Quantitation of the changes in splenic architecture during the rejection of cardiac allografts or xenografts

From bench to bedside: reversing established antibody responses and desensitization

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Basic transplant immunology has primarily focused on the definition of mechanisms, but an often-stated aspirational goal is to translate basic mechanistic research into future therapy. Pretransplant donor-specific antibodies (DSA) mediate hyperacute as well as early antibody-mediated rejection (AMR), whereas DSA developing late posttransplantation may additionally mediate chronic rejection. Although contemporary immunosuppression effectively prevents early cellular rejection after transplant in nonsensitized patients, it is less effective at controlling preexisting HLA antibody responses or reversing DSA once established, thus underscoring a need for better therapies.

RECENT FINDINGS

We here review the development of a bench-to-bedside approach involving transient proteasome inhibition to deplete plasma cells, combined with maintenance co-stimulation blockade, with CTLA-4Ig or belatacept, to prevent the generation of new antibody-secreting cells (ASCs).

SUMMARY

This review discusses how this treatment regimen, which was rationally designed and validated to reverse established DSA responses in mouse models, translated into reversing active AMR in the clinic, as well as desensitizing highly sensitized patients on the transplant waitlist.

TNF blockade abrogates the induction of T cell-dependent humoral responses in an allotransplantation model

TNF blockade modulates many aspects of the immune response and is commonly used in a wide array of immune-mediated inflammatory diseases. As anti-TNF induces anti-dsDNA IgM antibodies but not other antinuclear reactivities in human arthritis, we investigated here the effect of TNF blockade on the induction of TD humoral responses using cardiac allograft and xenograft models. A single injection of an anti-rat TNF antibody in LEW.1A recipients grafted with congenic LEW.1W hearts almost completely abrogated the induction of IgM and IgG alloantibodies. This was associated with decreased Ig deposition and leukocyte infiltration in the graft at Day 5. TNF blockade did not affect germinal-center formation in the spleen or expression of Th1/Th2 cytokines, costimulatory and regulatory molecules, and TLRs in spleen and graft of the recipient animals. Clinically, the abrogation of the induction of the alloantibodies was associated with a marked prolongation of graft survival. In contrast, anti-TNF did not alter acute xenograft rejection mediated by TI antibodies in a hamster-to-rat model. Taken together, these data indicate that TNF blockade abrogates the induction of TD humoral responses and accordingly, may have a beneficial effect in antibody-mediated inflammatory pathologies.

Role of CD4+ and CD8+ T cells in the rejection of concordant pancreas xenografts

BACKGROUND

We studied the ability of CD4 and CD8 T cells to induce rejection of pancreas xenografts in a concordant combination using rat pancreas xenografts as donors and chemically induced diabetic mice as recipients.

METHODS

Lewis rat (2 to 3 weeks old) pancreas xenografts were transplanted into streptozotocin (STZ)-induced diabetic mice. Lymphocyte proliferation and cytokine production were analyzed in vitro. All pancreas xenografts were assessed by functional (blood glucose) and histopathologic examinations.

RESULTS

Lewis rat pancreas grafts were rejected within 10 to 13 days, with mononuclear cell infiltrate and tissue necrosis in STZ-induced diabetic mice. A predominant T cell receptor alphabeta -CD4 cell (on day 4) and T cell receptor alphabeta -CD8 cell (on day 8) infiltrate and IgM deposition were found in the pancreas xenografts after transplantation. Anti-CD4 (GK1.5), but not anti-CD8 (YTS169.4), monoclonal antibodies resulted in a prolonged survival of Lewis rat pancreas xenografts. Lewis pancreas xenografts were permanently accepted by CD4 knockout mice but not by CD8 knockout mice. The pancreas xenografts were acutely rejected with a mean survival time of 15.3 days in B cell-deficient mice (microMT/microMT). Transfer of CD4 but not CD8 spleen cells from naïve C57BL/6 mice into Rag2 mice led to acute rejection of transplanted pancreas xenografts. However, activated CD8 spleen cells elicited rejection of Lewis rat pancreas xenografts in SZT-induced diabetic mice.

CONCLUSION

The current results show that CD4 T cells are necessary and sufficient for mediating the rejection of Lewis rat pancreas xenografts in STZ-induced diabetic mice. However, CD8 cells, when activated, can also induce acute rejection of concordant pancreas xenografts.

Acute xenograft rejection, late xenograft rejection and long term survival xenografts in the hamster-to-rat heart transplantation model: histological characterisation under low-dose of FK506

BACKGROUND

Long-term survival studies have been conducted in hamster-to-rat cardiac models with a range of immunosuppressive treatments, but the histological pattern of Late Xenograft Rejection (LXR) has not been outlined. This study offers a detailed description of the histological changes in cardiac xenografts under three different immunological responses.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Heterotopic hamster-to-Lewis rat cardiac transplant. Recipients were administered an antiproliferative drug (MMF, 25 mg/kg, or CyP, 10 mg/kg, from day -7 to +7 or from day 0 to +7, according to group) and FK506 (0.2 mg/kg; from day 0 to +30 or continuously). Unmodified recipients were used as controls. Conventional histology and indirect immunofluorescence of IgM, IgG and C3 deposits were performed.

RESULTS

In our study, xenografted rats that did not receive treatment developed a pattern of Acute Xenograft Rejection (AXR), with substantial tissue breakdown. Pretreated and treated animals until day 30 post-transplant developed LXR that may present two different histological patterns: one with vascular damage and predominant interstitial haemorrhage, and the other with extensive myocardial fibrosis. Long-term surviving rats (LTS) showed a morphology that was almost normal, with mild fibrosis and vascular endothelium preserved.

CONCLUSIONS

AXR, LXR and LTS in the hamster-to-rat heart transplantation model present a common humoral mechanism although their histopathological patterns are different depending on the length of immunosuppressive treatment but not on the type of antiproliferative drug administered. Pretreatment exerts an effect on fibrosis formation.

Induction of xenograft accommodation by modulation of elicited antibody responses1 2

BACKGROUND

We have established that the timing of splenectomy influences the magnitude of the xenoreactive antibody (XAb) response and thus hamster heart survival in cyclosporine (CyA)-treated rats. This model has been used to test our hypothesis that modulation of XAb responses without perturbation of complement may influence the development of graft accommodation.

METHODS

Pretransplantation splenectomy (day -1/day 0) fully abrogated anti-graft IgM response, whereas a delayed procedure (day 1/day 2) caused significantly delayed (3-4 days) and decreased levels (two- to threefold) of XAb. Both interventions resulted in long-term graft survival. After surviving for 7 or more days, xenografts in CyA-treated rats with post-, but not pre-, transplantation splenectomy were also resistant to exogenous anti-graft XAb. Such grafts meet the criteria for accommodation. Accommodating hearts displayed progressive and increasing expression of protective genes, such as heme oxygense (HO)-1 and A20, in endothelial cells and smooth muscle cells.

RESULTS

Our results suggest that XAb responses may influence the kinetics of accommodation development possibly by promoting protective gene expression. This hypothesis was directly tested in vitro. Pretreatment of porcine aortic endothelial cells with sublytic amounts of baboon anti-pig serum for 24 hr induced HO-1 expression; this was associated with cell resistance to lytic amounts of such serum. Overexpression of HO-1 by adenoviral-mediated gene transfer in porcine aortic endothelial cells resulted in similar protective effects.

CONCLUSIONS

Delayed and relatively low levels of XAb IgM promote expression of protective genes in the graft and thereby aid in the progress of accommodation. Expression of HO-1 protects xenoserum-mediated endothelial cell destruction.

Leflunomide-mediated suppression of antiviral antibody and Tcell responses: differential restoration by uridine

BACKGROUND

Leflunomide is an isoxazol derivative with immunosuppressive capacities in various experimental allo- and xenotransplantation models. Two main mechanisms of action have been described: Inhibition of pyrimidine de novo synthesis and impairment of tyrosine phosphorylation of different tyrosine kinases involved in receptor signaling via B cell and cytokine receptors.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Interference of Leflunomide with the IgM antibody responses to vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV, T-independent type 1), IgM to recombinant VSV glycoprotein (T-independent type 2), and IgG to lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus (LCMV, T-dependent) were analyzed whereas the cytotoxic T cell (CTL) response was examined after LCMV infection. Interference with the CD8+ T cell-mediated autoimmune diabetes in a transgenic mouse expressing the LCMV-glycoprotein in the pancreatic islets was studied as a model for T cell-mediated autoimmune diseases. Uridine substitution experiments were performed to differentiate between the above mentioned two mechanisms of action on different functions of the immune system in vivo.

RESULTS

Leflunomide at 35 mg/kg/day suppressed the humoral immune response against all antigens tested. Similar effects on T-independent compared to T-dependent antibody responses required two to four times higher drug doses. CTL responses to LCMV were considerably impaired. Uridine substitution prevented lethal VSV encephalitis under Leflunomide treatment by restoring the neutralizing IgM and IgG responses. However, the inhibition of LCMV specific CTLs and suppression of CD8+ T cell-mediated autoimmune diabetes remained unaffected by additional uridine treatment.

CONCLUSIONS

Leflunomide-mediated suppression of B cell and T helper cell activity but not of CTLs largely depends on inhibition of pyrimidine de novo synthesis.

Prolonged survival of musculoskeletal xenografts with combined cyclosporine and 15-deoxyspergualin

This study was undertaken to evaluate the feasibility of performing vascularized musculoskeletal xenografts between mice and rats using immunosuppression. Vascularized musculoskeletal grafts were harvested from the hind limb of C57BL/6J (B6) mice, transplanted heterotopically into Lewis rats, and revascularized by microanastomoses of the graft artery and the recipient femoral artery and the graft vein to the recipient femoral vein. Recipient rats were divided into four groups. Group 1 received no immunosuppression (n = 10), group 2 was treated with cyclosporine (10 mg/kg/day; n = 10), group 3 was treated with 15-deoxyspergualin (5 mg/kg/day; n = 10), and group 4 received both cyclosporine and 15-deoxyspergualin (n = 10). Graft survival was directly examined on postoperative days 4, 7, and 14. In vitro assays were performed using mixed lymphocyte reactions and anti-donor cytotoxic antibody assays to assess the recipient's immune response. Grafts were examined by histology and immunohistochemistry. All grafts in group 1 were rejected by day 4. In groups 2 and 3, all grafts were rejected by day 7. In group 4, however, 8 of 10 recipients had viable grafts on day 14. Data from mixed lymphocyte reactions showed that cell-mediated immune responses were uniformly suppressed in groups 2, 3, and 4 compared with group 1. However, anti-donor antibody production was only partly suppressed in groups 2 and 3, suggesting that graft rejection was primarily caused by circulating cytotoxic anti-donor antibodies in groups 1, 2, and 3. Histologic observations in groups 1, 2, and 3 confirmed the important role of the humoral mechanism in xenograft rejection. Furthermore, immunohistochemical results demonstrated that the small vessels in the rejected grafts showed anti-rat immunoglobulin and complement depositions. Only a combination therapy of cyclosporine and 15-deoxyspergualin attenuated the rejection of xenografts.

Tolerance of T-independent xeno-antibody responses in the hamster-to-rat xenotransplantation model is species-restricted but not tissue-specific

Control of early acute xenograft rejection xenoreactions in the hamster-to-Lewis rat xenotransplantation model with cyclosporine (CsA) and leflunomide subdues early T-independent xenoreactivity and uncovers a late immune response that can be controlled by CsA alone. We had attributed this acquired responsiveness to CsA to the induction of tolerance of T-independent xeno-antibody responses in the recipient and recently reported that this tolerance is species-specific. Here we have further characterized the specificity and nature of this tolerant state. Lewis rats transplanted with either hearts, skin, kidney or spleen/pancreas from Golden Syrian hamsters were treated with leflunomide (5 mg/kg/day by gavage) for 14-21 days and CsA (20 mg/kg/day by gavage) continuously from the day of transplant. Some Lewis rats received a second graft of hearts or skin from Golden Syrian hamsters (day 21-30 after first transplant), and a third heart graft from Balb/c mice (day 60 after the first transplant). Serum was harvested and the titers of xenoreactive antibodies were quantified by flow cytometry. All grafts were harvested at the end of each experiment and examined by histological and immunohistochemical methods. The combination of CsA and leflunomide was able to completely inhibit the rejection of kidney, spleen and pancreas xenografts in this hamster-to-rat xenotransplantation model. In addition, only a transient treatment with leflunomide was necessary, and long-term graft survival could subsequently be maintained by CsA alone. Histological examination of these grafts at > 80 days post-transplantation indicated minimal signs of rejection. These immediately vascularized organs induced T-independent B-cell tolerance, so that second grafts of hamster hearts and skin could be maintained with CsA alone. Under the same immunosuppressive regimen, only four out of nine Lewis rats exhibited long-term hamster skin survival, probably reflecting the increased immunogenicity of the skin compared with other vascularized grafts. Nonetheless, all rats that did not reject the hamster skin graft also did not reject the hamster heart while on CsA alone. Finally, we demonstrate that the tolerant state could be maintained for up to 30 days in the absence of xenograft. The vigorous T-independent antibody response that mediates acute xenograft rejection in the hamster-to-rat model can be tolerized by the immunosuppressive regimen of CsA and leflunomide. The lack of organ specificity for the induction of this tolerance suggests that the xenoantigens inducing tolerance may be common endothelial cell antigens. Finally, the presence of the xenograft has been previously shown to be critical for the induction of T-independent B-cell tolerance, however, the tolerant state is relatively stable and persists after the removal of the xenograft.

In vivo activity of leflunomide: pharmacokinetic analyses and mechanism of immunosuppression

BACKGROUND

Leflunomide is an experimental drug with demonstrated ability to prevent and reverse acute allograft and xenograft rejection. The two biochemical activities reported for the active metabolite of leflunomide, A77 1726, are inhibition of tyrosine phosphorylation and inhibition of dihydroorotate dehydrogenase, an enzyme necessary for de novo pyrimidine synthesis. These activities can be distinctly separated in vitro by the use of uridine, which reverses the anti-proliferative effects of A77 1726 caused by inhibition of de novo pyrimidine synthesis. We report the effect of uridine on the in vivo immunosuppressive activities of leflunomide.

METHODS

We first quantified the serum levels of A77 1726, the active metabolite of leflunomide, after a single treatment of leflunomide (5, 15, and 35 mg/kg). Additionally, we quantified the levels of serum uridine and of nucleotide triphosphates in the liver, spleen, and lymph nodes of Lewis rats after the administration of a single dose of uridine (500 mg/kg; i.p.). Lewis rats heterotopically transplanted with brown Norway or Golden Syrian hamster hearts were treated for 50 or 75 days with leflunomide (5, 15, and 35 mg/kg/day; gavage) alone or in combination with uridine (500 mg/ kg/day; i.p.). Hematocrits were determined and the levels of alloreactive or xenoreactive immunoglobulin (Ig)M and IgG were determined by flow cytometric analysis. The allograft and xenografts, small bowel, liver, kidney, and spleen were subjected to pathological examination.

RESULTS

A linear relationship was observed between the serum A77 1726 concentrations in Lewis rats and the dose of leflunomide administered. Peak A77 1726 concentrations were 20.9, 71.8 and 129.3 mg/l (77.5, 266.1 and 478.8 microM) for the 5, 15, and 35 mg/kg doses of leflunomide, respectively. The concentration of uridine in the serum of normal Lewis rats is 6.5 microM; after i.p. administration of 500 mg/kg uridine, the serum uridine concentrations peaked at 384.1 microM in 15-30 min. The rapid elimination of uridine was not reflected in the lymphoid compartments, and the pharmacokinetics of pyrimidine nucleotides in the spleen resembled that of A77 1726. This dose of uridine, when administered daily (500 mg/kg/day, i.p.), weakly antagonized the immunosuppressive activities of leflunomide (5, 15, and 35 mg/kg/day) in the allotransplantation model. In contrast, in the xenotransplantation model, the same concentration of uridine completely antagonized the immunosuppressive activities of low-dose leflunomide (15 mg/kg/day) and partially antagonized the immunosuppressive activities of high-dose leflunomide (35 mg/kg/day). Toxicities associated with high-dose leflunomide (35 mg/kg/day) were anemia, diarrhea, and pathological changes in the small bowel and liver. These toxicities were significantly reduced by uridine co-administration.

CONCLUSION

These studies reveal that the blood levels of A77 1726 in Lewis rats satisfy in vitro requirements for both inhibition of de novo pyrimidine synthesis and protein tyrosine kinase activity. Our data also illustrate that the in vivo mechanism of immunosuppression by leflunomide is complex and is affected by at least the following four factors: type and vigor of the immune response, availability of uridine for salvage by proliferating lymphocytes, species being investigated, and concentration of serum A77 1726.

Induction of Species-Specific Host Accommodation in the Hamster-to-Rat Xenotransplantation Model

The combination of two immunosuppressants, leflunomide and cyclosporin A (CsA), completely inhibits immune xenoreactions in the hamster-to-Lewis rat xenotransplantation model. In addition, the control of acute xenograft rejection with this combination of immunosuppressants subdues early T-independent xenoreactivity and uncovers a late immune response that can be controlled by CsA alone. We attribute this acquired responsiveness to CsA to a modification in the recipient’s humoral response to the xenograft, and refer to this change as host accommodation. Host accommodation can be induced in Lewis rats receiving hamster hearts by the combination of leflunomide and CsA. A 7-day treatment with leflunomide and CsA was able to convert xenoreactivity from one that was resistant to CsA treatment into one that was controlled by CsA. The presence of the hamster xenograft was critical for the induction of host accommodation since the immunosuppressive regimen, either alone or in combination with a transfusion with donor-specific spleen cells, was unable to modify the anti-hamster reactivity in Lewis rats. When accommodation was induced in the presence of hamster hearts, these accommodated rats were able to acutely reject third-party mouse hearts while under CsA therapy, thus indicating that the host accommodation is species specific. Finally, we demonstrate that host accommodation is associated with a loss in the ability to produce species-specific, T-independent xenoantibodies. These novel observations suggest that xenoreactive T-independent humoral responses can be deleted selectively without significant loss of other innate, Ag-specific T-independent humoral responses.