Efficacy and Safety of 2 Injection Techniques for Hand Biostimulatory Treatment With Diluted Calcium Hydroxylapatite

Photoaging and cosmeceutical solutions in sun-overexposed countries: The experience of Australia and Brazil

Skin aging is the result of physiological changes determined by genetically driven processes and intrinsic factors, and exacerbated by a combination of multiple environmental factors, the main one being sun exposure. The effects of photoaging are particularly apparent on the face, where the appearance of aging signs can have a significant impact on the emotions conveyed and well-being. Photoprotection and facial skin care for managing photoaging signs are thus of particular importance for both physical and mental health. Countries, like Australia and Brazil, where the level of sun exposure is high and the populations have predominantly outdoor lifestyles, are particularly aware of the harms of photoaging and have implemented several measures to help reduce the risk of skin cancer in their populations. However, sun-seeking behaviours are difficult to change, and it takes time before interventions provide perceptible results. Australia still has some of the highest skin cancer incidence and mortality rates in the world. Solutions that target individuals can also be used for minimizing the clinical signs of facial aging and for improving skin quality, with the ultimate aim being not only to improve the appearance of the skin but also to mitigate the occurrence of pre-malignant and malignant lesions. This review summarizes the features of facial skin photoaging in photo-exposed populations, based on evidence gained from studies of Australian individuals, and discusses the various available solutions for skin photoaging, in particular those that are most popular in Brazil, which is a country with many years of experience in managing photoaged skin.

A systematic review of Radiesse® (calcium hydroxylapatite): evidence and recommendations for the body

A filler composed of calcium hydroxylapatite and carboxymethylcellulose gel (CaHA/CMC) has been shown to possess biostimulatory and skin-tightening properties that have been applied not just to the face but also to the body to boost rejuvenation. Recently, evidence and recommendations for CaHA/CMC treatment of the face have been provided, but they are still lacking in terms of body treatment. This article aims to perform a systematic review of the literature on CaHA/CMC applications on the body and provide evidence from the literature. Currently, the only FDA-approved indication on the body is treating the hands and a recent European Union Medical Device Regulation approval has been released for decolletage treatment. The application of hyperdilutions on the neck, feet, arms, thighs, abdomen, and other body parts has been proven to provide a skin-tightening effect. However, despite their wide use with a good safety profile in clinical practice, recent trends and guidelines of diluted and hyperdiluted CaHA/CMC have yet to be supported by randomized controlled trials.

Hand Rejuvenation with Customizable Hybrid Fillers: Premixed Calcium Hydroxyapatite and Hyaluronic Acid

INTRODUCTION

Hand aging is a prevalent concern characterized by the atrophy of local soft tissues and increased visibility of vessels and tendons. Hyaluronic acid (HA) and calcium hydroxyapatite (CaHA) are well-established treatments for addressing this issue. While hybrid filler containing HA and CaHA has been proposed for facial rejuvenation, studies investigating its efficacy for hand rejuvenation are lacking.

OBJECTIVE

This study aims to assess the safety and efficacy of a premixed hybrid filler containing calcium hydroxyapatite (CaHA) and hyaluronic acid (HA) for hand rejuvenation.

METHODS

A prospective, double-blind, controlled trial was conducted. The control arm (CA) received conventional subdermal treatment with CaHA at a 1:1 dilution. The intervention arm (IA) underwent hybrid treatment, consisting of CaHA at a 1:1 dilution combined with 1 ml of low-density HA. Evaluation was performed subjectively using the Global Aesthetic Improvement Scale (GAIS) and the Manchester Hand Grading System (MHGS), and objectively using cutometry, corneometry, and ultrasound.

RESULTS

Both the CA and the IA exhibited high rates of patient satisfaction and satisfaction as assessed by blinded evaluators. Although numerical superiority was observed in the IA, no statistical difference was found between the two groups. Significant improvements in hydration, elasticity, and skin thickness were observed in both arms, with no discernible difference between them. Greater ultrasound echogenicity was noted in the IA, which, as indicated by existing literature, may suggest enhanced biostimulation. No adverse effects were reported in either arm.

CONCLUSION

Premixed filler containing HA and CaHA for hand rejuvenation appears to be a safe and effective approach.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE I

This journal requires that authors assign a level of evidence to each article. For a full description of these Evidence-Based Medicine ratings, please refer to the Table of Contents or the online Instructions to Authors www.springer.com/00266 .

Dilutional rheology of Radiesse: Implications for regeneration and vascular safety

BACKGROUND

Calcium hydroxylapatite-carboxymethylcellulose (CaHA-CMC) injectables have emerged as dual-purpose fillers with bioregenerative and direct filling capabilities.

AIMS

This study investigates the rheological properties of CaHA-CMC and its CMC carrier gel at various dilutions.

METHODS

The storage modulus (G'), loss modulus (G″), complex viscosity (η*), loss factor (tan δ), cohesivity, and extrusion force were evaluated for a range of CaHA-CMC aqueous dilutions with an oscillatory rheometer, drop weight testing, and force analysis, respectively.

RESULTS

Results revealed a significant decrease in G', η*, and increase in tan(δ) with increasing dilution, indicating a decline in the product's direct filling capabilities. Cohesivity decreased dramatically with dilution, potentially enhancing tissue biointegration and the product's biostimulatory effects. The CMC gel carrier displayed inelastic and non-resilient properties, with rheological changes differing from CaHA-CMC. Dilutional rheology was also correlated with previously published dilution-dependent biostimulatory data where hyperdiluted CaHA-CMC (>1:2) demonstrated a regenerative profile and diluted or hypodiluted mixtures retained meaningful filling properties and increased regeneration.

CONCLUSIONS

These findings offer a continuum for tailoring the product's rheological profile to match specific tissue requirements. Customizable rheology allows CaHA-CMC to be tuned for either filling and contouring or optimal regenerative effects. Importantly, safety implications related to vascular occlusion suggest that dilutional rheomodulation decreases the risk of vascular events. In conclusion, this study highlights the significant impact of aqueous dilution on the rheological properties of CaHA-CMC and its carrier gel. The findings support the clinical application of tailored dilutions to achieve desired outcomes, providing versatility and safety for aesthetic applications.

A 15% Trichloroacetic Acid + 3% Glycolic Acid Chemical Peel Series Improves Appearance of Hand Lentigines: An Evaluator-Blinded, Split-Hand Prospective Trial

BACKGROUND

Improving the appearance of lentigines on the hands is a key component to hand rejuvenation. Soft tissue fillers revolumize hands, but do not address pigmentary changes. OBJECTIVE: This study investigated the effiacy of a 15% trichloroacetic acid (TCA) + 3% glycolic acid (GA) combination peel in improvement of appearance of hand lentigines.

METHODS

A prospective evaluator-blinded, split-hand study was performed using a 15% TCA + 3% GA peel to treat patients with hand lentigines. Subjects received a total of 3 treatments at 4-week intervals on 1 hand, with the other hand serving as an untreated control. Final photographs were taken 12 weeks after the last treatment. Two blinded board-certified dermatologists graded improvement in hand lentigines using a 5-point scale.

RESULTS

Eighteen of 20 patients completed the study (90%). The mean age was 64.4 years (SE 1.6, range 51-71). The mean pain scores were 3.8 (SE 0.4) on a 10-point scale (1 = no pain, 10 = extremely painful). Blinded evaluators correctly identified the after-treatment photographs in 16 patients (88%). Physician and patient-graded mean improvement of lentigines was significant for treated versus control hands ( p < .01). No adverse events were noted.

CONCLUSION

A series of three 15% TCA + 3% GA peels are effective and safe in the treatment of hand lentigines.

Global facial rejuvenation with one treatment of incobotulinumtoxinA, hyaluronic acid, and calcium hydroxyapatite results in long-term patient-reported satisfaction

Background

Global facial rejuvenation using injectables (neuromodulators and fillers) has reported patient satisfaction after 2 treatments: an initial and touch-up treatment at 2-4 weeks afterward. In practice, patients typically receive only 1 treatment and do not return for a touch-up treatment within a month.

Objective

The purpose of this study was to assess patient-reported satisfaction after only 1 treatment, thus mimicking real-world scenarios.

Methods

Patients with facial photoaging (Glogau facial aging scale ≥2) were treated with calcium hydroxyapatite, hyaluronic acid 22.5 mg/mL, and incobotulinumtoxinA injections for full facial rejuvenation, with no touch-up treatments. Patients completed the FACE-Q Satisfaction with Facial Appearance survey at baseline and 1- and 3-month post-treatment. The treating physician completed the Global Aesthetic Improvement Scale at 1- and 3-month post-treatment.

Results

Twenty-two patients were enrolled in the study, with 1 patient lost to follow-up. There was a significant improvement in mean FACE-Q scores at 1-month (80.1, P = .01) and 3-month (77.9, P = .02) compared to baseline (71.4). Mean Global Aesthetic Improvement Scale scores at 1-month (2.1) and 3-month (2.2) were not statistically significant, indicating sustained improvement at 3 months. The product amount used per patient varied and was not correlated with either score. Limitations included a lack of a control group and follow-up ending at 3 months. Strengths included assessment of patient satisfaction after only 1 treatment, compared to other studies allowing 2 treatments.

Limitations

Limitations include a small sample size and lack of a control group.

Conclusion

Global full facial rejuvenation using 1 treatment of calcium hydroxyapatite, hyaluronic acid 22.5 mg/mL, and incobotulinumtoxinA provides sustained patient-reported satisfaction at 3 months.

Starting Point for Protocols on the Use of Hyperdiluted Calcium Hydroxylapatite (Radiesse®) for Optimizing Age-Related Biostimulation and Rejuvenation of Face, Neck, Décolletage and Hands: A Case Series Report

Radiesse® is a dermal filler made of calcium hydroxylapatite, a natural component of the human body, which, in diluted and hyperdiluted forms, promotes, unlike other fillers, neocollagenesis, neoelastinogenesis, fibroblast proliferation, and angiogenesis, leading to a long-term improved skin quality, elasticity, tightening, and firmness. This case series examined the use of Radiesse® (Merz, Frankfurt, Germany) for skin rejuvenation and regeneration through a long-lasting action of collagen biostimulation. The report explored for the first time the use of different dilution ratios of Radiesse® in 50 patients of varying ages and skin needs. By combining microboluses, tunneling, and/or fanning techniques, Radiesse® was superficially injected in different body regions, including the full-face, neck, décolletage, and hands. The treatment was effective in improving skin thickness, laxity, and wrinkles in 95% of 30-40 year-olds, 80% of 40-60 year-olds, and 70% of >60 year-olds, with an average improvement of 81.6% for the general population. The treatment was well-tolerated with no significant adverse effects reported. The report also describes specific cases and includes pictures comparing the baseline condition to the changes obtained after different months and Radiesse® sessions. The patients reported a clear improvement in skin firmness and brightness, as well as a visible improvement in wrinkles' appearance. This report found that diluting and hyperdiluting Radiesse® with flexible dilution ratios favoured a treatment's individualization, providing improved skin quality, elasticity, tightening, and firmness, without volume augmentation. In conclusion, it highlights the versatility and flexibility of Radiesse® and emphasizes its efficacy and safety in skin rejuvenation and regeneration.

Buttocks Beautification 3D with Calcium Hydroxylapatite (RadiesseTM): An Individualized Approach to Diagnosing and Treating Contour, Sagging, and Cellulite of the Buttocks in Seven Cases

Background

The demand for body procedures is increasing, and buttocks beautification is one of the most sought-after procedures in dermatological and plastic surgery clinics. Several aspects affect the beauty of this area, including sagging, cellulite, contour irregularity, and volume reduction. This makes treatment of the area more challenging. Calcium hydroxylapatite (CaHA), which may be injected into the buttocks, stimulates local neocollagenesis, provides volume replacement, increases the strength and elasticity of the dermis, and thickens the underlying superficial fascia. However, no protocol for buttocks beautification tailors the dilution and deep application of CaHA filler simultaneously according to clinical assessments and personal priorities regarding contour, sagging, and cellulite.

Purpose

To report the results of a minimally invasive protocol using different dilutions of CaHA (Buttocks Beautification 3D) in the buttocks with application in different planes. The treatment was performed according to a previous individualized evaluation to improve the area aesthetically.

Patients and methods

Six women and one man were submitted to the protocol. An assessment was performed to determine the shape, sagging, cellulite (in women), and patients' preferences for buttocks beautification. The dilution, volume, depth, and injection technique for CaHA were based on these assessments. The results of the treatment were then assessed using standardized photographs and patient satisfaction.

Results

We reported favorable results in six women and one man with different grades of sagging, female cellulite, and shapes of the gluteal region who were treated with CaHA injections according to a tailored protocol. All participants reported high satisfaction with the procedure.

Conclusion

Highly satisfactory results were achieved in seven adult patients who were assessed and treated for the buttocks with CaHA using an individualized protocol. Prospective studies should be performed to corroborate our findings and optimize the use of Buttocks Beautification 3D as a reliable modality of treatment for this body area.

Skin regeneration-related mechanisms of Calcium Hydroxylapatite (CaHA): a systematic review

Introduction

Calcium Hydroxylapatite (CaHA) is a common dermal filler used in aesthetic medicine for volumizing and contouring. Understanding mechanisms of actions of CaHA can help improve our understanding of its clinical applications.

Methods

We performed a systematic review to summarize the skin-regeneration related mechanisms of CaHA. Five bibliographic databases were searched for English-language publications that evaluated CaHA in skin regeneration outcomes including neocollagenesis, cell proliferation and growth factors, angiogenesis, vascular dynamic and inflammatory markers, among others. Methodological rigor of included studies was assessed.

Results

Of 2,935 identified citations, 12 studies were included for final analysis. Collagen production was reported by nine studies, cell proliferation by four, elastic fibers and/or elastin by four, and three studies on angiogenesis, while limited studies were available on the other outcomes. Six were clinical/observational studies. Only seven studies had a control group. Overall, studies showed CaHA resulted in increased cell proliferation, increased collagen production and angiogenesis, as well as in higher elastic fiber and elastin formation. Limited and inconclusive evidence was available on the other mechanisms. The majority of the studies had methodological limitations.

Discussion

Current evidence is limited but indicates several mechanisms through which CaHA could lead to skin regeneration, volume enhancement, and contouring.

Systematic review registration

https://doi.org/10.17605/OSF.IO/WY49V.

Efficacy and Tolerability of Hyperdiluted Calcium Hydroxylapatite (Radiesse) for Neck Rejuvenation: Clinical and Ultrasonographic Assessment

Background

The subdermal injection of calcium hydroxylapatite (CaHA) can improve the mechanical properties of the skin, providing immediate correction and stimulating the endogenous production of collagen, elastin, angiogenesis, and dermal cell proliferation; however, few studies have examined the neck region.

Purpose

This study assessed the clinical and ultrasonographic improvement induced by two sessions of subdermal injection of hyperdiluted (1:4) CaHA for neck rejuvenation in 22 women.

Patients and Methods

A quasi-experimental longitudinal trial (before and after) was performed by enrolling 22 adult women with mild and moderate neck aging (grades 1 and 2) on Merz Neck Volume Scale at rest (laxity) and Neck Horizontal Lines. They were submitted to two sessions of subdermal hyperdiluted CaHA (D0 and D45) treatments and assessed clinically and ultrasonographically at D0, D45, and D120. The main outcomes were the blinded photographic assessment (Merz scales of neck laxity and horizontal lines), dermal thickness (at three points), and the GAIS (Global Aesthetic Improvement Scale) score.

Results

The mean (SD) age was 43.5 (5.6) years. At the inclusion, the Merz scores for neck laxity were mild for 27% and moderate for 73% of participants, and the Merz scores for necklines were mild for 32% and moderate for 68%. At D120, scores decreased in 86% (95% CI 68-99%) of the participants by at least one degree on the necklines scale and in 82% (95% CI 73-90%) for neck laxity. According to the GAIS, 91% (95% CI 77-99%) of the participants evidenced improvement at D120. The mean dermal thickness increased by 15% (95% CI 8-21%) at D120. No severe adverse effects were recorded, and high satisfaction was reported by 82% of the participants.

Conclusion

Two sessions of subdermal hyperdiluted CaHA were well-tolerated and improved necklines, neck laxity, and dermal thickness in adult women with mild and moderate cervical aging.

Revitalizing Hands: A Comprehensive Review of Anatomy and Treatment Options for Hand Rejuvenation

Dorsal hand rejuvenation is gaining popularity as a solitary procedure and adjunct to face and neck rejuvenation treatments. As the hands age, the skin loses elasticity and becomes more translucent, the veins, joints, and tendons appear more prominent, and the bones become more noticeable. These changes are due to intrinsic and extrinsic factors. Current treatment methods include the injection of dermal fillers and autologous fat grafting. Anatomic studies to ensure the successful implementation of rejuvenation procedures identified three separate fascial layers in the dorsum, from superficial to deep. More recent re-evaluations revealed a less distinct, inseparable, sponge-like fascial layer. All authors agree that the superficial dermal layer is probably the optimal location for the injection of volumizing materials because it is free of anatomical structures. Many methods for harvesting, preparing, and injecting fat grafts to the dorsum of the hand have been described in the past three decades. Both filler and fat-graft procedures are performed on an ambulatory basis under local anesthesia. Good results with low postoperative and long-term complication rates and high patient satisfaction have been reported.

Ultrasound Analyses of the Dorsal Hands for Volumetric Rejuvenation

BACKGROUND

Volumetric hand rejuvenation of the dorsal hands is increasingly applied for aged, skeletonized dorsal hand skin, with prominent veins, tendons, and joints due to volumetric loss of subcutaneous fat. However, the aging process of the fatty laminae remains unexplored.

OBJECTIVES

We aim to investigate the impact of aging and potential determinants on the fatty laminae to improve the therapeutic effect of volumetric injection.

METHODS

This cross-sectional study enrolled 105 Taiwanese participants aged ≥20 years, divided into five age groups per decade. Thicknesses of the dorsal superficial lamina (DSL), dorsal intermediate lamina (DIL), and dorsal deep lamina (DDL) were measured via ultrasonography by a single-blinded practitioner. The potential determining factors of the laminae thickness (age, sex, body mass index, and hand dominance) were analyzed.

RESULTS

The thicknesses of the three laminae decreased with aging, with the mean decrease in thickness from the 20s to >60 years in DSL, DIL, and DDL being 0.21 mm (30.0%), 1.38 mm (63.89%), and 0.31 mm (20.95%), respectively. DIL thickness decrease was the greatest and most significant since the 30s. Multiple linear regression analysis showed age as the only determinant for thicknesses of the 3 laminae (all P<0.001), whereas DIL was significantly thicker in men (P<0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

Volumetric fat loss was noted in the three fatty laminae of dorsal hands during aging; DIL has the greatest progressive fat loss since the 30s. Volumetric rejuvenation of the 3 laminae may result in the most esthetic appearance, especially in women.