Distortion generated by the ear: its emergence and evolution during development

Masking of low-frequency signals by high-frequency, high-level narrow bands of noise

Low-frequency masking by intense high-frequency noise bands, referred to as remote masking (RM), was the first evidence to challenge energy-detection models of signal detection. Its underlying mechanisms remain unknown. RM was measured in five normal-hearing young-adults at 250, 350, 500, and 700 Hz using equal-power, spectrally matched random-phase noise (RPN) and low-noise noise (LNN) narrowband maskers. RM was also measured using equal-power, two-tone complex (TC2) and eight-tone complex (TC8). Maskers were centered at 3000 Hz with one or two equivalent rectangular bandwidths (ERBs). Masker levels varied from 80 to 95 dB sound pressure level in 5 dB steps. LNN produced negligible masking for all conditions. An increase in bandwidth in RPN yielded greater masking over a wider frequency region. Masking for TC2 was limited to 350 and 700 Hz for one ERB but shifted to only 700 Hz for two ERBs. A spread of masking to 500 and 700 Hz was observed for TC8 when the bandwidth was increased from one to two ERBs. Results suggest that high-frequency noise bands at high levels could generate significant low-frequency masking. It is possible that listeners experience significant RM due to the amplification of various competing noises that might have significant implications for speech perception in noise.

Comparing the optimal signal conditions for recording cubic and quadratic distortion product otoacoustic emissions

Odd- and even-order distortion products (DPs), evoked by two primary tones (f(1),f(2),f(1)<f(2)), represent different aspects of cochlear nonlinearity. The cubic and quadratic difference tones (CDT 2f(1)-f(2) and QDT f(2)-f(1)) are prominent representatives of the odd and even DPs. Distortion product otoacoustic emissions (DPOAEs) were measured within a primary level (L(1),L(2)) space over a wide range of f(2)f(1) ratios to compare the optimal signal conditions for these DPs. For CDT, the primary level difference decreased as L(1) increased with a rate proportional to the f(2)f(1) ratio. Moreover, the optimal ratio increased with L(1). A set of two formulas is proposed to describe the optimal signal conditions. However, for a given level of a primary, increasing the other tone level could maximize the QDT amplitude. The frequency ratio at the maximal QDT was about 1.3 and quite constant across different primary levels. A notch was found in the QDT amplitude at the f(2)f(1) ratio of about 1.22-1.25. These opposite behaviors suggest that the optimal recording conditions are different for CDT and QDT due to the different aspects in the cochlear nonlinearity. Optimizing the DPOAE recordings could improve the reliability in clinical or research practices.

The influence of thyroid hormone deficiency on the development of cochlear nonlinearities

It is well known that failure to treat severe congenital hypothyroidism leads to profound auditory disability, and it has been suggested that an intracochlear defect, or defects, associated with the condition diminishes the efficacy of an active, physiologically vulnerable nonlinear transduction process commonly referred to as cochlear amplification. We address this question directly by tracking the development of threshold-frequency (tuning) curves and two-tone suppression in hypothyroid, Tshr mutant mice born to hypothyroid dams and comparing those findings with findings observed in euthyroid mice. Like sharp tuning, two-tone suppression is a product of transduction nonlinearity and is a useful indicator of the functional status of cochlear amplification. In contrast to euthyroid mice that acquire sharp tuning, normal two-tone suppression, and adultlike sensitivity by the end of the third postnatal week, as shown in earlier studies, hypothyroid mice remained grossly insensitive to sound throughout life. In addition, tuning was generally broad in hypothyroid mice, tuning curve "tips" were frequently missing, and two-tone suppression was rarely observed. However, unlike tip thresholds, tuning curve "tail" thresholds, a feature that reflects the functional status of passive elements of transduction, acquired normal values over a roughly 2-month postnatal time period. These observations collectively suggest that active transduction micromechanics, at least in the frequency region studied here, are profoundly affected by thyroid hormone and support speculation that abnormal outer hair cell function may be the cause of the primary, enduring peripheral auditory defect associated with profound, congenital hypothyroidism in the Tshr mutant mouse.

Development of Cochlear Amplification, Frequency Tuning, and Two-Tone Suppression in the Mouse

It is generally believed that the micromechanics of active cochlear transduction mature later than passive elements among altricial mammals. One consequence of this developmental order is the loss of transduction linearity, because an active, physiologically vulnerable process is superimposed on the passive elements of transduction. A triad of sensory advantage is gained as a consequence of acquiring active mechanics; sensitivity and frequency selectivity (frequency tuning) are enhanced and dynamic operating range increases. Evidence supporting this view is provided in this study by tracking the development of tuning curves in BALB/c mice. Active transduction, commonly known as cochlear amplification, enhances sensitivity in a narrow frequency band associated with the “tip” of the tuning curve. Passive aspects of transduction were assessed by considering the thresholds of responses elicited from the tuning curve “tail,” a frequency region that lies below the active transduction zone. The magnitude of cochlear amplification was considered by computing tuning curve tip-to-tail ratios, a commonly used index of active transduction gain. Tuning curve tip thresholds, frequency selectivity and tip-to-tail ratios, all indices of the functional status of active biomechanics, matured between 2 and 7 days after tail thresholds achieved adultlike values. Additionally, two-tone suppression, another product of active cochlear transduction, was first observed in association with the earliest appearance of tuning curve tips and matured along an equivalent time course. These findings support a traditional view of development in which the maturation of passive transduction precedes the maturation of active mechanics in the most sensitive region of the mouse cochlea.

Frequency- and level-dependent changes in auditory brainstem responses (ABRS) in developing mice

The development of the auditory brainstem response was studied to quantitatively assess its dependence on stimulus frequency and level. Responses were not observed to stimuli > or =16 kHz on P12, however, the full range of responsive frequencies included in the study was observed by P14. Response thresholds were high on P12, exceeding 100 dB SPL for all stimuli tested. The rate of threshold development increased progressively for stimulus frequencies between -2 and 10 kHz, with the most rapid changes occurring at frequencies >10 kHz. Adultlike thresholds were observed by P18. Response latencies and interpeak intervals matured rapidly over the course of the second and third postnatal weeks and did not achieve adultlike characteristics until after P18. Latencies of higher-order peaks were progressively and sequentially delayed relative to wave I. Wave I amplitudes developed nonmonotonically, growing during the first 24 days and stabilizing at adult values by approximately P36. Slopes of wave I amplitude-and latency-level curves were significantly steeper than those of adults during the neonatal period and the outcome of input-output analyses, as well as frequency-specific maturational profiles, support developmental models in which function initially matures in the mid-frequency range and proceeds, simultaneously, in both apical and basal directions.

Loss and recovery of sound-evoked otoacoustic emissions in young chicks following acoustic trauma

Young and adult chickens exhibit substantial inner-ear damage and post-exposure deterioration in cochlear nerve activity following exposure to intense sound. Both the structural and functional losses largely recover in both age groups within 2-4 weeks after exposure. However, some aspects of acoustic trauma differ between the young and adult chicken ear. Overstimulation in the young chick causes considerable post-exposure loss and then recovery of the steady-state endocochlear potential, while in the adult animal there is little post-exposure effect on this potential. Moreover, in adults there is post-exposure loss but little recovery in the distortion product otoacoustic emission (DPOAE). The present study explores the possibility of an age difference in the effects of overstimulation on the DPOAE by examining these emissions in young chicks following exposure to an intense pure tone. Chicks exposed to intense sound were formed into groups at 0 and 12 days of recovery, and these were complemented by two additional groups of age-matched controls. The cubic difference tone emission (the 2f(1)-f(2) DPOAE component) was measured at 9 levels for 13 frequencies in all groups. Shortly after the exposure, the DPOAE reliably declined with the maximum loss at or above the exposure tone frequency. The exposed chicks examined 12 days after exposure showed complete recovery of the DPOAE. It would appear that 12 days of recovery sufficiently repaired inner ear damage to completely restore DPOAE production. This result is different from that in adult chicken and may be related to the greater severity of acoustic damage in the adult ear, a reduced susceptibility of the young ear to acoustic trauma, or the ability of the young animal to more successfully repair the inner ear.

Evaluation of distortion products produced by the human auditory system

During the simultaneous monaural presentation of two primary tones, distortion products can be measured acoustically in the ear canal (DPOAEs) and electrically as auditory evoked potentials (DPAEPs). The purpose of this investigation was to elucidate the sources of nonlinearity within the human auditory system responsible for generating quadratic (QDT) and cubic (CDT) difference tones. Measurements of DPOAEs and DPAEPs were obtained from 24 normal-hearing adults (12 male) in conditions with and without presentation of a 60 dB SPL contralateral noise. The effects of primary-tone signal duration and mode of presentation on measurements of DPAEPs were also examined. Results indicated that overall, both acoustic and electric distortion products were suppressed during presentation of a contralateral noise. Increases in the duration of the primary tones caused increases in DPAEP amplitudes. A greater proportion of individuals exhibited DPAEPs with monotic compared to dichotic presentation of the primary tones. The findings of the investigation supported the conjecture that a cochlear nonlinearity produced CDT acoustic and electric distortion products. Evidence concerning the origin of the QDT DPAEP was inconclusive, and contributions from both cochlear and neural nonlinear sources could not be ruled out.

Paradoxical relationship between frequency selectivity and threshold sensitivity during auditory-nerve fiber development

The acquisition of adult-like frequency selectivity is generally assumed to be the tightly coupled to improvements in threshold sensitivity during cochlear development. In this study, frequency versus threshold (tuning) curves obtained from 1108 auditory-nerve fibers were used to investigate the relationship between tuning and threshold at characteristic frequency (CF) during postnatal development in kittens. At the earliest ages included in this study, sharpness was within the adult range, but thresholds were significantly higher than adult values. Tuning and thresholds improved along different exponential time courses that varied with CF. For units with CFs below 1 kHz, tuning curve slopes below CF matured earliest, followed by CF threshold, and then by slopes above CF. In contrast, for CFs above 1 kHz, the high-frequency slopes matured first, followed by threshold and then by slope below CF. One interpretation of these results is that tuning and thresholds are not tightly coupled in immature animals. Paradoxically, however, high-frequency slopes were correlated with threshold for individual units at all ages, suggesting that the relationship between tuning and threshold is maintained during development. This contradiction can be resolved by a developmental model that features a functional separation between cochlear nonlinearities and mechanical/electrical conversion.

Long-term effects of sectioning the olivocochlear bundle in neonatal cats

The olivocochlear bundle (OCB) was cut in neonatal cats to evaluate its role in the development of normal cochlear function. Approximately 1 year after deefferentation, acute auditory nerve fiber (ANF) recordings were made from lesioned animals, lesion shams, and normal controls. The degree of deefferentation was quantified via light microscopic evaluation of the density of OCB fascicles in the tunnel of Corti, and selected cases were analyzed via electron microscopy. In the most successful cases, the deefferentation was virtually complete. ANFs from successfully lesioned animals exhibited significant pathophysiology compared with normals and with other animals in which the surgery failed to interrupt the OCB. Thresholds at the characteristic frequency (CF), the frequency at which ANFs are most sensitive, were elevated across the CF range, with maximal effects for CFs in the 10 kHz region. Frequency threshold or tuning curves displayed reduction of tip-to-tail ratios (the difference between CF and low-frequency "tail" thresholds) and decreased sharpness of tuning. These pathological changes are generally associated with outer hair cell (OHC) damage. However, light microscopic histological analysis showed minimal hair cell loss and no significant differences between normal and deefferented groups. Spontaneous discharge rates (SRs) were lower than normal; however, those fibers with the highest SRs remained more sensitive than those with lower SRs. Findings suggest that the interaction between OC efferents and OHCs early in development may be critical for full expression of active mechanical processes.