The local deletion of a microvillar cytoskeleton from photoreceptors of tipulid flies during membrane turnover

The cell biology of the retinal pigment epithelium

The retinal pigment epithelium (RPE), a monolayer of post-mitotic polarized epithelial cells, strategically situated between the photoreceptors and the choroid, is the primary caretaker of photoreceptor health and function. Dysfunction of the RPE underlies many inherited and acquired diseases that cause permanent blindness. Decades of research have yielded valuable insight into the cell biology of the RPE. In recent years, new technologies such as live-cell imaging have resulted in major advancement in our understanding of areas such as the daily phagocytosis and clearance of photoreceptor outer segment tips, autophagy, endolysosome function, and the metabolic interplay between the RPE and photoreceptors. In this review, we aim to integrate these studies with an emphasis on appropriate models and techniques to investigate RPE cell biology and metabolism, and discuss how RPE cell biology informs our understanding of retinal disease.

Ectoplasm, ghost in the R cell machine?

Drosophila photoreceptors (R cells) are an extreme instance of sensory membrane amplification via apical microvilli, a widely deployed and deeply conserved operation of polarized epithelial cells. Developmental rotation of R cell apices aligns rhabdomere microvilli across the optical axis and enables enormous membrane expansion in a new, proximal distal dimension. R cell ectoplasm, the specialized cortical cytoplasm abutting the rhabdomere is likewise enormously amplified. Ectoplasm is dominated by the actin-rich terminal web, a conserved operational domain of the ancient vesicle-transport motor, Myosin V. R cells harness Myosin V to move two distinct cargoes, the biosynthetic traffic that builds the rhabdomere during development, and the migration of pigment granules that mediates the adaptive "longitudinal pupil" in adults, using two distinct Rab proteins. Ectoplasm further shapes a distinct cortical endosome compartment, the subrhabdomeral cisterna (SRC), vital to normal cell function. Reticulon, a protein that promotes endomembrane curvature, marks the SRC. R cell visual arrestin 2 (Arr2) is predominantly cytoplasmic in dark-adapted photoreceptors but on illumination it translocates to the rhabdomere, where it quenches ongoing photosignaling by binding to activated metarhodopsin. Arr2 translocation is "powered" by diffusion; a motor is not required to move Arr2 and ectoplasm does not obstruct its rapid diffusion to the rhabdomere.

Endocytosis, the sorting problem and cell locomotion in fibroblasts

Fibroblasts endocytose lipid plus a subset of plasma membrane proteins over their entire surface and reinsert this into the plasma membrane at the cell's leading edge. This process is used to extend the fibroblast forwards. This circulation causes a flow of these endocytosed molecules over the cell's surface. Molecules, such as proteins, sitting in this flow can distribute themselves randomly by Brownian motion, but large objects (or small tethered ones) cannot. These large objects therefore cap. A mechanism is presented whereby this process could be used for locomotion using many weak interactions with the substrate. In addition it is suggested that the observed selectivity of coated pits may be sufficient to sort out proteins during transfer of membrane from one organelle to another so that the specific characters of the parent membranes are maintained.

The extrarhabdomeral cytoskeleton in photoreceptors of Diptera. II. Plasmalemmal undercoats

The plasmalemmal undercoats of those regions of the photoreceptors of the blowfly Lucilia that flank the central extracellular space of each ommatidium are described from en face and transverse thin sections. Labile structures were stabilized before fixation for electron microscopy by using an inhibitor of thiol proteases, Ep-475, as described in the previous paper (Blest et al., Proc. R. Soc. Lond . B 220, 339-352, 1984). Membranes of R 1-6 are underlain by a closely associated, randomly organized filamentous meshwork. That of the basal region of R 7 is highly organized, and consists of very long, about 8 nm filaments running parallel to each other and to the longitudinal ommatidial axis; these ‘backbone’ filaments are tightly adherent to the plasma membrane, and are spaced some 190-200 nm apart. They are linked by abundant transverse filaments that form a reticulum between them. The degree of ordering of the reticulum in life is not clear, but some well-preserved profiles suggest that it may be high. Replicas obtained by the freeze-fracture technique show that extrarhabdomeral membranes have dense populations of intramembrane particles, just as they do in Drosophila where a genetic analysis has shown them to consist largely of rhodopsin. It is proposed as a working hypothesis that these planar membranes can be regarded as flat equivalents of the microvillar membranes, that some fraction of the integral membrane proteins may be immobilized by bonding to the plasmalemmal undercoat, and that the latter may help to constrain both the translational and rotational movements of rhodopsin molecules.

Post-embryonic development of the principal retina of a jumping spider. II. The acquisition and reorganization of rhabdomeres and growth of the glial matrix

An accompanying paper by Blest ( Phil. Trans. R. Soc. Lond. B 320, 489 (1988 b )) describes the conformational changes undergone by principal retinae of a salticid spider during post-embryonic development, and identifies the origins of the tiered receptor mosaics. We now discuss the ultrastructural morphogenesis of the individual receptive segments, with particular reference to the growth of microvilli, to the achievement of light-guide properties by rhabdomeres of the foveal mosaic of Layer I, and to putative mechanisms that ensure that inter-receptor spacings are optically apt. 1. Establishment of the tiered retina by conformational changes precedes the first appearance of plasmalemmal microvilli in all four Layers of receptive segments. Microvilli are first differentiated in the ventral retina. 2. Short, irregular microvilli, initially interdigitated, appear on the plasmalemmae of receptive segments around day 10 of post-embryonic development. They progressively lengthen, cease to be inter-digitated, and become more regular throughout subsequent development, during the moult to the second instar at day 12, and until day 15 when spiderlings become fully independent and principal retinae attain their final conformation. 3. Until late in development, after the moult to the second instar, foveal Layer I receptive segments are contiguous, and densely occupied by organelles. The six glial strands that flank each receptive segment are prominent. A transformation between days 14 and 15 variously reduces or eliminates the glial columns, and, by endocytosis, the plasmalemmal areas of the receptive segments. The Layer I cytoplasm is stripped of organelles other than microtubules. Consequently, receptive segments become separated from each other, and their rhabdomeres can perform as light-guides. 4. Over the same period, receptive segments of Layers II-IV slowly acquire the dense population of mitochondria that have been shown to equilibrate the refractive indices of rhabdomeres and their surrounds. 5. Final conformational changes to the retinae and the establishment of definitive spacings between receptive segments seem to be assured by the differential growth and local involution of the finely divided glial processes intercalated between them. Despite some caveats, it is argued that this protracted sequence of events is consistent with a limited degree of ontogenetic recapitulation. In particular, it is remarkable that the early states of the nascent microvilli so closely resemble those found in less advanced families of spiders.

The extrarhabdomeral cytoskeleton in photoreceptors of Diptera. I. Labile components in the cytoplasm

Labile cytoskeletal structures in the cytoplasm of photoreceptors of the blowfly Lucilia and of Drosophila were stabilized before primary fixation for electron microscopy by retinal infiltration with two inhibitors of thiol proteases, Ep-459 or Ep-475. Alternatively, pretreatments employed EGTA in combination with the Ca 2+ ionophore A23187. The following cytoskeletal structures were revealed, (i) Radial, robust filaments run roughly parallel to the axes of the rhabdomeral microvilli and may be continuous with the axial microvillar filaments. They have diameters of 8 nm upwards, and are occasionally seen to be in association with radial microtubules and with pigment granules. (ii) Slender radial filaments with diameters in the 6-8 nm range extend for shorter distances from the bases of microvilli, and are also associated with endocytotic structures. (iii) The receptor cytoplasm is densely occupied by an ill-defined, filamentous network. (iv) Bundles of slender filaments run longitudinally on each side of rhabdoms of R 1-6 in Lucilia , close to the plasma membrane. Dimensions cited for all categories of filament must be treated with caution because of problems of resolution. Photoreceptors do not bind the fluorescent F-actin probe NBD-phallacidin either without or after treatment with thiol protease inhibitors, and slender filaments are of greater diameter than the 4-5 nm obtained for identified actin filaments in the basement membrane of the compound eye of Lucilia . Infiltration of retinae with Ep-459 or Ep-475 neither prejudices phototransduction, nor impairs the radial migrations of granules of screening pigment in response to light or dark adaption. The status of these cytoskeletal elements is discussed in terms of the dynamic processes of the photoreceptors, and of various labile filaments described from recent studies of vertebrate material using the deep-etch freeze-fracture technique.

Role of the ninaC proteins in photoreceptor cell structure: ultrastructure of ninaC deletion mutants and binding to actin filaments

The ninaC proteins are found in Drosophila photoreceptor cells. Their primary sequences suggest they are kinase/myosin chimeras, but their myosin head-like domain is the most divergent amongst all the myosin-like proteins described to date. To investigate possible roles of the ninaC proteins in cell structure, we examined the ultrastructure of the photoreceptor cells in various ninaC mutants, and tested the ability of the proteins to interact with actin filaments in a myosin-like manner. In flies lacking the larger ninaC protein, p174, an ultrastructural phenotype was evident before eclosion. The axial actin cytoskeleton of the rhabdomeral microvilli appeared either fragmented or as an isolated structure, without linkage to the microvillar membrane. Deletion of the myosin head-like domain or the calmodulin-binding domain of p174 resulted in a similar abnormal cytoskeleton. Breakdown of the rhabdomeres followed, although at different rates depending on the deletion. Lack of the smaller protein, p132, per se did not result in photoreceptor degeneration, but in older flies there was an abnormal accumulation of multivesicular bodies. Moreover, the presence of p132 retarded the degeneration that occurs in the absence of p174, even though the p132 remained outside the rhabdomere. Biochemical studies showed that both ninaC proteins bind actin filaments and cosediment with actin filaments in an ATP-sensitive manner. These results outline structural roles for the ninaC proteins, and are consistent with the notion, suggested by their amino acid sequences, that the proteins are actin-based mechanoenzymes.

Actin depolymerization is not involved in phototransduction

The rhabdomeral microvilli in the eyes of invertebrates have a cytoskeletal core (Saibil, 1982; Blest et al., 1982a, b, 1983) of actin (de Couet et al., 1984; Arikawa et al., 1990; Williams, 1991; Caiman & Chamberlain, 1992) which might be involved in phototransduction. Tsukita et al. (1988) suggested that light stimulation triggers the breakdown of the microvillar actin filament complex and that this may play a role in phototransduction. To test their suggestion, we pressure-injected phalloidin into Limulus ventral photoreceptors to prevent actin depolymerization (Cooper, J.A., 1987) and tested to see if this blocked phototransduction. We have previously shown that injected rho-damine-phalloidin brightly labels the microvillar actin filaments in living Limulus ventral photoreceptors for several hours (Feng et al., 1994). In the experiments reported here, phalloidin unconjugated with fluorophore was used, and the final concentration in the cell after many small injections from a pipette containing 10 mg/ml phalloidin was estimated to be 1 mg/ml (1.2 mM). This concentration is 100 times higher than that used in an extracted cellular preparation to stabilize actin (Biegel & Pachter, 1992). Fig. 1 shows that the responses to steps of light at different intensities are normal 1 h after phalloidin injection. Similar results were obtained in two other cells.

Three-dimensional organization of endoplasmic reticulum in the ventral photoreceptors of Limulus

Living Limulus ventral photoreceptor cells were injected with long chain lipophilic carbocyanine fluorescent dyes to label the endoplasmic reticulum (ER). The purpose of this study was to examine the continuity, dynamic changes, and structure of the ER in the living cell, using laser scanning confocal microscopy and three-dimensional image reconstruction. In this highly polarized neuron, three lines of evidence indicate that the ER is a continuous network extending throughout both lobes of the cell. First, injection of DiO or DiI results in the labeling of ER throughout both lobes of the cell. Second, three-dimensional image reconstruction of the optical sections reveals a dispersed membrane meshwork which may be the structure that serves to interconnect the ER in the two lobes. Third, in cells fixed before dye injection, the pattern of labeling was similar to that in living cells, indicating that vesicle transport was not responsible for the spread of dye throughout the cell. The overall organization of the ER in the photoreceptor cell is relatively stable; however, the fine structure changes over time. This dynamic process appears to represent continual reorganization of the intracellular membranes in the cell. Three morphological types of ER were observed. The ER of the light-sensitive lobe, identified by coinjection of rhodamine-phalloidin to label the microvillar actin, is characterized by a concentration of stratiform membranes interconnected by thin tubular cross-bridges. The perinuclear ER is characterized by a tangle of convoluted tubules sometimes terminating in bulbous structures. Finally, there is a fine tubular reticulum dispersed throughout the cell.

Localization of actin filaments and microtubules in the cells of the Limulus lateral and ventral eyes

The ommatidia of the lateral eye of the horseshoe crab, Limulus polyphemus, undergo rhythmic changes in structure that are driven by diurnal lighting and efferent neural activity from a circadian clock in the brain. This study uses cytochemical probes to investigate the cytoskeletal elements mediating these responses and to develop models for their control. Antibodies to actin and phallodin, a specific F-actin probe, label the rhabdom of lateral eye ommatidia, the cone cells of the ommatidial aperture, the ommatidial sheath, and the peripheral regions of the photoreceptor (retinular cell) cytoplasm. These probes also label the rhabdomere of ventral photoreceptors. Antibodies to tubulin label the eccentric cell dendrite and soma in each lateral eye ommatidium, the cone cells of the aperture, and the peripheral retinular cell cytoplasm. Models are proposed for the cytoskeletal mechanisms involved in controlling aperture and rhabdom shape, pigment movement, and shedding of rhabdomeral membrane.

The distribution of actin immunoreactivity in rhabdomeres of tipulid flies in relation to extracellular membrane shedding

Rhabdomeres of tipulid flies lose membrane during turnover from a 'shedding zone' composed of microvillar tips. These distal domains lack intramicrovillar cytoskeletons and appear to be empty sacs of membrane. Recent concerns about the role of ninaC mechano-enzymes in the architecture of dipteran rhabdomeral microvilli and the dynamic role that they may play in the creation of shedding zones demand an examination of the distribution of actin in tipulid rhabdomeres. We compared rhabdomeres from tipulid retinae incubated before fixation for immunocytochemistry in a buffer without additives and a stabilising buffer that contained a cocktail of cysteine protease inhibitors; both were challenged by an anti-actin antibody for immunogold labelling after embedding in LR White Resin. Shedding zones thus processed collapse to structureless detritus. Stabilised and unstabilized shedding zones were immunonegative to anti-actin. To ensure that the negative results were not consequent upon conformational changes generated by the processing protocol, we examined microvilli of degenerating rhabdomeres of the Drosophila light-dependent retinal degeneration mutant rdgBKS222 (which separate and collapse without creating a shedding zone) and found the detritus they generate to be immunopositive to anti-actin. Stabilised and unstabilized regions of basal regions of tipulid rhabdomeres were equally immunopositive. We infer that (a) actin is absent from shedding zones; (b) actin is not degraded by microvillar cysteine proteases. The implications of these conclusions are discussed in relation to some functional models of arthropod photoreceptor microvilli.

Actin filaments and photoreceptor membrane turnover

The shape and turnover of photoreceptor membranes appears to depend on associated actin filaments. In dipterans, the photoreceptor membrane is microvillar. It is turned over by the addition of new membrane at the bases of the microvilli and by subsequent shedding, mostly from the distal ends. Each microvillus contains actin filaments as a component of its cytoskeletal core. Two myosin I-like proteins co-localize with the actin filaments. It is suggested that one of the myosin I-like proteins might be linked to the microvillar membrane. By interacting with the actin filaments, this motor should move the membrane of a microvillus in a distal direction, thus providing a possible mechanism for the turnover of the membrane. A vertebrate photoreceptor cell contains a small cluster of actin filaments in its connecting cilium at the site where new transductive disk membranes are formed. Disruption of the actin filaments perturbs disk morphogenesis. The most likely explanation for this perturbation is that the process of initiating a new disk is inhibited. Conventional myosin (myosin II) is found in the connecting cilium with the same distribution as actin. A simple model is proposed to illustrate how the actin-myosin system of the connecting cilium might function to initiate the morphogenesis of a disk membrane.

Phototransduction: different mechanisms in vertebrates and invertebrates

The photoreceptor cells of invertebrate animals differ from those of vertebrates in morphology and physiology. Our present knowledge of the different structures and transduction mechanisms of the two animal groups is described. In invertebrates, rhodopsin is converted by light into a meta-rhodopsin which is thermally stable and is usually re-isomerized by light. In contrast, photoisomerization in vertebrates leads to dissociation of the chromophore from opsin, and a metabolic process is necessary to regenerate rhodopsin. The electrical signals of visual excitation have opposite character in vertebrates and invertebrates: the vertebrate photoreceptor cell is hyperpolarized because of a decrease in conductance and invertebrate photoreceptors are depolarized owing to an increase in conductance. Single-photon-evoked excitatory events, which are believed to be a result of concerted action (the opening in invertebrates and the closing in vertebrates) of many light-modulated cation channels, are very different in terms of size and time course of photoreceptors for invertebrates and vertebrates. In invertebrates, the single-photon events (bumps) produced under identical conditions vary greatly in delay (latency), time course and size. The multiphoton response to brighter stimuli is several times as long as a response evoked by a single photon. The single-photon response of vertebrates has a standard size, a standard latency and a standard time course, all three parameters showing relatively small variations. Responses to flashes containing several photons have a shape and time scale that are similar to the single-photon-evoked events, varying only by an amplitude scaling factor, but not in latency and time course. In both vertebrate and invertebrate photoreceptors the single-photon-evoked events become smaller (in size) and faster owing to light adaptation. Calcium is mainly involved in these adaptation phenomena. All light adaptation in vertebrates is primarily, or perhaps exclusively, attributable to calcium feedback. In invertebrates, cyclic AMP (cAMP) is apparently another controller of sensitivity in dark adaptation. The interaction of photoexcited rhodopsin with a G-protein is similar in both vertebrate and invertebrate photoreceptors. However, these G-proteins activate different photoreceptor enzymes (phosphodiesterases): phospholipase C in invertebrates and cGMP phosphodiesterase in vertebrates. In the photoreceptors of vertebrates light leads to a rapid hydrolysis of cGMP which results in closing of cation channels. At present, the identity of the internal terminal messenger in invertebrate photoreceptors is still unsolved.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Identification of actin filaments in the rhabdomeral microvilli of Drosophila photoreceptors

The phototransductive microvilli of arthropod photoreceptors each contain an axial cytoskeleton. The present study shows that actin filaments are a component of this cytoskeleton in Drosophila. Firstly, actin was detected in the rhabdomeral microvilli and in the subrhabdomeral cytoplasm by immunogold labeling with antiactin. Secondly, the rhabdomeres were labeled with phalloidin, indicating the presence of filamentous actin. Finally, the actin filaments were decorated with myosin subfragment-1. The characteristic arrowhead complex formed by subfragment-1 decoration points towards the base of the microvilli, so that the fast growing end of each filament is at the distal end of the microvillus, where it is embedded in a detergent-resistant cap. Each microvillus contains more than one actin filament. Decorated filaments extend the entire length of each microvillus and project into the subrhabdomeral cytoplasm. This organization is comparable to that of the actin filaments in intestinal brush border microvilli. Similar observations were made with the photoreceptor microvilli of the crayfish, Procambarus. Our results provide an indication as to how any myosin that is associated with the rhabdomeres might function.

Anti-actin immunoreactivity is retained in rhabdoms of Drosophila ninaC photoreceptors

The Drosophila ninaC mutation produces small rhabdomeres with the axial filament of the microvillar cytoskeleton reduced or missing. Using post-embedding immunogold labelling of LR White-embedded eyes, we show that several alleles of this mutation retain positive anti-actin immunoreactivity in the rhabdomeres, comparable to that of wild-type flies.

Membrane-associated actin in the rhabdomeral microvilli of crayfish photoreceptors

Infiltration of compound eyes of crayfish, Cherax destructor, with the thiol protease inhibitor Ep-475 or with trifluoperazine prior to fixation for electron microscopy was found to stabilize an axial filament of 6-12 nm diam within each rhabdomeral microvillus of the photoreceptors. Rhabdoms isolated from retinal homogenates by sucrose gradient centrifugation under conditions that stabilize cytoskeletal material contained large amounts of a 42-kd polypeptide that co-migrated with insect flight muscle actin in one- and two-dimensional PAGE, inhibited pancreatic DNase l, and bound to vertebrate myosin. Vertebrate skeletal muscle actin added to retinal homogenates did not co-purify with rhabdoms, implying that actin was not a contaminant from nonmembranous structures. DNase l inhibition assays of detergent-lysed rhabdoms indicated the presence of large amounts of filamentous actin provided ATP was present. Monomeric actin in such preparations was completely polymerizable only after 90 min incubation with equimolar phalloidin. More than half of the actin present could be liberated from the membrane by sonication, indicating a loose association with the membrane. However, a large proportion of the actin was tightly bound to the rhabdomeral membrane, and washing sonicated membrane fractions with solutions of a range of ionic strengths and nonionic detergents failed to remove it. Antibodies to scallop actin only bound to frozen sections of rhabdoms after gentle permeabilization and very long incubation periods, probably because of steric hindrance and the hydrophobicity of the structure. The F-actin probe nitrobenzoxadiazol phallacidin bound to rhabdoms and labeled F-actin aggregates in other retinal components, but rhabdom fluorescence was not abolished by preincubation with phalloidin. The biochemical data indicate the existence of two distinct actin-based cytoskeletal systems, one being closely membrane associated. The other may possibly constitute the axial filament, although the evidence for this is equivocal.

Phagocytosis of rhabdomeral membrane by crab photoreceptors (Leptograpsus variegatus)

Many crabs possess fused rhabdoms which are partly broken down at dawn and re-synthesised at dusk. The cross-sectional area of the rhabdom is therefore smaller during the day than at night. The only previously described mechanism of membrane removal from the rhabdomere in Crustacea involves the formation of pinocytotic vesicles at the bases of the microvilli. The geometry of the rhabdom is such that uniform pinocytosis across the base of each rhabdomere would result in a stack of orthogonally oriented rectangles. In the process described here, microvilli from the outer edges of the rhabdomeres are engulfed by adjacent retinula cells, reducing the number as well as the length of the microvilli and maintaining the smooth longitudinal profile needed for optimal functioning of the rhabdom.