Conformational changes and inhibitor binding at the active site of elastase

Setting our bibliographic references free: towards open citation data

Purpose

– Citation data needs to be recognised as a part of the Commons – those works that are freely and legally available for sharing – and placed in an open repository. The paper aims to discuss this issue.

Design/methodology/approach

– The Open Citation Corpus is a new open repository of scholarly citation data, made available under a Creative Commons CC0 1.0 public domain dedication and encoded as Open Linked Data using the SPAR Ontologies.

Findings

– The Open Citation Corpus presently provides open access (OA) to reference lists from 204,637 articles from the OA Subset of PubMed Central, containing 6,325,178 individual references to 3,373,961 unique papers.

Originality/value

– Scholars, publishers and institutions may freely build upon, enhance and reuse the open citation data for any purpose, without restriction under copyright or database law.

Multiple solvent crystal structures: probing binding sites, plasticity and hydration

Multiple solvent crystal structures (MSCS) of porcine pancreatic elastase were used to map the binding surface the enzyme. Crystal structures of elastase in neat acetonitrile, 95% acetone, 55% dimethylformamide, 80% 5-hexene-1,2-diol, 80% isopropanol, 80% ethanol and 40% trifluoroethanol showed that the organic solvent molecules clustered in the active site, were found mostly unclustered in crystal contacts and in general did not bind elsewhere on the surface of elastase. Mixtures of 40% benzene or 40% cyclohexane in 50% isopropanol and 10% water showed no bound benzene or cyclohexane molecules, but did reveal bound isopropanol. The clusters of organic solvent probe molecules coincide with pockets occupied by known inhibitors. MSCS also reveal the areas of plasticity within the elastase binding site and allow for the visualization of a nearly complete first hydration shell. The pattern of organic solvent clusters determined by MSCS for elastase is consistent with patterns for hot spots in protein-ligand interactions determined from database analysis in general. The MSCS method allows probing of hot spots, plasticity and hydration simultaneously, providing a powerful complementary strategy to guide computational methods currently in development for binding site determination, ligand docking and design.

Analogous inhibitors of elastase do not always bind analogously

It has been assumed that the structure of a single inhibitor complex is sufficient to define the available subsites of an enzyme that has a unique binding site and a uniquely defined mode for ligand binding--the specificity for these subsites can thus be probed by kinetic experiments. Elastase is an enzyme for which these traditional assumptions, which underlie such structural and kinetic studies, do not hold. Three new crystal structures of elastase complexed to chemically similar inhibitors with similar binding affinities reveal a diversity of binding modes as well as two new subsites on elastase. The existence of multiple binding sites and different binding modes for such similar inhibitors indicates that researchers must proceed with caution when using kinetics to map out protein subsites.

Structure of human neutrophil elastase in complex with a peptide chloromethyl ketone inhibitor at 1.84-A resolution

Human neutrophil elastase (HNE) has been implicated as a major contributor to tissue destruction in various disease states, including emphysema. The structure of HNE, at neutral pH, in complex with methoxysuccinyl-Ala-Ala-Pro-Ala chloromethyl ketone (MSACK), has been solved and refined to an R factor of 16.4% at 1.84-A resolution. Results are consistent with the currently accepted mechanism of peptide chloromethyl ketone inhibition of serine proteases, in that MSACK cross-links the catalytic residues His-57 and Ser-195. The structure of the HNE-MSACK complex is compared with that of porcine pancreatic elastase in complex with L-647,957, a beta-lactam inhibitor of both elastases. The distribution of positively charged residues on HNE is highly asymmetric and may play a role in its specific association with the underlying negatively charged proteoglycan matrix of the neutrophil granules in which the enzyme is stored.

Primary structure of human neutrophil elastase

The complete amino acid sequence of human neutrophil elastase has been determined. The protein consists of 218 amino acid residues, contains two asparagine-linked carbohydrate side chains, and is joined together by four disulfide bonds. Comparison of the sequence to other serine proteinases indicates only moderate homology with porcine pancreatic elastase (43.0%) or neutrophil cathepsin G (37.2%). In particular, many of the residues suggested to play important roles in the mechanism by which the pancreatic elastase functions are significantly changed in the neutrophil enzyme, indicating alternative types of binding with the human proteinase.

Pig pancreatic anhydro-elastase. Role of the serine-195 hydroxy group in the binding of inhibitors and substrate

The binding constants of a number of ligands were measured for pancreatic elastase (PE) and anhydro-elastase (AE) in order to assess the contribution of Ser-195 to substrate and inhibitor binding by PE. AE was purified by affinity chromatography on a column containing immobilized turkey ovomucoid inhibitor. The AE had 0.1 +/- 0.1% of the activity of the native enzyme and contained 0.8 +/- 0.06 residue of dehydroalanine per molecule. A difference electron-density map, derived from an X-ray crystallographic analysis of AE, showed that the modified residue was Ser-195. The complexing of 3-carboxypropionyl-Ala-Ala-Ala-p-nitroanilide (SAN) to the active site of AE was also demonstrated by X-ray-diffraction analysis of an AE crystal soaked overnight with substrate. The nitroanilide moiety was not observed in the difference map. AE was shown to bind turkey ovomucoid inhibitor with a dissociation constant (Kd) of 0.3 +/- 0.06 microM compared with 0.10 microM for PE. The Kd of the AE-SAN complex (0.2 mM) was comparable with the Michaelis constant for SAN with PE (1.0 mM). A number of inhibitors, such as elastatinal, which forms a hemiketal adduct with PE, while others such as the beta-lactams, which function as acylators of the active-site serine residue, bound AE with a lower affinity than to PE. The binding of a peptidylchloromethane (acetyl-Ala-Ala-Pro-Ala-CH2Cl) to AE occurs without evidence for alkylation of histidine. The binding constants for benzoisothiazolinone and 3,4-dichloroisocoumarin to PE differed from their binding constants to AE by less than a factor of 4.0-fold. The contribution of the hydroxy group of Ser-195 to the binding of these inhibitors to PE in their non-covalent complexes is relatively small, even though they inactivate PE by an acylation mechanism. These results suggest that the hydroxy group on Ser-195 in PE is of secondary importance in the energetics of ligand binding, in contrast with its essential role in the catalytic properties of the enzyme.

Interaction of dansylated peptidyl chloromethanes with trypsin, chymotrypsin, elastase, and thrombin

A series of N alpha-1-(dimethylamino)-5-naphthalenesfulfonyl (dansyl) derivatives of peptidyl chloromethanes (chloromethyl ketones) were synthesized and employed to introduce the fluorescent dansyl moiety specifically into the active sites of proteinases via affinity labeling. Dansylalanyllysychloromethane (DALCM) was utilized to inactivate and fluorescently label trypsin and the trypsin-like enzyme thrombin. Dansylleucylphenylalanylchloromethane (DLPCM) was synthesized and selectively employed as an inhibitor of chymotrypsin. The di-, tri-, and tetrapeptides--dansylprolylalanylchloromethane (DPACM), dansylalanylprolylalanylchloromethane (DAPACM), and dansylprolylalanylprolylalanylchloromethane (DPAPACM)--were synthesizedand their interaction with elastase was evaluated. The compounds DALCM, DLPCM, and DAPACM all proved to be effective, fast-acting proteinase inhibitors. Studies of energy transfer in the enzyme-inhibitor conjugates led to results entirely consistent with the proposed conformational bomology of thrombin with the other serine proteinases studied. The fluorescent affinity labels are believed to posses enormous potential for the localization, isolation, and characterization of enzymes.

The indirect mechanism of action of the trifluoroacetyl peptides on elastase. Enzymatic and 19F NMR studies

Trifluoroacetyl (CF3CO) dipeptide anilides are potent reversible inhibitors of elastase. Their 19F NMR spectra in the presence of the enzyme correspond therefore to slow chemical exchange. Their characteristics are very similar to those previously reported for other CF3CO-peptides. This should correspond to a single binding mode, in which the CF3CO group lies in a specific site in close contact with protein protons. Elastase, irreversibly inhibited by alkylation of Ser-195 with phenylsulfonyl fluoride derivatives, binds the CF3CO-Ala-containing dipeptide anilides still more tightly than the native enzyme. It no longer binds the dipeptide anilides containing a bulky CF3CO-Lys group, suggesting a location of the CF3CO site near the S1 subsite. On the other hand, the chemical shift of the CF3CO 19F resonance in the complex is the only NMR property affected by the enzyme sulfonylation, the T1 and nuclear Overhauser effect values being unmodified as compared to those in the complexes with the native enzyme. The observation of the NMR characteristics of elastases inhibited by phenylsulfonyl groups substituted with fluorine shows that complexation with CF3CO-peptides induces a change of conformation of the catalytic site which should correspond to a displacement of His-57 toward the ortho position of the phenylsulfonyl ring. Such a transconformation is not observed with corresponding acetylated peptides. The phenylsulfonyl fluoride derivatives are still able to react with elastase in the presence of a large excess of CF3CO-peptides. In such conditions the rate of inactivation is much slower but still at least 5% of that measured in the absence of the reversible inhibitors. This residual activity is hardly compatible with the presence of two exclusive modes of interaction of the CF3CO-peptides with native elastase. On the contrary, these observations are better interpreted by a single and identical mode of binding of the peptide to the native and sulfonylated enzymes. According to this mode of binding, the reversible inhibition of elastase by CF3CO-peptides should correspond to an indirect mechanism by which a change of conformation at the active site results in a reduced catalytic activity.

The specificity of the S1 and S2 subsites of elastase

Esters of tetrapeptides of the general formula ethoxycarbonyl-prolyl-alanyl-X-Y where either X or Y was an alanine residue were synthesised and their cleavage by elastase studied. It was found that variation of the alcohol moiety between methyl, cyclohexyl and nitrophenyl residues had no effect on the catalytic rate constant for cleavage of ethoxycarbonyl-prolyl-dialanyl-alanine esters demonstrating that acylation is much faster than deacylation for this system and also that non-productive binding is not kinetically significant. The effect of changing the amino acid residue in position X was small compared with that of change in position Y. The presence of valine and serine residues in position Y produced the highest specificity constant but the highest catalytic rate constant was found for a leucine residue in this position. The results are discussed in terms of the binding of the substrate to the enzyme.

Secondary and conformational specificities of trypsin and chymotrypsin

Specific and non-specific trypsin substrates of known structure have been examined for common features. This analysis suggests that trypsin has a specificity for a particular conformation near the scissile bond which I denote as a conformational specificity. This conformation is a bent left-handed helix at the third and fourth (P3 and P4) amino acid positions toward the amino terminus from the scissile bond which I denote as a conformational specificity. This conformation is a bent left-handed show a high frequency of proline and glycine at these positions consistent with the left-handed helical conformation. This apparent secondary specificity for a particular substrate residue other than that at the primary position is not related to the nature of the residues at the third and fourth positions. Rather, these residues determine the bend of left-handed helix which has the effect of exposing main chain hydrogen-bonding groups of the substrate peptide chain to hydrogen-bonding groups on the enzyme. Thus, the secondary specificity of trypsin is not sequence-specific, but is for peptide main chain in the third and fourth positions and is determined by the tertiary structure of the substrate. This hypothesis for conformational and secondary specificity in trypsin can be extended to chymotrypsin. It also provides a means for the regulation of certain processes in vivo catalyzed by other proteases.

Formation of stable crystalline enzyme-substrate intermediates at sub-zero temperatures

Sub-zero temperatures can be used to trap intermediates in enzyme-catalysed reactions using suitable cryosolvents. The feasibility of obtaining such intermediates in the crystalline state for X-ray diffraction studies has been demonstrated with several proteases, using specific substrates and optimal pH.

Crystal structure of elastase-substrate complex at -- 55 degrees C

The structure of a specific acyl-enzyme intermediate in the elastase-catalysed hydrolysis of N-carbobenzoxy-L-alanyl-p-nitrophenol ester has been determined by X-ray diffraction at 3.5 A resolution. The acyl-enzyme was stabilised by cooling the crystal to --55 degrees C during substrate addition and data collection.

Tertiary structural differences between microbial serine proteases and pancreatic serine enzymes

Although primary structural homology between bacterial serine proteases and those from the mammalian pancreas is slight, two-thirds of the residues in the bacterial enzyme SGPB as seen at 2.8-A resolution, adopt a similar polypeptide chain conformation to that of the chymotrypsin family. The three major regions of difference show how this family of proteolytic enzymes has developed from the more primitive bacterial to the relatively sophisticated pancreatic enzymes.