T-cell frequency analysis does not predict the incidence of graft-versus-host disease in HLA-matched sibling bone marrow transplantation

Gene expression changes in HLA mismatched mixed lymphocyte cultures reveal genes associated with allorecognition

Human leucocyte antigen (HLA) compatibility is the main factor determining the occurrence of graft‐vs‐host disease (GVHD) in patients. It has also been shown that minor histocompatibility antigen differences as well as genetic polymorphisms that are not sequenced by standard methodology for HLA typing can play a role. We used mixed lymphocyte cultures (MLCs) as a functional cellular test and investigated gene expression changes driven by HLA incompatibility in an effort to better understand the mechanisms involved in the disease. Gene expression profile of HLA matched and HLA mismatched MLC identified differentially regulated genes and pathways. We found that a great number of genes related to immune function were differentially regulated; these genes were also found to be associated with GVHD and graft rejection. The majority of differentially regulated genes were interferon‐gamma (IFNγ)‐inducible genes and IFNγ neutralisation in MLCs abrogated their induction. The microRNA‐155, a recently identified target for acute GVHD (aGVHD), was also found to be significantly induced in HLA mismatched MLC but not in the matched setting and its induction was not diminished by blocking IFNγ. In this proof‐of‐principle study we show gene expression changes in mismatched MLC that represent alloreactive responses, correlate with markers involved in GVHD and can potentially be useful in the study of the biological processes involved in this disease.

Antigen-Specific Priming is Dispensable in Depletion of Apoptosis-Sensitive T Cells for GvHD Prophylaxis

Prophylactic approaches to graft versus host disease (GvHD) have employed both phenotypic reduction of T cells and selective elimination of host-primed donor T cells in vitro and in vivo. An additional approach to GvHD prophylaxis by functional depletion of apoptosis-sensitive donor T cells without host-specific sensitization ex vivo showed remarkable reduction in GHD incidence and severity. We address the role and significance of antigen-specific sensitization of donor T cells and discuss the mechanisms of functional T cell purging by apoptosis for GvHD prevention. Host-specific sensitization is dispensable because migration is antigen-independent and donor T cell sensitization is mediated by multiple and redundant mechanisms of presentation of major and minor histocompatibility complex and tissue antigens by donor and host antigen-presenting cells. Our data suggest that potential murine and human GvH effectors reside within subsets of preactivated T cells susceptible to negative regulation by apoptosis prior to encounter of and sensitization to specific antigens.

Detection and characterisation of alloreactive T cells

T cell alloreactivity is responsible for much of the morbidity and mortality associated with tissue transplantation and graft versus host disease. Immunoassays for ex vivo monitoring and quantitation of alloreactive T cells are being increasingly utilised to provide valuable information for individualised clinical management of transplant recipients. Here we describe detailed methodologies for both traditional and novel assays utilised for the detection, quantitation, and functional characterisation of alloreactive T cells and highlight the key advantages and disadvantages of each system.

Serum proteomic profiling and haptoglobin polymorphisms in patients with GVHD after allogeneic hematopoietic cell transplantation

We studied serum proteomic profiling in patients with graft versus host disease (GVHD) after allogeneic hematopoietic cell transplantation (allo-HCT) by two-dimensional gel electrophoresis (2-DE) and mass spectrometry analysis. The expression of a group of proteins, haptoglobin (Hp), alpha-1-antitrypsin, apolipoprotein A-IV, serum paraoxonase and Zn-alpha-glycoprotein were increased and the proteins, clusterin precursor, alpha-2-macroglobulin, serum amyloid protein precursor, sex hormone-binding globulin, serotransferrin and complement C4 were decreased in patients with extensive chronic GVHD (cGVHD). Serum haptoglobin (Hp) levels in patients with cGVHD were demonstrated to be statistically higher than in patients without cGVHD and normal controls (p < 0.01). We used immunoblotting and PCR in combination with 2-DE gel image analysis to determine Hp polymorphisms in 25 allo-HCT patients and 16 normal donors. The results demonstrate that patients with cGVHD had a higher incidence of HP 2-2 phenotype (43.8%), in comparison to the patients without cGVHD (0%) and normal donors (18.7%), suggesting the possibility that specific Hp polymorphism may play a role in the development of cGVHD after allo-HCT. In this study, quantitative serum Hp levels were shown to be related to cGVHD development. Further, the data suggest the possibility that specific Hp polymorphisms may be associated with cGVHD development and warrant further investigation.

Immunodominance hierarchies and gender bias in direct T(CD8)-cell alloreactivity

Allogeneic solid organ transplantation often occurs across multiple donor-recipient HLA mismatches with consequent risk of allograft rejection. However, there is growing evidence that not all HLA mismatches are equivalent in their stimulation of allogeneic T cells making it important to determine which of these might be more significant as predictors of allograft rejection. To this end, we used defined antigen-presenting cell (APC) transfectants expressing single MHC-I allotypes as target cells that could discriminate the relative contribution of individual mismatched MHC-I allotypes to direct T-cell alloreactivity. We demonstrate remarkably reproducible patterns of immunodominance in reactivity across mismatched MHC-I allotypes. These patterns are HLA context-dependent, partly reflecting alloantigenic competition in responder cell responses. In strong alloresponses, we also observed an increased percentage of alloreactive T(CD8) cells in female responders, regardless of the stimulator gender, highlighting HLA-independent factors in the potency of the alloresponse. This approach provides a potential measure of specific alloreactive T cells that could be used in clinical practice for selection of donors, assessment of posttransplant outcomes, modulation of immunosuppression and detection of rejection episodes.

Alloreactive T cell clonotype recruitment in a mixed lymphocyte reaction: Implications for graft engineering

OBJECTIVE

The selective elimination of alloreactive T cells from donor stem cell grafts prior to hematopoietic stem cell transplantation (HSCT) is an important goal in the prevention of graft-vs-host disease (GVHD). However, in HLA-identical donor-recipient pairs, it has proven difficult to identify alloreactive T cells using in vitro systems pretransplant due, in part, to their low frequency and a lack of methodological standardization. To better understand the alloresponse between HLA-identical related pairs, we characterized the alloreactive T cells generated in a mixed lymphocyte reaction (MLR) assay system.

METHODS

HSCT donor peripheral blood mononuclear cells (responder) were labeled with carboxyfluorescein diacetate, succinimidyl ester (CFSE) dye and cocultured with irradiated HSCT recipient cells (stimulator) in a one-way MLR. Alloreactive T cells were sorted by upregulation of activation markers (CD25 in most cases) and the responding clonotypes were defined by sequencing the complementarity region 3 (CDR3) of the T cell receptor beta-chain.

RESULTS

We show that the recruitment of alloreactive CD4(+) T cells is highly variable. Oligoclonal CD4(+) T-cell expansions in repeated MLRs performed in the same donor-recipient pair showed inconsistent recruitment of clonotypes. The recruitment of alloreactive CD8(+) T cells was more consistent in repeated assays, with the same clonotypes identified in the same donor-recipient pair performed under different conditions.

CONCLUSION

Taken together, our data show that even in culture conditions constrained to eliminate background proliferation, stochastic events and low precursor frequencies preclude reproducible elicitation of immunodominant T cell clonotypes with the potential to cause GVHD.

The clinical spectrum of acute graft-versus-host disease

Acute graft-versus-host disease (GVHD), initiated by the reaction of donor T lymphocytes against nonshared recipient antigens, typically leads to a clinical syndrome characterized by cutaneous eruptions and intestinal and hepatic dysfunction. These three organ systems are considered in the clinical grading of acute GVHD. However, other targets may be involved. With conventional transplant conditioning regimens and in vivo prophylaxis, GVHD becomes clinically manifest within 2 to 4 weeks. With reduced-intensity conditioning, the onset of acute GVHD may be delayed until 2 to 3 months after transplantation. Hyperacute GVHD may occur within a week of transplantation after severely human leukocyte antigen (HLA)-mismatched transplants or transplants without GVHD prophylaxis. There is no reliable laboratory test for acute GVHD, and the diagnosis is based on clinical assessment.

Limiting Dilution Analysis of Interleukin-2 Producing Helper T-cell Frequencies as a Tool in Allogeneic Hematopoietic Cell Transplantation

BACKGROUND

A reliable in vitro test that estimates the level of ongoing alloreactivity would be valuable in allogeneic hematopoietic cell transplantation (HCT) as a help to guide clinical interventions such as donor lymphocyte infusions and changes in the immunosuppression. In the present study, the use of limiting dilution analysis of interleukin-2 (IL-2) producing helper T lymphocyte frequencies (HTL assay) as a way to quantify alloreactivity following HCT was investigated.

METHODS

Serial HTL assays were performed following allogeneic HCT with myeloablative or nonmyeloablative conditioning in 26 patients with hematologic malignancies.

RESULTS

Deviations from single-hit kinetics were frequently observed in the HTL assays and a nonlinear model was therefore used for analysis. The results of this analysis suggested the presence of an inhibitory cell population. Inhibition was observed in the majority of patients and was not restricted to a specific transplant regimen. Inhibition occurred more often with high frequencies of IL-2 producing cells, indicating a physiological role of the putative inhibitory cell population in the regulation of an immune response. Higher frequencies of IL-2 producing cells were observed in patients with acute graft-versus-host disease grades II-IV than in patients with grades 0-I (P = 0.046), indicating that the degree of ongoing alloreactivity is indeed quantified by the HTL assay.

CONCLUSIONS

We find that the HTL assay may yield interesting insight into regulation of immune responses following allogeneic HCT, but because of the complexity of the results obtained, its use as a routine procedure to guide immunosuppression cannot be recommended.

Improved detection of clinically significant host-reactive antigens prior to HLA-identical sibling peripheral blood stem cell transplantation using a dendritic cell-based helper T-lymphocyte precursor assay

SUMMARY

Graft-versus-host disease (GVHD) due to host-reactive antigenic differences between HLA-identical pairs remains an important cause of morbidity and mortality after allogeneic transplantation. The helper T-lymphocyte precursor (HTLp) assay, using peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs), has been variably shown to detect such host-reactive differences. We assessed whether using dendritic cells (DCs) as the stimulator cells would improve the ability of the HTLp assay to detect these differences. We used PBMCs (standard HTLp assay) or monocyte-derived DCs (DC-HTLp assay) as the stimulator cells for 12 HLA-identical sibling pairs undergoing allogeneic peripheral blood stem cell transplantation. HTLp frequencies were greater by the DC-HTLp assay (median 1:77 712 vs 1:727 514; P=0.008). The standard HTLp assay did not predict for acute GVHD (P=0.42), whereas a trend was noted for the DC-HTLp assay (P=0.095). Of note, of seven patients developing moderately severe to severe acute GVHD, four had a significantly greater DC-HTLp frequency compared to the standard HTLp frequency, whereas all four patients who developed no to moderate acute GVHD had similar HTLp frequencies whether PBMCs or DCs were used as the stimulator cells. Although the small number of donor/recipient pairs assessed limits the strength of any conclusions, our study suggests that the DC-HTLp assay is better able to detect clinically significant host-reactive antigenic differences between HLA-identical siblings.

The helper T lymphocyte precursor (HTLp) frequency does not predict outcome after HLA-identical sibling donor G-CSF-mobilised peripheral blood stem cell transplantation

Here, we report the first study assessing the helper T lymphocyte precursor (HTLp) frequency as a predictor of outcome in patients undergoing allogeneic PBSC transplantation. The HTLp assay uses limiting dilution analysis to measure the frequency, in PBMCs from the donor, of T lymphocytes capable of producing IL-2 in response to histocompatibility antigenic differences on PBMCs from the recipient. This assay has shown promise as a functional histocompatibility assessment used to predict the risk of recipients of HLA-matched donor bone marrow developing severe acute GVHD: the higher the HTLp frequency, the greater the significance of any histoincompatibility, and the greater the risk of severe acute GVHD. In the current report, the HTLp frequency was measured in 28 HLA-identical sibling pairs who subsequently underwent allogeneic PBSC transplantation for haematological malignancies. The HTLp frequency did not predict for acute GVHD (P = 0.38), chronic GVHD (P = 0.95), transplant-related mortality (P = 0.79), relapse (P = 0.39) or overall survival (P = 0.84). Converting the HTLp frequency to HTLp infused per kilogram of recipient body weight also did not predict for any of the outcome measures. We conclude that, although the HTLp assay may be useful for patients undergoing BMT, it does not predict for outcome after HLA-identical sibling donor G-CSF-mobilised PBSC transplantation.

The predictive value of helper T lymphocyte precursor frequencies for graft-versus-host disease and graft-versus-leukaemia effects in allogeneic bone marrow transplantation

Helper T lymphocyte precursor (HTLp) frequencies determined by limiting dilution analysis were studied in the graft-versus-host direction to assess the predictive value for outcome in allogeneic BMT. The HTLp frequencies correlated with the degree of HLA disparity. HTLp frequencies from 28 HLA-identical sibling BMT pairs had a median of 1:557 362 (range 1:9511 to <1:2 500 000). The HTLp frequencies from 20 HLA-matched unrelated and partially HLA-matched related BMT pairs had a median of 1:88 110 (range 1:4139-1:736 123). The HLA-identical sibling BMT pairs were split evenly into high and low HTLp frequency groups above and below 1:500 000. There was a trend towards a higher risk for acute GVHD > or =grade II (P = 0.075) in the high frequency group. There was no difference in TRM. The high HTLp frequency group had a significantly higher risk for chronic GVHD (P = 0.04), a significantly lower risk for relapse (P = 0.01), as well as a significantly better overall survival (P = 0.045) and leukaemia-free survival (P = 0.008). The HLA-matched unrelated and partially HLA-matched related BMT pairs were split evenly into high and low HTLp frequency groups above and below 1:90 000. There was a significantly higher risk for acute GVHD > or = grade II (P = 0.007) in the high HTLp frequency group. There was a trend towards a higher TRM in the high HTLp frequency group (P = 0.05). There were no differences in chronic GVHD, risk of relapse, overall survival and leukaemia-free survival. Analyzing all 48 patients the risk of acute GVHD > or = grade II and TRM was significantly higher (P = 0.012 and 0.021, respectively) with HTLp frequencies >1:100 000 and there was a trend towards a higher risk of relapse (P = 0.058) with low HTLp frequencies <1:400 000. Patients in the intermediate HTLp frequency group 1:100 000-1:400 000 had a trend towards improved survival (P = 0.059). The HTLp frequency seems to detect clinically significant differences in alloreactivity, that can be useful in donor selection and graft engineering.

Genes highly expressed in the early phase of murine graft-versus-host reaction

Graft-versus-host reaction (GVHR) is a complex process initiated upon allorecognition. For detection of early molecular events in GVHR, we first assessed time courses with respect to symptoms and serum interferon (IFN)-gamma levels and then used the differential display method to compare gene transcript patterns during the early phase between acute lethal GVHR mice and syngeneic controls. In the GVHR mice, high expression levels of seven genes encoding the following molecules were detected: TGTP/Mg21 (an IFN-gamma-related signaling molecule), vitronectin, Nedd5 (a mammalian septin), manganese superoxide dismutase, activin betaC subunit, PRCC (a papillary renal cell carcinoma-associated molecule), and an uncharacterized gene corresponding to a mouse expressed sequence tag (EST). The expression levels of most genes peaked before the symptomatological onset and the peak of IFN-gamma levels. Thus, gene expression monitoring may characterize the inductive process of GVHR and aid in the development of gene-based diagnostics and therapies.