Measurement of tissue factor-positive extracellular vesicles in plasma: strengths and weaknesses of current methods

Comparison of assays measuring extracellular vesicle tissue factor in plasma samples: communication from the ISTH SSC Subcommittee on Vascular Biology

BACKGROUND

Scientific and clinical interest in extracellular vesicles (EVs) is growing. EVs that expose tissue factor (TF) bind factor VII/VIIa and can trigger coagulation. Highly procoagulant TF-exposing EVs are detectable in the circulation in various diseases, such as sepsis, COVID-19, or cancer. Many in-house and commercially available assays have been developed to measure EV-TF activity and antigen, but only a few studies have compared some of these assays.

OBJECTIVES

The International Society on Thrombosis and Haemostasis Scientific and Standardization Committee Subcommittee on Vascular Biology initiated a multicenter study to compare the sensitivity, specificity, and reproducibility of these assays.

METHODS

Platelet-depleted plasma samples were prepared from blood of healthy donors. The plasma samples were spiked either with EVs from human milk or EVs from TF-positive and TF-negative cell lines. Plasma was also prepared from whole human blood with or without lipopolysaccharide stimulation. Twenty-one laboratories measured EV-TF activity and antigen in the prepared samples using their own assays representing 18 functional and 9 antigenic assays.

RESULTS

There was a large variability in the absolute values for the different EV-TF activity and antigen assays. Activity assays had higher specificity and sensitivity compared with antigen assays. In addition, there was a large intra-assay and interassay variability. Functional assays that used a blocking anti-TF antibody or immunocapture were the most specific and sensitive. Activity assays that used immunocapture had a lower coefficient of variation compared with assays that isolated EVs by high-speed centrifugation.

CONCLUSION

Based on this multicenter study, we recommend measuring EV-TF using a functional assay in the presence of an anti-TF antibody.

Activated Factor VII-Antithrombin Complex, a Biomarker of Tissue Factor-Related Pathways in Different Clinical Settings: A Narrative Review from Cardiovascular Diseases to Cancer

Tissue factor (TF) is a transmembrane glycoprotein that represents the fundamental physiological initiator of the coagulation cascade through its interaction with factor VII. TF belongs to the cytokine receptor protein superfamily and contributes to the transduction of cellular signaling. Therefore, TF-related pathways are involved in multiple pathophysiological processes, not only in coagulation/thrombosis but in a wider mechanisms' panorama, ranging from infective to neoplastic diseases. Consistently, the measurement of TF activity could have a diagnostic and/or prognostic meaning in different clinical conditions. However, the transmembrane localization, the expression on different cellular types and circulating extracellular vesicles, and the different conformations (encrypted and decrypted) and variants (such as the soluble alternatively spliced TF) hamper TF assessment in clinical practice. The activated factor VII-antithrombin (FVIIa-AT) complex is proposed as an indirect biomarker of the TF-FVIIa interaction and, consequently, of the functionally active TF expression. In this narrative review, we evaluate the clinical studies investigating the role of plasma concentration of FVIIa-AT in health and disease. Although without conclusive data, high FVIIa-AT concentrations predict the worst clinical outcomes in different pathologic conditions, such as cardiovascular disease and cancer, thereby suggesting that overactivation of TF-related pathways may play an unfavorable role in various clinical settings.

Tissue factor pathway-related biomarkers in liver cancer: activated factor VII-antithrombin complex and tissue factor mRNA levels are associated with mortality

Background

Tissue factor (TF), the main initiator of the coagulation cascade, plays a role in cancer progression and prognosis. Activated factor VII-antithrombin complex (FVIIa-AT) is considered an indirect marker of TF exposure by reflecting TF-FVIIa interaction.

Objectives

To assess the link between FVIIa-AT plasma levels, TF messenger RNA (mRNA) expression, and survival in cancer.

Methods

TF pathway-related coagulation biomarkers were assessed in 136 patients with cancer (52 with hepatocellular carcinoma, 41 with cholangiocarcinoma, and 43 with colon cancer) undergoing surgical intervention with curative intent. TF mRNA expression analysis in neoplastic vs nonneoplastic liver tissues was evaluated in a subgroup of 91 patients with primary liver cancer.

Results

FVIIa-AT levels were higher in patients with cancer than in 136 sex- and age-matched cancer-free controls. In patients with cancer, high levels of FVIIa-AT and total TF pathway inhibitor were associated with an increased mortality risk after adjustment for confounders, but only FVIIa-AT remained a predictor of mortality by including both FVIIa-AT and total TF pathway inhibitor in Cox regression (hazard ratio, 2.80; 95% CI, 1.23-6.39; the highest vs the lowest quartile). This association remained significant even after adjustment for extracellular vesicle-associated TF-dependent procoagulant activity. In the subgroup of patients with primary liver cancer, patients with high TF mRNA levels had an increased mortality risk compared with that for those with low TF mRNA levels (hazard ratio, 1.92; 95% CI, 1.03-3.57), and there was a consistent correlation among high FVIIa-AT levels, high TF mRNA levels, and increased risk of mortality.

Conclusion

High FVIIa-AT levels may allow the identification of patients with cancer involving high TF expression and predict a higher mortality risk in liver cancer.

Evaluation of the ability of commercial enzyme-linked immunosorbent assays to measure mouse tissue factor

Background

Tissue factor (TF) is the primary cellular initiator of the blood coagulation cascade. Increased levels of TF expression on circulating monocytes or on extracellular vesicles (EVs) are associated with thrombosis in a variety of diseases, including sepsis and COVID-19.

Objectives

Here, we aimed to evaluate the ability of 4 commercial TF enzyme-linked immunosorbent assays (ELISAs) to measure mouse TF in cells and plasma.

Methods

We used 4 commercial mouse TF ELISAs (SimpleStep, R&D Systems, MyBioSource [sandwich], and MyBioSource [competitive]). We used recombinant mouse TF (rmTF; 16-1000 pg/mL), cell lysates from a TF-expressing mouse pancreatic cancer cell line, and plasma and EVs isolated from plasma from mice injected with vehicle or bacterial lipopolysaccharide (LPS).

Results

The 2 MyBioSource kits failed to detect rmTF or TF in cell lysates. The SimpleStep and R&D kits detected rmTF in buffer or spiked into plasma in a concentration-dependent manner. These kits also detected TF in cell lysates from a mouse pancreatic cancer cell line. A higher signal was observed with the SimpleStep kit compared to the R&D kit. However, the SimpleStep and R&D kits failed to detect TF in plasma or EVs from LPS-treated mice.

Conclusion

Our results indicate that some commercial ELISAs can be used to measure mouse TF levels in cell lysates but they cannot detect TF in plasma or EVs from endotoxemic mice.

Monocyte Tissue Factor Expression: Lipopolysaccharide Induction and Roles in Pathological Activation of Coagulation

The coagulation system is a part of the mammalian host defense system. Pathogens and pathogen components, such as bacterial lipopolysaccharide (LPS), induce tissue factor (TF) expression in circulating monocytes that then activates the coagulation protease cascade. Formation of a clot limits dissemination of pathogens, enhances the recruitment of immune cells, and facilitates killing of pathogens. However, excessive activation of coagulation can lead to thrombosis. Here, we review studies on the mechanism of LPS induction of TF expression in monocytes and its contribution to thrombosis and disseminated intravascular coagulation. Binding of LPS to Toll-like receptor 4 on monocytes induces a transient expression of TF that involves activation of intracellular signaling pathways and binding of various transcription factors, such as c-rel/p65 and c-Fos/c-Jun, to the TF promoter. Inhibition of TF in endotoxemia and sepsis models reduces activation of coagulation and improves survival. Studies with endotoxemic mice showed that hematopoietic cells and myeloid cells play major roles in the activation of coagulation. Monocyte TF expression is also increased after surgery. Activated monocytes release TF-positive extracellular vesicles (EVs) and levels of circulating TF-positive EVs are increased in endotoxemic mice and in patients with sepsis. More recently, it was shown that inflammasomes contribute to the induction of TF expression and activation of coagulation in endotoxemic mice. Taken together, these studies indicate that monocyte TF plays a major role in activation of coagulation. Selective inhibition of monocyte TF expression may reduce pathologic activation of coagulation in sepsis and other diseases without affecting hemostasis.

A sensitive tissue factor activity assay determined by an optimized thrombin generation method

BACKGROUND

Tissue factor (TF) is the principal activator of the coagulation system, but an increased concentration in the blood in cancer and inflammatory diseases has been suggested to play a role increasing the risk of venous thromboembolism. However, measurement of the TF concentration is difficult, and quantitation of activity is the most valid estimation. The objective of this study was to establish a sensitive method to measure TF activity based on thrombin generation.

METHODS

The assay is based on thrombin generation (TG) measured on the Calibrated Automated Thrombogram (CAT). Various low concentrations of TF were prepared from reagents containing 1 pM TF and 4 μM phospholipid (PPL), and no TF and 4 μM PPL, and a calibration curve was produced from Lagtime vs TF concentration. TF in blood samples was measured after isolation and resuspension of extracellular vesicles (EVs) in a standard plasma from which EVs had been removed. The same standard plasma was used for the calibrators.

RESULTS

Contact activation of the coagulation system was avoided using CTI plasma samples in Monovette tubes. EVs contain procoagulant phospholipids but addition of PPL only reduced lagtime slightly at very low concentrations of TF resulting in overestimation to a lesser extent at 10 fM but no interference at 30 fM or higher. Addition of EVs to the TG analysis induced a small unspecific TF-independent activity (i.e., an activity not inhibited by antibodies against TF) which also may result in a smaller error in estimation of TF activity at very low levels but the effect was negligible at higher concentrations. It was possible to measure TF activity in healthy controls which was found to be 1-6 fM (EVs were concentrated, i.e. solubilized in a lower volume than the original volume plasma). Coefficient of variation (CV) was below 20% at the low level, and below 10% at a level around 100 fM TF. However, the step with isolation of EVs have a higher inherent CV.

CONCLUSION

A sensitive and rather precise one-stage TG-based method to measure TF activity has been established.

Reprogramming the immunosuppressive tumor microenvironment: exploiting angiogenesis and thrombosis to enhance immunotherapy

This review focuses on the immunosuppressive effects of tumor angiogenesis and coagulation on the tumor microenvironment (TME). We summarize previous research efforts leveraging these observations and targeting these processes to enhance immunotherapy outcomes. Clinical trials have documented improved outcomes when combining anti-angiogenic agents and immunotherapy. However, their overall survival benefit over conventional therapy remains limited and certain tumors exhibit poor response to anti-angiogenic therapy. Additionally, whilst preclinical studies have shown several components of the tumor coagulome to curb effective anti-tumor immune responses, the clinical studies reporting combinations of anticoagulants with immunotherapies have demonstrated variable treatment outcomes. By reviewing the current state of the literature on this topic, we address the key questions and future directions in the field, the answers of which are crucial for developing effective strategies to reprogram the TME in order to further the field of cancer immunotherapy.

Evaluation of four commercial ELISAs to measure tissue factor in human plasma

Background

Under pathological conditions, tissue factor (TF)-positive extracellular vesicles (EVs) are released into the circulation and activate coagulation. Therefore, it is important to identify methods that accurately quantitate levels of TF in plasma. Enzyme-linked immunosorbent assays (ELISAs) are a fast and simple method to quantitate levels of proteins. However, there are several specific challenges with measuring TF antigen in plasma including its low concentration and the complexity of plasma.

Objectives

We aimed to evaluate the ability of 4 commercial ELISAs to measure TF in human plasma.

Methods

We determined the ability of 4 commercial ELISAs (Imubind, Quantikine, Human SimpleStep, and CD142 Human) to detect recombinant human TF (Innovin) (12.5-100 pg/mL), TF-positive EVs isolated from the culture supernatant from a human pancreatic cancer cell line (57 pg/mL), TF in plasma containing low levels of EV TF activity (1.2-2.6 pg/mL) from lipopolysaccharide-stimulated whole blood, and plasma containing high levels of EV TF activity (151-696 pg/mL) from patients with acute leukemia.

Results

The CD142 Human ELISA could not detect recombinant TF. Imubind and Quantikine but not Human SimpleStep detected recombinant TF spiked into plasma and TF-positive EVs isolated from the culture supernatant of a human pancreatic cancer cell line. Quantikine and Imubind could not detect low levels of TF in plasma from lipopolysaccharide-stimulated whole blood. However, Quantikine but not Imubind detected TF in plasma from acute leukemia patients with high levels of EV TF activity.

Conclusion

Our results indicate that commercial ELISAs have different abilities to detect TF. Quantikine and Imubind could not detect low levels of TF in plasma, but Quantikine detected TF in plasma with high levels of TF.

Cardiovascular Disease and Thrombosis in HIV Infection

HIV infection has transitioned from an acute, fatal disease to a chronic one managed by antiretroviral therapy. Thus, the aging population of people living with HIV (PLWH) continues to expand. HIV infection results in a dysregulated immune system, wherein CD4+ T cells are depleted, particularly in the gastrointestinal tract, disrupting the gut epithelial barrier. Long-term HIV infection is associated with chronic inflammation through potentially direct mechanisms caused by viral replication or exposure to viral proteins and indirect mechanisms resulting from increased translocation of microbial products from the intestine or exposure to antiretroviral therapy. Chronic inflammation (as marked by IL [interleukin]-6 and CRP [C-reactive protein]) in PLWH promotes endothelial cell dysfunction and atherosclerosis. PLWH show significantly increased rates of cardiovascular disease, such as myocardial infarction (risk ratio, 1.79 [95% CI, 1.54-2.08]) and stroke (risk ratio, 2.56 [95% CI, 1.43-4.61]). In addition, PLWH have increased levels of the coagulation biomarker D-dimer and have a two to ten-fold increased risk of venous thromboembolism compared with the general population. Several small clinical trials analyzed the effect of different antithrombotic agents on platelet activation, coagulation, inflammation, and immune cell activation. Although some markers for coagulation were reduced, most agents failed to reduce inflammatory markers in PLWH. More studies are needed to understand the underlying mechanisms driving inflammation in PLWH to create better therapies for lowering chronic inflammation in PLWH. Such therapies can potentially reduce atherosclerosis, cardiovascular disease, and thrombosis rates in PLWH and thus overall mortality in this population.