history undergoing orbital decompression, blepharoplasty, and/or brow fat removal. Histologic examination was performed on the orbital and brow fat.

RESULTS

Fat histologies obtained from patients with TAO and those without known systemic disease were compared. Specimens from patients with TAO showed an increase of fibrosis and fibrous septae. Furthermore, certain biologic markers, including insulin-like growth factor 1 receptor β (IGF-1Rβ) and thyroid-stimulating hormone receptor (TSHR), were increased in the fat obtained from patients with TAO. This was identical in both the brow and the orbital fat. Fat from patients with no significant past medical history showed normal fat histology, absence of fibrous septae, and decreased marker expression.

CONCLUSION

Graves disease is a systemic autoimmune disease that affects patients in a variety of ways. In addition to the orbital changes seen in these patients, we have observed an increase in the brow fat compartment. We are intrigued to find that the histologic changes are identical in both the orbital and the brow fat of patients with TAO. The increased IGF-1Rβ and TSHR expression in both the brow and the orbital fat further support their role as putative markers in patients with Graves disease.

Stability of eyelid height after graded anterior-approach lid lowering for dysthyroid upper lid retraction

OBJECTIVE

To investigate the outcome of a modified anterior approach surgical procedure for the correction of primary upper eyelid retraction in thyroid eye disease.

METHODS

A retrospective review of 52 consecutive cases (in 32 patients) of anterior-approach graded upper lid lowering for the treatment of primary eyelid retraction, carried out at Moorfields Eye Hospital between 2006-2009 was conducted. Measurements of upper margin-reflex distance (MRD), upper lid skin crease height and skin fold height were taken from clinical records and photographs. A comparison between pre-operative and both early and late post-operative measurements was conducted, with a maximal follow-up of 12 months. Surgery was considered successful when all of the following criteria were met; an upper lid margin covering 0.5-1.5 mm of the superior cornea in the 12 o'clock position, smooth eyelid contour, skin crease height within 6-10 mm or upper lid skin fold within 2-5 mm of the lid margin, symmetry of lid position (difference in MRD of < 1 mm between both eyes) and patient satisfaction.

RESULTS

A successful outcome was achieved in 86.5% (45/52) of lids with a single procedure. For the whole group, the mean MRD was 7.0 mm pre-operatively and 3.6 mm at 1 month after surgery. The corresponding values from photographic estimates were 6.5 mm and 3.6 mm, respectively. These values remained stable over the maximum follow-up period of 12 months. Under-correction occurred in 6/52 (11.5%) lids, one of which had persistent lateral flare, whereas over-correction occurred in 1/52 (2%).

CONCLUSIONS

The described surgical approach produces reasonably predictable and stable outcome for upper eyelid lowering in patients with thyroid eye disease.

Prominent Premalar and Cheek Swelling: A Sign of Thyroid-associated Orbitopathy

PURPOSE

To describe prominent premalar and cheek swelling as a previously undescribed clinical feature of thyroid-associated orbitopathy (TAO).

DESIGN

Retrospective interventional case series.

METHODS

A retrospective case review of patients with prominent premalar and/or cheek swelling and TAO was undertaken. All patients who presented from March 2002 to February 2005 with complaints of premalar and/or cheek swelling in TAO were analyzed.

RESULTS

Six female patients between the ages of 28 and 66 years (average, 44.2 years) who had complaints of prominent premalar and/or cheek swelling and TAO were included in the study, among 326 new patients with TAO (incidence: 1.84%). Five of the 6 patients had Graves hyperthyroidism. One initially had Hashimoto thyroiditis, which converted to Graves hyperthyroidism. In all cases, TAO preceded the thyroid disease or developed simultaneously (average time from TAO to thyroid disease was 3.0 months). No patient had received corticosteroids before premalar and/or cheek swelling. The premalar and/or cheek swelling was bilateral in all cases, but 2 of 6 were asymmetric. No diurnal fluctuation or tenderness in premalar and/or cheek swelling was noted. All improved incompletely over several months. Brow, eyelid swelling, and orbital-fat hypertrophy on radiologic examination was coincidentally noted in 5 of 6 cases. Pretibial myxedema was noted in one case. One case was associated with another autoimmune disease (rheumatoid arthritis).

CONCLUSIONS

Prominent premalar and cheek swelling should be considered among the clinical features of TAO. The true incidence will become apparent as we question and examine patients more carefully regarding this entity and as we review premorbid photographs.

Thyroid-associated orbitopathy: a clinicopathologic and therapeutic review

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

To review the literature related to thyroid-associated orbitopathy and to emphasize recent developments in its pathophysiology, diagnosis, and therapy. Current therapeutic trends and controversies are discussed.

RECENT FINDINGS

Expression of thyroid stimulating hormone receptor is highest in the fat and connective tissue of patients with thyroid-associated orbitopathy, where fibroblasts have the potential for adipogenesis. Electrophysiology can now detect subclinical optic neuropathy, and somatostatin-receptor scintigraphy can help justify immunomodulation. Other than steroids, radiotherapy can control inflammation, but its use is controversial. Current trends in orbital decompression are to camouflage incisions and to limit strabismus with balanced decompression, deep lateral wall techniques, fat removal, and onlay implants. Proptosis reductions of 0.9 to 12.5mm are possible by the use of various algorithms. Before or after decompression, botulinum toxin can correct strabismus, intraocular pressure elevation, and retraction. The latter is now also treated with full-thickness blepharotomy.

SUMMARY

As knowledge of the pathophysiology of thyroid-associated orbitopathy grows, there is a slow movement from nonspecific and invasive measures to more directed treatments causing less morbidity.