Patient Age and Hip Morphology Alter Joint Mechanics in Computational Models of Patients With Hip Dysplasia

Providing a computationally derived, mechanically optimised target correction during preoperative planning can improve joint contact mechanics of hip dysplasia treated with periacetabular osteotomy

AIM

Preoperative identification of acetabular corrections that optimally improve joint stability and reduce elevated contact stresses could further reduce osteoarthritis progression in patients with hip dysplasia who are treated with periacetabular osteotomy (PAO). The purpose of this study was to investigate how providing patient-specific, mechanically optimal acetabular reorientations to the surgeon during preoperative planning affected the surgically achieved correction.

METHODS

Preoperative CT scans were used to create patient-specific hip models for 6 patients scheduled for PAO. A simulated acetabular fragment was extracted from the preoperative pelvis model and computationally rotated to simulate candidate acetabular reorientations. For each candidate, discrete element analysis was used to compute contact stresses during walking, which were summed over the gait cycle and scaled by patient age to obtain chronic contact stress-time exposure. The ideal patient-specific reorientation was identified using a cost function that balances minimising chronic stress exposures and achieving surgically acceptable acetabular coverage angles. The optimal reorientation angles and associated contact mechanics were provided to the surgeon preoperatively. After PAO was performed, a model of the surgically achieved correction was created from a postoperative CT scan. Radiographic coverage and contact mechanics were compared between preoperative, optimal, and surgically achieved orientations.

RESULTS

While surgically achieved reorientations were not significantly different from optimal reorientations in radiographically measured lateral (p = 0.094) or anterior (p = 0.063) coverage, surgically achieved reorientations had significantly (p = 0.031) reduced total contact area compared to optimal reorientations. The difference in lateral coverage and peak chronic exposure between surgically achieved and optimal reorientations decreased with increasing surgeon experience using the models (R² = 0.758, R2 = 0.630, respectively).

CONCLUSIONS

Providing hip surgeons with a patient-specific, computationally optimal reorientation during preoperative planning may improve contact mechanics after PAO, which may help reduce osteoarthritis progression in patients with hip dysplasia.

Are Abnormal Muscle Biomechanics and Patient-reported Outcomes Associated in Patients With Hip Dysplasia?

BACKGROUND

Developmental dysplasia of the hip (DDH) is a major risk factor for the early development of hip osteoarthritis. Recent studies have demonstrated how DDH alters hip muscle moment arms and elevates muscle-induced biomechanical variables such as joint reaction forces and acetabular edge loads. Understanding the link between abnormal biomechanics and patient-reported outcome measures (PROMs) is important for evidence-based clinical interventions that improve patient symptoms and functional outcomes. To our knowledge, there are no reports of the relationships between muscle-induced biomechanics and PROMs.

QUESTIONS/PURPOSES

(1) Are there associations between PROMs and muscle-induced hip biomechanics during gait for patients with DDH and controls? (2) Are there associations among PROMs and separately among biomechanical variables?

METHODS

Participants in this prospective cross-sectional comparative study included 20 female patients with DDH who had no prior surgery or osteoarthritis and 15 female individuals with no evidence of hip pathology (controls) (age: median 23 years [range 16 to 39 years]; BMI: median 22 kg/m 2 [range 17 to 27 kg/m 2 ]). Muscle-induced biomechanical variables for this cohort were reported and had been calculated from patient-specific musculoskeletal models, motion data, and MRI. Biomechanical variables included joint reaction forces, acetabular edge loads, hip center lateralization, and gluteus medius muscle moment arm lengths. PROMs included the Hip Disability and Osteoarthritis Outcome Score (HOOS), the WOMAC, International Hip Outcome Tool-12, National Institutes of Health Patient-Reported Outcome Measure Information System (PROMIS) Pain Interference and Physical Function subscales, and University of California Los Angeles activity scale. Associations between PROMs and biomechanical variables were tested using Spearman rank-order correlations and corrected for multiple comparisons using the Benjamini-Yekutieli method. For this study, associations between variables were considered to exist when correlations were statistically significant (p < 0.05) and were either strong (ρ ≥ 0.60) or moderate (ρ = 0.40 to 0.59).

RESULTS

Acetabular edge load impulses (the cumulative acetabular edge load across the gait cycle), medially directed joint reaction forces, and hip center lateralization most commonly demonstrated moderate or strong associations with PROMs. The strongest associations were a negative correlation between acetabular edge load impulse on the superior acetabulum and the HOOS function in daily living subscale (ρ = -0.63; p = 0.001), followed by a negative correlation between hip center lateralization and the HOOS pain subscale (ρ = -0.6; p = 0.003), and a positive correlation between hip center lateralization and the PROMIS pain subscale (ρ = 0.62; p = 0.002). The University of California Los Angeles activity scale was the only PROM that did not demonstrate associations with any biomechanical variable. All PROMs, aside from the University of California Los Angeles activity scale, were associated with one another. Although most of the biomechanical variables were associated with one another, these relationships were not as consistent as those among PROMs.

CONCLUSION

The associations with PROMs detected in the current study suggest that muscle-induced biomechanics may have wide-reaching effects not only on loads within the hip, but also on patients' perceptions of their health and function. As the treatment of DDH evolves, patient-specific joint preservation strategies may benefit from targeting the underlying causes of biomechanical outcomes associated with PROMs.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level III, prognostic study.

Radiographically successful periacetabular osteotomy does not achieve optimal contact mechanics in dysplastic hips

BACKGROUND

Optimal correction of hip dysplasia via periacetabular osteotomy may reduce osteoarthritis development by reducing damaging contact stress. The objective of this study was to computationally determine if patient-specific acetabular corrections that optimize contact mechanics can improve upon contact mechanics resulting from clinically successful, surgically achieved corrections.

METHODS

Preoperative and postoperative hip models were retrospectively created from CT scans of 20 dysplasia patients treated with periacetabular osteotomy. A digitally extracted acetabular fragment was computationally rotated in 2-degree increments around anteroposterior and oblique axes to simulate candidate acetabular reorientations. From discrete element analysis of each patient's set of candidate reorientation models, a mechanically optimal reorientation that minimized chronic contact stress exposure and a clinically optimal reorientation that balanced improving mechanics with surgically acceptable acetabular coverage angles was selected. Radiographic coverage, contact area, peak/mean contact stress, and peak/mean chronic exposure were compared between mechanically optimal, clinically optimal, and surgically achieved orientations.

FINDINGS

Compared to actual surgical corrections, computationally derived mechanically/clinically optimal reorientations had a median[IQR] 13[4-16]/8[3-12] degrees and 16[6-26]/10[3-16] degrees more lateral and anterior coverage, respectively. Mechanically/clinically optimal reorientations had 212[143-353]/217[111-280] mm2 more contact area and 8.2[5.8-11.1]/6.4[4.5-9.3] MPa lower peak contact stresses than surgical corrections. Chronic metrics demonstrated similar findings (p ≤ 0.003 for all comparisons).

INTERPRETATION

Computationally selected orientations achieved a greater mechanical improvement than surgically achieved corrections; however, many predicted corrections would be considered acetabular over-coverage. Identifying patient-specific corrections that balance optimizing mechanics with clinical constraints will be necessary to reduce the risk of osteoarthritis progression after periacetabular osteotomy.

Joint contact stress improves in dysplastic hips after periacetabular osteotomy but remains higher than in normal hips

AIM

The purpose of this study was to use computational modeling to determine if surgical correction of hip dysplasia restores hip contact mechanics to those of asymptomatic, radiographically normal hips.

METHODS

Discrete element analysis (DEA) was used to compute joint contact stresses during the stance phase of normal walking gait for 10 individuals with radiographically normal, asymptomatic hips and 10 age- and weight-matched patients with acetabular dysplasia who underwent periacetabular osteotomy (PAO).

RESULTS

Mean and peak contact stresses were higher (p < 0.001 and p = 0.036, respectively) in the dysplastic hips than in the matched normal hips. PAO normalised standard radiographic measurements and medialised the location of computed contact stress within the joint. Mean contact stress computed in dysplastic hips throughout the stance phase of gait (median 5.5 MPa, [IQR 3.9-6.1 MPa]) did not significantly decrease after PAO (3.7 MPa, [IQR 3.2-4.8]; p = 0.109) and remained significantly (p < 0.001) elevated compared to radiographically normal hips (2.4 MPa, [IQR 2.2-2.8 MPa]). Peak contact stress demonstrated a similar trend. Joint contact area during the stance phase of gait in the dysplastic hips increased significantly (p = 0.036) after PAO from 395 mm2 (IQR 378-496 mm2) to 595 mm2 (IQR 474-660 mm2), but remained significantly smaller (p = 0.001) than that for radiographically normal hips (median 1120 mm2, IQR 853-1444 mm2).

CONCLUSIONS

While contact mechanics in dysplastic hips more closely resembled those of normal hips after PAO, the elevated contact stresses and smaller contact areas remaining after PAO indicate ongoing mechanical abnormalities should be expected even after radiographically successful surgical correction.

Effect of periacetabular osteotomy on the distribution pattern of subchondral bone mineral density in patients with hip dysplasia

Despite the availability of long-term follow-up data, the effect of pelvic osteotomy on the natural history of osteoarthritis is not yet fully understood, partly because there is untapped potential for radiographs to better describe osteoarthritis. Therefore, this study aimed to assess the distribution of subchondral bone mineral density (BMD) across the acetabulum in patients with hip dysplasia immediately (2 weeks) and 1 year after undergoing periacetabular osteotomy (PAO). To that end, we reviewed 40 hips from 33 patients with developmental dysplasia of the hip who underwent PAO between January 2016 and July 2019 at our institution. We measured subchondral BMD through the articular surface of the acetabulum using computed tomography osteoabsorptiometry, dividing the distribution map into nine segments. We then compared the subchondral BMD between 2 weeks and 1 year after PAO in each area. At 2 weeks after PAO, the high-density area tended to be localized particularly in the lateral part of the acetabulum, whereas 1 year after PAO, the high-density area moved to the central and lateral parts. The percentage ratios of the subchondral BMD for the central-posterior, lateral-central, and lateral-posterior areas relative to the central-central area were significantly decreased at 1 year after PAO, as compared to those at 2 weeks after PAO. These findings suggest that loading was altered by PAO to be more similar to physiological loading. A long follow-up observational study is warranted to confirm the association between early changes in subchondral BMD by PAO and joint degeneration.

Chronically elevated contact stress exposure correlates with intra-articular cartilage degeneration in patients with concurrent acetabular dysplasia and femoroacetabular impingement

Hip dysplasia is known to lead to premature osteoarthritis. Computational models of joint mechanics have documented elevated contact stresses in dysplastic hips, but elevated stress has not been directly associated with regional cartilage degeneration. The purpose of this study was to determine if a relationship exists between elevated contact stress and intra-articular cartilage damage in patients with symptomatic dysplasia and femoroacetabular impingement. Discrete element analysis was used to compute hip contact stresses during the stance phase of walking gait for 15 patients diagnosed with acetabular dysplasia and femoral head-neck offset deformity. Contact stresses were summed over the duration of the walking gait cycle and then scaled by patient age to obtain a measure of chronic cartilage contact stress exposure. Linear regression analysis was used to evaluate the relationship between contact stress exposure and cartilage damage in each of six acetabular subregions that had been evaluated arthroscopically for cartilage damage at the time of surgical intervention. A significant correlation (R2  = 0.423, p < 0.001) was identified between chondromalacia grade and chronic stress-time exposure above both a 1 MPa damage threshold and a 2 MPa-years accumulated damage threshold. Furthermore, an over-exposure threshold of 15% regional contact area exceeding the 1 and 2 MPa-years threshold values resulted in correct identification of cartilage damage in 83.3% (55/66) of the acetabular subregions loaded during gait. These results suggest corrective surgery to alleviate impingement and reduce chronic contact stress exposures below these damage-inducing thresholds could mitigate further cartilage damage in patients with hip dysplasia.

Effect of modeling femoral version and head-neck offset correction on computed contact mechanics in dysplastic hips treated with periacetabular osteotomy

While correction of dysplastic acetabular deformity has been a focus of both clinical treatment and research, concurrent femoral deformities have only more recently received serious attention. The purpose of this study was to determine how including abnormalities in femoral head-neck offset and femoral version alter computationally derived contact stresses in patients with combined dysplasia and femoroacetabular impingement (FAI). Hip models with patient-specific bony anatomy were created from preoperative and postoperative CT scans of 20 hips treated with periacetabular osteotomy and femoral osteochondroplasty. To simulate performing only a PAO, a third model was created combining each patient's postoperative pelvis and preoperative femur geometry. These three models were initialized with the femur in two starting orientations: (1) standardized template orientation, and (2) using patient-specific anatomic landmarks. Hip contact stresses were computed in all 6 model sets during an average dysplastic gait cycle, an average FAI gait cycle, and an average stand-to-sit activity using discrete element analysis. No significant differences in peak contact stress (p = 0.190 to 1), mean contact stress (p = 0.273 to 1), or mean contact area (p = 0.050 to 1) were identified during any loading activity based on femoral alignment technique or inclusion of femoral osteochondroplasty. These findings suggest that presence of abnormal femoral version and/or head-neck offset deformities are not themselves predominant factors in intra-articular contact mechanics during gait and stand-to-sit activities. Inclusion of modified movement patterns caused by these femoral deformities may be necessary for models to adequately capture the mechanical effects of these clinically recognized risk factors for negative outcomes.

Challenges in Kinetic-Kinematic Driven Musculoskeletal Subject-Specific Infant Modeling

Musculoskeletal computational models provide a non-invasive approach to investigate human movement biomechanics. These models could be particularly useful for pediatric applications where in vivo and in vitro biomechanical parameters are difficult or impossible to examine using physical experiments alone. The objective was to develop a novel musculoskeletal subject-specific infant model to investigate hip joint biomechanics during cyclic leg movements. Experimental motion-capture marker data of a supine-lying 2-month-old infant were placed on a generic GAIT 2392 OpenSim model. After scaling the model using body segment anthropometric measurements and joint center locations, inverse kinematics and dynamics were used to estimate hip ranges of motion and moments. For the left hip, a maximum moment of 0.975 Nm and a minimum joint moment of 0.031 Nm were estimated at 34.6° and 65.5° of flexion, respectively. For the right hip, a maximum moment of 0.906 Nm and a minimum joint moment of 0.265 Nm were estimated at 23.4° and 66.5° of flexion, respectively. Results showed agreement with reported values from the literature. Further model refinements and validations are needed to develop and establish a normative infant dataset, which will be particularly important when investigating the movement of infants with pathologies such as developmental dysplasia of the hip. This research represents the first step in the longitudinal development of a model that will critically contribute to our understanding of infant growth and development during the first year of life.

Analysis of Factors Affecting Early Functional Recovery of Bernese Periacetabular Osteotomy

OBJECTIVES

To explore factors affecting the efficacy of Bernese periacetabular osteotomy for the treatment of hip dysplasia.

METHODS

A retrospective study was conducted on 44 patients with hip dysplasia who underwent Bernese periacetabular osteotomy with a modified Smith-Peterson approach between January 2017 and November 2019. Among them, 40 were women and four were men. The average age was 31.2 ± 9.4. Preoperative and postoperative imaging parameters were measured. The acetabular top tilt angle, lateral central edge angle, acetabular abduction angle, femoral head extrusion index, sphericity index of femoral head, Shenton line, Tonnis grade of osteoarthritis, joint congruency, p/a ratio, acetabular anteversion angle, Western Ontario and McMaster Universities Osteoarthritis Index (WOMAC) scale scores, and modified Harris hip score (MHHS) were observed. MHHS were divided into three clinically relevant categories: poor (<70 points), good (70-85 points), and excellent (86-91 points). Patient demographic data, as well as preoperative and postoperative radiographic parameters, were subjected to univariate logistic regression analysis. Multiple regression analysis was used to determine factors influencing postoperative MHHS.

RESULTS

The follow-up time was 1.0-3.9 years after surgery, with an average of 1.6 years. By the last follow-up, MHHS increased from 70 points before surgery to 91 points after surgery (P < 0.001), WOMAC pain score decreased from 4 points before surgery to 0 points after surgery (P < 0.001). WOMAC functional score decreased (Preoperative: 18.0 [4.0]; Postoperative: 4.0 [0], P = 0.004). Six patients had sensory disturbance of the lateral femoral cutaneous nerve, four of which recovered completely during follow-up. No other complications related to surgical approach, osteotomy, acetabular displacement, acetabular fixation, and postoperative stage were found. There was no significant vascular, nerve, or visceral injuries in any of the patients. On multiple regression analysis, the probability of the postoperative modified Harris hip score of a hip joint with a preoperative lateral center edge angle ≥4.5° being classified as excellent was six times that of angles <4.5° (Exp[β]: 6.249, 95% CI: 1.03-37.85, P = 0.046). Regression analysis of other factors found no significant correlation with postoperative functional scores.

CONCLUSION

Overall functional scores post-PAO significantly improved, and pain symptoms were significantly reduced. Patients with a preoperative lateral center edge angle ≥4.5° had better joint function after surgery.

Isolated changes in femoral version do not alter intra-articular contact mechanics in cadaveric hips

Abnormal femoral version is a deformity in the angle between the femoral neck and the transcondylar axis of the knee. Both femoral anteversion and retroversion alter passive and active rotation of the hip and are associated with intra-articular or extra-articular impingement. However, little is known about the effect of abnormal femoral version on intra-articular hip contact stresses. To quantify the effect of femoral version on hip contact stress, five cadaveric pelvis specimens were mechanically tested with a hip-specific Tekscan sensor inserted in the joint space. Specimens were oriented in a heel-strike position and loaded with 1000 N of compressive force. Pressure measurements were recorded by the Tekscan sensor with the femur oriented in 0°, 15°, and 30° of version. At the completion of testing, specimens were locked into place at 0° and post-test CT scans were obtained to register the pressure sensor measurements to the joint anatomy. There were minor changes in contact area (<7%) and translation of the peak contact stress location (8.8 ± 7.6 mm). There was no significant change in peak contact stress (p = 0.901) in either the retroverted (0°) or anteverted (30°) conditions relative to normal version (15°) under identical gait-related loading conditions. While abnormalities in patient gait and resultant joint loading caused by femoral version abnormalities may contribute to hip pain, the present findings would suggest that future joint degeneration in hips with version abnormalities are not simply the result of abnormal contact stress induced by joint incongruity due to femoral version abnormalities.

The association between periacetabular osteotomy reorientation and hip joint reaction forces in two subgroups of acetabular dysplasia

Acetabular dysplasia is primarily characterized by an altered acetabular geometry that results in deficient coverage of the femoral head, and is a known cause of hip osteoarthritis. Periacetabular osteotomy (PAO) is a surgical reorientation of the acetabulum to normalize coverage, yet its effect on joint loading is unknown. Our objective was to establish how PAO, simulated with a musculoskeletal model and probabilistic analysis, alters hip joint reaction forces (JRF) in two representative patients of two different acetabular dysplasia subgroups: anterolateral and posterolateral coverage deficiencies. PAO reorientation was simulated within the musculoskeletal model by adding three surgical degrees of freedom to the acetabulum relative to the pelvis (acetabular adduction, acetabular extension, medial translation of the hip joint center). Monte Carlo simulations were performed to generate 2000 unique PAO reorientations for each patient; from which 99% confidence bounds and sensitivity factors were calculated to assess the influence of input variability (PAO reorientation) on output (hip JRF) during gait. Our results indicate that reorientation of the acetabulum alters the lines of action of the hip musculature. Specifically, as the hip joint center was medialized, the moment arm of the hip abductor muscles was increased, which in turn increased the mechanical force-generating capacity of these muscles and decreased joint loading. Independent of subgroup, hip JRF was most sensitive to hip joint center medialization. Results from this study improve understanding of how PAO reorientation affects muscle function differently dependent upon acetabular dysplasia subgrouping and can be used to inform more targeted surgical interventions.