Regulatory cell-mediated tolerance does not protect against chronic rejection

Immunoregulatory function of IL-27 and TGF-β1 in cardiac allograft transplantation

BACKGROUND

Deciphering the mechanisms of tolerance represents a crucial aim of research in transplantation. We previously identified by DNA chip interleukin (IL)-27 p28 and transforming growth factor (TGF)-β1 as overexpressed in a model of rat cardiac allograft tolerance mediated by regulatory CD4CD25 T cells. The role of these two molecules on the control of the inflammatory response remains controversial. However, both are involved in the regulation of the T helper 17/Treg axis, suggesting their involvement in tolerance.

METHODS

We analyzed regulation of IL-27 and TGF-β1 expression in allograft response and their role in tolerance by using blocking anti-TGF-β antibody and by generating an adeno-associated virus encoding IL-27.

RESULTS

Here, we confirmed the overexpression of IL-27 and TGF-β1 in tolerated cardiac allografts in two different rodent models. We observed that their expression correlates with inhibition of T helper 17 differentiation and with expansion of regulatory CD4CD25 T cells. We showed in a rat model that anti-TGF-β treatment abrogates infectious tolerance mediated by the transfer of regulatory CD4CD25 T cells. Moreover, overexpression of IL-27 by adeno-associated virus administration in combination with a short-term immunosuppression allows prolongation of cardiac allograft survival and one tolerant recipient. We found that IL-27 overexpression did not induce Foxp3CD4CD25 T-cell expansion but rather IL-10-expressing CD4 T cells in the tolerant recipient.

CONCLUSIONS

Taken together, these data suggest that both TGF-β1 and IL-27 play a role in the mechanisms of tolerance. However, in contrast to TGF-β1, IL-27 seems not to be involved in regulatory CD4CD25 T-cell expansion but rather in their mode of action.

Regulatory T cells in transplantation

T Regulatory cells (Treg) play an important role in the induction and maintenance of immunological tolerance to self and alloantigens. Recent findings in experimental transplant models have demonstrated that Treg can control acute and delayed allograft rejection. Preclinical attempts to use Treg as a cellular therapy have been successfully undertaken demonstrating the safety and feasibility of such treatment, suggesting that they have therapeutic potential.

Immunologic unresponsiveness to alloantigen in vivo: a role for regulatory T cells

Exposure to alloantigen in vivo or in vitro induces alloantigen reactive regulatory T cells that can control transplant rejection. The mechanisms that underpin the activity of alloantigen reactive regulatory T cells in vivo are common with those of regulatory T cells that prevent autoimmunity. The identification and characterization of regulatory T cells that control rejection and contribute to the induction of immunologic unresponsiveness to alloantigens in vivo has opened up exciting opportunities for new therapies in transplantation. Findings from laboratory studies are informing the design of clinical protocols using regulatory T cells as a cellular therapy.

Long-term allograft tolerance is characterized by the accumulation of B cells exhibiting an inhibited profile

Numerous reports have highlighted the central role of regulatory T cells in long-term allograft tolerance, but few studies have investigated the B-cell aspect. We analyzed the B-cell response in a rat model of long-term cardiac allograft tolerance induced by a short-term immunosuppression. We observed that tolerated allografts are infiltrated by numerous B cells organized in germinal centers that are strongly regulated in their IgG alloantibody response. Moreover, alloantibodies from tolerant recipients exhibit a deviation toward a Th2 isotype and do not activate in vitro donor-type endothelial cells in a pro-inflammatory way but maintained expression of cytoprotective molecules. Interestingly, this inhibition of the B-cell response is characterized by the progressive accumulation in the graft and in the blood of B cells blocked at the IgM to IgG switch recombination process and overexpressing BANK-1 and the inhibitory receptor Fcgr2b. Importantly, B cells from tolerant recipients are able to transfer allograft tolerance. Taken together, these results demonstrate a strong regulation of the alloantibody response in tolerant recipients and the accumulation of B cells exhibiting an inhibited and regulatory profile. These mechanisms of regulation of the B-cell response could be instrumental to develop new strategies to promote tolerance.

Intensity of transplant chronic rejection correlates with level of graft-infiltrating regulatory cells

BACKGROUND

The understanding of chronic rejection (transplant vascular sclerosis, or TVS) mechanisms is a major goal of transplantation. In this study we tested a cardiac transplant model for TVS development in connection with emerging T-regulatory cells (T-regs). We used 40-mer peptides derived from the donor MHC Class I alpha1 helix of the alpha1-domain to make recipients tolerant.

METHODS

ACI recipients were transplanted with either RT1.A(u) (WF), RT1.A(l) (LEW), RT1.A(c) (PVG), or RT1.A(b) (BUF) cardiac grafts. The grafts were analyzed 120 days later for TVS and development of T-regs.

RESULTS

Donor MHC peptides were injected through the portal vein (0.1 mg) into ACI recipients of WF hearts in addition to sub-therapeutic cyclosporine (CsA, 10 mg/kg for 3 days post-operatively). Peptide treatment specifically prolonged graft survival for >100 days (n = 31). ACI recipients of WF or LEW hearts treated with PVG peptides promptly rejected the transplanted grafts (15 +/- 4 and 20 +/- 1 days, respectively). Presence of T-regs in tolerant recipients was confirmed by the adoptive transfer of T cells into a new cohort of syngeneic recipients (mean survival time [MST] >100 days, n = 3). CD4(+) and FoxP3(+) cells were detected in 70% of the chronically rejected grafts vs 38% (CD4) and 22% (FoxP3) in the well-preserved transplants. IgG and IgM deposits were found in only half of surviving cardiac grafts with a high level of TVS. Blood vessels in grafts with attenuated TVS were 80% IgG and IgM positive. Interleukin (IL)-4 and IL-2 were markedly down-regulated in the hearts with high TVS compared with well-preserved grafts. Long-term-surviving hearts demonstrated increased IL-10 expression. Interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma) was more evident in the grafts with a high TVS.

CONCLUSIONS

Donor MHC Class I peptides can specifically prolong transplant survival and generate T-regs. The level of intragraft T-regs correlates with severity of TVS and IL-2/IL-4 down-regulation.

Value of FOXP3 expression in peripheral blood as rejection marker after miniature swine lung transplantation

BACKGROUND

Outcome for highly immunogenic lung transplantation remains unsatisfactory despite the development of potent immunosuppressants. The poor outcome may be the result of a lack of minimally invasive methods to detect early rejection. There is emerging clinical evidence that, paradoxically, expression of forkhead box P3 (FOXP3, a specific marker for the regulatory T cells) is upregulated within rejecting grafts.

METHODS

Orthotopic lung transplantation was performed using miniature swine without immunosuppression. Rejection was monitored by chest radiography and open lung biopsy. Expressions levels of FOXP3, perforin, Fas-L and IP-10 mRNA were quantified in the peripheral blood. In addition, rescue immunosuppressive therapy (steroid plus tacrolimus) was administered on post-operative day (POD) 4 or 6.

RESULTS

Early rejection was detected by open lung biopsy, but misdiagnosed by chest radiography on POD 4. Expression of FOXP3 in the peripheral blood reached its highest value as early as POD 4, followed by a decline. Such an increase of FOXP3 was not observed in recipients given high-dose tacrolimus. Neither perforin, Fas-L or IP-10 in the peripheral blood exhibited significant fluctuations in the early phase of rejection. Rescue immunosuppressive therapy from POD 4, when peak FOXP3 was seen, prolonged graft survival (27.2 days, versus 9.1 days without immunosuppression, p < 0.001), in contrast to POD 6, when rejection was suspected by chest radiography (11.5 days, p = not statistically significant [NS]).

CONCLUSIONS

In a miniature swine lung transplantation model, the FOXP3 mRNA level in the peripheral blood was upregulated at an early phase of rejection. The clinical implication of this finding remains to be elucidated.

Indirect CD4+ TH1 response, antidonor antibodies and diffuse C4d graft deposits in long-term recipients conditioned by donor antigens priming

Priming of recipients by DST induces long-term survival of mismatched allografts in adult rats. Despite these recipients developing inducible T regulatory cells able to transfer long-term graft survival to a secondary host, a state of chronic rejection is also observed. We revisited the molecular donor MHC targets of the cellular response in acute rejection and analyzed the cellular and humoral responses in recipients with long-term graft survival following transplantation. We found three immunodominant peptides, all derived from LEW.1W RT1.D(u) molecules to be involved in acute rejection of grafts from unmodified LEW.1A recipients. Although the direct pathway of allorecognition was reduced in DST-treated recipients, the early CD4+ indirect pathway response to dominant peptides was almost unimpaired. We also detected early and sustained antidonor class I and II antibody subtypes with diffuse C4d deposits on graft vessels. Finally, long-term accepted grafts displayed leukocyte infiltration, endarteritis and fibrosis, which evolved toward vascular narrowing at day 100. Altogether, these data suggest that the chronic graft lesions developed in long-term graft recipients are the result of progressive humoral injury associated with a persisting indirect T helper response. These features may represent a useful model for understanding and manipulating chronic active antibody-mediated rejection in human.

Ischemia- reperfusion injury and its influence on the epigenetic modification of the donor kidney genome

BACKGROUND

In clinical transplantation, ischemia-reperfusion injury (I/RI) causes damage to DNA. We hypothesize that one form of damage is the demethylation of methylated cytosines in the donor genome caused by the oxidative environment created first by ischemia, and subsequently by reperfusion on transplantation. This study contributes to the understanding of how the short-lived and transient ischemic insult may influence chronic pathological changes that occur in clinical transplantation in the long term.

METHODS

A model of I/RI and chronic rejection; Fisher to Fisher kidney transplant rendered cold-ischemic for 4 hr before transplantation, to induce antigen-independent chronic nephropathy over a 6-month period, was used. Tissue was assessed by histopathology and methylation by pyrosequencing analysis.

RESULTS

An epigenetic map of the rat renal C3 promoter was produced, which identified methylated Cytosine phospho Guanine (CpG) sites coincident to cytokine response elements and nuclear factor kappa-light-chain-enhancer of activated B cells (NF-kappaB) binding sites. Pyrosequencing analysis showed that the tissue that had undergone 4 hr ischemia and reperfusion developed aberrant demethylation of cytosines in putative regulatory sites within the C3 promoter.

CONCLUSION

These findings may describe a newly recognized phenomena in the field of transplantation. Aberrant demethylation has long been linked to the development of tumors, and our data suggest a similar mechanism of gene dysregulation that may be initiated by I/RI with acute and chronic effects. These data may contribute to a further understanding of how the short lived and transient ischemic insult influences chronic pathological changes that occur even in the absence of major histocompatibility complex disparity in transplantation.

Implication of matrix metalloproteinase 7 and the noncanonical wingless-type signaling pathway in a model of kidney allograft tolerance induced by the administration of anti-donor class II antibodies

In rats, tolerance to MHC-incompatible renal allografts can be induced by the administration of anti-donor class II Abs on the day of transplantation. In this study we explored the mechanisms involved in the maintenance phase of this tolerance by analyzing intragraft gene expression profiles by microarray in long-term accepted kidneys. Comparison of the gene expression patterns of tolerated to syngeneic kidneys revealed 5,954 differentially expressed genes (p < 0.05). Further analysis of this gene set revealed a key role for the wingless-type (WNT) signaling pathway, one of the pivotal pathways involved in cell regulation that has not yet been implicated in transplantation. Several genes within this pathway were significantly up-regulated in the tolerated grafts, particularly matrix metalloproteinase 7 (MMP7; fold change > 40). Analysis of several other pathway-related molecules indicated that MMP7 overexpression was the result of the noncanonical WNT signaling pathway. MMP7 expression was restricted to vascular smooth muscle cells and was specific to anti-class II Ab-induced tolerance, as it was undetectable in other models of renal and heart transplant tolerance and chronic rejection induced across the same strain combination. These results suggest a novel role for noncanonical WNT signaling in maintaining kidney transplant tolerance in this model, with MMP7 being a key target. Determining the mechanisms whereby MMP7 contributes to transplant tolerance may help in the development of new strategies to improve long-term graft outcome.

Short-term cyclosporine therapy and cotransplantation of donor splenocytes: effects on graft rejection and survival rates in pigs subjected to renal transplantation

BACKGROUND

Donor-specific allogeneic loading can prolong the survival of solid organ transplants by inducing a state known as acceptance. Several populations of cells are known to be involved in this process, but their exact roles have yet to be defined. The aim of this study was to assess the effects of portal-vein transfusion of donor-specific splenocytes (DST) after short-term cyclosporine A (CyA) therapy in pigs subjected to renal transplantation.

METHODS

Four groups of unrelated swine underwent renal transplantation with removal of the native kidneys. Antirejection protocols consisted in portal-vein DST (3 x 10(8) cells/kg) (Group 2, n = 7); intravenous CyA (9 mg/kg/d) on postoperative days 1-12 (Group 3, n = 14); and DST + CyA (as described above) (Group 4, n = 13). Results (through postoperative day 90) were compared with those obtained in untreated control recipients (Group 1, n = 7).

RESULTS

Compared with animals of Groups 1, 2, and 3, Group 4 recipients presented significantly longer survival (mean: 90 days, P < 0.01 in Kaplan-Meier analysis) and better renal function (P < 0.05). Graft histology revealed preserved parenchyma.

CONCLUSION

The role of spleen cells in the immune response has probably been underestimated. Cotransplantation of donor splenocytes seems to induce a certain degree of acceptance toward the renal allograft. The route of administration (portal-vein infusion in this study) may be crucial for developing favorable mechanisms of recognition.

The protective effect of CD8+CD28- T suppressor cells on the acute rejection responses in rat liver transplantation

Regulatory T cells (Tr) or T-suppressor cells (Ts), which include CD4+CD25+ T cells and CD8+CD28- T cells respectively, have been shown to be essential for the induction and maintenance of immune tolerance. We have investigated the effect of CD8+CD28- Ts and CD4+CD25+ Tr on acute rejection responses in rat liver transplantation (OLT).

METHODS

CD8+CD28- Ts/CD4+CD25+ Tr were obtained from inbred and naïve rats that show spontaneous tolerance to OLT. Adoptive transfers were performed in acute rejection models of various strain combinations with survival times observed to evaluate suppressive effects. Donor-specific blood transfusion (DST) was used to induce CD8+CD28- Ts in naïve rats, which were assayed in vitro using carboxyfluorescein diacetate succinimidyl easter-labeled one-way mixed lymphocyte reactions. Secondary adoptive transfers of DST-induced CD8+CD28- Ts were also performed in an acute OLT rejection model.

RESULTS

CD8+CD28- Ts from tolerant OLT model rats possessed immunosuppressive activity in allogeneic recipients; adoptive transfers of these cells alleviated the acute rejection responses. However, CD4+CD25+ Tr derived from tolerant or naïve rats failed to do so. In vitro DST-induced CD8+CD28- Ts inhibited alloantigen T-cell responses in naïve syngeneic rats in an antigen-specific manner. Secondary adoptive transfer of DST-induced CD8+CD28-Ts further reduced acute rejection but not chronic rejection responses.

CONCLUSIONS

CD8+CD28- Ts cells protected allogeneic recipients from acute rejection in rat OLT. Furthermore, this activity was not present in CD4+CD25+Tr. DST was observed to be an effective method to generate functional CD8+CD28-Ts in naïve rats.

Spontaneous operational tolerance after immunosuppressive drug withdrawal in clinical renal allotransplantation

Tolerance is the so-called "Holy Grail" of transplantation, but achieving this state is proving a major challenge, particularly in the clinical setting. Even in rodents, the definition of true transplant tolerance is not applicable to many models, with late graft damage often occurring despite long-term graft survival. Hence the term "operational tolerance," based more on graft function and absence of exogenous immunosuppression, is being adopted. Although the most sought-after goal in this field is to intentionally induce this state in a controlled manner, translating protocols across species from rodents to the clinic, the current literature demonstrates that this is proving a formidable task. A complementary approach is to address transplant tolerance from a different angle, by studying tolerance-like phenomena that occur "unintentionally" in transplant patients after immunosuppressive drug weaning. Such spontaneous operational tolerance, which can take place after years of immunosuppression, is rare in kidney transplant recipients. However, determining exactly how this state arises and how it can be detected may make it possible to induce it in a greater number of patients and then to return to the drawing board to rationally design protocols that have a greater chance of clinical success. Moreover, the study of such patients should help in the identification of biomarkers of low immunological risk that could be used to select patients for potential weaning. Collaborative efforts through international networks, together with the application of newer and more powerful technologies to diagnostic, prognostic, and mechanistic research, may help transplanters to achieve this goal.

T regulatory cells in stable posttransplant bronchiolitis obliterans syndrome

BACKGROUND

Obliterative bronchiolitis (OB), mainly mediated by T cells, remains the major cause of morbidity and death in long-term lung transplant. Acute rejection (AR), also a T-cell mediated process, is strongly linked to OB. For unknown reasons, several patients with OB halt their pulmonary function decline and stabilize their obstructive defect for a long period. Our aim was to assess the T-cell activation in blood, induced sputum, and broncho-alveolar lavage during AR, stable OB (sOB), and evolving OB (eOB).

METHODS

T-cell phenotype and cytokine production were assessed by flow cytometry in these three compartments. Interleukin-4, interferon-gamma and transforming growth factor (TGF)-beta levels were measured by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay in blood cell culture supernatants. Results were compared between healthy lung transplant recipients and AR (n=7), sOB (n=7), and eOB (n=13).

RESULTS

Stable and evolutive OB were characterized by a Treg, Th1, and Th2 activation, but compared to eOB, Treg and Th2 cells predominated in sOB. A clear Th1 activation was observed in AR. TGF-beta was increased in AR and evolving OB.

CONCLUSION

These preliminary results indicate a contrasted T-cell activation profile depending on the clinical conditions. We speculate that Treg cells could counterbalance the Th0 activation seen in evolving OB and participate in stabilization of airway obstruction.

Regulation of transplant arteriosclerosis by CD25+CD4+ T cells generated to alloantigen in vivo

BACKGROUND

CD25+CD4+ regulatory T cells have been shown to suppress alloimmunity in various experimental settings. Here, we hypothesized that alloantigen-reactive regulatory T cells would reduce the severity of transplant arteriosclerosis.

METHODS

CD25+CD4+ T cells from CBA mice that were pretreated with C57BL/6 (B.6) blood (donor-specific transfusion, DST) and nondepleting anti-CD4 Ab (YTS 177) were cotransferred with naïve CBA CD25-CD4+"effector" T cells into CBA-rag-/- mice. These animals received aorta transplants from B.6 CD31-/- donors. CBA wild-type recipients of B.6 aorta grafts were pretreated with 177/DST directly. Some animals received 6x10(5) CD25+CD4+ T cells from pretreated mice to augment regulation on day -1. Grafts were harvested on day 30.

RESULTS

Luminal occlusion of the graft caused by neointima formation was 29.3+/-19.4% (n=5) after transfer of effector T cells only. Co-transfer of CD25+CD4+ regulators reduced occlusion significantly (2.4+/-3.3%, n=3; P=0.009). This effect was partially abrogated in the presence of a CTLA4 blocking Ab (11.1+/-4.7%, n=4; P=0.008). Pretreating immunocompetent CBA recipients of B.6 aortic allografts with 177/DST did not reduce transplant arteriosclerosis significantly (43.0+/-15.7%, n=5 vs. 56.6+/-16.8%, n=5; 177/DST vs. controls; P=0.22). However, when pretreated primary CBA recipients received an additional transfer of 6 x 10(5) CD25+CD4+ T cells procured from other mice pretreated with 177/DST before transplantation, luminal occlusion of the graft was markedly reduced (33.0+/-7.6%, n=5; P=0.002).

CONCLUSION

Regulatory T cells generated in vivo to alloantigen can prevent CD25-CD4+ T-cell-mediated transplant arteriosclerosis. In immunocompetent recipients, these cells have potential to be used as cellular immunotherapy to control transplant arteriosclerosis.

Functional compartmentalization following induction of long-term graft survival with pregraft donor-specific transfusion

Long-term survival is achieved in rat recipients by pre-graft donor-specific blood transfusion. We characterized the immune compartments in long-term survivors and analyzed them for capacity to transfer tolerance and protect against chronic rejection. Splenocytes and spleen T cells from treated recipients transferred long-term graft survival to 100% of secondary recipients. In contrast, blood transferred graft survival to only 50% of recipients whereas blood T cells had no effect. An unaltered TCR repertoire, an increase in suppressive CD4+CD25+ T cells, a decrease in antidonor T-cell proliferative response and normal perforin-granzyme levels were the hallmarks of the spleen T cells. Blood T cells were characterized by a strongly altered CD8+ repertoire, normal CD4+CD25+ T cell number with unchanged antidonor T-cell proliferative response, an activated T-cell phenotype and an increase in perforin-granzyme levels. However, following the transfer of blood or spleen cells into secondary recipients, all grafts displayed chronic rejection. These findings provide evidence that distinct compartments play critical roles in DST recipients. Regulatory cells do not accumulate in blood, which appears to be a reservoir for cytotoxic T cells. Spleen T cells, which display a regulatory-like profile and transfer graft survival, are not able to prevent chronic rejection.

New evidence for a role of allograft accommodation in long-term tolerance

BACKGROUND

Progressively better therapies have largely prevented or at least effectively treated acute allograft rejection. Consequently, the long-term survival of solid organ transplants has increasingly become limited primarily by the development of chronic allograft rejection. The mechanisms of chronic rejection remain largely unknown and the induction of specific tolerance would be the ultimate achievement in transplant immunology. We previously demonstrated, in a fully major histocompatibility complex (MHC)-mismatched rat cardiac allograft combination, that a 20-day treatment with a deoxyspergualin (DSG) analogue, LF15-0195, induces allograft tolerance with the development of potent CD4CD25 regulatory T cells. In order to better characterize the mechanisms involved in allograft tolerance, we compared long-term tolerated allografts with allografts exhibiting signs of chronic rejection induced by donor-specific blood transfusion.

METHODS

We analyzed both types of allografts for infiltration, alloantibody production and gene expression by histology, exhaustive microarray and quantitative reverse-transcriptase polymerase chain reaction.

RESULTS

Interestingly, we observed in tolerated allografts an infiltrate as dense as the one observed in chronically rejected allografts and alloantibody deposits on graft endothelial cells. Prominent gene expression of many putative proinflammatory cytokines and genes related to cell activation or cytotoxicity were observed in tolerated allografts. However, we observed a specific upregulation of cytoprotective genes such as nitric oxide synthase, BclXL, and indoleamine 2,3 dioxygenase, and a poor in situ expression of immunoglobulin chain gene.

CONCLUSIONS

This study demonstrates a state of accommodation of tolerated allografts and suggests the importance of early control of humoral immunity for the prevention of chronic rejection and the maintenance of long-term tolerance.

Development of CD25– regulatory T cells following heart transplantation: Evidence for transfer of long-term survival

Donor-specific heart allograft acceptance can be induced in the MHC-mismatched LEW.1 W to LEW.1A rat by donor-specific transfusions. Whereas the induction phase of tolerance has been studied in detail, its maintenance remained poorly understood. Here, we performed a side-by-side comparison of CD25+ and CD25- splenic T cells of 100-day tolerant rats. Administration of CD25- T cells from tolerant rats to sublethally irradiated recipients transferred long-term graft survival. These CD25- T cells displayed a decreased donor-specific response in the mixed lymphocyte reaction and presented suppressive activity. These CD25- T cells accumulated IFN-gamma, IL-10 and Foxp3 transcripts. The in vitro suppressive activity of CD25- T cells required both cell contact and soluble factors (IL-10 and IFN-gamma). The CD25+ T cells from tolerant rats did not show any modification of their regulatory properties. We show that splenic CD25- T cells of tolerant rats contribute to the maintenance of tolerance following the transplantation. Our data show that regulatory T cells are not restricted to the CD4+ CD25+ T cell subset and provide new insights on the mechanisms of tolerance to allograft following donor cell priming.

Opposite effects of donor apoptotic versus necrotic splenocytes on splenic allograft tolerance

BACKGROUND

Apoptotic cells have immunosuppressive activity, whereas necrotic cells activate immune response, indicating they might have different effects on immune rejection against splenic allografts. The aim of this study was to determine whether administration of apoptotic or necrotic splenocytes of donor origin could impact the acute rejection of splenic allografts.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Apoptotic or necrotic splenocytes derived from donor rats were induced by irradiation or freeze thaw, respectively. Heterotopic vascularized spleen transplantation was performed from Wistar-Furth (donor) to Sprague-Dawley (recipient) rats, and splenocytes were intravenously injected into the recipients. At different time points, the recipients were sacrificed and the splenic allografts underwent histological examination. The interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma) and transforming growth factor-beta1 (TGF-beta1) in sera, spleens of recipients, and donor splenocytes before administration were measured. Mixed leukocyte reaction (MLR) was detected with recipient splenocytes as effectors and donor splenocytes as stimulators.

RESULTS

Exposure to gamma-irradiation at dose of 10,000 rad caused over 80% splenocytes to become apoptotic. The levels of TGF-beta1 released by apoptotic splenocytes in vitro were significantly higher than that by untreated splenocytes, whereas there was almost no TGF-beta1 detected in necrotic splenocytes culture medium. Administration of apoptotic splenocytes significantly attenuated acute rejection of splenic allografts, evidenced by less severe splenic histological alteration and reduction of histological scores compared with control; whereas necrotic splenocytes exacerbated the acute rejection. Apoptotic splenocytes inhibited production of IFN-gamma but increased the levels of TGF-beta1, whereas necrotic splenocytes showed opposite activity in production of those cytokines. Administration of apoptotic splenocytes inhibited MLR, and necrotic splenocytes promoted MLR.

CONCLUSIONS

The apoptotic and necrotic splenocytes exhibited opposite effects on acute rejection against splenic allografts, and IFN-gamma and TGF-beta1 have been involved in the effects.

Is clinical tolerance realistic in the next decade?

Tolerance to allografts would mean a better quality of life and prognosis for transplant patients. Despite the first descriptions of tolerance to alloantigens over 50 years ago, deliberately induced tolerance in the clinic on a wide scale remains a goal that is not quite in reach. However, much progress has been made in understanding tolerance in rodent models and in the few reports of induced or spontaneously occurring tolerance in humans. Here, we review this progress made in the quest to achieve clinical tolerance.

Immunological analogy between allograft rejection, recurrent abortion and pre-eclampsia - the same basic mechanism?

There are still controversies concerning the role of immunological mechanisms engaged both in recurrent abortions (RA) and pre-eclampsia (PE). According to some opinions, recurrent miscarriage is comparable to organ-specific autoimmune disease. Analysis of immune reactions shows that graft rejection shares many similar mechanisms with RA and PE. This fact allows us to conclude that rejection of transplanted alloantigenic organs and pregnancy loss have probably the same evolutionary origin. Subsets and functions of immunocompetent cells (T CD4, suppressor gammadeltaT, cytotoxic T CD8, Treg, Tr1, uterine NK cells), over-activation of innate immunity (activation of NK cytotoxic cells, macrophages, neutrophils and complement), changes of Th1/Th2 cytokine balance (IL-2, IL-12, IL-15, IL-18, IFNgamma, TNFalpha vs. IL-4, IL-10, TGFbeta), importance of HLA-G molecule, CD200/CD200R interaction, over-expression of adhesion molecules, fgl2 prothrombinase activation and stimulation of IDO and HO expression, all suggest that RA and PE are syndromes of fetal allograft rejection, and not organ-specific autoimmune diseases. According to that supposition, an analogy might exist between acute graft rejection and recurrent abortion, and between chronic graft rejection and pre-eclampsia.

Dominant Tolerance to Kidney Allografts Induced by Anti-Donor MHC Class II Antibodies: Cooperation between T and Non-T CD103+Cells

Allograft acceptance can be induced in the rat by pretransplant infusion of donor blood or spleen cells. Although promoting long-term acceptance, this treatment is also associated with chronic rejection. In this study, we show that a single administration of anti-donor MHC class II alloimmune serum on the day of transplantation results in indefinite survival of a MHC-mismatched kidney graft. Long-term recipients accept a donor-type skin graft and display no histological evidence of chronic rejection. The kidney grafts of tolerant animals display an accumulation of TCR Cbeta, FoxP3, and IDO transcripts. Moreover, as compared with syngeneic recipients, tolerant recipients harbor a large infiltrate of MHC class II(+) cells and CD103(+) cells. In vitro, splenocytes from tolerant recipients exhibit decreased donor-specific proliferation, which is restored by depletion of non-T cells and partially restored by the blockade of IDO. Finally, splenocytes from tolerant recipients, but not purified T cell splenocytes, transfer donor-specific infectious tolerance without chronic rejection, after infusion into naive recipients, over two generations. However, splenocytes depleted of T cells or splenocytes depleted of CD103(+) cells fail to transfer tolerance. Collectively, these data show that a single administration of anti-donor MHC class II alloimmune serum induces a tolerant state characterized by an infiltration of the kidney graft by regulatory T cells and CD103(+) cells. These data also show that the transfer of tolerance requires the presence of both T cells and CD103(+) dendritic cells. The precise mechanism of cooperation of these two cell subsets remains to be defined.

Immunological Unresponsiveness in Chimeric Miniature Swine following MHC-Mismatched Spleen Transplantation

BACKGROUND

In rodents, spleen allotransplantation (SpTx) induces tolerance. We investigated the induction of chimerism and donor-specific unresponsiveness following pig SpTx.

METHODS

Thirteen pigs underwent splenectomy (day 0); all received a blood transfusion. In 11/13 pigs, SpTx was performed across a MHC class I (n=1) or full (n=10) barrier; two control pigs received no SpTx. All pigs were monitored for chimerism, and anti-donor immune responses, including suppressor assays. Four pigs (two asplenic controls and two with SpTx) underwent delayed donor-matched kidney transplantation without immunosuppression.

RESULTS

Six of the 11 spleen grafts were lost from rejection (n=5) or splenic vein thrombosis (n=1), and five remained viable. All 11 SpTx recipients developed multilineage chimerism, but chimerism was rapidly lost if the graft failed. Two control pigs showed <6% blood chimerism for 4 and 11 days only. Pigs with functioning spleen grafts had multilineage chimerism in blood, thymus and bone marrow for at least 2-6 months, without graft-versus-host disease. These pigs developed in vitro donor-specific hyporesponsiveness and suppression. In 2 pigs tolerant to the spleen graft, donor MHC-matched kidney grafts survived for >4 and >7 months in the absence of exogenous immunosuppression; in two asplenic pigs, kidney grafts were rejected on days 4 and 15.

CONCLUSIONS

Successful SpTx can result in hematopoietic cell engraftment and in vitro donor-specific unresponsiveness, enabling prolonged survival of subsequent donor-matched kidney grafts without immunosuppression.

Combination Treatment with Donor-Specific Transfusions and Cyclosporine A Induces Long-Term Survival of Cardiac Allografts in Miniature Swine

BACKGROUND

To evaluate whether pretransplant donor-specific transfusions (DST) can induce tolerance to cardiac allografts in large animals, heterotopic cardiac transplants were performed across a class I MHC barrier in inbred miniature swine.

METHODS

Experimental animals received two DSTs, each containing 1.4x10 viable peripheral blood mononuclear cells, 14 and 7 days prior to transplantation together with a 12-day course of cyclosporine (CyA) (13 mg/kg IV) starting on postoperative day (POD) 0.

RESULTS

Untreated (n=2) and DST-only (n=2) treated control animals rejected between POD 6 and 8. Animals treated with CyA alone (n=3) exhibited graft survival to 53, 52 and 59 days. In contrast, the combination of DST and CyA (n=3) led to stable graft function for >200 days. Long-term survivors maintained peripheral CML response against donor antigen. Following DSTs, the donor-specific proliferative response of CD8+ recipient T cells was significantly increased (P=0.011), and a significant number of CD8+ T cells underwent apoptosis (10.1% on POD 0; 5.2% on POD -14; P=0.04). None of the DST-treated animals developed donor-specific antibodies.

CONCLUSIONS

These results are the first to demonstrate the ability of DST to induce operational tolerance to cardiac allografts in large animals, and they suggest that peripheral mechanisms of tolerance mediate this effect.

Early Presence of Regulatory Cells in Transplanted Rats Rendered Tolerant by Donor-Specific Blood Transfusion

Mechanisms by which donor-specific blood transfusion (DSBT) promotes organ allograft acceptance are unclear. In a rat fully mismatched cardiac allograft model, we found that DSBT alone (without immunotherapy) induces the development of regulatory T cells (DSBT-Tregs) posttransplant, thereby shedding new light in the mechanisms of the transfusion effect. Compartments and timing of expansion, requirements, and phenotype of DSBT-Tregs are unknown. It is generally assumed that some time is necessary before Tregs develop. However, we show-by adoptive transfer from DSBT-tolerant into naive recipients: 1) the presence of DSBT-Tregs at 5 days posttransplant in spleen and lymph nodes; 2) their gradual expansion in these compartments; and 3) their presence in the graft 14 of 30 days posttransplant. DSBT-Tregs are donor specific and do not protect third-party allografts. Splenocytes from DSBT-treated nontransplanted recipients or from transplanted DSBT-untreated (rejecting) recipients do not transfer tolerance, indicating that both DSBT and graft are required for sufficient numbers of DSBT-Tregs to develop. Thymectomy (or splenectomy) before DSBT (not at transplantation) abrogate DSBT-Tregs generation and tolerance, showing that thymus (and spleen) are required for DSBT-Tregs generation (not for expansion/maintenance). In contrast with other Tregs models, DSBT-Tregs activity is not restricted to CD4(+)CD25(+) but to CD4(+)CD45RC(-) cells, whereas CD4(+)CD45RC(+) cells act as effector cells and accelerate rejection. In conclusion, DSBT alone induces-rapidly posttransplant-the development of alloantigen-specific Tregs in lymphoid tissues and in the graft. DSBT, graft, thymus, and spleen are required for DSBT-Tregs generation. DSBT-Tregs in this model are CD4(+)CD45RC(-) (identical to Tregs protecting from autoimmunity in rats).

Administration of tolerogenic dendritic cells induced by interleukin-10 prolongs rat splenic allograft survival

The risk and intensity in splenic graft rejection are greater than in other types of transplants, because the spleen is the largest peripheral lymphoid organ and the immunosuppressive drugs administered can cause splenic dysfunction. In this study, we demonstrate that intravenous injection of interleukin-10-treated donor-type dendritic cells into recipient rats prolongs the survival of splenic allografts. Although the mechanisms are not clear, the induction of tolerance to grafted spleens seems to rely mainly on blockage of expression of the costimulatory molecule CD86, by interleukin-10, leading to enhanced apoptosis of allospecific T cells by immature and tolerogenic dendritic cells. Administration of tolerogenic cells induced by interleukin-10 may thus represent a useful approach for protection of splenic allografts. Further study is required to investigate the operative pathways and to optimize the strategy targeting dendritic cells to induce tolerance in splenic allografts.

Inhibitory and Stimulatory Effects of Cyclosporine A on the Development of Regulatory T Cells In Vivo

BACKGROUND

Regulatory T cells (Tregs) are increasingly recognized as playing a major role in nondeletional tolerance. To avoid rejection before tolerance is established, clinical trials of tolerance induction include immunosuppressive drugs early posttransplant. It is therefore essential that immunosuppressive protocols do not block Tregs generation. Tregs function has been shown to depend upon interleukin-2 signaling, but there are limited data available on how calcineurin inhibitors influence Tregs development and function in vivo.

METHODS

To study this, we used a previously established rat cardiac allograft model where donor-specific Tregs and tolerance are induced by pretransplant donor-specific blood transfusion (DSBT).

RESULTS

In this model, we found that adjunction of 50 mg/kg cyclosporine (CsA) (not a lower dose, 10 mg/kg) at the time of DSBT (not at the time of transplantation) abrogates Tregs development and causes rejection. Interestingly, 10 mg/kg CsA given posttransplant (day 0-11) in the absence of pretransplant DSBT induced the development of Tregs and provoked a state of tolerance indistinguishable from the one induced by DSBT. Finally, DSBT given the day of transplantation did not promote tolerance, unless recipients also received a delayed short course (day 5-9) of 10 mg/kg CsA.

CONCLUSIONS

Adjunction of high-dose CsA to pretransplant DSBT abrogates Tregs generation. On the contrary, a lower dose (10 mg/kg) of CsA promotes Tregs development either in synergy with perioperative DSBT (providing that a drug-free interval is respected) or by its own effect. These data provide new guidelines for a more tolerogenic use of calcineurin inhibitors in the clinic, particularly when immunomodulatory strategies aimed at inducing Tregs are applied.

Regulatory Cells, Th1/Th2 Unbalance, and Antibody-Induced Chronic Rejection in Operational Tolerance Induced by Donor-Specific Blood Transfusion

We developed a rodent model in which donor-specific blood transfusion (DSBT) promotes hyporesponsiveness and graft acceptance. In this model, signs of immune activation are present early posttransplant, with preserved proliferative responses against the donor and a dense cellular infiltrate in tolerant grafts. Intriguingly, an early accumulation of IFN-gamma is seen in grafts destined to become tolerized, supporting recent evidence that Th1 cytokines play a role in tolerance induction. Specific regulatory cells capable of propagating tolerance into naive recipients are operating. These mechanisms of immune activation and the generation of regulatory cells are influenced by immunosuppression (steroids and calcineurin inhibitors). In this model, in a second phase, a Th2 immune deviation occurs and is associated with the development of chronic rejection (vascular obliteration, endothelial IgG deposition, and complement binding). It remains unclear whether chronic rejection in this model is caused by Th2 type regulatory cells or whether chronic rejection is the consequence of an insufficient number of regulatory cells. In the clinic, the current strategy of profoundly inhibiting immune activation (in particular Th1 cytokines/responses) by using high dose calcineurin inhibitors and steroids may prove antagonistic with the development of tolerance, particularly when immunomodulatory strategies (such as DSBT) are applied. Development of chronic rejection in a regulation-based tolerance model suggests that deletion-based tolerogenic strategies may offer a more robust protection against chronic rejection.

Early Accumulation of Interferon-?? in Grafts Tolerized by Donor-Specific Blood Transfusion: Friend or Enemy?

BACKGROUND

We previously documented an early (day-2) interferon (IFN)-gamma accumulation in cardiac allografts of rats made tolerant by donor-specific blood transfusion (DSBT) but not in rejecting controls. This contrasted with the IFN-gamma peak seen later (day 5) in rejecting but not in tolerant rats.

METHODS

To further examine the role of early intragraft IFN-gamma in DSBT-induced tolerance, we studied whether IFN-gamma up-regulation correlates with the magnitude of the DSBT effect and how IFN-gamma is influenced by interventions abrogating tolerance.

RESULTS

The protective effect of DSBT depended upon the timing of administration: day-12 DSBT induced indefinite graft survival; day-6 DSBT gave a moderate, and day-0 DSBT, no graft prolongation. IFN-gamma up-regulation correlated with the DSBT effect: it was maximal after day-12 DSBT, intermediate after day-6 DSBT, and absent after day-0 DSBT. Tolerant splenocytes transferred tolerance into naive rats in a donor-specific manner, indicating that alloantigen-specific regulatory cells operate. Thymectomy prevented regulatory cells development, caused further amplification of intragraft IFN-gamma, and led to rejection, although graft survival was still prolonged.

CONCLUSIONS

Day 2 intragraft IFN-gamma correlates with the DSBT protective effect. Thymectomy abrogates DSBT-induced tolerance, prevents regulatory cell development, and paradoxically causes further accumulation of intragraft IFN-gamma. These data indicate that DSBT has a stimulatory and a (thymus-dependent) inhibitory effect on early intragraft IFN-gamma. Intragraft IFN-gamma is beneficial, providing it occurs early and remains moderate. The role of intragraft IFN-gamma in tolerance and rejection depends upon the timing and the degree of production and perhaps the type of IFN-gamma producing cells (regulatory or effector).

Gene transfer of interleukin-4 delays acute rejection of splenic allografts in rats

Spleen transplantation is the treatment of choice for some diseases, such as hemophilia A. However, the risk and intensity of rejection after spleen transplantation is greater and more difficult to control than other types of transplant. In the present study, we demonstrated that perfusion of IL-4 expression plasmids into donor spleens pretransplantation led to overexpression of IL-4 and downregulation of IFN-gamma in situ, associated with delayed acute rejection of the allograft. Gene transfer of IL-4 may represent a potential therapeutic approach to induce tolerance to splenic allografts.