Determination of Optimal Coronary Flow for the Preservation of "Donation after Circulatory Death" in Murine Heart Model

Assessment of Machine Perfusion Conditions for the Donation After Circulatory Death Heart Preservation

Background

Donation after circulatory death (DCD) hearts requires machine perfusion preservation, the conditions of which are not well defined.

Methods

To achieve this, rat hearts were procured following a DCD or control beating‐heart donation (CBD) model, and perfused for 60 min with one of three machine perfusion solutions—St. Thomas (ST), University of Wisconsin (UW), or Polyethylene Glycol‐20k (PEG)—at one of two temperatures, 4°C or 15°C. At 15‐min intervals, perfusion pressure was measured as a marker of vascular resistance. Colored microspheres were added to capture the distribution of perfusate into the metabolically active sub‐endocardium, and the eluate was collected for troponin assays. Analyses compared groups using Wilcoxon rank‐sum and ANOVA.

Results

Perfusion pressure was significantly higher for DCD than CBD hearts at 15°C regardless of solutions. The lowest rise in perfusion pressure over time was observed with PEG at 15°C. Except for PEG at 15°C, ST and UW solutions at 4 or 15°C had decreased sub‐endocardial perfusion in DCD hearts. Troponin release from DCD hearts with UW and PEG solutions was comparable to CBD hearts but was significantly higher with ST solution at 15°C.

Conclusions

Optimal preservation conditions for DCD hearts were observed with PEG machine perfusion solution at 15°C.

Oxygenated machine perfusion at room temperature as an alternative for static cold storage in porcine donor hearts

Background

There is a continued interest in ex situ heart perfusion as an alternative strategy for donor heart preservation. We hypothesize that oxygenated machine perfusion of donor hearts at a temperature that avoids both normothermia and deep hypothermia offers adequate and safe preservation.

Methods

Cardioplegia‐arrested porcine donor hearts were randomly assigned to six hours of preservation using cold storage (CS, n = 5) or machine perfusion using an oxygenated acellular perfusate at 21°C (MP, n = 5). Subsequently, all grafts were evaluated using the Langendorff method for 120 min. Metabolic parameters and histology were analyzed. Systolic function was assessed by contractility and elastance. Diastolic function was assessed by lusitropy and stiffness.

Results

For both groups, in vivo baseline and post‐Langendorff biopsies were comparable, as were lactate difference and myocardial oxygen consumption. Injury markers gradually increased and were comparable. Significant weight gain was seen in MP (p = 0.008). Diastolic function was not impaired in MP, and lusitropy was superior from 30 min up to 90 min of reperfusion. Contractility was superior in MP during the first hour of evaluation.

Conclusion

We conclude that the initial functional outcome of MP‐preserved hearts was transiently superior compared to CS, with no histological injury post‐Langendorff. Our machine perfusion strategy could offer feasible and safe storage of hearts prior to transplantation. Future studies are warranted for further optimization.

A Novel Rat Model of Cardiac Donation After Circulatory Death Combined With Normothermic ex situ Heart Perfusion

Background: In heart transplantation, the adoption of hearts from donation after circulatory death (DCD) is considered to be a promising approach to expanding the donor pool. Normothermic ex situ heart perfusion (ESHP) is emerging as a novel preservation strategy for DCD hearts. Therefore, pre-clinical animal models of ESHP are essential to address some key issues before efficient clinical translation. We aim to develop a novel, reproducible, and economical rat model of DCD protocol combined with normothermic ESHP.

Methods: Circulatory death of the anesthetized rats in the DCD group was declared when systolic blood pressure below 30 mmHg or asystole was observed after asphyxiation. Additional 15 min of standoff period was allowed to elapse. After perfusion of cold cardioplegia, the DCD hearts were excised and perfused with allogenic blood-based perfusate at constant flow for 90 min in the normothermic ESHP system. Functional assessment and blood gas analysis were performed every 30 min during ESHP. The alteration of DCD hearts submitted to different durations of ESHP (30, 60, and 90 min) in oxidative stress, apoptosis, tissue energy state, inflammatory response, histopathology, cell swelling, and myocardial infarction during ESHP was evaluated. Rats in the non-DCD group were treated similarly but not exposed to warm ischemia and preserved by the normothermic ESHP system for 90 min.

Results: The DCD hearts showed compromised function at the beginning of ESHP and recovered over time, while non-DCD hearts presented better cardiac function during ESHP. The alteration of DCD hearts in oxidative stress, apoptosis, tissue energy state, histopathological changes, cell swelling, and inflammatory response didn't differ among different durations of ESHP. At the end of 90-min ESHP, DCD, and non-DCD hearts presented similarly in apoptosis, oxidative stress, inflammatory response, myocardial infarction, and histopathological changes. Moreover, the DCD hearts had lower energy storage and more evident cell swelling compared to the non-DCD hearts.

Conclusion: We established a reproducible, clinically relevant, and economical rat model of DCD protocol combined with normothermic ESHP, where the DCD hearts can maintain a stable state during 90-min ESHP.

Comparison of Experimental Rat Models in Donation After Circulatory Death (DCD): in-situ vs. ex-situ Ischemia

Introduction: Donation after circulatory death (DCD) could substantially improve donor heart availability. However, warm ischemia prior to procurement is of particular concern for cardiac graft quality. We describe a rat model of DCD with in-situ ischemia in order to characterize the physiologic changes during the withdrawal period before graft procurement, to determine effects of cardioplegic graft storage, and to evaluate the post-ischemic cardiac recovery in comparison with an established ex-situ ischemia model.

Methods: Following general anesthesia in male, Wistar rats (404 ± 24 g, n = 25), withdrawal of life-sustaining therapy was simulated by diaphragm transection. Hearts underwent no ischemia or 27 min in-situ ischemia and were explanted. Ex situ, hearts were subjected to a cardioplegic flush and 15 min cold storage or not, and 60 min reperfusion. Cardiac recovery was determined and compared to published results of an entirely ex-situ ischemia model (n = 18).

Results: In donors, hearts were subjected to hypoxia and hemodynamic changes, as well as increased levels of circulating catecholamines and free fatty acids prior to circulatory arrest. Post-ischemic contractile recovery was significantly lower in the in-situ ischemia model compared to the ex-situ model, and the addition of cardioplegic storage improved developed pressure-heart rate product, but not cardiac output.

Conclusion: The in-situ model provides insight into conditions to which the heart is exposed before procurement. Compared to an entirely ex-situ ischemia model, hearts of the in-situ model demonstrated a lower post-ischemic functional recovery, potentially due to systemic changes prior to ischemia, which are partially abrogated by cardioplegic graft storage.

Ex vivo evaluation of the biventricular cardiac function for donation after circulatory death model: An experimental study

Few reports on a biventricular working heart model with ex vivo perfusion exist owing to the complexity of establishing a circuit. Hence, we investigated it for donation after circulatory death. The heart in six juvenile pigs (~20 kg) was arrested by asphyxiation. After 30 minutes of global ischemia, the heart was harvested, reperfused with normoxemic blood cardioplegia for 20 minutes, and subsequently perfused with hyperxemic blood. After 70 minutes of controlled reperfusion, the system was switched to the biventricular working mode. Cardiac function was assessed before anoxia and during the biventricular mode. Left and right ventricular functions worsened during the biventricular mode, as compared to those before anoxia (dP/dt_max , 673 ± 120 vs. 283 ± 95 and 251 ± 35 vs. 141 ± 21 mm Hg/s, respectively; P < .001). Systemic (resistance/100 g net heart weight) and pulmonary vascular resistance indexes during the biventricular mode were similar to those before anoxia (829 ± 262 vs. 759 ± 359, P = .707, and 167 ± 57 vs. 158 ± 83 dynes·sec·cm^-5 - l-100-g net heart weight, P = .859, respectively). The biventricular working heart model with ex vivo perfusion was feasible, exhibited stable hemodynamics, and has the potential to be a powerful tool for direct cardiac function assessment.

Cardioprotection via Metabolism for Rat Heart Preservation Using the High-Pressure Gaseous Mixture of Carbon Monoxide and Oxygen

The high-pressure gas (HPG) method with carbon monoxide (CO) and oxygen (O₂) mixture maintains the preserved rat heart function. The metabolites of rat hearts preserved using the HPG method (HPG group) and cold storage (CS) method (CS group) by immersion in a stock solution for 24 h were assessed to confirm CO and O₂ effects. Lactic acid was significantly lower and citric acid was significantly higher in the HPG group than in the CS group. Moreover, adenosine triphosphate (ATP) levels as well as some pentose phosphate pathway (PPP) metabolites and reduced nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide phosphate (NADPH) were significantly higher in the HPG group than in the CS group. Additionally, reduced glutathione (GSH), which protects cells from oxidative stress, was also significantly higher in the HPG group than in the CS group. These results indicated that each gas, CO and O₂, induced the shift from anaerobic to aerobic metabolism, maintaining the energy of ischemic preserved organs, shifting the glucose utilization from glycolysis toward PPP, and reducing oxidative stress. Both CO and O₂ in the HPG method have important effects on the ATP supply and decrease oxidative stress for preventing ischemic injury. The HPG method may be useful for clinical application.

Temperature and flow rate limit the optimal ex-vivo perfusion of the heart - an experimental study

Background

Ex-vivo heart perfusion can be utilized to study a variety of physiologic and molecular pathways in a controlled system outside of the body. It can also be used in clinical settings such as for organ preservation before transplantation. Myocardial oxygen consumption (MVO₂) correlates with energy production in the myocardium and can also be used to determine the balance between the oxygen supply and demand of the perfused heart. This study sought to determine an ex-vivo perfusion rate that matches the metabolic demands of the heart according to different temperatures and solution compositions (with and without the addition of erythrocytes), a flow below which the supply of oxygen is not sufficient to maintain an aerobic state of the perfused heart (“D_CRIT”).

Methods

Under general anesthesia, rat hearts were procured and preserved by perfusing with the University of Wisconsin Belzer machine perfusion system (UW Belzer MPS) solution saturated with 100% O₂. The key elements of this solution include supraphysiological potassium (to stop the heartbeat and reduce the cellular metabolic demand), starch, gluconate and mannitol (to maintain cell wall integrity), glucose (to sustain basal metabolism), and glutathione (to scavenge free radicals). Three groups of rat hearts (n = 7) were randomly allocated to be perfused at 15 °C, 22 °C or 37 °C, at a varying flow index (FI) starting from a minimum of 380 mL/min/100 g to less than 50 mL/min/100 g, decreasing by 50 mL/min/100 g at 10 min intervals while measuring the MVO₂ at each FI. Lactate was measured from coronary sinus samples to determine the onset of tissue hypoxia/anaerobic state.

Results

The D_CRIT at 15 °C was 99.9 ± 4.9 mL/min/100 g; however, at 22 °C and 37 °C we could not reach a D_CRIT. The myocardial oxygen demand could not be met at 22 °C and 37 °C with the maximum FI above 380 mL/min/100 g even when erythrocytes (10% V/V) were added to the solution. At 15 °C, the production of lactate was evident only below the D_CRIT, while at 22 °C lactate production was present at all flow indices.

Conclusions

Determining the D_CRIT for optimal ex-vivo perfusion of the heart is necessary to ensure adequate tissue oxygenation and limit anaerobic state. Temperatures employed above 15 °C limit the efficient ex-vivo perfusion preservation of heart with the UW Belzer MPS solution.

The Commonalities and Differences in Mitochondrial Dysfunction Between ex vivo and in vivo Myocardial Global Ischemia Rat Heart Models: Implications for Donation After Circulatory Death Research

Heart transplantation is the ultimate treatment option for patients with advanced heart failure. Since hearts from donation after brain death (DBD) donors are limited, donation after circulatory death (DCD) donor hearts could be another source for heart transplantation. DCD process involves ischemia-reperfusion (IR) injury. Mitochondrial dysfunction contributes to IR and is well established in the ex vivo (buffer perfused) ischemia animal model. However, DCD hearts undergo in vivo ischemia with a variable "ischemic period." In addition, the DCD hearts are exposed to an intense catecholamine surge that is not seen with ex vivo perfused hearts. Thus, the severity of mitochondrial damage in in vivo ischemia hearts could differ from the ex vivo ischemia hearts even following the same period of ischemia. The aim of our current study is to identify the mitochondrial dysfunction in DCD hearts and propose strategies to protect mitochondria. Adult Sprague Dawley rat hearts underwent in vivo or ex vivo ischemia for 25 min. Subsarcolemmal mitochondria (SSM) and interfibrillar mitochondria (IFM) were isolated from hearts following ischemia. We found that both ex vivo and in vivo ischemia led to decreased oxidative phosphorylation in SSM and IFM compared to time control or DBD hearts. The proportion of damage to SSM and IFM, including proton leak through the inner membrane, was higher with ex vivo ischemia compare to in vivo ischemia. Time control hearts showed a decrease in SSM and IFM function compared to DBD hearts. The calcium retention capacity (CRC) was also decreased in SSM and IFM with ex vivo and in vivo ischemia, indicating that ischemic damage to mitochondria sensitizes mitochondrial permeability transition pores (MPTP). Our study found differential mitochondrial damage between the in vivo ischemia and the ex vivo ischemia setup. Therefore, consideration should be given to the mode of ischemia while evaluating and testing myocardial protective interventions targeting mitochondria to reduce IR injury in hearts.

NLRP3 Inflammasome in Acute Myocardial Infarction

Acute myocardial infarction (AMI) is associated with the induction of a sterile inflammatory response that leads to further injury. The NACHT, leucine-rich repeat, and pyrin domain-containing protein 3 (NLRP3) inflammasome is a macromolecular structure responsible for the inflammatory response to injury or infection. NLRP3 can sense intracellular danger signals, such as ischemia and extracellular or intracellular alarmins during tissue injury. The NLRP3 inflammasome is primed and triggered by locally released damage-associated molecular patterns and amplifies the inflammatory response and cell death through caspase-1 activation. Here, we examine the scientific evidence supporting a role for NLRP3 in AMI and the available strategies to inhibit the effects of the inflammasome. Our focus is on the beneficial effects seen in experimental models of AMI in preclinical animal models and the initial results of clinical trials.

Machine perfusion of circulatory determined death hearts: A scoping review

BACKGROUND

Ex vivo machine perfusion (EVMP) is reported to can successfully be applied for donor heart preservation. To respond to the organ shortage, some centres also accept hearts from marginal donors such as non-heart beating donors (NHBD) or hearts donated after cardiac death (DCD) for heart transplantation (HTx). Clinical as well as preclinical science on EVMP of DCD hearts seems to be promising but the ideal perfusion practice itself appears unclear.

OBJECTIVES

In accordance with the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic reviews and Meta-Analyses extension for Scoping Reviews (PRISMA), this systematic review scopes all EVMP techniques for human and animal DCD heart preservation and addresses three specific questions, which refer to (a) the perfusion solutions, (b) the perfusion parameters and respective target values and (c) if possible, a direct comparison between cold static storage (CSS) and EVMP.

RESULTS

Search results predominantly consisted of animal studies. Either perfusion with a crystalloid or blood-based solution, each with cardioplegic or non-cardioplegic properties was used. Some perfusates were supplemented with specific pharmacological medication to block pathophysiological pathways, which are involved in ischemia/reperfusion injury or edema formation. Besides normothermic EVMP with oxygenated blood, a wide range of temperature was applied in all approaches, with the lowest temperature at 4 °C. Pressure controlled anterograde Langendorff perfusion was applied mostly. If investigated, crystalloid machine perfusion was presented superior to CSS.

CONCLUSIONS

Only blood based EVMP was introduced into clinical practice. More research, clinical as well as preclinical, is needed to develop the ideal EVMP technique, in terms of blood or crystalloid perfusion.

Heart Transplantation With Donation After Circulatory Death

Heart transplantation remains the preferred option for improving quality of life and survival for patients suffering from end-stage heart failure. Unfortunately, insufficient supply of cardiac grafts has become an obstacle. Increasing organ availability with donation after circulatory death (DCD) may be a promising option to overcome the organ shortage. Unlike conventional donation after brain death, DCD organs undergo a period of warm, global ischemia between circulatory arrest and graft procurement, which raises concerns for graft quality. Nonetheless, the potential of DCD heart transplantation is being reconsidered, after reports of more than 70 cases in Australia and the United Kingdom over the past 3 years. Ensuring optimal patient outcomes and generalized adoption of DCD in heart transplantation, however, requires further development of clinical protocols, which in turn require a better understanding of cardiac ischemia-reperfusion injury and the various possibilities to limit its adverse effects. Thus, we aim to provide an overview of the knowledge obtained with preclinical studies in animal models of DCD heart transplantation, to facilitate and promote the most effective and efficient advancement in preclinical research. A literature search of the PubMed database was performed to identify all relevant preclinical studies in DCD heart transplantation. Specific aspects relevant for DCD heart transplantation were analyzed, including animal models, graft procurement and storage conditions, cardioprotective approaches, and graft evaluation strategies. Several potential therapeutic strategies for optimizing graft quality are identified, and recommendations for further preclinical research are provided.

Heart transplantation from donation after circulatory death donors: Present and future

The first successful human heart transplantation was reported on 3 December 1967, by Christiaan Barnard in South Africa. Since then this life-saving procedure has been performed in over 120 000 patients. A limitation to the performance of this procedure is the availability of donor hearts with as many as 20% of patients dying before a donor's heart is available for transplant. Today, hearts for transplantation are procured from individuals experiencing donation after brain death (DBD). Interestingly, this, however, was not always the case as the first heart transplants occurred after circulatory death. Revisiting the availability of hearts for transplant from those experiencing donation after circulatory death (DCD) could further expand the number of hearts suitable for transplantation. There are several considerations pertinent to transplanting hearts from those undergoing circulatory death. In this review, we summarize the main distinctions between DBD and DCD heart donation and discuss the research relevant to increasing the number of hearts available for transplantation by including individual's hearts that experience circulatory death.