Making Sense of Stem Cells and Fat Grafting in Plastic Surgery: The Hype, Evidence, and Evolving U.S. Food and Drug Administration Regulations

Micronized cellular adipose matrix purified with a bladed connector contains abundant functional adipose stem cells

INTRODUCTION

A specialized device equipped with a sharp blade filter has been developed to enable more efficient purification of a micronized cellular adipose matrix (MCAM) containing stem cells. The aim of this study is to compare the characteristics and functions of the population of stromal cells (mSVF) and cultured cells (mASCs) purified using this device with those of cSVF and cASCs obtained through conventional enzymatic purification.

METHODS

Cell viability, proliferation capacity and yield were assessed. Characterization of stem cell potency was performed by analyzing cell surface markers including CD34, a marker of activated adipose-derived stem cells. The trilineage differentiation potential was evaluated using RT-PCR and histology.

RESULTS

The yield rate of mSVF obtained from MCAM was significantly higher than that with the conventional method, although use of the device resulted in a slight decrease in cell viability. After culture, mASCs exhibited a remarkable clonogenic potential and significantly higher cell proliferation potential than cASCs. The mASCs also displayed a distinct pattern of ASC cell surface markers, increased expression of genes related to CD34, high pluripotency, and a high trilineage differentiation ability.

CONCLUSION

The specialized device enhanced the yield of SVF and produced cells with high proliferation rates and characteristics that include expression of stem cell markers.

Non-enzymatic methods for isolation of stromal vascular fraction and adipose-derived stem cells: A systematic review

BACKGROUND

Adipose-derived stem cells (ADSCs) and the stromal vascular fraction (SVF) have garnered substantial interest in regenerative medicine due to their potential to treat a wide range of conditions. Traditional enzymatic methods for isolating these cells face challenges such as high costs, lengthy processing time, and regu-latory complexities.

AIM

This systematic review aimed to assess the efficacy and practicality of non-enzymatic, mechanical methods for isolating SVF and ADSCs, comparing these to conventional enzymatic approaches.

METHODS

Following the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses guidelines, a comprehensive literature search was conducted across multiple databases. Studies were selected based on inclusion criteria focused on non-enzymatic isolation methods for SVF and ADSCs from adipose tissue. The risk of bias was assessed, and a qualitative synthesis of findings was performed due to the methodological heterogeneity of the included studies.

RESULTS

Nineteen studies met the inclusion criteria, highlighting various mechanical techniques such as centrifugation, vortexing, and ultrasonic cavitation. The review identified significant variability in cell yield and viability, and the integrity of isolated cells across different non-enzymatic methods compared to enzymatic procedures. Despite some advantages of mechanical methods, including reduced processing time and avoidance of enzymatic reagents, the evidence suggests a need for optimization to match the cell quality and therapeutic efficacy achievable with enzymatic isolation.

CONCLUSION

Non-enzymatic, mechanical methods offer a promising alternative to enzymatic isolation of SVF and ADSCs, potentially simplifying the isolation process and reducing regulatory hurdles. However, further research is necessary to standardize these techniques and ensure consistent, high-quality cell yields for clinical applications. The development of efficient, safe, and reproducible non-enzymatic isolation methods could significantly advance the field of regenerative medicine.

Intraoperative Intradermal Application of Stromal Vascular Fraction into the Abdominal Suture Line: Histological Analysis of Abdominal Scar Tissue

BACKGROUND

Stem cell therapy is a promising new approach to wound healing. Stromal vascular fraction is a heterogeneous collection of cells, including adipose-derived stem cells, which are traditionally isolated using a manual collagenase-based technique. To our knowledge, this is the first human study that histologically assesses the potential of intraoperative intradermal injection of stromal vascular fraction on skin regeneration.

METHODS

In this controlled study, 20 patients undergoing deep inferior epigastric perforator flap breast reconstruction and bilateral flank liposuction were included. Stromal vascular fraction was injected intradermally into one side of the abdominal suture line, while the other side served as a control. Outcome measures included analysis of stromal vascular fraction by flow cytometry, histological analysis of scar tissue, and scar photography.

RESULTS

Cell yield for application and cell viability were 55.9 ± 28.5 × 10⁶ and 75.1% ± 14.5%, respectively. Age and body mass index were positively correlated with the number of cells for application and adipose-derived stem cells. Mean vascular density, elastic fiber content, collagen maturity (scar index), epidermal thickness, and number of rete ridges all showed higher values on the treated side. Furthermore, the injected number of adipose-derived stem cells and pericytes positively correlated with vascular density.

CONCLUSIONS

It is safe to speculate that intradermal stromal vascular fraction injection at the beginning of the healing process increases vascular density, collagen maturity and organization, elastic fiber content, epidermal thickness, epidermal-dermal anchoring of the scarring skin and is therefore responsible for improved skin regeneration. It is a viable and safe method that can be used as an adjunctive treatment in plastic surgery procedures where suboptimal wound healing is anticipated.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE IV

This journal requires that authors assign a level of evidence to each article. For a full description of these Evidence-Based Medicine ratings, please refer to the Table of Contents or the online Instructions to Authors www.springer.com/00266 .

Viewing stromal vascular fraction de novo vessel formation and association with host microvasculature using the rat mesentery culture model

OBJECTIVE

The objective of the study is to demonstrate the innovation and utility of mesenteric tissue culture for discovering the microvascular growth dynamics associated with adipose-derived stromal vascular fraction (SVF) transplantation. Understanding how SVF cells contribute to de novo vessel growth (i.e., neovascularization) and host network angiogenesis motivates the need to make observations at single-cell and network levels within a tissue.

METHODS

Stromal vascular fraction was isolated from the inguinal adipose of adult male Wistar rats, labeled with DiI, and seeded onto adult Wistar rat mesentery tissues. Tissues were then cultured in MEM + 10% FBS for 3 days and labeled for BSI-lectin to identify vessels. Alternatively, SVF and tissues from green fluorescent-positive (GFP) Sprague Dawley rats were used to track SVF derived versus host vasculature.

RESULTS

Stromal vascular fraction-treated tissues displayed a dramatically increased vascularized area compared to untreated tissues. DiI and GFP+ tracking of SVF identified neovascularization involving initial segment formation, radial outgrowth from central hub-like structures, and connection of segments. Neovascularization was also supported by the formation of segments in previously avascular areas. New segments characteristic of SVF neovessels contained endothelial cells and pericytes. Additionally, a subset of SVF cells displayed the ability to associate with host vessels and the presence of SVF increased host network angiogenesis.

CONCLUSIONS

The results showcase the use of the rat mesentery culture model as a novel tool for elucidating SVF cell transplant dynamics and highlight the impact of model selection for visualization.

Cell-Assisted Lipotransfer in Breast Augmentation Surgery: Clinical Outcomes and Considerations for Future Research

Autologous fat transfer is a widely used surgical technique, chosen by numerous plastic surgeons for breast augmentation surgery. This technique is based on three steps: 1. harvesting of the lipoaspirate from the patient, 2. centrifugation and removal of the top, oily, layer, and 3. implantation in the patient’s breast(s). It has been associated with various complications, including post-surgical fat resorption, as measured quantitatively with MRI, CT, and other 3D-quantification systems.

Adipose-derived stem cells have been explored as a means of addressing fat resorption. They can be separated from the lipoaspirate following centrifugation, and enzymatically purified from unwanted debris, with collagenase, forming the stromal vascular fraction. The stromal vascular fraction is then recombined with the graft volume prior to implantation. This novel technique, referred to as “cell-assisted lipotransfer”, has shown promising results in terms of reducing fat resorption. These results are due to the pro-angiogenic and pro-adipogenic ability of the stem cells, which allow the graft to address the conditions of ischemia more effectively than autologous fat transfer.

The aim of this review is to explore the ways in which cell-assisted lipotransfer is different from the autologous fat transfer, as well as how and why adipose-derived stem cells may contribute towards limiting fat resorption. The immunological background of these cells is discussed in detail, while grounds for further development are discussed, by means of the administration of external growth factors, which could, potentially, maximize outcomes, while limiting complications.

Indication-based protocols with different solutions for mechanical stromal-cell transfer

Background

Regenerative medicine is the fastest developing branch of plastic surgery in recent times. Adipose tissue is one of the largest and most important sources in the body for stromal cells. Although mechanical isolation methods are both very popular and have many advantages, they still have no accepted protocols.

Objective

We developed new protocols called indication-based protocols (IPs) for standardization and new techniques called mechanical stromal-cell transfer (MEST) by using ultra-sharp blades and dilution of adipose tissue with different solutions (saline, Ringer and 5% Dextrose)

Methods & material: In order to obtain the desired physical structure (liquid, gel, solid) and the desired volume, four different types of IPs have been defined. Adipose tissue was prediluted with different solutions using 10 or 20 cc injectors in IPs 1 and 2, while condensed adipose tissue was used directly in IPs 3 and 4.

Results

In MEST, stromal cells were obtained from 100 mL of condensed fat using different IPs with 92% mean viability and cell counts of 26.80–91.90 × 10⁶. Stromal cells can be obtained in the desired form and number of cells by using four different IPs.

Conclusion

Isolation of stromal cells by cutting fat with sharp blades will prevent the death of fat tissue and stromal cells and will allow high viability and cell count with our new technique. Predilution with different solutions: Diluting the condensed adipose tissue with the desired solutions (saline, Ringer or 5% Dextrose) before the adinizing process will provide even more stromal cells.

Lay Summary

Obtaining regenerative stromal cells from adipose tissue can be done by two methods: Enzymatic and mechanical. Mechanical methods have many advantages. Although mechanical stromal cell extraction from adipose tissue is very popular and many techniques have been described, there are still no accepted protocols, definition for the end product, and no consensus on the status of the stromal cells. In this study, stromal cells were obtained mechanically by using ultra-sharp blade systems, without exposing adipose tissue to blunt trauma. Thus, a higher number of cells and higher viability could be obtained. An “Indication based” protocol has been defined for the first time in order to obtain the desired number and status (solid, semi-solid, liquid)

end product. Diluting the condensed adipose tissue with the desired solutions (saline, Ringer or 5% Dextrose) before the adinizing process will provide even more stromal cells. This will provide an opportunity for clinicians to obtain and apply a stromal cell solution for different indications in different anatomical regions.

"Fasting: An Effective Preconditioning Method to Increase Fat Graft Survival"

BACKGROUND

Most preconditioning techniques before fat grafting require external manipulation. Since nutrition is the main factor maintaining the balance of lipogenesis and lipolysis, we hypothesized that fasting before undergoing autologous fat grafting may increase lipolysis and reduce adipocyte size, thereby improving the fat graft survival rate.

METHODS

C57BL/6 mice were divided into 24 h starved or fed groups. Adipose tissue lipolysis, adipogenesis, and angiogenesis-related gene expression, in fat from both groups, were analyzed. The volume and weight of the grafted fat at 4-8 weeks postoperatively were measured using micro-computed tomography. Immunohistochemistry staining and mRNA expression analysis were also performed to evaluate the effect of fasting on fat graft survival.

RESULTS

Fasting decreased adipocyte size by inducing adipose tissue lipolysis. Adipogenesis-related genes were remarkably downregulated while lipolysis-related genes and angiogenesis inducer genes were significantly upregulated in the starved adipose tissue. The mice grafted with the fat from the 24 h starved group had approximately 20% larger volumes and considerably heavier weights than those from the fed group. Increased viable adipocytes and vessels, and reduced macrophages in the fat grafts obtained from the 24 h starved group were also observed.

CONCLUSIONS

Fasting for 24 h before harvesting fat increased the retention volume of fat graft by increasing angiogenesis via VEGF induction. Therefore, fasting would be a novel and reliable preconditioning strategy to improve graft survival in autologous fat grafting.

NO LEVEL ASSIGNED

This journal requires that authors assign a level of evidence to each submission to which Evidence-Based Medicine rankings are applicable. This excludes Review Articles, Book Reviews, and manuscripts that concern Basic Science, Animal Studies, Cadaver Studies, and Experimental Studies. For a full description of these Evidence-Based Medicine ratings, please refer to the Table of Contents or the online Instructions to Authors www.springer.com/00266.

Regenerative and stem cell-based techniques for facial rejuvenation

This review discusses the most novel ideas and modalities being incorporated into facial rejuvenation. Recent innovative techniques include the use of regenerative stem cell techniques and regeneration supportive modalities such as nano-technology or gene therapies. This review aims to investigate approaches that are less well known and lacking established evidence in order to proactively study these techniques prior to them becoming popularized. These applications and relevant research were reviewed in the context of both surgical and non-surgical modalities in clinical practice. Future directions include the concept of "precision cosmetic medicine" utilizing gene editing and cellular therapies to tailor rejuvenation techniques based on each individual's genetic make-up and therefore needs.

Microenvironmental Changes in the Surviving Fat 1 Year After Autologous Fat Transplantation for Breast Augmentation

BACKGROUND

Autologous fat is currently one of the most commonly used soft tissue materials in plastic surgery, but the changes that occur in fat after transplantation are unclear. Existing studies on the changes in surviving fat mostly involve animal experiments.

OBJECTIVES

The aim of this study was to obtain surviving fat 1 year after clinical autologous fat transplantation for breast augmentation, to explain the microenvironmental changes after fat transplantation from a clinical perspective, and to verify previous research conclusions, thus providing new insight into fat survival.

METHODS

Samples of surviving fat were obtained from 5 patients 1 year after they had undergone autologous fat transplantation for breast augmentation, and normal fat samples were obtained from 5 patients who had not undergone this procedure. The differences between CD68 and CD31 were analyzed immunohistochemically, and between CD34 and Ki67 by immunofluorescence. We also tested whether UCP-1 is expressed in surviving fat.

RESULTS

The relative CD68, CD34, and Ki67 expression levels in the surviving fat tissue were significantly higher than those in the normal fat tissue (PCD68 = 0.04, PCD34 = 0.03, PKi67 = 0.02). The relative CD31 expression was not significantly different between the two groups (P = 0.52). No UCP-1 expression was observed in any surviving fat tissue.

CONCLUSIONS

Chronic inflammatory reactions mediated by macrophages were detectable 1 year after autologous fat transplantation for breast augmentation. The mesenchymal stem cell content in surviving fat was higher than that in normal fat, but the number of blood vessels was close to that in normal breast fat tissue. No genesis of brown fat was found.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: 5

Not Stromal Vascular Fraction (SVF) or Nanofat, but Total Stromal-Cells (TOST): A New Definition. Systemic Review of Mechanical Stromal-Cell Extraction Techniques

The most important and greatest source in the body for regenerative cells is fat tissue. Obtaining regenerative cells from adipose tissue can be done in two ways: Enzymatic and mechanical. The regenerative cell cocktail obtained by the enzymatic method, including stem cells, is called Stromal vascular fracture (SVF). In the literature, there is no clear definition of regenerative cells obtained by mechanical method. We systematically searched the techniques and definitions for stromal cells obtained from adipose tissue by scanning different databases. To evaluate the mechanical stromal-cell isolation techniques and end products from adipose tissue. Systematic review of English and non-English articles using Embase, PubMed, Web of Science and Google scholar databases. Search terms included Nanofat, fragmented fat, mechanical stromal / stem cell, mechanical SVF, SVF gel. We screened all peer-reviewed articles related with mechanical stromal-cell isolation. Author performed a literature query with the aforementioned key words and databases. A total of 276 publications containing the keywords we searched were reached. In these publications, there are 46 different definitions used to obtain mechanical stromal cells. The term SVF is only suitable for enzymatic methods. A different definition is required for mechanical. The most used term nanofat is also not suitable because the product is not in both "fat" and in "nanoscale". We think that the term total stromal-cells would be the most appropriate definition since both extracellular matrix and all stromal cells are protected in mechanical methods.

A clinical perspective on adipose-derived cell therapy for enhancing microvascular health and function: Implications and applications for reconstructive surgery

Restoration of form and function requires apposition of tissues in the form of flaps to reconstitute local perfusion. Successful reconstruction relies on flap survival and its integration with the recipient bed. The flap's precariously perfused hypoxic areas undergo adaptive microvascular changes both internally and in connection with the recipient bed. A cell-mediated, coordinated response to hypoxia drives these adaptive processes, restoring a tissue's normoxic homeostasis via de novo vasculogenesis, sprouting angiogenesis, and stabilizing arterialization. As cells exert prolonged and coordinated effects on site, their use as biological agents merit translational consideration of sourcing angio-competent cells and delivering them to territories enduring microcirculatory acclimatization. Angio-competent cells abound in adipose tissue: a reliable, accessible, and expendable source of adipose-derived cells (ADC). When subject to enzymatic digestion and centrifugation, adipose tissue separates its various ADC: A subset of buoyant oil-dense adipocytes (the tissue's parenchymal component) accumulates on a supra-natant layer, whereas the mesenchymal component remains in the infra-natant sediment, containing the tissue's stromal vascular fraction (SVF), where angio-component cells abound. The SVF can be further manipulated, selected, or culture expanded into more specific stromal subsets (herein defined as adipose stromal cells, ASC). While promising clinical applications for ADC await clinical proof and regulatory authorization, basic science investigation is needed to elucidate the specific ADC mechanisms that influence microvascular growth, remodeling, and function following flap surgery. The objective of this article is to share the clinical perspectives of reconstructive plastic surgeons regarding the use of ADC-based therapies to help with flap tissue integration, revascularization, and wound healing. Specifically, the focus will be on considering the potential for ADC as therapeutic agents and how their clinical application motivates basic science opportunities.

New normal: two aspects of adipose tissue in COVID-19-treat and threat?

INTRODUCTION

Adipose-derived stromal cells (ADSCs) can be an important alternative in COVID-19 prevention, treatment, and subsequent sequelae repair. However, ACE-2 plays a common role in the pathogenesis of adipocyte hypertrophy and COVID 19.

AREAS COVERED

In this 'Perspective,' the author would like to emphasize the use of adipose tissue-derived stromal cells in COVID 19 and the issues that clinicians should pay attention to in fat graft applications in terms of adipose tissue-RAS relationship. The new normal for adipose tissue in COVID 19 will be highlighted.

EXPERT OPINION

ADSCs may potentially be used in COVID-19. However, it has been speculated that ACE2 receptors are responsible for the pathogenesis of adipose tissue overgrowth and may be a potential danger in terms of the relationship between ACE2 receptors and COVID19. We speculate that reducing the size of overgrown fat tissue by ultra-sharp blades and using near-normal adipocytes will create a 'new normal.'

New Mechanical Fat Separation Technique: Adjustable Regenerative Adipose-tissue Transfer (ARAT) and Mechanical Stromal Cell Transfer (MEST)

Background

Adipose tissue is not only a very important source of filler but also the body's greatest source of regenerative cells.

Objectives

In this study, adipose tissue was cut to the desired dimensions using ultra-sharp blade systems to avoid excessive blunt pressure and applied to various anatomical areas-a procedure known as adjustable regenerative adipose-tissue transfer (ARAT). Mechanical stromal cell transfer (MEST) of regenerative cells from fat tissue was also examined.

Methods

ARAT, MEST, or a combination of these was applied in the facial area of a total of 24 patients who were followed for at least 24 months. The integrity of the fat tissue cut with different diameter blades is shown histopathologically. The number and viability of the stromal cells obtained were evaluated and secretome analyses were performed. Patient and surgeon satisfaction were assessed with a visual analog scale.

Results

With the ARAT technique, the desired size fat grafts were obtained between 4000- and 200-micron diameters and applied at varying depths to different aesthetic units of the face, and a guide was developed. In MEST, stromal cells were obtained from 100 mL of condensed fat using different indication-based protocols with 93% mean viability and cell counts of 28.66 to 88.88 × 10⁶.

Conclusions

There are 2 main complications in fat grafting: visibility in thin skin and a low retention rate. The ARAT technique can be used to prevent these 2 complications. MEST, on the other hand, obtains a high rate of fat and viable stromal cells without applying excessive blunt pressure.

Level of Evidence 4

Safety and Regulation of Fat Grafting

Today, fat grafting has wide applicability across plastic surgery disciplines, including both aesthetic and reconstructive procedures. However, much controversy has surrounded adipose tissue transfer throughout the 20th century, necessitating extensive research to improve the fat grafting process and to better understand its associated complications and benefits. Initial concerns included the technical difficulties of properly handling and processing adipose to ensure adequate outcomes. As these issues were addressed, more modern concerns were raised by the U.S Food and Drug Administration and the general scientific community regarding the oncological potential of adipose tissue and its potential interference with breast cancer screenings. Today, many formalized clinical studies have evidenced the safety of fat grafting, allowing the procedure to gain widespread popularity and opening avenues for future applications.

Autologous Fat Grafting Promotes Macrophage Infiltration to Increase Secretion of Growth Factors and Revascularization, Thereby Treating Diabetic Rat Skin Defect

BACKGROUND

Diabetic skin defect is difficult to manage in surgical clinics, and there is still lack of effective treatments for diabetic skin defects. Currently, autologous fat grafting (AFG) is promising in the field of reconstructive surgery, while macrophage infiltration in autologous adipose tissue is considered vital for tissue regeneration. But AFG is rarely applied to the treatment of diabetic skin defects, and whether macrophage infiltration assists AFG to promote wound healing is still unknown.

METHODS

Full-thickness skin defect diabetic rats were divided into 3 groups: control group, autologous fat grafting (AFG) group and AFG with macrophage depletion (AFG+MD) group. We examined the amount of macrophages in the wounds bed and the expression level of inflammatory factors IL-10, IL-6, TNF-α, and also growth factors PDGF-β, TGF-β, IGF-1 at the same time. The content of collagen-I and α-smooth muscle actin protein in the wounds were determined by Western blot analysis. Finally, the healing of the wounds was evaluated.

RESULTS

The AFG group showing more rapid healing, secreting more growth factors and more obvious vascularization in the healing process, compared with the control group. But, the secretion of growth factors and the construction of extracellular matrix (ECM) in the wounds were limited when macrophages were depleted after AFG.

CONCLUSION

AFG promotes the infiltration of macrophages to improve the healing environment of diabetic wounds by increasing the secretion of growth factors and revascularization, which provides a potential method for the treatment of diabetic skin defects.