Trying to Do What Is Best: A Qualitative Study of Maternal-Infant Bonding and Neonatal Abstinence Syndrome

Grounded Theory Approach to Understand Self-Management of Opioid Recovery Through Pregnancy and Early Parenting

OBJECTIVE

To develop a theory to explain the processes women use to self-manage recovery from opioid use disorder during pregnancy, the postpartum period, and early parenting.

DESIGN

Constructivist grounded theory approach.

PARTICIPANTS

Women (N = 16) who gave birth during the past 12 months and used medication for opioid use disorder for recovery through pregnancy and the postpartum period.

METHODS

We recruited participants through seven medication-assisted treatment clinics in a mid-size Midwestern city and the surrounding suburbs and through online parenting and recovery community groups with national-based memberships. We conducted semistructured, individual audio interviews from November 2020 to July 2021. Interviews continued until we reached theoretical and meaning saturation. We used constant comparative methods during initial and intermediate coding.

RESULTS

Participants described a central process, Growing as a Healthy Dyad, that included six processes they used to self-manage recovery: Maintaining Vigilance, Performing Self-Care, Putting in the Work of Recovery, Advocating, Navigating Social Support, and Acquiring Skills and Knowledge. These processes were affected by personal and social contextual factors.

CONCLUSIONS

The grounded theory, Self-Management of Opioid Recovery Through Pregnancy and Early Parenting, can be used to explain the unique processes of self-management by women in opioid recovery and highlights the need for a strengths-based approach to caring for the maternal-infant dyad.

Mutual Mistrust: The Multilayered Experiences at the Intersection of Healthcare and Early Parenting Among Mothers With Opioid Use Disorder

OBJECTIVE

The aim of the study is to explore the early parenting experiences among a cohort of postpartum individuals with opioid use disorder (OUD) both during and after the delivery hospitalization to identify areas of intervention to strengthen bonding and attachment.

METHODS

Semistructured qualitative interviews with recently pregnant people with OUD assessed parenting needs, supports, and goals in the context of the demands of addiction treatment and early motherhood. Probes explored the relationship between early parenting experiences, addiction, and recovery, as well as enabling factors and barriers to mother-infant bonding. Interviews were completed between 2019 to 2020. A constant comparative methods approach was used for codebook development and analysis.

RESULTS

Twenty-six women completed interviews a mean of 10.1 months postpartum. Twenty-four women were receiving methadone or buprenorphine treatment at delivery for OUD. Four interrelated themes emerged. Women experienced the following: (1) increased surveillance from healthcare workers who doubted their parenting ability; (2) a desire for a "normal" early parenting experience that was not disrupted by increased medical monitoring and surveillance; (3) complex and intersecting identities of being both a mother and a person in recovery; and (4) the importance of support from and advocacy by clinicians and peers to developing maternal confidence and connection.

CONCLUSIONS

Interventions are needed to improve the early parenting experiences of opioid-exposed mother-infant dyads, to address the mutual mistrust between health care providers and parents, and to provide additional supports to families. Promotion of positive attachment and parental self-efficacy should be prioritized over increased surveillance and scrutiny to sustain maternal recovery trajectories into early childhood and foster family well-being.

Rise in Neonatal Abstinence Syndrome Rate Is Associated with Increase in Buprenorphine Prescription Numbers

OBJECTIVES

Southern Appalachia is a region of the United States that is disproportionately affected by the opioid epidemic and by increasing rates of neonatal abstinence syndrome (NAS). NAS rates increased approximately 400% between 1999 and 2012. Buprenorphine prescriptions written to treat opioid use disorder also increased dramatically. The present study was undertaken to ascertain any relationship between the number of buprenorphine prescriptions compared with NAS rates in southern Appalachia.

METHODS

A total of 250 southern Appalachian counties across seven states, including all of West Virginia and portions of Virginia, Kentucky, Maryland, North Carolina, Ohio, and Tennessee were identified. A retrospective cohort analysis of these counties was conducted for the years 2005-2018. All of the data were obtained from publicly accessible sources or direct communication with government offices. Measures from each county in southern Appalachia included annual NAS rates, buprenorphine prescription rates, drug-induced death rates, and opioid prescribing rates. Associations among these variables were examined using a generalized linear regression.

RESULTS

Significant linear associations exist between the rising rate of NAS diagnoses and the rising rate of buprenorphine prescriptions (r = 0.977, R2 = 95.53%, P < 0.001) and between the rising rate of buprenorphine prescriptions and the increase in drug-induced deaths (r = 0.712, R2 = 50.82%, P = 0.031).

CONCLUSIONS

This is the first report that documents an association between rising NAS rates and increasing buprenorphine prescribing. Between the years 2010 and 2018, the NAS rate in southern Appalachia rose by 335%, and the number of buprenorphine prescriptions rose by 413%. Discussions regarding the current policies for buprenorphine management during pregnancy are warranted. We suggest a reevaluation of buprenorphine prescribing recommendations during pregnancy and further research on establishing the lowest effective buprenorphine dose for each pregnant patient.

Stigma Experienced by Perinatal Women with Opioid Dependency in the United States: A Qualitative Meta-Synthesis

Stigma is a barrier to accessing care and treatment for perinatal women with pain and opioid dependency, resulting in increased maternal/neonatal morbidity and mortality, prolonged neonatal hospitalizations, and increased healthcare-related costs. This theory-generating qualitative meta-synthesis includes 18 qualitative research reports and describes the stigma-related experiences of perinatal women with opioid dependency. A model emerged consisting of cyclical yet pivotal care points, facilitators/deterrents of stigma, and stigma experiences including infant-associative stigma. Findings of this qualitative meta-synthesis include the following: (a) Perinatal stigma experiences may prevent women from accessing care; (b) Infant-associative stigma may influence the woman to deflect stigma from her infant onto herself; and (c) There is the risk of mothers withdrawing their infants from healthcare to protect from future anticipated stigma. Implications reveal ideal time points to enact healthcare interventions to reduce perinatal stigma experiences and its consequences on maternal/child health and wellness.

"It's a proactive intervention instead of a reactive one": measuring facilitators and barriers regarding readiness to implement a treatment program for infants with neonatal opioid withdrawal syndrome

BACKGROUND

Managing Abstinence in Newborns (MAiN) is an evidence-based, cost-saving approach to caring for infants at risk of developing neonatal opioid withdrawal syndrome (NOWS). MAiN provides medication management in combination with education and is being implemented in hospitals across South Carolina (SC). This expansion of MAiN throughout the state includes educational training for providers on managing NOWS symptomology and evaluation support for data collection and analysis. This evaluation assessed the readiness of hospitals to implement MAiN by identifying potential barriers and facilitators to early program adoption.

METHODS

We used the Consolidated Framework for Implementation Framework (CFIR) to guide the evaluation. As part of the ongoing evaluation of MAiN implementation, brief, structured interviews were conducted with healthcare providers (n = 82) at seven hospitals between 2019 and 2022 to learn more about perceived barriers and facilitators to implementation readiness. Two coders independently reviewed all transcripts and used deductive thematic analysis to code qualitative data using Atlas.ti Web using the established CFIR codebook.

RESULTS

We identified barriers and facilitators to implementing MAiN in all five CFIR domains. Providers identified MAiN as an evidence-based, patient-centered model with the flexibility to adapt to patients' complex needs. Specific champions, external support, alignment with providers' personal motivation, and an adaptable implementation climate were identified as facilitators for implementation readiness. Barriers included a lack of consistent communication among hospital providers, minimal community resources to support patients and families after discharge, and a lack of provider buy-in early in implementation.

CONCLUSIONS

Key barriers and facilitators of MAiN implementation readiness were identified at seven participating hospitals throughout SC. Communication, staff and hospital culture and climate, and internal and external resource were all reported as essential to implementation. These findings could inform the MAiN program expansion in hospitals across SC.

Factors Associated with Maternal Engagement in Infant Care When Mothers Use Substances

Introduction

Mothers who use substances can play a key role in the treatment and care of their infants. However, challenges exist to engaging these mothers in the care of their infant. The purpose of this study was to identify factors associated with maternal engagement in infant care when mothers are experiencing substance use disorders.

Materials and Methods

A systematic search was conducted using the databases of CINAHL, APA PsycINFO, and PubMed along with a manual search of Google Scholar between the years of 2012 and 2022. Studies were included if they were (1) original qualitative research; (2) published in English; (3) peer reviewed; (4) from the perspective of mothers who use substances or nurses; (5) included descriptions of interactions between mothers who use substances and their infants during postpartum care, and/or in the nursery or neonatal intensive care unit; and (6) conducted in the United States. The studies were assessed for quality and validity using 10 criteria from the Joanne Briggs Institute critical appraisal checklist for qualitative research.

Results

Findings from 22 qualitative studies were synthesized using a thematic synthesis approach and revealed 3 overarching themes that included 7 descriptive subthemes that identified factors to maternal engagement. The seven descriptive subthemes included: (1) Attitudes Toward Mothers Who Use Substances; (2) Knowledge on Addiction; (3) Complicated Backgrounds; (4) Emotional Experiences; (5) Managing Infant Symptoms; (6) Model of Postpartum Care; and (7) Hospital Routines.

Discussion

Participants described stigma from nurses, complex backgrounds of mothers who use substances, and postpartum models that influenced mothers' engagement in infants' care. The findings suggest several clinical implications for nurses. Nurses should manage their biases and approach mothers who use substances in a respectful manner, increase their knowledge of issues and care related to addiction in the perinatal period, and promote family-centered approaches to care.

Conclusion

The findings of 22 qualitative studies described factors associated with maternal engagement in mothers who use substances that were integrated using a thematic synthesis method. Mothers who use substances have complex backgrounds and experience stigma which can negatively impact their engagement with their infants.

Supporting perinatal individuals with opioid use disorder and their newborns experiencing neonatal abstinence syndrome: impressions from patients and healthcare providers

Background: Facilitating maternal-newborn involvement and care is critical for improving outcomes for perinatal individuals receiving opioid agonist therapy (OAT) and newborns experiencing Neonatal Abstinence Syndrome (NAS). Comprehensive education strategies are needed to prepare pregnant individuals receiving OAT for navigating the perinatal period.Objectives: Identify facilitators to successful care of perinatal individuals receiving OAT and newborns experiencing NAS via interviews with perinatal individuals and healthcare providers. The goal of identifying this information is to inform a future educational tool development.Methods: Ten perinatal individuals receiving OAT and ten healthcare providers participated in interviews conducted via phone or video conference using semi-structured, open-ended questions. Data were analyzed separately for the two groups and later merged across samples using a qualitative descriptive content analysis approach to identify themes.Results: Under the overarching theme of empowerment to improve outcomes for perinatal women, four themes arose from perinatal and provider interviews: 1) Preparation for Child Protective Services (CPS) involvement, 2) Healthcare providers shape experience through stigma and support 3) Caring for newborns with NAS, and 4) Managing health and resources during postpartum.Conclusion: Perinatal participants emphasized the importance of self-advocacy while navigating healthcare and social systems. Providers highlighted the importance of communicating expectations to empower patients. Education is needed for pregnant individuals receiving OAT on what to expect during pregnancy and postpartum, as well as for providers to help them optimally support their perinatal patients receiving OAT.

Mothers overcoming remorse to care for self and baby: An emerging concept

Objectives

Method

Result

Conclusion

Elucidating the context for implementing nonpharmacologic care for neonatal opioid withdrawal syndrome: a qualitative study of perinatal nurses

BACKGROUND

Up to 95% of neonates exposed to opioids in utero experience neonatal opioid withdrawal syndrome at birth. Nonpharmacologic approaches (e.g., breastfeeding; rooming-in; skin-to-skin care) are evidence-based and should be implemented. These approaches, especially breastfeeding, rely on engagement of the neonates' mothers to help deliver them. However, little is known about the structural and social dynamic context barriers and facilitators to implementing maternal-delivered nonpharmacologic care.

METHODS

Using a qualitative descriptive design, perinatal nurses from a Midwest United States hospital family birthing center, neonatal intensive care unit, and inpatient pediatric unit were interviewed. These units were involved in caring for mothers and neonates affected by opioid use. Telephone interviews followed a semi-structured interview guide developed for this study, were audio-recorded, and lasted about 30-60 min. Interviews were transcribed verbatim and independently analyzed by five investigators using the constant comparative method. Themes were discussed until reaching consensus and subsequently mapped to a conceptual model adapted for this study.

RESULTS

Twenty-one nurses participated in this study (family birth center, n = 9; neonatal intensive care, n = 6; pediatrics, n = 6). Analysis resulted in four major themes: 1) Lack of education and resources provided to staff and mothers; 2) Importance of interdisciplinary and intradisciplinary care coordination; 3) Flexibility in nurse staffing models for neonatal opioid withdrawal syndrome; and 4) Unit architecture and layout affects maternal involvement. Minor themes supported each of the four major themes. All themes mapped to the conceptual model.

CONCLUSIONS

This study provides a more comprehensive understanding of the barriers and facilitators affecting implementation of maternal involvement in nonpharmacologic care of newborns with neonatal opioid withdrawal syndrome. Future efforts implementing nonpharmacologic approaches must consider the context factors affecting implementation, including structural and social factors within the units, hospital, and broader community.

Engaging Mothers to Implement Nonpharmacological Care for Infants With Neonatal Abstinence Syndrome: Perceptions of Perinatal and Pediatric Nurses

BACKGROUND

Little is known about nurse perceptions regarding engagement of mothers in implementation of nonpharmacological care for opioid-exposed infants.

PURPOSE

This study was designed to describe perinatal and pediatric nurse perceptions of (1) engaging mothers in the care of opioid-exposed infants and (2) facilitators and barriers to maternal engagement.

METHODS

This study used a qualitative descriptive design to interview perinatal and pediatric nurses in one Midwest United States hospital. Interviews were conducted via telephone using a semistructured interview guide and audio recorded. Audio files were transcribed verbatim and thematically analyzed using the constant comparative method.

RESULTS

Twenty-one nurses participated in the study, representing a family birth center, neonatal intensive care unit, and pediatric unit. Five major themes resulted from analysis: (1) vulnerability and bias; (2) mother-infant care: tasks versus model of care; (3) maternal factors affecting engagement and implementation; (4) nurse factors affecting engagement and implementation; and (5) recommendations and examples of nursing approaches to barriers. Minor themes supported each of the major themes.

IMPLICATIONS FOR PRACTICE

Nurses must engage mothers with substance use histories with empathy and nonjudgment, identify and promote maternal agency to care for their infants, and engage and activate mothers to deliver nonpharmacological care during the hospital stay and following discharge.

IMPLICATIONS FOR RESEARCH

Findings suggest interventions are needed to improve (1) nursing education regarding maternal substance use and recovery, (2) empathy for substance-using mothers and mothers in treatment, and (3) identification and support of maternal agency to provide nonpharmacological care to withdrawing infants.

Hospital Care of Opioid-Exposed Newborns: Clinical and Psychosocial Challenges

In the past two decades, the incidence of neonatal abstinence syndrome (NAS) has risen fivefold, mirroring the rise of opioid use disorder (OUD) among pregnant women. The resulting increases in length of stay and neonatal intensive care utilization are associated with higher hospital costs, particularly among Medicaid-financed deliveries. Pregnant women with OUD require comprehensive medical and psychosocial evaluation and management; this combined with medication-assisted treatment is critical to optimize maternal and newborn outcomes. Multidisciplinary collaboration and standardized approaches to screening for intrauterine opioid exposure, evaluation and treatment of NAS, and discharge planning are important for clinical outcomes and may improve maternal experience of care.

Knowledge of and Perceived Competence in Trauma-Informed Care and Attitudes of NICU Nurses Toward Mothers of Newborns With Neonatal Abstinence Syndrome

OBJECTIVE

To explore how knowledge of and perceived competence in trauma-informed care inform the attitudes of NICU nurses toward mothers of newborns with neonatal abstinence syndrome (NAS).

DESIGN

A cross-sectional survey study.

SETTING

A southern U.S. metropolitan children's hospital with 145 NICU beds.

PARTICIPANTS

Convenience sample of 150 NICU nurses.

METHODS

Participants completed an online survey questionnaire adapted from the Attitudes About Drug Abuse in Pregnancy questionnaire and the Trauma-Informed Pediatric Care survey. Participants also responded to one open-ended question about their experiences in working with mothers of newborns with NAS. We used descriptive and inferential statistics and content analysis to analyze the survey data.

RESULTS

Participants demonstrated low to moderate knowledge about and perceived competence in trauma-informed care and showed more judgmental attitudes toward mothers of newborns with NAS. Level of knowledge about mothers with substance use disorder and perceived competence in trauma-informed care were associated with participants' attitudes toward mothers of newborns with NAS. Emergent themes from qualitative data included the following: Mother-Newborn Dyads Shape Nurses' Judgmental Attitudes, Caring for Mothers of Newborns With NAS Is a Challenging Experience, and Need to Refine Care for Mothers Through Intra- and Interdisciplinary Collaboration.

CONCLUSION

NICU nurses need further education about mothers of newborns with NAS. Improved knowledge about these women and adaptation of the principles of trauma-informed care may influence NICU nurses' judgmental attitudes toward mothers of newborns with NAS.