Eyelid Reconstruction Using Oral Mucosa and Ear Cartilage Strips as Sandwich Grafting

Esthetic Posterior Reconstruction of Lower Eyelid Using Stripe-Shaped Antihelix Cartilage With Perichondrium

Eyelid malignancies are often resected in the entire layer, typically requiring anterior and posterior lamellae reconstruction. Posterior lamella reconstruction has been reported using grafts from the nasal septum, palatal mucosa, and auricular cartilage, which have advantages and disadvantages. The authors performed anterior and posterior lamellar reconstruction using a local skin flap and stripe-shaped anti-helical cartilage with the perichondrium in 3 total defect cases after basal cell carcinoma resection of the lower eyelid. The auricular cartilage was excised in strips with the surrounding perichondrium attached and simultaneously reconstructed, with the auricular cartilage as the tarsal and the perichondrium as the conjunctival substitute. In all 3 cases, good results were obtained without eyelid ectropion or corneal irritation 1 year postoperatively. No auricular deformities were observed. However, partial lower eyelid ptosis was observed in 2 cases. In future cases, correctively over-fixating the lower eyelid morphology is necessary.

Bioengineering autologous cartilage grafts for functional posterior lamellar eyelid reconstruction: A preliminary study in rabbits

The reconstruction of posterior lamellar eyelid defects remains a significant challenge in clinical practice due to anatomical complexity, specialized function, and aesthetic concerns. The ideal substitute for the posterior lamellar should replicate the native tarsoconjunctival tissue, providing both mechanical support for the eyelids and a smooth surface for the globe after implantation. In this study, we present an innovative approach utilizing tissue-engineered cartilage (TEC) grafts generated from rabbit auricular chondrocytes and a commercialized type I collagen sponge to reconstruct critical-sized posterior lamellar defects in rabbits. The TEC grafts demonstrated remarkable mechanical strength and maintained a stable cartilaginous phenotype both in vitro and at 6 months post-implantation in immunodeficient mice. When employed as autografts to reconstruct tarsal plate defects in rabbits' upper eyelids, these TEC grafts successfully restored normal eyelid morphology, facilitated smooth eyelid movement, and preserved the histological structure of the conjunctival epithelium. When applied in bilayered tarsoconjunctival defect reconstruction, these TEC grafts not only maintained the normal contour of the upper eyelid but also supported conjunctival epithelial cell migration and growth from the defect margin towards the centre. These findings highlight that auricular chondrocyte-based TEC grafts hold great promise as potential candidates for clinical posterior lamellar reconstruction. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE: The complex structure and function of the posterior lamellar eyelid continue to be significant challenges for clinical reconstructive surgeries. In this study, we utilized autologous auricular chondrocyte-based TEC grafts for posterior lamellar eyelid reconstruction in a preclinical rabbit model. The TEC grafts exhibited native cartilaginous histomorphology and comparable mechanical strength to those of the native human tarsal plate. In rabbit models with either tarsal plate defects alone or bilayered tarsoconjunctival defects, TEC grafts successfully restored the normal eyelid contour and movement, as well as supported preservation and growth of conjunctival epithelium. This is the first study to demonstrate autologous TEC grafts can be employed for repairing tarsal plate defects, thereby offering an alternative therapeutic approach for treating posterior lamellar defects in clinic settings.

A Single Staged Reconstruction of Upper Eyelid and Eyelashes

The upper eyelid is a complex structural part of the face that plays an important role in protecting the cornea from drying and damage to preserve vision. The eyelashes are an essential part of the upper eyelid and help in protecting the eyes from dust, foreign bodies, and sweat. Being a part of the face, which is the most noticeable part of the body, both structures hold an important role in reconstructive procedures. Reconstruction of both structures simultaneously is tricky but helps reduce the number of procedures required in achieving an aesthetically acceptable eye. Our techniques describe the use of the paramedian forehead flap with an anterior hairline to reconstruct the upper eyelid and eyelashes in a single stage in a posttraumatic near-total upper eyelid defect with a favorable outcome. Depending on the parting of the patient's hair, the anterior hairline of one side can be included in the distal edge of the flap while raising, which can be inset so that the direction and orientation of the eyelashes perfectly match. Our technique refurbishes an established technique for eyelid reconstruction to include eyelash reconstruction at the same time, thus saving time and resources without any inconvenience to the patient.

Polymers and Biomaterials for Posterior Lamella of the Eyelid and the Lacrimal System

The application of biopolymers in the reconstruction of the posterior lamella of the eyelid and the lacrimal system marks a significant fusion of biomaterial science with clinical advancements. This review assimilates research spanning 2015 to 2023 to provide a detailed examination of the role of biopolymers in reconstructing the posterior lamella of the eyelid and the lacrimal system. It covers the anatomy and pathophysiology of eyelid structures, the challenges of reconstruction, and the nuances of surgical intervention. This article progresses to evaluate the current gold standards, alternative options, and the desirable properties of biopolymers used in these intricate procedures. It underscores the advancements in the field, from decellularized grafts and acellular matrices to innovative natural and synthetic polymers, and explores their applications in lacrimal gland tissue engineering, including the promise of 3D bioprinting technologies. This review highlights the importance of multidisciplinary collaboration between material scientists and clinicians in enhancing surgical outcomes and patient quality of life, emphasizing that such cooperation is pivotal for translating benchtop research into bedside applications. This collaborative effort is vital for restoring aesthetics and functionality for patients afflicted with disfiguring eyelid diseases, ultimately aiming to bridge the gap between innovative materials and their clinical translation.

Use of biomaterials in the reconstruction of posterior lamellar eyelid defects: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Eyelid defects can occur secondary to tumours, trauma, burns, and congenital factors. Among the most challenging aspects of eyelid reconstruction is the rebuilding of a tarsal substitute due to its delicate and multi-layered tissue composition. Attempts to use biomaterials for posterior lamellar reconstruction are intended to provide an alternative to traditional autograft reconstructions. In this review, we aimed to assess the types of biomaterials used for the reconstruction of the posterior lamella associated with eyelid defects and the associated clinical outcomes. A literature search was conducted on Pubmed, Prospero, Dynamed, DARE, EMBASE, and COCHRANE databases. A total of 15 articles fulfilled the inclusion criteria, and 129 patients with 142 eyelids reconstructed, using artificial grafts, were included in the review. Acellular dermis allograft (AlloDerm®, LifeCell) (n = 49) was the most common artificial graft used. A meta-analysis was performed, which demonstrated a pooled success rate of artificial grafts of 99% (95% CI 96-100, p = 0.05; I2 = 40%, total complications seen 39% (95% CI 96-100, p = 0.05; I2 = 40%) and re-operation rates of 5.6% (n = 8). The biomaterials used demonstrated an overall success rate of 99%, which is similar if not greater than that reported with the use of traditional autograft reconstruction techniques, with similar complications and fewer re-operations than autografts. This suggests that clinicians should consider the clinical use of artificial grafts for posterior lamellar reconstruction.

Labia Minora Transplantation With Local Flap for Reconstruction of Full-Thickness Defect of the Lower Eyelid

Large lower eyelid full-thickness defects require reconstruction before closure. Although several methods for replantation of the posterior lamella are reported, there are advantages and disadvantages. Herein, the authors report reconstruction of the posterior lamella of the lower eyelid by labia minora transplantation. A 70-year-old woman developed basal cell carcinoma of the right lower eyelid. Excision of the tumor resulted in a full-thickness defect of 25 mm in width on the central portion of the lower eyelid. The posterior lamella was reconstructed by labia minora transplantation, whereas the anterior lamella was reconstructed using the angular flap. There were no perioperative problems, and 2 years after the operation, the esthetic appearance and function was favorable. The labia minora mucosa has almost no donor trouble functionally and has both hardness and elasticity. Although there are some disadvantages, labia minora transplantation would be useful for posterior lamella reconstruction of the lower eyelid.

Surgical Strategies for Eyelid Defect Reconstruction: A Review on Principles and Techniques

Reconstruction of eyelid defects, especially the posterior lamella, remains challenging because of its anatomical complexity, functional considerations, and aesthetic concerns. The goals of eyelid reconstruction include restoring eyelid structure and function and achieving an aesthetically acceptable appearance. An in-depth understanding of the complex eyelid anatomy and several reconstructive principles are mandatory to achieve these goals. Currently, there are multiple surgical treatment options for eyelid reconstruction, including different flaps, grafts, and combinations of them. This comprehensive review outlines the principles of reconstruction and discusses the indications, advantages, and disadvantages of currently available surgical techniques. We also propose our clinical thinking for solving specific clinical questions in eyelid reconstruction and offer perspectives on new potential methodologies in the future.

How and when of eyelid reconstruction using autologous transplantation

Reconstructive surgery of the eyelid after tumor excision, trauma or other causes can be challenging, especially due to the complexities of the anatomic structures and to the necessity of both functional and aesthetic successful outcomes. The aim of this minireview was to investigate the use of tissue transplantation in eyelid reconstruction. Surgical procedures are various, based on the use of both flaps, pedicled or free, and grafts, in order to guarantee adequate tissue reconstruction and blood supply, which are necessary for correct healing. Common techniques normally include the use of local tissues, combining non-vascularized grafts with a vascularized flap for the two lamellae repair, to attempt a reconstruction similar to the original anatomy. When defects are too wide, vast, deep, and complex or when no adjacent healthy tissues are available, distant area tissues need to be recruited as free flaps or grafts and paired with mucosal layer reconstruction. With regards to the anterior lamella, full thickness skin grafts are commonly preferred. With regards to the reconstruction of posterior lamella, there are different graft options, which include conjunctival or tarsoconjunctival, mucosal or palatal or cartilaginous grafts usually combined with local flaps. Free flap transplantation, normally reserved for rare select cases, include the use of the radial forearm and anterolateral flaps combined with mucosal grafts, which are surgical options currently reported in the literature.

Auricular skin-cartilage sandwich graft technique for full-thickness eyelid reconstruction

Full-thickness deficiency of eyelid tissues can result in coloboma or retraction or both. Here we report our initial experience on the use of auricular skin-cartilage sandwich graft technique for full-thickness eyelid deformities. Five patients (4-32 years) underwent the procedure. Patients with full-thickness eyelid deformity were included. Three patients were operated for large-sized coloboma and two for eyelid retraction. One patient had congenital, and four patients had acquired etiology. The following parameters were specifically assessed: correction of deformity, ocular surface problems, graft status, and epithelization of skin-cartilage graft. All the patients had a good correction of eyelid position, except one patient who had severe eyelid retraction (8 mm) at presentation. None of our patients had corneal erosion/defect, persistent ocular surface redness, or graft loss. The auricular skin-cartilage sandwich graft technique produces optimal results with no graft loss. Advancement of orbicularis muscle in between the auricular skin and cartilage grafts (sandwich technique) is an imperative step that leads to the survival of both grafts.

Eyelid Reconstruction: An Algorithm Based on Defect Location

ABSTRACT

Eyelid reconstruction is a complex topic. This review looks at articles from 1990 to 2018 on eyelid reconstruction that had at least 10 patients and a mean 6 month follow-up. The authors present the results of our findings and propose an algorithm to guide the surgeon in choosing the best technique based on location, size, and lamella. Defects less than 1/3rd of the upper or lower eyelid may be closed primarily. Anterior and posterior lamella defects of the lower eyelid greater than 1/3rd in size should be reconstructed with a double mucosal and myocutaneous island flap. Those greater than 50% in size should be recreated with a Tripier flap for the anterior lamella and conchal chondroperichondral graft for the posterior lamella. For total lid reconstruction, a Fricke flap is best for the anterior lamella and the tarsoconjunctival free graft/lateral orbital rim periosteal flap is best for the posterior lamella. Full-thickness defects between 1/3rd and 2/3rd in size of the upper eyelid should be reconstructed with a myotarsocutaneous flap and those greater than 2/3rd should be reconstructed with a Cutler-Beard flap for the anterior lamella and auricular cartilage for the posterior lamella. For the medial canthal region, the island pedicle and horizontal cheek advancement flap is recommended for the anterior lamella and a composite upper lid graft for the posterior lamella. For the lateral canthal region, a bilobed flap is recommended for the anterior lamella and a periosteal flap for the posterior lamella.

Use of subdermal hyaluronic acid injections and a free labial mucocutaneous graft for the repair of feline eyelid agenesis

OBJECTIVE

To describe a technique to repair feline eyelid agenesis using a hyaluronic acid (HA) subdermal filler injection to allow for acute soft tissue expansion, followed by a free labial mucocutaneous graft.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Thirty-nine colobomatous eyelids in 24 feline patients with secondary keratitis were recruited to the study group.

RESULTS

Keratitis and trichiasis were markedly resolved in 27/39 (69.2%) eyelids after a single procedure. Post-operative HA subdermal filler injections were required to resolve 5/39 (12.8%) eyelids that had mild post-operative trichiasis, and 1/39 (2.5%) eyelids that had post-operative lateral canthal collapse. Complications occurred in 6/39 (15.4%) cases, consisting of distal graft necrosis (n = 2 eyes), suture rubbing the cornea (n = 2 eyes), moderate trichiasis (n = 1 eye) and graft adherence to the episclera (n = 1 eye).

CONCLUSION

The technique was successful in enhancing corneal protection, cosmesis and eyelid function and should be considered as a surgical option for any degree of eyelid agenesis in feline patients.

Auricular cartilage versus donor sclera as a wrapping of hydroxyapatite orbital implants

AIM

To retrospectively compare postoperative outcomes after primary enucleation and placement of a hydroxyapatite (HA) implant without wrapping, wrapped with auricular cartilage or donor sclera.

METHODS

Medical records of patients presented as intraocular tumor or severe ocular injury were identified from the electronic medical record system. Cases underwent enucleation and HA orbital implantation were enrolled in this study and were divided into 3 groups according to the wrapping material of HA implant. Cases with autogenous cartilage caps were enrolled in group A (n=11), with donor sclera caps in group B (n=12), and without any wrapping material in group C (n=9). Follow-ups were set at 1, 2wk, 1, 3, 6, and 12mo after surgery.

RESULTS

Altogether 32 cases finished the follow-up and were enrolled in this study. Three cases (27.27%) in group A, 4 cases (33.33%) in group B, and 4 cases (44.44%) in group C developed one complication each after surgery. In group A, no HA exposure occurred, but conjunctival inclusion cyst occurred in one and severe conjunctive chemosis in two cases. In group B, one HA exposure occurred, conjunctive inclusion cysts occurred in one, severe conjunctive chemosis occurred in one, and conjunctival granuloma occurred in one case. In group C, one HA exposure occurred, severe conjunctive chemosis occurred in two cases, and conjunctival granuloma occurred in one case. The case of exposure of none-wrapped implant was noted in the first 6mo after placement of the orbital implant. The case of exposure of donor sclera-wrapped implant was noted at the 12mo after placement of the orbital implant. Both exposure cases were treated successfully with conservative treatment.

CONCLUSION

With low incidence of implant exposure and mild complications, auricular cartilage can be a good choice of alternative wrapping material of orbit implant with satisfied outcome.

[Eyelid surgery : Eyelid surgical techniques from a histopathological perspective]

Eyelid surgery and histopathology are closely related, especially in tumor surgery. Based on histological specimens from the archive of the Department of Ophthalmopathology, Eye Centre Freiburg, this article deals with the search for traces following eyelid surgery, and explains the respective clinical relevance for ophthalmologists involved in surgical and conservative treatment. Thermal, electrical and mechanical impacts on the tissue during tumor removal lead to histologically detectable artifacts. These must be kept to a minimum by the surgeon in order to ensure histological assessability and avoid adverse consequences for the patient. During the subsequent eyelid reconstruction, the eyelid architecture is changed depending on the surgical technique. Thus, after Hughes' operation a degeneration of the meibomian glands is histologically noticeable, which should be taken into account in the clinical aftercare of the patients. Suture material can lead to foreign body granulomas, which can be clinically misinterpreted as tumor recurrence. In contrast to foreign material, transplanted autologous tissue, such as cartilage or oral mucosa in the case of eyelid malposition, usually does not lead to chronic inflammation.

Use of free oral mucosal graft for treatment of feline eyelid agenesis in seven patients

OBJECTIVE

To describe a simple and effective surgery for feline eyelid agenesis.

PROCEDURE

Free oral mucosal grafts were harvested from the upper lips of the surgical patients. A recipient bed was created by incising the conjunctiva at the conjunctival-skin border and opening a space in the tissue with blunt dissection without removal of tissue. The free oral mucosal graft was sutured into the space with simple continuous suture pattern of 7-0 Vicryl.

RESULTS

Eyelids were cosmetically acceptable at final examination, and areas of coloboma appeared less prominent. Patient comfort was improved in all subjects as subjectively noted by decreased blepharospasm. All grafts were successfully incorporated. All patients developed brown-colored crusting over the grafts within days of the surgery, which gradually resolved over a 4- to 6-week period. Three of seven patients developed few trichiatic hairs at the donor-recipient junction, and two of these patients had follow-up cryoepilation.

CONCLUSION

For feline eyelid agenesis, free oral mucosal graft implantation was successful in creating space between fur and cornea with insertion of smooth-surfaced, hairless tissue, alleviating the discomfort of hair contacting the cornea. The extra tissue can also create a small overhang or fold of tissue (pseudo-lid) which may also be protective. For two cases, cryoepilation of few trichiatic hairs at the donor-recipient border was performed at a later date. As illustrated by case 3, use of a long and wide rectangular graft with squared edges is recommended to lessen the chance of trichiasis at lateral or medial edges of recipient-donor junctions.

[Experimental justification of the use of a polymeric implant in reconstructive and regenerative surgery of the sclera and tarsal plate]

INTRODUCTION

Congenital and acquired diseases, as well as traumatic injuries of the sclera and tarsal plate can lead to serious complications up to the complete loss of visual functions and loss of the eye as an organ if not treated timely. Due to that, it becomes necessary to use biological and synthetic materials during reconstructive and regenerative surgeries to replace the defects and reinforce the carcass properties of the sclera and tarsal plate.

PURPOSE

To compare experimental and morphological features of the response of the eye and surrounding tissues to implantation of the synthetic polymeric implant for reconstructive and regenerative surgery (PERRS) 'Reperen-6' and biological xenopericardium implant taken from cattle on the sclera in animal experiment.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

The studies were conducted on 12 chinchilla rabbits. PERRS 'Reperen-6' was implanted on the surface of the sclera (into the subtenon space) of left eyes of 6 rabbits from the main group. Similar surgeries with biological xenopericardium implant taken from cattle were performed on the left eyes of 6 rabbits from the comparison group. The right eyes of each animal from both groups remained intact. After the surgery, we performed examination of the animals and acquisition of the material (the eyes and surrounding tissue) in 16, 34 and 68 days. Enucleated eyes were fixed in 10% buffered formalin solution with subsequent preparation of histologic specimen according to standard procedure.

CONCLUSION

The experimental and morphological studies showed that the postoperative period went smoother in the main group of animals. Thanks to its structure, PERRS 'Reperen-6' fixed tightly to the sclera and surrounding structures forming a firm 'own tissue-implant' complex. The polymeric implant 'Reperen-6' can be recommended for reconstructive and regenerative surgeries to reinforce the connective tissue structures in pathological conditions of sclera and appendages of the eyes.

Analysis of Risk Factors Associated With Drooping Deformity After Lower Eyelid Reconstruction: A Newly Developed Drooping Index

BACKGROUND

Lower eyelid reconstruction is challenging because of the risk of severe postreconstruction deformities of the lower eyelid, such as drooping, entropion, and ectropion. However, the risk factors for these postreconstruction deformities are unclear. The present study aimed to quantify the drooping deformity of the lower eyelid after reconstruction using a cheek rotation flap and to identify risk factors associated with postreconstruction deformities.

METHODS

Our study group included 28 patients who underwent full-thickness lower eyelid reconstruction using a cheek rotation flap for anterior lamella reconstruction. We developed the drooping index to classify postreconstruction outcomes as good (index <1.2), fair (index between 1.2 and 1.5), and poor (index >1.5). We identified risk factors for a drooping deformity using univariate analyses (Mann-Whitney U or Spearman rank correlation, depending on data distribution).

RESULTS

Overall, the drooping index ranged between 1.0 and 2.11, with an average value of 1.3. A good outcome was obtained in 11, a fair outcome in 12, and a poor outcome in 5 patients. Clinically severe ectropion was observed in five of the 17 patients in the fair and poor outcome groups, with four of these patients requiring revision surgery. Risk factors for postreconstruction drooping deformity included medial location of the tumor, resection involving more than 50% of the horizontal width of the lower eyelid, and dissection of subcutaneous tissue of the cheek extending below the zygomatic arch.

CONCLUSIONS

A cheek rotation flap provides satisfactory outcomes for full-thickness reconstruction of the lower eyelid. Extension of dissection of subcutaneous tissue of the cheek below the zygomatic arch increases the risk of postsurgical drooping deformity. Our drooping index provides a quantitative measure of drooping deformity and is clinically useful to classify outcomes.

Giant Squamous Cell Papilloma of the Eyelid-Diagnostic and Therapeutic Challenges

Squamous cell papilloma (SCP) is generally a human papillomavirus (HPV) induced exophytic or endophytic proliferation on the surface of the skin, oral cavity, larynx, esophagus, cervix, vagina, and anal canal. The endophytic type SCP can cause differential diagnostic difficulties with keratoacanthoma, inverted follicular keratosis, and squamous cell carcinoma; however, these lesions are not associated with HPV infection. The authors present a female patient who noticed an extremely rapidly growing tumor destructing the left lower eyelid. The histological analysis of the biopsy sample revealed a virus-induced squamoproliferative lesion. The eyelid affected was completely removed, and the histological examination resulted in a HPV induced endophytic squamous cell papilloma. The tarsus and the conjunctiva were replaced by a chondromucosal graft harvested from the nasal septum, while the skin defect could be closed directly. Restoration of the eyelid function has been achieved with satisfying functional and cosmetic results.

Using π-Shaped Auricular Cartilage With a Local Flap for Lower Eyelid Support

INTRODUCTION

Auricular cartilage has been largely reported as an available substitute of defected tarsus to restore lower eyelid stability. However, undesirable results such as displacement, detachment, warping, down-gaze disturbance, and surface irregularity of the cartilage graft have been reported in previous reports, some of which require reoperations. In this study, the authors present a new technique to use strips of auricular cartilage with a local flap to restore the lower eyelid stability for a reliable eyelid support.

METHODS

From 2013 to 2018, the technique was carried out on 13 patients who suffered inadequate lower eyelid support with cicatricial retraction or ectropion and incomplete eyeball coverage, which was caused by soft tissue deletion secondary to different etiologies. Two kinds of local flaps were used to reconstruct the anterior soft tissue layer, whereas the posterior layer was supported with a π-shaped auricular cartilage. The preoperative and postoperative photographs were taken. Three indexes, including the vertical distance between inferior corneal margin and inferior palpebral margin, the maximal breadth of palpebral conjunctiva caused by ectropion, and the maximal palpebral fissure breadth when eyelid is closed, were measured before and 6 months after the operation to evaluate the operative effect.

RESULTS

The average follow-up was 32 months (range, 6-62 months). The local flap survived in all patients. No complications were seen in any of the patients. Postoperative average of the aforementioned first 2 indexes measured at 6 months was 0 mm, whereas the preoperative one was 2.69 and 1.08 mm, respectively. Postoperative average of the third index was also far more lower than the preoperative one (0.08 vs 2.77 mm). The difference between the preoperative and postoperative evaluation of the 3 indexes was statistically significant (paired t test, P < 0.001). No further intervention was required.

CONCLUSIONS

The present technique using a combination of π-shaped auricular cartilage and a local flap provides a satisfying horizontal and vertical support to maintain the lower eyelid in a normal position without compromising the mobility of the lower eyelid. This technique can be used as an effective and safe method for lower eyelid support.

Surgical Treatment with Locoregional Flaps for the Eyelid: A Review

Reconstruction of the eyelids after skin cancer excision can be challenging. Surgical treatment options are multiple; deep anatomy knowledge of lamellar components is mandatory to choose the most adequate surgical planning. Eyelids' role in vision and social relationship is critical; both function and aesthetics are tough to restore. Using a flap provides a satisfying texture and colour match with adjacent tissues and ensures short contraction during healing; furthermore, grafts are sometimes necessary to achieve pleasing results. Hundreds of surgical techniques have been described aiming for eyelid reconstruction; in our paper, we want to provide for our audience the most reliable and useful procedures for subtotal and total eyelid reconstruction following NMSC full-thickness excision.