Radiographic outcomes over time after endoscopic anterior scoliosis correction: a prospective series of 106 patients

Analysis of the Change Patterns of Sagittal Alignment Values After Selective Thoracic Fusion in Lenke 1 Adolescent Idiopathic Scoliosis According to Preoperative Thoracic Kyphosis Status

STUDY DESIGN

This was a retrospective study.

OBJECTIVE

The objective of this study was to demonstrate the different change patterns in reciprocal sagittal alignment values after selective thoracic fusion (STF) in Lenke type 1 adolescent idiopathic scoliosis (AIS) according to preoperative thoracic kyphosis (TK).

SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA

Several studies have found significant increase in TK after STF, while other studies have reported decrease in TK postoperatively. Similar inconclusive results on changes in lumbar lordosis (LL) have been reported, showing LL increase, decrease, or no change.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Ninety-three patients presenting with Lenke type 1 AIS treated by posterior STF with a minimum follow-up of 2 years were included in this study. Using whole spine radiographs, sagittal parameters including TK, LL, and upper lumbar lordosis (ULL) were compared preoperatively and at the last follow-up between a hypokyphosis group (preoperative TK<20 degrees) and a normokyphosis group (preoperative TK≥20 degrees). Health-related quality of life (HRQOL) was assessed using scoliosis research society health-related quality of life-30 (SRS-30) and short from health survey-36 questionnaire at the last visit.

RESULTS

The mean follow-up duration was 74.9 months. In the hypokyphosis group (35 patients), TK, LL, and ULL statistically significantly increased after surgery by mean 7.7, 5.1, and 3.7 degrees (P<0.001, <0.001, and 0.001). In the normokyphosis group (58 patients), these parameters did not show significant changes after STF. Final TK was significantly lower in hypokyphosis group than that in the normokyphosis group (21.2 vs. 30.9 degrees, P<0.001) while final LL did not differ between 2 groups (52.4 vs. 54.6 degrees, P=0.194). HRQOL did not differ significantly between the 2 groups.

CONCLUSIONS

After STF in Lenke 1 AIS, TK, and LL statistically significantly increased through an increase in the mean ULL in the hypokyphosis group while those mean values did not change in the normokyphosis group. Despite the final mean value of the TK in the hypokyphosis group increasing by 7.7 degrees, it was statistically significantly lower than the final mean TK value in the normokyphosis group which did not increase after STF surgery by posterior approach. However, HRQOL showed no significant difference between the 2 groups.

Is vertebral rotation correction maintained after thoracoscopic anterior scoliosis surgery? A low-dose computed tomography study

Background

Axial vertebral rotation is a key characteristic of adolescent idiopathic scoliosis (AIS), and its reduction is one of the goals of corrective surgery. Recurrence of deformity after surgical correction may relate to rotation changes that occur in the anterior vertebral column after surgery, but whether any change occurs within the fused segment or in adjacent unfused levels following thoracoscopic anterior spinal fusion (TASF) is unknown. An analysis of measurements from an existing postoperative CT dataset was performed to investigate the occurrence of inter- and intra-vertebral rotation changes after TASF within and adjacent to the fused spinal segment and look for any relationships with the Cobb angle and rib hump in the two years after surgery.

Methods

39 Lenke Type 1 main thoracic patients underwent TASF for progressive AIS and low dose computed tomography scanning of the instrumented levels of the spine at 6 and 24 months after surgery. Vertebral rotation was measured at the superior and inferior endplates on true axial images for all vertebral levels in the fused segment plus one adjacent level cranially and caudally. Intra-observer variability for rotation measurements was assessed using 95% limits of agreement to detect significant changes in inter/intra-vertebral rotation.

Results

Significant local changes in inter- and intra-vertebral rotation were found to have occurred between 6 and 24 months after anterior surgical fusion within the fused spinal segment, albeit with no consistent pattern of location or direction within the instrumented fusion construct. No significant en-bloc movement of the entire fused spinal segment relative to the adjacent un-instrumented cranial and caudal intervertebral levels was found. No clear correlation was found between any vertebral rotation changes and Cobb angle or rib hump measures.

Conclusions

Localised inter- and intra-vertebral rotation occurs between 6 and 24 months after TASF, both within the instrumented spinal segments and in the adjacent un-instrumented levels of the adolescent spine. The lack of measurable en-bloc movement of the fused segment relative to the adjacent un-instrumented levels suggests that overall stability of the instrumented construct is achieved, however the vertebrae within the fusion mass continue to adapt and remodel, resulting in ongoing local anatomical and biomechanical changes in the adolescent spine.

Evaluating the Change in Axial Vertebral Rotation Following Thoracoscopic Anterior Scoliosis Surgery Using Low-Dose Computed Tomography

BACKGROUND CONTEXT

In recent years, there has been increasing appreciation of the need to treat scoliosis as a three-dimensional deformity.

PURPOSE

Assessment of surgical strategies and outcomes should consider not only the coronal plane correction but also derotation of the transverse plane deformity that can affect trunk appearance.

STUDY DESIGN

This study included a cohort of 29 female adolescent idiopathic scoliosis patients who received thoracoscopic single rod anterior fusion (TASF) surgery. This study used pre- and postoperative low-dose computed tomographic (CT) scans to accurately measure apical axial vertebral rotation (AVR).

METHODS

The pre- and postoperative values for clinically measured coronal Cobb correction and rib hump correction as well as AVR were compared to determine whether these values improved postoperatively. There are no conflicts of interest to report for authors of this investigation.

RESULTS

As expected, statistically significant reductions in coronal Cobb angle (mean preoperative Cobb 51°, reducing to 24° at the two-year follow-up) and rib hump (mean preoperative rib hump 15°, reducing to 7° at two-year follow-up) were achieved. The mean reduction in apical AVR measured using CT was only 3° (mean preoperative AVR 16°, reducing to 13° at two-year follow-up), which was statistically but not clinically significant. Significant correlations were found between Cobb angle and rib hump, between Cobb angle and AVR, and between AVR and rib hump, suggesting that patients with greater coronal Cobb correction also achieve better derotation with this surgical procedure.

CONCLUSIONS

The historical low-dose CT data set permitted detailed three-dimensional assessment of the deformity correction that is achieved using thoracoscopic anterior spinal fusion for progressive adolescent idiopathic scoliosis.

Partial Intervertebral Fusion Secures Successful Outcomes After Thoracoscopic Anterior Scoliosis Correction: A Low-Dose Computed Tomography Study

STUDY DESIGN

Retrospective review of prospectively collected data.

OBJECTIVES

To analyze intervertebral (IV) fusion after thoracoscopic anterior spinal fusion (TASF) and explore the relationship between fusion scores and key clinical variables.

SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND INFORMATION

TASF provides comparable correction with some advantages over posterior approaches but reported mechanical complications, and their relationship to non-union and graft material is unclear. Similarly, the optimal combination of graft type and implant stiffness for effecting successful radiologic union remains undetermined.

METHODS

A subset of patients from a large single-center series who had TASF for progressive scoliosis underwent low-dose computed tomographic scans 2 years after surgery. The IV fusion mass in the disc space was assessed using the 4-point Sucato scale, where 1 indicates <50% and 4 indicates 100% bony fusion of the disc space. The effects of rod diameter, rod material, graft type, fusion level, and mechanical complications on fusion scores were assessed.

RESULTS

Forty-three patients with right thoracic major curves (mean age 14.9 years) participated in the study. Mean fusion scores for patient subgroups ranged from 1.0 (IV levels with rod fractures) to 2.2 (4.5-mm rod with allograft), with scores tending to decrease with increasing rod size and stiffness. Graft type (autograft vs. allograft) did not affect fusion scores. Fusion scores were highest in the middle levels of the rod construct (mean 2.52), dropping off by 20% to 30% toward the upper and lower extremities of the rod. IV levels where a rod fractured had lower overall mean fusion scores compared to levels without a fracture. Mean total Scoliosis Research Society (SRS) questionnaire scores were 98.9 from a possible total of 120, indicating a good level of patient satisfaction.

CONCLUSIONS

Results suggest that 100% radiologic fusion of the entire disc space is not necessary for successful clinical outcomes following thoracoscopic anterior selective thoracic fusion.

Secondary curve behavior in Lenke type 1C adolescent idiopathic scoliosis after thoracoscopic selective anterior thoracic fusion

STUDY DESIGN

Analysis of a case series of 24 patients with Lenke 1C adolescent idiopathic scoliosis (AIS) receiving selective thoracoscopic anterior scoliosis correction.

OBJECTIVE

To report the behavior of the compensatory lumbar curve in a group of patients with Lenke IC AIS after thoracoscopic anterior scoliosis correction and to compare the results of this study with previously published data.

SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA

Several prior studies have reported spontaneous lumbar curve correction for both anterior and posterior selective fusions in patients with Lenke 1C/King-Moe 2; however, to our knowledge no previous studies have reported outcomes of thoracoscopic anterior correction for this curve type.

METHODS

All patients with AIS with a curve classification of Lenke 1C and a minimum of 24-month follow-up were obtained from a consecutive series of 190 patients with AIS who underwent thoracoscopic anterior instrumented fusion. Cobb angles of the major curve, instrumented levels, compensatory lumbar curve, and T5-T12 kyphosis were recorded, as well as coronal spinal balance, T1 tilt angle, and shoulder balance. All radiographical parameters were measured before surgery and at 2, 6, 12, and 24 months after surgery.

RESULTS

Twenty-four female patients with right thoracic curves had a mean thoracic Cobb angle of 53.0° before surgery, decreasing to 24.9° 2 years after surgery. The mean lumbar compensatory Cobb angle was 43.5° before surgery, spontaneously correcting to 25.4° 2 years after surgery, indicating balance between the thoracic and lumbar scoliotic curves. The lumbar correction achieved (41.8%) compares favorably to previous studies.

CONCLUSION

Selective thoracoscopic anterior fusion allows spontaneous lumbar curve correction and achieves coronal balance of main thoracic and compensatory lumbar curves, good cosmesis, and patient satisfaction. Correction and balance are maintained 24 months after surgery.

CT and radiographic analysis of sagittal profile changes following thoracoscopic anterior scoliosis surgery

Background

Previous studies report an increase in thoracic kyphosis after anterior approaches and a flattening of sagittal contours following posterior approaches. Difficulties with measuring sagittal parameters on radiographs are avoided with reformatted sagittal CT reconstructions due to the superior endplate clarity afforded by this imaging modality.

Methods

A prospective study of 30 Lenke 1 adolescent idiopathic scoliosis (AIS) patients receiving selective thoracoscopic anterior spinal fusion (TASF) was performed. Participants had ethically approved low dose CT scans at minimum 24 months after surgery in addition to their standard care following surgery. The change in sagittal contours on supine CT was compared to standing radiographic measurements of the same patients and with previous studies. Inter-observer variability was assessed as well as whether hypokyphotic and normokyphotic patient groups responded differently to the thoracoscopic anterior approach.

Results

Mean T5-12 kyphosis Cobb angle increased by 11.8 degrees and lumbar lordosis increased by 5.9 degrees on standing radiographs two years after surgery. By comparison, CT measurements of kyphosis and lordosis increased by 12.3 degrees and 7.0 degrees respectively. 95% confidence intervals for inter-observer variability of sagittal contour measurements on supine CT ranged between 5-8 degrees. TASF had a slightly greater corrective effect on patients who were hypokyphotic before surgery compared with those who were normokyphotic.

Conclusions

Restoration of sagittal profile is an important goal of scoliosis surgery, but reliable measurement with radiographs suffers from poor endplate clarity. TASF significantly improves thoracic kyphosis and lumbar lordosis while preserving proximal and distal junctional alignment in thoracic AIS patients. Supine CT allows greater endplate clarity for sagittal Cobb measurements and linear relationships were found between supine CT and standing radiographic measurements. In this study, improvements in sagittal kyphosis and lordosis following surgery were in agreement with prior anterior surgery studies, and add to the current evidence suggesting that anterior correction is more capable than posterior approaches of addressing the sagittal component of both the instrumented and adjacent non instrumented segments following surgical correction of progressive Lenke 1 idiopathic scoliosis.

The relationship between deformity correction and clinical outcomes after thoracoscopic scoliosis surgery: a prospective series of one hundred patients

STUDY DESIGN

Prospective clinical case series of 100 patients receiving thoracoscopic anterior scoliosis correction.

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the relationship between clinical outcomes of thoracoscopic anterior scoliosis surgery and deformity correction, using the Scoliosis Research Society (SRS) outcomes instrument.

SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA

Surgical treatment of scoliosis is quantitatively assessed in the clinic, using radiographic measures of deformity correction and the rib hump, but it is important to understand the extent to which these quantitative measures correlate with self-reported improvements in patients' quality of life after surgery.

METHODS

A series of 100 consecutive adolescent idiopathic scoliosis patients received a single anterior rod via a thoracoscopic approach at the Mater Children's Hospital, Brisbane, Australia. Patients completed SRS outcomes questionnaires before surgery and at 24 months after surgery. Multiple regression and t tests were used to investigate the relationship between SRS scores and deformity correction achieved (radiographic measurements and rib hump) after surgery.

RESULTS

There were 94 females and 6 males with a mean age of 16.1 years. The mean Cobb angle improved from 52° before surgery to 25° after surgery (52%) and the mean rib hump improved from 16° to 8° (51%). The mean total SRS score for the cohort was 99.4/120. None of the deformity-related parameters in the multiple-regression were significant. However, patients with the lowest postoperative major Cobb angles reported significantly higher SRS scores than those with the highest postoperative Cobb angles, but there was no difference on the basis of rib hump correction. There were no significant differences between patients with either rod fractures or screw-related complications compared to those without complications.

CONCLUSION

Patients undergoing thoracoscopic anterior scoliosis correction reported good SRS scores which are comparable with those in previous studies. Postoperative major Cobb angle is a significant predictor of patient satisfaction when comparing subgroups of patients with the highest and lowest postoperative Cobb angles.

A biomechanical study of top screw pullout in anterior scoliosis correction constructs

STUDY DESIGN.: Biomechanical testing of vertebral body screw pullout resistance with relevance to top screw pullout in thoracoscopic anterior scoliosis constructs.

OBJECTIVE

To analyze the effect of screw positioning and angulation on pullout resistance of vertebral body screws, where the pullout takes place along a curved path as occurs in anterior scoliosis constructs.

SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA

Top screw pullout is a significant clinical problem in thoracoscopic anterior scoliosis surgery, with rates of up to18% reported in the literature.

METHODS

A custom-designed biomechanical test rig was used to perform pullout tests of Medtronic anterior vertebral screws where the pullout occurred along an arc of known radius. Using synthetic bone blocks, a range of pullout radiuses and screw angulations were tested, in order to determine an "optimal" configuration. The optimal configuration was then compared with standard screw positioning using a series of tests on ovine vertebrae (n=29).

RESULTS

Screw angulation has a small but significant effect on pullout resistance, with maximum strength being achieved at 10-degree cephalad angulation. Combining 10-degree cephalad angulation with maximal spacing between the top 2 screws (maximum pullout radius) increased the pullout resistance by 88% compared with "standard" screw positioning (screws inserted perpendicular to rod at midbody height).

CONCLUSION

The positioning of the top screw in anterior scoliosis constructs can significantly alter its pullout resistance.