Comparison between aortic and sinusoidal liver endothelial cells as targets of hyperacute xenogeneic rejection in the pig to human combination

Liver and Hepatocyte Transplantation: What Can Pigs Contribute?

About one-fifth of the population suffers from liver diseases in China, meaning that liver disorders are prominent causative factors relating to the Chinese mortality rate. For patients with end-stage liver diseases such as hepatocellular carcinoma or acute liver diseases with life-threatening liver dysfunction, allogeneic liver transplantation is the only life-saving treatment. Hepatocyte transplantation is a promising alternative for patients with acute liver failure or those considered high risk for major surgery, particularly for the bridge-to-transplant period. However, the lack of donors has become a serious global problem. The clinical application of porcine xenogeneic livers and hepatocytes remains a potential solution to alleviate the donor shortage. Pig grafts of xenotransplantation play roles in providing liver support in recipients, together with the occurrence of rejection, thrombocytopenia, and blood coagulation dysfunction. In this review, we present an overview of the development, potential therapeutic impact, and remaining barriers in the clinical application of pig liver and hepatocyte xenotransplantation to humans and non-human primates. Donor pigs with optimized genetic modification combinations and highly effective immunosuppressive regimens should be further explored to improve the outcomes of xenogeneic liver and hepatocyte transplantation.

Pig Liver Xenotransplantation: A Review of Progress Toward the Clinic

Experience with clinical liver xenotransplantation has largely involved the transplantation of livers from nonhuman primates. Experience with pig livers has been scarce. This brief review will be restricted to assessing the potential therapeutic impact of pig liver xenotransplantation in acute liver failure and the remaining barriers that currently do not justify clinical trials. A relatively new surgical technique of heterotopic pig liver xenotransplantation is described that might play a role in bridging a patient with acute liver failure until either the native liver recovers or a suitable liver allograft is obtained. Other topics discussed include the possible mechanisms for the development of the thrombocytopenis that rapidly occurs after pig liver xenotransplantation in a primate, the impact of pig complement on graft injury, the potential infectious risks, and potential physiologic incompatibilities between pig and human. There is cautious optimism that all of these problems can be overcome by judicious genetic manipulation of the pig. If liver graft survival could be achieved in the absence of thrombocytopenia or rejection for a period of even a few days, there may be a role for pig liver transplantation as a bridge to allotransplantation in carefully selected patients.

Current status of hepatocyte xenotransplantation

The treatment of acute liver failure, a condition with high mortality, comprises optimal clinical care, and in severe cases liver transplantation. However, there are limitations in availability of organ donors. Hepatocyte transplantation is a promising alternative that could fill the medical need, in particular as the bridge to liver transplantation. Encapsulated porcine hepatocytes represent an unlimited source that could function as a bioreactor requiring minimal immunosuppression. Besides patients with acute liver failure, patients with alcoholic hepatitis who are unresponsive to a short course of corticosteroids are a target for hepatocyte transplantation. In this review we present an overview of the innate immune barriers in hepatocyte xenotransplantation, including the role of complement and natural antibodies; the role of phagocytic cells and ligands like CD47 in the regulation of phagocytic cells; and the role of Natural Killer cells. We present also some illustrations of physiological species incompatibilities in hepatocyte xenotransplantation, such as incompatibilities in the coagulation system. An overview of the methodology for cell microencapsulation is presented, followed by proof-of-concept studies in rodent and nonhuman primate models of fulminant liver failure: these studies document the efficacy of microencapsulated porcine hepatocytes which warrants progress towards clinical application. Lastly, we present an outline of a provisional clinical trial, that upon completion of preclinical work could start within the upcoming 2-3 years.

Experimental hepatocyte xenotransplantation--a comprehensive review of the literature

Hepatocyte transplantation (Tx) is a potential therapy for certain diseases of the liver, including hepatic failure. However, there is a limited supply of human livers as a source of cells and, after isolation, human hepatocytes can be difficult to expand in culture, limiting the number available for Tx. Hepatocytes from other species, for example, the pig, have therefore emerged as a potential alternative source. We searched the literature through the end of 2014 to assess the current status of experimental research into hepatocyte xenoTx. The literature search identified 51 reports of in vivo cross-species Tx of hepatocytes in a variety of experimental models. Most studies investigated the Tx of human (n = 23) or pig (n = 19) hepatocytes. No studies explored hepatocytes from genetically engineered pigs. The spleen was the most common site of Tx (n = 23), followed by the liver (through the portal vein [n = 6]) and peritoneal cavity (n = 19). In 47 studies (92%), there was evidence of hepatocyte engraftment and function across a species barrier. The data provided by this literature search strengthen the hypothesis that xenoTx of hepatocytes is feasible and potentially successful as a clinical therapy for certain liver diseases, including hepatic failure. By excluding vascular structures, hepatocytes isolated from genetically engineered pig livers may address some of the immunological problems of xenoTx.

An in vitro model of pig liver xenotransplantation--pig complement is associated with reduced lysis of wild-type and genetically modified pig cells

BACKGROUND

After pig liver transplantation in humans, the graft will produce pig complement (C). We investigated in vitro the lysis of wild-type (WT), α1,3-galactosyltransferase gene-knockout (GTKO), and CD46 transgenic (CD46) pig peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) caused by human anti-pig antibodies (Abs) + pig C.

METHODS

Human serum IgM/IgG binding to WT and GTKO PBMC was determined by flow cytometry, and lysis of pig PBMC by a C-dependent cytotoxicity assay using (i) human serum (human Abs + C), (ii) GTKO pig serum (anti-Gal Abs + pig C), (iii) heat-inactivated human serum (human Abs) + rabbit C, or (iv) human Abs + pig C (serum).

RESULTS

Binding of human IgM and IgG to GTKO PBMC was less than to WT PBMC (P < 0.05). In the presence of human Abs, lysis of WT and GTKO PBMC by rabbit C was 87 and 13%, respectively (WT vs. GTKO, P < 0.01), but was only 37 and 0.4% in the presence of pig C (WT vs. GTKO, P < 0.05). Human/rabbit C-induced lysis was greater than pig C-induced lysis for both WT and GTKO PBMC. CD46 pig PBMC reduced rabbit/human C- and pig C-mediated lysis (P < 0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

Pig livers, particularly from GTKO and CD46 pigs, are likely to have an immunologic advantage over other organs after transplantation into humans. In the absence of pig antibodies directed to human tissues, pig complement is unlikely to cause problems after liver xenotransplantation, especially if GTKO/CD46 pigs are used as the source of the livers.

Hepatocyte xenotransplantation for treating liver disease

The treatment of acute and chronic liver failure is still a challenge despite modern therapeutic innovations. While liver transplantation can restore liver function and improve patient survival, donor shortages limit this treatment to a small number of patients. Cellular xenotransplantation has emerged as an alternative for treating liver failure. Xenohepatocytes could be readily available in sufficient quantities to treat patients in critical condition and thereby reduce the donor shortage. The use of isolated encapsulated or non-encapsulated cells can reduce the immunorejection response. Several studies using animal models of acute or chronic liver failure have demonstrated improved survival and recovery of liver function after xenotransplantation of adult hepatocytes. Porcine liver cells are a potential source of xenohepatocytes due to similarities with human physiology and the great number of hepatocytes that can be obtained. The recent development of less immunogenic transgenic pigs, new immunosuppressive drugs, and cellular encapsulation systems represents important advances in the field of cellular xenotransplantation. In this study, we review the work carried out in animal models that deals with the advantages and limitations of hepatocyte xenotransplantation, and we propose new studies needed in this field.

New Strategies for Acute Liver Failure: Focus on Xenotransplantation Therapy

Acute liver failure (ALF) has a poor prognosis and, despite intensive care support, reported average survival is only 10-40%. The most common causes responsible for ALF are viral hepatitis (mainly hepatitis A and B) and acetaminophen poisoning. Hepatic transplantation is the only appropriate treatment for patients with unlikely survival with supportive care alone. Survival rates after transplantation can be as high as 80-90% at the end of the first year. However, there is a shortage of donors and is not uncommon that no appropriate donor matches with the patient in time to avoid death. Therefore, new technologies are in constant development, including blood purification therapies as plasmapheresis, hemodiafiltration, and bioartificial liver support. However, they are still of limited efficacy or at an experimental level, and new strategies are welcome. Accordingly, cell transplantation has been developed to serve as a possible bridge to spontaneous recovery or liver transplantation. Xenotransplant of adult hepatocytes offers an interesting alternative. Moreover, the development of transgenic pigs with less immunogenic cells associated with new immunosuppressor strategies has allowed the development of this area. This article reviews some of the newly developed techniques, with focus on xenotransplant of adult hepatocytes, which might have clinical benefits as future treatment for ALF.

Human immune reactivity against liver sinusoidal endothelial cells from GalTα(1,3)GalT-deficient pigs

Elimination of galactose-α(1,3)galactose (Gal) expression in pig organs has been previously shown to prevent hyperacute xenograft rejection. However, naturally present antibodies to non-Gal epitopes activate endothelial cells, leading to acute humoral xenograft rejection. Still, it is unknown whether xenogeneic pig liver sinusoidal endothelial cells (LSECs) from α(1,3)galactosyltransferase (GalT)-deficient pigs are damaged by antibody and complement-mediated mechanisms. The present study examined the xeno-antibody response of LSECs from GalT-deficient and wild pigs. Isolated LSEC from wild-type and GalT pigs were expose to human and baboon sera; IgM and IgG binding was analyzed by flow cytometry. Complement activation (C3a and CH50) was quantified in vitro from serum-exposed LSEC cultures using Enzyme-Linked ImmunoSorbent assay (ELISA). Levels of complement-activated cytotoxicity (CAC) were also determined by a fluorescent Live-Dead Assay and by the quantification of LDH release. IgM binding to GalT knockout (KO) LSECs was significantly lower (80% human and 87% baboon) compare to wild-type pig LSEC. IgG binding was low in all groups. Moreover, complement activation (C3a and CH50) levels released following exposure to human or baboon sera were importantly reduced (42% human and 52% baboon), CAC in GalT KO LSECs was reduced by 60% in human serum and by 72% in baboon serum when compared to wild-type LSECs, and LDH release levels were reduced by 37% and 57%, respectively. LSECs from GalT KO pigs exhibit a significant protection to humoral-induced cell damage compared to LSECs from wild pigs when exposed to human serum. Although insufficient to inhibit xenogeneic reactivity completely, transgenic GalT KO expression on pig livers might contribute to a successful application of clinical xenotransplantation in combination with other protective strategies.

Liver xenografts for the treatment of acute liver failure: clinical and experimental experience and remaining immunologic barriers

A critical element restricting the application of liver transplantation is the shortage of human deceased donor organs. Xenotransplantation using pig organs might be a solution to this shortage. Although the problems that still require resolution include the immunologic barrier, the potential risk of transferring infectious agents with the transplanted organ, and uncertainty about whether the transplanted organ will function satisfactorily in the human environment, recent progress in the genetic manipulation of pigs has led to the prospect that clinical xenografting, at least as a bridge to allotransplantation, may be possible in the foreseeable future. Experience with clinical auxiliary and orthotopic liver xenotransplantation and experimental liver xenotransplantation in nonhuman primate and other large animal models is reviewed, and the remaining immunologic problems are discussed. Evidence suggests that, in patients with hepatic failure, the pig liver may be less susceptible to antibody-mediated injury than other pig organs, such as the heart or kidney. Pig Kupffer cells and other macrophages will recognize and phagocytose primate red blood cells, but this problem should be overcome by pretransplant depletion of macrophages from the organ-source pig. From the evidence currently available, it does not seem unduly optimistic to anticipate that a liver from an alpha1,3-galactosyltransferase gene-knockout pig would survive at least long enough to function as a successful bridge to allotransplantation.

In vivo study of the effects of cryopreservation on heart valve xenotransplantation

BACKGROUND

Recent reports have suggested that cryopreservation reduces the immunogenicity of donor tissue. The immunomodulation by cryopreservation might influence on the tissue durability after xenotransplantation. We investigated the in vivo morphologic changes in cryopreserved xenograft (CXG) heart valves.

MATERIAL AND METHOD

We transplanted a fresh (fresh xenograft; FXG) and a cryopreserved (CXG) porcine aortic root and a cryopreserved canine (cryopreserved allograft; CAG) aortic root into the abdominal aorta of a dog without any immunosuppressive agents. Explanted grafts on the 21st to 49th days after implantation were analyzed morphologically with light microscopy using some special stains, immunohistochemical analysis, and scanning electron microscopy (SEM).

RESULT

Light microscopy showed the absence of smooth muscle cells in the media of the aorta in any group after transplantation. FXG valves did not maintain any cellularity after transplantation. CXG valves contained cellular infiltration in themselves. CAG valves contained numerous fibroblasts, which showed the maintenance of tissue integrity without allowing cellular infiltration. The structure of elastic fibers was well maintained, even in the part of CXG valve with cellular infiltration. Immunohistochemical studies documented the infiltration of T lymphocytes in CXG valves that were labeled by anti-CD3 antibodies. SEM demonstrated that no endothelia were seen on the surface of the valves in any group after transplantation.

CONCLUSION

We concluded that the cryopreservation method might provide an immunomodulation of xenogeneic heart valves for transplantation.

Liver sinusoidal endothelial cells represents an important blood clearance system in pigs

BACKGROUND: Numerous studies in rats and a few other mammalian species, including man, have shown that the sinusoidal cells constitute an important part of liver function. In the pig, however, which is frequently used in studies on liver transplantation and liver failure models, our knowledge about the function of hepatic sinusoidal cells is scarce. We have explored the scavenger function of pig liver sinusoidal endothelial cells (LSEC), a cell type that in other mammals performs vital elimination of an array of waste macromolecules from the circulation. RESULTS: 125I-macromolecules known to be cleared in the rat via the scavenger and mannose receptors were rapidly removed from the pig circulation, 50% of the injected dose being removed within the first 2-5 min following injection. Fluorescently labeled microbeads (2 &mgr;m in diameter) used to probe phagocytosis accumulated in Kupffer cells only, whereas fluorescently labeled soluble macromolecular ligands for the mannose and scavenger receptors were sequestered only by LSEC. Desmin-positive stellate cells accumulated no probes. Isolation of liver cells using collagenase perfusion through the portal vein, followed by various centrifugation protocols to separate the different liver cell populations yielded 280 x 107 (range 50-890 x 107) sinusoidal cells per liver (weight of liver 237.1 g (sd 43.6)). Use of specific anti-Kupffer cell- and anti-desmin antibodies, combined with endocytosis of fluorescently labeled macromolecular soluble ligands indicated that the LSEC fraction contained 62 x 107 (sd 12 x 107) purified LSEC. Cultured LSEC avidly endocytosed ligands for the mannose and scavenger receptors. CONCLUSIONS: We show here for the first time that pig LSEC, similar to what has been found earlier in rat LSEC, represent an effective scavenger system for removal of macromolecular waste products from the circulation.

Adhesive interactions between human NK cells and porcine endothelial cells

Human natural killer (NK) cells are able to adhere to xenogeneic porcine endothelial cells (EC) and evidence from in vitro studies as well as animal models suggests a potential role for NK cells in the cellular recognition and damage of porcine xenogeneic tissues. One possible explanation for the observed NK cell-mediated xenogeneic cytotoxicity against porcine EC is the molecular incompatibility between porcine major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I molecules and MHC-specific inhibitory receptors on human NK cells. In this review we attempt to summarize the current knowledge concerning adhesive interactions between human NK cells and porcine EC under special considerations of the cross-species receptor-ligand interactions. Methodological differences in assessing adhesion between various studies are reviewed and comparisons to the syngeneic/allogeneic adhesion mechanisms are made. Finally, the therapeutic potential of blocking antibodies and transgenic HLA expression in preventing NK-cell adhesion and xenogeneic cytotoxicity is discussed.

Rejection of pig liver xenografts in patients with liver failure: implications for xenotransplantation

The pathophysiological state of rejection in liver xenotransplantation is poorly understood. Data from clinical pig liver perfusion suggest that pig livers might be rejected less vigorously than pig hearts or kidneys. Pig livers used in clinical xenoperfusions were exposed to blood from patients with liver failure. We have shown in an animal model that transplant recipients with liver failure are less capable of initiating hyperacute rejection of a xenografted liver than a healthy transplant recipient. The goal of this report is to examine the pathological characteristics of pig livers used in 2 clinical pig liver perfusions and combine this information with in vitro studies of pig-to-human liver xenotransplantation to determine whether the findings in the perfused pig livers could be explained in part by the diminished capacity of the patient with liver failure to respond to xenogeneic tissue. Pathological analysis of the perfused pig livers showed immunoglobulin M deposition in the sinusoids with little evidence of complement activation. Our in vitro studies showed that serum from patients with liver failure caused less injury to pig liver endothelium than serum from healthy subjects. Serum from patients with liver failure had similar levels of xenoreactive antibodies as serum from healthy humans. Incubation of serum from patients with liver failure with pig hepatic endothelial cells generated less iC3b, Bb fragment, and C5b-9 than serum from healthy subjects. We conclude that the altered injury in the perfused pig livers can be attributed to the relative complement deficiency that accompanies liver failure.

The target antigens of naturally occurring human anti-beta-galactose IgG are cryptic on porcine aortic endothelial cells

The identification of the xeno-antigens/xeno-antibodies combinations involved in pig-to-human xenograft rejection is an essential step for understanding this process and for the development of procedures to prevent it. Although it is widely accepted that the terminal disaccharide Galalpha1,3Gal-R is by far the major epitope recognized by human natural antibodies reactive with pig tissues, there is also evidence that other carbohydrate epitopes might be important in xenograft rejection. In an attempt to further improve our knowledge of the repertoire of human natural antibodies with anti-pig specificity we sought to determine whether naturally occurring human anti-beta-galactose IgG could interact with porcine aortic endothelial cells (PAEC). Histochemical analysis of porcine aorta sections revealed that the carbohydrate structures recognized by the anti-beta-galactose IgG are present on endothelial cells but in a cryptic form that can be unmasked by sialidase treatment. These structures were also found to be cryptic in cultured PAEC. In addition we demonstrated that PAEC may adsorb fetal calf serum (FCS) glycoproteins when cultured in FCS-supplemented medium, a process susceptible to generating artifactual observations in carbohydrate antigens analysis. In conclusion, despite their abundance, human anti-beta-galactose IgG do not represent a primary concern in pig-to-human xenotransplantation as the carbohydrate structures to which they bind are normally masked by sialic acid residues on porcine endothelial cells. However, whether these cryptic epitopes might be exposed on endothelial cells from genetically engineered animals should be further investigated because, if so, additional approaches will be needed to suppress their interaction with human anti-beta-galactose IgG.

Distribution of membrane cofactor protein (MCP/CD46) on pig tissues. Relevance To xenotransplantation

Membrane cofactor protein (MCP; CD46) is a 50-60 000 MW glycoprotein, expressed on a wide variety of cells and tissues in man, which plays an important role in regulating complement activation. Human MCP has also been shown to be the receptor for measles virus. We have recently identified the pig analogue of MCP and demonstrated that pig MCP has cofactor activity for factor I-mediated cleavage of C3b when these components are derived either from pig or human. As a consequence, pig MCP is an efficient regulator of the classic and alternative pathways of human and pig complement. In order to define the potential importance of MCP in protecting against complement activation in the pig, we have conducted a comprehensive survey of its distribution in pig cells and organs. As in humans, MCP in the pig is broadly and abundantly distributed. Pig MCP is highly expressed on all circulating cells, including erythrocytes, in contrast to its absence on human erythrocytes. Multiple isoforms of MCP are found on cells and in tissues, probably representing products of alternative splicing analogous to those found in man. MCP is abundantly expressed throughout all tissues examined with particularly strong staining on the vascular endothelium. Connective tissue elements within liver and testis are also strongly stained by anti-pig MCP antibodies. Pig MCP is expressed only weakly on skeletal muscle cells and expression is absent from smooth muscle cells in the lung and vessel walls, sites at which human MCP is expressed. Of particular note, MCP is not expressed in B-cell areas of the germinal centres of lymph nodes.

Prevention of initial perfusion failure during xenogeneic ex vivo liver perfusion by selectin inhibition

BACKGROUND

Endothelial cell activation triggered by xenoreactive antibodies and complement products is the main feature of discordant xenograft rejection. The contribution of early cell-mediated mechanisms to this rejection process is poorly understood, and the function of adhesion molecules in xenogeneic cell interactions in vivo is unclear. The aim of the study was to investigate the role of selectins in mediating cell-dependent initial perfusion failure and functional restrictions in xenoperfused guinea pig (GP) livers.

METHODS

Isolated GP livers were hemoperfused in a flow-constant, recirculating perfusion system via the portal vein. Microhemodynamic parameters such as sinusoidal perfusion rate and leukocyte flux were analyzed using intravital fluorescence microscopy. Hepatic oxygen consumption and bile production, as well as liver enzymes, potassium level, and numbers of white blood cells and platelets in the perfusate, were determined. The GP livers were perfused either with GP blood (control perfusion), with unmodified rat blood (xenoperfusion), or with rat blood treated with the selectin-blocking polysaccharide Fucoidin.

RESULTS

A significant sinusoidal perfusion failure was observed in the xenoperfusion group, which was accompanied by distinct signs of a functional restriction-like reduced oxygen consumption, bile production, and increased perfusion pressure. However, there were significantly fewer impairments in the Fucoidin group. Furthermore, fewer platelets were trapped and a smaller number of stagnant leukocytes were observed in this group.

CONCLUSION

Fucoidin did not suppress complement activation during xenoperfusion. Considering that Fucoidin inhibits the selectin-dependent interactions among white blood cells, platelets, and sulfate-containing proteoglycans on the surface of vascular endothelium, these findings suggest an important role for early cellular interactions in the development of organ failure during xenogeneic rejection.

Complement activation in discordant hepatic xenotransplantation

Little is known about hyperacute rejection in hepatic xenotransplantation. Information from clinical xenoperfusions suggests that the liver may be rejected by a mechanism less vigorous than either kidney or heart xenografts. We used the in vitro model of porcine hepatic sinusoidal endothelial cells (PHEC) incubated with either complement replete or deficient human serum to determine the relative roles of the classical and alternate pathways of complement in the immediate response to hepatic xenotransplantation. Our results suggest that either the classical or alternate pathways are capable of independently activating the complement cascade upon exposure to the porcine hepatic sinusoidal endothelium. Our results also imply that either pathway alone is capable of initiating similar degrees of injury as the entire cascade.