Mechanisms of tolerance to rat heart allografts using posttransplant TLI. Changes in cytokine expression

Development of immunosuppressive myeloid cells to induce tolerance in solid organ and hematopoietic cell transplant recipients

Replacement of failed organs followed by safe withdrawal of immunosuppressive drugs has long been the goal of organ transplantation. We studied changes in the balance of T cells and myeloid cells in the blood of HLA-matched and -mismatched patients given living donor kidney transplants followed by total lymphoid irradiation, anti-thymocyte globulin conditioning, and donor hematopoietic cell transplant to induce mixed chimerism and immune tolerance. The clinical trials were based on a conditioning regimen used to establish mixed chimerism and tolerance in mice. In preclinical murine studies, there was a profound depletion of T cells and an increase in immunosuppressive polymorphonuclear (pmn) myeloid-derived suppressor cells (MDSCs) in the spleen and blood following transplant. Selective depletion of pmn MDSCs in mice abrogated mixed chimerism and tolerance. In our clinical trials, patients given an analogous tolerance conditioning regimen developed similar changes, including profound depletion of T cells and a marked increase in MDSCs in blood posttransplant. Posttransplant pmn MDSCs transiently increased expression of lectin-type oxidized LDL receptor-1, a marker of immunosuppression, and production of the T-cell inhibitor arginase-1. These posttransplant pmn MDSCs suppressed the activation, proliferation, and inflammatory cytokine secretion of autologous T-cell receptor microbead-stimulated pretransplant T cells when cocultured in vitro. In conclusion, we elucidated changes in receptors and function of immunosuppressive myeloid cells in patients enrolled in the tolerance protocol that were nearly identical to those of MDSCs required for tolerance in mice. These trials were registered at www.clinicaltrials.gov as #NCT00319657 and #NCT01165762.

Combined kidney and hematopoeitic cell transplantation to induce mixed chimerism and tolerance

Based on preclinical studies, combined kidney and hematopoietic cell transplantation was performed on fully HLA matched and haplotype matched patients at the Stanford University Medical Center. The object of the studies was to induce mixed chimerism, immune tolerance, and complete immunosuppressive drug withdrawal. Tolerance, persistent mixed chimerism, and complete withdrawal was achieved in the majority of fully matched patients. Persistent mixed chimerism and partial withdrawal has been achieved in the haplotype matched patients at present.

Stable mixed chimerism and tolerance to human organ transplants

Tolerance to combined kidney and hematopoietic cell transplant has been achieved in humans after establishment of mixed chimerism allowing for the withdrawal of immunosuppressive drugs. The seminal contributions of Ray Owen provided the scientific basis for the human protocol.

Translational studies in hematopoietic cell transplantation: treatment of hematologic malignancies as a stepping stone to tolerance induction

Allogeneic hematopoietic cell transplantation (HCT) has most commonly been used to treat hematologic malignancies, where it is often the only potentially curative option available. The success of HCT has been limited by transplant-associated toxicities related to the conditioning regimens used and to the common immunologic consequence of donor T cell recognition of recipient alloantigens, graft-vs-host disease (GVHD). The frequency and severity of GVHD observed when extensive HLA barriers are transgressed has essentially precluded the routine use of extensively HLA-mismatched HCT. Allogeneic HCT also has potential as an approach to organ allograft tolerance induction, but this potential has not been previously realized because of the toxicity associated with traditional conditioning. In this paper we review two approaches to HCT involving reduced intensity conditioning regimens that have been associated with improvements in safety in patients with hematologic malignancies, even in the HLA-mismatched transplant setting. These strategies have been applied in the first successful pilot studies for the induction of organ allograft tolerance in humans. Thus, we summarize an example of vertical translational research between animal models and humans and horizontal translation between two separate goals that culminated in the use of HCT to achieve allograft tolerance in humans.

Nonmyeloablative conditioning with total lymphoid irradiation and antithymocyte globulin: an update

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

The immune modulatory effects of total lymphoid irradiation (TLI) for graft-versus-host disease (GVHD) protection and transplantation tolerance following allogeneic bone marrow and organ transplantation have been studied for years in animal models. In preclinical models nonmyeloablative TLI conditioning alters residual host T cell subsets to favor regulatory natural killer T cells that suppress GVHD and prevent organ allograft rejection. These preclinical models have been recently adapted to human transplantation.

RECENT FINDINGS

Patients receiving allogeneic hematopoietic cell transplantation for hematological malignancies conditioned with TLI and depletive T cell antibodies showed sustained donor chimerism, a reduced incidence of acute GVHD yet retained graft antitumor activity. As in the preclinical models, nonmyeloablative TLI conditioning significantly altered residual host T cell subsets favoring natural killer T cells, and the low incidence of GVHD was associated with increased IL-4 secretion by chimeric donor T cells. The TLI regimen used in cancer patients was modified to determine conditions for stable mixed chimerism and tolerance induction following combined hematopoietic cell and kidney transplantation.

SUMMARY

This review summarizes the evolution of the preclinical TLI protocols and their recent translation to clinical trials, and discusses the mechanisms involved in protection from GVHD and the induction of tolerance following mixed chimerism.

Liver allografts are toleragenic in rats conditioned with posttransplant total lymphoid irradiation

BACKGROUND

Posttransplant total lymphoid irradiation (TLI) treatment has been applied to tolerance induction protocols in heart and kidney transplantation models.

METHODS

We examined the efficacy and mechanism of posttransplant TLI treatment in the induction and maintenance of tolerance in a rat orthotopic liver transplantation model.

RESULTS

Posttransplant TLI prolonged ACI (RT1(a)) liver allograft survival in Lewis (RT1(b)) hosts, with 50% long-term engraftment without immunosuppression and without evidence of chronic rejection. Injection of donor-type liver mononuclear cells (LMCs) facilitated the prolongation of graft survival, with more than 70% of grafts in LMC recipients surviving more than 100 days without chronic rejection. Recipients with long-term liver allograft survival accepted ACI but not PVG skin grafts. In TLI-conditioned recipients with accepted grafts, apoptosis occurred predominantly in graft-infiltrating leukocytes. In contrast, there were few apoptotic leukocytes in rejecting grafts. Recipients with long-term graft acceptance (>100 days of survival) demonstrated evidence of immune deviation; mixed lymphocyte reaction to ACI stimulator cells was vigorous, but secretion of interferon-gamma and interleukin-2 was reduced. In tolerant recipients, the number of Foxp3(+) CD25(+) CD4(+) regulatory T cells was increased in the liver allograft as well as in the peripheral blood.

CONCLUSION

We conclude that posttransplant TLI induces tolerance to liver allografts via a mechanism involving apoptotic cell-deletion and immunoregulation.

Tolerance induction in clinical transplantation

Introduction of modern immunosuppressive agents has led to great success of allotransplantation in humans, and survival rates for all solid organs have been dramatically improved. However, a constant proportion of organs is lost every year due to chronic allograft rejection and immunosuppressive drug toxicity. This has led to a situation where, despite the of donor organ shortage, about one third of the patients on the kidney transplant waiting list are listed for a retransplant. The induction of donor-specific tolerance has the potential of at least partially resolving this problem, since it might prevent chronic rejection and drug toxicity at the same time. For a variety of protocols, successful tolerance induction has been demonstrated in rodent models. However, translation of such protocols to large animal models and on clinical trials has turned out to be very difficult. This review briefly describes mechanisms and barriers to transplantation tolerance, and then focuses on pre-clinical and clinical studies in non-human primates and humans. We have divided the strategies into two groups, based on the principle mechanisms of tolerance induction: the first group are protocols not using hematopoietic stem cell transplantation (HCT) as part of there regimen. They rely mainly on intensive T cell depletion (either by total body irradiation, total lymphoid irradiation or treatment with T cell-depleting agents such as anti-thymocyte globulin, anti-CD52 antibody or CD3 immunotoxin), which have been combined with costimulatory blockade, signaling blockade or donor antigen infusion. The second group are HCT-based protocols combining HCT with T cell-depleting agents and cytoreductive treatment. So far, only two protocols (one with total lymphoid irradiation and anti-thymocyte globulin, but no HCT; one with HCT, cyclophosphamide, anti-thymocyte globulin and thymic irradiation) have been translated into successful human studies. We summarize and discuss the results of these trials and suggest goals for further studies for the development tolerance protocols applicable for a broad population of allograft recipients.

Mechanisms of tolerance induced by PG490-88 in a bone marrow transplantation model

BACKGROUND

PG490-88, a semisynthetic derivative of a novel compound PG490 (triptolide) purified from a Chinese herb (Tripterygium wilfordii Hook F), is effective in prevention of murine graft-versus-host disease (GVHD).

METHODS

PG490-88 was administrated into recipients in a model (B10.D2 [H2d, Mls-2b, Mls-3b]-->BALB/c [H2d, Mls-2a, Mls-3a]) of lethal GVHD. Tolerance was evaluated by transplantation of neonatal hearts. The mechanisms of tolerance were studied.

RESULTS

Host-specific tolerance was established in PG490-88-treated BALB/c recipients. Significant numbers of host reactive Vbeta3+ T cells (3.56+/-1.66% among CD4, 4.06+/-1.62% among CD8, P<0.0001 vs. normal BALB/c mice, P>0.05 vs. normal B10.D2 mice) were present in PG490-88-treated mice, suggesting that clonal deletion was not responsible for the observed tolerance. Spleen cells from PG490-88-treated mice could not respond to the host antigens measured by a popliteal lymph node weight gain assay. The unresponsiveness was unable to be overcome by supplementation of exogenous interleukin (IL)-2. Tolerant Vbeta3+ T cells obtained from PG490-88-treated mice proliferated normally to nonantigen-specific T cell receptor cross-linking. Neither antigen-specific nor nonantigen-specific suppressor cells were found in PG490-88-treated mice. The tolerant mice produced IL-4 rather than IL-2 and interferon (IFN)-gamma.

CONCLUSIONS

Host-specific tolerance induced by PG490-88 in a murine bone marrow transplantation model is not due to deletion of alloreactive cells. Moreover, suppressor cells are not involved in the maintenance of tolerance. Rather, PG490-88 seems to lead to allogeneic tolerance either through the induction of a state of antigen-specific anergy of the responding T cells or through the induction of T-helper cell, type II (TH2) responses.

Tolerance, mixed chimerism and protection against graft-versus-host disease after total lymphoid irradiation

Total lymphoid irradiation (TLI), originally developed as a non-myeloablative treatment for Hodgkin's disease, has been adapted for the induction of immune tolerance to organ allografts in rodents, dogs and non-human primates. Moreover, pretransplantation TLI has been used in prospective studies to demonstrate the feasibility of the induction of tolerance to cadaveric kidney allografts in humans. Two types of tolerance, chimeric and non-chimeric, develop after TLI treatment of hosts depending on whether donor bone marrow cells are transplanted along with the organ allograft. An advantageous feature of TLI for combined marrow and organ transplantation is the protection against graft-versus-host disease (GVHD) and facilitation of chimerism afforded by the predominance of CD4+ NK1.1(+) -like T cells in the irradiated host lymphoid tissues. Recently, a completely post-transplantation TLI regimen has been developed resulting in stable mixed chimerism and tolerance that is enhanced by a brief course of cyclosporine. The post-transplantation protocol is suitable for clinical cadaveric kidney transplantation. This review summarizes the evolution of TLI protocols for eventual application to human clinical transplantation and discusses the mechanisms involved in the induction of mixed chimerism and protection from GVHD.

Cyclosporine facilitates chimeric and inhibits nonchimeric tolerance after posttransplant total lymphoid irradiation

BACKGROUND

Previous studies showed that Lewis rats given posttransplant total lymphoid irradiation, antithymocyte globulin, and a single infusion of ACI peripheral blood or bone marrow cells develop tolerance to ACI heart allografts.

METHODS

To determine the effects of cyclosporine on these tolerance induction protocols, groups of Lewis hosts, given either ACI blood or marrow infusions, were given a 60-day course of daily cyclosporine immediately after the cell infusion.

RESULTS

Cyclosporine treatment was associated with uniform graft rejection in the groups given an ACI blood transfusion, and was associated with uniform graft acceptance in the groups given an ACI bone marrow infusion. Studies of donor-type T and B cell chimerism in the host blood showed that cyclosporine facilitated chimerism in the hosts given ACI bone marrow cells, and stable chimerism over a 300-day observation period was predicted by detectable chimerism by day 30. None of the hosts given ACI blood cells developed chimerism.

CONCLUSION

Cyclosporine facilitated long-term graft acceptance in a tolerization protocol that induced mixed chimerism, but prevented long-term graft acceptance in a tolerization protocol that did not induce chimerism.

Peritransplant tolerance induction in macaques: early events reflecting the unique synergy between immunotoxin and deoxyspergualin

BACKGROUND

Day of transplant T cell depletion with anti-CD3 immunotoxin or F(Ab)2 immunotoxin induces stable tolerance to renal allografts in rhesus monkeys given 15-deoxyspergualin (DSG), a NF-kappaB inhibitor that suppresses proinflammatory cytokine (PC) production. Because PC and NF-kappaB are involved in dendritic cell (DC) maturation, we asked if impaired DC maturation and Th2-type cytokine deviation might be related to the synergistic effect of DSG in this novel model.

METHODS

Immunosuppression was initiated 4 hr before transplanting a major histocompatibility complex mismatched renal allograft. Some groups received a supplemental 5-day course of cyclosporine A or DSG or a 15-day course of DSG. Peripheral lymph nodes were sequentially examined for presence of mature DC. In vitro effects of DSG on PC-induced maturation of DC were also examined.

RESULTS

Allografts survived without rejection in 87% of recipients given immunotoxin or F(Ab)2 immunotoxin with DSG x 15 days, in 50% with DSG x 5 days, and 0% with cyclosporine A. The longest DSG survivors are >1000 days with normal graft function and tolerance validated, including acceptance of challenge second donor kidneys without treatment. DSG-treated recipients were unique in developing polarized Th2-type plasma cytokines. In DSG recipients, mature DC were significantly reduced in day +5 lymph node biopsies, with complete repopulation by 30 days. In vitro studies verified an inhibitory effect of DSG on DC maturation.

CONCLUSIONS

The study suggests DSG arrests DC maturation. The unusual synergy of immunotoxin and DSG apparently involves coincidental reduction in lymph node T cell mass and mature DC, a transient circumstance favoring development of stable tolerance.

Comparison of chimeric acid and non-chimeric tolerance using posttransplant total lymphoid irradiation: cytokine expression and chronic rejection

BACKGROUND

Previous studies showed that an intravenous infusion of donor blood cells facilitates tolerance to ACI heart allografts in Lewis rat hosts given posttransplant total lymphoid irradiation (TLI) and anti-thymocyte globulin (ATG). The object of the current study was to compare tolerance induction using donor cells that do or do not induce chimerism.

METHODS

Normal peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC), granulocyte colony-stimulating factor (G-CSF)-mobilized PBMC, and bone marrow (BM) cells from ACI donors were tested for their capacity to prolong ACI heart allograft survival in Lewis hosts. Chimerism, anti-donor cell reactivity, and cytokine gene expression in grafts were determined.

RESULTS

Intravenous injections of equal numbers of all three donor cells markedly prolonged graft survival (median: >164 to >175 days) as compared to uninjected controls (median: 53 days). Chimerism among T and B cells in the blood was determined by immunofluorescent staining in hosts bearing long-term (> 150 days) grafts. Although no chimerism was detected in hosts given normal or G-CSF-mobilized PBMC, chimerism was detected at variable levels in all hosts given BM cells. Vigorous anti-donor reactivity in the mixed leukocyte reaction was present only in non-chimeric hosts. Long-term grafts from hosts given normal ACI PBMC developed chronic rejection, but those from hosts given ACI BM cells did not. The latter hosts showed the lowest levels of intragraft cytokine mRNA.

CONCLUSIONS

Chimeric tolerance is more robust than non-chimeric tolerance in the model of posttransplant TLI, ATG, and donor cell infusion, and is associated with less chronic rejection.

Induction of specific tolerance to allografts in rats by therapy with non-mitogenic, non-depleting anti-CD3 monoclonal antibody: association with TH2 cytokines not anergy

BACKGROUND

Anti-CD3 monoclonal antibodies (mAb) are potent immunosuppressives in transplantation but most do not induce tolerance. They induce anergy in Th1 cells but, if they bind to Fc receptors on antigen presenting cells, they activate T cells to release cytokines.

METHODS

This study examined the mechanisms of transplant tolerance induction to PVG fully allogeneic grafts in dark agouti rats by G4.18, a mouse immunoglobulinG3 anti-rat CD3 mAb that does not bind rat Fc receptors. Evidence of T cell activation was assayed by flow cytometry, reverse transcription (RT)-polymerase chain reaction (PCR) for cytokine mRNA, and responsiveness in mixed lymphocyte culture.

RESULTS

G4.18 treatment modulated T cell receptor/CD3 and CD2 and depleted T cells by <20% but did not induce activation surface markers. mRNA for interleukin (IL)-2, interferon (IFN)-gamma, tumor necrosis factor (TNF)-alpha, and IL-4 in the lymph node, spleen, and thymus was not increased, and IFN-gamma mRNA was reduced. G4.18-treated and naive rat cells had similar proliferation and expression of IL-2, IFN-gamma, and IL-4 in vitro. G4.18-treated allograft recipients had no induction of mRNA for IL-2, IFN-gamma, TNF-alpha, TNF-beta, IL-4, IL-5, IL-10, perforin, and granzyme A & B in the spleen or grafts, with levels similar to those in isografts. The IL-4 and IL-5 mRNA levels in the spleen but not the graft of G4.18-treated recipients were higher than in rejecting and naive animals. Cells from G4.18-treated graft recipients proliferated more rapidly to the donor than to the third party and had increased IL-4 expression.

CONCLUSIONS

G4.18 induced transplant tolerance by a combination of modulation and blocking of the TCR/CD3, associated with increased Th2 cytokines, without depletion, induction of anergy, or nonspecific activation of T cells.

Monocyte-derived dendritic cell precursors facilitate tolerance to heart allografts after total lymphoid irradiation

BACKGROUND

Previous studies have shown that posttransplant total lymphoid irradiation, anti-thymocyte globulin, and an intravenous donor blood cell infusion induce tolerance to ACI heart allografts in Lewis rat hosts.

METHODS

In the current study, fresh ACI monocytes and dendritic cell precursors, derived from short-term culture of the latter cells in granulocyte macrophage colony-stimulating factor, were tested for their capacity to prolong heart allograft survival in this model.

RESULTS

The experimental results show that significant prolongation of graft survival was achieved after injection of the fresh donor monocytes or 2-day or 6-day cultured cells. The 2-day cultured cells were most effective, and more than 60% of hosts maintained graft survival for more than 160 days. Ten-day cultured cells and fresh splenic dendritic cells failed to prolong graft survival. Studies of cell surface markers showed that the 2-day cultured cells had up-regulated class II major histocompatibility complex and CD80, but not CD86 molecules. On the other hand, the 10-day cultured cells and splenic dendritic cells showed intense expression of all three markers. The latter cells stimulated vigorous proliferative and cell-mediated lympholysis responses in the mixed leukocyte reaction, but the fresh and 2-day cultured cells were weak stimulators.

CONCLUSION

The intravenous injection of donor dendritic cell precursors derived from blood monocytes facilitates long-term acceptance of heart allografts.

Anti-CD4 Monoclonal Antibody-Induced Tolerance to MHC-Incompatible Cardiac Allografts Maintained by CD4+ Suppressor T Cells That Are Not Dependent upon IL-4

Anti-CD4 mAb-induced tolerance to transplanted tissues has been proposed as due to down-regulation of Th1 cells by preferential induction of Th2 cytokines, especially IL-4. This study examined the role of CD4+ cells and cytokines in tolerance to fully allogeneic PVG strain heterotopic cardiac allografts induced in naive DA rats by treatment with MRC Ox38, a nondepleting anti-CD4 mAb. All grafts survived &gt;100 days but had a minor mononuclear cell infiltrate that increased mRNA for the Th1 cytokines IL-2, IFN-γ, and TNF-β, but not for Th2 cytokines IL-4 and IL-6 or the cytolytic molecules perforin and granzyme A. These hosts accepted PVG skin grafts but rejected third-party grafts, which were not blocked by anti-IL-4 mAb. Cells from these tolerant hosts proliferated in MLC and produced IL-2, IFN-γ, and IL-4 at levels equivalent to naive cells. Unfractionated and CD4+ T cells, but not CD8+ T cells, transferred specific tolerance to irradiated heart grafted hosts and inhibited reconstitution of rejection by cotransferred naive cells. This transfer of tolerance was associated with normal induction of IL-2 and delayed induction of IFN-γ, but not with increased IL-4 or IL-10 mRNA. Transfer of tolerance was also not inhibited by anti-IL-4 mAb. This study demonstrated that tolerance induced by a nondepleting anti-CD4 mAb is maintained by a CD4+ suppressor T cell that is not associated with preferential induction of Th2 cytokines or the need for IL-4; nor is it associated with an inability to induce Th1 cytokines or anergy.

Donor blood monocytes but not T or B cells facilitate long-term allograft survival after total lymphoid irradiation

BACKGROUND

Previous studies showed that a combination of posttransplant total lymphoid irradiation (TLI), rabbit antithymocyte globulin (ATG), and a single donor blood transfusion induced tolerance to ACI heart allografts in Lewis rats. All three modalities were required to achieve tolerance. The objective of the current study was to determine the subset(s) of cells in the donor blood that facilitated long-term allograft survival.

METHODS

Lewis hosts received TLI, ATG, and donor cell infusion after heart transplantation. Graft survival, mixed leukocyte reaction (MLR), and intragraft cytokine mRNA were studied.

RESULTS

The intravenous injection of 25 x 10(6) ACI peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) significantly prolonged graft survival as compared with that of Lewis hosts given TLI and ATG alone. Injection of highly enriched blood T cells or splenic B cells adjusted for the number contained in 25 x 10(6) PBMC failed to induce significant graft prolongation. Unexpectedly, depletion of monocytes (CD11b+ cells) from PBMC resulted in the loss of graft prolongation activity. Enriched populations of monocytes obtained by plastic adherence were more efficient in prolonging graft survival than PBMC on a per cell basis. Hosts with long-term grafts (>100-day survival) showed evidence of immune deviation, because the MLR to ACI stimulator cells was vigorous, but secretion of interferon-gamma in the MLR was markedly reduced. In situ hybridization studies of long-term grafts showed markedly reduced levels of interferon-gamma mRNA as compared with rejecting grafts.

CONCLUSION

Infusion of donor monocytes facilitated graft prolongation via immune deviation.

Balancing the immune system for tolerance: a case for regulatory CD4 cells

In the past, tolerance mechanisms have focused on processes that involve elimination (deletion) or paralysis (anergy) of immune responses. It is now becoming clearer that peripheral tolerance to antigen depends on the generation of regulatory cells that function to maintain the tolerant state. The development of peripheral tolerance may require that the immune system utilize several strategies, including deletion, anergy, and immunoregulatory pathways, and these strategies may overlap. Recent investigations using animal models of transplantation tolerance have demonstrated that immunoregulatory CD4 mechanisms may play a central role in limiting organ-destructive immune responses. In this Overview, we discuss the rationale behind the need for invoking active regulatory mechanisms in peripheral immunologic tolerance and summarize the data that support or refute a CD4 regulatory mechanism.