SCOTOMA CHARACTERISTICS IN MACULAR TELANGIECTASIA TYPE 2: MacTel Project Report No. 7-The MacTel Research Group

Unraveling the mysteries of macular telangiectasia 2: the intersection of philanthropy, multimodal imaging and molecular genetics. The 2022 founders lecture of the pan American vitreoretinal society

PURPOSE

Offer a personal perspective on the scientific advances on macular telangiectasia type 2 (MacTel2) since the launch of the MacTel Project in 2005.

DESIGN

Literature review and personal perspective.

METHODS

Critical review of the peer-reviewed literature and personal perspective.

RESULTS

Generous financial support from the Lowy Medical Research Institute laid the foundations of the MacTel Project. MacTel Project investigators used state of the art multimodal retinal imaging and advanced modern biological methods to unravel many of the mysteries surrounding MacTel2. Major accomplishments includes elucidation of the pathogenic role that low serine levels, elevated 1-deoxysphingolipids and other mechanisms induce mitochondrial dysfunction which lead to Müller cell and photoreceptor degeneration; the use of objective measures of retinal structures such as the area of ellipsoid zone disruption as an outcome measure in clinical trials; the demonstration that the ciliary neurotrophic factor slows down retinal degeneration and the development of a new severity scale classification based on multimodal imaging findings.

CONCLUSIONS

MacTel2 is a predominantly metabolic disease characterized by defects in energy metabolism. Despite relatively good visual acuities, MacTel2 patients experience significant visual disability. The Mac Tel Project has been instrumental in advancing MacTel2 knowledge in the past two decades.

Visual function correlates with foveal slope, retinal and choroidal thickness on optical coherence tomography in type 2 Macular Telangiectasia

PURPOSE

To correlate the foveal slope angle (FSA), retinal (RT) and choroidal (CT) thickness measured using optical coherence tomography (OCT) across different stages of type 2 macular telangiectasia (MacTel) with best-corrected visual acuity (BCVA).

METHODS

A cross-sectional study of 182 gradable quality macular OCT images of 49 patients with type 2 MacTel was carried out. RT was measured on the Spectralis OCT machine from ETDRS (Early Treatment Diabetic Retinopathy Study) retinal thickness map and later used for calculating FSA. RT and CT were measured at 500-µm intervals up to 1500 µm from foveal centre manually. The change in RT, CT and FSA across five stages of type 2 MacTel was assessed. The measurements were correlated with BCVA.

RESULTS

The FSA, RT and CT were calculated quadrantwise and stagewise. The FSA and RT showed a significant negative correlation with disease stage and BCVA (p < .05) in all four quadrants. No significant correlation was noted between CT and BCVA. Multivariate linear regression analysis identified the temporal FSA to correlate best with BCVA.

CONCLUSION

BCVA correlates best with temporal FSA. Smaller the temporal FSA, poorer the vision.

Macular Telangiectasia type 2: multimodal assessment of retinal function and microstructure

PURPOSE

To assess the impact of neurodegenerative morphologic alterations due to macular telangiectasia type 2 (MacTel) on microperimetry (MP) and multifocal electroretinography (mfERG).

METHODS

Thirty-five eyes of 18 patients with MacTel were examined using spectral domain optical coherence tomography (SD-OCT), fundus autofluorescence (FAF), mfERG and MP. Software was used to match SD-OCT B-scans with the corresponding retinal sensitivity map and multifocal electroretinograms (mfERGs), thus enabling direct structure/function correlation.

RESULTS

Loss of the ellipsoid zone (EZ) had the strongest negative association with retinal sensitivity (16.77 dB versus 4.58 dB, adj. p < 0.001) of all parameters examined, and a limited negative effect on mfERGs (0.32 SD versus -1.97 SD adj. p = 0.121). Ellipsoid zone (EZ) irregularity was associated with reduced MP values but preserved mfERGs. There was a significant association between areas of inner retinal hyporeflectivity and loss of MP sensitivity (adj. p < 0.001) but the reduction in sensitivity was less than in locations with EZ loss. Areas of mfERG abnormality showed similar sensitivity loss with either inner retinal hyporeflectivity or EZ loss (adj. p = 0.063). In areas with EZ loss alone, preservation of the external limiting membrane (ELM) was associated with higher MP values than in areas with additional ELM loss; the integrity of the ELM alone was not associated with changes either in MP or mfERG. Increased FAF was observed in 51% of eyes, mixed/reduced FAF in 40%, and no abnormality was detected in 9% of eyes.

CONCLUSION

The data suggest both MP and mfERG to be useful non-invasive modalities for detecting localised macular dysfunction in MacTel. The findings suggest a different sensitivity of the two modalities to inner and outer retinal changes in macular function and are therefore complementary.

Macular Telangiectasia Type 2: Visual Acuity, Disease End Stage, and the MacTel Area: MacTel Project Report Number 8

PURPOSE

To report the visual acuity measures from the macular telangiectasia type 2 (MacTel) registry and to investigate and describe phenotypic findings in eyes with substantial vision loss resulting from MacTel.

DESIGN

Cross-sectional multicenter study.

PARTICIPANTS

Participants in the MacTel Natural History Observation Registration Study.

METHODS

Best-corrected visual acuity (BCVA) data, retinal imaging data, and clinical data were accessed from the MacTel Study databases in May 2019.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Frequency distribution of BCVA and its relationship to age; morphologic changes in eyes with very late disease stages, defined by a BCVA of 20/200 or worse; average retinal thickness of macular subfields on OCT; and dimensions of the area affected by MacTel (i.e., the MacTel area).

RESULTS

Best-corrected visual acuity was 20/50 or worse in 37.3% and 20/200 or worse in 3.8% of 4449 eyes of 2248 patients; 18.4% and 0.7% of all patients showed bilateral BCVA of 20/50 or worse and 20/200 or worse, respectively. Asymmetry between right and left eyes was present (median BCVA, 71 letters vs. 74 letters), a finding supported by more advanced morphologic changes in right eyes. Participant age correlated with BCVA, but the effect size was small. If a neovascularization or macular hole were present, bilateral occurrence was frequent (33% or 17%, respectively), and BCVA was better than 20/200 (79% or 78%, respectively) or 20/50 or better (26% or 13%, respectively). Eyes with advanced disease (BCVA, ≤20/200) showed the following characteristics: (1) atrophy of the foveal photoreceptor layer with or without associated subretinal fibrosis; (2) an affected area, termed MacTel area, limited to a horizontal diameter not exceeding the distance between the temporal optic disc margin and foveal center, and the vertical diameter not exceeding approximately 0.8 times this distance (exceptions were eyes with large active or inactive neovascular membranes); (3) reduced retinal thickness measures within the MacTel area; and (4) less frequent retinal greying and more frequent hyperpigmentations compared with eyes that have better BCVA.

CONCLUSIONS

Severe vision loss is rare in MacTel and is related to photoreceptor atrophy in most people. Results indicate disease asymmetry with slightly worse vision and more advanced disease manifestation in right eyes. MacTel-related neurodegeneration does not spread beyond the limits of the MacTel area.

Binocular Inhibition of Reading in Macular Telangiectasia Type 2

Purpose

To assess the presence of binocular gain in macular telangiectasia type 2 (MacTel) and its correlation to paracentral scotomas.

Methods

Sixty-eight patients with MacTel were consecutively recruited for a cross-sectional analysis. Best-corrected visual acuity (BCVA), reading acuity, and reading speed were tested monocularly and binocularly. Macular retinal sensitivity was examined with fundus-controlled perimetry (microperimetry). Scotomas were quantified by their size, their depth, and their proximity to the fovea.

Results

Binocular reading speed and acuity were lower than monocular reading speed and acuity in the functionally better eye (142 vs. 159 words per minute and 0.43 vs. 0.28 log reading acuity determination, P < 0.001). Magnitude of binocular inhibition of reading speed was correlated to the degree of interocular functional difference (R2 = 0.61, P < 0.001). This correlation was not found for reading acuity or BCVA (R2 < 0.03). Binocular reading speed was negatively correlated to size of right and left eye scotomas, with bigger effect size for left eye scotomas. The magnitude of binocular inhibition was correlated to size of left eye scotomas, but not of right eye scotomas. When both eyes had similar scotoma characteristics, the right eye was more frequently the better reading eye.

Conclusions

We provide evidence for the presence of binocular inhibition of reading performance in MacTel, likely due to binocular rivalry. This may result from the characteristic paracentral scotomas in noncorresponding retinal fields and, in particular, a disruptive projection of scotomas in reading direction arising from the left eyes. Patients may benefit from occluding one eye while reading.

Estimating Retinal Sensitivity Using Optical Coherence Tomography With Deep-Learning Algorithms in Macular Telangiectasia Type 2

IMPORTANCE

As currently used, microperimetry is a burdensome clinical testing modality for testing retinal sensitivity requiring long testing times and trained technicians.

OBJECTIVE

To create a deep-learning network that could directly estimate function from structure de novo to provide an en face high-resolution map of estimated retinal sensitivity.

DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS

A cross-sectional imaging study using data collected between January 1, 2016, and November 30, 2017, from the Natural History Observation and Registry of macular telangiectasia type 2 (MacTel) evaluated 38 participants with confirmed MacTel from 2 centers.

MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES

Mean absolute error of estimated compared with observed retinal sensitivity. Observed retinal sensitivity was obtained with fundus-controlled perimetry (microperimetry). Estimates of retinal sensitivity were made with deep-learning models that learned on superpositions of high-resolution optical coherence tomography (OCT) scans and microperimetry results. Those predictions were used to create high-density en face sensitivity maps of the macula. Training, validation, and test sets were segregated at the patient level.

RESULTS

A total of 2499 microperimetry sensitivities were mapped onto 1708 OCT B-scans from 63 eyes of 38 patients (mean [SD] age, 74.3 [9.7] years; 15 men [39.5%]). The numbers of examples for our algorithm were 67 899 (103 053 after data augmentation) for training, 1695 for validation, and 1212 for testing. Mean absolute error results were 4.51 dB (95% CI, 4.36-4.65 dB) when using linear regression and 3.66 dB (95% CI, 3.53-3.78 dB) when using the LeNet model. Using a 49.9 million-variable deep-learning model, a mean absolute error of 3.36 dB (95% CI, 3.25-3.48 dB) of retinal sensitivity for validation and test was achieved. Correlation showed a high degree of agreement (Pearson correlation r = 0.78). By paired Wilcoxon rank sum test, our model significantly outperformed these 2 baseline models (P < .001).

CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE

High-resolution en face maps of estimated retinal sensitivities were created in eyes with MacTel. The maps were of unequalled resolution compared with microperimetry and were able to correctly delineate functionally healthy and impaired retina. This model may be useful to monitor structural and functional disease progression and has potential as an objective surrogate outcome measure in investigational trials.

Stereoscopic Vision in Macular Telangiectasia Type 2

PURPOSE

To investigate stereoscopic vision in patients with macular telangiectasia (MacTel) type 2 and correlate paracentral sensitivity loss to reduced stereoscopic function.

METHODS

In a prospective single-center study, 50 patients with MacTel type 2 and 25 age-matched controls were investigated. Stereoscopic function was evaluated with Lang I, Titmus, and TNO tests. Sensitivity of the central 16° was tested using fundus-controlled perimetry (microperimetry). Functional loss was quantified as depth, size, and localization of scotomata.

RESULTS

Both the Titmus and the TNO test revealed significantly reduced stereoscopic vision in patients compared to controls (p < 0.0001 for both). This applied even to patients with only relative or monocular paracentral scotoma. A strong correlation was observed for reduced stereoscopic vision with horizontal scotoma size and with the distance of scotomata from the foveal center.

CONCLUSIONS

The results indicate that stereoscopic vision is impaired early in patients with MacTel type 2. A paracentral sensitivity loss, even if mild and limited to one eye, may considerably interfere with stereoscopic function despite normal visual acuity. Projection of paracentral scotomata within the patient's central visual field plays an important role in stereoscopic vision and should be considered when interpreting stereoscopic test results.

Contrast sensitivity and visual acuity under low light conditions in macular telangiectasia type 2

Background/Aim

Macular pigment optical density (MPOD) is centrally depleted early on in macular telangiectasia type 2 (MacTel). Contrast sensitivity (CS) might be related to MPOD, and thus impaired in early MacTel. The effect of low luminance was assessed on both CS and best corrected visual acuity (BCVA).

Methods

This is a cross-sectional study. Pelli-Robson charts were used for CS testing at 1 m in photopic (110 lux) and mesopic (1 lux) conditions. BCVA was tested with ETDRS charts and low luminance visual acuity (LLVA) with a 2.0 log unit neutral density filter. MPOD was obtained with dual-wavelength autofluorescence.

Results

One hundred and three eyes of 52 patients with MacTel (mean±SD age 62.9±10.2, range 35–77) were compared with 34 healthy eyes of 17 controls (mean±SD age 65.2±7.4, range 53–78). CS was significantly lower in the eyes with MacTel. This impairment was higher in low light conditions (low light contrast sensitivity (LL-CS)). Eyes at the early stages of MacTel had significantly lower LL-CS than controls, but normal (photopic) CS. The results were similar but less pronounced for BCVA/LLVA. Decrease in CS was correlated with loss of MPOD.

Conclusions

Low light conditions have a detrimental effect on visual performance in MacTel. Impaired CS might correlate with MPOD depletion as a pathognomonic finding in MacTel. Functional impairment might precede structural disintegration, indicating dysfunction at the cellular level. The applied tests might be useful as additional functional assessments in clinical routine and as outcome measures in future interventional clinical trials.