Combination of decay-accelerating factor expression and alpha1,3-galactosyltransferase knockout affords added protection from human complement-mediated injury

Efficient production of multi-modified pigs for xenotransplantation by 'combineering', gene stacking and gene editing

Xenotransplantation from pigs could alleviate the shortage of human tissues and organs for transplantation. Means have been identified to overcome hyperacute rejection and acute vascular rejection mechanisms mounted by the recipient. The challenge is to combine multiple genetic modifications to enable normal animal breeding and meet the demand for transplants. We used two methods to colocate xenoprotective transgenes at one locus, sequential targeted transgene placement - ‘gene stacking’, and cointegration of multiple engineered large vectors - ‘combineering’, to generate pigs carrying modifications considered necessary to inhibit short to mid-term xenograft rejection. Pigs were generated by serial nuclear transfer and analysed at intermediate stages. Human complement inhibitors CD46, CD55 and CD59 were abundantly expressed in all tissues examined, human HO1 and human A20 were widely expressed. ZFN or CRISPR/Cas9 mediated homozygous GGTA1 and CMAH knockout abolished α-Gal and Neu5Gc epitopes. Cells from multi-transgenic piglets showed complete protection against human complement-mediated lysis, even before GGTA1 knockout. Blockade of endothelial activation reduced TNFα-induced E-selectin expression, IFNγ-induced MHC class-II upregulation and TNFα/cycloheximide caspase induction. Microbial analysis found no PERV-C, PCMV or 13 other infectious agents. These animals are a major advance towards clinical porcine xenotransplantation and demonstrate that livestock engineering has come of age.

The pathobiology of pig-to-primate xenotransplantation: a historical review

The immunologic barriers to successful xenotransplantation are related to the presence of natural anti-pig antibodies in humans and non-human primates that bind to antigens expressed on the transplanted pig organ (the most important of which is galactose-α1,3-galactose [Gal]), and activate the complement cascade, which results in rapid destruction of the graft, a process known as hyperacute rejection. High levels of elicited anti-pig IgG may develop if the adaptive immune response is not prevented by adequate immunosuppressive therapy, resulting in activation and injury of the vascular endothelium. The transplantation of organs and cells from pigs that do not express the important Gal antigen (α1,3-galactosyltransferase gene-knockout [GTKO] pigs) and express one or more human complement-regulatory proteins (hCRP, e.g., CD46, CD55), when combined with an effective costimulation blockade-based immunosuppressive regimen, prevents early antibody-mediated and cellular rejection. However, low levels of anti-non-Gal antibody and innate immune cells and/or platelets may initiate the development of a thrombotic microangiopathy in the graft that may be associated with a consumptive coagulopathy in the recipient. This pathogenic process is accentuated by the dysregulation of the coagulation-anticoagulation systems between pigs and primates. The expression in GTKO/hCRP pigs of a human coagulation-regulatory protein, for example, thrombomodulin, is increasingly being associated with prolonged pig graft survival in non-human primates. Initial clinical trials of islet and corneal xenotransplantation are already underway, and trials of pig kidney or heart transplantation are anticipated within the next few years.

The cellular repair of the brain in Parkinson's disease—past, present and future

Damage to the central nervous system was once considered irreparable. However, there is now growing optimism that neural transplant therapies may one day enable complete circuit reconstruction and thus functional benefit for patients with neurodegenerative conditions such as Parkinson's disease (PD), and perhaps even those with more widespread damage such as stroke patients. Indeed, since the late 1980s hundreds of patients with Parkinson's disease have received allografts of dopamine-rich embryonic human neural tissue. The grafted tissue has been shown to survive and ameliorate many of the symptoms of the disease, both in the clinical setting and in animal models of the disease. However, practical problems associated with tissue procurement and storage, and ethical concerns over using aborted human fetal tissue have fuelled a search for alternative sources of suitable material for grafting. In particular, stem cells and xenogeneic embryonic dopamine-rich neural tissue are being explored, both of which bring their own practical and ethical dilemmas. Here we review the progress made in neural transplantation, both in the laboratory and in the clinic with particular attention to the development of stem cell and xenogeneic tissue based therapy.

Hyperacute rejection of mouse lung by human blood: characterization of the model and the role of complement

BACKGROUND

The pathophysiology of hyperacute lung rejection (HALR) is not fully understood. A mouse model of HALR by human blood would be valuable to efficiently dissect the molecular mechanisms underlying this complex process, but it has not been described.

METHODS

We developed a xenogenic mouse lung-perfusion model. Perfusion with heparinized autologous blood (n=3) was compared with human blood unmodified (n=7) or pretreated with C1 inhibitor (n=5) or soluble complement receptor type 1 (n=6) at unchanged flow conditions.

RESULTS

Perfusion with autologous blood was associated with stable physiologic parameters and no overt evidence of lung injury for up to 2 hr. Pulmonary artery perfusion pressure increased rapidly after introduction of unmodified human blood, plasma anti-Gal(alpha)1,3Gal antibodies declined (90% immunoglobulin [Ig]M, 80% IgG), and lungs reliably met survival endpoints within 11 min (median 10 min, confidence interval [CI]: 9-11). Human Ig and neutrophils were rapidly sequestered in the lung. Survival was significantly prolonged in the soluble complement receptor type 1 group (36 min, CI: 26-46) (P<0.01) and in the C1 inhibitor group (23 min, CI: 21-25) (P<0.05), and pulmonary vascular resistance elevation and complement activation were significantly attenuated but not prevented.

CONCLUSIONS

Hyperacute rejection of mouse lung by human blood occurs with kinetics, physiology, and histology closely analogous to the pig-to-human model. In addition, as in that model, neither of two potent soluble-phase complement inhibitors prevented complement activation or HALR. We conclude that the mouse lung model is relevant to dissect the cellular and molecular mechanisms governing HALR.

Outline of a Risk Assessment: The Welfare of Future Xeno-Donor Pigs

The welfare of transgenic animals is often not considered prior to their generation. However, we demonstrate here how a welfare risk assessment can be carried out before transgenic animals are created. We describe a risk assessment identifying potential welfare problems in transgenic pigs generated for future xeno-donation of organs. This assessment is based on currently available information concerning transgenic animal models in which one or more transgenes relevant to future xeno-donation have been inserted. The welfare risk assessment reveals that future xeno-donor pigs may have an increased tendency toward septicaemias, reduced fertility and/or impaired vision. The transgenic animal models used in generating hypotheses about the welfare of xeno-donor pigs can also assist in the testing of these hypotheses. To ensure high levels of welfare of transgenic animals, analogous risk assessments can be used to identify potential welfare problems during the early stages of the generation of new transgenic animals. Such assessments may form part of the basis on which licenses to generate new transgenic animals are granted to research groups.

Efficient generation of alpha(1,3) galactosyltransferase knockout porcine fetal fibroblasts for nuclear transfer

Pigs are currently considered the most likely source of organs for human xenotransplantation because of anatomical and physiological similarities to humans, and the relative ease with which they can be bred in large numbers. A severe form of rejection known as hyperacute rejection has been the major barrier to the use of xenografts. Generating transgenic pigs for organ transplantation is likely to involve precise genetic manipulation to ablate the alpha(1,3) galactosyltransferase (galT) gene. In contrast to the mouse, homologous recombination in livestock species to ablate genes is hampered by the inability to isolate functional embryonic stem cells. However, nuclear transfer using genetically targeted cultured somatic cells provides an alternative means to producing pigs deficient for galT. In this study we successfully produced galT+/- somatic porcine fetal fibroblasts using two approaches; positive negative selection (PNS) using an isogenic targeting construct, and with a promoterless vector using non-isogenic DNA.

Contrast in the efficacy of hDAF mouse hearts between ex vivo perfusion and transplantation into primates

In recent experiments, in which we compared hDAF transgenic rat hearts perfused with 15% human serum in the Langendorff device and hDAF rat hearts transplanted into cynomolgus monkeys, we demonstrated that in the ex vivo heart perfusion model both homozygous and heterozygous hDAF hearts survived longer as nontransgenic controls. Surprisingly, we found that only homozygous hDAF hearts were protected against hyperacute rejection in vivo. The first aim of this study was to determine whether perfusion of mouse hearts with higher human serum concentrations or human blood might explain some of the differences found in survival time of the recently performed experiments with rat heart xenografts. Secondly, we investigated whether the observed differences in survival times of rat xenografts between in vivo and ex vivo transplantation would also hold for mouse hearts transgenic for hDAF. An ex vivo model was used to perfuse hDAF mouse hearts and controls with human serum or blood, and hDAF transgenic hearts and controls were transplanted into cynomolgus monkeys. hDAF transgenic mouse hearts survived significantly longer than their controls when perfused with 15% human serum, but no difference was found when 30% human serum was used, or when these hearts were transplanted into cynomolgus monkeys. However, in both the in vivo and ex vivo models the amount of PMNs adhering to the vascular endothelium was significantly lower in hDAF transgenes as compared with their controls. In conclusion, in the ex vivo situation, the efficacy of hDAF transgenesis in preventing HAR is limited by serum complement concentration.

Novel functions of complex carbohydrates elucidated by the mutant mice of glycosyltransferase genes

Complex carbohydrates consist of carbohydrate moieties and protein or lipid portions, resulting in the formation of glycoproteins, proteoglycans or glycosphingolipids. The polymorphic carbohydrate structures are believed to contain profound biological implications which are important in cell-cell or cell-extracellular matrix interactions. A number of studies to delineate the roles of carbohydrates have been performed, and demonstrated definite changes in their profiles, cellular phenotypic changes or, sometimes, morphological and functional changes in tissues after modification of their structures. Recent successes in the isolation of glycosyltransferase genes and their modification enzyme genes has enabled clearer demonstrations of the roles of complex carbohydrates. In particular, genetic modification of glycosyltransferase genes in mice can elucidate the biological significances of their products in vivo. Here, we summarize recent advances in the understanding of the roles of complex carbohydrates provided from studies of gene knock-out mice of glycosyltransferase and modification enzyme genes focusing on novel functions which had not been expected.

Cardiac xenotransplantation: clinical experience and future direction

The shortage of human organs has focused research on finding an animal source of replacement organs. The immunological barriers to xenotransplantation are now more clearly defined, allowing retrospective interpretation of past clinical experience in humans. Due to physiological compatibilities as well as ethical and infectious considerations, pigs have now emerged as the most likely source of future xenografts. The introduction of transgenic pigs expressing human complement regulatory proteins and new immunosuppressive regimens have shown early promise in the laboratory, although further advancements are needed to advance to clinical trials. Additional clarification of infectious risks and patient strategies are remaining obstacles to application in the clinical arena.

An in vivo model of hyperacute rejection: characterization and evaluation of the effect of transgenic human complement inhibitors

Hyperacute rejection (HAR) occurring after transplantation within phylogenetically distant species is a severe reaction triggered by preexisting xenoreactive antibodies and complement activation, leading to the destruction of the donor organ. Expression of human complement inhibitors in transgenic pig organs prolongs the survival of xenograft in experimental models. Moreover, the extent of protection from hyperacute rejection is dependent on the level and site of expression of the transgenic molecules and, probably, on the combination of different molecules. In this regard a small animal model to test the efficacy of expression vectors and different human molecules could be very advantageous. A murine model developed in our laboratory was characterized by measurement of several parameters characteristic of HAR in the livers of control and transgenic mice expressing transgenic human DAF (CD55) or MCP (CD46) at the end of 2 h of perfusion with human plasma and after I day. The parameters studied were heamatological values of hepatic functions (GOT and GPT), induction of pro-inflammatory molecules and histopathological evaluation. Cytokines (IL-1alpha, IL-1beta, IL-6) induction and exposure of P-selectin on the endothelial cell surface, was only observed in control animals after 2 h of perfusion, as an early event. GOT and GPT values increase dramatically after 2 h perfusion and 1 day after the treatment according to the histopathological observation of liver damage. On the contrary, the livers of hDAF or hMCP transgenic mice, under the same treatment were significantly protected although the extent of this protection is dependent on the level of expression of transgenic human molecules.

Porcine MCP gene promoter directs high level expression of human DAF (CD55) in transgenic mice

Porcine membrane cofactor protein (pMCP), a complement regulatory protein, is widely expressed in various tissues. Particularly, it is highly expressed on vascular endothelium. The objective of this study was to investigate whether the pMCP gene promoter can induce efficient expression of a human complement regulatory protein, decay-accelerating factor (DAF; CD55) in transgenic mice. Two fragments of the 5'-flanking region of pMCP gene (0.9 kb and 5.4 kb) connected with human DAF minigene (0.9/hDAF and 5.4/hDAF) were used to produce transgenic mice. The expression of hDAF in heart, liver, kidney, lung, pancreas, brain and testis of the transgenic mice was examined by immunohistochemical analysis. The vascular endothelia and the nerves in all organs examined were intensely stained. The staining pattern in these tissues was similar in all transgenic mice examined regardless of the length of the promoters. The surface expression levels of hDAF on peripheral red blood cells and splenocytes from a mouse carrying 5.4/hDAF hemizygously was twice the level of expression on corresponding human cells. The red blood cells and splenocytes from the transgenic mice exhibited resistance to lysis by human serum in a manner dependent upon expressed hDAF level. The hearts from the transgenic mice functioned for a significantly longer time than those from normal mice under perfusion with human serum in the Langendorff perfusion system. These results demonstrated that the pMCP gene promoter is a good candidate of the regulatory element in the transgene to produce transgenic animals for xenotransplantation.

The target antigens of naturally occurring human anti-beta-galactose IgG are cryptic on porcine aortic endothelial cells

The identification of the xeno-antigens/xeno-antibodies combinations involved in pig-to-human xenograft rejection is an essential step for understanding this process and for the development of procedures to prevent it. Although it is widely accepted that the terminal disaccharide Galalpha1,3Gal-R is by far the major epitope recognized by human natural antibodies reactive with pig tissues, there is also evidence that other carbohydrate epitopes might be important in xenograft rejection. In an attempt to further improve our knowledge of the repertoire of human natural antibodies with anti-pig specificity we sought to determine whether naturally occurring human anti-beta-galactose IgG could interact with porcine aortic endothelial cells (PAEC). Histochemical analysis of porcine aorta sections revealed that the carbohydrate structures recognized by the anti-beta-galactose IgG are present on endothelial cells but in a cryptic form that can be unmasked by sialidase treatment. These structures were also found to be cryptic in cultured PAEC. In addition we demonstrated that PAEC may adsorb fetal calf serum (FCS) glycoproteins when cultured in FCS-supplemented medium, a process susceptible to generating artifactual observations in carbohydrate antigens analysis. In conclusion, despite their abundance, human anti-beta-galactose IgG do not represent a primary concern in pig-to-human xenotransplantation as the carbohydrate structures to which they bind are normally masked by sialic acid residues on porcine endothelial cells. However, whether these cryptic epitopes might be exposed on endothelial cells from genetically engineered animals should be further investigated because, if so, additional approaches will be needed to suppress their interaction with human anti-beta-galactose IgG.

Comparative analysis of three genetic modifications designed to inhibit human serum-mediated cytolysis

Hyperacute rejection (HAR) remains a critical immunologic hurdle in the development of xenogeneic organs for human transplantation. Strategies that simultaneously eliminate both natural antibody reactivity and complement activation on the xenogeneic cell surface may be the best approach to achieve clinical application of xenogeneic vascularized organ transplantation. We have developed multiple lines of genetically manipulated mice to evaluate the combination of different genetic approaches aimed at inhibiting antibody and complement-mediated cell lysis. We utilized transgenic mice expressing the human complement inhibitor, CD59, the human 1,2-fucosyltransferase (H-transferase, HT) and the alpha1,3-galactosyltransferase (alpha1,3-GT) knock-out mouse line (Gal KO). Our data show that expression of hCD59 in combination with HT expression or the null phenotype of alpha1,3-GT are equally effective at preventing human serum-mediated cytolysis. Interestingly, the triple combination affords no additional protective effect. Therefore, coexpression of HT and a complement inhibitor is the most immediate strategy to genetically engineer transgenic pigs to be used as xenogeneic donors.

Intracellular expression in pig cells of anti-alpha1,3galactosyltransferase single-chain FV antibodies reduces Gal alpha1,3Gal expression and inhibits cytotoxicity mediated by anti-Gal xenoantibodies

BACKGROUND

The carbohydrate structure Gal alpha1,3Gal expressed on pig cells is the major antigen recognized by xenoreactive natural antibodies in the higher primates. In xenotransplantation, natural antibodies binding to that structure initiate hyperacute rejection, and the anti-Gal alpha1,3Gal antibodies that are elicited probably take part in later phases of vascularized graft rejection. This epitope also appears to be involved in innate cellular responses. Inactivation of alpha1,3 galactosyltransferase in transgenic pigs would certainly lead to the success of xenotransplantation, but gene knockout in pigs is not feasible yet.

METHODS

As a novel strategy to inhibit alpha1,3 galactosylation, we generated recombinant single-chain Fv (ScFv) antibodies directed against pig alpha1,3-galactosyltransferase and evaluated the effect of their intracellular expression on enzyme activity and Gal alpha1,3Gal expression.

RESULTS

After in vitro transfection in pig cells, the scFv antibody anti-pig alpha1,3-galactosyltransferase reduced the amount or function of enzyme by up to 70% as evidenced by immunofluorescence and measurement of cell-associated activity. Consequently, Gal alpha1,3Gal on cell membranes was reduced to the same extent. This led to a profound (more than 90%) reduction in the cytotoxicity involving anti-Gal antibodies and complement.

CONCLUSION

Although not sufficient to knock out the overall human anti-pig natural xenoreactivity, intracellular expression of the scFv antibody anti-alpha1,3-galactosyltransferase in pig cells significantly decreases the amount of Gal alpha1,3Gal and could be important to protect cells from elicited antibodies as well as from innate effectors.

A murine model of antibody-mediated hyperacute rejection by galactose-alpha(1,3)galactose antibodies in Gal o/o mice

BACKGROUND

In pig-to-primate/human xenografts, hyperacute rejection of primarily vascularized organs usually occurs in 10-60 min and is due to the reaction of the recipients' natural antibodies with antigens expressed on the donor endothelium, the fixation of complement, and ultimately vascular stasis and hemorrhage. Surprisingly, the major target of the natural antibodies is the disaccharide galactose-alpha(1,3)galactose (Gal alpha(1,3)Gal), which is found on many different molecules in pig tissues and reacts with naturally occurring human anti-pig IgM and IgG antibodies. There are a number of strategies to remove/block/alter Gal alpha(1,3)Gal expression in pig tissues, all of which involve the expression of transgenes in pigs. To overcome the difficulty of preclinical studies using primates, we describe a model of hyperacute rejection of heart transplants to Gal o/o mice, which are similar to humans in that they have anti-Gal alpha(1,3)Gal antibodies.

METHODS

Gal o/o mice received skin or heart grafts from Gal+ mice or rats, and additional antibody and complement were provided; hyperacute rejection was monitored by observation and histology.

RESULTS

Gal alpha(1,3)Gal+ mouse tissues (skin or heart) are not rejected by Gal o/o mice. This was not unexpected, as mice do not utilize alloantibody/complement systems satisfactorily in experimental transplantation studies. However, with the addition of anti-Gal alpha(1,3)Gal antibody and complement, hyperacute rejection of hearts can occur in 10-20 min; it is mediated by IgM, not IgG, antibodies and leads predominantly to tissue hemorrhage.

CONCLUSION

Gal alpha(1,3)Gal antigen modification by expression of the H transferase cDNA leads to "indefinite" survival (>120 min) and no hyperacute rejection, which shows that this model is suitable for the study of antibody-mediated rejection of relevance to pig-to-human xenografts.

High-level co-expression of complement regulators on vascular endothelium in transgenic mice: CD55 and CD59 provide greater protection from human complement-mediated injury than CD59 alone

High-level endothelial expression of the human complement regulatory factor CD59 has been shown to protect transgenic mouse hearts from human complement-mediated injury in an ex vivo perfusion model. In this study we examine whether co-expression of CD55 provides additional protection. CD55/CD59 double-transgenic mice were generated by co-injection of CD55 and CD59 expression constructs driven by the human intercellular adhesion molecule 2 (ICAM-2) promoter. A line was established from one mouse that exhibited strong expression of CD55 and CD59 on vascular endothelium in the heart and other transplantable organs. An ex vivo perfusion model was used to compare hearts from these CD55/CD59 mice with hearts from a previously established line, which expressed CD59 at a similar level to the double transgenic line. CD59 hearts displayed prolonged survival compared to wild-type hearts during perfusion with 40% human plasma and maintained approximately 20% maximum work after 60 min. CD55/CD59 hearts were further protected, with work maintained at 35% of the maximum level after 60 min. The data demonstrate that high-level endothelial co-expression of CD55 and CD59 provides greater protection from human complement-mediated injury in this model than expression of CD59 alone.

Knock out of alpha1,3-galactosyltransferase or expression of alpha1,2-fucosyltransferase further protects CD55- and CD59-expressing mouse hearts in an ex vivo model of xenograft rejection

BACKGROUND

Organs from transgenic animals with high-level endothelial expression of the human complement regulatory factors CD55 and CD59 are significantly protected from human complement-mediated injury. Elimination or reduction of the major xenoepitope alphaGal, achieved by knocking out the alpha1,3-galactosyltransferase gene (Gal KO) or expressing human alpha1,2-fucosyltransferase (H transferase or HTF), also affords protection, although to a lesser degree. In this study, we examined whether the protection provided by strong CD55 and CD59 expression can be augmented by the Gal KO or HTF modifications.

METHODS

Hearts from four groups of mice (wild type, CD55/CD59, CD55/CD59/HTF, and CD55/CD59/Gal KO) were perfused ex vivo with 40% human plasma. Mean heart work for each group was compared over a 60-min period.

RESULTS

Wild-type hearts ceased to function effectively within 15 min of plasma addition. CD55/CD59 hearts displayed prolonged survival and maintained approximately 10% maximum work at the end of perfusion. Introduction of Gal KO or HTF onto the CD55/CD59 background resulted in a further prolongation, with work maintained at 20-30% of the maximum level.

CONCLUSIONS

We used an ex vivo model to demonstrate that eliminating alphaGal expression further prolongs the function of mouse hearts expressing high levels of CD55 and CD59. In addition, we showed that reducing alphaGal by expressing HTF is equally as effective in prolonging CD55/CD59 heart function as knocking out Gal transferase, thus providing a feasible strategy for translating these advances to the pig.