Velopharyngeal insufficiency

Surgery for Velopharyngeal Insufficiency Following Cleft Palate Repair: An Audit of Contemporary Practice and Proposed Schema of Techniques and Variations

OBJECTIVE

Surgical treatment of velopharyngeal insufficiency (VPI) includes a wide array of procedures. The purpose of this study was to develop a classification for VPI procedures and to describe variations in how they are performed.Design/participants/setting/outcomes: We completed an in-depth review of the literature to develop a preliminary schema that encompassed existing VPI procedures. Forty-one cleft surgeons from twelve hospitals across the USA and Canada reviewed the schema and either confirmed that it encompassed all VPI procedures they performed or requested additions. Two surgeons then observed the conduct of the procedures by surgeons at each hospital. Standardized reports were completed with each visit to further explore the literature, refine the schema, and delineate the common and unique aspects of each surgeon's technique.

RESULTS

Procedures were divided into three groups: palate-based surgery; pharynx-based surgery; and augmentation. Palate-based operations included straight line mucosal incision with intravelar veloplasty, double-opposing Z-plasty, and palate lengthening with buccal myomucosal flaps. Many surgeons blended maneuvers from these three techniques, so a more descriptive schema was developed classifying the maneuvers employed on the oral mucosa, nasal mucosa, and muscle. Pharynx-based surgery included pharyngeal flap and sphincter pharyngoplasty, with variations in design for each. Augmentation procedures included palate and posterior wall augmentation.

CONCLUSIONS

A comprehensive schema for VPI procedures was developed incorporating intentional adaptations in technique. There was substantial variation amongst surgeons in how each procedure was performed. The schema may enable more specific evaluations of surgical outcomes and exploration of the mechanisms through which these procedures improve speech.

Surgical Management of Submucous Cleft Palate by Radical Muscle Dissection Veloplasty: Speech Outcomes in Patients with 22q11.2 Deletion Syndrome

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the benefit of anatomical muscle dissection repair for velopharyngeal insufficiency (VPI) in patients with submucous cleft palate (SMCP) with 22q11.2 deletion syndrome.

DESIGN

Retrospective blinded randomised analysis of a surgeon's management over 10 years.

SETTING

The study was performed at a specialised Paediatric hospital in the United Kingdom.

PATIENTS

Children with SMCP and 22q11.2 deletion syndrome.

INTERVENTIONS

All participants underwent radical muscle dissection veloplasty.

OUTCOMES MEASURED

Pre- and post- operative measurements included severity of anatomical defect, speech samples and lateral images which were digitised, randomised then externally and blindly analysed using validated techniques. Stata software was used to perform statistical analysis.

RESULTS

57 children with 22q11.2 deletion syndrome were included in this analysis. Intra-operatively, the majority of cases were identified as SMCP Grade I anomalies. Post-operatively, a statistically significant improvement in hypernasality, resting palate length, palate length at maximum closure, palate excursion and gap size at maximum closure was observed. Secondary surgery was performed for 59% of patients by ten years.

CONCLUSION

Muscle dissection repair improves hypernasality, palate closure function and the closure gap in patients with 22q11.2 deletion syndrome. Although over 50% of patients may require further surgery, muscle dissection repair should be a first step due to its utility at a younger age, when invasive investigations are impossible, its lower morbidity, speech and language benefits or altering the plans for less obstructive secondary surgery when it lead to reduced velo-pharyngeal gap and improved palate mobility even when adequate velo-pharyngeal closure was not achieved.

Velopharyngeal incompetence following transoral robotic surgery for oropharyngeal carcinoma: A scoping review

PURPOSE

Following transoral robotic surgery (TORS) for oropharyngeal carcinoma (OPC), velopharyngeal incompetence (VPI) is a known consequence that may contribute to swallowing and speech disorders. As the incidence of OPC increases affecting a younger demographic, a better understanding of VPI is required to support speech and swallowing rehabilitation.

METHOD

A scoping review was conducted using Arskey & O'Malley's framework. Studies were identified from five databases between 2007 and 2020. The methodological quality was measured with the RevMan Risk of Bias Tool by two independent evaluators.

RESULT

A total of seven studies met the inclusion criterion. There was a combined total of 306 participants, their average age was 59.2 years. A high risk of bias and degree of heterogeneity across all seven cohort studies was observed. Validated and instrumental evaluations of VPI were present in two papers, with the majority only reporting the presence or absence of VPI. The incidence of VPI reported in each study ranged from 0 to 53%, (median 3.5%).

CONCLUSION

There are few high-quality studies and considerable heterogeneity in the terminology, inclusion criteria and measurement of VPI. Instrumentation, to date, has been rarely used but is necessary for a normed and validated approach to VPI. Based on this review, there is considerable need for larger studies which instrumentally and longitudinally assess VPI as a consequence of TORS, in order to guide patient education and management prior to, and following their surgery.

Paediatric velopharyngeal insufficiency following adenotonsillar surgery

OBJECTIVE

Paediatric velopharyngeal insufficiency (VPI) is a known but rare complication following adenotonsillar surgery that can have significant adverse effects on the communication as well as psychological well-being of the patient and their family. We sought to assess risk factors, aetiology, assessment and management of these patients through a dedicated multidisciplinary clinic.

METHODS

Retrospective data collection was performed for patients seen in the Great Ormond Street Hospital for Children multidisciplinary VPI clinic from the 1^st of January 2015 until 30^th of April 2020. Paediatric patients with previous adenotonsillar surgery and no evidence of cleft palate or speech and language disorder were included in the study.

RESULTS

29 patients met the inclusion criteria, with 16 having previous adenotonsillectomy and 13 isolated adenoidectomy. In our VPI clinic, patients were seen on average for 4.9 occasions over a 38.3-month period. Clinical assessment was conducted using GOS.SP.ASS '98 speech assessment tool, speech videofluoroscopy and nasoendoscopy, as per individual needs. The main cause of post-adenoidectomy VPI was identified in 72.5% of the cases. Speech videofluoroscopy was performed in 27 cases. Associated anatomic features identified included deep pharynx (37%), long palate (22.2%) and variable levator position. Severe hypernasality was noted in 3 patients, while in 20 cases moderate or mild hypernasality was found. There were no patients with normal speech. Ten patients were treated with speech therapy alone, whereas surgical intervention was required in seventeen cases. In the population who received treatment and had adequately recorded follow-up, improvement in speech was noted in 86.9%, with 30.4% having oral resonance on last review. Of the patients with severe hypernasality, all improved but had some persistent hyper nasality on last clinic review.

CONCLUSIONS

We present our multidisciplinary management of post adenoidectomy VPI. Through the investigations in our dedicated specialist VPI clinic, the cause of VPI was found more frequently than in previous reports in the literature. Intense treatment is usually required with lengthy follow-up and multiple attendances in VPI clinic. Main modalities of management include SLT, surgery and speech prostheses. Most patients' speech will improve with intervention. We highlight the importance of early recognition, referral and a multi-disciplinary approach in treating this condition. We advise ENT surgeons to ensure patients are adequately aware of this complication given its potential impact.

Comparison of Real-Time Speech Magnetic Resonance Imagings With Perceptual Speech Analysis in Evaluation Velopharyngeal Sphincter Function

ABSTRACT

Identifying substantial data and their normative values related to velopharyngeal structures in cleft palate patients may have clinical significance, in order to selection of surgical intervention and prediction of postsurgical outcomes. Previous studies are lack of referring certain anatomic locations or distances that may have affect on speech intelligibility, especially in dynamic state. The aim of this study is to investigate effectiveness of magnetic resonance imagings on the velopharyngeal sphincter function and the correlation with speech intelligibility after functional cleft palate repair. Seventeen patients with repaired cleft palate by single surgeon were enrolled in this study.Quantitative velopharyngeal measures from the oblique coronal plane and midsagittal plane in static and dynamic positions were collected. Patients' speech intelligibility was evaluated by using Pittsburgh Weighted Speech Scale and nasalance score was also measured. Correlation analysis methods were used for evaluating relation between MRI gathered measurements and speech intelligibility scores for determiningconsequential data.Our study shows that the velar knee-posterior pharyngeal wall distance measurement while explosive sound production is the most related data with speech intelligibility. Although future works with more sample number is needed, according to current study the authors think magnetic resonance imagings is a very helpful method in providing reliable information.

Musculo-mucous web velum and velopharyngeal dysfunction associated with 8q22.1-22.2 microduplication

This report presents a rare case of isolated non-cleft velopharyngeal dysfunction (VPD). An eight-year-old child presented 1. a phenotypically unique band-gap pattern of the velar musculature with anteroposterior insertion; 2. a mosaic partial trisomy on chromosome 19 as well as microduplications on chromosomes 8 and 22. Following cytogenetic analysis, microduplication on chromosome 8 was found in another member of her family. A family history of VPI with hypernasality and nasal regurgitation was reported over three different generations on the patient's maternal side. Since only one case of velum malformation is found in this family, we cannot conclude to a link between the palatal anomaly or VPD and the DNA rearrangements.

Nasoseptal flap for palatal reconstruction after hemi-maxillectomy: case report

OBJECTIVE

Palatal reconstruction following maxillectomy is a surgical challenge, and a nasoseptal flap is a feasible approach. This paper reports the first known successful clinical case of a nasoseptal pedicle flap applied for the reconstruction of maxillary bone following hemi-maxillectomy.

CASE REPORT

This report describes hemi-maxillectomy in a 60-year-old Italian male diagnosed with stage IV squamous cell carcinoma of the left maxilla. Endoscopic transnasal extended medial maxillectomy was performed, followed by a transoral modified midfacial degloving technique for removal of the maxillary bone. The contralateral nasoseptal pedicle flap was used to reconstruct the defect. The case was followed up prospectively for the assessment of flap reception and healing.

CONCLUSION

The locally accessible nasoseptal flap is a viable alternative for palatal reconstruction; therefore, a second surgical procedure with its associated donor site morbidity can be avoided. Large-scale studies may help in establishing the cosmetic and functional outcomes.

Health-related quality of life in patients with cleft palate: Validity and reliability of the VPI Effects on Life Outcomes (VELO) questionnaire translated to Dutch

BACKGROUND

Disease-specific health-related quality of life (HRQOL) questionnaires provide the clinician with important information regarding the impact of the disease on functioning and well-being. For patients with velopharyngeal insufficiency (VPI), the VPI Effects on Life Outcomes (VELO) questionnaire was developed and validated in English by Skirko et al. (2012). However, a valid and reliable Dutch translation of this questionnaire is not available yet.

METHODS

The English questionnaire was translated to Dutch following a forward-backward translation procedure. A linguistic validation and the evaluation of the internal consistency (Cronbach's α) of this Dutch version were performed based on the responses of 39 parents of patients with cleft (lip and) palate (mean age: 6.8 years) (parent report) and the responses of 14 patients older than 8 years (mean age: 9.5 years) (child report). Additionally, the concurrent validity was assessed by comparing the scores on the parent report to those on the pediatric voice handicap index. Furthermore, the validity of the parent proxy assessment and the relationship between age and responses on the VELO questionnaire were investigated. Based on the responses of an age and gender matched control group without cleft palate, the discriminant validity was evaluated.

RESULTS

The parent report was easy to complete for all parents. Nine of the fourteen (64%) patients were able to complete the child report independently. The median scores on the parent report and the child report were 82.7 and 95.1 respectively. The patient group had a significantly worse perception of HRQOL compared to the control group (p < 0.001; p = 0.029). There were no significant differences between the responses of the parent and their child's (p = 0.345). A significant positive correlation was found between the score on the parent report and the age of the patients (p = 0.001). Furthermore, a significant negative correlation was found between the parent report and the P-VHI (p < 0.001). Cronbach's α was 0.955 and 0.817 for the parent report and the child report respectively.

CONCLUSION

The Dutch VELO questionnaire is a valid, reliable and user-friendly tool that provides important information about HRQOL in patients with cleft (lip and) palate.

Negative dystonia of the palate: a novel entity and diagnostic consideration in hypernasal speech

OBJECTIVE

To present the first documented series of patients with negative dystonia (ND) of the palate, including clinical symptoms, functional MRI findings, and management options.

STUDY DESIGN

Case series ascertained from clinical research centers that evaluated patients with both hyperkinetic and hypokinetic movement disorders.

METHODS

Between July 1983 and March 2013, data was collected on patient demographics, disease characteristics, functional MRI findings, long-term management options, and outcomes. We sought patients whose clinical examination demonstrated absent palatal movement on speaking, despite normal palatal activity on other activities.

RESULTS

Five patients (2 males, 3 females) met clinical criteria. All patients presented with hypernasal speech without associated dysphagia. Clinical examination revealed absent palatal movement on speaking despite intact gag reflexes, normal palate elevation on swallowing, and normal cranial nerve examinations. Other cranial and/or limb dystonias were present in four patients (80.0%). Three patients (60.0%) had previously failed oral pharmacologic therapy. Two patients underwent functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) studies, which demonstrated an overall decrease of cortical and subcortical activation during production of symptomatic syllables and asymptomatic coughing. Management included speech therapy (all patients) and palatal lift (2 patients) with limited improvement. Calcium hydroxyapatite injection (1 patient) into the soft palate and Passavants' ridge was beneficial.

CONCLUSIONS

This is the first report of ND of the palate. Characteristic findings were task-specific absent palatal movement with speech, despite normal movement on swallowing, coughing, and an intact gag reflex, as well as disorder-specific decreased brain activation on functional MRI. A diagnosis of ND of the palate should be considered for patients who present with hypernasal speech.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

4.

Effect of central inset pharyngeal flap for velopharyngeal insufficiency on eustachian tube function

OBJECTIVES/HYPOTHESIS

The aim of this study was to assess the effect of the central inset pharyngeal flap, used for correcting persistent velopharyngeal incompetence after cleft palate repair, on Eustachian tube (ET) function.

METHODS

This study included 28 patients who were diagnosed with persistent velopharyngeal insufficiency following primary cleft palate repair, together with otitis media with effusion (OME) and/or ET dysfunction that failed to improve after the primary palatoplasty and extensive medical treatment. Diagnosis of velopharyngeal insufficiency (VPI) in these cases was performed by video nasoendoscopy and speech assessment. Prior to and after surgery, patients were assessed through otoscopic, tympanometric, and audiometric evaluation.

RESULTS

All postoperative otoscopic findings were significantly better than preoperative (P < 0.05) finding, except for tympanic membrane (TM) calcification (P > 0.05). Postoperative tympanometry revealed type A curve (normal) in 30 ears (53.6%), with significant improvement in ET function after this type of flap (P < 0.001).

CONCLUSION

ET can be improved after performing the superiorly based flap with new central inset in patients with persistent VPI following palatoplasty. Thus, there is no need for surgical interference to manage OME in these cases, except after trying this technique.

Cadaveric study of the posterior pedicle nasoseptal flap: a novel flap for reconstruction of pharyngeal defects and velopharyngeal insufficiency

BACKGROUND

The posterior pedicle nasoseptal flap has been the workhorse for endoscopic reconstruction of medium to large cranial base defects, with excellent outcomes and minimal flap failures. The authors present the anatomical foundations for the use of the nasoseptal flap for reconstruction of soft palate and pharyngeal defects and for surgical treatment of velopharyngeal insufficiency in a cadaveric model.

METHODS

Posterior pedicle nasoseptal flaps were endoscopically harvested and transposed to the naso/oropharynx in seven cadavers. The reach and relationships of the flap with nasopharyngeal and oropharyngeal structures were documented.

RESULTS

A total of nine nasoseptal flaps (bilateral in two specimens) were transposed into the nasopharynx and oropharynx. The most anterior aspect of the flap was visualized transorally several millimeters inferior to the soft palate in all specimens. Six flaps were sutured transorally to the posterior pharyngeal wall and three were sutured to defects of the soft palate. The width of a fully harvested flap (entire septal mucosa) was more than twice the width of the posterior nasopharyngeal/oropharyngeal wall in all specimens. Nasoseptal flaps were easily tailored endoscopically and transorally with standard instrumentation to fit the defects.

CONCLUSIONS

In a cadaveric model, the nasoseptal flap can be transposed into the nasopharynx and upper oropharynx and is a potential alternative for pharyngeal reconstruction and surgical treatment of velopharyngeal insufficiency in patients in whom traditional flaps are not available. The application of this technique for reconstruction of pharyngeal and velar defects is novel, and further studies evaluating clinical outcomes are needed.

Velopharyngeal insufficiency: high detection rate of genetic abnormalities if associated with additional features

OBJECTIVE

To review the clinical and molecular-genetic characteristics of 34 children who were referred to the clinical genetics department with a presenting diagnosis of definite or suspected velopharyngeal insufficiency (VPI, defined as the inability to close off the nasal from the oral cavity during speech) or hyponasal/hypernasal speech. All the patients referred also had additional anomalies and did not therefore comprise the whole VPI population.

METHODS

Patients were clinically investigated by a clinical geneticist. Fluorescent in situ hybridisation for chromosome 22q11 deletion and/or array comparative genomic hybridisation (array CGH) analysis was performed in all cases. A literature review was performed using the Pubmed online database.

RESULTS

Microdeletions or microduplications were identified in half of the patients. Six patients (∼18% of total) carried a chromosome 22q11 microdeletion, one patient had a chromosome 22q11 microduplication, and four patients had microdeletions in other chromosomes that were considered likely to be associated with the phenotype. One patient had KBG syndrome. Thus, an underlying genetic abnormality was found in approximately one-third (35%) of our patients. An additional seven patients harboured copy number variations that were considered benign or of unknown significance.

CONCLUSIONS

We present an overview of patients with VPI or hyponasal/hypernasal speech with additional anomalies and their clinical and genetic findings. In one-third of these patients, an underlying genetic abnormality was identified. This has important implications for family counselling and medical follow-up. Furthermore, we recommend array CGH testing in all patients with VPI and associated anomalies because of the high percentage of copy number variants identified in these patients.

A review of the evaluation and management of velopharyngeal insufficiency in children

This article highlights the most common causes of velopharyngeal insufficiency (VPI), and discusses routine evaluation and treatment algorithms for the management of VPI in children. VPI is a multifactorial condition that occurs commonly in syndromic and non-syndromic children. The most common features of VPI are audible hypernasal speech, facial grimacing, decreased speech intelligibility, nasal regurgitation, and nasal emission from failure to produce oronasal separation. Work-up of VPI typically involves radiologic and endoscopic testing performed with the assistance of a speech-language pathologist. Management of VPI involves initial speech therapy followed by operative repair with sphincter or pharyngeal flap pharyngoplasty, if needed.

Lateral Pharyngeal Wall and Velar Movement and Tailoring Velopharyngeal Surgery: Determinants of Velopharyngeal Incompetence Resolution in Patients with Cleft Palate

BACKGROUND

After primary palatoplasty, patients with cleft palate may still require secondary surgical procedures to correct residual velopharyngeal incompetence. This study evaluated speech outcomes of patients who underwent differential velopharyngeal surgery based on degree of lateral pharyngeal wall movement and velar movement.

METHODS

In this retrospective cohort study, 31 patients with cleft palate from 1992 to 2003 underwent tailor-made velopharyngeal surgery with complete preoperative and postoperative speech assessments. All patients were evaluated postoperatively for velopharyngeal incompetence resolution, persistent velopharyngeal incompetence, and hyponasality.

RESULTS

Velopharyngeal incompetence was resolved in 90 percent of patients. Severe hyponasality occurred as a complication in 16 percent, requiring subsequent division of the pharyngeal flap. Patients with lateral pharyngeal wall movement greater than 25 percent had a significantly greater chance of incompetence resolution compared with those with lateral pharyngeal wall movement less than 25 percent (p < 0.001). Regarding combined lateral pharyngeal wall movement plus velar movement, all groups showed significantly lower velopharyngeal competence scores following surgery (p < 0.001). Patients with lateral pharyngeal wall movement less than 25 percent and velar movement greater than 50 percent had the least successful speech outcome. The data also showed that various types of surgical operations performed on patients with similar combined degrees of lateral pharyngeal wall movement and velar movement can result in equally successful speech outcomes. This finding indicated flexibility in following the treatment algorithm for tailoring velopharyngeal surgery.

CONCLUSION

The degree of lateral pharyngeal wall movement and velar movement, rather than type of surgical procedure chosen, is a more important determinant of velopharyngeal incompetence resolution in patients with cleft palate.

Cerclage sphincter pharyngoplasty: a new technique for velopharyngeal insufficiency

OBJECTIVES

Several surgical techniques are available for the treatment of velopharyngeal insufficiency (VFI). Each method has its own complications and non-dynamic roles. So the aim of this study was to present a novel physiological surgical technique designed by the author for reconstruction of the velopharyngeal sphincter in VFI.

METHODS

This prospective study included six patients with VFI (two males and four females) with ages from 5 to 20 years (mean: 12.50 years). Speeches, nasopharyngeal and oral endoscopies for velopharyngeal valve closure were measured according to a 5-point scale where 0 was equivalent to normal and 4 meant a severe (constant) deviation. They were scheduled for cerclage sphincter pharyngoplasty after failure of appropriate speech therapy. Under general anaesthesia and the patient in semiflower's position; two level cerclages (1-0 polypropylene suture materials) were inserted behind the muscles of the velopharynx. The first at the level of junction of posterior and middle one-thirds of the soft palate passing through soft palate, left lateral pharyngeal wall, posterior pharyngeal wall, right lateral pharyngeal wall and the soft palate. The second was at 3mm in front of the latter. The surgical technique was described in details.

RESULTS

Before surgery five patients (83.3%) had sever hypernasality (rating scale 3). After the cerclage operation and speech therapy four patients (66.6%) significantly improved to normal nasality (rating scale 0) and the remaining two patients improved to mild and moderate hypernasality (rating scale 1 and 2), respectively (p<0.05). By endoscopy the closing activity was (rating scale 3) in five patients (83.3%) and (rating scale 2) in one patient (18%). After the cerclage operation and speech therapy five patients (83.3%) changed significantly to complete closure (rating scale 0) and to (rating scale 1) in one patient (p<0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

Cerclage sphincter pharyngoplasty is a new procedure designed by the author in VFI. It helps the velopharynx to function physiologically in three-dimensional patterns without dependency on the type of closure. Also it is an easy technique; without tissue flaps transfer, upper airway obstruction or hyponasality.