A Comparison between Primary and Secondary Toe-to-Hand Transplantation

Three-Dimensional Computer-Aided Design Modeling and Printing for Accurate Toe-to-Hand Transplantation

PURPOSE

To introduce toe-to-hand transplantation performed with the assistance of both bone and soft tissue modeling using 3-dimensional printing technology.

METHODS

From May 2015 to October 2018, 31 patients (group A, 24 thumbs and 7 fingers) were included. Computed tomography scans were acquired using a spiral computed tomography scanner, and the data were processed with software. Bone, skin, and nail models were created for tailoring the flap taken from the great toe. The impact of foot pathology in terms of pain, disability, and activity restriction was assessed using the Foot Function Index. For comparison, we included 35 patients (group B) who underwent toe-to-hand transplantation without the assistance of 3-dimensional computer-aided modeling.

RESULTS

The mean duration of follow-up of groups A and B was 26 months (range, 24-31 months) and 27 months (range, 24-33 months), respectively. The mean Foot Function Index of groups A and B was 5 (range: 0-15) and 17 (range, 0-39), respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

Three-dimensional computer-aided modeling and printing provide geometric accuracy in toe-to-hand transplantation. It also may reduce the donor foot morbidity by accurate flap designing and harvesting.

TYPE OF STUDY/LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Therapeutic IV.

Reconstructive Principles for the Metacarpal Hand: Case Report

Metacarpal hand is one of the most devastating upper-extremity lesions. We report a case of a multidigit amputation corresponding to a Wei et al.5 IA metacarpal hand in a 56 year-old-male. He underwent a sequential toe-to-hand transfer to the third and fourth radii. Reconstruction of the metacarpal hand, either in an acute or deferred presentation, must consider some reconstructive principles, including the identification of the structures to be spared and the coverage strategies for the acute stage. Toe-to-hand transfer is the preferred technique when replantation is not an option. It is critical to know which structures should be transferred to which positions, as well as to adapt the reconstructive plan to the characteristics from each patient.

Emergency toe-to-hand transfer for post-traumatic finger reconstruction: A multicenter case series

BACKGROUND

The aim of this paper was to evaluate the outcomes of a homogenous series of emergency with a toe-to-hand transfer reconstructions with a different timing: immediate (same surgical step with the debridement), primary (in the first 24 h), early (24-72 h after the debridement) or delayed (72 h-7 days).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Between 2001 and 2011, 31 patients received an immediate reconstruction with a toe-to-hand transfer. Data on indications, timing, type of surgery, complications and outcomes (sensory and motor recovery, patient satisfaction) were extrapolated and recorded.

RESULTS

Most of the procedures in our series (71%) were performed in the first 24 h. Survival rate was 100%. The only complications were 3 venous thrombosis (10%), solved with surgical re-exploration. Only 1 patient required secondary surgery for web deepening. No functional problems were recorded at the donor site. Sensibility recovery was acceptable in all patients; toe mobility was higher for the reconstructed thumb (85%) than for other digits (77%). Patient satisfaction was high with regard to functional results and lower but acceptable with regard to the aesthetic outcome. There was no difference in satisfaction rate of patients treated within 24 h or within 7 days.

CONCLUSION

No conclusive evidence exists in favor of an immediate versus a primary, early or delayed emergency reconstruction. Emergency toe transfer for finger reconstruction is a safe procedure and its outcomes are comparable to those reported in the literature for secondary reconstruction. Immediate reconstruction has the advantage of an easier dissection, but early or delayed reconstruction gives more time to discuss with the patient and to plan surgery.

Microsurgical thumb repair and reconstruction

In this article, we review microsurgical reconstructive techniques available to treat thumb amputation at different levels based on our experience. We reference techniques used by other surgeons and identify the most suitable technique for different clinical situations. Indications and techniques for microsurgical partial or composite transfer of the great or second toe for thumb reconstruction are summarized. Different microsurgical transfer techniques suggest a great freedom of surgical choices. However, the choices are considerably restricted if all functional and cosmetic requirements are to be met. We recommend individualized surgical design and reconstruction because each case of thumb amputation is unique.

Current Reconstruction Options for Traumatic Thumb Loss

Traumatic loss of a thumb results in notable functional impairment. Multiple reconstructive procedures have been described to address these deficits. Compared with no reconstruction, any procedure is of benefit. However, each of the described methods offers subtle benefits and downsides and may be more applicable in certain situations. We present a review of current reconstructive options for traumatic thumb amputation in 2016.

Functional salvage of a hand after unsuccessfull attempt of replantation

Amputation by crush injuries generally represents a contraindication for replantation, and especially when the lesion is caused by the summation of multiple concomitant traumatic mechanisms.

We present the case of a 22 year- old female who arrived in our service with a crush/torsion amputation of all long fingers at the metacarpo-phalangeal level of the right hand. After the unsuccessful attempt of replantation, the functional reconstruction of the hand was achieved by using a double free flap transfer: anterolateral thigh perforator flap (ALT) and digital block transfer of second and third toes.

Secondary Thumb Reconstruction in a Mutilated Hand

The thumb plays an integral role in hand function. Traumatic amputation results in significant morbidity. With loss of the thumb, up to a 40% reduction in hand function may result. Thumb replantation must be attempted when possible. The goals of thumb reconstruction are to replicate normal function as closely as possible, minimize donor site morbidity, and expedite recovery. In the setting of a mutilated hand, the status of the remaining digits must be carefully assessed. Toe transfers, osteoplastic thumb reconstruction, and pollicization are commonly used. This article summarizes the indications and technical considerations in addressing the deficiencies after thumb amputation.

Neo-digit functional reconstruction of mutilating hand injury using transplantation of multiple composite tissue flaps

PURPOSE

Functional reconstruction of mutilating hand injuries poses a challenge to the surgeon. We present our experience with use of multiple composite tissue flaps transplant for functional reconstruction of hand in patients with mutilating hand injuries. The associated merits and demerits of these surgical approaches are briefly discussed.

METHODS

From August 2004 to October 2014, functional reconstruction of hand with transplantation of multiple composite tissue flaps was performed in 8 patients. These included the toe with dorsal pedis artery flap, the reverse posterior interosseous artery flap, and the anterolateral thigh flap. Mean interval from injury to functional reconstruction was 10.6 days.

RESULTS

All transplanted skin flaps and reconstructed neofingers survived completely. Only 1 patient developed wound infection at the recipient site (hand), which resolved without any debridement or revision surgery. At the donor site (foot), partial skin necrosis was observed in 1 patient, which healed with local wound care. In other patients, all wounds healed without any complications. The average range of movement at the neofinger metacarpophalangeal and interphalangeal joints was 38° and 73°, respectively. None of the patients required revision surgery.

CONCLUSION

Use of negative pressure wound therapy and multiple composite tissue flap transplantation appears to be an effective strategy for hand functional reconstruction in patients with mutilating hand injuries. Among the multiple composite tissue flaps, use of toe transplantation combined with reverse posterior interosseous artery flap appears to be the best option.

One-stage cosmetic finger reconstruction using a second toe island flap containing terminal branches of the toe artery

INTRODUCTION

A finger reconstructed by toe transfer may have morphological defects. We report the results of second toe transfer for 1-stage finger reconstruction with an island flap based on terminal branches of the toe artery.

HYPOTHESIS

The technique can improve the morphological outcomes of reconstructed fingers.

MATERIALS AND METHOD

Between January 2008 and June 2011, toe-to-finger transfer was performed for 36 fingers in 31 patients. An island flap containing terminal branches of the toe artery was embedded in the neck of the second toe to eliminate the morphological defect caused by stenosis in that area.

RESULTS

All reconstructed fingers and all flaps survived. No donor site complications occurred. The mean follow-up was 8 months (range, 5 to 25 months). The morphology of the reconstructed finger was close to that of a normal finger, and a natural transition could be observed in the finger pulp, the finger neck, and the junction between the toe and the finger. Sensory recovery of the finger pulp ranged from S1 to S3+. The mean pinch strength of the reconstructed fingers was 48% to 60% of that of the contralateral side. The mean DASH scores were 52.9, 48.9, and 46.0 for patients that had the index, third, and fourth fingers reconstructed, respectively, and the lowest mean aesthetic score was 70.

DISCUSSION

The method provides good aesthetic and functional outcomes, and overcomes aesthetic difficulties associated with other methods of toe transfer for finger reconstruction.

Reconstruction of the traumatized thumb

BACKGROUND

The goals of thumb reconstruction include the restoration of thumb length, strength, position, stability, mobility, sensibility, and aesthetics. It is a rare event when all of these objectives can be achieved, and prioritization should be based on the goals and functional demands of the patient.

METHODS

In this article, the authors review the most common reconstructive strategies for all types of traumatic thumb defects.

RESULTS

Replantation is approached first as the primary option for most amputations. Nonreplantable injuries are organized using a simple classification adapted from Lister, dividing thumb amputations into four functional categories: soft-tissue deficit with acceptable length, subtotal amputation with borderline length, total amputation with preservation of the carpometacarpal joint, and total amputation with destruction of the carpometacarpal joint. Within each category, relevant microsurgical and nonmicrosurgical reconstructive techniques are discussed, with a focus on appropriate technique selection for a given patient. Evidence and outcomes data are reviewed where available, and case examples from our own experience are provided.

CONCLUSIONS

Given that available options now range from simple gauze dressings to complex microsurgical reconstruction, preservation of reconstructive flexibility is essential and should be facilitated by judicious preservation of intact structures. The divergence of available reconstructive pathways underscores the importance of knowing one's patients, understanding their motivation, and assessing their goals. Only in properly matching the right reconstruction with the right patient will a mutually satisfactory result be achieved.

Risk factors for reexploration in toe-to-hand transfer: a multivariate analysis of 363 cases

BACKGROUND

Reexploration after toe-to-hand transfer increases the risk of failure. In this study, the authors aimed to identify risk factors for reexploration after toe-to-hand transfer.

METHODS

The medical records of 363 patients who underwent single toe-to-hand transfer between 2000 and 2010 were reviewed retrospectively. Patient demographics, clinical data, and operative data were collected, and multivariate analysis was performed.

RESULTS

Of these 363 patients, 299 toes (82.4 percent) had primary success in transplantation. Sixty-four toes required reexploration, of which seven toes failed. The overall success rate was 98.1 percent. Of the 64 toes that required reexploration, arterial spasm was found in 39 (60.9 percent), arterial thrombosis was found in 27 (42.2 percent), and venous thrombosis was found in 16 (25.0 percent). Multivariate logistic regression analysis revealed that postoperative wound infection, metacarpal hand injuries, and preceding flap coverage were independently associated with reexploration.

CONCLUSIONS

Reducing reexploration in toe-to-hand transfer may be facilitated by managing or avoiding these risk factors. Particular attention must be paid to avoid postoperative wound infection, which was the single greatest factor contributing to reexploration (adjusted OR, 12.6).

CLINICAL QUESTION/LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Risk, III.

Toe-to-hand transfer: evolving indications and relevant outcomes

Toe-to-hand transfer is indicated for many types of congenital and traumatic thumb absences. This review will highlight the applications of toe-to-hand transfer and their functional, aesthetic, and psychosocial outcomes. Despite its technical complexity, toe to hand reconstruction techniques can provide an elegant option to restore function for patients with difficult hand disabilities.

Posttraumatic reconstruction of the hand--a retrospective review of 87 toe-to-hand transfers compared with an earlier report

PURPOSE

The purpose of this study was to retrospectively review the results of 87 toe-to-hand transfers performed in 73 procedures, compare them to the report published by the senior author in 1983, and confirm the hypothesis that results of toe-to-hand transfers at our center have improved over time.

METHODS

The results of 87 toe-to-hand transfers performed between 1981 and 2001 were reviewed and compared with the results of 54 toe-to-hand transfers performed between 1974 and 1980. The measured parameters were type of reconstruction performed, anticoagulation therapy, vascular patency, frequency of secondary surgery, and strength of thumb reconstructions.

RESULTS

In the recent time period, 11% of the procedures had complications with revascularization of the transferred digit, and long-term survival was seen in 98% of the toe-to-hand transfers. This is a significant improvement over earlier results, in which 33% of the cases had some microvascular compromise and the survival of grafts was lower (91%). Pinch strength for thumb reconstructions improved, and the number of secondary surgeries performed dropped, but neither of these parameters reached a significant level. Toes used for reconstruction changed, with an 18% decrease in use of big toe for thumb reconstruction and a similar increase in use of the second toe. For non-thumb digital reconstructions there was a 60% decrease in use of second and third toe combined, whereas use of the second toe alone increased similarly.

CONCLUSIONS

This study showed reduction of the incidence of vascular compromise compared to the previous report. Improved strength of thumb reconstructions and reduced need for secondary surgery was also displayed. These findings are likely attributed to refinements in reconstructive procedures and operative techniques.

TYPE OF STUDY/LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Therapeutic IV.

Thumb reconstruction with toe transfer

Microsurgical toe transfer has become a gold standard option for amputated thumb reconstruction. It can be used to correct almost any thumb defect. However, for optimal functional and esthetic results, proper initial care, preoperative planning, proper selection of suitable techniques, adjunct or secondary procedures and proper, postoperative rehabilitation are important.

Functional and aesthetic results of immediate reconstruction of traumatic thumb defects by toe-to-thumb transplantation

Traumatic thumb defects significantly affect the function and appearance of the hand; thus, thumb reconstruction is very important in clinical practice. In our report, three reconstruction strategies of toe-to-thumb transplantation, based on the amputation level of the thumb, were used for immediate thumb reconstruction in 27 patients with traumatic thumb defects. All procedures were performed successfully. Patients were satisfied with the function and appearance of the reconstructed thumb. These results indicate that if the reconstruction method is properly selected based on the amputation level of the thumb, toe-to-thumb transplantation is feasible for the immediate reconstruction of the thumb.

Ischemic toe encountered during harvesting: report of 6 cases

Local vessel disease causing lack of arterial inflow at the time of toe harvesting represents a surgical emergency. In a personal experience of 194 toe transfers to the hand, 6 cases (in 4 patients) were found to have diseased vessels at the first web to the point that acute ischemia of the toe occurred when the tourniquet was released at the lower limb. We report our experience in these 6 cases.

Posttraumatic finger reconstruction with microsurgical transplantation of toes

This article outlines current methods of toe transplantation as applied to posttraumatic finger reconstruction (excluding the thumb). Key points that are important during the initial assessment and surgical treatment of such injuries are addressed. Reconstructive options for distal and proximal finger injuries, single and multiple finger injuries, and metacarpal hand injuries are presented, and the timing of toe transplantation procedures is discussed. Finally, additional concepts and techniques that, with experience, have proved useful for optimizing functional and esthetic results are highlighted, along with schemes for motor and sensory rehabilitation.

Salvage of sensation in a hallux-to-thumb transfer by nerve tube reconstruction

We report a patient in whom, at 3 years after successful reconstruction of a right avulsed thumb with a microvascular hallux transfer, the insensate transfer had sensibility restored. The radial sensory and both volar digital nerves of the thumb were reconstructed using 2.3-mm-diameter bioabsorbable neural conduits. At 30 months after reconstruction, static 2-point discrimination of the hallux was 4 mm at 14.7 g/mm(2) in this now 42-year-old right-handed man. The cutaneous pressure threshold for 1-point static touch was 0.7 g/mm(2). There were no painful neuromas at the nerve reconstruction sites.