Ear Reconstruction after Mohs Cancer Excision: Lessons Learned from 327 Consecutive Cases

Partial Central Anterior Reconstruction of the Auricle with One-Stage Combined Retroauricular Flaps

SUMMARY

Basal cell carcinomas of the central anterior area of the auricle limited to the antihelix and scapha without peripheral infiltration of the helix are not uncommon. Resection is rarely transfixing, but resection of the underlying cartilage is often required. The complex anatomy of the ear and the lack of local tissue available makes its reparation challenging. Defects of antihelix and scapha require special reconstructive techniques, taking into account skin structure and the three-dimensional architecture of the ear. The reconstruction usually consists of full-thickness skin grafting or anterior transposition flap, requiring an extended skin resection. The authors describe a one-stage technique that uses a pedicled retroauricular skin flap turned over the anterior defect, followed by immediate closure of the donor site with a transposition or a bilobed retroauricular skin flap. The one-stage combined retroauricular flap reparation optimizes cosmetic outcome and reduces the risk of successive surgical procedures.

Tunnelised superiorly based preauricular flap and conchal cartilage graft for antihelix reconstruction

Reconstruction of a full-thickness defect of the auricle's anterior surface represents a challenge for plastic surgeons. This report describes the case of a man in his 70s, who underwent radical excision of a squamous cell carcinoma involving his right antihelix. We adopted an innovative approach for the reconstruction of the antihelix, using a tunnelled preauricular flap reinforced with an ipsilateral concha cartilage graft. The flap's base was de-epithelialised, allowing a single-stage procedure. Three months postoperation, no complications arose, and the scars at the donor site were effectively concealed. The aesthetic result was excellent, thanks to the perfect colour match, symmetry, shape of the auricle and the long-lasting integrity of the antihelical structure.This technique allows for accurate reconstruction of the convoluted surface of the auricle in cases of full-thickness defects of the antihelix, without the need to harvest cartilage from other donor sites and in a single surgical procedure.

Reconstruction of Full-Thickness Helical Defects Using a Superior Auricular Artery-Based Postauricular Chondrocutaneous Flap

BACKGROUND

The helix is the most common localization of auricular defects. Various techniques have been successfully used for the reconstruction of helical defects. However, redistributing the remaining auricular tissue to supply an ideal reconstruction base provides the best possible esthetic outcomes. The aim of this study is to present a new design for a postauricular chondrocutaneous flap to reconstruct the 3-dimensional curve and the folded structures in full-thickness helical defects.

METHODS

Nineteen patients with full-thickness helical defects were treated with the superior pedicle chondrocutaneous flap based on the superior auricular artery. The flap was designed on the postauricular area and comprised 3 sections, namely, deepithelialized, chondrocutaneous, and cutaneous sections (proximal to distal). Levels of patient's satisfaction on the final shape and auricular symmetry, and tissue compatibility between the flap and surrounding tissues were evaluated by the patients and objective observers.

RESULTS

The overall dimensions, projections, and curved structures of the defective helix maintained a smooth and contiguous appearance without asymmetry, notching, or trap-door deformities. The color, texture, and thickness of the flaps matched well with the adjacent auricles, and there was a moderate positive correlation between patient (9.47 ± 0.51) and observer (8.68 ± 0.63) correlation scores (r = 0.7485). The vast majority of the patients were very satisfied with the surgical outcome, and there was a statistically significant improvement in patient satisfaction (mean preoperative score, 1.26 ± 0.45; mean 12-month score, 4.79 ± 0.42; P < 0.00001).

CONCLUSIONS

Reconstruction of full-thickness helical defects requires "like tissue" characteristics and 3-dimensional cartilage support to avoid depression and notch deformities. The postauricular chondrocutaneous flap based on the superior auricular artery was shown to preserve the helical curve and folded sulcus, retain the size and subunits of the auricle, and ensure a color, texture, and thickness match between the flap and the adjacent tissues.

State of the Evidence for Facial Skin Cancer Reconstruction

This review provides a comprehensive presentation of the evidence available in facial reconstruction post-Mohs micrographic surgery. Given the large diversity in post-Mohs reconstruction, there are limited guidelines in the management of defects. The aim of the present work is to provide a review of the best evidence as it pertains to several considerations in facial reconstruction. Data suggests that Mohs micrographic surgery and many reconstructive procedures can be performed as outpatient procedures under local anesthesia, with narcotic pain medication only given in certain patient populations following a minority of reconstructive procedures. Perioperative and topical antibiotics are generally not indicated. Aspirin and warfarin can generally be continued for most reconstructive procedures, but clopidogrel and novel anticoagulants may predispose to increased bleeding complications. Delayed reconstruction appears to be safe, although data are discordant on this topic. No specific wound closure technique or suture choice appears to be consistently superior. Given the lack of robust comparative studies, consistent methodology, and variable defect sizes/locations, no robust evidence-based guidelines can be generated for reconstruction techniques of facial subsites.

A Retrospective Study on Single-Stage Reconstruction of the Ear following Skin Cancer Excision in Elderly Patients

Ear reconstructive surgery aims to solve the deformities caused by cancer excision. Despite the numerous surgical procedures described, recreating the complex anatomy of the ear still represents a challenge, particularly for young surgeons. The purpose of this exploratory pilot study is to review our experience with single stage reconstruction of the partial defects of the auricle, and propose an algorithm based on defect size, location, and characteristics. We retrospectively reviewed patients who underwent ear reconstruction after cancer excision at our institution between February 2018 and November 2020. The data collected included patients’ demographics, defect characteristics, reconstructive technique used, complications, and outcomes. The patients were evaluated at a minimum follow-up time of 12 months. Forty-six patients were included in the study. The most common cause for ear reconstruction was basal cell carcinoma. The mean area of defect was 4.3 cm2 and the helix was the most frequent location of defect. Two patients experienced post-operative complications. At the one-year follow-up, difference in skin pigmentation was reported in 10 cases, a depressed contour of the ear was found in 4 cases, and moderate ear asymmetry was found in 11 cases. No patient needed a secondary procedure. In conclusion, the proposed reconstructive algorithm represents a reconstructive indication that is simple and characterized by low complication rates and good outcomes for both the patient and the surgeon.

Nasal Reconstruction after Mohs Cancer Resection: Lessons Learned from 2553 Consecutive Cases

BACKGROUND

Nasal defects following Mohs resection are a reconstructive challenge, demanding aesthetic and functional considerations. Many reconstructive modalities are available, each with varying utility and efficacy. The goal of this study was to provide an algorithmic approach to nasal reconstruction and illustrate lessons learned from decades of reconstructing Mohs defects.

METHODS

A retrospective review was conducted of consecutive patients who underwent nasal reconstruction after Mohs excision from 2003 to 2019 performed by the senior author (J.F.T.). Data were collected and analyzed regarding patient and clinical demographics, defect characteristics, reconstructive modality used, revisions, and complications.

RESULTS

A total of 2553 cases were identified, among which 1550 (1375 patients) were analyzed. Defects most commonly affected the nasal ala (48.1 percent); 74.8 percent were skin-only. Full-thickness skin-grafts were the most common reconstructive method (36.2 percent); 24.4 percent of patients underwent forehead flaps and 17.0 percent underwent nasolabial flaps. The overall complication rate was 11.6 percent (n = 181), with poor wound healing being most common. Age older than 75 years, defects larger than 2 cm2, and active smoking were associated with increased complication rates.

CONCLUSIONS

Nasal reconstruction can be divided based on anatomical location, and an algorithmic approach facilitates excellent results. Although local flaps may be suitable for some patients, they are not always the most aesthetic option. The versatility and low risk-to-benefit profile of the forehead flap make it a suitable option for elderly patients. Although reconstruction is still safe to be performed without discontinuation of anticoagulation, older age, smoking, and large defect size are predictors of complications.

CLINICAL QUESTION/LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Therapeutic, IV.

Auricular reconstruction after Mohs micrographic surgery: analysis of 101 cases

Background

The ear is a region that has a high prevalence of cutaneous carcinomas and several guidelines indicate Mohs micrographic surgery as the first-choice treatment in such cases. Although the technique allows maximum preservation of healthy tissue, many auricular surgical wounds constitute a challenge due to the peculiar local anatomy, with evident curves and reliefs. Auricular reconstruction should prioritize function before aesthetics, but without leaving the latter aside, since postoperative distortions can have a significant psychological impact.

Objective

To describe the authors’ experience in auricular reconstruction after Mohs surgery and to evaluate the most frequently used repair methods.

Methods

Retrospective study of consecutive cases submitted to Mohs surgery and auricular reconstruction, over a period of 3 years.

Results

One hundred and one cases were included and the most common repair method was primary closure (n = 35), followed by full-thickness skin graft (n = 30) and flaps (n = 24). In thirty cases, reconstruction methods were associated. Seven patients had complications (partial graft necrosis, postoperative bleeding or infection).

Study limitations

Retrospective design and the absence of long-term follow-up of some cases.

Conclusions

The dermatologic surgeon should be familiarized with different options for auricular reconstruction. Primary closure and skin grafts were the most frequently used repair methods.

Clinical Results of Ear Elevations in Patients with Microtia Using Skin Grafts from Three Donor Sites: A Retrospective Study

BACKGROUND

Skin grafts, frequently used for ear elevation in ear reconstructions, may suffer from color mismatches, scar hypertrophy, secondary contraction, and auricular sulcus depth differences. To determine the most suitable donor area, we compared the contralateral postauricular area, groin, and scalp as potential donor sites.

METHODS

Since 2008, we have used three donor sites for obtaining skin grafts used in ear reconstructions. Full-thickness groin skin, split-thickness grafts from the scalp, and contralateral postauricular and groin composite full-thickness skin grafts were used in 202, 231, and 195 patients, respectively. Photographic assessments were used to assess color matching, sulcus depth, cranioauricular angle symmetry, and flatness of the skin grafts; surgical complications were also documented.

RESULTS

Among the three donor sites, there were no significant differences in the color matching scores (p = 0.456). The scalp donor scores had significantly lower mean scores for sulcus depth and symmetry and for graft flatness scores than the other donor sites. The assessment scores between the groin and postauricular donor groups were similar. Each donor site was associated with some surgical complications. However, postauricular skin, when combined with groin skin, demonstrated the best cosmetic results and the fewest complications.

CONCLUSION

All three donor sites are viable options for skin graft donor sites in ear elevation surgeries. Although the advantages and disadvantages of each site should be explained to the patient, the ultimate donor site selection may be determined according to patient and surgeon preferences.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE IV

This journal requires that authors assign a level of evidence to each article. For a full description of these Evidence-Based Medicine ratings, please refer to the Table of Contents or the online Instructions to Authors www.springer.com/00266 .