Agreement analysis of variables involved in lipodystrophy syndrome definition in HIV-infected patients

Anthropometric definitions for antiretroviral-associated lipodystrophy derived from a longitudinal South African cohort with serial dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry measurements

The development of lipodystrophy is associated with the long-term use of antiretroviral therapy (ART). We assessed agreement between patient-reported lipodystrophy and body composition measures using dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry (DXA) and developed objective measures to define lipoatrophy and lipohypertrophy in black South Africans. One hundred and eighty-seven ART-naïve HIV-infected adults were enrolled in a 24-month longitudinal study. Self-reported information on regional fat loss and fat gain, anthropometry, and DXA measures were collected at baseline, three, six, 12, 18, and 24 months after starting ART. Receiver operating characteristic curves were used to describe the performance of anthropometric variables using change in limb and trunk fat measured by DXA, as the reference standard. The proportion of men and women who developed lipoatrophy and lipohypertrophy increased over the 24-month period, with lipoatrophy occurring more frequently in men (21% versus 10%). In women, lipoatrophy was best determined by thigh skinfold thickness (80.3% correctly classified) and mid-arm circumference (77.6% correctly classified). None of the anthropometric measures performed well for defining lipoatrophy in men. Anthropometric measures performed well for defining lipoatrophy in women, but not lipohypertrophy.

Lipoatrophy/lipohypertrophy outcomes after antiretroviral therapy switch in children in the UK/Ireland

BACKGROUND

Following widespread use of stavudine, a thymidine analogue, in antiretroviral therapy (ART) over the past three decades, up to a third of children developed lipoatrophy (LA) and/or lipohypertrophy (LH). Following phasing-out of stavudine, incidence of newly-diagnosed LA and LH declined dramatically. However, the natural history of existing cases should be explored, particularly with prolonged protease inhibitor exposure.

METHODS

The Collaborative HIV Paediatric Study (CHIPS) is a multicentre cohort study of most HIV-infected children in the United Kingdom and Ireland. Those on ART with a LA/LH assessment recorded in 2003-2011 were included. Assessments were completed annually by consultant physicians. Using the 0-3 grading system, LA or LH was defined as grade 2 or 3. Resolution was defined as return to grade 1 or 0 in all body regions.

RESULTS

Of 1345 children followed for median (IQR) 5.5 (2.9, 8.2) years after ART initiation, 30 developed LA and 27 developed LH, all at least 2 years after ART initiation. Median age at LA diagnosis was 11 (10, 13) years and at LH diagnosis was 13 (11, 15) years. Children with LA were more likely white (p<0.0001); lower height-for-age z-score at ART initiation (p = 0.02); initiated ART earlier (p = 0.04), with longer ART exposure (p = 0.04). Children with LH were similar to those without. Analysis of individual drugs revealed that LA was associated with greater duration of exposure to stavudine and didanosine; while LH was associated with greater duration of exposure to stavudine and ritonavir (given alone or in combination with another protease inhibitor). Median time in follow-up following ART switch was 2.8 (1.9, 4.9) and 2.5 (1.6, 4.7) years respectively. Resolution occurred in 10 (30%) of LA cases (median time to resolution 2.3 [1.8, 3.6] years) and 3 (11%) of LH cases (median time to resolution 2.0 [1.7, 2.1] years).

CONCLUSIONS

Prevalence of LA and LH were low, with some resolution noted, especially for LA. More long-term data are needed.

Changes in abdominal fat following antiretroviral therapy initiation in HIV-infected individuals correlate with waist circumference and self-reported changes

BACKGROUND

We examined whether waist circumference (WC) and self-reported abdominal size changes can estimate visceral adipose tissue (VAT) changes for those initiating antiretroviral therapy (ART).

METHODS

Prospectively collected data from ACTG A5257 and its metabolic substudy, A5260s, were used for this analysis. ART-naive HIV-infected participants were randomized to one of three contemporary ART regimens. Changes in abdominal CT-measured VAT and total adipose tissue (TAT) and DXA-measured trunk fat were tested for association with WC changes (by Pearson correlation) and categories of self-reported abdominal size changes (by ANOVA) between entry and week 96. Linear models compared WC and self-reported changes.

RESULTS

The study population (n=328) was predominantly male (90%) and White non-Hispanic (44%) with a baseline median age of 36 years and body mass index of 25 kg/m². At week 96, median WC change was +2.8 cm. Of those reporting at week 96, 53% indicated 'no change/lost', 39% 'gained some/somewhat larger' and 8% 'gained a lot/much larger' as their self-reported changes. Trunk fat, VAT and TAT changes differed across self-reported groups (ANOVA P<0.0001 for all), and the group ordering was as expected. WC changes were strongly correlated with CT and DXA changes (trunk fat: ρ=0.72, p<0.0001; VAT: ρ=0.52, p<0.0001; TAT: ρ=0.62, p<0.0001). While WC changes explained a greater proportion of VAT, TAT and trunk fat variation, self-reported changes remained a significant predictor after controlling for WC (p<0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

WC and self-reported abdominal changes each correlated directly with imaging-derived abdominal fat measures, and can be used as reliable, affordable tools for central adiposity assessment.

HIV/AIDS and lipodystrophy: implications for clinical management in resource-limited settings

Introduction

Lipodystrophy is a term used to describe a metabolic complication of fat loss, fat gain, or a combination of fat loss and gain, which is associated with some antiretroviral (ARV) therapies given to HIV-infected individuals. There is limited research on lipodystrophy in low- and middle-income countries, despite accounting for more than 95% of the burden of HIV/AIDS. The objective of this review was to evaluate the prevalence, pathogenesis and prognosis of HIV-related lipoatrophy, lipohypertrophy and mixed syndrome, to inform clinical management in resource-limited settings.

Methods

We conducted a structured literature search using MEDLINE electronic databases. Relevant MeSH terms were used to identify published human studies on HIV and lipoatrophy, lipohypertrophy, or mixed syndrome in low-, low-middle- and upper-middle-income countries through 31 March 2014. The search resulted in 5296 articles; after 1599 studies were excluded (958 reviews, 641 non-human), 3697 studies were extracted for further review. After excluding studies conducted in high-income settings (n=2808), and studies that did not meet inclusion criteria (n=799), 90 studies were included in this review.

Results and Discussion

Of the 90 studies included in this review, only six were from low-income countries and eight were from lower middle-income economies. These studies focused on lipodystrophy prevalence, risk factors and side effects of antiretroviral therapy (ART). In most studies, lipodystrophy developed after the first six months of therapy, particularly with the use of stavudine. Lipodystrophy is associated with increased risk of cardiometabolic complications. This is disconcerting and anticipated to increase, given the rapid scale-up of ART worldwide, the increasing number and lifespan of HIV-infected patients on long-term therapy, and the emergence of obesity and non-communicable diseases in settings with extensive HIV burden.

Conclusions

Lipodystrophy is common in resource-limited settings, and has considerable implications for risk of metabolic diseases, quality of life and adherence. Comprehensive evidence-based interventions are urgently needed to reduce the burden of HIV and lipodystrophy, and inform clinical management in resource-limited settings.

HIV-associated adipose redistribution syndrome (HARS): definition, epidemiology and clinical impact

A segment of the HIV infected population develops abnormal and excessive accumulation of adipose tissue in the trunk, including accumulation of visceral (deep abdominal) adipose tissue. This condition, known as HIV-related adipose redistribution syndrome (HARS), may also be accompanied by fat accumulation in the upper back/neck (dorsocervical region) and/or depletion of subcutaneous adipose tissue from the abdomen, face, limbs, or buttocks. HARS is estimated to occur in up to 32% of patients and is associated with health risks similar to those of metabolic syndrome. Techniques to detect and measure HARS include physician and patient assessments and radiologic or anthropometric methods.

Balancing disfigurement and fear of disease progression: Patient perceptions of HIV body fat redistribution

This study was conducted to identify and describe the perceived morphologic changes of body fat redistribution and related distress among persons taking combination antiretroviral therapy. Six focus group interviews were conducted in four different US cities with men and women (n = 58) who reported antiretroviral-related symptoms of body fat loss and/or gain. Interview data were audiotaped, transcribed verbatim and systematically analysed using inductive techniques. Physical discomfort and impairment and psychological and social distress were reported across sex, sexual orientation and geographic subgroups. While participants acknowledged that antiretroviral drugs were keeping them alive, there was tension between the desire for life-sustaining treatment and optimal quality of life. Some participants engaged in harmful heath behaviours in an attempt to control bodily changes (e.g. non-adherence to antiretroviral regimen). Participants feared that fat loss represented disease progression and worried that visible changes would lead to unintentional disclosure of their HIV status. Although a potential source of support, healthcare providers were commonly perceived as ignoring and, in so doing, discrediting patient distress. Participants recognised the limitations of current lipodystrophy treatment options, yet a cure for the syndrome seemed less important to them in the short term than simply being listened to and the powerful, but oblique sources of distress addressed.

Prevalence of lipodystrophy in HIV-infected children: a cross-sectional study

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this study was to assess the changes in body fat distribution and lipid abnormalities in a population of HIV-infected children and adolescents followed in one single centre who had been exposed, or not, to antiretroviral therapy (ART).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Patients aged between 3 and 19 years were evaluated in a cross-sectional study carried out between October and December 2002. Fat redistribution was evaluated independently by the physician and the patient. Fasting blood lipid profile, glucose, insulin and C peptide were measured. Among the 88 patients evaluated, 74 were taking ART.

RESULTS

Fat redistribution was present in 20 patients, metabolic alterations alone were found in 22 children and 46 children had neither physical nor metabolic abnormalities. Patients with fat redistribution were found to have been on ART for a significantly longer period of time, with 42% of the children showing fat redistribution having been treated with antiretroviral agents for more than 5 years. These children had also been exposed to a higher number of antiretroviral agents. In contrast, metabolic alterations in the absence of fat redistribution were not related to the duration of ART nor to the number of drugs received. Treatment with stavudine or protease inhibitors was significantly associated with the presence of physical changes.

CONCLUSION

Regular assessment of fat redistribution and metabolic markers should be carried out in children treated with antiretroviral agents and taken into account when adapting therapy during the long-term follow up of these children.

Toxic metabolic syndrome associated with HAART

Acquired fat redistribution, that is, peripheral fat loss often accompanied by central fat accumulation in patients with HIV infection is the most common form of lipodystrophy in man. Approximately 30 - 50% of HIV-infected individuals after > or = 12 months on highly active antiretroviral therapy (HAART) may encounter the HIV-associated lipodystrophy syndrome (HALS), which attenuates patient compliance to this treatment. HALS is characterised by impaired glucose and lipid metabolism and other risk factors for cardiovascular disease. This review depicts the metabolic abnormalities associated with HAART by describing the key cell and organ systems that are involved, emphasising the role of insulin resistance. An opinion on the remedies available to treat the metabolic abnormalities and phenotype of HALS is provided.

Reproducibility of DXA estimations of body fat in HIV lipodystrophy: implications for clinical research

Dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry (DXA) estimates of body fat are increasingly used for the evaluation of human immunodeficiency virus lipodystrophy (HIV LD); however, limited data are available on their reproducibility. This information is essential for using this tool as an end point in treatment trials or as a diagnostic tool. This study evaluates the reproducibility of DXA body fat estimation in HIV-positive subjects with and without lipodystrophy. Thirty subjects representing a spectrum of severity of fat redistribution underwent same-day repeat whole-body DXA scans (Hologic QDR 4500A scanner). Root mean square coefficients of variation (RMS-CV) were used to estimate minimum detectable differences (MDDs) for body fat content in different regions. Absolute MDD was calculated by multiplying the MDD by the mean fat-mass value for each anatomical area. The RMS-CV ranged from 4.0% for arm fat to 1.6% for total fat. Relative and absolute MDD values ranged from 11.0% or 160 g for arm fat to 4.3% or 628 g for total fat. DXA measurements of regional body fat mass in subjects with HIV show similar reproducibility to other populations. Minimal detectable differences were smaller than differences observed in published studies for all measurements. DXA is a sensitive tool for detecting changes in peripheral fat among patients with HIV lipodystrophy.

Mitochondrial DNA Levels in Fat and Blood Cells from Patients with Lipodystrophy or Peripheral Neuropathy and the Effect of 90 Days of High-Dose Coenzyme Q Treatment: A Randomized, Double-Blind, Placebo-Controlled Pilot Study

BACKGROUND

Mitochondrial toxicity can be induced by reverse-transcriptase inhibitors, and an association between levels of mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) per cell and lipodystrophy, peripheral neuropathy, and HIV infection per se has been suggested. Studies aimed at increasing the oxidative capacity in HIV-infected patients have been sparse.

METHODS

Levels of mtDNA in fat and peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs) from 25 HIV infected patients and 10 healthy control subjects were studied with real-time PCR analysis. A placebo-controlled and double-blind design was used to assign individuals to receive either 100 mg of coenzyme Q twice daily for 3 months or a matching placebo regimen. Levels of mtDNA and other parameters were assessed before and after the intervention period.

RESULTS

The mean number of mtDNA copies per cell was lower in fat tissue obtained from patients with peripheral neuropathy (1547 mtDNA copies/cell; P=.045), patients with lipodystrophy (1732 mtDNA copies/cell; P=.003) and in HIV patients with no complications associated with highly active antiretroviral therapy (2935 mtDNA copies/cell; P=.078), compared with healthy control subjects (6198 mtDNA copies/cell). No clear difference was seen in mtDNA content in PBMCs. Coenzyme Q therapy improved the general condition of patients (P=.005) and caused a reversible increase in peripheral neuropathy pain (P=.048). Compared with placebo, treatment with coenzyme Q did not result in changes in mtDNA levels in fat cells or in PBMCs after the treatment period.

CONCLUSIONS

Levels of mtDNA in fat tissue, but not in PBMCs, were associated with peripheral neuropathy and lipodystrophy. High-dose coenzyme Q therapy increased well-being in asymptomatic HIV-infected patients and those with lipodystrophy, as well as in control subjects, but aggravated pain in patients with peripheral neuropathy.

Prospective evaluation of blood concentration of mitochondrial DNA as a marker of toxicity in 157 consecutively recruited untreated or HAART-treated HIV-positive patients

Highly active antiretroviral therapy (HAART) can cause mitochondrial toxicity. The concentration of mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) in peripheral blood cells has been reported to be a marker of this toxicity. However, these observations are controversial and were drawn from small series. Thus, we analysed the value of blood mtDNA as a marker of mitochondrial toxicity in a large cohort of human immunodeficiency virus (HIV)-infected out-patients during routine clinical evaluations. Real-time quantitative PCR was used to determine the mtDNA to nuclear DNA (nDNA) ratio in peripheral blood mononuclear cells from 157 consecutive HIV-1-infected patients (13 naive, 144 receiving HAART) and 30 HIV-1-uninfected patients. The mtDNA to nDNA ratio was significantly lower in both groups of HIV-infected patients than in the control group. No significant difference was observed between treated and naive HIV-infected patients. Lactataemia was significantly lower in controls than in the group of HIV-treated patients. None of the treated patients had lactataemia >5 mmol/l or bicarbonates <20 mmol/l. Triglyceride levels were significantly higher in the HAART-treated patients than in the nontreated patients. Clinical symptoms of lipodystrophy were observed in 62 HAART-treated patients. These symptoms were not associated with an abnormal mtDNA to nDNA ratio or plasma triglyceride concentration. The mtDNA to nDNA ratio was lower in DDI/D4T-treated patients than in AZT/3TC-treated patients. In conclusion, there are no obvious links between the mtDNA to nDNA ratio in peripheral mononuclear cells and any clinical symptoms or lactate level. Thus, the mtDNA to nDNA ratio in leukocytes does not seem to be an accurate marker of mild and/or long-term mitochondrial toxicity.

An objective case definition of lipodystrophy in HIV-infected adults: a case-control study

BACKGROUND

Lipodystrophy (peripheral lipoatrophy, central fat accumulation, and lipomatosis) is a common and disfiguring problem in adult patients with HIV-1 infection on antiretrovirals. However, an objective, validated definition of the disorder does not exist. We aimed to develop an objective, sensitive, specific, and broadly applicable case definition of HIV lipodystrophy.

METHODS

In a case-control study, 1081 consecutive, HIV-infected, adult outpatients (261 [15%] women) without active AIDS were recruited from 32 sites worldwide. We classed patients with at least one moderate or severe subjective lipodystrophic feature, identified by lipodystrophy-specific physical examination and patient questionnaire, and apparent to both doctor and patient as cases (n=417). We classed patients with no such feature as controls (n=371), and patients without a clear diagnosis as non-assigned. We used objective clinical, metabolic, and body composition measurements to construct a logistic regression model with a subset of randomly selected cases and controls. The model was validated in the remaining patients.

FINDINGS

A model including age, sex, duration of HIV infection, HIV disease stage, waist to hip ratio, anion gap, serum HDL cholesterol concentration, trunk to peripheral fat ratio, percentage leg fat, and intra-abdominal to extra-abdominal fat ratio had 79% (95% CI 70-85) sensitivity and 80% (95% CI 71-87) specificity for diagnosis of lipodystrophy. Models that incorporated only clinical, or only clinical and metabolic variables had lower sensitivity and specificity than the inclusive model. Models for lipoatrophy, fat accumulation, and lipomatosis could not be developed since pure phenotypes occurred in fewer than 10% of patients with clinical diagnoses of these disorders.

INTERPRETATION

Our objective case definition of HIV-associated lipodystrophy should improve assessment of lipodystrophy prevalence, risk factors, and pathogenesis; prevention and treatment approaches; and assist in diagnosis.