Universal Non-Debye Scaling in the Density of States of Amorphous Solids

Jamming on convex deformable surfaces

Jamming is a fundamental transition that governs the behavior of particulate media, including sand, foams and dense suspensions. Upon compression, such media change from freely flowing to a disordered, marginally stable solid that exhibits non-Hookean elasticity. While the jamming process is well established for fixed geometries, the nature and dynamics of jamming for a diverse class of soft materials and deformable substrates, including emulsions and biological matter, remains unknown. Here we propose a new scenario, metric jamming, where rigidification occurs on a surface that has been deformed from its ground state. Unlike classical jamming processes that exhibit discrete mechanical transitions, surprisingly we find that metric jammed states possess mechanical properties continuously tunable between those of classically jammed and conventional elastic media. The compact and curved geometry significantly alters the vibrational spectra of the structures relative to jamming in flat Euclidean space, and metric jammed systems also possess new types of vibrational mode that couple particle and shape degrees of freedom. Our work provides a theoretical framework that unifies our understanding of solidification processes that take place on deformable media and lays the groundwork to exploit jamming for the control and stabilization of shape in self-assembly processes.

Local stability of spheres via the convex hull and the radical Voronoi diagram

Jamming is an emergent phenomenon wherein the local stability of individual particles percolates to form a globally rigid structure. However, the onset of rigidity does not imply that every particle becomes rigid, and indeed some remain locally unstable. These particles, if they become unmoored from their neighbors, are called rattlers, and their identification is critical to understanding the rigid backbone of a packing, as these particles cannot bear stress. The accurate identification of rattlers, however, can be a time-consuming process, and the currently accepted method lacks a simple geometric interpretation. In this manuscript, we propose two simpler classifications of rattlers in hard sphere systems based on the convex hull of contacting neighbors and the maximum inscribed sphere of the radical Voronoi cell, each of which provides geometric insight into the source of their instability. Furthermore, the convex hull formulation can be generalized to explore stability in hyperstatic soft sphere packings, spring networks, nonspherical packings, and mean-field non-central-force potentials.

Non-phononic density of states of two-dimensional glasses revealed by random pinning

The vibrational density of states of glasses is considerably different from that of crystals. In particular, there exist spatially localized vibrational modes in glasses. The density of states of these non-phononic modes has been observed to follow g(ω) ∝ ω4, where ω is the frequency. However, in two-dimensional systems, the abundance of phonons makes it difficult to accurately determine this non-phononic density of states because they are strongly coupled to non-phononic modes and yield strong system-size and preparation-protocol dependencies. In this article, we utilize the random pinning method to suppress phonons and disentangle their coupling with non-phononic modes and successfully calculate their density of states as g(ω) ∝ ω4. We also study their localization properties and confirm that low-frequency non-phononic modes in pinned systems are truly localized without far-field contributions. We finally discuss the excess density of states over the Debye value that results from the hybridization of phonons and non-phononic modes.

Low-frequency vibrational states in ideal glasses with random pinning

Glasses exhibit spatially localized vibrations in the low-frequency regime. These localized modes emerge below the boson peak frequency ω_{BP}, and their vibrational densities of state follow g(ω)∝ω^{4} (ω is frequency). Here, we attempt to address how the localized vibrations behave through the ideal glass transition. To do this, we employ a random pinning method, which enables us to study the thermodynamic glass transition. We find that the localized vibrations survive even in equilibrium glass states. Remarkably, the localized vibrations still maintain the properties of appearance below ω_{BP} and g(ω)∝ω^{4}. Our results provide important insight into the material properties of ideal glasses.

Hard-sphere jamming through the lens of linear optimization

The jamming transition is ubiquitous. It is present in granular matter, foams, colloids, structural glasses, and many other systems. Yet, it defines a critical point whose properties still need to be fully understood. Recently, a major breakthrough came about when the replica formalism was extended to build a mean-field theory that provides an exact description of the jamming transition of spherical particles in the infinite-dimensional limit. While such theory explains the jamming critical behavior of both soft and hard spheres, investigating the transition in finite-dimensional systems poses very difficult and different problems, in particular from the numerical point of view. Soft particles are modeled by continuous potentials; thus, their jamming point can be reached through efficient energy minimization algorithms. In contrast, the latter methods are inapplicable to hard-sphere (HS) systems since the interaction energy among the particles is always zero by construction. To overcome these difficulties, here we recast the jamming of hard spheres as a constrained optimization problem and introduce the CALiPPSO algorithm, capable of readily producing jammed HS packings without including any effective potential. This algorithm brings a HS configuration of arbitrary dimensions to its jamming point by solving a chain of linear optimization problems. We show that there is a strict correspondence between the force balance conditions of jammed packings and the properties of the optimal solutions of CALiPPSO, whence we prove analytically that our packings are always isostatic and in mechanical equilibrium. Furthermore, using extensive numerical simulations, we show that our algorithm is able to probe the complex structure of the free-energy landscape, finding qualitative agreement with mean-field predictions. We also characterize the algorithmic complexity of CALiPPSO and provide an open-source implementation of it.

Density of states below the first sound mode in 3D glasses

Glasses feature universally low-frequency excess vibrational modes beyond Debye prediction, which could help rationalize, e.g., the glasses’ unusual temperature dependence of thermal properties compared to crystalline solids. The way the density of states of these low-frequency excess modes D( ω) depends on the frequency ω has been debated for decades. Recent simulation studies of 3D glasses suggest that D( ω) scales universally with ω4 in a low-frequency regime below the first sound mode. However, no simulation study has ever probed as low frequencies as possible to test directly whether this quartic law could work all the way to extremely low frequencies. Here, we calculated D( ω) below the first sound mode in 3D glasses over a wide range of frequencies. We find D( ω) scales with ω β with β < 4 at very low frequencies examined, while the ω4 law works only in a limited intermediate-frequency regime in some glasses. Moreover, our further analysis suggests our observation does not depend on glass models or glass stabilities examined. The ω4 law of D( ω) below the first sound mode is dominant in current simulation studies of 3D glasses, and our direct observation of the breakdown of the quartic law at very low frequencies thus leaves an open but important question that may attract more future numerical and theoretical studies.

Hyperuniform jammed sphere packings have anomalous material properties

A spatial distribution is hyperuniform if it has local density fluctuations that vanish in the limit of long length scales. Hyperuniformity is a well known property of both crystals and quasicrystals. Of recent interest, however, is disordered hyperuniformity: the presence of hyperuniform scaling without long-range configurational order. Jammed granular packings have been proposed as an example of disordered hyperuniformity, but recent numerical investigation has revealed that many jammed systems instead exhibit a complex set of distinct behaviors at long, emergent length scales. We use the Voronoi tessellation as a tool to define a set of rescaling transformations that can impose hyperuniformity on an arbitrary weighted point process, and show that these transformations can be used in simulations to iteratively generate hyperuniform, mechanically stable packings of athermal soft spheres. These hyperuniform jammed packings display atypical mechanical properties, particularly in the low-frequency phononic excitations, which exhibit an isolated band of highly collective modes and a band gap around zero frequency.

Vibrational density of states of jammed packing at high dimensions: Mean-field theory

Several mean-field theories predict that the Hessian matrix of amorphous solids converges the Wishart matrix in the limit of the large spatial dimensions d→∞. Motivated by these results, we calculate here the density of states of random packing of harmonic spheres by mapping the Hessian of the original system to the Wishart matrix. We compare our result with that of previous numerical simulations of harmonic spheres in several spatial dimensions d=3, 5, and 9. For small pressure p≪1 (near jamming), we find a good agreement even in d=3, and obtain better agreements in larger d, suggesting that the approximation becomes exact in the limit d→∞.

Correlation of plastic events with local structure in jammed packings across spatial dimensions

In frictionless jammed packings, existing evidence suggests a picture in which localized physics dominates in low spatial dimensions, d = 2, 3, but quickly loses relevance as d rises, replaced by spatially extended mean-field behavior. For example, quasilocalized low-energy vibrational modes and low-coordination particles associated with deviation from mean-field behavior (rattlers and bucklers) all vanish rapidly with increasing d. These results suggest that localized rearrangements, which are associated with low-energy vibrational modes, correlated with local structure, and dominant in low dimensions, should give way in higher d to extended rearrangements uncorrelated with local structure. Here, we use machine learning to analyze simulations of jammed packings under athermal, quasistatic shear, identifying a local structural variable, softness, that correlates with rearrangements in dimensions d = 2 to d = 5. We find that softness—and even just the local coordination number Z—is essentially equally predictive of rearrangements in all d studied. This result provides direct evidence that local structure plays an important role in higher d, suggesting a modified picture for the dimensional cross-over to mean-field theory.

Dionysian Hard Sphere Packings Are Mechanically Stable at Vanishingly Low Densities

High strength-to-weight ratio materials can be constructed by either maximizing strength or minimizing weight. Tensegrity structures and aerogels take very different paths to achieving high strength-to-weight ratios but both rely on internal tensile forces. In the absence of tensile forces, removing material eventually destabilizes a structure. Attempts to maximize the strength-to-weight ratio with purely repulsive spheres have proceeded by removing spheres from already stable crystalline structures. This results in a modestly low density and a strength-to-weight ratio much worse than can be achieved with tensile materials. Here, we demonstrate the existence of a packing of hard spheres that has asymptotically zero density and yet maintains finite strength, thus achieving an unbounded strength-to-weight ratio. This construction, which we term Dionysian, is the diametric opposite to the Apollonian sphere packing which completely and stably fills space. We create tools to evaluate the stability and strength of compressive sphere packings. Using these we find that our structures have asymptotically finite bulk and shear moduli and are linearly resistant to every applied deformation, both internal and external. By demonstrating that there is no lower bound on the density of stable structures, this work allows for the construction of arbitrarily lightweight high-strength materials.

Low-energy quasilocalized excitations in structural glasses

Glassy solids exhibit a wide variety of generic thermomechanical properties, ranging from universal anomalous specific heat at cryogenic temperatures to nonlinear plastic yielding and failure under external driving forces, which qualitatively differ from their crystalline counterparts. For a long time, it has been believed that many of these properties are intimately related to nonphononic, low-energy quasilocalized excitations (QLEs) in glasses. Indeed, recent computer simulations have conclusively revealed that the self-organization of glasses during vitrification upon cooling from a melt leads to the emergence of such QLEs. In this Perspective, we review developments over the past three decades toward understanding the emergence of QLEs in structural glasses and the degree of universality in their statistical and structural properties. We discuss the challenges and difficulties that hindered progress in achieving these goals and review the frameworks put forward to overcome them. We conclude with an outlook on future research directions and open questions.

Non-hyperuniform metastable states around a disordered hyperuniform state of densely packed spheres: stochastic density functional theory at strong coupling

The disordered and hyperuniform structures of densely packed spheres near and at jamming are characterized by vanishing of long-wavelength density fluctuations, or equivalently by long-range power-law decay of the direct correlation function (DCF). We focus on previous simulation results that exhibit the degradation of hyperuniformity in jammed structures while maintaining the long-range nature of the DCF to a certain length scale. Here we demonstrate that the field-theoretic formulation of stochastic density functional theory is relevant to explore the degradation mechanism. The strong-coupling expansion method of stochastic density functional theory is developed to obtain the metastable chemical potential considering the intermittent fluctuations in dense packings. The metastable chemical potential yields the analytical form of the metastable DCF that has a short-range cutoff inside the sphere while retaining the long-range power-law behavior. It is confirmed that the metastable DCF provides the zero-wavevector limit of the structure factor in quantitative agreement with the previous simulation results of degraded hyperuniformity. We can also predict the emergence of soft modes localized at the particle scale by plugging this metastable DCF into the linearized Dean-Kawasaki equation, a stochastic density functional equation.

Finite-size effects in the microscopic critical properties of jammed configurations: A comprehensive study of the effects of different types of disorder

Jamming criticality defines a universality class that includes systems as diverse as glasses, colloids, foams, amorphous solids, constraint satisfaction problems, neural networks, etc. A particularly interesting feature of this class is that small interparticle forces (f) and gaps (h) are distributed according to nontrivial power laws. A recently developed mean-field (MF) theory predicts the characteristic exponents of these distributions in the limit of very high spatial dimension, d→∞ and, remarkably, their values seemingly agree with numerical estimates in physically relevant dimensions, d=2 and 3. These exponents are further connected through a pair of inequalities derived from stability conditions, and both theoretical predictions and previous numerical investigations suggest that these inequalities are saturated. Systems at the jamming point are thus only marginally stable. Despite the key physical role played by these exponents, their systematic evaluation has yet to be attempted. Here, we carefully test their value by analyzing the finite-size scaling of the distributions of f and h for various particle-based models for jamming. Both dimension and the direction of approach to the jamming point are also considered. We show that, in all models, finite-size effects are much more pronounced in the distribution of h than in that of f. We thus conclude that gaps are correlated over considerably longer scales than forces. Additionally, remarkable agreement with MF predictions is obtained in all but one model, namely near-crystalline packings. Our results thus help to better delineate the domain of the jamming universality class. We furthermore uncover a secondary linear regime in the distribution tails of both f and h. This surprisingly robust feature is understood to follow from the (near) isostaticity of our configurations.

Mean-Field Predictions of Scaling Prefactors Match Low-Dimensional Jammed Packings

No known analytic framework precisely explains all the phenomena observed in jamming. The replica theory for glasses and jamming is a mean-field theory which attempts to do so by working in the limit of infinite dimensions, such that correlations between neighbors are negligible. As such, results from this mean-field theory are not guaranteed to be observed in finite dimensions. However, many results in mean field for jamming have been shown to be exact or nearly exact in low dimensions. This suggests that the infinite dimensional limit is not necessary to obtain these results. In this Letter, we perform precision measurements of jamming scaling relationships between pressure, excess packing fraction, and number of excess contacts from dimensions 2-10 in order to extract the prefactors to these scalings. While these prefactors should be highly sensitive to finite dimensional corrections, we find the mean-field predictions for these prefactors to be exact in low dimensions. Thus the mean-field approximation is not necessary for deriving these prefactors. We present an exact, first-principles derivation for one, leaving the other as an open question. Our results suggest that mean-field theories of critical phenomena may compute more for d≥d_{u} than has been previously appreciated.

Inferring the particle-wise dynamics of amorphous solids from the local structure at the jamming point

Jamming is a phenomenon shared by a wide variety of systems, such as granular materials, foams, and glasses in their high density regime. This has motivated the development of a theoretical framework capable of explaining many of their static critical properties with a unified approach. However, the dynamics occurring in the vicinity of the jamming point has received little attention and the problem of finding a connection with the local structure of the configuration remains unexplored. Here we address this issue by constructing physically well defined structural variables using the information contained in the network of contacts of jammed configurations, and then showing that such variables yield a resilient statistical description of the particle-wise dynamics near this critical point. Our results are based on extensive numerical simulations of systems of spherical particles that allow us to statistically characterize the trajectories of individual particles in terms of their first two moments. We first demonstrate that, besides displaying a broad distribution of mobilities, particles may also have preferential directions of motion. Next, we associate each of these features with a structural variable computed uniquely in terms of the contact vectors at jamming, obtaining considerably high statistical correlations. The robustness of our approach is confirmed by testing two types of dynamical protocols, namely molecular dynamics and Monte Carlo, with different types of interaction. We also provide evidence that the dynamical regime we study here is dominated by anharmonic effects and therefore it cannot be described properly in terms of vibrational modes. Finally, we show that correlations decay slowly and in an interaction-independent fashion, suggesting a universal rate of information loss.

Novel elastic instability of amorphous solids in finite spatial dimensions

Recently, progress has been made in the understanding of anomalous vibrational excitations in amorphous solids. In the lowest-frequency region, the vibrational spectrum follows a non-Debye quartic law, which persists up to zero frequency without any frequency gap. This gapless vibrational density of states (vDOS) suggests that glasses are on the verge of instability. This feature of marginal stability is now highlighted as a key concept in the theories of glasses. In particular, the elasticity theory based on marginal stability predicts the gapless vDOS. However, this theory yields a quadratic law and not the quartic law. To address this inconsistency, we presented a new type of instability, which is different from the conventional one, and proposed that amorphous solids are marginally stable considering the new instability in the preceding study [M. Shimada, H. Mizuno and A. Ikeda, Soft Matter, 2020, 16, 7279]. In this study, we further extend and detail the results for these instabilities. By analyzing various examples of disorder, we demonstrate that real glasses in finite spatial dimensions can be marginally stable by the proposed novel instability.

Critical point of jamming transition in two-dimensional monodisperse systems

The existence of amorphous packings in two-dimensional monodisperse system is a classical unsolved problem. We get the energy minimum state by the energy minimization method of enthalpy under constant pressure conditions. Firstly, we find that there are two peaks in the experiment, which demonstrate the interesting features of the coexistence of crystals and amorphous crystals. And then, we confirm the critical point of jamming transition of the two-dimensional monodisperse is [Formula: see text]. Finally, we prove that the jamming scaling is still satisfied in two-dimensional monodispersed system: [Formula: see text] and vanishes as [Formula: see text], and the boson peak shifts to lower frequencies for less compressed systems.

Vibrational density of states of amorphous solids with long-ranged power-law-correlated disorder in elasticity

A theory of vibrational excitations based on power-law spatial correlations in the elastic constants (or equivalently in the internal stress) is derived, in order to determine the vibrational density of states D([Formula: see text]) of disordered solids. The results provide the first prediction of a boson peak in amorphous materials where spatial correlations in the internal stresses (or elastic constants) are of power-law form, as is often the case in experimental systems, leading to a logarithmic enhancement of (Rayleigh) phonon attenuation. A logarithmic correction of the form [Formula: see text] is predicted to occur in the plot of the reduced excess DOS for frequencies around the boson peak in 3D. Moreover, the theory provides scaling laws of the density of states in the low-frequency region, including a [Formula: see text] regime in 3D, and provides information about how the boson peak intensity depends on the strength of power-law decay of fluctuations in elastic constants or internal stress. Analytical expressions are also derived for the dynamic structure factor for longitudinal excitations, which include a logarithmic correction factor, and numerical calculations are presented supporting the assumptions used in the theory.

Vibrational spectrum derived from local mechanical response in disordered solids

The low-frequency vibrations of glasses are markedly different from those of crystals. These vibrations have recently been categorized into two types: spatially extended vibrations, whose vibrational density of states (vDOS) follows a non-Debye quadratic law, and quasilocalized vibrations (QLVs), whose vDOS follows a quartic law. The former are explained by elasticity theory with quenched disorder and microscopic replica theory as being a consequence of elastic instability, but the origin of the latter is still debated. Here, we show that the latter can also be directly derived from elasticity theory with quenched disorder. We find another elastic instability that the theory encompasses but that has been overlooked so far, namely, the instability of the system against a local dipolar force. This instability gives rise to an additional contribution to the vDOS, and the spatial structure and energetics of the mode originating from this instability are consistent with those of the QLVs. Finally, we construct a model in which the additional contribution to the vDOS follows a quartic law.

Vibrational Properties of Hard and Soft Spheres Are Unified at Jamming

The unconventional thermal properties of jammed amorphous solids are directly related to their density of vibrational states. While the vibrational spectrum of jammed soft sphere solids has been fully described, the vibrational spectrum of hard spheres, a model glass former often related to physical colloidal glasses, is still unknown due to the difficulty of treating the nonanalytic interaction potential. We bypass this difficulty using the recently described effective interaction potential for the free energy of thermal hard spheres. By minimizing this effective free energy, we mimic the rapid compression of hard spheres and produce typical configurations of the thermal system. We measure the resulting vibrational spectrum and characterize its evolution toward the jamming point where configurations of hard and soft spheres are trivially unified. For densities approaching jamming from below, we observe low-frequency modes which agree with those found in numerical simulations of jammed soft spheres. Our measurements of the vibrational structure demonstrate that the jamming universality extends away from jamming: hard sphere thermal systems below jamming exhibit the same vibrational spectra as thermal and athermal soft sphere systems above the transition.

Low-frequency vibrations of jammed packings in large spatial dimensions

Amorphous packings prepared in the vicinity of the jamming transition play a central role in theoretical studies of the vibrational spectrum of glasses. Two mean-field theories predict that the vibrational density of states g(ω) obeys a characteristic power law, g(ω)∼ω^{2}, called the non-Debye scaling in the low-frequency region. Numerical studies have, however, reported that this scaling breaks down at low frequencies, due to finite-dimensional effects. In this study, we prepare amorphous packings of up to 128000 particles in spatial dimensions from d=3 to d=9 to characterize the range of validity of the non-Debye scaling. Our numerical results suggest that the non-Debye scaling is obeyed down to a frequency that gradually decreases as d increases, and possibly vanishes for large d, in agreement with mean-field predictions. We also show that the prestress is an efficient control parameter to quantitatively compare packings across different spatial dimensions.

Jamming Energy Landscape is Hierarchical and Ultrametric

The free energy landscape of mean-field marginal glasses is ultrametric. We demonstrate that this feature persists in finite three-dimensional systems that are out of equilibrium by finding sets of minima, which are nearby in configuration space. By calculating the distance between these nearby minima, we produce a small region of the distance metric. This metric exhibits a clear hierarchical structure and shows the signature of an ultrametric space. That such a hierarchy exists for the jamming energy landscape provides direct evidence for the existence of a marginal phase along the zero temperature jamming line.

Universal Relaxation Dynamics of Sphere Packings below Jamming

We show that non-Brownian suspensions of repulsive spheres below jamming display a slow relaxational dynamics with a characteristic timescale that diverges at jamming. This slow timescale is fully encoded in the structure of the unjammed packing and can be readily measured via the vibrational density of states. We show that the corresponding dynamic critical exponent is the same for randomly generated and sheared packings. Our results show that a wide variety of physical situations, from suspension rheology to algorithmic studies of the jamming transition are controlled by a unique diverging timescale, with a universal critical exponent.

Gardner physics in amorphous solids and beyond

One of the most remarkable predictions to emerge out of the exact infinite-dimensional solution of the glass problem is the Gardner transition. Although this transition was first theoretically proposed a generation ago for certain mean-field spin glass models, its materials relevance was only realized when a systematic effort to relate glass formation and jamming was undertaken. A number of nontrivial physical signatures associated with the Gardner transition have since been considered in various areas, from models of structural glasses to constraint satisfaction problems. This perspective surveys these recent advances and discusses the novel research opportunities that arise from them.

Universal non-mean-field scaling in the density of states of amorphous solids

Amorphous solids have excess soft modes in addition to the phonon modes described by the Debye theory. Recent numerical results show that if the phonon modes are carefully removed, the density of state of the excess soft modes exhibit universal quartic scaling, independent of the interaction potential, preparation protocol, and spatial dimensions. We hereby provide a theoretical framework to describe this universal scaling behavior. For this purpose, we extend the mean-field theory to include the effects of finite-dimensional fluctuation. Based on a semiphenomenological argument, we show that mean-field quadratic scaling is replaced by the quartic scaling in finite dimensions. Furthermore, we apply our formalism to explain the pressure and protocol dependence of the excess soft modes.

A broader view on jamming: from spring networks to circle packings

Jamming occurs when objects like grains are packed tightly together (e.g. grain silos). It is highly cooperative and can lead to phenomena like earthquakes, traffic jams, etc. In this paper we point out the paramount importance of the underlying contact network for jammed systems; the network must have one contact in excess of isostaticity and a finite bulk modulus. Isostatic means that the number of degrees of freedom is exactly balanced by the number of constraints. This defines a large class of networks that can be constructed without the necessity of packing particles together compressively (either in the lab or computationally). One such construction, which we explore here, involves setting up the Delaunay triangulation of a Poisson disk sampling and then removing edges to maximize the bulk modulus until the isostatic plus one edge is reached. This construction works in any dimensions and here we give results in 2D where we also show how such networks can be transformed into disk packs.

Marginally stable phases in mean-field structural glasses

A novel form of amorphous matter characterized by marginal stability was recently discovered in the mean-field theory of structural glasses. Using this approach, we provide complete phase diagrams delimiting the location of the marginally stable glass phase for a large variety of pair interactions and physical conditions, extensively exploring physical regimes relevant to granular matter, foams, emulsions, hard and soft colloids, and molecular glasses. We find that all types of glasses may become marginally stable, but the extent of the marginally stable phase highly depends on the preparation protocol. Our results suggest that marginal phases should be observable for colloidal and non-Brownian particles near jamming and for poorly annealed glasses. For well-annealed glasses, two distinct marginal phases are predicted. Our study unifies previous results on marginal stability in mean-field models and will be useful to guide numerical simulations and experiments aimed at detecting marginal stability in finite-dimensional amorphous materials.

Glassy, Gardner-like phenomenology in minimally polydisperse crystalline systems

We report on a nonequilibrium phase of matter, the minimally disordered crystal phase, which we find exists between the maximally amorphous glasses and the ideal crystal. Even though these near crystals appear highly ordered, they display glassy and jamming features akin to those observed in amorphous solids. Structurally, they exhibit a power-law scaling in their probability distribution of weak forces and small interparticle gaps as well as a flat density of vibrational states. Dynamically, they display anomalous aging above a characteristic pressure. Quantitatively, this disordered crystal phase has much in common with the Gardner-like phase seen in maximally disordered solids. Near crystals should be amenable to experimental realizations in commercially available particulate systems and are to be indispensable in verifying the theory of amorphous materials.

Low-frequency vibrational modes of stable glasses

Unusual features of the vibrational density of states D(ω) of glasses allow one to rationalize their peculiar low-temperature properties. Simulational studies of D(ω) have been restricted to studying poorly annealed glasses that may not be relevant to experiments. Here we report on D(ω) of zero-temperature glasses with kinetic stabilities ranging from poorly annealed to ultrastable glasses. For all preparations, the low-frequency part of D(ω) splits between extended and quasi-localized modes. Extended modes exhibit a boson peak crossing over to Debye behavior (Dex(ω) ~ ω2) at low-frequency, with a strong correlation between the two regimes. Quasi-localized modes obey Dloc(ω) ~ ω4, irrespective of the stability. The prefactor of this quartic law decreases with increasing stability, and the corresponding modes become more localized and sparser. Our work is the first numerical observation of quasi-localized modes in a regime relevant to experiments, and it establishes a direct connection between glasses' stability and their soft vibrational modes.

Universal Nonphononic Density of States in 2D, 3D, and 4D Glasses

It is now well established that structural glasses possess disorder- and frustration-induced soft quasilocalized excitations, which play key roles in various glassy phenomena. Recent work has established that in model glass formers in three dimensions, these nonphononic soft excitations may assume the form of quasilocalized, harmonic vibrational modes whose frequency follows a universal density of states D(ω)∼ω^{4}, independently of microscopic details, and for a broad range of glass preparation protocols. Here, we further establish the universality of the nonphononic density of vibrational modes by direct measurements in model structural glasses in two dimensions and four dimensions. We also investigate their degree of localization, which is generally weaker in lower spatial dimensions, giving rise to a pronounced system-size dependence of the nonphononic density of states in two dimensions, but not in higher dimensions. Finally, we identify a fundamental glassy frequency scale ω_{c} above which the universal ω^{4} law breaks down.

Mean-field model for the density of states of jammed soft spheres

We propose a class of mean-field models for the isostatic transition of systems of soft spheres, in which the contact network is modeled as a random graph and each contact is associated to d degrees of freedom. We study such models in the hypostatic, isostatic, and hyperstatic regimes. The density of states is evaluated by both the cavity method and exact diagonalization of the dynamical matrix. We show that the model correctly reproduces the main features of the density of states of real packings and, moreover, it predicts the presence of localized modes near the lower band edge. Finally, the behavior of the density of states D(ω)∼ω^{α} for ω→0 in the hyperstatic regime is studied. We find that the model predicts a nontrivial dependence of α on the details of the coordination distribution.

Soft modes and strain redistribution in continuous models of amorphous plasticity: the Eshelby paradigm, and beyond?

The deformation of disordered solids relies on swift and localised rearrangements of particles. The inspection of soft vibrational modes can help predict the locations of these rearrangements, while the strain that they actually redistribute mediates collective effects. Here, we study soft modes and strain redistribution in a two-dimensional continuous mesoscopic model based on a Ginzburg-Landau free energy for perfect solids, supplemented with a plastic disorder potential that accounts for shear softening and rearrangements. Regardless of the disorder strength, our numerical simulations show soft modes that are always sharply peaked at the softest point of the material (unlike what happens for the depinning of an elastic interface). Contrary to widespread views, the deformation halo around this peak does not always have a quadrupolar (Eshelby-like) shape. Instead, for finite and narrowly-distributed disorder, it looks like a fracture, with a strain field that concentrates along some easy directions. These findings are rationalised with analytical calculations in the case where the plastic disorder is confined to a point-like 'impurity'. In this case, we unveil a continuous family of elastic propagators, which are identical for the soft modes and for the equilibrium configurations. This family interpolates between the standard quadrupolar propagator and the fracture-like one as the anisotropy of the elastic medium is increased. Therefore, we expect to see a fracture-like propagator when extended regions on the brink of failure have already softened along the shear direction and thus rendered the material anisotropic, but not failed yet. We speculate that this might be the case in carefully aged glasses just before macroscopic failure.

Localization of soft modes at the depinning transition

We characterize the soft modes of the dynamical matrix at the depinning transition, and compare the matrix with the properties of the Anderson model (and long-range generalizations). The density of states at the edge of the spectrum displays a universal linear tail, different from the Lifshitz tails. The eigenvectors are instead very similar in the two matrix ensembles. We focus on the ground state (soft mode), which represents the epicenter of avalanche instabilities. We expect it to be localized in all finite dimensions, and make a clear connection between its localization length and the Larkin length of the depinning model. In the fully connected model, we show that the weak-strong pinning transition coincides with a peculiar localization transition of the ground state.

Anomalous vibrational properties in the continuum limit of glasses

The low-temperature thermal properties of glasses are anomalous with respect to those of crystals. These thermal anomalies indicate that the low-frequency vibrational properties of glasses differ from those of crystals. Recent studies revealed that, in the simplest model of glasses, i.e., the harmonic potential system, phonon modes coexist with soft localized modes in the low-frequency (continuum) limit. However, the nature of low-frequency vibrational modes of more realistic models is still controversial. In the present work, we study the Lennard-Jones (LJ) system using large-scale molecular-dynamics (MD) simulation and establish that the vibrational property of the LJ glass converges to coexistence of the phonon modes and the soft localized modes in the continuum limit as in the case of the harmonic potential system. Importantly, we find that the low-frequency vibrations are rather sensitive to the numerical scheme of potential truncation, which is usually implemented in the MD simulation, and this is the reason why contradictory arguments have been reported by previous works. We also discuss the physical origin of this sensitiveness by means of a linear stability analysis.

Instabilities of Jammed Packings of Frictionless Spheres Under Load

We consider the contribution to the density of vibrational states and the distribution of energy barrier heights of incipient instabilities in a glass modeled by a jammed packing of spheres. On approaching an instability, the frequency of a normal mode and the height of the energy barrier to cross into a new ground state both vanish. These instabilities produce a contribution to the density of vibrational states that scales as ω^{3} at low frequencies ω, and a contribution to the distribution of energy barriers ΔH that scales as ΔH^{-1/3} at low barrier heights.

Continuum limit of the vibrational properties of amorphous solids

The low-frequency vibrational and low-temperature thermal properties of amorphous solids are markedly different from those of crystalline solids. This situation is counterintuitive because all solid materials are expected to behave as a homogeneous elastic body in the continuum limit, in which vibrational modes are phonons that follow the Debye law. A number of phenomenological explanations for this situation have been proposed, which assume elastic heterogeneities, soft localized vibrations, and so on. Microscopic mean-field theories have recently been developed to predict the universal non-Debye scaling law. Considering these theoretical arguments, it is absolutely necessary to directly observe the nature of the low-frequency vibrations of amorphous solids and determine the laws that such vibrations obey. Herein, we perform an extremely large-scale vibrational mode analysis of a model amorphous solid. We find that the scaling law predicted by the mean-field theory is violated at low frequency, and in the continuum limit, the vibrational modes converge to a mixture of phonon modes that follow the Debye law and soft localized modes that follow another universal non-Debye scaling law.

Echoes of the Glass Transition in Athermal Soft Spheres

Recent theoretical advances have led to the creation of a unified phase diagram for the thermal glass and athermal jamming transitions. This diagram makes clear that, while related, the mode-coupling-or dynamic-glass transition is distinct from the jamming transition, occurring at a finite temperature and significantly lower density than the jamming transition. Nonetheless, we demonstrate a prejamming transition in athermal frictionless spheres which occurs at the same density as the mode-coupling transition and is marked by percolating clusters of locally rigid particles. At this density in both the thermal and athermal systems, individual motions of an extensive number of particles become constrained, such that only collective motion is possible. This transition, which is well below jamming, exactly matches the definition of collective behavior at the dynamical transition of glasses. Thus, we reveal that the genesis of rigidity in both thermal and athermal systems is governed by the same underlying topological transition in their shared configuration space.

Unjamming in models with analytic pairwise potentials

Canonical models for studying the unjamming scenario in systems of soft repulsive particles assume pairwise potentials with a sharp cutoff in the interaction range. The sharp cutoff renders the potential nonanalytic but makes it possible to describe many properties of the solid in terms of the coordination number z, which has an unambiguous definition in these cases. Pairwise potentials without a sharp cutoff in the interaction range have not been studied in this context, but should in fact be considered to understand the relevance of the unjamming phenomenology in systems where such a cutoff is not present. In this work we explore two systems with such interactions: an inverse power law and an exponentially decaying pairwise potential, with the control parameters being the exponent (of the inverse power law) for the former and the number density for the latter. Both systems are shown to exhibit the characteristic features of the unjamming transition, among which are the vanishing of the shear-to-bulk modulus ratio and the emergence of an excess of low-frequency vibrational modes. We establish a relation between the pressure-to-bulk modulus ratio and the distance to unjamming in each of our model systems. This allows us to predict the dependence of other key observables on the distance to unjamming. Our results provide the means for a quantitative estimation of the proximity of generic glass-forming models to the unjamming transition in the absence of a clear-cut definition of the coordination number and highlight the general irrelevance of nonaffine contributions to the bulk modulus.

Nontrivial Critical Fixed Point for Replica-Symmetry-Breaking Transitions

The transformation of the free-energy landscape from smooth to hierarchical is one of the richest features of mean-field disordered systems. A well-studied example is the de Almeida-Thouless transition for spin glasses in a magnetic field, and a similar phenomenon-the Gardner transition-has recently been predicted for structural glasses. The existence of these replica-symmetry-breaking phase transitions has, however, long been questioned below their upper critical dimension, d_{u}=6. Here, we obtain evidence for the existence of these transitions in d<d_{u} using a two-loop calculation. Because the critical fixed point is found in the strong-coupling regime, we corroborate the result by resumming the perturbative series with inputs from a three-loop calculation and an analysis of its large-order behavior. Our study offers a resolution of the long-lasting controversy surrounding phase transitions in finite-dimensional disordered systems.

Far infrared spectroscopy of hydrogen bonding collective motions in complex molecular systems

Far infrared spectroscopy as a tool for the study of inter and intramolecular interactions in complex molecular structures.

Metastable minima of the Heisenberg spin glass in a random magnetic field

We have studied zero-temperature metastable minima in classical m-vector component spin glasses in the presence of m-component random fields for two models, the Sherrington-Kirkpatrick (SK) model and the Viana-Bray (VB) model. For the SK model we have calculated analytically its complexity (the log of the number of minima) for both the annealed case where one averages the number of minima before taking the log and the quenched case where one averages the complexity itself, both for fields above and below the de Almeida-Thouless (AT) field, which is finite for m>2. We have done numerical quenches starting from a random initial state (infinite temperature state) by putting spins parallel to their local fields until there is no further decrease of the energy and found that in zero field it always produces minima that have zero overlap with each other. For the m=2 and m=3 cases in the SK model the final energy reached in the quench is very close to the energy E_{c} at which the overlap of the states would acquire replica symmetry-breaking features. These minima have marginal stability and will have long-range correlations between them. In the SK limit we have analytically studied the density of states ρ(λ) of the Hessian matrix in the annealed approximation. Despite the fact that in the presence of a random field there are no continuous symmetries, the spectrum extends down to zero with the usual sqrt[λ] form for the density of states for fields below the AT field. However, when the random field is larger than the AT field, there is a gap in the spectrum, which closes up as the AT field is approached. The VB model behaves differently and seems rather similar to studies of the three-dimensional Heisenberg spin glass in a random vector field.

Evidence for Marginal Stability in Emulsions

We report the first measurements of the effect of pressure on vibrational modes in emulsions, which serve as a model for soft frictionless spheres at zero temperature. As a function of the applied pressure, we find that the density of states D(ω) exhibits a low-frequency cutoff ω^{*}, which scales linearly with the number of extra contacts per particle δz. Moreover, for ω<ω^{*}, our results are consistent with D(ω)∼ω^{2}/ω^{*2}, a quadratic behavior whose prefactor is larger than what is expected from Debye theory. This surprising result agrees with recent theoretical findings [E. DeGiuli, A. Laversanne-Finot, G. A. Düring, E. Lerner, and M. Wyart, Soft Matter 10, 5628 (2014); S. Franz, G. Parisi, P. Urbani, and F. Zamponi, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 112, 14539 (2015)]. Finally, the degree of localization of the softest low frequency modes increases with compression, as shown by the participation ratio as well as their spatial configurations. Overall, our observations show that emulsions are marginally stable and display non-plane-wave modes up to vanishing frequencies.