Characterization of the FNR protein of Escherichia coli, an iron-binding transcriptional regulator

Transcriptional Regulation of Gene Expression by Metalloproteins

FNR and SoxR are transcriptional regulators containing an iron–sulfur cluster. The iron–sulfur cluster in FNR acts as an oxygen sensor by reacting with oxygen. The structural change of the iron–sulfur cluster takes place when FNR senses oxygen, which regulates the transcriptional regulator activity of FNR through the change of the quaternary structure. SoxR contains the [2Fe–2S] cluster that regulates the transcriptional activator activity of SoxR. Only the oxidized SoxR containing the [2Fe–2S]2+ cluster is active as the transcriptional activator. CooA is a transcriptional activator containing a protoheme that acts as a CO sensor. CO is a physiological effector of CooA and regulates the transcriptional activator activity of CooA. In this review, the biochemical and biophysical properties of FNR, SoxR, and CooA are described.

Lysine acetylation regulates the function of the global anaerobic transcription factor FnrL in Rhodobacter sphaeroides

The metabolism of the purple non-sulfur bacterium Rhodobacter sphaeroides is versatile and it can grow under various conditions. Here, we report evidence that the anaerobic photosynthetic metabolism of R. sphaeroides is regulated by protein lysine acetylation. Using a proteomic approach, 59 acetylated peptides were detected. Among them is the global anaerobic transcription factor FnrL, which regulates the biosynthetic pathway of tetrapyrroles and synthesis of the photosynthetic apparatus. Lysine 223 of FnrL was identified as acetylated. We show that all three lysines in the DNA binding domain (K223, K213 and K175) of FnrL can be acetylated by acetyl-phosphate in vitro. A bacterial deacetylase homolog, RsCobB can deacetylate FnrL in vitro. The transcription of genes downstream of FnrL decreased when the DNA binding domain of FnrL was acetylated, as revealed by chromatin immunoprecipitation and acetylation-mimicking mutagenesis. An increasing number of acetylated lysines resulted in a further decrease in DNA binding ability. These results demonstrate that the lysine acetylation can fine tune the function of the oxygen-sensitive FnrL; thus, it might regulate anaerobic photosynthetic metabolism of R. sphaeroides.

Composing a Tumor Specific Bacterial Promoter

Systemically applied Salmonella enterica spp. have been shown to invade and colonize neoplastic tissues where it retards the growth of many tumors. This offers the possibility to use the bacteria as a vehicle for the tumor specific delivery of therapeutic molecules. Specificity of such delivery is solely depending on promoter sequences that control the production of a target molecule. We have established the functional structure of bacterial promoters that are transcriptionally active exclusively in tumor tissues after systemic application. We observed that the specific transcriptional activation is accomplished by a combination of a weak basal promoter and a strong FNR binding site. This represents a minimal set of control elements required for such activation. In natural promoters, additional DNA remodeling elements are found that alter the level of transcription quantitatively. Inefficiency of the basal promoter ensures the absence of transcription outside tumors. As a proof of concept, we compiled an artificial promoter sequence from individual motifs representing FNR and basal promoter and showed specific activation in a tumor microenvironment. Our results open possibilities for the generation of promoters with an adjusted level of expression of target proteins in particular for applications in bacterial tumor therapy.

The ins and outs of bacterial iron metabolism

Iron is a critical nutrient for the growth and survival of most bacterial species. Accordingly, much attention has been paid to the mechanisms by which host organisms sequester iron from invading bacteria and how bacteria acquire iron from their environment. However, under oxidative stress conditions such as those encountered within phagocytic cells during the host immune response, iron is released from proteins and can act as a catalyst for Fenton chemistry to produce cytotoxic reactive oxygen species. The transitory efflux of free intracellular iron may be beneficial to bacteria under such conditions. The recent discovery of putative iron efflux transporters in Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium is discussed in the context of cellular iron homeostasis.

An integrative computational approach to effectively guide experimental identification of regulatory elements in promoters

Background

Transcriptional activity of genes depends on many factors like DNA motifs, conformational characteristics of DNA, melting etc. and there are computational approaches for their identification. However, in real applications, the number of predicted, for example, DNA motifs may be considerably large. In cases when various computational programs are applied, systematic experimental knock out of each of the potential elements obviously becomes nonproductive. Hence, one needs an approach that is able to integrate many heterogeneous computational methods and upon that suggest selected regulatory elements for experimental verification.

Results

Here, we present an integrative bioinformatic approach aimed at the discovery of regulatory modules that can be effectively verified experimentally. It is based on combinatorial analysis of known and novel binding motifs, as well as of any other known features of promoters. The goal of this method is the identification of a collection of modules that are specific for an established dataset and at the same time are optimal for experimental verification. The method is particularly effective on small datasets, where most statistical approaches fail. We apply it to promoters that drive tumor-specific gene expression in tumor-colonizing Gram-negative bacteria. The method successfully identified a number of potential modules, which required only a few experiments to be verified. The resulting minimal functional bacterial promoter exhibited high specificity of expression in cancerous tissue.

Conclusions

Experimental analysis of promoter structures guided by bioinformatics has proved to be efficient. The developed computational method is able to include heterogeneous features of promoters and suggest combinatorial modules for experimental testing. Expansibility and robustness of the methodology implemented in the approach ensures good results for a wide range of problems.

A proteomic and transcriptomic approach reveals new insight into beta-methylthiolation of Escherichia coli ribosomal protein S12

β-methylthiolation is a novel post-translational modification mapping to a universally conserved Asp 88 of the bacterial ribosomal protein S12. This S12 specific modification has been identified on orthologs from multiple bacterial species. The origin and functional significance was investigated with both a proteomic strategy to identify candidate S12 interactors and expression microarrays to search for phenotypes that result from targeted gene knockouts of select candidates. Utilizing an endogenous recombinant E. coli S12 protein with an affinity tag as bait, mass spectrometric analysis identified candidate S12 binding partners including RimO (previously shown to be required for this post-translational modification) and YcaO, a conserved protein of unknown function. Transcriptomic analysis of bacterial strains with deleted genes for RimO and YcaO identified an overlapping transcriptional phenotype suggesting that YcaO and RimO likely share a common function. As a follow up, quantitative mass spectrometry additionally indicated that both proteins dramatically impacted the modification status of S12. Collectively, these results indicate that the YcaO protein is involved in β-methylthiolation of S12 and its absence impairs the ability of RimO to modify S12. Additionally, the proteomic data from this study provides direct evidence that the E. coli specific β-methylthiolation likely occurs when S12 is assembled as part of a ribosomal subunit.

Reactions of nitric oxide and oxygen with the regulator of fumarate and nitrate reduction, a global transcriptional regulator, during anaerobic growth of Escherichia coli

The Escherichia coli fumarate and nitrate reductase (FNR) regulator protein is an important transcriptional regulator that controls the expression of a large regulon of more than 100 genes in response to changes in oxygen availability. FNR is active when it acquires a [4Fe-4S](2+) cluster under anaerobic conditions. The presence of the [4Fe-4S](2+) cluster promotes protein dimerization and site-specific DNA binding, facilitating activation or repression of target promoters. Oxygen is sensed by the controlled disassembly of the [4Fe-4S](2+) cluster, ultimately resulting in inactive, monomeric, apo-FNR. The FNR [4Fe-4S](2+) cluster is also sensitive to nitric oxide, such that under anaerobic conditions the protein is inactivated by nitrosylation of the iron-sulfur cluster, yielding a mixture of monomeric and dimeric dinitrosyl-iron cysteine species. This chapter describes some of the methods used to produce active [4Fe-4S] FNR protein and investigates the reaction of the [4Fe-4S](2+) cluster with nitric oxide and oxygen in vitro.

Reduced apo-fumarate nitrate reductase regulator (apoFNR) as the major form of FNR in aerobically growing Escherichia coli

Under anoxic conditions, the Escherichia coli oxygen sensor FNR (fumarate nitrate reductase regulator) is in the active state and contains a [4Fe-4S] cluster. Oxygen converts [4Fe-4S]FNR to inactive [2Fe-2S]FNR. After prolonged exposure to air in vitro, apoFNR lacking a Fe-S cluster is formed. ApoFNR can be differentiated from Fe-S-containing forms by the accessibility of the five Cys thiol residues, four of which serve as ligands for the Fe-S cluster. The presence of apoFNR in aerobically and anaerobically grown E. coli was analyzed in situ using thiol reagents. In anaerobically and aerobically grown cells, the membrane-permeable monobromobimane labeled one to two and four Cys residues, respectively; the same labeling pattern was found with impermeable thiol reagents after cell permeabilization. Alkylation of FNR in aerobic bacteria and counting the labeled residues by mass spectrometry showed a form of FNR with five accessible Cys residues, corresponding to apoFNR with all Cys residues in the thiol state. Therefore, aerobically growing cells contain apoFNR, whereas a significant amount of Fe-S-containing FNR was not detected under these conditions. Exposure of anaerobic bacteria to oxygen caused conversion of Fe-S-containing FNR to apoFNR within 6 min. ApoFNR from aerobic bacteria contained no disulfide, in contrast to apoFNR formed in vitro by air inactivation, and all Cys residues were in the thiol form.

In vivo demonstration of FNR dimers in response to lower O(2) availability

Escherichia coli FNR is an O(2)-sensing transcription factor. In vitro studies indicate that anaerobic iron-sulfur cluster acquisition promotes FNR dimerization. Here, two-hybrid assays show that iron-sulfur cluster-dependent FNR dimers are formed in vivo in response to lower O(2) availability, consistent with the current model of FNR activation.

In vivo cycling of the Escherichia coli transcription factor FNR between active and inactive states

FNR proteins are transcription regulators that sense changes in oxygen availability via assembly-disassembly of [4Fe-4S] clusters. The Escherichia coli FNR protein is present in bacteria grown under aerobic and anaerobic conditions. Under aerobic conditions, FNR is isolated as an inactive monomeric apoprotein, whereas under anaerobic conditions, FNR is present as an active dimeric holoprotein containing one [4Fe-4S] cluster per subunit. It has been suggested that the active and inactive forms of FNR are interconverted in vivo, or that iron-sulphur clusters are mostly incorporated into newly synthesized FNR. Here, experiments using a thermo-inducible fnr expression plasmid showed that a model FNR-dependent promoter is activated under anaerobic conditions by FNR that was synthesized under aerobic conditions. Immunoblots suggested that FNR was more prone to degradation under aerobic compared with anaerobic conditions, and that the ClpXP protease contributes to this degradation. Nevertheless, FNR was sufficiently long lived (half-life under aerobic conditions, approximately 45 min) to allow cycling between active and inactive forms. Measuring the abundance of the FNR-activated dms transcript when chloramphenicol-treated cultures were switched between aerobic and anaerobic conditions showed that it increased when cultures were switched to anaerobic conditions, and decreased when aerobic conditions were restored. In contrast, measurement of the abundance of the FNR-repressed ndh transcript under the same conditions showed that it decreased upon switching to anaerobic conditions, and then increased when aerobic conditions were restored. The abundance of the FNR- and oxygen-independent tatE transcript was unaffected by changes in oxygen availability. Thus, the simplest explanation for the observations reported here is that the FNR protein can be switched between inactive and active forms in vivo in the absence of de novo protein synthesis.

Bacterial redox sensors

Redox reactions pervade living cells. They are central to both anabolic and catabolic metabolism. The ability to maintain redox balance is therefore vital to all organisms. Various regulatory sensors continually monitor the redox state of the internal and external environments and control the processes that work to maintain redox homeostasis. In response to redox imbalance, new metabolic pathways are initiated, the repair or bypassing of damaged cellular components is coordinated and systems that protect the cell from further damage are induced. Advances in biochemical analyses are revealing a range of elegant solutions that have evolved to allow bacteria to sense different redox signals.

Mechanism of oxygen sensing by the bacterial transcription factor fumarate-nitrate reduction (FNR)

The facultative anaerobe Escherichia coli adopts different metabolic modes in response to the availability of oxygen. The global transcriptional regulator FNR (fumarate-nitrate reduction) monitors the availability of oxygen in the environment. Binding as a homodimer to palindromic sequences of DNA, FNR carries a sensory domain, remote from the DNA binding helix-turn-helix motif, which responds to oxygen. The sensing mechanism involves the transformation of a [4Fe-4S](2+) cluster into a [2Fe-2S] form in vitro on reaction with oxygen. Evidence is presented to show that this process proceeds by at least two steps, the first, an oxidative one, being the formation, on reaction with O(2), of a [3Fe-4S](1+) cluster as an intermediate accompanied by the production of hydrogen peroxide. This is followed by a slower, non-redox, pseudo-first order step in which the [3Fe-4S](1+) form converts to a [2Fe-2S](2+) cluster. This must be accompanied by a substantial protein conformational change since the four cysteine ligands that bind the two forms of the FeS clusters have different spatial disposition. Hydrogen peroxide is also an oxidant of the [4Fe-4S](2+), causing a similar cluster transformation to a [2Fe-2S] form. Either the hydrogen peroxide formed on reaction with oxygen can be recycled by intracellular catalase or it can be used to oxidize further Fe-S clusters. In both cases, the efficacy of oxygen sensing by FNR will be increased.

Anaerobic acquisition of [4FE 4S] clusters by the inactive FNR(C20S) variant and restoration of activity by second-site amino acid substitutions

The FNR protein of Escherichia coli controls the transcription of target genes in response to anoxia. The anaerobic incorporation of oxygen-sensitive [4Fe 4S] clusters promotes dimerization, which in turn enhances DNA binding. Four potential iron ligands (C20, C23, C29 and C122) are essential for normal FNR activity in vivo. Three FNR variants (C20S, C23G and C29G) retained the ability to incorporate oxygen-sensitive [4Fe 4S] clusters and to bind target DNA with essentially unimpaired affinity, suggesting that their failure to function normally in vivo resides at a later stage in the signal transduction pathway. The C122 variant failed to assemble iron-sulphur clusters and to bind DNA. Second-site substitutions that partially restore activity to FNR(C20S) were generated by error-prone polymerase chain reaction and were located in the dimer interface, in the activating regions (AR1, 2 or 3) or close to C122. Substitutions at E47, R48, E123, I124, E127 or T128 allowed the extent of the FNR AR2 surface to be defined. Only one revertant, FNR(C20S Y69F G149S), specifically corrected the C20S defect. It was concluded that [4Fe 4S] cluster acquisition, dimerization and DNA binding are not sufficient to confer transcription regulatory activity on FNR: the iron-sulphur cluster must also be correctly liganded in order to establish effective activating contacts between FNR and RNA polymerase.

Substitution of leucine 28 with histidine in the Escherichia coli transcription factor FNR results in increased stability of the [4Fe-4S](2+) cluster to oxygen

To understand the role of the [4Fe-4S](2+) cluster in controlling the activity of the Escherichia coli transcription factor FNR (fumarate nitrate reduction) during changes in O(2) availability, we have characterized a mutant FNR protein containing a substitution of Leu-28 with His (FNR-L28H) which, unlike its wild type (WT) counterpart, is functional under aerobic growth conditions. The His-28 substitution appears to stabilize the [4Fe-4S](2+) cluster of FNR-L28H in the presence of O(2) because air-exposed FNR-L28H did not undergo the rapid [4Fe-4S](2+) to [2Fe-2S](2+) cluster conversion or concomitant loss in site-specific DNA binding and dimerization, which are characteristic of WT-FNR under these conditions. This increased cluster stability was not a result of His-28 replacing the WT-FNR cluster ligands because substitution of any of these four Cys residues (cysteine 20, 23, 29, or 122) with Ser resulted in [4Fe-4S](2+) cluster-deficient preparations of FNR-L28H. The Mössbauer spectra of FNR-L28H indicated that the coordination environment of the [4Fe-4S](2+) cluster did not differ from that of WT-FNR. Whole cell Mössbauer spectroscopy showed that aerobically grown cells overexpressing FNR-L28H had levels of the FNR species containing the [4Fe-4S](2+) cluster similar to those of cells grown under anaerobic conditions. Thus, the increase in cluster stability is sufficient to allow accumulation of the [4Fe-4S](2+) cluster form of FNR-L28H under aerobic conditions and provides a reasonable explanation for why this mutant protein is functional under aerobic growth conditions. From these results, we present a model to explain how WT-FNR is normally inactivated under aerobic growth conditions.

Characterization of the Lactococcus lactis transcription factor FlpA and demonstration of an in vitro switch

The commercially important bacterium Lactococcus lactis contains two FNR-like proteins (FlpA and FlpB) which have a high degree of identity to each other and to the FLP of Lactobacillus casei. FlpA was isolated from a GST-FlpA fusion protein produced in Escherichia coli. Like FLP, isolated FlpA is a homodimeric protein containing both Zn and Cu. However, the properties of FlpA were more like those of the E. coli oxygen-responsive transcription factor FNR than the FLP of L. casei. As prepared FlpA recognized an FNR site (TTGAT-N4-ATCAA) but not an FLP site (CCTGA-N4-TCAGG) in band-shift assays. In contrast to FLP, DNA binding by FlpA did not require the formation of an intramolecular disulphide bond. However, despite containing only two cysteine residues per monomer, FlpA was able to acquire an FNR-like, oxygen-labile [4Fe 4S] cluster. But, whereas the incorporation of a [4Fe 4S] cluster into FNR enhances interaction with target DNA, it abolished DNA binding by FlpA. An FlpA variant (FlpA') with an N-terminal region designed to be more FLP-like failed to incorporate an iron-sulphur cluster but could now form an intramolecular disulphide. This simple example of protein engineering, converting an oxygen-labile [4Fe 4S] containing FNR-like protein into a dithiol-disulphide FLP-like redox sensor demonstrates the versatility of the basic CRP structure. Attempts to demonstrate an FlpA-based aerobic-anaerobic switch in the heterologous host E. coli were unsuccessful. However, studies with a series of FNR-dependent lac reporter fusions in strains of E. coli expressing flpA or flpB revealed that both homologues were able to activate expression of FNR-dependent promoters in vivo but only when positioned 61 base pairs upstream of the transcription start.

Cloning and characterisation of the Pasteurella multocida ahpA gene responsible for a haemolytic phenotype in Escherichia coli

Haemolysins are membrane-damaging agents which have been described as bacterial virulence factors due to their ability to lyse erythrocytes and other host cells, and therefore inducing a greater inflammatory response (Elliott et al., 1998). Pasteurella multocida was found to be haemolytic under anaerobic conditions. In this study, we cloned and characterised a P. multocida gene, designated ahpA, which conferred a haemolytic phenotype on Escherichia coli when incubated under anaerobic conditions. A deletion was introduced into the ahpA open reading frame which abolished the haemolytic phenotype. The clone containing ahpA showed erythrocyte specificity, causing haemolysis of bovine and equine erythrocytes, and demonstrated weak haemolysis on ovine erythrocytes. Upon further investigation, AhpA was found to affect the expression of the E. coli K-12 latent haemolysin, SheA, under anaerobic conditions.

Mechanisms for redox control of gene expression

This review discusses various mechanisms that regulatory proteins use to control gene expression in response to alterations in redox. The transcription factor SoxR contains stable [2Fe-2S] centers that promote transcription activation when oxidized. FNR contains [4Fe-4S] centers that disassemble under oxidizing conditions, which affects DNA-binding activity. FixL is a histidine sensor kinase that utilizes heme as a cofactor to bind oxygen, which affects its autophosphorylation activity. NifL is a flavoprotein that contains FAD as a redox responsive cofactor. Under oxidizing conditions, NifL binds and inactivates NifA, the transcriptional activator of the nitrogen fixation genes. OxyR is a transcription factor that responds to redox by breaking or forming disulfide bonds that affect its DNA-binding activity. The ability of the histidine sensor kinase ArcB to promote phosphorylation of the response regulator ArcA is affected by multiple factors such as anaerobic metabolites and the redox state of the membrane. The global regulator of anaerobic gene expression in alpha-purple proteobacteria, RegB, appears to directly monitor respiratory activity of cytochrome oxidase. The aerobic repressor of photopigment synthesis, CrtJ, seems to contain a redox responsive cysteine. Finally, oxygen-sensitive rhizobial NifA proteins presumably bind a metal cofactor that senses redox. The functional variability of these regulatory proteins demonstrates that prokaryotes apply many different mechanisms to sense and respond to alterations in redox.

Oxygen sensing by the global regulator, FNR: the role of the iron-sulfur cluster

FNR is a global regulator that controls transcription of genes whose functions facilitate adaptation to growth under O2 limiting conditions. It has long been appreciated that the activity of FNR must be regulated by O2 availability, since FNR dependent gene expression is observed in vivo only under anaerobic conditions, while similar levels of this protein are present in both aerobic and anaerobic grown cells. Recent progress in this field has shown that anaerobically purified FNR contains a [4Fe-4S]2+ cluster and that this [4Fe-4S]2+ cluster is sufficiently unstable toward O2 to make it suitable as an O2 sensor. The presence of the [4Fe-4S] cluster increases dimerization of FNR which is correlated with an increase in site-specific DNA binding of FNR, a property expected of transcription factors of the FNR/CRP family. According to Mössbauer spectroscopy on purified FNR and cells containing overexpressed FNR, the [4Fe-4S]2+ cluster of FNR is converted by O2 to a [2Fe-2S]2+ in high yield. The [2Fe-2S]2+ cluster can be reconverted to the [4Fe-4S]2+ cluster on reduction with dithionite in vitro raising the possibility that the [2Fe-2S]2+ cluster is a biologically inactive intermediate which may be more readily available for reconstitution into the [4Fe-4S]2+ form than the Fe-free apoform. The ability to observe, by Mössbauer spectroscopy, the Fe-S clusters of FNR in cells containing high levels of FNR should be of value in further unraveling how FNR functions in vivo. Attempts to reduce the [4Fe-4S]2+ cluster of FNR with dithionite indicated that the redox potential of the +1/+2 couple is < or = -650 mV and that the [4Fe-4S]+ cluster form is, therefore, not likely to occur in vivo.

Downregulation of Escherichia coli yfiD expression by FNR occupying a site at -93.5 involves the AR1-containing face of FNR

The promoter of the FNR-activated yfiD gene of Escherichia coli has an unusual architecture because it contains two FNR sites, an arrangement usually associated with FNR-mediated repression. Investigation of yfiD promoter derivatives with altered FNR sites revealed that occupation of the far upstream FNR site (FNR II) downregulated expression, despite the presence of a FNR dimer activating expression from the promoter proximal site (FNR I). Transcript mapping by primer extension, and mutagenesis of potential -10 elements, indicated that yfiD expression is driven from a single FNR-dependent promoter with FNR sites at -40.5 (FNR I) and -93.5 (FNR II). However, yfiD mRNA is processed in stationary-phase cultures independently of rne, rpoS, ihfA and fis to yield transcripts lacking 12 and 21 bases from their respective 5' ends. Single amino acid substitutions (G74-->C, F92-->S, A95-->P, R184-->P, P188-->A or L193-->P) in the surface of FNR that contains activating region 1 (AR1 contacts the alpha-subunit of RNA polymerase to promote transcription activation) reduced the inhibitory effect of FNR at FNR II, indicating that this region of the protein may have a role in repression as well as activation. The FNR variant F92-->S was notable because, although it activated transcription of yfiD (two FNR sites), it was unable to activate transcription from model Class I and II promoters, which contain only a single FNR site.

Molecular genetics of succinate:quinone oxidoreductase in eukaryotes

Succinate:quinone oxidoreductase is a membrane-associated complex in mitochondria, often referred to as complex II, based on the fractionation scheme developed by Y. Hatefi and colleagues. It consists of four peptides, two of which are integral membrane proteins (15 and 12-13 kDa, respectively) and two others that are peripheral membrane proteins, i.e., a flavoprotein (Fp, 70 kDa) and an iron-protein (Ip, 27 kDa). The mature, functional complex contains a cytochrome in association with the membrane proteins, a flavin linked covalently to the largest peptide, and three iron-sulfur clusters in the 27-kDa subunit. The present review touches only briefly on the biochemical and biophysical properties of this complex. Instead, the focus is on the molecular-genetic studies that have become possible since the first genes from eukaryotes were cloned in 1989. The evolutionary conservation of the amino acid sequence of both the Fp and the Ip peptides has facilitated the cloning of these genes from a large variety of eukaryotic organisms by PCR-based methods. The review addresses questions related to the regulation of the expression of these genes, with an emphasis on mammals and yeast, for which most of the information is available. Four different genes have to be co-ordinately regulated. Transcriptional as well as posttranscriptional regulatory mechanisms have been observed in diverse organisms. Intriguing observations have been made in studies of this enzyme during the life cycle of organisms existing alternately under aerobic and anaerobic conditions. Naturally occurring or induced mutations in these genes have shed light on several questions related to the assembly of this complex, and on the relationship between structure and function. Four different peptides are imported into the mitochondria. They have to be modified, folded, and assembled. The stage is set for the exploration of highly specific changes introduced by site-directed mutagenesis. Until recently the genes were believed to be exclusively nuclear in all eukaryotes, but exceptions have since been found. This finding has relevance in the discussion of the evolution of mitochondria from prokaryotes. A highly conserved set of genes is found in prokaryotes, and some informative comparisons on gene organization and expression in prokaryotes and eukaryotes have been included.

The molecular basis for the differential regulation of the hlyE-encoded haemolysin of Escherichia coli by FNR and HlyX lies in the improved activating region 1 contact of HlyX

The regulator of fumarate and nitrate reduction (FNR) protein of Escherichia coli is an oxygen-responsive transcription regulator that acts mainly to activate the transcription of genes associated with anaerobic energy generation during periods of oxygen starvation. The hlyX gene of the swine pathogen Actinobacillus pleuropneumoniae encodes an FNR homologue, HlyX, which can complement the anaerobic respiratory deficiencies of an fnr mutant. However, FNR and HlyX have distinct but overlapping regulons because during anaerobic incubation, hlyX-expressing E. coli K-12 strains produce an otherwise latent haemolysin. The gene encoding the 'latent' haemolysin has been designated hlyE and analysis of the promoter region by DNase I footprinting reveals the presence of an FNR- (HlyX-) binding site. Anaerobic expression of an hlyE::lacZ reporter was 6.5-fold higher in hlyX compared to fnr-expressing cells. Both FNR and HlyX recruited RNA polymerase to the hlyE promoter but formed different ternary complexes. One major transcript (tsp1) initiating at 78.5 bp downstream of the FNR-binding site and four minor transcripts initiating at 73.5 (tsp2), 71.5 (tsp3), 63.5 (tsp4) and 62.5 (tsp5) bp from the FNR site were detected. From the position of the FNR box relative to the transcript starts, hlyE is expressed from a Class I FNR-regulated promoter. Substitution of selected FNR amino acids with the residues found in the equivalent positions in HlyX indicated that Activating Region 1 (AR1) of FNR forms a surface encompassing beta to beta 11 and that the AR1 contact at Class I promoters is different to that at Class II promoters, although the same surface is involved. The FNR variant, FNR-A225T, combined the properties of FNR (good activation from Class II promoters) and HlyX (good activation of Class I promoters) and conferred the haemolytic phenotype.

FNR is a direct oxygen sensor having a biphasic response curve

FNR is a transcription regulator that controls the expression of target genes in response to anoxia. Anaerobiosis is accompanied by the acquisition of two [4Fe-4S]2+ clusters per FNR dimer and the ability to bind DNA site-specifically. Oxidation of the [4Fe-4S]2+ form of FNR by O2 produced a non-DNA-binding, transcriptionally inactive form which also contains an iron-sulfur cluster, recently identified by Mossbauer spectroscopy as a [2Fe-2S] cluster (Khoroshilova et al., 1997, PNAS. 94, 6078). Complete conversion needed at least 2.5-3.0 molecules of O2 per [4Fe-4S]2+ cluster. Using sub-stoicheiometric amounts of air-saturated buffer, stable equilibria were established in which the [4Fe-4S]2+ and [2Fe-2S]2+ forms co-exist and no EPR detectable free ferric ions were released. In contrast, a 20-fold molar excess K3Fe(CN)6 was required to oxidise the [4Fe-4S]2+ cluster and in this case, ferric ions were released. FNR is therefore a sensitive O2 sensor.

Alternative respiratory pathways of Escherichia coli: energetics and transcriptional regulation in response to electron acceptors

The electron-transport chains of Escherichia coli are composed of many different dehydrogenases and terminal reductases (or oxidases) which are linked by quinones (ubiquinone, menaquinone and demethylmenaquinone). Quinol:cytochrome c oxido-reductase ('bc1 complex') is not present. For various electron acceptors (O2, nitrate) and donors (formate, H2, NADH, glycerol-3-P) isoenzymes are present. The enzymes show great variability in membrane topology and energy conservation. Energy is conserved by conformational proton pumps, or by arrangement of substrate sites on opposite sides of the membrane resulting in charge separation. Depending on the enzymes and isoenzymes used, the H+/e- ratios are between 0 and 4 H+/e- for the overall chain. The expression of the terminal reductases is regulated by electron acceptors. O2 is the preferred electron acceptor and represses the terminal reductases of anaerobic respiration. In anaerobic respiration, nitrate represses other terminal reductases, such as fumarate or DMSO reductases. Energy conservation is maximal with O2 and lowest with fumarate. By this regulation pathways with high ATP or growth yields are favoured. The expression of the dehydrogenases is regulated by the electron acceptors, too. In aerobic growth, non-coupling dehydrogenases are expressed and used preferentially, whereas in fumarate or DMSO respiration coupling dehydrogenases are essential. Coupling and non-coupling isoenzymes are expressed correspondingly. Thus the rationale for expression of the dehydrogenases is not maximal energy yield, but could be maximal flux or growth rates. Nitrate regulation is effected by two-component signal transfer systems with membraneous nitrate/nitrite sensors (NarX, NarQ) and cytoplasmic response regulators (NarL, NarP) which communicate by protein phosphorylation. O2 regulates by a two-component regulatory system consisting of a membraneous sensor (ArcB) and a response regulator (ArcA). ArcA is the major regulator of aerobic metabolism and represses the genes of aerobic metabolism under anaerobic conditions. FNR is a cytoplasmic O2 responsive regulator with a sensory and a regulatory DNA-binding domain. FNR is the regulator of genes required for anaerobic respiration and related pathways. The binding sites of NarL, NarP, ArcA and FNR are characterized for various promoters. Most of the genes are regulated by more than one of the regulators, which can act in any combination and in a positive or negative mode. By this the hierarchical expression of the genes in response to the electron acceptors is achieved. FNR is located in the cytoplasm and contains a 4Fe4S cluster in the sensory domain. The regulatory concentrations of O2 are 1-5 mbar. Under these conditions O2 diffuses to the cytoplasm and is able to react directly with FNR without involvement of other specific enzymes or protein mediators. By oxidation of the FeS cluster, FNR is converted to the inactive state in a reversible process. Reductive activation could be achieved by cellular reductants in the absence of O2. In addition, O2 may cause destruction and loss of the FeS cluster. It is not known whether this process is required for regulation of FNR function.

Iron-sulfur cluster disassembly in the FNR protein of Escherichia coli by O2: [4Fe-4S] to [2Fe-2S] conversion with loss of biological activity

The transcription factor FNR (fumarate nitrate reduction) requires the presence of an iron-sulfur (Fe-S) cluster for its function as a global transcription regulator in Escherichia coli when oxygen becomes scarce. To define the oxidation state and type of Fe-S cluster present in the active form of FNR, we have studied anaerobically purified FNR with Mössbauer spectroscopy. Our data showed that this form of FNR contained a [4Fe-4S]2+ cluster (delta = 0.45 mm/s; DeltaEQ = 1.22 mm/s) and that the [4Fe-4S]2+ cluster was rapidly destroyed on exposure of FNR to air. Under these conditions, the yellow-green active form of FNR turned deep red; analysis of sulfide indicated that 70% of the labile sulfide was still present, suggesting that the Fe-S cluster had been converted into a different form. Little [3Fe-4S] cluster was, however, detected by EPR. According to Mössbauer spectroscopy, the [4Fe-4S]2+ cluster was converted in about 60% yield to a [2Fe-2S]2+ cluster (delta = 0.28 mm/s; DeltaEQ = 0.58 mm/s) following 17 min of exposure to air. The [2Fe-2S]2+ cluster form of FNR was much more stable to oxygen, but was unable to sustain biological activity (e.g., DNA binding). However, DNA binding and the absorption spectrum characteristic of the [4Fe-4S]2+ cluster could be largely restored from the [2Fe-2S]2+ form when Cys, Fe, DTT, and the NifS protein were added. It has yet to be determined whether the form of FNR containing the [2Fe-2S]2+ cluster has any biological significance, e.g., as an in vivo intermediate that is more rapidly converted to the active form than the apoprotein.

Purification of HlyX, a potential regulator of haemolysin synthesis, and properties of HlyX : FNR hybrids

The hlyX gene of the swine pathogen Actinobacillus pleuropneumoniae is homologous to FNR, an anaerobic transcriptional regulator of Escherichia coli. It endows a haemolytic phenotype upon E. coli, and will complement the anaerobic respiratory deficiencies of fnr mutants of E. coli. The coding region of the hlyX gene was expressed in E. coli and the HlyX protein was purified by using an assay based on its immunological cross-reactivity with anti-FNR antibodies. The HlyX protein had the predicted N-terminal sequence, and resembled the isolated FNR protein in size (Mr 29,000) and monomeric organization. It has no detectable haemolysin activity per se, and is therefore presumed to confer a haemolytic phenotype by activating a latent haemolysin gene in E. coli. Studies with gene fusions showed that HlyX, like FNR, can function as an anaerobic activator and repressor of FNR-regulated genes in vivo. Plasmids that express hybrid HlyX:FNR proteins in which the 189/190-residue N-terminal segments and the remaining 50/60-residue C-terminal segments are exchanged, retained their FNR-specific functions but failed to confer a haemolytic phenotype. This suggests that the specificity for activating the haemolytic response requires the participation of unique features in both the N- and C-terminal segments of HlyX.

O2 as the regulatory signal for FNR-dependent gene regulation in Escherichia coli

With an oxystat, changes in the pattern of expression of FNR-dependent genes from Escherichia coli were studied as a function of the O2 tension (pO2) in the medium. Expression of all four tested genes was decreased by increasing O2. However, the pO2 values that gave rise to half-maximal repression (pO(0.5)) were dependent on the particular promoter and varied between 1 and 5 millibars (1 bar = 10(5) Pa). The pO(0.5) value for the ArcA-regulated succinate dehydrogenase genes was in the same range (pO(0.5) = 4.6 millibars). At these pO2 values, the cytoplasm can be calculated to be well supplied with O2 by diffusion. Therefore, intracellular O2 could provide the signal to FNR, suggesting that there is no need for a signal transfer chain. Genetic inactivation of the enzymes and coenzymes of aerobic respiration had no or limited effects on the pO(0.5) of FNR-regulated genes. Thus, neither the components of aerobic respiration nor their redox state are the primary sites for O2 sensing, supporting the significance of intracellular O2. Non-redox-active, structural O2 analogs like CO, CN-, and N3-, could not mimic the effect of O2 on FNR-regulated genes under anaerobic conditions and did not decrease the inhibitory effect of O2 under aerobic conditions.

Reconstitution of the [4Fe-4S] cluster in FNR and demonstration of the aerobic-anaerobic transcription switch in vitro

The FNR protein of Escherichia coli is a redox-responsive transcription regulator that activates and represses a family of genes required for anaerobic and aerobic metabolism. Reconstitution of wild-type FNR by anaerobic treatment with ferrous ions, cysteine and the NifS protein of Azotobacter vinelandii leads to the incorporation of two [4Fe-4S]2+ clusters per FNR dimer. The UV-visible spectrum of reconstituted FNR has a broad absorbance at 420 nm. The clusters are EPR silent under anaerobic conditions but are degraded to [3Fe-4S]+ by limited oxidation with air, and completely lost on prolonged air exposure. The association of FNR with the iron-sulphur clusters is confirmed by CD spectroscopy. Incorporation of the [4Fe-4S]2+ clusters increases site-specific DNA binding about 7-fold compared with apo-FNR. Anaerobic transcription activation and repression in vitro likewise depends on the presence of the iron-sulphur cluster, and its inactivation under aerobic conditions provides a demonstration in vitro of the FNR-mediated aerobic-anaerobic transcriptional switch.

The ndh-binding protein (Nbp) regulates the ndh gene of Escherichia coli in response to growth phase and is identical to Fis

The ndh gene that encodes the non-proton-translocating NADH dehydrogenase II of Escherichia coli is anaerobically repressed by FNR. However, in the absence of FNR, ndh expression is enhanced by anaerobic growth in media containing amino acids. Two potential regulatory proteins that may be associated with this activation have previously been detected, Arr (amino acid response regulator) and Nbp (ndh-binding protein). Studies with the heat-stable Nbp have now shown that it is present in E. coli grown both aerobically and anaerobically in rich and minimal media, indicating that it is not specifically associated with the anaerobic enhancement of ndh expression. The Nbp activity of aerobic cultures was maximal during exponential growth phase (when ndh promoter activity is minimal) but fell rapidly as cultures entered stationary phase and ndh expression increased. Protein purification and mutant studies have further shown that Nbp is identical to the Fis protein (factor for inversion stimulation). Three major and two minor Nbp (Fis)-binding sites have been identified in the ndh promoter by gel retardation and DNase I footprinting. The major sites are centred at -123, -72 and +51, in decreasing order of binding affinity. At low concentrations, Nbp (Fis) increased transcription from the ndh promoter by up to 25%, whereas at higher concentrations it prevented RNA polymerase (RNAP) binding and open complex formation. Consequently, Nbp (Fis) can both activate and repress transcription from the ndh promoter. The results suggest that Nbp (Fis) serves to ensure that the energetically efficient proton-translocating NADH dehydrogenase I is used in preference to the non-proton translocating NADH dehydrogenase II during periods of rapid growth, by repressing expression of the ndh gene.

Isolation of an oxygen-sensitive FNR protein of Escherichia coli: interaction at activator and repressor sites of FNR-controlled genes

The Escherichia coli fnr gene product, FNR, is a DNA binding protein that regulates a large family of genes involved in cellular respiration and carbon metabolism during conditions of anaerobic cell growth. FNR is believed to contain a redox/O2-sensitive element for detecting the anaerobic state. To investigate this process, a fnr mutant that encodes an altered FNR protein with three amino acid substitutions in the N-terminal domain was constructed by site-directed mutagenesis. In vivo, the mutant behaved like a wild-type strain under anaerobic conditions but had a 14-fold elevated level of transcriptional activation of a reporter gene during aerobic cell growth. The altered fur gene was overexpressed in E. coli and the resultant FNR protein was purified to near homogeneity by using anaerobic chromatography procedures. An in vitro Rsa I restriction site protection assay was developed that allowed for the assessment of oxygen-dependent DNA binding of the mutant FNR protein. The FNR protein was purified as a monomer of M(r) 28,000 that contained nonheme iron at 2.05 +/- 0.34 mol of Fe per FNR monomer. In vitro DNase I protection studies were performed to establish the locations of the FNR-binding sites at the narG, narK, dmsA, and hemA promoters that are regulated by either activation or repression of their transcription. The sizes of the DNA footprints are consistent with the binding of two monomers of FNR that protect the symmetrical FNR-recognition sequence TTGAT-nnnnATCAA. Exposure of the FNR protein or protein-DNA complex to air for even short periods of time (approximately 5 min) led to the complete loss of DNA protection at a consensus FNR recognition site. A model whereby the FNR protein exists in the cell as a monomer that assembles on the DNA under anaerobic conditions to form a dimer is discussed.

DNA binding and dimerization of the Fe-S-containing FNR protein from Escherichia coli are regulated by oxygen

The transcription factor FNR from Escherichia coli regulates transcription of genes in response to oxygen deprivation. To determine how the activity of FNR is regulated by oxygen, a form of FNR had to be isolated that had properties similar to those observed in vivo. This was accomplished by purification of an FNR fraction which exhibited enhanced DNA binding in the absence of oxygen. Iron and sulfide analyses of this FNR fraction indicated the presence of an Fe-S cluster. To determine the type of Fe-S cluster present, an oxygen-stable mutant protein LH28-DA154 was also analyzed since FNR LH28-DA154 purified anoxically contained almost 3-fold more iron and sulfide than the wild-type protein. Based on the sulfide analysis, the stoichiometry (3.3 mol of S2-/FNR monomer) was consistent with either one [4Fe-4S] or two [2Fe-2S] clusters per mutant FNR monomer. However, since FNR has only four Cys residues as potential cluster ligands and an EPR signal typical of a 3Fe-4S cluster was detected on oxidation, we conclude that there is one [4Fe-4S] cluster present per monomer of FNR LH28-DA154. We assume that the wild type also contains one [4Fe-4S] cluster per monomer and that the lower amounts of iron and sulfide observed per monomer were due to partial occupancy. Consistent with this, the Fe-S cluster in the wild-type protein was found to be extremely oxygen-labile. In addition, molecular-sieve chromatographic analysis showed that the majority of the anoxically purified protein was a dimer as compared to aerobically purified FNR which is a monomer. The loss of the Fe-S cluster by exposure to oxygen was associated with a conversion to the monomeric form and decreased DNA binding. Taken together, these observations suggest that oxygen regulates the activity of wild-type FNR through the lability of the Fe-S cluster to oxygen.

Characterization of FNR* mutant proteins indicates two distinct mechanisms for altering oxygen regulation of the Escherichia coli transcription factor FNR

In order to gain insight into the mechanism by which the Escherichia coli transcription factor FNR* is activated in response to anaerobiosis, we have analyzed FNR mutant proteins which, unlike the wild-type protein, stimulate gene expression in the presence of oxygen in vivo. Cell extracts containing seven different FNR* mutant proteins were tested in vitro for the ability to bind to the FNR consensus DNA site in a gel retardation assay under aerobic conditions. At the concentration of protein tested, only extracts which contained FNR* mutant proteins with amino acid substitutions at position 154 showed significant DNA binding. The three position-154 FNR* mutant proteins could be further distinguished from the other mutant proteins by analysis of the in vivo phenotypes of FNR* proteins containing amino acid substitutions at either of two essential cysteine residues. In the presence of oxygen, FNR* mutant proteins with amino acid substitutions at position 154 were the least affected when either Cys-23 or Cys-122 was substituted for Ser. On the basis of these in vivo and in vitro analyses, FNR* mutant proteins appear to segregate into at least two classes. Thus, it appears that each class of FNR* substitutions alters the normal pathway of FNR activation in response to oxygen deprivation by a different mechanism.

Anaerobic activation of the entire denitrification pathway in Pseudomonas aeruginosa requires Anr, an analog of Fnr

The Pseudomonas aeruginosa gene anr, which encodes a structural and functional analog of the anaerobic regulator Fnr in Escherichia coli, was mapped to the SpeI fragment R, which is at about 59 min on the genomic map of P. aeruginosa PAO1. Wild-type P. aeruginosa PAO1 grew under anaerobic conditions with nitrate, nitrite, and nitrous oxide as alternative electron acceptors. An anr deletion mutant, PAO6261, was constructed. It was unable to grow with these alternative electron acceptors; however, its ability to denitrify was restored upon the introduction of the wild-type anr gene. In addition, the activities of two enzymes in the denitrification pathway, nitrite reductase and nitric oxide reductase, were not detectable under oxygen-limiting conditions in strain PAO6261 but were restored when complemented with the anr+ gene. These results indicate that the anr gene product plays a key role in anaerobically activating the entire denitrification pathway.

Purification of ArcA and analysis of its specific interaction with the pfl promoter-regulatory region

ArcA is one of several transcription factors required for optimal anaerobic induction of the pyruvate formatelyase (pfl) operon. To aid the study at the molecular level of the interaction of ArcA with the pfl promoter-regulatory region we developed a procedure for the isolation of ArcA. The purification of ArcA involved chromatography in heparin agarose, hydroxylapatite and Mono-Q matrices and delivered a protein that was > 95% pure. Gel retardation assays demonstrated that ArcA bound specifically to the pfl regulatory region. Three distinct ArcA-DNA complexes could be resolved depending on the ArcA concentration used. This finding suggested that either multiple ArcA-binding sites are present in the regulatory region or that ArcA can oligomerize at one or more sites. The DNA-binding activity of ArcA could be increased as estimated 10-fold by prior incubation of the protein with carbamoyl phosphate, suggesting that phosphorylation activates DNA binding or oligomerisation. DNase I footprint analyses identified four sites that were protected by ArcA from cleavage. Two of these sites spanned the transcription start site and -10 regions of promoters 6 and 7, while a third site partially overlapped the characterized binding site of integration host factor (IHF). ArcA exhibited the highest affinity for a stretch of DNA located between the IHF site and the transcription start site of promoter 7. These results are congruent with the hypothesis that a higher-order nucleoprotein complex comprising several proteins, including ArcA, is required to activate transcription from the multiple promoters of the pfl operon.

Association of a polynuclear iron-sulfur center with a mutant FNR protein enhances DNA binding

In the facultative anaerobe Escherichia coli, the transcription factor FNR (fumarate nitrate reduction) regulates gene expression in response to oxygen deprivation. To investigate how the activity of FNR is regulated by oxygen availability, two mutant proteins, DA154 and LH28-DA154, which have enhanced in vivo activity in the presence of oxygen, were purified and compared. Unlike other previously examined FNR preparations, the absorption spectrum of LH28-DA154 had two maxima at 324 nm and 419 nm, typical of iron-sulfur (Fe-S)-containing proteins. Consistent with these data, metal analysis showed that only the LH28-DA154 protein contained a significant amount of iron and acid-labile sulfide, and, by low temperature EPR spectroscopy, a signal typical of a [3Fe-4S]+ cluster was detected. The LH28-DA154 protein that contained the Fe-S cluster also contained a higher proportion of dimers and had a 3- to 4-fold higher apparent affinity for the target DNA than the DA154 protein. In agreement with this, we found that when the LH28-DA154 protein was treated with an iron chelator (alpha,alpha'-dipyridyl), it lost its characteristic absorption and the apparent affinity for DNA was reduced 6-fold. However, increased DNA binding and the characteristic absorption spectrum could be restored by in vitro reconstitution of the Fe-S center. DNA binding of the LH28-DA154 protein was also affected by the redox state of the Fe-S center, since protein exposed to oxygen bound 1/10th as much DNA as the protein reduced anaerobically with dithionite. The observation that DNA binding is enhanced when the Fe-S center is reduced indicates that the redox state of the Fe-S center affects the DNA-binding activity of this protein and suggests a possible mechanism for regulation of the wild-type protein.

Purification, characterization and mode of action of PdhR, the transcriptional repressor of the pdhR-aceEF-lpd operon of Escherichia coli

The repressor of the pdhR-aceEF-lpd operon of Escherichia coli, PdhR, was amplified to 23% of total cell protein and purified to homogeneity by heparin-agarose and cation-exchange chromatography. The purified protein is a monomer (M(r) 29,300) which binds specifically to DNA fragments containing the pdh promoter (Ppdh) in the absence of pyruvate. The pdh operator was identified by DNase I footprinting as a region of hyphenated dyad symmetry, +11AATTGGTaagACCAATT+27, situated just downstream of the transcript start site. In vitro transcription from Ppdh was repressed > 1000-fold by PdhR and this repression was antagonized in a concentration-dependent manner by its co-effector, pyruvate. Studies on RNA polymerase binding at Ppdh showed that RNA polymerase protects the -44 to +21 region in the absence of PdhR, but no RNA polymerase binding or protection upstream of +9 could be detected in the presence of PdhR. It is concluded that PdhR represses transcription by binding to an operator site centred at +19 such that effective binding of RNA polymerase is prevented.

Expression and functional properties of fumarate reductase

Images

Genetic regulation of nitrogen fixation in rhizobia

This review presents a comparison between the complex genetic regulatory networks that control nitrogen fixation in three representative rhizobial species, Rhizobium meliloti, Bradyrhizobium japonicum, and Azorhizobium caulinodans. Transcription of nitrogen fixation genes (nif and fix genes) in these bacteria is induced primarily by low-oxygen conditions. Low-oxygen sensing and transmission of this signal to the level of nif and fix gene expression involve at least five regulatory proteins, FixL, FixJ, FixK, NifA, and RpoN (sigma 54). The characteristic features of these proteins and their functions within species-specific regulatory pathways are described. Oxygen interferes with the activities of two transcriptional activators, FixJ and NifA. FixJ activity is modulated via phosphorylation-dephosphorylation by the cognate sensor hemoprotein FixL. In addition to the oxygen responsiveness of the NifA protein, synthesis of NifA is oxygen regulated at the level of transcription. This type of control includes FixLJ in R. meliloti and FixLJ-FixK in A. caulinodans or is brought about by autoregulation in B. japonicum. NifA, in concert with sigma 54 RNA polymerase, activates transcription from -24/-12-type promoters associated with nif and fix genes and additional genes that are not directly involved in nitrogen fixation. The FixK proteins constitute a subgroup of the Crp-Fnr family of bacterial regulators. Although the involvement of FixLJ and FixK in nifA regulation is remarkably different in the three rhizobial species discussed here, they constitute a regulatory cascade that uniformly controls the expression of genes (fixNOQP) encoding a distinct cytochrome oxidase complex probably required for bacterial respiration under low-oxygen conditions. In B. japonicum, the FixLJ-FixK cascade also controls genes for nitrate respiration and for one of two sigma 54 proteins.

Regulation of transcription at the ndh promoter of Escherichia coli by FNR and novel factors

FNR is a transcriptional regulator that controls gene expression in response to oxygen limitation in Escherichia coli. The NADH dehydrogenase II gene (ndh) is repressed by FNR under anaerobic conditions. Repression is not simply due to occlusion of the promoter (-35 and -10) region by FNR because adjacent pairs of FNR monomers were found to bind at two sites centred at -50.5 and -94.5 in the ndh promoter region without preventing RNA polymerase binding. However, contact between RNA polymerase and the -132 to -62 region of the non-coding strand of ndh DNA, and RNA polymerase-mediated open complex formation, were prevented by bound FNR. The upstream FNR-binding site (-94.5) was needed for efficient FNR-dependent repression of ndh transcription in vitro, and also for repression of an ndh-lacZ fusion in vivo. Anaerobic ndh repression may thus involve the binding of two pairs of FNR monomers upstream of the -35 region, which prevents essential RNA polymerase-DNA contacts in the upstream region as well as inhibiting RNA polymerase function by direct FNR interaction. Expression of the ndh-lacZ fusion in an fnr deletion strain was enhanced by anaerobic growth in rich medium or minimal medium supplemented with amino acids. Furthermore, two proteins (M(r) 12,000 and 35,000) which interact with and may activate transcription from the ndh promoter under these conditions were detected by gel retardation analysis. These putative amino acid-responsive activators may thus offset FNR-mediated repression and maintain a low level of anaerobic ndh expression for regulating the NAD+/NADH ratio during growth in rich media.

Anaerobic activation of arcA transcription in Escherichia coli: roles of Fnr and ArcA

The ArcA and Fnr regulators of Escherichia coli, both of which are activated in anaerobic conditions, negatively regulate the sodA gene (coding for manganese superoxide dismutase), but Fnr has no effect on anaerobic sodA expression in a delta arcA delta fnr background (Compan and Touati, 1993). We show here that the sdh gene (coding for succinate dehydrogenase) is also negatively regulated by Fnr, but again Fnr exerts no control in a delta arcA background. One interpretation of these results is that Fnr activates arcA transcription. Using arcA-lac transcriptional and translational fusions, we show that arcA expression increases (about fourfold) in anaerobiosis and that both Fnr and ArcA are required for full expression. In a delta fnr background, there is no autoactivation, suggesting that ArcA enhances activation by Fnr. Transcript and sequence analyses reveal that the arcA upstream regulatory region lies within a 530 bp non-coding DNA fragment, which contains five putative promoter sequences and a putative Fnr-binding site. Identification of the transcription start sites indicates that transcription occurs in aerobiosis from three constitutive upstream promoters (Pe, Pd, Pc). In anaerobiosis an additional completely Fnr-dependent transcript starting at Pa is present; expression from Pa is reduced in the absence of ArcA, and Fnr activation at Pa blocks the weak anaerobic-dependent expression from Pb. Fnr activation of arcA transcription may play an important role in the co-ordination of expression of genes associated with aerobic and anaerobic metabolism during environmental changes.

Repression of in vitro transcription of the Escherichia coli fnr and nar X genes by FNR protein

In facultative anaerobes, the anaerobic expression of respiratory genes is regulated by a transcriptional activator, FNR. Transcription in vitro of the E. coli fnr gene was repressed by its product, FNR. The transcription of the E. coli narX gene encoding the nitrate sensor protein was likewise repressed. DNA truncation experiments for fnr and narX genes indicated that multiple anaero-boxes in each promoter region are essential for repression by the FNR protein, but they also suggest that factor-independent upstream activation signals are operating with these promoters.

Oxygen regulated gene expression in facultatively anaerobic bacteria

In facultatively anaerobic bacteria such as Escherichia coli, oxygen and other electron acceptors fundamentally influence catabolic and anabolic pathways. E. coli is able to grow aerobically by respiration and in the absence of O2 by anaerobic respiration with nitrate, nitrite, fumarate, dimethylsulfoxide and trimethylamine N-oxide as acceptors or by fermentation. The expression of the various catabolic pathways occurs according to a hierarchy with 3 or 4 levels. Aerobic respiration at the highest level is followed by nitrate respiration (level 2), anaerobic respiration with the other acceptors (level 3) and fermentation. In other bacteria, different regulatory cascades with other underlying principles can be observed. Regulation of anabolism in response to O2 availability is important, too. It is caused by different requirements of cofactors or coenzymes in aerobic and anaerobic metabolism and by the requirement for different O2-independent biosynthetic routes under anoxia. The regulation mainly occurs at the transcriptional level. In E. coli, 4 global regulatory systems are known to be essential for the aerobic/anaerobic switch and the described hierarchy. A two-component sensor/regulator system comprising ArcB (sensor) and ArcA (transcriptional regulator) is responsible for regulation of aerobic metabolism. The FNR protein is a transcriptional sensor-regulator protein which regulates anaerobic respiratory genes in response to O2 availability. The gene activator FhlA regulates fermentative formate and hydrogen metabolism with formate as the inductor. ArcA/B and FNR directly respond to O2, FhlA indirectly by decreased levels of formate in the presence of O2. Regulation of nitrate/nitrite catabolism is effected by two 2-component sensor/regulator systems NarX(Q)/NarL(P) in response to nitrate/nitrite. Co-operation of the different regulatory systems at the target promoters which are in part under dual (or manifold) transcriptional control causes the expression according to the hierarchy. The sensing of the environmental signals by the sensor proteins or domains is not well understood so far. FNR, which acts presumably as a cytoplasmic 'one component' sensor-regulator, is suggested to sense directly cytoplasmic O2-levels corresponding to the environmental O2-levels.

Location and orientation of an activating region in the Escherichia coli transcription factor, FNR

We have characterized a number of mutations in fnr that interfere with FNR-dependent transcription activation at two promoters where the FNR-binding site is centred around 41 1/2 bp upstream from the transcription start site. The substituted residues in all but one of these FNR mutants are clustered around a presumed surface-exposed beta-turn containing G85 which, we suggest, forms an activating region that contacts RNA polymerase at these promoters. Using the 'oriented heterodimers' method described elsewhere, we show that this activating region on the promoter-proximal subunit of the FNR dimer is sufficient to activate transcription initiation. In contrast, this region is not essential for activation of a third FNR-dependent promoter where the FNR-binding site is centred at 61 1/2 bp upstream from the transcription start site. However, a substitution at S73 interferes with FNR-dependent activation at both this promoter and promoters in which the FNR site is located at 41 1/2 bp from the transcript start, suggesting that FNR may contain a second activating region.

The FNR family of transcriptional regulators

Homologues of the transcriptional regulator FNR from Escherichia coli have been identified in a variety of taxonomically diverse bacterial species. Despite being structurally very similar, members of the FNR family have disparate regulatory roles. Those from Shewanella putrefaciens, Pseudomonas aeruginosa, Pseudomonas stutzeri and Rhodopseudomonas palustris are functionally similar to FNR in that they regulate anaerobic respiration or carbon metabolism. Four rhizobial proteins (from Rhizobium meliloti, R. leguminosarum, B. japonicum and Azorhizobium caulinodans) are involved in the regulation of nitrogen fixation; a fifth (from Rhizobium strain IC3342) has unknown function. Two proteins from mammalian pathogens (Actinobacillus pleuropneumoniae and Bordetella pertussis) may be involved in the regulation of toxin expression. The FNR protein of Vibrio fischeri regulates bioluminescence, and the function of the one known FNR homologue from a Gram-positive organism (Lactobacillus casei) remains to be elucidated. Some members of this family, like FNR itself, appear to function as sensors of oxygen availability, whereas others do not. The ability to sense and respond to oxygen limitation may be correlated with the presence of cysteine residues which, in the case of FNR, are thought to be involved in oxygen or redox sensing. The mechanism of DNA sequence recognition is probably conserved, or very similar, throughout this family. In a number of other Gram-negative species, there is good indirect evidence for the existence of FNR analogues; these include Alcaligenes eutrophus, A. denitrificans, A. faecalis, Paracoccus denitrificans and a number of Pseudomonas species.

The hydrogenases and formate dehydrogenases of Escherichia coli

Escherichia coli has the capacity to synthesise three distinct formate dehydrogenase isoenzymes and three hydrogenase isoenzymes. All six are multisubunit, membrane-associated proteins that are functional in the anaerobic metabolism of the organism. One of the formate dehydrogenase isoenzymes is also synthesised in aerobic cells. Two of the formate dehydrogenase enzymes and two hydrogenases have a respiratory function while the formate dehydrogenase and hydrogenase associated with the formate hydrogenlyase pathway are not involved in energy conservation. The three formate dehydrogenases are molybdo-selenoproteins while the three hydrogenases are nickel enzymes; all six enzymes have an abundance of iron-sulfur clusters. These metal requirements alone invoke the necessity for a profusion of ancillary enzymes which are involved in the preparation and incorporation of these cofactors. The characterisation of a large number of pleiotropic mutants unable to synthesise either functionally active formate dehydrogenases or hydrogenases has led to the identification of a number of these enzymes. However, it is apparent that there are many more accessory proteins involved in the biosynthesis of these isoenzymes than originally anticipated. The biochemical function of the vast majority of these enzymes is not understood. Nevertheless, through the construction and study of defined mutants, together with sequence comparisons with homologous proteins from other organisms, it has been possible at least to categorise them with regard to a general requirement for the biosynthesis of all three isoenzymes or whether they have a specific function in the assembly of a particular enzyme. The identification of the structural genes encoding the formate dehydrogenase and hydrogenase isoenzymes has enabled a detailed dissection of how their expression is coordinated to the metabolic requirement for their products. Slowly, a picture is emerging of the extremely complex and involved path of events leading to the regulated synthesis, processing and assembly of catalytically active formate dehydrogenase and hydrogenase isoenzymes. This article aims to review the current state of knowledge regarding the biochemistry, genetics, molecular biology and physiology of these enzymes.