Hyperoxia in head injury

Physiological complexity of acute traumatic brain injury in patients treated with a brain oxygen protocol: utility of symbolic regression in predictive modeling of a dynamical system

Predictive modeling of emergent behavior, inherent to complex physiological systems, requires the analysis of large complex clinical data streams currently being generated in the intensive care unit. Brain tissue oxygen protocols have yielded outcome benefits in traumatic brain injury (TBI), but the critical physiological thresholds for low brain oxygen have not been established for a dynamical patho-physiological system. High frequency, multi-modal clinical data sets from 29 patients with severe TBI who underwent multi-modality neuro-clinical care monitoring and treatment with a brain oxygen protocol were analyzed. The inter-relationship between acute physiological parameters was determined using symbolic regression (SR) as the computational framework. The mean patient age was 44.4±15 with a mean admission GCS of 6.6±3.9. Sixty-three percent sustained motor vehicle accidents and the most common pathology was intra-cerebral hemorrhage (50%). Hospital discharge mortality was 21%, poor outcome occurred in 24% of patients, and good outcome occurred in 56% of patients. Criticality for low brain oxygen was intracranial pressure (ICP) ≥22.8 mm Hg, for mortality at ICP≥37.1 mm Hg. The upper therapeutic threshold for cerebral perfusion pressure (CPP) was 75 mm Hg. Eubaric hyperoxia significantly impacted partial pressure of oxygen in brain tissue (PbtO2) at all ICP levels. Optimal brain temperature (Tbr) was 34-35°C, with an adverse effect when Tbr≥38°C. Survivors clustered at [Formula: see text] Hg vs. non-survivors [Formula: see text] 18 mm Hg. There were two mortality clusters for ICP: High ICP/low PbtO2 and low ICP/low PbtO2. Survivors maintained PbtO2 at all ranges of mean arterial pressure in contrast to non-survivors. The final SR equation for cerebral oxygenation is: [Formula: see text]. The SR-model of acute TBI advances new physiological thresholds or boundary conditions for acute TBI management: PbtO2≥25 mmHg; ICP≤22 mmHg; CPP≈60-75 mmHg; and Tbr≈34-37°C. SR is congruous with the emerging field of complexity science in the modeling of dynamical physiological systems, especially during pathophysiological states. The SR model of TBI is generalizable to known physical laws. This increase in entropy reduces uncertainty and improves predictive capacity. SR is an appropriate computational framework to enable future smart monitoring devices.

Basic physiology of hyperbaric oxygen in brain

Oxygen is the proverbial 'double-edged sword' in that it is a necessity for life in moderation and toxic and detrimental to life in excess. This too is the dilemma in hyperbaric oxygen (HBO) treatment in cerebral ischemic-anoxic insults such as stroke, head injury, near drowning, asphyxia, cardiac arrest, etc., i.e. the brain at risk, where regions of ischemia are beside regions of marked hyperemia. The natural heterogeneity of normal brain tissue oxygenation compounds the problem with different microvascular brain regions living at various levels of oxygenation from 0 to arterial PO(2) as an added complication. The application of HBO, whether normobaric or hyperbaric, will result in brain tissue oxygenation ranging from normoxic to highly hyperoxic with the latter possibly exacerbating the injury sustained. On this basis, the application of multiple therapeutic interventions may be considered, for example, HBO in combination with free radical scavengers or inhibitors of free radical generating enzymes. Despite these difficulties in moderating oxygen delivery to treat cerebral ischemic-anoxic insults, overwhelming preclinical evidence indicates that HBO administered during or within 2 hours post-insult effectively attenuates the severity of brain damage sustained. The primary disconnection between pre-clinical and clinical efficacy of HBO then appears to be the time of application. Clinically, HBO therapy is applied at the earliest 6 hours post-insult but usually between 12 hours or longer post-insult. Pre-hospital application of HBO may be required for clear-cut demonstration of clinical efficacy.

Effect of short periods of normobaric hyperoxia on local brain tissue oxygenation and cerebrospinal fluid oxidative stress markers in severe traumatic brain injury

Preliminary evidence suggests local brain tissue oxygenation (PbtO(2)) values of <or=15 mm Hg following severe traumatic brain injury (TBI) represent brain tissue hypoxia. Accordingly, many neurotrauma units attempt to maintain PbtO(2) >or=20 mm Hg to avoid hypoxia. This study tested the impact of a short (2 h) trial of normobaric hyperoxia on measures of oxidative stress. We hypothesized this treatment would positively affect cerebral oxygenation but negatively affect the cellular environment via oxidative stress mechanisms. Cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) was serially assessed in 11 adults (9 male, 2 female), aged 26 +/- 1.8 years with severe TBI (Glasgow Coma Scale score, 6 +/- 1.4) before, during, and after a FiO(2) = 1.0 challenge for markers of oxidative stress, including lipid peroxidation (F(2)-isoprostane [ELISA]), protein oxidation (protein sulfhydryl [fluorescence]), and antioxidant defenses (total antioxidant reserve (AOR) [chemiluminescence] and glutathione [fluorescence]). Physiological parameters [PbtO(2), arterial oxygen content (PaO(2)), intracranial pressure (ICP), mean arterial pressure (MAP), and cerebral perfusion pressure (CPP)] were assessed at the same time points. Mean (+/-SD) PbtO(2) and PaO(2) levels significantly changed for each time point. Oxidative stress markers, antioxidant reserve defenses, and ICP, MAP, and CPP did not significantly change for any time period. These preliminary findings suggest that brief periods of normobaric hyperoxia do not produce oxidative stress and/or change antioxidant reserves in CSF. Additional studies are required to examine extended periods of normobaric hyperoxia in a larger sample.

Lactate and glucose as energy substrates and their role in traumatic brain injury and therapy

Traumatic brain injury is a leading cause of disability and mortality worldwide, but no new pharmacological treatments are clinically available. A key pathophysiological development in the understanding of traumatic brain injury is the energy crisis derived from decreased cerebral blood flow, increased energy demand and mitochondrial dysfunction. Although still controversial, new findings suggest that brain cells try to cope in these conditions by metabolizing lactate as an energy substrate ‘on-demand’ in lieu of glucose. Experimental and clinical data suggest that lactate, at least when exogenously administered, is transported from astrocytes to neurons for neuronal utilization, essentially bypassing the slow, catabolizing glycolysis process to quickly and efficiently produce ATP. Treatment strategies using systemically applied lactate have proved to be protective in various experimental traumatic brain injury studies. However, lactate has the potential to elevate oxygen consumption to high levels and, therefore, could potentially impose a danger for tissue-at-risk with low cerebral blood flow. The present review outlines the experimental basis of lactate in energy metabolism under physiological and pathophysiological conditions and presents arguments for lactate as a new therapeutical tool in human head injury.

[Monitoring of tissue oxygen pressure (PtiO2) in cerebral hypoxia: diagnostic and therapeutic approach]

One of the main causes of secondary cerebral injury is cerebral hypoxia, basically of ischemic origin. However, cerebral tissue oxygenation depends on multiple physiological variables and cerebral hypoxia may be caused by an alteration of any one of them. Although several methods of continuous cerebral oxygenation monitoring of neurocritical patients have been developed, direct and continuous measurement of the oxygen pressure in the cerebral tissue (PtiO2) has been a reality in the handling of the neurocritical patients over recent years. This technique is highlighted by its reliability and value of the information that it provides. This present article presents a review of the most outstanding aspects of the PtiO2 monitoring and proposes a protocol for the interpretation of this monitoring technique. This algorithm attempts to facilitate the identification of the different types of different cerebral hypoxia and of the correct therapeutic choice in the complex decision making process in neurocritical patients at risk of cerebral hypoxia.

Hyperoxia: good or bad for the injured brain?

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

For decades it was assumed that cerebral ischemia was a major cause of secondary brain injury in traumatic brain injury, and management focused on improving cerebral perfusion and blood flow. Following the observation of mitochondrial dysfunction in traumatic brain injury and the widespread use of brain tissue oxygen tension (P(br)O(2) monitoring, however, recent work has focused on the use of hyperoxia to reduce the impact of traumatic brain injury.

RECENT FINDINGS

Previous work on normobaric hyperoxia utilized very indirect measures of cerebral oxygen metabolism (intracranial pressure, brain oxygen tension and microdialysis) as outcome variables. Interpretation of these measures is controversial, making it difficult to determine the impact of hyperoxia. A recent study, however, utilized positron emission tomography to study the impact of hyperoxia on patients with acute severe traumatic brain injury and found no improvement on cerebral metabolic rate for oxygen with this intervention.

SUMMARY

Despite suggestive data from microdialysis studies, direct measurement of the ability of the brain to utilize oxygen indicates that hyperoxia does not increase oxygen utilization. This, combined with the real risk of oxygen toxicity, suggests that routine clinical use is not appropriate at this time and should await appropriate prospective outcome studies.

Reliability of the microdialysis pump CMA 107 under hyperbaric conditions

OBJECTIVE

Microdialysis measurements of extracellular substances under hyperbaric conditions were manifold used in several investigations. However, to our knowledge there is no analysis, which verified the applicability of microdialysis pumps under hyperbaric conditions. Thus, a goal of this study was to investigate the reliability of the microdialysis pump (MDP) CMA 107 in a hyperbaric environment up to 2.4bar absolute pressure.

METHODS

The CMA 107 with a perfusion rate of 2microL/min was stored in a decompression chamber. The ambient pressure was increased from 1 to 2.4bar absolute within 15min, maintained for 90min and then decreased to 1bar within 15min. The vials were changed every 15min, weighed before as well as after collecting the sample volume and the absolute recovery of glutamate, pyruvate, lactate, glucose and glycerol was determined. The same setup was performed under normobaric conditions.

RESULTS

The pumping capacity was 1.7% greater than expected under normobaric conditions, 36.5% less than expected in the compression phase, 10.5% less than expected in the isopression phase and 26.3% greater than expected in the decompression phase under hyperbaric conditions. The absolute recoveries under hyperbaric conditions were affected during the isopression phase with a deviation from -6 to +20% compared to normobaric environments.

CONCLUSION

The study demonstrated that an absolute ambient pressure up to 2.4bar did influence the pumping capacity and the reliability of the absolute recovery. These results need to be taken into consideration when interpreting microdialysis studies performed under hyperbaric conditions.

Effect of hyperoxia on cerebral metabolic rate for oxygen measured using positron emission tomography in patients with acute severe head injury

Object

Recent observations indicate that traumatic brain injury (TBI) may be associated with mitochondrial dysfunction. This, along with growing use of brain tissue PO2 monitors, has led to considerable interest in the potential use of ventilation with 100% oxygen to treat patients who have suffered a TBI. To date, the impact of normobaric hyperoxia has only been evaluated using indirect measures of its impact on brain metabolism. To determine if normobaric hyperoxia improves brain oxygen metabolism following acute TBI, the authors directly measured the cerebral metabolic rate for oxygen (CMRO2) with positron emission tomography before and after ventilation with 100% oxygen.

Methods

Baseline measurements of arterial and jugular venous blood gases, mean arterial blood pressure, intracranial pressure, cerebral blood flow (CBF), cerebral blood volume, oxygen extraction fraction, and CMRO2 were made at baseline while the patients underwent ventilation with a fraction of inspired oxygen (FiO2) of 0.3 to 0.5. The FiO2 was then increased to 1.0, and 1 hour later all measurements were repeated.

Five patients were studied a mean of 17.9 ±5.8 hours (range 12–23 hours) after trauma. The median admission Glasgow Coma Scale score was 7 (range 3–9). During ventilation with 100% oxygen, there was a marked rise in PaO2 (from 117 ± 31 to 371 ± 99 mm Hg, p < 0.0001) and a small rise in arterial oxygen content (12.7 ± 4.0 to 13.3 ± 4.6 vol %, p = 0.03). There were no significant changes in systemic hemodynamic or other blood gas measurements. At the baseline evaluation, bihemispheric CBF was 39 ± 12 ml/100 g/min and bihemispheric CMRO2 was 1.9 ± 0.6 ml/100 g/min. During hyperoxia there was no significant change in either of these measurements. (Values are given as the mean ± standard deviation throughout.)

Conclusions

Normobaric hyperoxia did not improve brain oxygen metabolism. In the absence of outcome data from clinical trials, these preliminary data do not support the use of 100% oxygen in patients with acute TBI, although larger confirmatory studies are needed.

Continuous monitoring of cerebral metabolism in traumatic brain injury: a focus on cerebral microdialysis

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

This review highlights recent advances in cerebral microdialysis as a tool for neurochemical monitoring of patients with traumatic brain injury.

RECENT FINDINGS

Progress in microdialysis research has come from validation studies of microdialysis biomarkers and clinical outcome in large cohorts of traumatic brain injury patients and by combining microdialysis with other methods, such as positron emission tomography, magnetic resonance spectroscopy, brain tissue oximetry and electrophysiology. The combination of rapid-sampling microdialysis and electrocorticography has revealed complex, transient fluctuations of microdialysis glucose and lactate and depolarization-like events that may affect the secondary injury process. The use of microdialysis to monitor global cerebral metabolic events (related to intracranial hypertension or reduced cerebral perfusion pressure for example) as opposed to focal events in peri-lesional brain tissue need to be clearly distinguished and the microdialysis catheter location verified by neuroimaging to ensure proper data interpretation. Differences in microdialysis biomarker levels between grey and white matter following traumatic brain injury need clarification.

SUMMARY

Microdialysis is established as a neurochemical research tool in neurointensive care, particularly in combination with other monitoring methods, and contributes to a growing knowledge of secondary injury mechanisms in traumatic brain injury. The value of microdialysis as a tool in routine neurointensive care decision-making remains unclear.

The role of tissue oxygen monitoring in patients with acute brain injury

Cerebral ischaemia is implicated in poor outcome after brain injury, and is a very common post-mortem finding. The inability of the brain to store metabolic substrates, in the face of high oxygen and glucose requirements, makes it very susceptible to ischaemic damage. The clinical challenge, however, remains the reliable antemortem detection and treatment of ischaemic episodes in the intensive care unit. Outcomes have improved in the traumatic brain injury setting after the introduction of progressive protocol-driven therapy, based, primarily, on the monitoring and control of intracranial pressure, and the maintenance of an adequate cerebral perfusion pressure through manipulation of the mean arterial pressure. With the increasing use of multi-modal monitoring, the complex pathophysiology of the injured brain is slowly being unravelled, emphasizing the heterogeneity of the condition, and the requirement for individualization of therapy to prevent secondary adverse hypoxic cerebral events. Brain tissue oxygen partial pressure (Pb(O2) monitoring is emerging as a clinically useful modality, and this review examines its role in the management of brain injury.

Managing head injured patients

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

In this article we aim to review the recent literature concerning the management of traumatic brain injury patients, summarize the main findings, and discuss the impact of these findings on clinical practice.

RECENT FINDINGS

Several authors have focused on the development of more reliable and informative tools to predict outcome in traumatic brain injury as well as refining the definition of cerebral ischemia in last year's literature. The validity of the current cerebral perfusion pressure management guidelines has also come under scrutiny. It appears that a one size fits all therapy is not a suitable approach for traumatic brain injury patients. An individualized approach, depending on the integrity of pressure autoregulation mechanisms, would be more advisable. Clinical trials investigating brain protective treatments in head injured patients have been disappointing so far. Increasing the homogeneity of patients entering brain protective studies might be an answer. Finally, the use of hyperoxia as well as factors contributing to secondary brain injury such as the occurrence of hyperthermia, with or without an infectious process, have been assessed in head injury patients.

SUMMARY

The key term for the management of traumatic brain injury patients in the early twenty-first century will clearly be 'individualized therapy'. The search of an ideal cerebral perfusion pressure target that would fit every head-injured patients is a utopia. More energy should be focused on the development of reliable tools for outcome prediction and outcome assessment for traumatic brain injured patients. That, and a better targeting of patients entering brain protective trials, should increase the likelihood of demonstrating a significant salvaging effect of a particular treatment in humans.

Monitoring of head injured patients

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

This article reviews recent advances in multimodality monitoring of patients following severe head injury during the period of 2004-2005.

RECENT FINDINGS

Whilst intracranial pressure measurement remains the cornerstone of neuromonitoring, analysis of the intracranial pressure waveform provides additional information, which may help guide treatment and predict outcome. Non-invasive detection of intracranial hypertension and assessment of cerebral perfusion pressure and autoregulation is the focus of ongoing research. Although jugular venous saturation monitoring remains a useful method for detecting global hypoperfusion its sensitivity to regional ischaemia is low. Brain tissue oxygen monitoring overcomes this deficiency and sheds new light on the pathophysiology of cerebral ischaemia following brain injury. Further studies are required to define ischaemic thresholds and their association with outcome. Extracellular brain pH has been recently linked to outcome and further studies are required to establish the role of pH regulation. Monitoring of brain metabolism using a cerebral microdialysis continues to develop its niche in clinical neuromonitoring, although it currently remains a research tool.

SUMMARY

Multimodality neuromonitoring plays an important role in managing patients with severe head injury. It helps guide treatment, provides prognostic information and explores the pathophysiology of evolving brain injury.