Depletion of anti-gal antibodies in baboons by intravenous therapy with bovine serum albumin conjugated to gal oligosaccharides

Porcine to Human Heart Transplantation: Is Clinical Application Now Appropriate?

Cardiac xenotransplantation (CXTx) is a promising solution to the chronic shortage of donor hearts. Recent advancements in immune suppression have greatly improved the survival of heterotopic CXTx, now extended beyond 2 years, and life-supporting kidney XTx. Advances in donor genetic modification (B4GALNT2 and CMAH mutations) with proven Gal-deficient donors expressing human complement regulatory protein(s) have also accelerated, reducing donor pig organ antigenicity. These advances can now be combined and tested in life-supporting orthotopic preclinical studies in nonhuman primates and immunologically appropriate models confirming their efficacy and safety for a clinical CXTx program. Preclinical studies should also allow for organ rejection to develop xenospecific assays and therapies to reverse rejection. The complexity of future clinical CXTx presents a substantial and unique set of regulatory challenges which must be addressed to avoid delay; however, dependent on these prospective life-supporting preclinical studies in NHPs, it appears that the scientific path forward is well defined and the era of clinical CXTx is approaching.

Modifying the sugar icing on the transplantation cake

As a transplant surgeon, my interest in glycobiology began through my research into ABO-incompatible allotransplantation, and grew when my goal became overcoming the shortage of organs from deceased human donors by the transplantation of pig organs into patients with terminal organ failure (xenotransplantation/cross-species transplantation). The major target for human "natural" (preformed) anti-pig antibodies is galactose-α(1,3)-galactose (the "Gal" epitope), which is expressed on many pig cells, including the vascular endothelium. The binding of human IgM and IgG antibodies to Gal antigens initiates the process of hyperacute rejection, resulting in destruction of the pig graft within minutes or hours. This major barrier has been overcome by the production of pigs in which the gene for the enzyme α(1,3)-galactosyltransferase (GT) has been deleted by genetic engineering, resulting in GT knockout (GTKO) pigs. The two other known carbohydrate antigenic targets on pig cells for human anti-pig antibodies are (i) the product of the cytidine monophosphate-N-acetylneuraminic acid hydroxylase (CMAH) gene, i.e., N-glycolylneuraminic acid, and (ii) the product of the β1,4 N-acetylgalactosaminyltransferase gene, i.e., the Sd(a) antigen. Expression of these two has also been deleted in pigs. These genetic manipulations, together with others directed to overcoming primate complement and coagulation activation (the latter of which also relates to glycobiology) have contributed to the prolongation of pig graft survival in nonhuman primate recipients to many months rather than a few minutes. Clinical trials of the transplantation of pig cells are already underway and transplantation of pig organs may be expected within the relatively near future.

The pathobiology of pig-to-primate xenotransplantation: a historical review

The immunologic barriers to successful xenotransplantation are related to the presence of natural anti-pig antibodies in humans and non-human primates that bind to antigens expressed on the transplanted pig organ (the most important of which is galactose-α1,3-galactose [Gal]), and activate the complement cascade, which results in rapid destruction of the graft, a process known as hyperacute rejection. High levels of elicited anti-pig IgG may develop if the adaptive immune response is not prevented by adequate immunosuppressive therapy, resulting in activation and injury of the vascular endothelium. The transplantation of organs and cells from pigs that do not express the important Gal antigen (α1,3-galactosyltransferase gene-knockout [GTKO] pigs) and express one or more human complement-regulatory proteins (hCRP, e.g., CD46, CD55), when combined with an effective costimulation blockade-based immunosuppressive regimen, prevents early antibody-mediated and cellular rejection. However, low levels of anti-non-Gal antibody and innate immune cells and/or platelets may initiate the development of a thrombotic microangiopathy in the graft that may be associated with a consumptive coagulopathy in the recipient. This pathogenic process is accentuated by the dysregulation of the coagulation-anticoagulation systems between pigs and primates. The expression in GTKO/hCRP pigs of a human coagulation-regulatory protein, for example, thrombomodulin, is increasingly being associated with prolonged pig graft survival in non-human primates. Initial clinical trials of islet and corneal xenotransplantation are already underway, and trials of pig kidney or heart transplantation are anticipated within the next few years.

Molecular deciphering of the ABO system as a basis for novel diagnostics and therapeutics in ABO incompatible transplantation

In recent years ABO incompatible kidney transplantation (KTx) has become a more or less clinical routine procedure with graft and patient survival similar to those of ABO compatible transplants. Antigen-specific immunoadsorption (IA) for anti-A and anti-B antibody removal constitutes in many centers an important part of the treatment protocol. ABO antibody titration by hemagglutination is guiding the treatment; both if the recipient can be transplanted as well as in cases of suspected rejections if antibody removal should be performed. Despite the overall success of ABO incompatible KTx, there is still room for improvements and an extension of the technology to include other solid organs. Based on an increased understanding of the structural complexity and tissue distribution of ABH antigens and the fine epitope specificity of the ABO antibody repertoire, improved IA matrices and ABO antibody diagnostics should be developed. Furthermore, understanding the molecular mechanisms behind accommodation of ABO incompatible renal allografts could make it possible to induce long-term allograft acceptance also in human leukocyte antigen (HLA) sensitized recipients and, perhaps, also make clinical xenotransplantation possible.

Qualitative and quantitative comparison of N-glycans between pig endothelial and islet cells by high-performance liquid chromatography and mass spectrometry-based strategy

N-glycan structures released from miniature pig endothelial and islet cells were determined by matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization time-of-flight (MALDI-TOF), negative ion electrospray ionization (ESI) MS/MS and normal-phase high performance liquid chromatography (NP-HPLC) combined with exoglycosidase digestion. Totally, the identified structures were 181 N-glycans including 129 sialylated and 18 alpha-galactosylated glycans from pig endothelial cells and 80 N-glycans including 41 sialylated and one alpha-galactosylated glycans from pig islet cells. The quantity of the alpha-galactosylated glycans from pig islet cells was certainly neglectable compared to pig endothelial cells. A number of NeuGc-terminated N-glycans (80 from pig endothelial cells and 13 from pig islet cells) are newly detected by our mass spectrometric strategies. The detailed structural information will be a matter of great interest in organ or cell xenotransplantation using alpha 1,3-galactosyltransferase gene-knockout (GalT-KO) pig.

Galectin-3-mediated xenoactivation of human monocytes

BACKGROUND

Delayed xenograft rejection (DXR) remains a roadblock to successful xenotransplantation. A feature of DXR is early recruitment of monocytes to the xenograft. Naïve human monocytes can recognize and adhere to unstimulated porcine aortic endothelial cells (PAEC) more than human aortic endothelial cells, partly due to endothelial expression of the xenoantigen galactose-alpha(1,3)galactose-beta(1,4)GlcNAc-R (alpha-gal). Previous work from our laboratory has implicated galectin-3 as a candidate molecule on monocytes involved in initial recognition and adhesion of human monocytes to PAEC.

METHODS

Flow cytometry was used to analyze monocyte activation and galectin-3 accumulation in PAEC. Reactive oxygen intermediate production was analyzed using dihydrorhodamine measured in a fluorescence plate reader. Western blotting was performed to determine galectin-3 secretion and expression by human monocytes. Immunofluorescence staining for the tight junction protein zona occludens-1 was used as a measure of PAEC monolayer integrity.

RESULTS

We demonstrate that galectin-3 can be secreted from monocyte intracellular stores on contact with alpha-gal. Soluble galectin-3 binds PAEC partly by expression of alpha-gal. Binding is reduced on endothelium derived from alpha-gal knockout animals, but not completely. Competing terminal sugars expressed on human aortic endothelial cells such as sialic acid, may block galectin-3 binding. Furthermore, soluble galectin-3 activates monocytes in an autocrine/paracrine manner. Blocking galectin-3 reduces the activation of human monocytes. Finally, the inhibition of galectin-3 reduces monocyte-mediated endothelial injury on co-culture with PAEC.

CONCLUSION

Galectin-3 plays a role in human monocyte activation and adhesion in the presence of PAEC, which may contribute to DXR. Additional transgenic strategies targeting galectin-3 ligands on porcine endothelium may be required to achieve optimal xenograft survival.

Achieving tolerance in pig-to-primate xenotransplantation: reality or fantasy

Because the immunologic differences between species are far greater than those within species, it is likely that the amount of immunosuppression that would be required for successful xenografting would be so much greater than that now used for allografting, that the side-effects and complications would be unacceptable. Tolerance approaches to xenotransplantation would overcome this concern. Studies in humanized mouse models have demonstrated that human T cells can be tolerized to porcine xenografts, providing important proofs of principle of the potential feasibility of pig-to-primate xenograft tolerance. The results available from studies of pig-to-primate xenotransplantation to date have demonstrated that while chronic immunosuppressive drugs have not completely avoided either T cell responses or humoral rejection, approaches directed toward tolerance induction have been encouraging with regard to avoiding immunization at both of these levels.

Pig-to-non-human primate heart transplantation: immunologic progress over 20 years

The major developments in pig-to-non-human primate heart xenotransplantation during the past 20 years are summarized, largely through the experience of one investigator. Genetic modifications to organ-source pigs have been important steps in increasing heart xenograft survival from a few minutes in 1986 to 2 to 6 months in 2005.

Allosensitization does not increase the risk of xenoreactivity to alpha1,3-galactosyltransferase gene-knockout miniature swine in patients on transplantation waiting lists

BACKGROUND

The recent availability of alpha1,3-galactosyltransferase knockout (GalT-KO) miniature swine has eliminated anti-Gal antibodies as the major barrier to xenotransplantation, potentially bringing this modality closer to clinical application. Highly-allosensitized patients, who have poor prospects of receiving a suitable cross-match negative human organ, might be the first patients to benefit from xenotransplantation of porcine organs. However, concerns exist regarding cross-reactivity of alloreactive anti-human leukocyte antigen (HLA) antibodies against xenogeneic swine leukocyte antigen (SLA) antigens. We have investigated this question using sera from such patients on GalT-KO target cells.

METHODS

Using flow cytometry and complement-dependent cytotoxicity (CDC) assays, we have tested a panel of 88 human serum samples from patients awaiting cadaveric renal allotransplantation for reactivity against: 1) human; 2) standard miniature swine; and 3) GalT-KO peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL) and cultured endothelial cells.

RESULTS

Anti-swine IgM and IgG antibody binding, as well as CDC, were significantly attenuated on GalT-KO versus standard swine. No correlation was found between the degree of anti-human panel reactive antibodies (PRA) and xenoreactivity against either standard or GalT-KO miniature swine. Treatment of sera with dithiothreitol (DTT) showed that the majority of remaining lymphocytotoxicity against GalT-KO swine was mediated by preformed IgM antibodies. Patients with high alloreactivity but low anti-GalT-KO xenoreactivity were readily identified.

CONCLUSIONS

Highly allosensitized patients awaiting renal transplants appear to be at no increased risk of xenosensitization over their non-sensitized cohorts, and could therefore be candidates for xenotransplantation using GalT-KO swine donors.

Characterization of Anti-Gal Antibody-Producing Cells of Baboons and Humans

BACKGROUND

Anti-Gal antibodies cause hyperacute and delayed xenograft rejection in pig-to-primate transplantation. The cell populations producing anti-Gal and other natural antibodies in primates are unknown.

METHODS

Cells from different lymphoid compartments of naïve or sensitized baboons were examined for anti-Gal and total Ig production by ELISPOT. B and plasma cells from humans and baboons were purified by FACS sorting and characterized for anti-Gal and total Ig production and cytology.

RESULTS

In naïve baboons, the spleen was the major source of anti-Gal IgM-secreting cells. Two months after sensitization with porcine tissues, high frequencies of anti-Gal IgM- and IgG-secreting cells were detected in the spleen, lymph nodes, and bone marrow. Six months after antigen exposure, anti-Gal IgM- and IgG-secreting cells were preferentially localized in the bone marrow. Cells from human spleen, bone marrow, and blood were also analyzed and anti-Gal IgM-secreting cells were detected mainly in the spleen. Sorting of baboon and human cells showed that anti-Gal IgM-secreting cells were mainly splenic B cells (CD20+, CD138-, and Ig+). Although low in percentage, sorted CD20-CD138+ plasma cells in spleen and bone marrow secreted large quantities of anti-Gal IgM. Most anti-Gal IgG-secreting cells were plasma cells (CD138+) at both early (Ig+) and late (Ig-) stages of differentiation.

CONCLUSIONS

Similar to Gal knockout mice, natural anti-Gal IgM antibodies in primates are produced mainly by splenic B cells. After antigen exposure, anti-Gal IgM and IgG were secreted by both B and plasma cells. These results suggest strategies to remove xenoreactive antibody-secreting cells prior to transplantation.

Similarities in the immunoglobulin response and VH gene usage in rhesus monkeys and humans exposed to porcine hepatocytes

Background

The use of porcine cells and organs as a source of xenografts for human patients would vastly increase the donor pool; however, both humans and Old World primates vigorously reject pig tissues due to xenoantibodies that react with the polysaccharide galactose α (1,3) galactose (αGal) present on the surface of many porcine cells. We previously examined the xenoantibody response in patients exposed to porcine hepatocytes via treatment(s) with bioartficial liver devices (BALs), composed of porcine cells in a support matrix. We determined that xenoantibodies in BAL-treated patients are predominantly directed at porcine αGal carbohydrate epitopes, and are encoded by a small number of germline heavy chain variable region (V_H) immunoglobulin genes. The studies described in this manuscript were designed to identify whether the xenoantibody responses and the IgV_H genes encoding antibodies to porcine hepatocytes in non-human primates used as preclinical models are similar to those in humans. Adult non-immunosuppressed rhesus monkeys (Macaca mulatta) were injected intra-portally with porcine hepatocytes or heterotopically transplanted with a porcine liver lobe. Peripheral blood leukocytes and serum were obtained prior to and at multiple time points after exposure, and the immune response was characterized, using ELISA to evaluate the levels and specificities of circulating xenoantibodies, and the production of cDNA libraries to determine the genes used by B cells to encode those antibodies.

Results

Xenoantibodies produced following exposure to isolated hepatocytes and solid organ liver grafts were predominantly encoded by genes in the V_H3 family, with a minor contribution from the V_H4 family. Immunoglobulin heavy-chain gene (V_H) cDNA library screening and gene sequencing of IgM libraries identified the genes as most closely-related to the IGHV3-11 and IGHV4-59 germline progenitors. One of the genes most similar to IGHV3-11, V_H3-11^cyno, has not been previously identified, and encodes xenoantibodies at later time points post-transplant. Sequencing of IgG clones revealed increased usage of the monkey germline progenitor most similar to human IGHV3-11 and the onset of mutations.

Conclusion

The small number of IGV_H genes encoding xenoantibodies to porcine hepatocytes in non-human primates and humans is highly conserved. Rhesus monkeys are an appropriate preclinical model for testing novel reagents such as those developed using structure-based drug design to target and deplete antibodies to porcine xenografts.

The effect of soluble complement receptor type 1 on acute humoral xenograft rejection in hDAF-transgenic pig-to-primate life-supporting kidney xenografts

BACKGROUND

In pig-to-nonhuman primate solid organ xenotransplantation using organs from donors transgenic for human decay-accelerating factor (hDAF), the main type of rejection is antibody-mediated (acute humoral xenograft rejection, AHXR). This occurs despite the complement-regulatory function of the transgene, neutralization of natural antibodies to Galalpha1-3Gal (Gal) using soluble glycoconjugates, and chronic immunosuppression. As complement components play a major role in graft destruction after antibody binding, we evaluated the efficacy of chronic complement inhibition by soluble complement receptor type 1 (TP10).

METHODS

Life-supporting hDAF-transgenic kidney transplantation was performed in cynomolgus monkeys, using cyclophosphamide induction, and maintenance immunosuppression with cyclosporin A, mycophenolate sodium, and tapering steroids. Rejection was treated with bolus steroid injections: if not successful animals were terminated. Three groups were studied: in group 1 (n=4) GAS914 (a soluble glycoconjugate comprising Gal on a poly-L-lysine backbone) was added before and after transplantation; group 2 (n=2) received GAS914 as in group 1 and in addition TP10 before and after transplantation; in group 3 (n=4) GAS914 was only given before transplantation and TP10 as in group 2. Monitoring included the regular assessment of anti-porcine antibodies, complement activity (soluble C5b-9), therapeutic drug monitoring, and graft histology.

RESULTS

Survival in group 1 was 6, 12, 31 and 37 days, respectively, and in all four cases graft histology showed AHXR. The two animals in groups 2 survived 3 and 15 days, respectively, and similarly showed AHXR in graft histology. In group 3 two animals showed AHXR (10 and 37 days survival, respectively), and two others did not show AHXR (20 and 32 days survival, respectively). The diagnosis AHXR included the deposition of complement activation products in the graft, which were present at lower intensity in animals treated with TP10. In all animals GAS914 effectively neutralized circulating anti-Gal antibody. Antibodies were detectable in the circulation of all animals using porcine erythrocytes in a hemolytic assay, although at lower levels than before transplantation. Soluble C5b-9 was not detectable in the circulation of animals receiving TP10, and circulating TP10 concentrations in these animals were in a presumed pharmacologically active range.

CONCLUSIONS

The inclusion of TP10 in the immunosuppressive protocol does not clearly lead to improved xenograft survival. Despite effective neutralization of anti-Gal antibodies and effective inhibition of systemic complement activity, AHXR was apparent in four of six animals under chronic TP10 treatment, including deposits of complement activation products in the graft. Apparently, effective systemic complement inhibition by TP10 in combination with local complement regulation by the hDAF transgene product does not necessarily result in effective inhibition of complement activation at locations in the xenograft upon binding of anti-porcine antibodies to the grafted endothelium.

Hyperacute rejection of hDAF-transgenic pig organ xenografts in cynomolgus monkeys: influence of pre-existing anti-pig antibodies and prevention by the alphaGAL glycoconjugate GAS914

BACKGROUND

Our introductory pig-to-cynomolgus monkey heart or kidney transplantation using organs from pigs transgenic for human decay-accelerating factor (hDAF), showed a high incidence of hyperacute rejection (HAR), which was ascribed to extraordinary high levels of anti-pig antibodies. We evaluated the efficacy of GAS914, a Gal alpha 1-3Gal trisaccharide linked to a poly-l-lysine backbone, in inhibition of HAR.

METHODS

hDAF transgenic heterotopic heart (n = 15) or life-supporting kidney (n = 8) transplantation included induction with cyclophosphamide or anti-thymocyte globulin, and maintenance with cyclosporine or tacrolimus, steroids and mycophenolate sodium/mofetil. Four doses of GAS914 were given before transplantation. Rejection was confirmed by graft histology, and anti-pig antibody levels were determined in various assays.

RESULTS

Four of six heart transplants without GAS914 treatment showed HAR. Nine subsequent transplants with GAS914 pre-treatment, did not show HAR (chi-square, P < 0.05). Two of four kidney transplants without GAS914 treatment ended with HAR. Four subsequent transplants with GAS914 did not show HAR. Animals with HAR showed extremely high antibody levels. Samples just before transplantation showed significantly higher antibody levels in recipients presenting with HAR. In all assays antibody levels were significantly lowered by GAS914 pre-treatment.

CONCLUSIONS

HAR of hDAF solid organs could be ascribed to high levels of anti-pig antibodies. It is hypothesized that the hDAF transgene shows a threshold in efficacy, above which an overwhelming attack by antibodies and complement activation cannot be modulated to prevent HAR. HAR does not occur when animals with lower levels are used, or when antibodies are effectively depleted from the circulation by GAS914 treatment.

Thrombotic microangiopathy and graft arteriopathy in pig hearts following transplantation into baboons

BACKGROUND

Acute humoral xenograft rejection (AHXR) is an immunologic barrier in pig-to-baboon organ transplantation (Tx). We report microvascular thrombosis and myocardial necrosis in a series of cardiac xenografts.

METHODS

Ten baboons underwent heterotopic heart Tx from pigs transgenic for human decay-accelerating factor. Recipients were treated with soluble Gal glycoconjugates and multiple immunosuppressive agents. Grafts were removed when palpable contractions stopped. Stained tissue sections from harvested grafts were analyzed by light and fluorescence microscopy.

RESULTS

Xenograft survival ranged from 4 to 139 (mean 37, median 27) days. Some histology was typical for AHXR (n = 4; median survival 22 days). Hemorrhage and edema were only focal in the longer-surviving grafts (n = 4, median survival 54 days). All grafts had multiple platelet-rich fibrin thrombi occluding myocardial vessels. Ischemic damage was manifested by contraction band necrosis in four grafts, myocytolysis in eight, coagulative necrosis in nine, and patchy myocyte dropout in all grafts. A notable paucity of interstitial mononuclear cells was observed in all grafts. Marked intimal thickening resembling that of allograft vasculopathy was observed in one graft. Immunofluorescence showed immunoglobulin (Ig)G and/or IgM deposition in five grafts. Multivessel C4d deposition appeared in seven grafts. Significant C3 deposition was absent.

CONCLUSIONS

Cardiac xenograft survival in the pig-to-baboon model can be significantly prolonged by vigorous immunosuppressive treatment of recipient animals. Additional efforts to block humoral activation of graft endothelial cells and/or to overcome species-specific molecular coagulation pathway incompatibilities may prevent the development of microvascular thrombosis and myocardial infarction. Cardiac xenograft vasculopathy (chronic rejection) can occur with prolonged graft survival.

A novel monoclonal antibody inhibits the immune response of human cells against porcine cells: identification of a porcine antigen homologous to CD58

BACKGROUND

Human CD58 is an adhesion molecule that interacts with CD2 on lymphocytes. We describe here an antibody that blocks responses of human peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs) to porcine cells and reacts with a porcine protein with homology to CD58.

METHODS

Antibodies were isolated with a screen for inhibition of the human antiporcine response. One of these antibodies was used for immunoaffinity purification of a protein that was identified by molecular weight determination, endoglycosidase sensitivity, and microsequencing analysis as a porcine homologue of CD58.

RESULTS

The antigen recognized by this antibody was a cell surface protein of relative molecular mass (Mr)=45,000 containing N-linked carbohydrate chains. Immunoaffinity purification of this protein and microsequencing revealed homology to sheep CD58 as well as sequences that were common to this protein and both sheep and human CD58. The protein was widely distributed on porcine cells, including lymphocytes, endothelial cells, muscle cells, and neuronal cells. This antibody efficiently inhibited lysis of porcine targets by human PBMCs in addition to preventing proliferation of the human PBMCs in response to the porcine cells.

CONCLUSIONS

The CD2 interaction with porcine cells is important for the efficient recognition of porcine tissue, and inhibition of the human antiporcine immune response with the antibody is likely to be caused by the disruption of the human CD2 interaction with this porcine homologue of CD58. The antibody may prove to be useful for the blocking of this interaction without interfering with other functions of T cells.

Suppression of natural and elicited antibodies in pig-to-baboon heart transplantation using a human anti-human CD154 mAb-based regimen

Natural and elicited antipig antibodies (Abs) lead to acute humoral xenograft rejection (AHXR). Ten baboons underwent heterotopic heart transplantation (Tx) from human decay-accelerating factor (hDAF) pigs. Depletion of anti-Galalpha1, 3Gal (Gal) Abs was achieved by the infusion of a Gal glycoconjugate from day-1. Immunosuppression included induction of antithymocyte globulin, thymic irradiation, and cobra venom factor, and maintenance with a human antihuman CD154 mAb, mycophenolate mofetil, and methylprednisolone; heparin and prophylactic ganciclovir were also administered. Pig heart survival ranged from 4 to 139 (mean 37, median 27) days, with three functioning for >50 days. Graft failure (n = 8) was from classical AHXR [4], thrombotic microangiopathy [3], or intragraft thrombosis [1], with death (n = 2) from pneumonia [1], or possible drug toxicity (with features of thrombotic microangiopathy) [1]. Anti-Gal Abs (in microg/mL) were depleted by Gal glycoconjugate before graft implantation from means of 41.3 to 6.3 (IgM) and 12.4-4.6 (IgG), respectively, and at graft excision were 6.3 and 1.7 microg/mL, respectively. No elicited Abs developed, and no cellular infiltration was seen. The treatment regimen was effective in maintaining low anti-Gal Ab levels and in delaying or preventing AHXR. The combination of costimulatory blockade and heparin with Tx of a Gal-negative pig organ may prolong graft survival further.

Reduction of anti-Galα1,3Gal antibodies by infusion of types 2 and 6 gal trisaccharides conjugated to poly-l-lysine

To investigate the specificity of anti-Galalpha1,3Gal (Gal) antibodies (Abs) with respect to Gal oligosaccharides of types 2 and 6, eight baboons received an intravenous infusion of either a poly-l-lysine conjugate of Gal type 2 (n = 5) or type 6 (n = 3), followed 48 h later by the alternative Gal type 6 or 2 conjugate, respectively. IgM Abs reactive to Gal type 2 were depleted by 80 to 89% by either Gal conjugate. IgM reactive to Gal type 6 was less efficiently depleted by the Gal type 2 conjugate (57% depletion) than the Gal type 6 (82% depletion). Gal-reactive IgG was depleted more slowly and less efficiently by either glycoconjugate (initially by only 28 to 54%). Our results indicate that the Gal type 6 conjugate depletes most anti-Gal IgM, but the Gal type 2 conjugate is less efficient in depleting anti-Gal IgM reactive with type 6. There remain small fractions of antibody that are unadsorbed, particularly of IgG, probably due to their low affinity and distribution in both the intra- and extra-vascular compartments.

Feasibility of xeno-transplantation

Within a relatively short time span, a significant number of barriers to xeno-transplantation have been identified and potential solutions generated; however, the survival rates for pig-to-primate heart transplantation remain modest at best, with the longest functioning heterotopic heart transplant surviving only 99 days and the longest functioning orthotopic heart transplant surviving only 39 days. A great deal of improvement in immunological strategies will be needed to make xeno-transplantation a clinical reality. The most exciting prospect in the near term is the use of organs from homozygous alphaGal knockout pigs. The diversity of the biological pathways involved in the total spectrum of xenograft rejection, however, makes it highly likely that the clinical feasibility of xeno-transplantation will depend on a multipronged approach that incorporates the advantages of genetically eliminating the alphaGal epitope on hyperacute and acute xenograft rejection and the advantages of tolerance induction on cellular and chronic xenograft rejection.

Initial investigation of the potential of modified porcine erythrocytes for transfusion in primates

There is a shortage of human blood for transfusion. The possibility of using alpha-galactosidase-treated pig red blood cells (pRBCs) for transfusion into humans has been investigated. pRBCs were treated in vitro with alpha-galactosidase. In vitro binding of antibodies (Abs) in baboon or human sera to untreated/treated pRBCs was assessed by flow cytometry and serum cytotoxicity. In vivo clearance rates of (1) autologous baboon red blood cells (RBCs), (2) unmodified pRBCs, and (3) alpha-galactosidase-treated pRBCs were measured after transfusion into baboons receiving either no treatment or depletion of complement +/- depletion of anti-Gal alpha 1-3Gal (Gal) Ab or of macrophage phagocytes. In vitro binding of baboon or human Abs to treated pRBCs was absent or minimal compared with untreated pRBCs, and serum cytotoxicity was completely inhibited. In vivo autologous baboon RBCs survived for >16 days and unmodified pRBCs for <15 min in an untreated baboon. Treated pRBCs survived for 2 h in an untreated baboon, for 24 h in a complement-depleted baboon, and for 72 h when the baboon was depleted of both complement and anti-Gal Ab, or of complement and macrophage phagocytes. All baboons, however, became sensitized to Gal antigens. Failure to prolong the in vivo survival of treated pRBCs could be due to inadequate removal of Gal epitopes because sensitization to Gal developed, or could imply other, as yet unidentified, causes for RBC destruction. To fully assess the potential of pRBC transfusion in humans, more complete alpha-galactosidase treatment of pRBCs will be required.

Pig kidney transplantation in baboons treated intravenously with a bovine serum albumin-Galα1-3Gal conjugate

The maintenance of depletion of antibody (Ab) reactive with Galalpha1-3Gal (Gal) on pig vascular endothelial cells by the intravenous (i.v.) infusion of a synthetic Gal conjugate has been proposed as a means of delaying Ab-mediated rejection of transplanted pig organs in primates. We have therefore studied the effect of the continuous i.v. infusion of bovine serum albumin conjugated to multiple synthetic Gal type 6 oligosaccharides (BSA-Gal) on anti-Gal Ab levels and on graft survival in baboons undergoing pig kidney transplantation. Group 1 baboons (n=3) underwent extracorporeal immunoadsorption of anti-Gal Ab, a cyclophosphamide (CPP)-based immunosuppressive regimen, and a non-transgenic pig kidney transplant. Group 2 (n=2) were treated identically to Group 1 but, in addition, received a continuous i.v. infusion of BSA-Gal. Group 3 (n=2) were treated identically to Group 2, but without CPP. A single baboon (Group 4) underwent extracorporeal immunoadsorption, a CPP-based regimen, and continuous i.v. BSA-Gal therapy for 28 days, but did not receive a pig kidney transplant. Two of the transplanted pig kidneys in Group 1 were excised on post transplant days 7 and 13 for a rejected ureter, and disseminated intravascular coagulation (DIC), respectively. The third baboon died of sepsis on day 6. All transplanted ureters and kidneys showed some histopathologic features of acute humoral xenograft rejection. Group 2 baboons were euthanized on days 8 and 11, respectively, for liver failure. At autopsy, there were histopathological features of widespread liver necrosis, but the pig kidneys and ureters showed no features of rejection. The pig kidneys in Group 3 baboons were excised for renal vein thrombosis (day 9) and DIC (day 12); there was no histological signs of rejection in the pig kidneys or ureter, although there were focal areas of modest liver injury in one baboon on biopsy. The single Group 4 baboon showed no biochemical or histological features of liver injury. Anti-Gal Ab levels returned in Group 1, but were maintained at negligible levels in the baboons in Groups 2 to 4 that received BSA-Gal therapy. Continuous i.v. therapy with BSA-Gal is largely successful in maintaining depletion of circulating anti-Gal antibodies and in preventing or delaying Ab deposition and acute humoral xenograft rejection in porcine grafts, but may be associated with liver injury when administered in the presence of a pig kidney transplant and CPP therapy. The mechanism of the hepatic injury remains uncertain.

Clinical xenotransplantion--how close are we?

CONTEXT

Xenotransplantation with pig organs offers a medium-term solution to the shortage of organs available for clinical transplantation. The immunological barriers to xenotransplantation have been, and remain, formidable. In the early 1990s, the identification of Galalpha1,3Gal (Gal) as the main target for human xenoreactive (anti-pig) antibodies and the development of pigs transgenic for a human complement regulatory protein, decay-accelerating factor (hDAF), were major advances. The presence of hDAF on the vascular endothelium of pig organs provided some protection against complement-mediated hyperacute rejection. This protection, however, was short-lived, and, until recently, the longest median time for organ survival that had been achieved (with combinations of biological and pharmacological immunosuppressants) in a series of pig-to-primate organ transplants was under a month.

STARTING POINT

Christopher McGregor and colleagues recently reported to the International Society of Heart and Lung Transplantation (J Heart Lung Transplant 2003; 22: S89) that, by combining the use of organs which express hDAF with the administration of a soluble Gal glycoconjugate and other immunosuppressive agents, the survival of pig hearts in baboons can be extended to a median of 76 days. McGregor's work suggests that immunological barriers to xenotransplantation are not insurmountable. WHERE NEXT? The recent generation of pigs that do not express Gal epitopes (alpha1,3-galactosyltransferase gene-knockout pigs) might remove the need both for the expression of hDAF and the administration of a soluble Gal glycoconjugate. The absence of a natural antibody response will allow investigation of the cellular immune response and of any molecular incompatibilities between pig and primate that may be detrimental to graft survival. Furthermore, the absence of a humoral response may open the way for the induction of immunological tolerance (or unresponsiveness in the absence of exogenous immunosuppression) to a transplanted pig organ.

Depletion of anti-Gal antibodies by the intravenous infusion of Gal type 2 and 6 glycoconjugates in baboons

BACKGROUND

Natural anti-Gal antibodies (NAb) to Gal epitopes play a key role in the rejection of pig cells or organs transplanted into primates. We have investigated the effect on NAb return after extracorporeal immunoadsorption (EIA) of the continuous intravenous (i.v.) infusion of (i) bovine serum albumin conjugated to Gal type 6 oligosaccharides (BSA-Gal) or (ii) a poly l-lysine backbone conjugated to Gal type 2 or 6 oligosaccharides (PLL-Gal).

METHODS

Porcine mobilized peripheral blood progenitor cells (PBPC) obtained by leukapheresis from MHC-inbred miniature swine (n = 9) were infused intravenously (i.v.) into baboons: Group 1 baboons (n = 4) received whole body and thymic irradiation, splenectomy, antithymocyte globulin, cobra venom factor, cyclosporine, mycophenolate mofetil, anti-CD154mAb, porcine hematopoietic growth factors, and EIA before transplantation of high doses (2 to 4 x 1010 cells/kg) of PBPC; Group 2 baboons (n = 3) received the Group 1 regimen plus a continuous i.v. infusion of BSA-Gal for up to 30 days; Group 3 baboons (n = 5) received the Group 1 regimen plus a continuous i.v. infusion of PLL-Gal type 2 (n = 2) or both PLL-Gal types 2 and 6 (n = 3) for up to 30 days.

RESULTS

Group 1: NAb returned to pre-PBPC levels within 20-30 days, but there was no induction of antibody to Gal or non-Gal determinants; Group 2: NAb was undetectable or at very low level during BSA-Gal therapy. In one baboon, however, IgG to Gal type 2, but not to type 6, returned during BSA-Gal therapy; Group 3: NAb was undetectable or at very low level during PLL-Gal therapy. In two baboons that received PLL-Gal type 2, NAb to Gal type 6, but not to type 2, returned during PLL-Gal treatment. Two of five baboons, however, developed systemic infection. Four of five baboons died within 14 days; autopsy revealed focal hemorrhagic injury to their hearts, lungs, and small intestines, with histologic abnormalities that varied between animals from hemorrhage and/or thrombosis in some organs (heart, lungs, or intestine) to signs of infections (bacteria in intestine, cytomegalovirus in liver).

CONCLUSIONS

(i) BSA-Gal and PLL-Gal therapy maintained depletion of NAb. (ii) Some heterogeneity in specificity of NAb was identified, indicating that the infusion of a combination of Gal type 2 and 6 glycoconjugates may be required. (iii) The addition of PLL-Gal to the immunosuppressive regimen was associated with a high incidence of morbidity and mortality without a clear histopathologic entity underlying the cause of death.

Pathology of xenograft rejection: a commentary

Trends in solid organ xenograft pathology are presented, with the focus on pig-to-nonhuman primate models. A simplified classification of rejection is followed, including hyperacute rejection (HAR), acute humoral xenograft rejection (AHXR), and acute cellular xenograft rejection (ACXR). The main components in HAR are natural xenoreactive antibodies in combination with complement activation. This is evident from the prevention of HAR in recipients in whom either antibodies or complement activation is depleted or inhibited. However, these strategies generally fail to prevent AHXR, which occurs later. AHXR is a multifactorial process in which natural and elicited antibodies may play roles, possibly in conjunction with complement, coagulation factors, and white blood cells. A main target appears to be the microvasculature which, in kidney grafts, is associated with a glomerular thrombotic microangiopathy. It is not clear to what extent species-specific physiologic disparities in complement and coagulation processes may play a role, separate from antibody-initiated processes. As rejection of solid organ xenografts is currently from AHXR, ACXR has not yet received close attention. In addition to intragraft rejection events, systemic complications following host-graft interactions have emerged, including (often fatal) consumptive coagulopathy and immune complex disease. It is anticipated that rejection processes will change when pigs with new genetic modifications become available. For instance, the precise role of natural antibodies to Galalpha1,3Gal will be able to be distinguished from other factors when pigs that lack the target antigen are available, and their organs can be evaluated in large animal xenotransplantation models.

Porcine cytomegalovirus and coagulopathy in pig-to-primate xenotransplantation

BACKGROUND

A rapidly progressive disorder termed consumptive coagulopathy (CC) has been observed frequently in pig-to-baboon renal xenotransplantation. CC may be initiated by endothelial activation and induction of procoagulant factors after immunologic injury or infection, or by molecular incompatibilities between porcine coagulation proteins and primate clotting factors. The activation of porcine (P) cytomegalovirus (PCMV) and baboon (B) CMV infections has been documented in pig-to-primate xenotransplantation. The purpose of this study was to determine the contribution of PCMV and BCMV to CC.

METHODS

Endothelial activation was assessed by means of measurement of porcine tissue factor (pTF) in a functional assay in primary porcine aortic endothelial cells (PAEC) in vitro. Renal xenografts and native kidneys were studied by immunohistochemistry in immunosuppressed swine and baboons. BCMV and PCMV DNA was measured by quantitative molecular assays using real-time polymerase chain reaction.

RESULTS

In vitro, infection of PAEC with PCMV resulted in a significant increase of pTF expression. In vivo, pTF increase occurred without the activation of PCMV in two xenografts, and in four grafts no pTF was detected despite PCMV activation. All animals with graft pTF increase developed CC. BCMV activation in the baboon xenograft recipients did not correlate with CC or pTF increase. Control pigs and baboons had activation of PCMV and BCMV, respectively, but without coagulation abnormalities.

CONCLUSIONS

PCMV induces endothelial cell activation in vitro with procoagulant expression. However, in vivo, CC and pTF induction has an uncertain relationship to increased replication of PCMV within a xenograft. Although the data do not exclude a contributory role of PCMV in CC, other mechanisms are also likely to contribute to coagulopathies observed in pig-to-primate xenotransplantation.

Removal of anti-Galalpha1,3Gal xenoantibodies with an injectable polymer

Preformed and elicited Ab's against the Galalpha1,3Gal terminating carbohydrate chains (alphaGal Ab's) are the primary cause of hyperacute and acute vascular xenograft rejection in pig-to-primate transplantation. alphaGal Ab's are produced by long-lived Ab-producing cells that are not susceptible to pharmacological immunosuppression. We reasoned that antigen-specific elimination of alphaGal Ab's might be achieved in vivo by systemic administration of nonimmunogenic polyvalent alphaGal structures with high avidity for alphaGal Ab's. We devised GAS914, a soluble trisaccharide-polylysine conjugate of approximately 500 kDa that effectively competes for alphaGal binding by alphaGal IgM (IC(50), 43 nM) and IgG (IC(50), 28 nM) in vitro. Injections of GAS914 in cynomolgus monkeys, at the dose of 1 mg/kg, resulted in the immediate decrease of more than 90% of circulating alphaGal Ab's and serum anti-pig cytotoxicity. In baboons, repeated injections of GAS914 effectively reduced both circulating alphaGal Ab's and cytotoxicity over several months. Studies with [(14)C]GAS914 in rhesus monkeys and Gal(-/-) mice indicate that GAS914 binds to circulating alphaGal Ab's and that the complex is quickly metabolized by the liver and excreted by the kidney. Remarkably, posttreatment alphaGal Ab titers never exceeded pretreatment levels and no sensitization to either alphaGal or the polylysine backbone has been observed. Furthermore there was no apparent acute or chronic toxicity associated with GAS914 treatment in primates. We conclude that GAS914 may be used therapeutically for the specific removal of alphaGal Ab's.

Removal of anti-Galalpha1,3Gal xenoantibodies with an injectable polymer

Preformed and elicited Ab's against the Galalpha1,3Gal terminating carbohydrate chains (alphaGal Ab's) are the primary cause of hyperacute and acute vascular xenograft rejection in pig-to-primate transplantation. alphaGal Ab's are produced by long-lived Ab-producing cells that are not susceptible to pharmacological immunosuppression. We reasoned that antigen-specific elimination of alphaGal Ab's might be achieved in vivo by systemic administration of nonimmunogenic polyvalent alphaGal structures with high avidity for alphaGal Ab's. We devised GAS914, a soluble trisaccharide-polylysine conjugate of approximately 500 kDa that effectively competes for alphaGal binding by alphaGal IgM (IC(50), 43 nM) and IgG (IC(50), 28 nM) in vitro. Injections of GAS914 in cynomolgus monkeys, at the dose of 1 mg/kg, resulted in the immediate decrease of more than 90% of circulating alphaGal Ab's and serum anti-pig cytotoxicity. In baboons, repeated injections of GAS914 effectively reduced both circulating alphaGal Ab's and cytotoxicity over several months. Studies with [(14)C]GAS914 in rhesus monkeys and Gal(-/-) mice indicate that GAS914 binds to circulating alphaGal Ab's and that the complex is quickly metabolized by the liver and excreted by the kidney. Remarkably, posttreatment alphaGal Ab titers never exceeded pretreatment levels and no sensitization to either alphaGal or the polylysine backbone has been observed. Furthermore there was no apparent acute or chronic toxicity associated with GAS914 treatment in primates. We conclude that GAS914 may be used therapeutically for the specific removal of alphaGal Ab's.