Evolution of long-range myofibrillar crystallinity in insect flight muscle as examined by X-ray cryomicrodiffraction

Synchrotron radiation X-ray diffraction studies on muscle: past, present, and future

X-ray diffraction is a technique to study the structure of materials at spatial resolutions up to an atomic scale. In the field of life science, the X-ray diffraction technique is especially suited to study materials having periodical structures, such as protein crystals, nucleic acids, and muscle. Among others, muscle is a dynamic structure and the molecular events occurring during muscle contraction have been the main interest among muscle researchers. In early days, the laboratory X-ray generators were unable to deliver X-ray flux strong enough to resolve the dynamic molecular events in muscle. This situation has dramatically been changed by the advent of intense synchrotron radiation X-rays and advanced detectors, and today X-ray diffraction patterns can be recorded from muscle at sub-millisecond time resolutions. In this review, we shed light mainly on the technical aspects of the history and the current status of the X-ray diffraction studies on muscle and discuss what will be made possible for muscle studies by the advance of new techniques.

Synchrotron Radiation X-ray Diffraction Techniques Applied to Insect Flight Muscle

X-ray fiber diffraction is a powerful tool used for investigating the molecular structure of muscle and its dynamics during contraction. This technique has been successfully applied not only to skeletal and cardiac muscles of vertebrates but also to insect flight muscle. Generally, insect flight muscle has a highly ordered structure and is often capable of high-frequency oscillations. The X-ray diffraction studies on muscle have been accelerated by the advent of 3rd-generation synchrotron radiation facilities, which can generate brilliant and highly oriented X-ray beams. This review focuses on some of the novel experiments done on insect flight muscle by using synchrotron radiation X-rays. These include diffraction recordings from single myofibrils within a flight muscle fiber by using X-ray microbeams and high-speed diffraction recordings from the flight muscle during the wing-beat of live insects. These experiments have provided information about the molecular structure and dynamic function of flight muscle in unprecedented detail. Future directions of X-ray diffraction studies on muscle are also discussed.

Flightin maintains myofilament lattice organization required for optimal flight power and courtship song quality in Drosophila

The indirect flight muscles (IFMs) of Drosophila and other insects with asynchronous flight muscles are characterized by a crystalline myofilament lattice structure. The high-order lattice regularity is considered an adaptation for enhanced power output, but supporting evidence for this claim is lacking. We show that IFMs from transgenic flies expressing flightin with a deletion of its poorly conserved N-terminal domain (fln^ΔN62 ) have reduced inter-thick filament spacing and a less regular lattice. This resulted in a decrease in flight ability by 33% and in skinned fibre oscillatory power output by 57%, but had no effect on wingbeat frequency or frequency of maximum power output, suggesting that the underlying actomyosin kinetics is not affected and that the flight impairment arises from deficits in force transmission. Moreover, we show that fln^ΔN62 males produced an abnormal courtship song characterized by a higher sine song frequency and a pulse song with longer pulses and longer inter-pulse intervals (IPIs), the latter implicated in male reproductive success. When presented with a choice, wild-type females chose control males over mutant males in 92% of the competition events. These results demonstrate that flightin N-terminal domain is required for optimal myofilament lattice regularity and IFM activity, enabling powered flight and courtship song production. As the courtship song is subject to female choice, we propose that the low amino acid sequence conservation of the N-terminal domain reflects its role in fine-tuning species-specific courtship songs.

The tymbal muscle of cicada has flight muscle-type sarcomeric architecture and protein expression

BACKGROUND

The structural and biochemical features of the tymbal (sound-producing) muscle of cicadas were studied by X-ray diffraction and immunochemistry, and compared with those of flight muscles from the same species.

RESULTS

The X-ray diffraction pattern of the tymbal muscle was very similar to that of the dorsal longitudinal flight muscle: In both muscles, the 2,0 equatorial reflection is much more intense than the 1,1, indicating that both muscles have a flight muscle-type myofilament lattice. In rigor, the first myosin/actin layer line reflection was finely lattice-sampled, indicating that the contractile proteins are arranged with a crystalline regularity as in asynchronous flight muscles. In contrast, the diffraction pattern from the tensor muscle, which modulates the sound by stressing the tymbal, did not show signs of such high regularity or flight muscle-type filament lattice. Electrophoretic patterns of myofibrillar proteins were also very similar in the tymbal muscle and flight muscles, but distinct from those from the tensor or leg muscles. The antibody raised against the flight muscle-specific troponin-I isoform reacted with an 80-kDa band from both tymbal and flight muscles, but with none of the bands from the tensor or leg muscles.

CONCLUSION

The close similarities of the structural and biochemical profiles between the tymbal and the flight muscles suggest the possibility that a set of flight muscle-specific proteins is diverted to the tymbal muscle to meet its demand for fast, repetitive contractions.

Structure of isolated Z-disks from honeybee flight muscle

The Z-disk is a complex structure comprising some 40 proteins that are involved in the transmission of force developed during muscle contraction and in important signalling pathways that govern muscle homeostasis. In the Z-disk the ends of antiparallel thin filaments from adjacent sarcomeres are crosslinked by α-actinin. The structure of the Z-disk lattice varies greatly throughout the animal kingdom. In vertebrates the thin filaments form a tetragonal lattice, whereas invertebrate flight muscle has a hexagonal lattice. The width of the Z-disk varies considerably and correlates with the number of α-actinin bridges. A detailed description at a high resolution of the Z-disk lattice is needed in order to better understand muscle function and disease. The molecular architecture of the Z-disk lattice in honeybee (Apis mellifera) is known from plastic embedded thin sections to a resolution of 7 nm, which is not sufficient to dock component protein crystal structures. It has been shown that sectioning is a damaging process that leads to the loss of finer details present in biological specimens. However, the Apis Z-disk is a thin structure (120 nm) suitable for cryo EM. We have isolated intact honeybee Z-disks from indirect flight muscle, thus obviating the need of plastic sectioning. We have employed cryo electron tomography and image processing to investigate the arrangement of proteins within the hexagonal lattice of the Apis Z-disk. The resolution obtained, ~6 nm, was probably limited by damage caused by the harshness of the conditions used to extract the myofibrils and isolate the Z-disks.

Mutations of the Drosophila myosin regulatory light chain affect courtship song and reduce reproductive success

The Drosophila indirect flight muscles (IFM) rely on an enhanced stretch-activation response to generate high power output for flight. The IFM is neurally activated during the male courtship song, but its role, if any, in generating the small amplitude wing vibrations that produce the song is not known. Here, we examined the courtship song properties and mating behavior of three mutant strains of the myosin regulatory light chain (DMLC2) that are known to affect IFM contractile properties and impair flight: (i) Dmlc2^Δ2–46 (Ext), an N-terminal extension truncation; (ii) Dmlc2^S66A,S67A (Phos), a disruption of two MLC kinase phosphorylation sites; and (iii) Dmlc2^{Δ2–46;S66A,S67A} (Dual), expressing both mutations. Our results show that the Dmlc2 gene is pleiotropic and that mutations that have a profound effect on flight mechanics (Phos and Dual) have minimal effects on courtship song. None of the mutations affect interpulse interval (IPI), a determinant of species-specific song, and intrapulse frequency (IPF) compared to Control (Dmlc2⁺ rescued null strain). However, abnormalities in the sine song (increased frequency) and the pulse song (increased cycles per pulse and pulse length) evident in Ext males are not apparent in Dual males suggesting that Ext and Phos interact differently in song and flight mechanics, given their known additive effect on the latter. All three mutant males produce a less vigorous pulse song and exhibit impaired mating behavior compared to Control males. As a result, females are less receptive to Ext, Phos, and Dual males when a Control male is present. These results open the possibility that DMLC2, and perhaps contractile protein genes in general, are partly under sexual selection. That mutations in DMLC2 manifest differently in song and flight suggest that this protein fulfills different roles in song and flight and that stretch activation plays a smaller role in song production than in flight.

Flight muscle-specific Pro-Ala-rich extension of troponin is important for maintaining the insect-type myofilament lattice integrity

Insect flight muscle (IFM) can oscillate at frequencies up to 1000Hz, owing to its capability of stretch activation (SA). It is a highly specialized form of cross striated muscles, and its peculiar features include the IFM-specific isoform of troponin-I (troponin-H or TnH) with an unusually long Pro-Ala-rich extension at the C-terminus. Although we have shown that this extension does not directly take part in SA, questions remain as to what its real role is and why it is expressed only in IFM. Here we explored the structural role of the extension, be comparing X-ray diffraction patterns and electron micrographs of bumblebee IFM fibers before and after enzymatic removal of the extension. The removal had a dramatic effect on diffraction patterns: In IFMs in general, the equatorial 2,0 reflection is much stronger than the 1,1 reflection, but after removal, their intensities became almost equal (stronger 1,1 is a feature of vertebrate skeletal muscle). Electron micrographs revealed that a substantial fraction of the thin filaments showed a tendency to move towards the vertebrate position (the trigonal position between three thick filaments), while the rest of the thin filaments remained in their original insect position (midway between two neighboring thick filaments). Therefore, one of the roles of the extension is suggested to keep the filament lattice in the correct configuration for IFM. This insect-type lattice structure is preserved among IFMs from varied insect orders but not in body muscles, suggesting that the maintenance of this lattice structure is important for flight functions.

Quasiperiodic distribution of rigor cross-bridges along a reconstituted thin filament in a skeletal myofibril

Electron microscopy has shown that cross-bridges (CBs) are formed at the target zone that is periodically distributed on the thin filament in striated muscle. Here, by manipulating a single bead-tailed actin filament with optical tweezers, we measured the unbinding events of rigor CBs one by one on the surface of the A-band in rabbit skeletal myofibrils. We found that the spacings between adjacent CBs were not always the same, and instead were 36, 72, or 108 nm. Tropomyosin and troponin did not affect the CB spacing except for a relative increase in the appearance of longer spacing in the presence of Ca(2+). In addition, in an in vitro assay where myosin molecules were randomly distributed, were obtained the same spacing, i.e., a multiple of 36 nm. These results indicate that the one-dimensional distribution of CBs matches with the 36-nm half pitch of a long helical structure of actin filaments. A stereospecific model composed of three actin protomers per target zone was shown to explain the experimental results. Additionally, the unbinding force (i.e., the binding affinity) of CBs for the reconstituted thin filaments was found to be larger and smaller relative to that for actin filaments with and without Ca(2+), respectively.

X-ray diffraction recording from single axonemes of eukaryotic flagella

We report the first X-ray diffraction patterns recorded from single axonemes of eukaryotic flagella with a diameter of only <0.2 μm, by using the technique of cryomicrodiffraction. A spermatozoon isolated from the testis of a fruit fly, Drosophila melanogaster, either intact or demembranated, was mounted straight in a glass capillary, quickly frozen and its 800-μm segment was irradiated end-on with intense synchrotron radiation X-ray microbeams (diameter, ~2 μm) at 74 K. Well-defined diffraction patterns were recorded, consisting of a large number of isolated reflection spots, extending up to 1/5 nm(-1). These reflections showed a tendency to peak every 20°, i.e., the patterns had features of an 18-fold rotational symmetry as expected from the 9-fold rotational symmetry of axonemal structure. This means that the axonemes remain untwisted, even after the manual mounting procedure. The diffraction patterns were compared with the results of model calculations based on a published electron micrograph of the Drosophila axoneme. The comparison provided information about the native state of axoneme, including estimates of axonemal diameter, interdoublet spacing, and masses of axonemal components relative to those of microtubules (e.g., radial spokes, dynein arms, and proteins associated with accessory singlet microtubules). When combined with the genetic resource of Drosophila, the technique presented here will serve as a powerful tool for studying the structure-function relationship of eukaryotic flagella in general.

Structure, function and evolution of insect flight muscle

Insects, the largest group of animals on the earth, owe their prosperity to their ability of flight and small body sizes. The ability of flight provided means for rapid translocation. The small body size allowed access to unutilized niches. By acquiring both features, however, insects faced a new problem: They were forced to beat their wings at enormous frequencies. Insects have overcome this problem by inventing asynchronous flight muscle, a highly specialized form of striated muscle capable of oscillating at >1,000 Hz. This article reviews the structure, mechanism, and molecular evolution of this unique invention of nature.

Fast x-ray recordings reveal dynamic action of contractile and regulatory proteins in stretch-activated insect flight muscle

To assess the ability of the thin-filament regulatory system to control each stretch-activation (SA) event in the fast beating of asynchronous insect flight muscle (IFM), we obtained fast (3.4 ms/frame) and semistatic (> or = 50 ms) x-ray diffraction recordings for IFM fibers from bumblebees (beating at 170 Hz) and compared the results with those acquired in giant waterbugs (20-30 Hz) and crane flies (40 Hz, semistatic only). In contrast to the well-documented large SA force of waterbug IFMs, the SA force of bumblebee and crane fly IFMs was small compared to their large isometric force. In semistatic recordings, step-stretched bumblebee and crane fly IFMs showed smaller net SA-associated intensity changes in reflections that report myosin attachment to actin and tropomyosin movement toward its activating position. However, fast recordings on bumblebee IFMs showed a fast and large temporary reversal of intensities in these reflections, suggesting that the myosin heads supporting isometric force are dynamically replaced by SA-supporting heads, and that tropomyosin moves to and back from its inactivating position in milliseconds. In waterbug IFMs, the fast temporary reversal of intensities was not obvious. The observed rates of the attachment/detachment of myosin heads and the motion of tropomyosin are fast enough for the thin-filament regulatory system to control each SA event in fast-beating insects.

Experimental approaches for solution X-ray scattering and fiber diffraction

X-ray scattering and diffraction from non-crystalline systems have gained renewed interest in recent years, as focus shifts from the structural chemistry information gained by high-resolution studies to the context of structural physiology at larger length scales. Such techniques permit the study of isolated macromolecules as well as highly organized macromolecular assemblies as a whole under near-physiological conditions. Time-resolved approaches, made possible by advanced synchrotron instrumentation, add a crucial dimension to many of these investigations. This article reviews experimental approaches in non-crystalline X-ray scattering and diffraction that may be used to illuminate important scientific questions such as protein/nucleic acid folding and structure-function relationships in large macromolecular assemblies.

Invertebrate muscles: thin and thick filament structure; molecular basis of contraction and its regulation, catch and asynchronous muscle

This is the second in a series of canonical reviews on invertebrate muscle. We cover here thin and thick filament structure, the molecular basis of force generation and its regulation, and two special properties of some invertebrate muscle, catch and asynchronous muscle. Invertebrate thin filaments resemble vertebrate thin filaments, although helix structure and tropomyosin arrangement show small differences. Invertebrate thick filaments, alternatively, are very different from vertebrate striated thick filaments and show great variation within invertebrates. Part of this diversity stems from variation in paramyosin content, which is greatly increased in very large diameter invertebrate thick filaments. Other of it arises from relatively small changes in filament backbone structure, which results in filaments with grossly similar myosin head placements (rotating crowns of heads every 14.5 nm) but large changes in detail (distances between heads in azimuthal registration varying from three to thousands of crowns). The lever arm basis of force generation is common to both vertebrates and invertebrates, and in some invertebrates this process is understood on the near atomic level. Invertebrate actomyosin is both thin (tropomyosin:troponin) and thick (primarily via direct Ca(++) binding to myosin) filament regulated, and most invertebrate muscles are dually regulated. These mechanisms are well understood on the molecular level, but the behavioral utility of dual regulation is less so. The phosphorylation state of the thick filament associated giant protein, twitchin, has been recently shown to be the molecular basis of catch. The molecular basis of the stretch activation underlying asynchronous muscle activity, however, remains unresolved.

Flight muscle myofibrillogenesis in the pupal stage of Drosophila as examined by X-ray microdiffraction and conventional diffraction

In the asynchronous flight muscles of higher insects, the lattice planes of contractile filaments are strictly preserved along the length of each myofibril, making the myofibril a millimetre-long giant single multiprotein crystal. To examine how such highly ordered structures are formed, we recorded X-ray diffraction patterns of the developing flight muscles of Drosophila pupae at various developmental stages. To evaluate the extent of long-range myofilament lattice order, end-on myofibrillar microdiffraction patterns were recorded from isolated quick-frozen dorsal longitudinal flight muscle fibres. In addition, conventional whole-thorax diffraction patterns were recorded from live pupae to assess the extent of development of flight musculature. Weak hexagonal fluctuations of scattering intensity were observed in the end-on patterns as early as approximately 15 h after myoblast fusion, and in the following 30 h, clear hexagonally arranged reflection spots became a common feature. The result suggests that the framework of the giant single-crystal structure is established in an early phase of myofibrillogenesis. Combined with published electron microscopy results, a myofibril in fused asynchronous flight muscle fibres is likely to start as a framework with fixed lattice plane orientations and fixed sarcomere numbers, to which constituent proteins are added afterwards without altering this basic configuration.