(p)ppGpp modulates cell size and the initiation of DNA replication in Caulobacter crescentus in response to a block in lipid biosynthesis

Phosphate starvation decouples cell differentiation from DNA replication control in the dimorphic bacterium Caulobacter crescentus

Upon nutrient depletion, bacteria stop proliferating and undergo physiological and morphological changes to ensure their survival. Yet, how these processes are coordinated in response to distinct starvation conditions is poorly understood. Here we compare the cellular responses of Caulobacter crescentus to carbon (C), nitrogen (N) and phosphorus (P) starvation conditions. We find that DNA replication initiation and abundance of the replication initiator DnaA are, under all three starvation conditions, regulated by a common mechanism involving the inhibition of DnaA translation. By contrast, cell differentiation from a motile swarmer cell to a sessile stalked cell is regulated differently under the three starvation conditions. During C and N starvation, production of the signaling molecules (p)ppGpp is required to arrest cell development in the motile swarmer stage. By contrast, our data suggest that low (p)ppGpp levels under P starvation allow P-starved swarmer cells to differentiate into sessile stalked cells. Further, we show that limited DnaA availability, and consequently absence of DNA replication initiation, is the main reason that prevents P-starved stalked cells from completing the cell cycle. Together, our findings demonstrate that C. crescentus decouples cell differentiation from DNA replication initiation under certain starvation conditions, two otherwise intimately coupled processes. We hypothesize that arresting the developmental program either as motile swarmer cells or as sessile stalked cells improves the chances of survival of C. crescentus during the different starvation conditions.

Mutant structure of metabolic switch protein in complex with monomeric c-di-GMP reveals a potential mechanism of protein-mediated ligand dimerization

Bacterial second messengers c-di-GMP and (p)ppGpp have broad functional repertoires ranging from growth and cell cycle control to the regulation of biofilm formation and virulence. The recent identification of SmbA, an effector protein from Caulobacter crescentus that is jointly targeted by both signaling molecules, has opened up studies on how these global bacterial networks interact. C-di-GMP and (p)ppGpp compete for the same SmbA binding site, with a dimer of c-di-GMP inducing a conformational change that involves loop 7 of the protein that leads to downstream signaling. Here, we report a crystal structure of a partial loop 7 deletion mutant, SmbA_∆loop in complex with c-di-GMP determined at 1.4 Å resolution. SmbA_∆loop binds monomeric c-di-GMP indicating that loop 7 is required for c-di-GMP dimerization. Thus the complex probably represents the first step of consecutive c-di-GMP binding to form an intercalated dimer as has been observed in wild-type SmbA. Considering the prevalence of intercalated c-di-GMP molecules observed bound to proteins, the proposed mechanism may be generally applicable to protein-mediated c-di-GMP dimerization. Notably, in the crystal, SmbA_∆loop forms a 2-fold symmetric dimer via isologous interactions with the two symmetric halves of c-di-GMP. Structural comparisons of SmbA_∆loop with wild-type SmbA in complex with dimeric c-di-GMP or ppGpp support the idea that loop 7 is critical for SmbA function by interacting with downstream partners. Our results also underscore the flexibility of c-di-GMP, to allow binding to the symmetric SmbA_∆loop dimer interface. It is envisaged that such isologous interactions of c-di-GMP could be observed in hitherto unrecognized targets.

Mutations in degP and spoT Genes Mediate Response to Fermentation Stress in Thermally Adapted Strains of Acetic Acid Bacterium Komagataeibacter medellinensis NBRC 3288

An acetic acid bacterium, Komagataeibacter medellinensis NBRC 3288, was adapted to higher growth temperatures through an experimental evolution approach in acetic acid fermentation conditions, in which the cells grew under high concentrations of ethanol and acetic acid. The thermally adapted strains were shown to exhibit significantly increased growth and fermentation ability, compared to the wild strain, at higher temperatures. Although the wild cells were largely elongated and exhibited a rough cell surface, the adapted strains repressed the elongation and exhibited a smaller cell size and a smoother cell surface than the wild strain. Among the adapted strains, the ITO-1 strain isolated during the initial rounds of adaptation was shown to have three indel mutations in the genes gyrB, degP, and spoT. Among these, two dispensable genes, degP and spoT, were further examined in this study. Rough cell surface morphology related to degP mutation suggested that membrane vesicle-like structures were increased on the cell surface of the wild-type strain but repressed in the ITO-1 strain under high-temperature acetic acid fermentation conditions. The ΔdegP strain could not grow at higher temperatures and accumulated a large amount of membrane vesicles in the culture supernatant when grown even at 30°C, suggesting that the degP mutation is involved in cell surface stability. As the spoT gene of ITO-1 lost a 3′-end of 424 bp, which includes one (Act-4) of the possible two regulatory domains (TGS and Act-4), two spoT mutant strains were created: one (ΔTGSAct) with a drug cassette in between the 5′-half catalytic domain and 3′-half regulatory domains of the gene, and the other (ΔAct-4) in between TGS and Act-4 domains of the regulatory domain. These spoT mutants exhibited different growth responses; ΔTGSAct grew better in both the fermentation and non-fermentation conditions, whereas ΔAct-4 did only under fermentation conditions, such as ITO-1 at higher temperatures. We suggest that cell elongation and/or cell size are largely related to these spoT mutations, which may be involved in fermentation stress and thermotolerance.

A simple, quantitative assay for the detection of viable but non-culturable (VBNC) bacteria

This protocol determines the fraction of a bacterial population that is viable and culturable, viable and non-culturable, or non-viable (dead). Each population is detected by isolating colonies on agar plates, performing direct counts, and staining for live or dead cells. Its application is limited to bacteria that are stainable and when permissible growth conditions are known. The quantitative data extracted allow for the detection of a viable but non-culturable (alive and non-dividing) population from a liquid culture.

For complete details on the use and execution of this protocol, please refer to Stott et al. (2015).

•

Liquid cultures are spread onto agar plates to quantify CFU/mL

•

Direct counting is performed to determine the total number of bacteria per mL

•

Fluorescence microscopy is used to distinguish between live and dead bacteria

•

In sum, the protocol can reveal VBNC populations in a culture

Possible Roles for Basal Levels of (p)ppGpp: Growth Efficiency Vs. Surviving Stress

Two (p)ppGpp nucleotide analogs, sometimes abbreviated simply as ppGpp, are widespread in bacteria and plants. Their name alarmone reflects a view of their function as intracellular hormone-like protective alarms that can increase a 100-fold when sensing any of an array of physical or nutritional dangers, such as abrupt starvation, that trigger lifesaving adjustments of global gene expression and physiology. The diversity of mechanisms for stress-specific adjustments of this sort is large and further compounded by almost infinite microbial diversity. The central question raised by this review is whether the small basal levels of (p)ppGpp functioning during balanced growth serve very different roles than alarmone-like functions. Recent discoveries that abrupt amino acid starvation of Escherichia coli, accompanied by very high levels of ppGpp, occasion surprising instabilities of transfer RNA (tRNA), ribosomal RNA (rRNA), and ribosomes raises new questions. Is this destabilization, a mode of regulation linearly related to (p)ppGpp over the entire continuum of (p)ppGpp levels, including balanced growth? Are regulatory mechanisms exerted by basal (p)ppGpp levels fundamentally different than for high levels? There is evidence from studies of other organisms suggesting special regulatory features of basal levels compared to burst of (p)ppGpp. Those differences seem to be important even during bacterial infection, suggesting that unbalancing the basal levels of (p)ppGpp may become a future antibacterial treatment. A simile for this possible functional duality is that (p)ppGpp acts like a car’s brake, able to stop to avoid crashes as well as to slow down to drive safely.

(p)ppGpp: Magic Modulators of Bacterial Physiology and Metabolism

When bacteria experience growth-limiting environmental conditions, the synthesis of the hyperphosphorylated guanosine derivatives (p)ppGpp is induced by enzymes of the RelA/SpoT homology (RSH)-type protein family. High levels of (p)ppGpp induce a process called "stringent response", a major cellular reprogramming during which ribosomal RNA (rRNA) and transfer RNA (tRNA) synthesis is downregulated, stress-related genes upregulated, messenger RNA (mRNA) stability and translation altered, and allocation of scarce resources optimized. The (p)ppGpp-mediated stringent response is thus often regarded as an all-or-nothing paradigm induced by stress. Over the past decades, several binding partners of (p)ppGpp have been uncovered displaying dissociation constants from below one micromolar to more than one millimolar and thus coincide with the accepted intracellular concentrations of (p)ppGpp under non-stringent (basal levels) and stringent conditions. This suggests that the ability of (p)ppGpp to modulate target proteins or processes would be better characterized as an unceasing continuum over a concentration range instead of being an abrupt switch of biochemical processes under specific conditions. We analyzed the reported binding affinities of (p)ppGpp targets and depicted a scheme for prioritization of modulation by (p)ppGpp. In this ranking, many enzymes of e.g., nucleotide metabolism are among the first targets to be affected by rising (p)ppGpp while more fundamental processes such as DNA replication are among the last. This preference should be part of (p)ppGpp's "magic" in the adaptation of microorganisms while still maintaining their potential for outgrowth once a stressful condition is overcome.

Multilayered control of chromosome replication in Caulobacter crescentus

The environmental Alphaproteobacterium Caulobacter crescentus is a classical model to study the regulation of the bacterial cell cycle. It divides asymmetrically, giving a stalked cell that immediately enters S phase and a swarmer cell that stays in the G1 phase until it differentiates into a stalked cell. Its genome consists in a single circular chromosome whose replication is tightly regulated so that it happens only in stalked cells and only once per cell cycle. Imbalances in chromosomal copy numbers are the most often highly deleterious, if not lethal. This review highlights recent discoveries on pathways that control chromosome replication when Caulobacter is exposed to optimal or less optimal growth conditions. Most of these pathways target two proteins that bind directly onto the chromosomal origin: the highly conserved DnaA initiator of DNA replication and the CtrA response regulator that is found in most Alphaproteobacteria The concerted inactivation and proteolysis of CtrA during the swarmer-to-stalked cell transition license cells to enter S phase, while a replisome-associated Regulated Inactivation and proteolysis of DnaA (RIDA) process ensures that initiation starts only once per cell cycle. When Caulobacter is stressed, it turns on control systems that delay the G1-to-S phase transition or the elongation of DNA replication, most probably increasing its fitness and adaptation capacities.

Learning from the master: targets and functions of the CtrA response regulator in Brucella abortus and other alpha-proteobacteria

The α-proteobacteria are a fascinating group of free-living, symbiotic and pathogenic organisms, including the Brucella genus, which is responsible for a worldwide zoonosis. One common feature of α-proteobacteria is the presence of a conserved response regulator called CtrA, first described in the model bacterium Caulobacter crescentus, where it controls gene expression at different stages of the cell cycle. Here, we focus on Brucella abortus and other intracellular α-proteobacteria in order to better assess the potential role of CtrA in the infectious context. Comparative genomic analyses of the CtrA control pathway revealed the conservation of specific modules, as well as the acquisition of new factors during evolution. The comparison of CtrA regulons also suggests that specific clades of α-proteobacteria acquired distinct functions under its control, depending on the essentiality of the transcription factor. Other CtrA-controlled functions, for instance motility and DNA repair, are proposed to be more ancestral. Altogether, these analyses provide an interesting example of the plasticity of a regulation network, subject to the constraints of inherent imperatives such as cell division and the adaptations to diversified environmental niches.

Surface Area to Volume Ratio: A Natural Variable for Bacterial Morphogenesis

An immediately observable feature of bacteria is that cell size and shape are remarkably constant and characteristic for a given species in a particular condition, but vary quantitatively with physiological parameters such as growth rate, indicating both genetic and environmental regulation. However, despite decades of research, the molecular mechanisms underlying bacterial morphogenesis have remained incompletely characterized. We recently demonstrated that a wide range of bacterial species exhibit a robust surface area to volume ratio (SA/V) homeostasis. Because cell size, shape, and SA/V are mathematically interconnected, if SA/V is indeed the natural variable that cells actively monitor, this finding has critical implications for our understanding of bacterial morphogenesis, placing fundamental constraints on the sizes and shapes that cells can adopt. In this Opinion article we discuss the broad implications that this novel perspective has for the field of bacterial growth and morphogenesis.

Bacterial Cell Size: Multifactorial and Multifaceted

How cells establish, maintain, and modulate size has always been an area of great interest and fascination. Until recently, technical limitations curtailed our ability to understand the molecular basis of bacterial cell size control. In the past decade, advances in microfluidics, imaging, and high-throughput single-cell analysis, however, have led to a flurry of work revealing size to be a highly complex trait involving the integration of three core aspects of bacterial physiology: metabolism, growth, and cell cycle progression.

Regulation of the replication initiator DnaA in Caulobacter crescentus

The decision to initiate DNA replication is a critical step in the cell cycle of all organisms. In nearly all bacteria, replication initiation requires the activity of the conserved replication initiation protein DnaA. Due to its central role in cell cycle progression, DnaA activity must be precisely regulated. This review summarizes the current state of DnaA regulation in the asymmetrically dividing α-proteobacterium Caulobacter crescentus, an important model for bacterial cell cycle studies. Mechanisms will be discussed that regulate DnaA activity and abundance under optimal conditions and in coordination with the asymmetric Caulobacter cell cycle. Furthermore, we highlight recent findings of how regulated DnaA synthesis and degradation collaborate to adjust DnaA abundance under stress conditions. The mechanisms described provide important examples of how DNA replication is regulated in an α-proteobacterium and thus represent an important starting point for the study of DNA replication in many other bacteria. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Dynamic gene expression, edited by Prof. Patrick Viollier.

Shapeshifting to Survive: Shape Determination and Regulation in Caulobacter crescentus

Bacterial cell shape is a genetically encoded and inherited feature that is optimized for efficient growth, survival, and propagation of bacteria. In addition, bacterial cell morphology is adaptable to changes in environmental conditions. Work in recent years has demonstrated that individual features of cell shape, such as length or curvature, arise through the spatial regulation of cell wall synthesis by cytoskeletal proteins. However, the mechanisms by which these different morphogenetic factors are coordinated and how they may be globally regulated in response to cell cycle and environmental cues are only beginning to emerge. Here, we have summarized recent advances that have been made to understand morphology in the dimorphic Gram-negative bacterium Caulobacter crescentus.

Hit the right spots: cell cycle control by phosphorylated guanosines in alphaproteobacteria

The class Alphaproteobacteria includes Gram-negative free-living, symbiotic and obligate intracellular bacteria, as well as important plant, animal and human pathogens. Recent work has established the key antagonistic roles that phosphorylated guanosines, cyclic-di-GMP (c-di-GMP) and the alarmones guanosine tetraphosphate and guanosine pentaphosphate (collectively referred to as (p)ppGpp), have in the regulation of the cell cycle in these bacteria. In this Review, we discuss the insights that have been gained into the regulation of the initiation of DNA replication and cytokinesis by these second messengers, with a particular focus on the cell cycle of Caulobacter crescentus. We explore how the fluctuating levels of c-di-GMP and (p)ppGpp during the progression of the cell cycle and under conditions of stress control the synthesis and proteolysis of key regulators of the cell cycle. As these signals also promote bacterial interactions with host cells, the enzymes that control (p)ppGpp and c-di-GMP are attractive antibacterial targets.

The stringent response plays a key role in Bacillus subtilis survival of fatty acid starvation

The stringent response is a universal adaptive mechanism to protect bacteria from nutritional and environmental stresses. The role of the stringent response during lipid starvation has been studied only in Gram-negative bacteria. Here, we report that the stringent response also plays a crucial role in the adaptation of the model Gram-positive Bacillus subtilis to fatty acid starvation. B. subtilis lacking all three (p)ppGpp-synthetases (Rel_Bs , RelP and RelQ) or bearing a Rel_Bs variant that no longer synthesizes (p)ppGpp suffer extreme loss of viability on lipid starvation. Loss of viability is paralleled by perturbation of membrane integrity and function, with collapse of membrane potential as the likely cause of death. Although no increment of (p)ppGpp could be detected in lipid starved B. subtilis, we observed a substantial increase in the GTP/ATP ratio of strains incapable of synthesizing (p)ppGpp. Artificially lowering GTP with decoyinine rescued viability of such strains, confirming observations that low intracellular GTP is important for survival of nutritional stresses. Altogether, our results show that activation of the stringent response by lipid starvation is a broadly conserved response of bacteria and that a key role of (p)ppGpp is to couple biosynthetic processes that become detrimental if uncoordinated.

A cell cycle kinase with tandem sensory PAS domains integrates cell fate cues

All cells must integrate sensory information to coordinate developmental events in space and time. The bacterium Caulobacter crescentus uses two-component phospho-signalling to regulate spatially distinct cell cycle events through the master regulator CtrA. Here, we report that CckA, the histidine kinase upstream of CtrA, employs a tandem-PAS domain sensor to integrate two distinct spatiotemporal signals. Using CckA reconstituted on liposomes, we show that one PAS domain modulates kinase activity in a CckA density-dependent manner, mimicking the stimulation of CckA kinase activity that occurs on its transition from diffuse to densely packed at the cell poles. The second PAS domain interacts with the asymmetrically partitioned second messenger cyclic-di-GMP, inhibiting kinase activity while stimulating phosphatase activity, consistent with the selective inactivation of CtrA in the incipient stalked cell compartment. The integration of these spatially and temporally regulated signalling events within a single signalling receptor enables robust orchestration of cell-type-specific gene regulation.

The membrane-bound kinase CckA controls the activity of the Caulobacter crescentus master regulator CtrA, which in turn coordinates asymmetric cell division. Here, the authors show that CckA contains two sensory domains that have distinct sensitivities to fluctuations in cyclic-di-GMP concentration and subcellular niche.

Adder and a coarse-grained approach to cell size homeostasis in bacteria

Cell size control and homeostasis is a long-standing subject in biology. Recent experimental work provides extensive evidence for a simple, quantitative size homeostasis principle coined adder (as opposed to sizer or timer). The adder principle provides unexpected insights into how bacteria maintain their size without employing a feedback mechanism. We review the genesis of adder and recent cell size homeostasis study on evolutionarily divergent bacterial organisms and beyond. We propose new coarse-grained approaches to understand the underlying mechanisms of cell size control at the whole cell level.

Convergence of alarmone and cell cycle signaling from trans-encoded sensory domains

Despite the myriad of different sensory domains encoded in bacterial genomes, only a few are known to control the cell cycle. Here, suppressor genetics was used to unveil the regulatory interplay between the PAS (Per-Arnt-Sim) domain protein MopJ and the uncharacterized GAF (cyclic GMP-phosphodiesterase-adenylyl cyclase-FhlA) domain protein PtsP, which resembles an alternative component of the phosphoenolpyruvate (PEP) transferase system. Both of these systems indirectly target the Caulobacter crescentus cell cycle master regulator CtrA, but in different ways. While MopJ acts on CtrA via the cell cycle kinases DivJ and DivL, which control the removal of CtrA at the G1-S transition, our data show that PtsP signals through the conserved alarmone (p)ppGpp, which prevents CtrA cycling under nutritional stress and in stationary phase. We found that PtsP interacts genetically and physically with the (p)ppGpp synthase/hydrolase SpoT and that it modulates several promoters that are directly activated by the cell cycle transcriptional regulator GcrA. Thus, parallel systems integrate nutritional and systemic signals within the cell cycle transcriptional network, converging on the essential alphaproteobacterial regulator CtrA while also affecting global cell cycle transcription in other ways.

IMPORTANCE

Many alphaproteobacteria divide asymmetrically, and their cell cycle progression is carefully regulated. How these bacteria control the cell cycle in response to nutrient limitation is not well understood. Here, we identify a multicomponent signaling pathway that acts on the cell cycle when nutrients become scarce in stationary phase. We show that efficient accumulation of the master cell cycle regulator CtrA in stationary-phase Caulobacter crescentus cells requires the previously identified stationary-phase/cell cycle regulator MopJ as well as the phosphoenolpyruvate protein phosphotransferase PtsP, which acts via the conserved (p)ppGpp synthase SpoT. We identify cell cycle-regulated promoters that are affected by this pathway, providing an explanation of how (p)ppGpp-signaling might couple starvation to control cell cycle progression in Caulobacter spp. and likely other Alphaproteobacteria. This pathway has the potential to integrate carbon fluctuation into cell cycle control, since in phosphotransferase systems it is the glycolytic product phosphenolpyruvate (PEP) rather than ATP that is used as the phosphor donor for phosphorylation.

Topological control of the Caulobacter cell cycle circuitry by a polarized single-domain PAS protein

Despite the myriad of different sensory domains encoded in bacteria, only a few types are known to control the cell cycle. Here we use a forward genetic screen for Caulobacter crescentus motility mutants to identify a conserved single-domain PAS (Per-Arnt-Sim) protein (MopJ) with pleiotropic regulatory functions. MopJ promotes re-accumulation of the master cell cycle regulator CtrA after its proteolytic destruction is triggered by the DivJ kinase at the G1-S transition. MopJ and CtrA syntheses are coordinately induced in S-phase, followed by the sequestration of MopJ to cell poles in Caulobacter. Polarization requires Caulobacter DivJ and the PopZ polar organizer. MopJ interacts with DivJ and influences the localization and activity of downstream cell cycle effectors. Because MopJ abundance is upregulated in stationary phase and by the alarmone (p)ppGpp, conserved systemic signals acting on the cell cycle and growth phase control are genetically integrated through this conserved single PAS-domain protein.

The bacterium Caulobacter crescentus is a model organism for research on the bacterial cell cycle and cell division processes. Here, Sanselicio et al. show that the MopJ protein contributes to the control of cell cycle and growth in C. crescentus.