Heart Transplantation From Brain Dead Donors: A Systematic Review of Animal Models

Echocardiographic surrogate of left ventricular stroke work in a model of brain stem death donors

BACKGROUND

The commonest echocardiographic measurement, left ventricular ejection fraction, can not necessarily predict mortality of recipients following heart transplantation potentially due to afterload dependency. Afterload-independent left ventricular stroke work index (LVSWI) is alternatively recommended by the current guideline; however, pulmonary artery catheters are rarely inserted in organ donors in most jurisdictions. We propose a novel non-invasive echocardiographic parameter, Pressure-Strain Product (PSP), as a potential surrogate of catheter-based LVSWI. This study aimed to investigate if PSP could correlate with catheter-based LVSWI in an ovine model of brain stem death (BSD) donors. The association between PSP and myocardial mitochondrial function in the post-transplant hearts was also evaluated.

METHODS

Thirty-one female sheep (weight 47 ± 5 kg) were divided into two groups; BSD (n = 15), and sham neurologic injury (n = 16). Echocardiographic parameters including global circumferential strain (GCS) and global radial strain (GRS) and pulmonary artery catheter-based LVSWI were simultaneously measured at 8-timepoints during 24-h observation. PSP was calculated as a product of GCS or GRS, and mean arterial pressure for PSPcirc or PSPrad, respectively. Myocardial mitochondrial function was evaluated following 6-h observation after heart transplantation.

RESULTS

In BSD donor hearts, PSPcirc (n = 96, rho = .547, p < .001) showed the best correlation with LVSWI among other echocardiographic parameters. PSPcirc returned AUC of .825 to distinguish higher values of cardiomyocyte mitochondrial function (cut-off point; mean value of complex 1,2 O2 Flux) in post-transplant hearts, which was greater than other echocardiographic parameters.

CONCLUSIONS

PSPcirc could be used as a surrogate of catheter-based LVSWI reflecting mitochondrial function.

Donor heart ischemic time can be extended beyond 9 hours using hypothermic machine perfusion in sheep

BACKGROUND

The global shortage of donor hearts available for transplantation is a major problem for the treatment of end-stage heart failure. The ischemic time for donor hearts using traditional preservation by standard static cold storage (SCS) is limited to approximately 4 hours, beyond which the risk for primary graft dysfunction (PGD) significantly increases. Hypothermic machine perfusion (HMP) of donor hearts has been proposed to safely extend ischemic time without increasing the risk of PGD.

METHODS

Using our sheep model of 24 hours brain death (BD) followed by orthotopic heart transplantation (HTx), we examined post-transplant outcomes in recipients following donor heart preservation by HMP for 8 hours, compared to donor heart preservation for 2 hours by either SCS or HMP.

RESULTS

Following HTx, all HMP recipients (both 2 hours and 8 hours groups) survived to the end of the study (6 hours after transplantation and successful weaning from cardiopulmonary bypass), required less vasoactive support for hemodynamic stability, and exhibited superior metabolic, fluid status and inflammatory profiles compared to SCS recipients. Contractile function and cardiac damage (troponin I release and histological assessment) was comparable between groups.

CONCLUSIONS

Overall, compared to current clinical SCS, recipient outcomes following transplantation are not adversely impacted by extending HMP to 8 hours. These results have important implications for clinical transplantation where longer ischemic times may be required (e.g., complex surgical cases, transport across long distances). Additionally, HMP may allow safe preservation of "marginal" donor hearts that are more susceptible to myocardial injury and facilitate increased utilization of these hearts for transplantation.

Beneficial Effects of Tacrolimus on Brain-Death-Associated Right Ventricular Dysfunction in Pigs

BACKGROUND

Right ventricular (RV) dysfunction remains a major problem after heart transplantation and may be associated with brain death (BD) in a donor. A calcineurin inhibitor tacrolimus was recently found to have beneficial effects on heart function. Here, we examined whether tacrolimus might prevent BD-induced RV dysfunction and the associated pathobiological changes.

METHODS

After randomized tacrolimus (n = 8; 0.05 mg·kg-1·day-1) or placebo (n = 9) pretreatment, pigs were assigned to a BD procedure and hemodynamically investigated 1, 3, 5, and 7 h after the Cushing reflex. After euthanasia, myocardial tissue was sampled for pathobiological evaluation. Seven pigs were used as controls.

RESULTS

Calcineurin inhibition prevented increases in pulmonary vascular resistance and RV-arterial decoupling induced by BD. BD was associated with an increased RV pro-apoptotic Bax-to-Bcl2 ratio and RV and LV apoptotic rates, which were prevented by tacrolimus. BD induced increased expression of the pro-inflammatory IL-6-to-IL-10 ratio, their related receptors, and vascular cell adhesion molecule-1 in both the RV and LV. These changes were prevented by tacrolimus. RV and LV neutrophil infiltration induced by BD was partly prevented by tacrolimus. BD was associated with decreased RV expression of the β-1 adrenergic receptor and sarcomere (myosin heavy chain [MYH]7-to-MYH6 ratio) components, while β-3 adrenergic receptor, nitric oxide-synthase 3, and glucose transporter 1 expression increased. These changes were prevented by tacrolimus.

CONCLUSIONS

Brain death was associated with isolated RV dysfunction. Tacrolimus prevented RV dysfunction induced by BD through the inhibition of apoptosis and inflammation activation.

Ex-situ oxygenated hypothermic machine perfusion in donation after circulatory death heart transplantation following either direct procurement or in-situ normothermic regional perfusion

BACKGROUND

Heart transplantation in donation after circulatory death (DCD) relies on warm perfusion using either in situ normothermic regional perfusion (NRP) or ex situ normothermic machine perfusion. In this study, we explore an alternative: oxygenated hypothermic machine perfusion (HMP) using a novel clinically applicable perfusion system, which is compared to NRP with static cold storage (SCS).

METHODS

In a porcine model, a DCD setting was simulated, followed by either (1) NRP and SCS (2) NRP and HMP with the XVIVO Heart preservation system or (3) direct procurement (DPP) and HMP. After preservation, heart transplantation (HTX) was performed. After weaning from cardiopulmonary bypass (CPB), biventricular function was assessed by admittance and Swan-Ganz catheters.

RESULTS

Only transplanted hearts in the HMP groups showed significantly increased biventricular contractility (end-systole elastance) 2 hour post-CPB (left ventricle absolute change: NRP HMP: +1.8 ± 0.56, p = 0.047, DPP HMP: +1.5 ± 0.43, p = 0.045 and NRP SCS: +0.97 ± 0.47 mmHg/ml, p = 0.21; right ventricle absolute change: NRP HMP: +0.50 ± 0.12, p = 0.025, DPP HMP: +0.82 ± 0.23, p = 0.039 and NRP SCS: +0.28 ± 0.26, p = 0.52) while receiving significantly less dobutamine to maintain a cardiac output >4l/min compared to SCS. Diastolic function was preserved in all groups. Post-HTX, both HMP groups showed significantly less increments in plasma troponin T compared to SCS.

CONCLUSION

In DCD HTX, increased biventricular contractility post-HTX was only observed in hearts preserved with HMP. In addition, the need for inotropic support and signs of myocardial damage were lower in the HMP groups. DCD HTX can be successfully performed using DPP followed by preservation with HMP in a preclinical setting.

A clinically relevant sheep model of orthotopic heart transplantation 24 h after donor brainstem death

Background

Heart transplantation (HTx) from brainstem dead (BSD) donors is the gold-standard therapy for severe/end-stage cardiac disease, but is limited by a global donor heart shortage. Consequently, innovative solutions to increase donor heart availability and utilisation are rapidly expanding. Clinically relevant preclinical models are essential for evaluating interventions for human translation, yet few exist that accurately mimic all key HTx components, incorporating injuries beginning in the donor, through to the recipient. To enable future assessment of novel perfusion technologies in our research program, we thus aimed to develop a clinically relevant sheep model of HTx following 24 h of donor BSD.

Methods

BSD donors (vs. sham neurological injury, 4/group) were hemodynamically supported and monitored for 24 h, followed by heart preservation with cold static storage. Bicaval orthotopic HTx was performed in matched recipients, who were weaned from cardiopulmonary bypass (CPB), and monitored for 6 h. Donor and recipient blood were assayed for inflammatory and cardiac injury markers, and cardiac function was assessed using echocardiography. Repeated measurements between the two different groups during the study observation period were assessed by mixed ANOVA for repeated measures.

Results

Brainstem death caused an immediate catecholaminergic hemodynamic response (mean arterial pressure, p = 0.09), systemic inflammation (IL-6 - p = 0.025, IL-8 - p = 0.002) and cardiac injury (cardiac troponin I, p = 0.048), requiring vasopressor support (vasopressor dependency index, VDI, p = 0.023), with normalisation of biomarkers and physiology over 24 h. All hearts were weaned from CPB and monitored for 6 h post-HTx, except one (sham) recipient that died 2 h post-HTx. Hemodynamic (VDI - p = 0.592, heart rate - p = 0.747) and metabolic (blood lactate, p = 0.546) parameters post-HTx were comparable between groups, despite the observed physiological perturbations that occurred during donor BSD. All p values denote interaction among groups and time in the ANOVA for repeated measures.

Conclusions

We have successfully developed an ovine HTx model following 24 h of donor BSD. After 6 h of critical care management post-HTx, there were no differences between groups, despite evident hemodynamic perturbations, systemic inflammation, and cardiac injury observed during donor BSD. This preclinical model provides a platform for critical assessment of injury development pre- and post-HTx, and novel therapeutic evaluation.

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s40635-021-00425-4.

Compromised right ventricular contractility in an ovine model of heart transplantation following 24 h donor brain stem death

BACKGROUND

Heart failure is an inexorably progressive disease with a high mortality, for which heart transplantation (HTx) remains the gold standard treatment. Currently, donor hearts are primarily derived from patients following brain stem death (BSD). BSD causes activation of the sympathetic nervous system, increases endothelin levels, and triggers significant inflammation that together with potential myocardial injury associated with the transplant procedure, may affect contractility of the donor heart. We examined peri-transplant myocardial catecholamine sensitivity and cardiac contractility post-BSD and transplantation in a clinically relevant ovine model.

METHODS

Donor sheep underwent BSD (BSD, n = 5) or sham (no BSD) procedures (SHAM, n = 4) and were monitored for 24h prior to heart procurement. Orthotopic HTx was performed on a separate group of donor animals following 24h of BSD (BSD-Tx, n = 6) or SHAM injury (SH-Tx, n = 5). The healthy recipient heart was used as a control (HC, n = 11). A cumulative concentration-effect curve to (-)-noradrenaline (NA) was established using left (LV) and right ventricular (RV) trabeculae to determine β₁-adrenoceptor mediated potency (-logEC₅₀ [(-)-noradrenaline] M) and maximal contractility (Emax).

RESULTS

Our data showed reduced basal and maximal (-)-noradrenaline induced contractility of the RV (but not LV) following BSD as well as HTx, regardless of whether the donor heart was exposed to BSD or SHAM. The potency of (-)-noradrenaline was lower in left and right ventricles for BSD-Tx and SH-Tx compared to HC.

CONCLUSION

These studies show that the combination of BSD and transplantation are likely to impair contractility of the donor heart, particularly for the RV. For the donor heart, this contractile dysfunction appears to be independent of changes to β₁-adrenoceptor sensitivity. However, altered β₁-adrenoceptor signalling is likely to be involved in post-HTx contractile dysfunction.