Duty hours and home call: the experience of plastic surgery residents and fellows

Work Where You Live or Live Where You Work? Resident Work and Sleep Patterns While on "Home Call"

Background

Unlike in-house call, the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education (ACGME) does not require a postcall day for "home call" shifts. Despite this, we hypothesize that on-call residents are still in the hospital for the majority of their shift despite having the luxury of home call and, thus, are not protected by ACGME postcall duty hour regulations.

Methods

A prospective single center survey study was conducted by surveying junior and senior residents who completed overnight call shifts from January 2023 to April 2023 at one of the busiest level 1 trauma centers in the United States. Data include number of trips into the hospital, hours spent in the hospital, and hours of sleep.

Results

Response rate was 195 of 200 (97.5%) total call shifts from 7 pm to 7 am the next morning. Junior residents reported an average of 3.25, 3.92, and 0.73 hours of sleep when on hand call, face call, and triple call (hand + face + general), respectively. Senior residents reported an average of 4.18 and 4.75 hours of sleep for hand and face call, respectively.

Conclusions

Hours of sleep when taking home call varies widely based on type of call. Junior residents reported significantly decreased sleep and more time in the hospital when taking hand, face, and triple call compared with general call alone. Senior residents reported that both hand and face call result in significantly decreased hours of sleep compared with general call alone. These results highlight the need to discuss ACGME protection for residents taking home call.

Evaluating the Impact of ACGME Resident Duty Hour Restrictions on Patient Outcomes for Bilateral Breast Reductions

The Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education (ACGME) implemented duty-hour restrictions limiting residents to 80 hours per week in 2003 and further extended restrictions in 2011 to improve resident and patient well-being. Numerous studies have examined the effects of these restrictions on patient outcomes with inconclusive results. Few efforts have been made to examine the impact of this reform on the safety of common plastic surgery procedures. This study seeks to assess the influence of ACGME duty-hour restrictions on patient outcomes, using bilateral breast reduction mammoplasty as a marker for resident involvement and operative autonomy.

Methods

Bilateral breast reductions performed in the 3 years before and after each reform were collected from the National Inpatient Sample database: pre-duty hours (2000-2002), duty hours (2006-2008), and extended duty hours (2012-2014). Multivariable logistic regression models were constructed to investigate the association between ACGME duty hour restrictions on medical and surgical complications.

Results

Overall, 19,423 bilateral breast reductions were identified. Medical and surgical complication rates in these patients increased with each successive iteration of duty hour restrictions (P < 0.001). The 2003 duty-hour restriction independently associated with increased surgical (OR = 1.51, P < 0.001) and medical complications (OR = 1.85, P < 0.001). The 2011 extended duty-hour restriction was independently associated with increased surgical complications (OR = 1.39, P < 0.001).

Conclusions

ACGME duty-hour restrictions do not seem associated with better patient outcomes for bilateral breast reduction although there are multiple factors involved. These considerations and consequences should be considered in decisions that affect resident quality of life, education, and patient safety.

Analysis of Plastic Surgery Consultations in a High-Volume Paediatric Emergency Department: A Quality Improvement Initiative

Introduction

Consult services influence emergency department (ED) workflow. Prolonged ED length of stay (LOS) correlates with ED overcrowding and as a consequence decreased quality of care and satisfaction of health team professionals. To improve management of paediatric ED patients requiring plastic and reconstructive surgery (PRS) expertise, current processes were analyzed.

Methods

Patient characteristics and metrics of PRS consultations in our paediatric ED were collected over a 3-month period. Data analysis was followed by feedback education intervention to ED and PRS staff. Data collection was then resumed and results were compared to the pre-intervention period.

Results

One hundred ninety-eight PRS consultations were reviewed, mean patient age was 6.3 years. Most common (52%) diagnoses were burns and hand trauma; 81% of PRS referrals were deemed appropriate; 25% of PRS consults were requested after hour with no differences in patient characteristics compared to regular hours; 60% of consultations involved interventions in the ED. Time between ED registration and PRS consultation request (116.5 minutes), quality of procedural sedation (52% rated inadequate), and overall ED LOS (289.2 minutes) were identified as main areas of concern and addressed during feedback education intervention. Emergency department LOS and quality of sedation did not improve in the post-intervention period.

Conclusion

The study provides detailed insights in the characteristics of PRS consultation in the paediatric ED population. Despite high referral appropriateness and education feedback intervention, significant inefficiencies were identified that call for further collaborative efforts to optimize quality of care for paediatric ED patients and improve satisfaction of involved healthcare professionals.

The utility and benefit of a newly established postgraduate training course in surgical exposures for orthopedic and trauma surgery

INTRODUCTION

Limited data exist on specialty surgical cadaver courses for graduates, their skill gain, and whether the course contents are transferable to other surgical disciplines.

AIM

We present the details on the establishment of a specialist trauma and orthopedics approach course, and explore educational and career outcomes from this program.

METHODS

A 3-day surgical approach course was developed, including a dissection program utilizing Thiel embalmed cadavers. The course was accredited with the local orthopedics association. Participants were assessed by survey on acquired surgical knowledge, skill, decision-making, confidence, and on self-development and effect on career.

RESULTS

Thirty-one participants successfully completed the courses over 3 years. Increases in surgical skill, knowledge, surgical decision-making and confidence were reported. Skills and confidence also positively impacted on other surgical disciplines. Courses rated highly for learning outcomes; comments highlighted usefulness, applicability, and practicing opportunities, while also impacting positively on career opportunities.

CONCLUSION

Surgical courses have shown being useful for the acquisition of skills, knowledge, confidence and decision-making, with a positive impact on confidence and decision-making. This information is relevant to future participants, benefactors, surgical programs, and tertiary institutions who want to establish specialist surgical courses.

Urology residents on call: Investigating the workload and relevance of calls

INTRODUCTION

On-call medical services assumed by residents represent many hours of hard work and no studies have documented what it really entails. As part of an effort to improve our on-call system, we examined phone calls received by residents on call. Our objectives were to evaluate the characteristics of phone calls received by residents on call (who, when, why, need to go to the hospital) and to determine residents' perception of these calls. We also looked into implementing strategies to reduce unnecessary calls.

METHODS

We prospectively collected information about calls using a standardized reporting form with the participation of all residents (10) from a single urology program over two periods of four weeks from November 2014 to March 2015. Residents answered pre- and post-collecting period questionnaires.

RESULTS

A total of 460 calls were recorded on 97 on-call days in two on-call lists. There was a mean of 3.5 (median 3, range 0-12) calls per weeknight and 7.7 (median 6, range 0-23) calls per weekend full day. Nintey-three calls (20%) led to the need for bedside evaluation and many of these were for new consultations (49%). The majority of calls originated from the clinical in-patient ward (49%) and emergency room (29%), and nurses (66%) and doctors (23%) most commonly initiated the calls. Calls between 11:00 pm and 8:00 am represented 13% of all calls. Most of the calls (77%) were perceived as relevant or very relevant. Most residents reported at least 80% of calls.

CONCLUSIONS

Although likely representing an underestimate of the reality, we provide a first effort in documenting the call burden of Canadian urology residents.

Canadian Plastic Surgery Resident Work Hour Restrictions: Practices and Perceptions of Residents and Program Directors

Background

The impact of resident work hour restrictions on training and patient care remains a highly controversial topic, and to date, there lacks a formal assessment as it pertains to Canadian plastic surgery residents.

Objective

To characterize the work hour profile of Canadian plastic surgery residents and assess the perspectives of residents and program directors regarding work hour restrictions related to surgical competency, resident wellness, and patient safety.

Methods

An anonymous online survey developed by the authors was sent to all Canadian plastic surgery residents and program directors. Basic summary statistics were calculated.

Results

Eighty (53%) residents and 10 (77%) program directors responded. Residents reported working an average of 73 hours in hospital per week with 8 call shifts per month and sleep 4.7 hours/night while on call. Most residents (88%) reported averaging 0 post-call days off per month and 61% will work post-call without any sleep. The majority want the option of working post-call (63%) and oppose an 80-hour weekly maximum (77%). Surgical and medical errors attributed to post-call fatigue were self-reported by 26% and 49% of residents, respectively. Residents and program directors expressed concern about the ability to master surgical skills without working post-call.

Conclusions

The majority of respondents oppose duty hour restrictions. The reason is likely multifactorial, including the desire of residents to meet perceived expectations and to master their surgical skills while supervised. If duty hour restrictions are aggressively implemented, many respondents feel that an increased duration of training may be necessary.

Return of the cadaver: Key role of anatomic dissection for plastic surgery resident training

Successful Plastic Surgery Residency training is subjected to evolving society pressure of lower hourly work weeks imposed by external committees, labor laws, and increased public awareness of patient care quality. Although innovative measures for simulation training of surgery are appearing, there is also the realization that basic anatomy training should be re-enforced and cadaver dissection is of utmost importance for surgical techniques.In the development of new technology for implantable neurostimulatory electrodes for the management of phantom limb pain in amputee patients, a design of a cadaveric model has been developed with detailed steps for innovative transfascicular insertion of electrodes. Overall design for electrode and cable implantation transcutaneous was established and an operating protocol devised.Microsurgery of the nerves of the upper extremities for interfascicular electrode implantation is described for the first time. Design of electrode implantation in cadaver specimens was adapted with a trocar delivery of cables and electrodes transcutaneous and stabilization of the electrode by suturing along the nerve. In addition, the overall operating arena environment with specific positions of the multidisciplinary team necessary for implantable electrodes was elaborated to assure optimal operating conditions and procedures during the organization of a first-in-man implantation study.Overall importance of plastic surgery training for new and highly technical procedures is of importance and particularly there is a real need to continue actual cadaveric training due to patient variability for nerve anatomic structures.

Effect of Home-Call on Otolaryngology Resident Education: A Pilot Study

OBJECTIVE

To inform institutional policies regarding call encounters through an evaluation of the effect of home-call on academic experience and fatigue among surgical residents. This study conducted an assessment of the nature of resident call encounters premidnight and postmidnight and a comparative analysis of sleep deprivation and efficiency in residents during home-call and off call.

DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS

All Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery residents (n = 9) at single Canadian institution were asked to establish the time and nature of call encounters during home-call. Residents completed the Stanford Sleepiness Scale precall and postcall to measure sleepiness and wore an Actigraph device to measure sleep efficiency to establish fatigue in the setting of home-call as compared with residents off call. Home-call and off call patterns were studied using a random computer-generated selection of days for participants in both study groups. Analysis was conducted from December 1, 2013 to December 30, 2014.

RESULTS

Residents received on average 7 pages per night, of which 78.5% of pages were for nonurgent issues. On an average, change in sleep deprivation scores postcall was 3.0 points higher (95% CI: 2.48-3.57, p < 0.0001) in residents who were qualified for a postcall day compared with residents who did not qualify for a postcall day and residents off call according to the Stanford Sleepiness Scale. Postcall sleep deprivation was significantly associated with number of encounters managed after midnight, regardless of management through telephone or in-hospital (p = 0.01). The Actigraph device identified a significant decrease in sleep efficiency in residents who were qualified for a postcall day compared with residents off call (mean = -31.1; 95% CI: -38.9, -23.4; p < 0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

This is the first study to evaluate surgical residents' home-call experience. We identified a high proportion of nonurgent encounters that residents managed on call and increased postcall fatigue associated with postmidnight telephone encounters. This study highlights the detrimental effects of frequent sleep interruptions because of encounters on call and suggests the need for institutional guidelines to help minimize these interruptions.