Genetic strategy for analyzing specificity of dimer formation: Escherichia coli cyclic AMP receptor protein mutant altered in its dimerization specificity

Dimerization of the quorum-sensing transcription factor TraR enhances resistance to cytoplasmic proteolysis

TraR is a LuxR-type quorum-sensing protein encoded by the tumour-inducing plasmid of Agrobacterium tumefaciens. TraR requires the pheromone N-3-oxooctanoyl-L-homoserine lactone (OOHL) for biological activity, and is dimeric both in solution and when bound to DNA. Dimerization is mediated primarily by two alpha-helices, one in the N-terminal OOHL binding domain, and the other in the C-terminal DNA binding domain. Each of these helices forms a parallel coiled coil with the identical helix of the opposite subunit. We have previously shown that OOHL is essential for resistance to proteolysis, and here we asked whether dimerization is also required for protease resistance. We constructed a series of site-directed mutations at the dimer interface, and tested these mutants for activity in vivo. Alteration of residues A149, A150, A153, A222 and I229 completely abolished activity, while alteration of three other residues also caused significant defects. All mutants were tested for dimerization as well as for specific DNA binding. The cellular abundance of these proteins in A. tumefaciens was measured using Western immunoblots and OOHL sequestration, while the half-life was measured by pulse-chase radiolabelling. We found a correlation between defects in in vivo activity, in vitro dimerization, DNA binding and protein half-life. We conclude that dimerization of TraR enhances resistance to cellular proteases.

A stochastic model of Escherichia coli AI-2 quorum signal circuit reveals alternative synthesis pathways

Quorum sensing (QS) is an important determinant of bacterial phenotype. Many cell functions are regulated by intricate and multimodal QS signal transduction processes. The LuxS/AI-2 QS system is highly conserved among Eubacteria and AI-2 is reported as a 'universal' signal molecule. To understand the hierarchical organization of AI-2 circuitry, a comprehensive approach incorporating stochastic simulations was developed. We investigated the synthesis, uptake, and regulation of AI-2, developed testable hypotheses, and made several discoveries: (1) the mRNA transcript and protein levels of AI-2 synthases, Pfs and LuxS, do not contribute to the dramatically increased level of AI-2 found when cells are grown in the presence of glucose; (2) a concomitant increase in metabolic flux through this synthesis pathway in the presence of glucose only partially accounts for this difference. We predict that 'high-flux' alternative pathways or additional biological steps are involved in AI-2 synthesis; and (3) experimental results validate this hypothesis. This work demonstrates the utility of linking cell physiology with systems-based stochastic models that can be assembled de novo with partial knowledge of biochemical pathways.

Cyclic AMP (cAMP) and cAMP receptor protein influence both synthesis and uptake of extracellular autoinducer 2 in Escherichia coli

Bacterial autoinducer 2 (AI-2) is proposed to be an interspecies mediator of cell-cell communication that enables cells to operate at the multicellular level. Many environmental stimuli have been shown to affect the extracellular AI-2 levels, carbon sources being among the most important. In this report, we show that both AI-2 synthesis and uptake in Escherichia coli are subject to catabolite repression through the cyclic AMP (cAMP)-CRP complex, which directly stimulates transcription of the lsr (for "luxS regulated") operon and indirectly represses luxS expression. Specifically, cAMP-CRP is shown to bind to a CRP binding site located in the upstream region of the lsr promoter and works with the LsrR repressor to regulate AI-2 uptake. The functions of the lsr operon and its regulators, LsrR and LsrK, previously reported in Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium, are confirmed here for E. coli. The elucidation of cAMP-CRP involvement in E. coli autoinduction impacts many areas, including the growth of E. coli in fermentation processes.

Repositioning about the dimer interface of the transcription regulator CooA: a major signal transduction pathway between the effector and DNA-binding domains

Activation of the homodimeric transcriptional regulator CooA depends on the coupling of CO binding at an effector domain heme with the allosteric repositioning of the DNA-binding domain F-helix that promotes specific DNA interaction. By analogy to the homologous cAMP receptor protein (CRP), it has been proposed that effector binding elicits subunit reorientation about their coiled-coil C-helix interface, and that this effector domain reorientation stabilizes the active position of the DNA-binding domains. Here, we describe experiments in which effector-independent "CooA*" variants were selected following randomization of a six-residue portion of the C-helix dimerization domain. Subsequent activity analyses, both in vivo and in vitro, were consistent with a model wherein improved C-helix "leucine zipper" interactions modestly shifted the regulator population equilibrium towards the active conformation, although full activation remained CO-dependent. However, in addition to the improved leucine zipper, maximal CooA* activity required additional C-helix changes which in a WT background decreased normal CO-dependent DNA-binding 100-fold. This seemingly paradoxical combination suggested that maximal CooA* activity depended both on the improved coiled-coil interactions and the decoupling of the signal pathway within the effector domain. Both types of C-helix changes indicate that its repositioning is crucial for the allosteric shift in the inactive/active equilibrium of the DNA-binding domain.

Characterization of the dimerization domain in the FNR transcription factor

The global anaerobic regulator FNR from Escherichia coli is a dimeric Fe-S protein that is inactivated by O(2) through disruption of its [4Fe-4S] cluster and conversion to a monomeric form. As a first step in elucidating the molecular interactions that control FNR dimerization, we have performed alanine-scanning mutagenesis of a potential dimerization domain. Replacement of many hydrophobic residues (Met-143, Met-144, Leu-146, Met-147, Ile-151, Met-157, and Ile-158) and two charged residues (Arg-140 and Arg-145) with Ala decreased FNR activity in vivo. Size exclusion chromatography and Fe-S cluster analysis of three representative mutant proteins, FNR-M147A, FNR-I151A, and FNR-I158A, showed that the Ala substitutions produced specific defects in dimerization. Because hydrophobic side chains are known to stabilize subunit-subunit interactions between alpha-helices, we propose that Met-147, Ile-151, and Ile-158 lie on the same face of an alpha-helix that constitutes a dimerization interface. This alignment would also position Arg-140, Met-144, and Asp-154 on the same helical face. In support of the unusual positioning of a negatively charged residue at the dimer interface, we found that replacing Asp-154 with Ala repaired the defects caused by Ala substitutions of other residues located on the same helical face. These data also suggest that Asp-154 has an inhibitory effect on dimerization, which may be a key element in the control of FNR dimerization by O(2) availability.

A chimeric activator of transcription that uses two DNA-binding domains to make simultaneous contact with pairs of recognition sites

Many well-known transcriptional regulatory proteins are composed of at least two independently folding domains and, typically, only one of these is a DNA-binding domain. However, some transcriptional regulators have been described that have more than one DNA-binding domain. Regulators with a single DNA-binding domain often bind co-operatively to the DNA in homotypic or heterotypic combinations, and two or more DNA-binding domains of a single regulatory protein can also bind co-operatively to suitably positioned recognition sequences. Here, we examine the behaviour of a chimeric activator of transcription with two different DNA-binding domains, that of the bacteriophage lambda cI protein and that of the Escherichia coli cyclic AMP receptor protein. We show that these two DNA-binding moieties, when present in the same molecule, can bind co-operatively to a pair of cognate recognition sites located upstream of a test promoter, thereby permitting the chimera to function as a particularly strong activator of transcription from this promoter. Our results show how such a bivalent DNA-binding protein can be used to regulate transcription differentially from promoters that bear either one or both recognition sites.

Genetic systems for analyzing protein-protein interactions in bacteria

Analysis of protein-protein interactions has been revolutionized by the yeast two-hybrid system introduced by Fields and coworkers. In recent years, similar genetic assays have been developed in bacteria. We describe here several of these systems and highlight some potential applications of these technologies.

Escherichia coli one- and two-hybrid systems for the analysis and identification of protein-protein interactions

Genetic methods based on fusion proteins allow the power of a genetic approach to be applied to the self-assembly of proteins or protein fragments, regardless of whether or not the normal function of the fused assembly domains is either known or amenable to selection or screening. The widespread adoption of variations of the yeast two-hybrid system originally described by S. Fields and O. Song (1989, Nature 340, 245-246) demonstrates the usefulness of these kinds of assays. This review describes some of the many systems used to select or screen for protein-protein interactions based on the regulation of reporter constructs by hybrid proteins expressed in bacteria, including recent implementations of generalizable two-hybrid systems for Escherichia coli.

A cyclic AMP receptor protein mutant that constitutively activates an Escherichia coli promoter disrupted by an IS5 insertion

Previously an Escherichia coli mutant that had acquired the ability to grow on propanediol as the sole carbon and energy source was isolated. This phenotype is the result of the constitutive expression of the fucO gene (in the fucAO operon), which encodes one of the enzymes in the fucose metabolic pathway. The mutant was found to bear an IS5 insertion in the intergenic regulatory region between the divergently oriented fucAO and fucPIK operons. Though expression of the fucAO operon was constitutive, the fucPIK operon became noninducible such that the mutant could no longer grow on fucose. A fucose-positive revertant which was found to contain a suppressor mutation in the crp gene was selected. Here we identify this crp mutation, which results in a single amino acid substitution (K52N) that has been proposed previously to uncover a cryptic activating region in the cyclic AMP receptor protein (CRP). We show that the mutant CRP constitutively activates transcription from both the IS5-disrupted and the wild-type fucPIK promoters, and we identify the CRP-binding site that is required for this activity. Our results show that the fucPIK promoter, a complex promoter which ordinarily depends on both CRP and the fucose-specific regulator FucR for its activation, can be activated in the absence of FucR by a mutant CRP that uses three, rather than two, activating regions to contact RNA polymerase. For the IS5-disrupted promoter, which retains a single CRP-binding site, the additional activating region of the mutant CRP evidently compensates for the lack of upstream regulatory sequences.

A genetic method for dissecting the mechanism of transcriptional activator synergy by identical activators

Pairs of transcriptional activators in prokaryotes have been shown to activate transcription synergistically from promoters with two activator binding sites. In some cases, such synergistic effects result from cooperative binding, but in other cases each DNA-bound activator plays a direct role in the activation process by interacting simultaneously with separate surfaces of RNA polymerase. In such cases, each DNA-bound activator must possess a functional activating region, the surface that mediates the interaction with RNA polymerase. When transcriptional activation depends on two or more identical activators, it is not straightforward to test the requirement of each activator for a functional activating region. Here we describe a method for directing a mutationally altered activator to either one or the other binding site, and we demonstrate the use of this method to examine the mechanism of transcriptional activator synergy by the Escherichia coli cyclic AMP receptor protein (CRP) working at an artificial promoter bearing two CRP-binding sites.

Dimerization of the Agrobacterium tumefaciens VirB4 ATPase and the effect of ATP-binding cassette mutations on the assembly and function of the T-DNA transporter

The Agrobacterium tumefaciens VirB4 ATPase functions with other VirB proteins to export T-DNA to susceptible plant cells and other DNA substrates to a variety of prokaryotic and eukaryotic cells. Previous studies have demonstrated that VirB4 mutants with defects in the Walker A nucleotide-binding motif are non-functional and exert a dominant negative phenotype when synthesized in wild-type cells. This study characterized the oligomeric structure of VirB4 and examined the effects of Walker A sequence mutations on complex formation and transporter activity. VirB4 directed dimer formation when fused to the amino-terminal portion of cI repressor protein, as shown by immunity of Escherichia coli cells to lambda phage infection. VirB4 also dimerized in Agrobacterium tumefaciens, as demonstrated by the recovery of a detergent-resistant complex of native protein and a functional, histidine-tagged derivative by precipitation with anti-His6 antibodies and by Co2+ affinity chromatography. Walker A sequence mutants directed repressor dimerization in E. coli and interacted with His-VirB4 in A. tumefaciens, indicating that ATP binding is not required for self-association. A dimerization domain was localized to a proposed N-terminal membrane-spanning region of VirB4, as shown by the dominance of an allele coding for the N-terminal 312 residues and phage immunity of host cells expressing cI repressor fusions to alleles for the first 237 or 312 residues. A recent study reported that the synthesis of a subset of VirB proteins, including VirB4, in agrobacterial recipients has a pronounced stimulatory effect on the virB-dependent conjugal transfer of plasmid RSF1010 by agrobacterial donors. VirB4'312 suppressed the stimulatory effect of VirB proteins for DNA uptake when synthesized in recipient cells. In striking contrast, Walker A sequence mutants contributed to the stimulatory effect of VirB proteins to the same extent as native VirB4. These findings indicate that the oligomeric structure of VirB4, but not its capacity to bind ATP, is important for the assembly of VirB proteins as a DNA uptake system. The results of these studies support a model in which VirB4 dimers or homomultimers contribute structural information for the assembly of a transenvelope channel competent for bidirectional DNA transfer, whereas an ATP-dependent activity is required for configuring this channel as a dedicated export machine.

Catabolic repression of secB expression is positively controlled by cyclic AMP (cAMP) receptor protein-cAMP complexes at the transcriptional level

SecB, a protein export-specific chaperone, enhances the export of a subset of proteins across cytoplasmic membranes of Escherichia coli. Previous studies showed that the synthesis of SecB is repressed by the presence of glucose in the medium. The derepression of SecB requires the products of both the cya and crp genes, indicating that secB expression is under the control of catabolic repression. In this study, two secB-specific promoters were identified. In addition, 5' transcription initiation sites from these two promoters were determined by means of secB-lacZ fusions and primer extension. The distal P1 promoter appeared to be independent of carbon sources, whereas the proximal P2 promoter was shown to be subject to control by the cyclic AMP (cAMP) receptor protein (CRP)-cAMP complexes. Gel-mobility shift studies showed that this regulation results from direct interaction between the secB P2 promoter region and the CRP-cAMP complex. Moreover, the CRP binding site on the secB gene was determined by DNase I footprinting and further substantiated by mutational analysis. The identified secB CRP binding region is centered at the -61.5 region of the secB gene and differed from the putative binding sites predicted by computer analysis.

Oligomerization properties of GCN4 leucine zipper e and g position mutants

Putative intersubunit electrostatic interactions between charged amino acids on the surfaces of the dimer interfaces of leucine zippers (g-e' ion pairs) have been implicated as determinants of dimerization specificity. To evaluate the importance of these ionic interactions in determining the specificity of dimer formation, we constructed a pool of > 65,000 GCN4 leucine zipper mutants in which all the e and g positions are occupied by different combinations of alanine, glutamic acid, lysine, or threonine. The oligomerization properties of these mutants were evaluated based on the phenotypes of cells expressing lambda repressor-leucine zipper fusion proteins. About 90% of the mutants do not form stable homooligomers. Surprisingly, approximately 8% of the mutant sequences have phenotypes consistent with the formation of higher-order (> dimer) oligomers, which can be classified into three types based on sequence features. The oligomerization states of mutants from two of these types were determined by characterizing purified fusion proteins. The Type I mutant behaved as a tetramer under all tested conditions, whereas the Type III mutant formed a variety of higher-order oligomers, depending on the solution conditions. Stable homodimers comprise less than 3% of the pool; several g-e' positions in these mutants could form attractive ion pairs. Putative repulsive ion pairs are not found among the homodimeric mutants. However, patterns of charged residues at the e and g positions do not seem to be sufficient to predict either homodimer or heterodimer formation among the mutants.

Buried asparagines determine the dimerization specificities of leucine zipper mutants

Regulation of gene expression by many transcription factors is controlled by specific combinations of homo- and heterodimers through a short alpha-helical coiled-coil known as a leucine zipper. The dimer interface of a leucine zipper involves side chains of the residues at the a, d, e, and g positions of the (abcdefg)n heptad repeat. To understand the basis for the specificity of dimer formation, we characterized GCN4 leucine zipper mutants with all 16 possible permutations and combinations of isoleucines and asparagines at four a positions in the dimer interface, using a genetic test for the specificity of dimer formation by lambda repressor-leucine zipper fusions. Heterodimers were detected by loss of repressor activity in the presence of a fusion to a dominant-negative mutant form of the DNA-binding domain of repressor. Reconstruction experiments using leucine zippers from GCN4, Jun, Fos, and C/EBP showed that this assay distinguishes pairs that form heterodimers from those that do not. We found that the mutants have novel dimerization specificities determined by the positioning of buried asparagine residues at the a positions. The pattern of buried polar residues could also explain the dimerization specificities of some naturally occurring leucine zippers. The altered specificity mutants described here should be useful for the construction of artificial regulatory circuitry.

Interaction between proteins containing homeodomains associated to leucine zippers from sunflower

A strategy based on the use of PCR with one degenerate oligonucleotide deduced from conserved sequences and lambda gt10 primers was used to isolate homeobox containing sequences from sunflower stem and root cDNA libraries. Six different partial cDNAs coding for the first 48 amino acids of homeodomains and amino terminal sequences were analyzed and found to be members of the HD-Zip superfamily, which contain a homeobox linked to a leucine zipper coding region. A full-length cDNA clone, Hahb-10, was isolated and characterized. The leucine zipper portions of Hahb-10 and of the previously reported Hahb-1 have been utilized to construct fusions with the N-terminal domain of the lambda repressor. These fusions were tested for their ability to bind to lambda promoters in vivo. The expression of a protein containing an active dimerization domain, but not capable of DNA binding, exerts a dominant negative effect on the ability of repressor-zipper fusions to bind to its target DNA. From these experiments, it was concluded that Hahb-1 and -10, when co-expressed, form preferentially homodimers. Exchange of conserved threonines and leucines at positions a1 and d1 of both zippers reduces dimerization efficiency and allows the formation of heterodimers, suggesting that these residues are, among others, determinants of the specificity of interaction, most likely through changes in hydrophobic packing interactions at the dimer interface. The results imply that a great number of interacting molecular entities compose this protein superfamily which is presumably involved in regulating plant developmental responses.

Carbon source-dependent synthesis of SecB, a cytosolic chaperone involved in protein translocation across Escherichia coli membranes

SecB is a cytosolic chaperone involved in protein translocation across cytoplasmic membranes in Escherichia coli. It has been shown to be required for efficient translocation of a subset of precursor proteins but is not essential for cell viability. This study investigated whether synthesis of SecB is growth rate dependent. Interestingly, the total amount of SecB synthesized in the cells was relatively small. Moreover, the levels of SecB were found to be carbon source dependent since more SecB was produced in cells grown in glycerol media than in cells grown in glucose media, regardless of the growth rate. This is in contrast to the other Sec proteins, whose synthesis is growth rate dependent and not related to glucose as a carbon source. In addition, cyclic AMP (cAMP) partially relieves the lower levels of SecB observed in glucose medium, a compensatory effect that depends on the presence of both cya and crp gene products. Thus, the glucose-dependent synthesis of SecB may be related to the cAMP-cAMP receptor protein complex-mediated activation.