HIV-1–Specific CD4 Helper Function in Persons With Chronic HIV-1 Infection on Antiviral Drug Therapy as Measured by ELISPOT After Treatment With an Inactivated, gp120-Depleted HIV-1 in Incomplete Freund's Adjuvant:

Comparative evaluation of oral and intranasal priming with replication-competent adenovirus 5 host range mutant (Ad5hr)-simian immunodeficiency virus (SIV) recombinant vaccines on immunogenicity and protective efficacy against SIV(mac251)

Oral, replication-competent Ad-HIV vaccines are advancing to human trials. Previous evaluation of protective efficacy in non-human primates has primarily followed upper respiratory tract administrations. Here we compared sequential oral (O/O) versus intranasal/oral (I/O) priming of rhesus macaques with Ad5 host range mutant-SIV recombinants expressing SIV env/rev, gag, and nef genes followed by boosting with SIV gp120 protein. Cellular immune responses in PBMC were stronger and more frequent after I/O administration. Both groups developed mucosal immunity, including memory cells in bronchial alveolar lavage, and gut-homing receptors on PBMC. Following intrarectal SIV(mac251) challenge, both groups exhibited equivalent, significant protection and robust post-challenge cellular immunity. Our results illustrate the promise of oral replication-competent Ad-recombinant vaccines. Pre-challenge PBMC ELISPOT and proliferative responses did not predict protection in the O/O group, highlighting the need for simple, non-invasive methods to reliably assess mucosal immunity.

Statistical positivity criteria for the analysis of ELISpot assay data in HIV-1 vaccine trials

The enzyme-linked immunospot (ELISpot) assay is one of the leading technologies used to measure cellular responses in many settings including HIV vaccine clinical trials. HIV-1-specific effector T lymphocyte responses are considered necessary in the control of infection. Accurate measurement and summary of cellular immune responses are critical to HIV research. ELISpot assay readout is often dichotomized into positive/negative responses according to some pre-specified criteria. Given the increase in the number of replicates used for each stimulation with current assay configurations in the HIV Vaccine Trials Network (HVTN) laboratories, a new approach is now possible. We propose an objective criteria based on a hypothesis-driven method that controls the false positive rate while maintaining sensitivity to each of the antigen-specific responses under study. The new approach is compared to other commonly employed criteria using real and simulated data.

Enhanced HIV-1 specific immune response by CpG ODN and HIV-1 immunogen-pulsed dendritic cells confers protection in the Trimera murine model of HIV-1 infection

We have recently developed a novel small animal model for HIV-1 infection (Ayash-Rashkovsky et al., http://www.fasebj.org/cgi/doi/10.1096/fj.04-3184fje; doi:10.1096/fj.04-3184fje). The mice were successfully infected with HIV-1 for 4-6 wk with different clades of either T- or M-tropic isolates. HIV-1 infection was accompanied by rapid loss of human CD4+ T cells, decrease in CD4/CD8 ratio, and increased T cell activation. HIV specific human humoral and cellular immune responses were observed in all HIV-1 infected animals. In the present study, HIV specific human immune responses, both humoral and cellular, were generated in noninfected Trimera mice, after their immunization with gp120-depleted HIV-1 antigen, presented by autologous human dendritic cells. Addition of CpG ODN to the antigen-pulsed DCs significantly enhanced (by 2- to 30-fold) the humoral and cellular HIV-1 specific immune responses. Only mice immunized with the HIV-1 immunogen and CpG were completely protected from infection with HIV-1 after challenge with high infection titers of the virus. This novel small animal model for HIV-1 infection may thus serve as an attractive platform for rapid testing of candidate HIV-1 vaccines and of adjuvants and may shorten the time needed for the development and final assessment of protective HIV-1 vaccines in human trials.

Loss of HIV-1-specific CD8+ T cell proliferation after acute HIV-1 infection and restoration by vaccine-induced HIV-1-specific CD4+ T cells

Virus-specific CD8(+) T cells are associated with declining viremia in acute human immunodeficiency virus (HIV)1 infection, but do not correlate with control of viremia in chronic infection, suggesting a progressive functional defect not measured by interferon gamma assays presently used. Here, we demonstrate that HIV-1-specific CD8(+) T cells proliferate rapidly upon encounter with cognate antigen in acute infection, but lose this capacity with ongoing viral replication. This functional defect can be induced in vitro by depletion of CD4(+) T cells or addition of interleukin 2-neutralizing antibodies, and can be corrected in chronic infection in vitro by addition of autologous CD4(+) T cells isolated during acute infection and in vivo by vaccine-mediated induction of HIV-1-specific CD4(+) T helper cell responses. These data demonstrate a loss of HIV-1-specific CD8(+) T cell function that not only correlates with progressive infection, but also can be restored in chronic infection by augmentation of HIV-1-specific T helper cell function. This identification of a reversible defect in cell-mediated immunity in chronic HIV-1 infection has important implications for immunotherapeutic interventions.

Progress on new vaccine strategies against chronic viral infections

Among the most cost-effective strategies for preventing viral infections, vaccines have proven effective primarily against viruses causing acute, self-limited infections. For these it has been sufficient for the vaccine to mimic the natural virus. However, viruses causing chronic infection do not elicit an immune response sufficient to clear the infection and, as a result, vaccines for these viruses must elicit more effective responses--quantitative and qualitative--than does the natural virus. Here we examine the immunologic and virologic basis for vaccines against three such viruses, HIV, hepatitis C virus, and human papillomavirus, and review progress in clinical trials to date. We also explore novel strategies for increasing the immunogenicity and efficacy of vaccines.

Therapeutic immunization with an inactivated HIV-1 Immunogen plus antiretrovirals versus antiretroviral therapy alone in asymptomatic HIV-infected subjects

To determine whether the addition of an inactivated-gp120-depleted HIV-1 Immunogen to antiretrovirals (ARTs) conferred a beneficial effect on delaying time to virologic failure relative to that obtained by ARTs alone, a phase II clinical trial was performed in 243 asymptomatic, ART naïve, HIV-1 seropositive adults. The Cox model showed that HIV-1 Immunogen treatment was associated with a 34% decrease in the risk of virologic failure (P = 0.056). When the analysis incorporated baseline HIV-RNA stratification the risk of virologic failure in the HIV-1 Immunogen Arm was significantly reduced a 37% compared to the IFA placebo Arm (P = 0.034). The data suggest that therapeutic immunization plus ARTs could influence virologic control.

Evaluation of Elispot assays: influence of method and operator on variability of results

In this study, a comprehensive comparative analysis of different evaluation methods of Elispot plates was performed. Three investigators using three different evaluation approaches read 50 randomly selected wells at three different time points. The methods were: (1) manual evaluation using a stereomicroscope, (2) automated evaluation using an image analysis reader system with reading parameters established by each investigator, and (3) automated evaluation using a reader system with preset reading parameters using assay-specific controls. We demonstrate that manual evaluation had the highest variability both within the same method and when comparing all methods, followed by automated evaluation with investigator-dependent parameters. The variability was low only when all investigators used the same parameters established using assay-specific controls. This variability was independent of operator or spot number per well. Based on this study, recommendations for standardization and validation procedures of Elispot assay performance and evaluation procedures are presented.

Augmentation of HIV-1-specific T helper cell responses in chronic HIV-1 infection by therapeutic immunization

OBJECTIVE

To determine whether therapeutic immunization with a whole inactivated HIV-1 immunogen augments HIV-1-specific T helper cell responses in chronically infected individuals receiving suppressive antiretroviral therapy (ART).

DESIGN

An investigator-initiated, single center, double-blind, placebo-controlled, randomized trial.

METHODS

Subjects selected for study were HIV-1-infected adults on ART with an HIV-1-RNA plasma viral load of less than 500 copies/ml for at least 6 months, and a CD4 cell count greater than 250 cells/mm3 before starting ART. Study subjects were randomly assigned to receive either immunogen (inactivated envelope-depleted HIV-1 coupled with incomplete Freund's adjuvant; IFA), versus placebo (IFA alone). The primary outcome was significant CD4 cell lymphoproliferative responses to HIV-1 proteins. Secondary endpoints included HIV-1-specific CD8 T cell responses, CD4 cell count/percentage, HIV-1-RNA plasma viral load, and delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH) responses.

RESULTS

The augmentation of HIV-1-specific T helper cell responses was achieved in five out of five vaccine recipients and none out of four controls (P = 0.008, Fisher's exact test). There were no significant changes in the breadth or magnitude of cytotoxic T lymphocyte responses, CD4 cell count/percentages, or DTH test responses.

CONCLUSION

HIV-1-specific T helper cell responses can be successfully increased by therapeutic immunization in individuals with chronic infection on suppressive ART. Further studies will be needed to determine whether the augmentation of these responses correlate with long-term clinical benefits.

Generation of Th1 immune responses to inactivated, gp120-depleted HIV-1 in mice with a dominant Th2 biased immune profile via immunostimulatory [correction of imunostimulatory] oligonucleotides--relevance to AIDS vaccines in developing countries

Vaccination against HIV-1 of hosts with a dominant Th2 immune profile may fail to induce essential protective Th1 immune responses. By using Schistosoma-infected mice, with a pre-existent Th2 immune background, we demonstrate that oligodeoxynucleotides (ODN) containing unmethylated cytosine-phosphate-guanosine (CpG) immunostimulatory sequences co-administered with inactivated, gp120-depleted HIV-1 viral particles (HIV-1 immunogen) lead to potent Th1 anti-HIV-1 immune responses overcoming the Th2 bias. In contrast, Schistosoma-infected mice immunized with HIV-1 immunogen in incomplete Freund's adjuvant only, induced Th2 anti-HIV-1 immune responses. These findings strongly support the advisability of using CpG ODN as a Th1 inducing adjuvant when immunizing human populations with a strong pre-existent Th2 immune profile.

Therapeutic vaccination against chronic viral infections

Chronic viral infections such as those caused by hepatitis B virus, human papilloma virus, herpes simplex virus, and HIV, in theory, present logical targets of active specific immunotherapy. Indeed, immunological mechanisms are involved in several aspects of their pathogenesis and natural course, such as virus persistence, destruction of infected cells and control of viral replication. Therapeutic vaccination could therefore be an adequate replacement for, or adjunct to, existing therapies. Almost all approaches to therapeutic vaccination have been evaluated in those four disease areas. Despite encouraging results in animals none of these attempts has, so far, been completely successful in the human setting. However, with a better understanding of the immunological mechanisms involved in the control of disease successful therapeutic vaccines, used alone or in combination with other therapies, are an achievable goal.

Alternative strategies for anti-HIV treatment

New HIV treatment strategies are needed. Over the past year, substantial progress has been made in the development of new antiretroviral agents, although the journey from drug discovery to wide clinical use is completed by only a small number of medications. Strategies to enhance immune control and either discontinue or decrease the need for prolonged HAART are under study. The promising preliminary results in very early PHI are in contrast with the minor successes in chronic infection.

Comparison of human immunodeficiency virus antigens as stimulants for lymphocyte proliferation assays

CD4 proliferative responses to the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) type 1 (HIV-1) p24 (gag) antigen inversely correlate with the plasma viral load in HIV-infected subjects who control viral replication without antiretroviral therapy. Use of a single HIV-1 protein to assess CD4 proliferative responses may not reflect the global response to this pathogen. We compared the abilities of HIV p24 and gp120 antigens from two different vendors, an inactivated whole HIV-1 MN virion preparation and an HIV-1E culture supernatant antigen, to elicit proliferative responses in HIV-seropositive and HIV-seronegative donors. Peripheral blood mononuclear cells from 12 HIV-seropositive donors (each with HIV-1 loads <4,000 copies/ml of plasma, >350 CD4 T lymphocytes/mm(3), and no antiretroviral therapy) and 15 HIV-seronegative donors were assessed with multiple concentrations of each stimulant by standard lymphocyte proliferation assays. Wide variations in response rates were found, with zero, three, five, and eight individuals demonstrating stimulation indices of >3 for the HIV culture antigen supernatant, gp120, p24, and inactivated whole-virus preparations, respectively. These results suggest that the use of the inactivated whole virus resulted in a more sensitive assay for detection of CD4 T-lymphocyte function in HIV-infected subjects.

The basis for HIV immunotherapeutic vaccines

The drug treatments introduced in recent years for HIV infection have enabled a marked reduction in morbidity and prolongation of life. These treatments, however, are often associated with acute and chronic toxicities, the development of resistant virus can limit their effectiveness, and they are too expensive and difficult to administer in most third world settings. A successful HIV immunotherapeutic vaccine has the potential to overcome these problems, and would be a valuable advance. The most promising approaches have induced the type of immune response found to correlate with reduced activity of HIV in man, especially cytotoxic T-cell responses, or have led to reduced HIV or SIV viral load and increased CD4 counts in non-human primates or man. The agents that have led to one or both of these effects have been selected for review, and include inactivated envelope depleted virus, recombinant envelope glycoprotein, DNA vaccines utilising HIV peptides or gene products, viral vectors, such as canarypox or attenuated vaccinia, with HIV core proteins. There are other approaches, such as alloimmunity, for which no candidate products yet exist, but which conceptually appear promising. Currently, however, only a few phase III studies of HIV therapeutic vaccines have been completed in man, and there has been a modest therapeutic effect. Further development of both existing and new candidates remains one of the key priorities in our fight against HIV.

Candidate vaccines for immunotherapy in HIV

In this short article we review the immunopathology of HIV infection and delineate the kinds of immune responses seen in acute infection and in long-term nonprogression that are understood to be necessary if the host is to maintain long-term control of the virus. In this context we discuss the potential promise of therapeutic vaccination in HIV infection.

Immunopathogenesis of human immunodeficiency virus: implications for immune-based therapies

Human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) infection leads to a state of CD4 lymphopenia and generalized immune activation with subsequent development of opportunistic infections and neoplasms. The use of highly active antiretroviral treatment has dramatically improved the clinical outcome for HIV-infected patients, but the associated cost and toxicity and the eventual development of drug resistance have underscored the need for additional therapeutic strategies. Immune-based therapies, such as treatment with cytokines or immunosuppressants, adoptive immunotherapy, and therapeutic immunizations, are being intensely investigated as potential supplements to antiretroviral therapy. Although much data have been generated as a result of these efforts, to date there has been little evidence of the clinical efficacy of these strategies. Randomized clinical studies remain critical in evaluating the clinical significance and the role of immune-based therapies in the therapeutic armamentarium against HIV.