Lethality of glnD null mutations in Azotobacter vinelandii is suppressible by prevention of glutamine synthetase adenylylation

Deferred control of ammonium cross-feeding in a N2-fixing bacterium-microalga artificial consortium

There is an increasing interest in the use of N₂-fixing bacteria for the sustainable biofertilization of crops. Genetically-optimized bacteria for ammonium release have an improved biofertilization capacity. Some of these strains also cross-feed ammonium into microalgae raising additional concerns on their sustainable use in agriculture due to the potential risk of producing a higher and longer-lasting eutrophication problem than synthetic N-fertilizers. Here we studied the dynamic algal cross-feeding properties of a genetically-modified Azotobacter vinelandii strain which can be tuned to over-accumulate different levels of glutamine synthetase (GS, EC 6.3.1.20) under the control of an exogenous inducer. After switching cells overaccumulating GS into a noninducing medium, they proliferated for several generations at the expense of the previously accumulated GS. Further dilution of GS by cell division slowed-down growth, promoted ammonium-excretion and cross-fed algae. The final bacterial population, and timing and magnitude of algal N-biofertlization was finely tuned in a deferred manner. This tuning was in accordance with the intensity of the previous induction of GS accumulation in the cells. This bacterial population behavior could be maintained up to about 15 bacterial cell generations, until faster-growing and nonammonium excreting cells arose at an apparent high frequency. Further improvements of this genetic engineering strategy might help to align efficiency of N-biofertilizers and safe use in an open environment. KEY POINTS: • Ammonium-excreting bacteria are potential eutrophication agents • GS-dependent deferred control of bacterial growth and ammonium release • Strong but transient ammonium cross-feeding of microalgae.

Diazotrophic Growth Allows Azotobacter vinelandii To Overcome the Deleterious Effects of a glnE Deletion

Overcoming the inhibitory effects of excess environmental ammonium on nitrogenase synthesis or activity and preventing ammonium assimilation have been considered strategies to increase the amount of fixed nitrogen transferred from bacterial to plant partners in associative or symbiotic plant-diazotroph relationships. The GlnE adenylyltransferase/adenylyl-removing enzyme catalyzes reversible adenylylation of glutamine synthetase (GS), thereby affecting the posttranslational regulation of ammonium assimilation that is critical for the appropriate coordination of carbon and nitrogen assimilation. Since GS is key to the sole ammonium assimilation pathway of Azotobacter vinelandii, attempts to obtain deletion mutants in the gene encoding GS (glnA) have been unsuccessful. We have generated a glnE deletion strain, thus preventing posttranslational regulation of GS. The resultant strain containing constitutively active GS is unable to grow well on ammonium-containing medium, as previously observed in other organisms, and can be cultured only at low ammonium concentrations. This phenotype is caused by the lack of downregulation of GS activity, resulting in high intracellular glutamine levels and severe perturbation of the ratio of glutamine to 2-oxoglutarate under excess-nitrogen conditions. Interestingly, the mutant can grow diazotrophically at rates comparable to those of the wild type. This observation suggests that the control of nitrogen fixation-specific gene expression at the transcriptional level in response to 2-oxoglutarate via NifA is sufficiently tight to alone regulate ammonium production at levels appropriate for optimal carbon and nitrogen balance.IMPORTANCE In this study, the characterization of the glnE knockout mutant of the model diazotroph Azotobacter vinelandii provides significant insights into the integration of the regulatory mechanisms of ammonium production and ammonium assimilation during nitrogen fixation. The work reveals the profound fidelity of nitrogen fixation regulation in providing ammonium sufficient for maximal growth but constraining energetically costly excess production. A detailed fundamental understanding of the interplay between the regulation of ammonium production and assimilation is of paramount importance in exploiting existing and potentially engineering new plant-diazotroph relationships for improved agriculture.

Metabolic engineering of a diazotrophic bacterium improves ammonium release and biofertilization of plants and microalgae

The biological nitrogen fixation carried out by some Bacteria and Archaea is one of the most attractive alternatives to synthetic nitrogen fertilizers. However, with the exception of the symbiotic rhizobia-legumes system, progress towards a more extensive realization of this goal has been slow. In this study we manipulated the endogenous regulation of both nitrogen fixation and assimilation in the aerobic bacterium Azotobacter vinelandii. Substituting an exogenously inducible promoter for the native promoter of glutamine synthetase produced conditional lethal mutant strains unable to grow diazotrophically in the absence of the inducer. This mutant phenotype could be reverted in a double mutant strain bearing a deletion in the nifL gene that resulted in constitutive expression of nif genes and increased production of ammonium. Under GS non-inducing conditions both the single and the double mutant strains consistently released very high levels of ammonium (>20mM) into the growth medium. The double mutant strain grew and excreted high levels of ammonium under a wider range of concentrations of the inducer than the single mutant strain. Induced mutant cells could be loaded with glutamine synthetase at different levels, which resulted in different patterns of extracellular ammonium accumulation afterwards. Inoculation of the engineered bacteria into a microalgal culture in the absence of sources of C and N other than N₂ and CO₂ from the air, resulted in a strong proliferation of microalgae that was suppressed upon addition of the inducer. Both single and double mutant strains also promoted growth of cucumber plants in the absence of added N-fertilizer, while this property was only marginal in the parental strain. This study provides a simple synthetic genetic circuit that might inspire engineering of optimized inoculants that efficiently channel N₂ from the air into crops.

Metabolic engineering of ammonium release for nitrogen-fixing multispecies microbial cell-factories

The biological nitrogen fixation carried out by some Bacteria and Archaea is one of the most attractive alternatives to synthetic nitrogen fertilizers. In this study we compared the effect of controlling the maximum activation state of the Azotobacter vinelandii glutamine synthase by a point mutation at the active site (D49S mutation) and impairing the ammonium-dependent homeostatic control of nitrogen-fixation genes expression by the ΔnifL mutation on ammonium release by the cells. Strains bearing the single D49S mutation were more efficient ammonium producers under carbon/energy limiting conditions and sustained microalgae growth at the expense of atmospheric N2 in synthetic microalgae-bacteria consortia. Ammonium delivery by the different strains had implications for the microalga׳s cell-size distribution. It was uncovered an extensive cross regulation between nitrogen fixation and assimilation that extends current knowledge on this key metabolic pathway and might represent valuable hints for further improvements of versatile N2-fixing microbial-cell factories.

Nitrogen metabolism in Sinorhizobium meliloti-alfalfa symbiosis: dissecting the role of GlnD and PII proteins

To contribute nitrogen for plant growth and establish an effective symbiosis with alfalfa, Sinorhizobium meliloti Rm1021 needs normal operation of the GlnD protein, a bifunctional uridylyltransferase/uridylyl-cleavage enzyme that measures cellular nitrogen status and initiates a nitrogen stress response (NSR). However, the only two known targets of GlnD modification in Rm1021, the PII proteins GlnB and GlnK, are not necessary for effectiveness. We introduced a Tyr→Phe variant of GlnB, which cannot be uridylylated, into a glnBglnK background to approximate the expected state in a glnD-sm2 mutant, and this strain was effective. These results suggested that unmodified PII does not inhibit effectiveness. We also generated a glnBglnK-glnD triple mutant and used this and other mutants to dissect the role of these proteins in regulating the free-living NSR and nitrogen metabolism in symbiosis. The glnD-sm2 mutation was dominant to the glnBglnK mutations in symbiosis but recessive in some free-living phenotypes. The data show that the GlnD protein has a role in free-living growth and in symbiotic nitrogen exchange that does not depend on the PII proteins, suggesting that S. meliloti GlnD can communicate with the cell by alternate mechanisms.

In vitro studies of the uridylylation of the three PII protein paralogs from Rhodospirillum rubrum: the transferase activity of R. rubrum GlnD is regulated by alpha-ketoglutarate and divalent cations but not by glutamine

P(II) proteins have been shown to be key players in the regulation of nitrogen fixation and ammonia assimilation in bacteria. The mode by which these proteins act as signals is by being in either a form modified by UMP or the unmodified form. The modification, as well as demodification, is catalyzed by a bifunctional enzyme encoded by the glnD gene. The regulation of this enzyme is thus of central importance. In Rhodospirillum rubrum, three P(II) paralogs have been identified. In this study, we have used purified GlnD and P(II) proteins from R. rubrum, and we show that for the uridylylation activity of R. rubrum GlnD, alpha-ketoglutarate is the main signal, whereas glutamine has no effect. This is in contrast to, e.g., the Escherichia coli system. Furthermore, we show that all three P(II) proteins are uridylylated, although the efficiency is dependent on the cation present. This difference may be of importance in understanding the effects of the P(II) proteins on the different target enzymes. Furthermore, we show that the deuridylylation reaction is greatly stimulated by glutamine and that Mn(2+) is required.

Transposon mutations in the 5' end of glnD, the gene for a nitrogen regulatory sensor, that suppress the osmosensitive phenotype caused by otsBA lesions in Escherichia coli

GlnD of Escherichia coli is a bifunctional signal-transducing enzyme (102.4 kDa) which uridylylates the allosteric regulatory protein PII and deuridylylates PII-UMP in response to growth with nitrogen excess or limitation, respectively. GlnD catalyzes these reactions in response to high or low levels of cytoplasmic glutamine, respectively, and indirectly directs the expression of nitrogen-regulated genes, e.g., the glnK-amtB operon. We report that chromosomal mini-Tn10 insertions situated after nucleotide number 997 or 1075 of glnD partially suppressed the osmosensitive phenotype of DeltaotsBA or otsA::Tn10 mutations (defective osmoregulatory trehalose synthesis). Strains carrying these glnD::mini-Tn10 mutations either completely repressed the expression of trp::(glnKp-lacZ) or induced this reporter system to nearly 60% of the wild-type glnD level in response to nitrogen availability, an essentially normal response. This was in contrast to the much-studied glnD99::Tn10 mutation, which carries its insertion in the 3' end of the gene, causes a complete repression of glnKp-lacZ expression under all growth conditions, and also confers leaky glutamine auxotrophy. When expressed from the Pm promoter in plasmid constructs, the present glnD mutations produced proteins with an apparent mass of 39 or 42 kDa. These proteins were deduced to comprise 344 or 370 N-terminal residues, respectively, harboring the known nucleotidyltransferase domain of GlnD, plus a common C-terminal addition of 12 residues encoded by IS10. They lacked three other domains of GlnD. Apparently, the transferase domain by itself enabled the cells to catalyze the uridylylation reaction and direct nitrogen-regulated gene expression. Our data indicate that there exists a link between osmotic stress and the nitrogen response.

The poor growth of Rhodospirillum rubrum mutants lacking PII proteins is due to an excess of glutamine synthetase activity

The P(II) family of proteins is found in all three domains of life and serves as a central regulator of the function of proteins involved in nitrogen metabolism, reflecting the nitrogen and carbon balance in the cell. The genetic elimination of the genes encoding these proteins typically leads to severe growth problems, but the basis of this effect has been unknown except with Escherichia coli. We have analysed a number of the suppressor mutations that correct such growth problems in Rhodospirillum rubrum mutants lacking P(II) proteins. These suppressors map to nifR3, ntrB, ntrC, amtB(1) and the glnA region and all have the common property of decreasing total activity of glutamine synthetase (GS). We also show that GS activity is very high in the poorly growing parental strains lacking P(II) proteins. Consistent with this, overexpression of GS in glnE mutants (lacking adenylyltransferase activity) also causes poor growth. All of these results strongly imply that elevated GS activity is the causative basis for the poor growth seen in R. rubrum mutants lacking P(II) and presumably in mutants of some other organisms with similar genotypes. The result underscores the importance of proper regulation of GS activity for cell growth.

GlnD is essential for NifA activation, NtrB/NtrC-regulated gene expression, and posttranslational regulation of nitrogenase activity in the photosynthetic, nitrogen-fixing bacterium Rhodospirillum rubrum

GlnD is a bifunctional uridylyltransferase/uridylyl-removing enzyme and is thought to be the primary sensor of nitrogen status in the cell. It plays an important role in nitrogen assimilation and metabolism by reversibly regulating the modification of P(II) proteins, which in turn regulate a variety of other proteins. We report here the characterization of glnD mutants from the photosynthetic, nitrogen-fixing bacterium Rhodospirillum rubrum and the analysis of the roles of GlnD in the regulation of nitrogen fixation. Unlike glnD mutations in Azotobacter vinelandii and some other bacteria, glnD deletion mutations are not lethal in R. rubrum. Such mutants grew well in minimal medium with glutamate as the sole nitrogen source, although they grew slowly with ammonium as the sole nitrogen source (MN medium) and were unable to fix N(2). The slow growth in MN medium is apparently due to low glutamine synthetase activity, because a DeltaglnD strain with an altered glutamine synthetase that cannot be adenylylated can grow well in MN medium. Various mutation and complementation studies were used to show that the critical uridylyltransferase activity of GlnD is localized to the N-terminal region. Mutants with intermediate levels of uridylyltransferase activity are differentially defective in nif gene expression, the posttranslational regulation of nitrogenase, and NtrB/NtrC function, indicating the complexity of the physiological role of GlnD. These results have implications for the interpretation of results obtained with GlnD in many other organisms.

A crucial arginine residue is required for a conformational switch in NifL to regulate nitrogen fixation in Azotobacter vinelandii

NifL is an antiactivator that tightly regulates transcription of genes required for nitrogen fixation in Azotobacter vinelandii by controlling the activity of its partner protein NifA, a member of the family of sigma(54)-dependent transcriptional activators. Although the C-terminal region of A. vinelandii NifL shows homology to the transmitter domains of histidine protein kinases, signal transduction between NifL and NifA is conveyed by means of protein-protein interactions rather than by phosphorylation. Binding of the ligand 2-oxoglutarate to NifA plays a crucial role in preventing inhibition by NifL under conditions appropriate for nitrogen fixation. We have used a suppressor screen to identify a critical arginine residue (R306) in NifL that is required to release NifA from inhibition under appropriate environmental conditions. Amino acid substitutions at position 306 result in constitutive inhibition of NifA activity by NifL, thus preventing nitrogen fixation. Biochemical studies with one of the mutant proteins demonstrate that the substitution alters the conformation of NifL significantly and prevents the response of NifA to 2-oxoglutarate. We propose that arginine 306 is critical for the propagation of signals perceived by A. vinelandii NifL in response to the redox and fixed-nitrogen status and is required for a conformational switch that inactivates the inhibitory function of NifL under conditions appropriate for nitrogen fixation.

The GlnD and GlnK homologues of Streptomyces coelicolor A3(2) are functionally dissimilar to their nitrogen regulatory system counterparts from enteric bacteria

Glutamine synthetase I (GSI) enzyme activity in Streptomyces coelicolor is controlled post-translationally by the adenylyltransferase (GlnE) as in enteric bacteria. Although other homologues of the Escherichia coli Ntr system (glnK, coding for a PII family protein; and glnD, coding for an uridylyltransferase) are found in the S. coelicolor genome, the regulation of the GSI activity was found to be different. The functions of glnK and glnD were analysed by specific mutants. Surprisingly, biochemical assay and two-dimensional PAGE analysis showed that modification of GSI by GlnE occurs normally in all mutant strains, and neither GlnK nor GlnD are required for the regulation of GlnE in response to nitrogen stimuli. Analysis of the post-translational regulation of GlnK in vivo by two-dimensional PAGE and mass spectrometry indicated that it is subject to both a reversible and a non-reversible modification in a direct response to nitrogen availability. The irreversible modification was identified as removal of the first three N-terminal amino acid residues of the protein, and the reversible modification as adenylylation of the conserved tyro-sine 51 residue that is known to be uridylylated in E. coli. The glnD insertion mutant expressing only the N-terminal half of GlnD was capable of adenylylating GlnK, but was unable to perform the reverse deadenylylation reaction in response to excess ammonium. The glnD null mutant completely lacked the ability to adenylylate GlnK. This work provides the first example of a PII protein that is modified by adenylylation, and demonstrates that this reaction is performed by a homologue of GlnD, previously described only as a uridylyltransferase enzyme.

Isolation and characterization of the glnD gene of Gluconacetobacter diazotrophicus, encoding a putative uridylyltransferase/uridylyl-removing enzyme

The glnD gene of Gluconacetobacter diazotrophicus was isolated by complementation of the Azotobacter vinelandii glnD (nfrX) mutant strain MV17 using a pLAFR3 cosmid library. The 5 kb chromosomal DNA region encoding the glnD gene on cosmid pAD401 was identified by introduction of deletions as well as subcloning of restriction fragments followed by subsequent DNA sequencing. Three open reading frames were identified with the deduced amino acid sequence of ORF1 showing significant homologies to known GlnD proteins of other proteobacteria such as Sinorhizobium meliloti, Rhizobium tropici, Escherichia coli and Azotobacter vinelandii.A mutagenesis of the chromosomal glnD gene was carried out by insertion of an interposon carrying the kanamycin resistance gene of Tn5. Mutants carrying the cassette inserted into a central region of glnD could not be isolated, while an interposon mutation at the 3' end of glnD was successful. The resulting strain showed a prolonged generation time in complex growth medium and was unable to utilize ammonium as sole nitrogen source. This phenotype appears to be pleiotropic, since the addition of single amino acids to the minimal medium was not sufficient to allow growth. Furthermore, the glnD mutant was able to express nitrogenase under diazotrophic as well as repressing growth conditions.

Direct interaction of the NifL regulatory protein with the GlnK signal transducer enables the Azotobacter vinelandii NifL-NifA regulatory system to respond to conditions replete for nitrogen

The Azotobacter vinelandii NifL-NifA regulatory system integrates metabolic signals for redox, energy, and nitrogen status to fine tune regulation of the synthesis of molybdenum nitrogenase. The NifL protein utilizes discrete mechanisms to perceive these signals leading to the formation of a protein-protein complex, which inhibits NifA activity. Whereas redox signaling is mediated via a flavin-containing PAS domain in the N-terminal region of NifL, the nitrogen status is sensed via interaction with PII-like signal transduction proteins and small molecular weight effectors. The nonuridylylated form of the PII-like protein encoded by A. vinelandii glnK (Av GlnK) stimulates NifL to inhibit transcriptional activation by NifA in vitro. Here we demonstrate that the nonmodified form of Av GlnK directly interacts with A. vinelandii NifL and that this interaction is dependent on Mg(2+), ATP, and 2-oxoglutarate. Differences were observed in the regulation of the Av GlnK-NifL interaction by 2-oxoglutarate compared with the role of this effector in modulating the interaction of enteric PII-like proteins with their receptors. We also report that the interaction between Av GlnK and NifL is abolished by site-directed substitution of a single amino acid in the T-loop region of Av GlnK and that uridylylation of the conserved tyrosine residue in the T-loop inhibits the interaction. No association was detected between Av GlnK and the N-terminal region of NifL and our results demonstrate that Av GlnK directly interacts with the C-terminal histidine protein kinase-like domain.

Role of GlnK in NifL-mediated regulation of NifA activity in Azotobacter vinelandii

In several diazotrophic species of Proteobacteria, P(II) signal transduction proteins have been implicated in the regulation of nitrogen fixation in response to NH(4)(+) by several mechanisms. In Azotobacter vinelandii, expression of nifA, encoding the nif-specific activator, is constitutive, and thus, regulation of NifA activity by the flavoprotein NifL appears to be the primary level of nitrogen control. In vitro and genetic evidence suggests that the nitrogen response involves the P(II)-like GlnK protein and GlnD (uridylyltransferase/uridylyl-removing enzyme), which reversibly uridylylates GlnK in response to nitrogen limitation. Here, the roles of GlnK and GlnK-UMP in A. vinelandii were studied to determine whether the Nif (-) phenotype of glnD strains was due to an inability to modify GlnK, an effort previously hampered because glnK is an essential gene in this organism. A glnKY51F mutation, encoding an unuridylylatable form of the protein, was stable only in a strain in which glutamine synthetase activity is not inhibited by NH(4)(+), suggesting that GlnK-UMP is required to signal adenylyltransferase/adenylyl-removing enzyme-mediated deadenylylation. glnKY51F strains were significantly impaired for diazotrophic growth and expression of a nifH-lacZ fusion. NifL interacted with GlnK and GlnKY51F in a yeast two-hybrid system. Together, these data are consistent with those obtained from in vitro experiments (Little et al., EMBO J., 19:6041-6050, 2000) and support a model for regulation of NifA activity in which unmodified GlnK stimulates NifL inhibition and uridylylation of GlnK in response to nitrogen limitation prevents this function. This model is distinct from one proposed for the related bacterium Klebsiella pneumoniae, in which unmodified GlnK relieves NifL inhibition instead of stimulating it.

glnD and mviN are genes of an essential operon in Sinorhizobium meliloti

To evaluate the role of uridylyl-transferase, the Sinorhizobium meliloti glnD gene was isolated by heterologous complementation in Azotobacter vinelandii. The glnD gene is cotranscribed with a gene homologous to Salmonella mviN. glnD1::Omega or mviN1::Omega mutants could not be isolated by a powerful sucrose counterselection procedure unless a complementing cosmid was provided, indicating that glnD and mviN are members of an indispensable operon in S. meliloti.