HIV-1 superinfection is associated with an accelerated viral load increase but has a limited impact on disease progression

Dynamics of HIV DNA reservoir seeding in a cohort of superinfected Kenyan women

A reservoir of HIV-infected cells that persists despite suppressive antiretroviral therapy (ART) is the source of viral rebound upon ART cessation and the major barrier to a cure. Understanding reservoir seeding dynamics will help identify the best timing for HIV cure strategies. Here we characterize reservoir seeding using longitudinal samples from before and after ART initiation in individuals who sequentially became infected with genetically distinct HIV variants (superinfected). We previously identified cases of superinfection in a cohort of Kenyan women, and the dates of both initial infection and superinfection were determined. Six women, superinfected 0.2–5.2 years after initial infection, were subsequently treated with ART 5.4–18.0 years after initial infection. We performed next-generation sequencing of HIV gag and env RNA from plasma collected during acute infection as well as every ~2 years thereafter until ART initiation, and of HIV DNA from PBMCs collected 0.9–4.8 years after viral suppression on ART. We assessed phylogenetic relationships between HIV DNA reservoir sequences and longitudinal plasma RNA sequences prior to ART, to determine proportions of initial and superinfecting variants in the reservoir. The proportions of initial and superinfection lineage variants present in the HIV DNA reservoir were most similar to the proportions present in HIV RNA immediately prior to ART initiation. Phylogenetic analysis confirmed that the majority of HIV DNA reservoir sequences had the smallest pairwise distance to RNA sequences from timepoints closest to ART initiation. Our data suggest that while reservoir cells are created throughout pre-ART infection, the majority of HIV-infected cells that persist during ART entered the reservoir near the time of ART initiation. We estimate the half-life of pre-ART DNA reservoir sequences to be ~25 months, which is shorter than estimated reservoir decay rates during suppressive ART, implying continual decay and reseeding of the reservoir up to the point of ART initiation.

During HIV infection, a reservoir of long-lived latently infected cells is established that persists during antiretroviral therapy (ART) and is the source of virus replication after treatment cessation. A better understanding of when viruses enter the HIV reservoir (reservoir seeding) will aid efforts to target these long-lived HIV infected cells during their establishment. We studied women infected at two different times with two genetically distinct HIV strains (called superinfection), and assessed the genetic relationship between sequences of the HIV strains that circulated throughout infection (pre-ART HIV RNA sequences) and the HIV strains that persisted in reservoir cells (HIV DNA sequences during ART). We estimated when HIV DNA sequences entered the reservoir by identifying the time the most genetically related HIV RNA sequence was detected. In most cases we observed that viruses in the reservoir included both the initial and superinfecting lineages, suggesting reservoir seeding occurs throughout HIV infection. However, the majority of HIV sequences entered the reservoir near the time of ART initiation, suggesting that novel strategies that aim to reduce reservoir size should focus on times immediately prior to ART.

Triple HIV-1 Infection Is Associated With Faster CD4+ T-Cell Decline

HIV-1 dual infection occurs when an individual is simultaneously or sequentially infected with two or more genetically distinct HIV-1 strains. According to the number of infected strains, HIV-1 dual infection can be divided in double infection and triple infection and so on. Currently, the majority of dual infection cases have been reported to be double infections which can result in detrimental clinical outcomes. The high incidence of double infection among specific high-risk populations increases the likelihood of triple infection, which has been sporadically described. There is no doubt that we are concerned about the association between triple infection and disease progression. However, this relationship is still unclear on the population level. In this study, 70 individuals from the Beijing PRIMO cohort were longitudinally followed up with a median time of 15.75 months for the purpose of investigating the incidence of dual infection. Phylogenetic analyses using bulk and single-genome sequences showed that nine individuals acquired double infection, with the incidence of 9.21 per 100 person-years, and three individuals with triple infection were identified, with the incidence of 3.07 per 100 person-years. The further survival analysis demonstrated that the triple infection group exhibited faster CD4⁺ T-cell decline. In summary, these results demonstrate for the first time that the triple HIV-1 infection might reduce CD4⁺ T-cell counts, which would predict a more rapid disease progression.

Reduced frequency of HIV superinfection in a high-risk cohort in Zambia

Rates of HIV-1 superinfection, re-infection with a genetically distinct virus despite HIV-1 specific immune responses, vary in different risk populations. We previously found the rates of superinfection were similar to primary HIV infection (PHI) in a Zambian heterosexual transmission cohort. Here, we conduct a similar analysis of 47 HIV-positive Zambians from an acute infection cohort with more frequent follow-up, all infected by non-spousal partners. We identified only one case of superinfection in the first two years, significantly fewer than in our previous study, which was likely due to increased counseling during acute infection and an overall population-wide decline in factors associated with HIV transmission. The predominant virus detected after superinfection was a recombinant of the transmitted founder (TF) and the superinfecting strain. The superinfected individual mounted a neutralizing antibody response to the primary TF virus, which remained TF-specific over time and even after superinfection, did not neutralize the superinfecting variant.

HIV controllers suppress viral replication and evolution and prevent disease progression following intersubtype HIV-1 superinfection

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this study was to investigate the impact of intersubtype HIV-1 superinfection on viremia, reservoir reseeding, viral evolution and disease progression in HIV controllers (HIC).

DESIGN

A longitudinal analysis of two Brazilian HIC individuals (EEC09 and VC32) previously identified as dually infected with subtypes B and F1 viruses.

METHODS

Changes in plasma viremia, total HIV-1 DNA levels, CD4+ T-cell counts and HIV-1 quasispecies composition were measured over time. HIV-1 env diversity in peripheral blood mononuclear cell (PBMC) and plasma samples was accessed by single genome amplification and next-generation sequencing approaches, respectively. Viral evolution was evaluated by estimating nucleotide diversity and divergence.

RESULTS

Individual EEC09 was probably initially infected with a CCR5-tropic subtype B strain and sequentially superinfected with a CXCR4-tropic subtype B strain and with a subtype F1 variant. Individual VC32 was infected with a subtype B strain and superinfected with a subtype F1 variant. The intersubtype superinfection events lead to a moderate increase in viremia and extensive turnover of viral population in plasma but exhibited divergent impact on the size and composition of cell-associated HIV DNA population. Both individuals maintained virologic control (<2000 copies/ml) and presented no evidence of viral evolution or immunologic progression for at least 2 years after the intersubtype superinfection event.

CONCLUSION

These data revealed that some HIC are able to repeatedly limit replication and evolution of superinfecting viral strains of a different subtype with no signs of disease progression.

Maintenance and reappearance of extremely divergent intra-host HIV-1 variants

Understanding genetic variation in human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) is clinically and immunologically important for patient treatment and vaccine development. We investigated the longitudinal intra-host genetic variation of HIV in over 3,000 individuals in the US National HIV Surveillance System with at least four reported HIV-1 polymerase (pol) sequences. In this population, we identified 149 putative instances of superinfection (i.e. an individual sequentially infected with genetically divergent, polyphyletic viruses). Unexpectedly, we discovered a group of 240 individuals with consecutively sampled viral strains that were >0.015 substitutions/site divergent, despite remaining monophyletic in the phylogeny. Viruses in some of these individuals had a maximum genetic divergence approaching that found between two random, unrelated HIV-1 subtype-B pol sequences within the US population. Individuals with these highly divergent viruses tended to be diagnosed nearly a decade earlier in the epidemic than people with superinfection or virus with less intra-host genetic variation, and they had distinct transmission risk factor profiles. To better understand this genetic variation in cases with extremely divergent, monophyletic viruses, we performed molecular clock phylogenetic analysis. Our findings suggest that, like Hepatitis C virus, extremely divergent HIV lineages can be maintained within an individual and reemerge over a period of years.

Frequency of occurrence of HIV-1 dual infection in a Belgian MSM population

Introduction

HIV-1 dual infection is a condition that results from infection with at least two HIV-1 variants from different sources. The scarceness of information on this condition is partly due to the fact that its detection is technically challenging. Using next-generation sequencing we defined the extent of HIV-1 dual infection in a cohort of men who have sex with men (MSM).

Material & methods

Eighty-six MSM, diagnosed with HIV-1 subtype B infection between 2008 and 2013 were selected for next-generation sequencing of the HIV-1 envelope V3. Sequencing was performed on 2 plasma samples collected with an interval of > 6 months before the initiation of antiretroviral therapy. Maximum likelihood phylogenetic trees were inspected for dual infection, defined as the presence of two or more monophyletic clusters with ≥ 90% bootstrap support and a mean between-cluster genetic distance of ≥ 10%. To confirm dual infection, deep V3 sequencing of intermediate samples was performed as well as clonal sequencing of the HIV-1 protease-reverse transcriptase gene.

Results

Five of the 74 patients (6.8%) for whom deep sequencing was successful, showed clear evidence of dual infection. In 4 of them, the second strain was absent in the first sample but occurred in subsequent samples. This was highly suggestive for superinfection. In 3 patients both virus variants were of subtype B, in 2 patients at least one of the variants was a subtype B/non-B recombinant virus.

Conclusions

Dual infection was confirmed in 6.8% of MSM diagnosed with HIV-1 in Belgium. This prevalence is probably an underestimation, because stringent criteria were used to classify viral variants as originating from a new infection event.

Dual Infection Contributes to Rapid Disease Progression in Men Who Have Sex With Men in China

Supplemental Digital Content is Available in the Text.

Background:

Considerable numbers of HIV-1–infected men who have sex with men (MSM) show a relatively rapid disease progression in China; however, the cause remains elusive. HIV-1 dual infection was reported to occur commonly among the MSM population, and its contribution to clinical prognosis remains controversial. We investigated the occurrence and impact on disease progression of dual infection in a prospective MSM cohort in China.

Methods:

Sixty-four HIV-1 early-infected participants were longitudinally followed up for 2 years. Deep sequencing was used as dual-infection screening. CD4⁺ T-cell counts and HIV-1 viral load were compared between coinfection and single-infection participants and pre- versus post-superinfection.

Results:

Eight coinfected participants and 10 superinfected participants were identified, including 9 participants with intersubtype and 9 with intrasubtype dual infections. The prevalence of coinfection was 13.1%, with a superinfection incidence of 15.6%. Coinfection participants showed lower CD4⁺ T-cell counts at 120 days after infection (P = 0.042) and a higher viral set point tendency (P = 0.053) as compared with single-infection participants. Kaplan–Meier analysis showed that the time for the viral load to increase to above 4 log₁₀ copies per milliliter was shorter in coinfection participants than in single-infection participants (P < 0.001). After superinfection, the median CD4⁺ T-cell count decreased from 635 to 481 cells/μL (P = 0.027).

Conclusions:

The occurrence of dual infection among Chinese MSM is relatively high, and HIV-1 dual infection might contribute to rapid disease progression seen in the MSM population.

Brief Report: Sexual Violence Against HIV-Positive Women in the Nyanza Region of Kenya: Is Condom Negotiation an Instigator?

For people living with HIV, exposure to sexual violence (SV) is associated with decreased adherence to antiretroviral medication, a primary predictor of their survival. Identification of risk factors for SV is a pressing issue in sub-Saharan Africa, where the global majority of HIV-positive women live and the prevalence of SV against women is high. We used qualitative data to examine SV against HIV-positive women enrolled in HIV care in Kenya. Respondents identified husbands as perpetrators of SV in the context of women's efforts to use condoms as directed by HIV care providers.

Increased HIV-1 superinfection risk in carriers of specific human leukocyte antigen alleles

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this study was to characterize the demographic, behavioural, clinical and immunogenetic determinants of HIV-1 superinfection in a high-risk cohort of MSM.

DESIGN

A retrospective cohort study of prospectively followed MSM.

METHODS

Ninety-eight MSM with acute or early HIV-1 monoinfection were followed for a median of 15.6 months. Demographic and human leukocyte antigen (HLA) genotype data were collected at enrolment. Sexual behaviour, clinical and the infection status (monoinfection or superinfection) data were recorded at each visit (at enrolment and thereafter at a median of 4.2-month intervals). HIV-1 superinfection risk was determined by Cox regression and Kaplan-Meier survival analysis.

RESULTS

Ten individuals (10.2%) had superinfection during follow-up. Cox regression did not show significantly increased superinfection risk for individuals with an increased amount of condomless anal intercourse, lower CD4 T-cell count or higher viral load, but higher number of sexual contacts demonstrated a trend towards significance [hazard ratio, 4.74; 95% confidence interval (95% CI), 0.87-25.97; P = 0.073]. HLA-A*29 (hazard ratio, 4.10; 95% CI, 0.88-14.76; P = 0.069), HLA-B*35 (hazard ratio, 4.64; 95% CI, 1.33-18.17; P = 0.017), HLA-C*04 (hazard ratio, 5.30; 95% CI, 1.51-20.77; P = 0.010), HLA-C*16 (hazard ratio, 4.05; 95% CI, 0.87-14.62; P = 0.071), HLA-DRB1*07 (hazard ratio, 3.29; 95% CI, 0.94-12.90; P = 0.062) and HLA-DRB1*08 (hazard ratio, 15.37; 95% CI, 2.11-79.80; P = 0.011) were associated with an increased risk of superinfection at α = 0.10, whereas HLA-DRB1*11 was associated with decreased superinfection risk (hazard ratio, 0.13; 95% CI, 0.00-1.03; P = 0.054).

CONCLUSION

HLA genes may, in part, elucidate the genetic basis of differential superinfection risk, and provide important information for the development of efficient prevention and treatment strategies of HIV-1 superinfection.

Comprehensive Characterization of Humoral Correlates of Human Immunodeficiency Virus 1 Superinfection Acquisition in High-risk Kenyan Women

HIV-1 superinfection, in which an infected individual acquires a second HIV-1 infection from a different partner, is one of the only settings in which HIV acquisition occurs in the context of a pre-existing immune response to natural HIV infection. There is evidence that initial infection provides some protection from superinfection, particularly after 6 months of initial infection, when development of broad immunity occurs. Comparison of the immune response of superinfected individuals at the time of superinfection acquisition to that of individuals who remain singly infected despite continued exposure can shed light on immune correlates of HIV acquisition to inform prophylactic vaccine design. We evaluated a panel of humoral immune responses in the largest published group of superinfected individuals (n = 21), compared to a set of 3:1 matched singly infected controls from the same cohort. The immune functions studied included plasma neutralization, plasma and cervical antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity, and plasma IgG and IgA binding to a panel of 18 envelope antigens, including correlates of HIV acquisition in the RV144 vaccine trial, IgG binding to V1V2 and IgA binding to gp140. Association between each immune function and HIV superinfection was evaluated using conditional logistic regression. No significant associations were detected between any of the immune functions and superinfection acquisition. This study constitutes the most comprehensive and detailed characterization of multiple immune correlates of superinfection to date. The results suggest that immune responses not commonly measured in current HIV studies may be important in protection from HIV infection, and these or a more robust humoral response than that seen in naturally infected women may be needed for a protective vaccine.

•

We conducted a case-control study of the association between humoral immune functions and HIV superinfection (SI).

•

Neutralization, antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity, and IgG and IgA binding to Env antigens were interrogated.

•

We found no significant associations between SI acquisition and neutralizing or non-neutralizing antibody activity.

HIV superinfection (repeat infection from a second partner) is a unique situation in which infection occurs in the presence of a pre-existing HIV-specific immune response. Identification of immune deficits in superinfected individuals prior to superinfection can shed light on immune functions associated with HIV acquisition, and help inform prophylactic vaccine development. We compared various antibody measures in superinfected women vs. women who remained singly infected. We found no evidence that deficits in any of the measures analyzed were associated with superinfection risk. This suggests a prophylactic vaccine may need to elicit stronger or different immune responses than those investigated here.

Deciphering Multiplicity of HIV-1C Infection: Transmission of Closely Related Multiple Viral Lineages

BACKGROUND

A single viral variant is transmitted in the majority of HIV infections. However, about 20% of heterosexually transmitted HIV infections are caused by multiple viral variants. Detection of transmitted HIV variants is not trivial, as it involves analysis of multiple viral sequences representing intra-host HIV-1 quasispecies.

METHODOLOGY

We distinguish two types of multiple virus transmission in HIV infection: (1) HIV transmission from the same source, and (2) transmission from different sources. Viral sequences representing intra-host quasispecies in a longitudinally sampled cohort of 42 individuals with primary HIV-1C infection in Botswana were generated by single-genome amplification and sequencing and spanned the V1C5 region of HIV-1C env gp120. The Maximum Likelihood phylogeny and distribution of pairwise raw distances were assessed at each sampling time point (n = 217; 42 patients; median 5 (IQR: 4-6) time points per patient, range 2-12 time points per patient).

RESULTS

Transmission of multiple viral variants from the same source (likely from the partner with established HIV infection) was found in 9 out of 42 individuals (21%; 95 CI 10-37%). HIV super-infection was identified in 2 patients (5%; 95% CI 1-17%) with an estimated rate of 3.9 per 100 person-years. Transmission of multiple viruses combined with HIV super-infection at a later time point was observed in one individual.

CONCLUSIONS

Multiple HIV lineages transmitted from the same source produce a monophyletic clade in the inferred phylogenetic tree. Such a clade has transiently distinct sub-clusters in the early stage of HIV infection, and follows a predictable evolutionary pathway. Over time, the gap between initially distinct viral lineages fills in and initially distinct sub-clusters converge. Identification of cases with transmission of multiple viral lineages from the same source needs to be taken into account in cross-sectional estimation of HIV recency in epidemiological and population studies.

HIV-associated neurocognitive disorder is associated with HIV-1 dual infection

OBJECTIVE

Compared with HIV monoinfection, HIV dual infection has been associated with decreased CD4 T-cell counts and increased viral loads. The same markers are also associated with the development of HIV-associated neurocognitive disorder (HAND), which continues to be a prevalent problem in the era of combination antiretroviral therapy (ART). We sought to determine the relationship between dual infection and HAND.

METHODS

Participants on ART (N = 38) underwent deep sequencing of four PCR-amplified HIV coding regions derived from peripheral blood mononuclear cell DNA samples. Phylogenetic analyses were performed to evaluate whether two distinct viral lineages, that is, dual infection, were present in the same individual. All study participants underwent neurocognitive, substance use, and neuromedical assessments at each study visit.

RESULTS

Of 38 participants, nine (23.7%) had evidence of dual infection. Using clinical ratings, global neurocognitive impairment was identified in 21 (55%) participants, and multivariate analysis demonstrated a significant association between dual infection and impairment; odds ratio (95% confidence interval) = 18.3 (1.9, 414.2), P = 0.028. Neurocognitive impairment was also associated with lower current (P = 0.028) and nadir (P = 0.043) CD4 T-cell counts.

CONCLUSIONS

Deep sequencing of HIV DNA populations in blood mononuclear cell identified dual infection in nearly a quarter of HIV-infected adults receiving ART, and dual infection was associated with HAND. Dual infection may contribute to the development of HAND, perhaps because of increased viral diversity. Further investigation is needed to determine how dual infection results in worse neurocognitive performance.

Differences in Activation of HIV-1 Replication by Superinfection With HIV-1 and HIV-2 in U1 Cells

Macrophages contribute to HIV-1 pathogenesis by forming a viral reservoir that serve as a viral source for the infection of CD4 T cells. The relationship between HIV-1 latent infection and superinfection in macrophages has not been well studied. Using susceptible U1 cells chronically infected with HIV-1, we studied the effects of HIV superinfection on latency and differences in superinfection with HIV-1 and HIV-2 in macrophages. We found that HIV-1 (MN) superinfection displayed increased HIV-1 replication in a time-dependent manner; while cells infected with HIV-2 (Rod) initially showed increased HIV-1 replication, followed by a decrease in HIV-1 RNA production. HIV-1 superinfection upregulated/activated NF-ĸB, NFAT, AP-1, SP-1, and MAPK Erk through expression/activation of molecules, CD4, CD3, TCRβ, Zap-70, PLCγ1, and PKCΘ in T cell receptor-related signaling pathways; while HIV-2 superinfection initially increased expression/activation of these molecules followed by decreased protein expression/activation. HIV superinfection initially downregulated HDAC1 and upregulated acetyl-histone H3 and histone H3 (K4), while HIV-2 superinfection demonstrated an increase in HDAC1 and a decrease in acetyl-histone H3 and histone H3 (K4) relative to HIV-1 superinfection. U1 cells superinfected with HIV-1 or HIV-2 showed differential expression of proteins, IL-2, PARP-1, YB-1, and LysRS. These findings indicate that superinfection with HIV-1 or HIV-2 has different effects on reactivation of HIV-1 replication. HIV-1 superinfection with high load of viral replication may result in high levels of cytotoxicity relative to HIV-2 superinfection. Cells infected with HIV-2 showed lower level of HIV-1 replication, suggesting that co-infection with HIV-2 may result in slower progression toward AIDS. J. Cell. Physiol. 232: 1746-1753, 2017. © 2016 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.

A trend towards increasing viral load in newly diagnosed HIV-infected inpatients in southeast China

Peripheral blood viral load is an important indicator of viral production and clearance. Previous studies have suggested that viral load might predict the rate of decrease in CD4+ cell count and progression to AIDS and death. Here, we conducted a retrospective analysis of the trends in HIV-1 viral load in southeast China. Among inpatients newly diagnosed with HIV infection, we found that viral load has increased over the past decade from 4·20 log10 copies/ml in 2002 to 6·61 log10 copies/ml in 2014, with a mean increase of 0·19 log10 copies/ml each year. However, the CD4+ cell count was stable and insensitive to changes in viral load. Thus, increasing viral load appears to be an emerging trend in newly diagnosed HIV-infected inpatients.

Evaluation of postpartum HIV superinfection and mother-to-child transmission

OBJECTIVE

This study examined HIV superinfection in HIV-infected women postpartum, and its association with mother-to-child transmission (MTCT).

DESIGN

Plasma samples were obtained from HIV-infected women who transmitted HIV to their infants after 6 weeks of age (transmitters, n = 91) and HIV-infected women who did not transmit HIV to their infants (nontransmitters, n = 91). These women were originally enrolled in a randomized trial for prevention of MTCT of HIV in Malawi (Post-Exposure Prophylaxis of Infants trial in Malawi).

METHODS

Two HIV genomic regions (p24 and gp41) were analyzed by next-generation sequencing for HIV superinfection. HIV superinfection was established if the follow-up sample contained a new, phylogenetically distinct viral population. HIV superinfection and transmission risk were examined by multiple logistic regression, adjusted for Post-Exposure Prophylaxis of Infants study arm, baseline viral load, baseline CD4 cell count, time to resumption of sex, and breastfeeding duration.

RESULTS

Transmitters had lower baseline CD4 cell counts (P = 0.001) and higher viral loads (P < 0.0001) compared with nontransmitters. There were five cases of superinfection among transmitters (rate of superinfection = 4.7/100 person-years) compared with five cases among the nontransmitters (rate of superinfection = 4.4/100 person-years; P = 0.78). HIV superinfection was not associated with increased risk of postnatal MTCT of HIV after controlling for maternal age, baseline viral load, and CD4 cell count (adjusted odds ratio = 2.32, P = 0.30). Longer breastfeeding duration was independently associated with a lower risk of HIV superinfection after controlling for study arm and baseline viral load (P = 0.05).

CONCLUSION

There was a significant level of HIV superinfection in women postpartum, but this was not associated with an increased risk of MTCT via breastfeeding.

HIV-infected sex workers with beneficial HLA-variants are potential hubs for selection of HIV-1 recombinants that may affect disease progression

Cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) responses against the HIV Gag protein are associated with lowering viremia; however, immune control is undermined by viral escape mutations. The rapid viral mutation rate is a key factor, but recombination may also contribute. We hypothesized that CTL responses drive the outgrowth of unique intra-patient HIV-recombinants (URFs) and examined gag sequences from a Kenyan sex worker cohort. We determined whether patients with HLA variants associated with effective CTL responses (beneficial HLA variants) were more likely to carry URFs and, if so, examined whether they progressed more rapidly than patients with beneficial HLA-variants who did not carry URFs. Women with beneficial HLA-variants (12/52) were more likely to carry URFs than those without beneficial HLA variants (3/61) (p < 0.0055; odds ratio = 5.7). Beneficial HLA variants were primarily found in slow/standard progressors in the URF group, whereas they predominated in long-term non-progressors/survivors in the remaining cohort (p = 0.0377). The URFs may sometimes spread and become circulating recombinant forms (CRFs) of HIV and local CRF fragments were over-represented in the URF sequences (p < 0.0001). Collectively, our results suggest that CTL-responses associated with beneficial HLA variants likely drive the outgrowth of URFs that might reduce the positive effect of these CTL responses on disease progression.