Estimating Mesophyll Conductance from Measurements of C18OO Photosynthetic Discrimination and Carbonic Anhydrase Activity

The interplay of short-term mesophyll and stomatal conductance responses under variable environmental conditions

Understanding the short-term responses of mesophyll conductance (gm) and stomatal conductance (gsc) to environmental changes remains a challenging yet central aspect of plant physiology. This review synthesises our current knowledge of these short-term responses, which underpin CO2 diffusion within leaves. Recent methodological advances in measuring gm using online isotopic discrimination and chlorophyll fluorescence have improved our confidence in detecting short-term gm responses, but results need to be carefully evaluated. Environmental factors like vapour pressure deficit and CO2 concentration indirectly impact gm through gsc changes, highlighting some of the complex interactions between the two parameters. Evidence suggests that short-term responses of gm are not, or at least not fully, mechanistically linked to changes in gsc, cautioning against using gsc as a reliable proxy for gm. The overarching challenge lies in unravelling the mechanistic basis of short-term gm responses, which will contribute to the development of accurate models bridging laboratory insights with broader ecological implications. Addressing these gaps in understanding is crucial for refining predictions of gm behaviour under changing environmental conditions.

A step forward in the study of photosynthetic limitation by CO2 diffusion into the mesophyll

This article is a Commentary on Rao et al. (2024), 243: 2102–2114.

Harnessing photosynthetic C18O16O discrimination dynamics under leaf water nonsteady state to estimate mesophyll conductance: a new, regression-based method

Mesophyll conductance (gm) is a crucial plant trait that can significantly limit photosynthesis. Measurement of photosynthetic C18O16O discrimination (Δ18O) has proved to be the only viable means of resolving gm in both C3 and C4 plants. However, the currently available methods to exploit Δ18O for gm estimation are error prone due to their inadequacy in constraining the degree of oxygen isotope exchange (θ) during mesophyll CO2 hydration. Here, we capitalized on experimental manipulation of leaf water isotopic dynamics to establish a novel, nonsteady state, regression-based approach for simultaneous determination of gm and θ from online Δ18O measurements. We demonstrated the methodological and theoretical robustness of this new Δ18O-gm estimation approach and showed through measurements on several C3 and C4 species that this approach can serve as a benchmark method against which to identify previously-unrecognized biases of the existing Δ18O-gm methods. Our results highlight the unique value of this nonsteady state-based approach for contributing to ongoing efforts toward quantitative understanding of mesophyll conductance for crop yield improvement and carbon cycle modeling.

Cooperation of an external carbonic anhydrase and HCO3- transporter supports underwater photosynthesis in submerged leaves of the amphibious plant Hygrophila difformis

BACKGROUND AND AIMS

HCO3- can be a major carbon resource for photosynthesis in underwater environments. Here we investigate the underlying mechanism of uptake and membrane transport of HCO3- in submerged leaves of Hygrophila difformis, a heterophyllous amphibious plant. To characterize these mechanisms, we evaluated the sensitivity of underwater photosynthesis to an external carbonic anhydrase (CA) inhibitor and an anion exchanger protein inhibitor, and we attempted to identify components of the mechanism of HCO3- utilization.

METHODS

We evaluated the effects of the external CA inhibitor and anion exchanger protein inhibitor on the NaHCO3 response of photosynthetic O2 evolution in submerged leaves of H. difformis. Furthermore, we performed a comparative transcriptomic analysis between terrestrial and submerged leaves.

KEY RESULTS

Photosynthesis in the submerged leaves was decreased by both the external CA inhibitor and anion exchanger protein inhibitor, but no additive effect was observed. Among upregulated genes in submerged leaves, two α-CAs, Hdα-CA1 and Hdα-CA2, and one β-carbonic anhydrase, Hdβ-CA1, were detected. Based on their putative amino acid sequences, the α-CAs are predicted to be localized in the apoplastic region. Recombinant Hdα-CA1 and Hdβ-CA1 showed dominant CO2 hydration activity over HCO3- dehydration activity.

CONCLUSIONS

We propose that the use of HCO3- for photosynthesis in submerged leaves of H. difformis is driven by the cooperation between an external CA, Hdα-CA1, and an unidentified HCO3- transporter.

Using Carbon Stable Isotopes to Study C3 and C4 Photosynthesis: Models and Calculations

Stable carbon isotopes are a powerful tool to study photosynthesis. Initial applications consisted of determining isotope ratios of plant biomass using mass spectrometry. Subsequently, theoretical models relating C isotope values to gas exchange characteristics were introduced and tested against instantaneous online measurements of 13C photosynthetic discrimination. Beginning in the twenty-first century, laser absorption spectroscopes with sufficient precision for determining isotope mixing ratios became commercially available. This has allowed collection of large data sets at lower cost and with unprecedented temporal resolution. More data and accompanying knowledge have permitted refinement of 13C discrimination model equations, but often at the expense of increased model complexity and difficult parametrization. This chapter describes instantaneous online measurements of 13C photosynthetic discrimination, provides recommendations for experimental setup, and presents a thorough compilation of equations available to researchers. We update our previous 2018 version of this chapter by including recently improved descriptions of (photo)respiratory processes and associated fractionations. We discuss the capabilities and limitations of the diverse 13C discrimination model equations and provide guidance for selecting the model complexity needed for different applications.

Effects of leaf age during drought and recovery on photosynthesis, mesophyll conductance and leaf anatomy in wheat leaves

statement: Mesophyll conductance (g _m) was negatively correlated with wheat leaf age but was positively correlated with the surface area of chloroplasts exposed to intercellular airspaces (S _c). The rate of decline in photosynthetic rate and g _m as leaves aged was slower for water-stressed than well-watered plants. Upon rewatering, the degree of recovery from water-stress depended on the age of the leaves, with the strongest recovery for mature leaves, rather than young or old leaves. Diffusion of CO₂ from the intercellular airspaces to the site of Rubisco within C₃ plant chloroplasts (g_m) governs photosynthetic CO₂ assimilation (A). However, variation in g _m in response to environmental stress during leaf development remains poorly understood. Age-dependent changes in leaf ultrastructure and potential impacts on g _m, A, and stomatal conductance to CO₂ (g _sc) were investigated for wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) in well-watered and water-stressed plants, and after recovery by re-watering of droughted plants. Significant reductions in A and g _m were found as leaves aged. The oldest plants (15 days and 22 days) in water-stressed conditions showed higher A and gm compared to irrigated plants. The rate of decline in A and g _m as leaves aged was slower for water-stressed compared to well-watered plants. When droughted plants were rewatered, the degree of recovery depended on the age of the leaves, but only for g _m. The surface area of chloroplasts exposed to intercellular airspaces (S _c) and the size of individual chloroplasts declined as leaves aged, resulting in a positive correlation between g _m and S _c. Leaf age significantly affected cell wall thickness (t _cw), which was higher in old leaves compared to mature/young leaves. Greater knowledge of leaf anatomical traits associated with g _m partially explained changes in physiology with leaf age and plant water status, which in turn should create more possibilities for improving photosynthesis using breeding/biotechnological strategies.

CO2 mesophyll conductance regulated by light: a review

MAIN CONCLUSION

Light quality and intensity regulate plant mesophyll conductance, which has played an essential role in photosynthesis by controlling leaf structural and biochemical properties. Mesophyll conductance (g_m), a crucial physiological factor influencing the photosynthetic rate of leaves, is used to describe the resistance of CO₂ from the sub-stomatal cavity into the chloroplast up to the carboxylation site. Leaf structural and biochemical components, as well as external environmental factors such as light, temperature, and water, all impact g_m. As an essential factor of plant photosynthesis, light affects plant growth and development and plays a vital role in regulating g_m as well as determining photosynthesis and yield. This review aimed to summarize the mechanisms of g_m response to light. Both structural and biochemical perspectives were combined to reveal the effects of light quality and intensity on the g_m, providing a guide for selecting the optimal conditions for intensifying photosynthesis in plants.

Exploring the potential of Δ17O in CO2 for determining mesophyll conductance

Mesophyll conductance to CO2 from the intercellular air space to the CO2-H2O exchange site has been estimated using δ18O measurements (gm18). However, the gm18 estimates are affected by the uncertainties in the δ18O of leaf water where the CO2-H2O exchange takes place and the degree of equilibration between CO2 and H2O. We show that measurements of Δ17O (i.e.Δ17O=δ17O-0.528×δ18O) can provide independent constraints on gm (gmΔ17) and that these gm estimates are less affected by fractionation processes during gas exchange. The gm calculations are applied to combined measurements of δ18O and Δ17O, and gas exchange in two C3 species, sunflower (Helianthus annuus L. cv. 'sunny') and ivy (Hedera hibernica L.), and the C4 species maize (Zea mays). The gm18 and gmΔ17 estimates agree within the combined errors (P-value, 0.876). Both approaches are associated with large errors when the isotopic composition in the intercellular air space becomes close to the CO2-H2O exchange site. Although variations in Δ17O are low, it can be measured with much higher precision compared with δ18O. Measuring gmΔ17 has a few advantages compared with gm18: (i) it is less sensitive to uncertainty in the isotopic composition of leaf water at the isotope exchange site and (ii) the relative change in the gm due to an assumed error in the equilibration fraction θeq is lower for gmΔ17 compared with gm18. Thus, using Δ17O can complement and improve the gm estimates in settings where the δ18O of leaf water varies strongly, affecting the δ18O (CO2) difference between the intercellular air space and the CO2-H2O exchange site.

Mesophyll conductance response to short-term changes in pCO2 is related to leaf anatomy and biochemistry in diverse C4 grasses

Mesophyll CO₂ conductance (g_m ) in C₃ species responds to short-term (minutes) changes in environment potentially due to changes in leaf anatomical and biochemical properties and measurement artefacts. Compared with C₃ species, there is less information on g_m responses to short-term changes in environmental conditions such as partial pressure of CO₂ (pCO₂ ) across diverse C₄ species and the potential determinants of these responses. Using 16 C₄ grasses we investigated the response of g_m to short-term changes in pCO₂ and its relationship with leaf anatomy and biochemistry. In general, g_m increased as pCO₂ decreased (statistically significant increase in 12 species), with percentage increases in g_m ranging from +13% to +250%. Greater increase in g_m at low pCO₂ was observed in species exhibiting relatively thinner mesophyll cell walls along with greater mesophyll surface area exposed to intercellular air spaces, leaf N, photosynthetic capacity and activities of phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase and Rubisco. Species with greater CO₂ responses of g_m were also able to maintain their leaf water-use efficiencies (TE_i ) under low CO₂ . Our study advances understanding of CO₂ response of g_m in diverse C₄ species, identifies the key leaf traits related to this response and has implications for improving C₄ photosynthetic models and TE_i through modification of g_m .

Overexpression of cytoplasmic C4 Flaveria bidentis carbonic anhydrase in C3 Arabidopsis thaliana increases amino acids, photosynthetic potential, and biomass

An important method to improve photosynthesis in C₃ crops, such as rice and wheat, is to transfer efficient C₄ characters to them. Here, cytosolic carbonic anhydrase (CA: βCA3) of the C₄ Flaveria bidentis (Fb) was overexpressed under the control of ³⁵ S promoter in Arabidopsis thaliana, a C₃ plant, to enhance its photosynthetic efficiency. Overexpression of CA resulted in a better supply of the substrate HCO3- for the endogenous phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase in the cytosol of the overexpressers, and increased its activity for generating malate that feeds into the tricarboxylic acid cycle. This provided additional carbon skeleton for increased synthesis of amino acids aspartate, asparagine, glutamate, and glutamine. Increased amino acids contributed to higher protein content in the transgenics. Furthermore, expression of FbβCA3 in Arabidopsis led to a better growth due to expression of several genes leading to higher chlorophyll content, electron transport, and photosynthetic carbon assimilation in the transformants. Enhanced CO₂ assimilation resulted in increased sugar and starch content, and plant dry weight. In addition, transgenic plants had lower stomatal conductance, reduced transpiration rate, and higher water-use efficiency. These results, taken together, show that expression of C₄ CA in the cytosol of a C₃ plant can indeed improve its photosynthetic capacity with enhanced water-use efficiency.

Lack of leaf carbonic anhydrase activity eliminates the C4 carbon-concentrating mechanism requiring direct diffusion of CO2 into bundle sheath cells

Carbonic anhydrase (CA) performs the first enzymatic step of C₄ photosynthesis by catalysing the reversible hydration of dissolved CO₂ that diffuses into mesophyll cells from intercellular airspaces. This CA-catalysed reaction provides the bicarbonate used by phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase to generate products that flow into the C₄ carbon-concentrating mechanism (CCM). It was previously demonstrated that the Zea mays ca1ca2 double mutant lost 97% of leaf CA activity, but there was little difference in the growth phenotype under ambient CO₂ partial pressures (pCO₂ ). We hypothesise that since CAs are among the fastest enzymes, minimal activity from a third CA, CA8, can provide the inorganic carbon needed to drive C₄ photosynthesis. We observed that removing CA8 from the maize ca1ca2 background resulted in plants that had 0.2% of wild-type leaf CA activity. These ca1ca2ca8 plants had reduced photosynthetic parameters and could only survive at elevated pCO₂ . Photosynthetic and carbon isotope analysis combined with modelling of photosynthesis and carbon isotope discrimination was used to determine if ca1ca2ca8 plants had a functional C₄ cycle or were relying on direct CO₂ diffusion to ribulose 1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase within bundle sheath cells. The results suggest that leaf CA activity in ca1ca2ca8 plants was not sufficient to sustain the C₄ CCM.

Limitation of C4 photosynthesis by low carbonic anhydrase activity increases with temperature but does not influence mesophyll CO2 conductance

The CO2-concentrating mechanism (CCM) in C4 plants is initiated by the uptake of bicarbonate (HCO3-) via phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase (PEPC). Generation of HCO3- for PEPC is determined by the interaction between mesophyll CO2 conductance and the hydration of CO2 to HCO3- by carbonic anhydrase (CA). Genetic reduction of CA was previously shown not to limit C4 photosynthesis under ambient atmospheric partial pressures of CO2 (pCO2). However, CA activity varies widely across C4 species and it is unknown if there are specific environmental conditions (e.g. high temperature) where CA may limit HCO3- production for C4 photosynthesis. Additionally, CA activity has been suggested to influence mesophyll conductance, but this has not been experimentally tested. We hypothesize that CA activity can limit PEPC at high temperatures, particularly at low pCO2, but does not directly influence gm. Here we tested the influence of genetically reduced CA activity on photosynthesis and gm in the C4 plant Zea mays under a range of pCO2 and temperatures. Reduced CA activity limited HCO3- production for C4 photosynthesis at low pCO2 as temperatures increased, but did not influence mesophyll conductance. Therefore, high leaf CA activity may enhance C4 photosynthesis under high temperature when stomatal conductance restricts the availability of atmospheric CO2.

Expression of a CO2-permeable aquaporin enhances mesophyll conductance in the C4 species Setaria viridis

A fundamental limitation of photosynthetic carbon fixation is the availability of CO₂. In C₄ plants, primary carboxylation occurs in mesophyll cytosol, and little is known about the role of CO₂ diffusion in facilitating C₄ photosynthesis. We have examined the expression, localization, and functional role of selected plasma membrane intrinsic aquaporins (PIPs) from Setaria italica (foxtail millet) and discovered that SiPIP2;7 is CO₂-permeable. When ectopically expressed in mesophyll cells of Setaria viridis (green foxtail), SiPIP2;7 was localized to the plasma membrane and caused no marked changes in leaf biochemistry. Gas exchange and C¹⁸O¹⁶O discrimination measurements revealed that targeted expression of SiPIP2;7 enhanced the conductance to CO₂ diffusion from the intercellular airspace to the mesophyll cytosol. Our results demonstrate that mesophyll conductance limits C₄ photosynthesis at low pCO₂ and that SiPIP2;7 is a functional CO₂ permeable aquaporin that can improve CO₂ diffusion at the airspace/mesophyll interface and enhance C₄ photosynthesis.

Updating the steady-state model of C4 photosynthesis

C4 plants play a key role in world agriculture. For example, C4 crops such as maize and sorghum are major contributors to food production in both developed and developing countries, and the C4 grasses sugarcane, miscanthus, and switchgrass are major plant sources of bioenergy. In the challenge to manipulate and enhance C4 photosynthesis, steady-state models of leaf photosynthesis provide an important tool for gas exchange analysis and thought experiments that can explore photosynthetic pathway changes. Here a previous C4 photosynthetic model developed by von Caemmerer and Furbank has been updated with new kinetic parameterization and temperature dependencies added. The parameterization was derived from experiments on the C4 monocot, Setaria viridis, which for the first time provides a cohesive parameterization. Mesophyll conductance and its temperature dependence have also been included, as this is an important step in the quantitative correlation between the initial slope of the CO2 response curve of CO2 assimilation and in vitro phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase activity. Furthermore, the equations for chloroplast electron transport have been updated to include cyclic electron transport flow, and equations have been added to calculate the electron transport rate from measured CO2 assimilation rates.

Updating the steady-state model of C4 photosynthesis

C4 plants play a key role in world agriculture. For example, C4 crops such as maize and sorghum are major contributors to food production in both developed and developing countries, and the C4 grasses sugarcane, miscanthus, and switchgrass are major plant sources of bioenergy. In the challenge to manipulate and enhance C4 photosynthesis, steady-state models of leaf photosynthesis provide an important tool for gas exchange analysis and thought experiments that can explore photosynthetic pathway changes. Here a previous C4 photosynthetic model developed by von Caemmerer and Furbank has been updated with new kinetic parameterization and temperature dependencies added. The parameterization was derived from experiments on the C4 monocot, Setaria viridis, which for the first time provides a cohesive parameterization. Mesophyll conductance and its temperature dependence have also been included, as this is an important step in the quantitative correlation between the initial slope of the CO2 response curve of CO2 assimilation and in vitro phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase activity. Furthermore, the equations for chloroplast electron transport have been updated to include cyclic electron transport flow, and equations have been added to calculate the electron transport rate from measured CO2 assimilation rates.

Leaf scale quantification of the effect of photosynthetic gas exchange on Δ47 of CO2

The clumped isotope composition (Δ₄₇, the anomaly of the mass 47 isotopologue relative to the abundance expected from a random isotope distribution) of CO₂ has been suggested as an additional tracer for gross CO₂ fluxes. However, the effect of photosynthetic gas exchange on Δ₄₇ has not been directly determined and two indirect/conceptual studies reported contradicting results. In this study, we quantify the effect of photosynthetic gas exchange on Δ₄₇ of CO₂ using leaf cuvette experiments with one C₄ and two C₃ plants. The experimental results are supported by calculations with a leaf cuvette model. Our results demonstrate the important roles of the Δ₄₇ value of CO₂ entering the leaf, kinetic fractionation as CO₂ diffuses into, and out of the leaf and CO₂–H₂O isotope exchange with leaf water. We experimentally confirm the previously suggested dependence of Δ₄₇ of CO₂ in the air surrounding a leaf on the stomatal conductance and back-diffusion flux. Gas exchange can enrich or deplete the Δ₄₇ of CO₂ depending on the Δ₄₇ of CO₂ entering the leaf and the fraction of CO₂ exchanged with leaf water and diffused back to the atmosphere, but under typical ambient conditions, it will lead to a decrease in Δ₄₇.

Differences in leaf anatomy determines temperature response of leaf hydraulic and mesophyll CO2 conductance in phylogenetically related C4 and C3 grass species

Leaf hydraulic and mesophyll CO₂ conductance are both influenced by leaf anatomical traits, however it is poorly understood how the temperature response of these conductances differs between C₄ and C₃ species with distinct leaf anatomy. This study investigated the temperature response of leaf hydraulic conductance (K_leaf ), stomatal (g_s ) and mesophyll (g_m ) conductance to CO₂ , and leaf anatomical traits in phylogenetically related Panicum antidotale (C₄ ) and P. bisulcatum (C₃ ) grasses. The C₄ species had lower hydraulic conductance outside xylem (K_ox ) and K_leaf compared with the C₃ species. However, the C₄ species had higher g_m compared with the C₃ species. Traits associated with leaf water movement, K_leaf and K_ox , increased with temperature more in the C₃ than in the C₄ species, whereas traits related to carbon uptake, A_net and g_m , increased more with temperature in the C₄ than the C₃ species. Our findings demonstrate that, in addition to a CO₂ concentrating mechanism, outside-xylem leaf anatomy in the C₄ species P. antidotale favours lower water movement through the leaf and stomata that provides an additional advantage for greater leaf carbon uptake relative to water loss with increasing leaf temperature than in the C₃ species P. bisulcatum.

Linking canopy-scale mesophyll conductance and phloem sugar δ13 C using empirical and modelling approaches

Interpreting phloem carbohydrate or xylem tissue carbon isotopic composition as measures of water-use efficiency or past tree productivity requires in-depth knowledge of the factors altering the isotopic composition within the pathway from ambient air to phloem contents and tree ring. One of least understood of these factors is mesophyll conductance (g_m ). We formulated a dynamic model describing the leaf photosynthetic pathway including seven alternative g_m descriptions and a simple transport of sugars from foliage down the trunk. We parameterised the model for a boreal Scots pine stand and compared simulated g_m responses with weather variations. We further compared the simulated δ¹³ C of new photosynthates among the different g_m descriptions and against measured phloem sugar δ¹³ C. Simulated g_m estimates of the seven descriptions varied according to weather conditions, resulting in varying estimates of phloem δ¹³ C during cold/moist and warm/dry periods. The model succeeded in predicting a drought response and a postdrought release in phloem sugar δ¹³ C indicating suitability of the model for inverse prediction of leaf processes from phloem isotopic composition. We suggest short-interval phloem sampling during and after extreme weather conditions to distinguish between mesophyll conductance drivers for future model development.

C4 grasses adapted to low precipitation habitats show traits related to greater mesophyll conductance and lower leaf hydraulic conductance

In habitats with low water availability, a fundamental challenge for plants will be to maximize photosynthetic C-gain while minimizing transpirational water-loss. This trade-off between C-gain and water-loss can in part be achieved through the coordination of leaf-level photosynthetic and hydraulic traits. To test the relationship of photosynthetic C-gain and transpirational water-loss, we grew, under common growth conditions, 18 C₄ grasses adapted to habitats with different mean annual precipitation (MAP) and measured leaf-level structural and anatomical traits associated with mesophyll conductance (g_m ) and leaf hydraulic conductance (K_leaf ). The C₄ grasses adapted to lower MAP showed greater mesophyll surface area exposed to intercellular air spaces (S_mes ) and adaxial stomatal density (SD_ada ) which supported greater g_m . These grasses also showed greater leaf thickness and vein-to-epidermis distance, which may lead to lower K_leaf . Additionally, grasses with greater g_m and lower K_leaf also showed greater photosynthetic rates (A_net ) and leaf-level water-use efficiency (WUE). In summary, we identify a suite of leaf-level traits that appear important for adaptation of C₄ grasses to habitats with low MAP and may be useful to identify C₄ species showing greater A_net and WUE in drier conditions.

Mesophyll CO2 conductance and leakiness are not responsive to short- and long-term soil water limitations in the C4 plant Sorghum bicolor

Breeding economically important C₄ crops for enhanced whole-plant water-use efficiency (WUE_plant ) is needed for sustainable agriculture. WUE_plant is a complex trait and an efficient phenotyping method that reports on components of WUE_plant , such as intrinsic water-use efficiency (WUE_i , the rate of leaf CO₂ assimilation relative to water loss via stomatal conductance), is needed. In C₄ plants, theoretical models suggest that leaf carbon isotope composition (δ¹³ C), when the efficiency of the CO₂ -concentrating mechanism (leakiness, ϕ) remains constant, can be used to screen for WUE_i . The limited information about how ϕ responds to water limitations confines the application of δ¹³ C for WUE_i screening of C₄ crops. The current research aimed to test the response of ϕ to short- or long-term moderate water limitations, and the relationship of δ¹³ C with WUE_i and WUE_plant , by addressing potential mesophyll CO₂ conductance (g_m ) and biochemical limitations in the C₄ plant Sorghum bicolor. We demonstrate that g_m and ϕ are not responsive to short- or long-term water limitations. Additionally, δ¹³ C was not correlated with gas-exchange estimates of WUE_i under short- and long-term water limitations, but showed a significant negative relationship with WUE_plant . The observed association between the δ¹³ C and WUE_plant suggests an intrinsic link of δ¹³ C with WUE_i in this C₄ plant, and can potentially be used as a screening tool for WUE_plant in sorghum.

Cold acclimation of mesophyll conductance, bundle-sheath conductance and leakiness in Miscanthus × giganteus

The cold acclimations of mesophyll conductance (g_m ), bundle-sheath conductance (g_bs ) and the CO₂ concentrating mechanism (CCM) of C₄ plants have not been well studied. Here, we estimated the temperature response of g_m , g_bs and leakiness (ϕ), the amount of concentrated CO₂ that escapes the bundle-sheath cells, for the chilling-tolerant C₄ plant Miscanthus × giganteus grown at 14 and 25°C. To estimate these parameters, we combined the C₄ -enzyme-limited photosynthesis model and the Δ¹³ C discrimination model. These combined models were parameterised using in vitro activities of carbonic anhydrase (CA), pyruvate, phosphate dikinase (PPDK), ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase (RuBisCO), and phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase (PEPc). Cold-grown Miscanthus plants increased in vitro activities of RuBisCO and PPDK but decreased PEPc activity compared with warm-grown plants. Mesophyll conductance and g_bs responded strongly to measurement temperatures but did not differ between plants from the two growth temperatures. Furthermore, modelling showed that ϕ increased with measurement temperatures for both cold-grown and warm-grown plants, but was only marginally larger in cold-grown compared with warm-grown plants. Our results in Miscanthus support that g_m and g_bs are unresponsive to growth temperature and that the CCM is able to acclimate to cold through increased activity of PPDK and RuBisCO.

Mesophyll conductance: the leaf corridors for photosynthesis

Besides stomata, the photosynthetic CO2 pathway also involves the transport of CO2 from the sub-stomatal air spaces inside to the carboxylation sites in the chloroplast stroma, where Rubisco is located. This pathway is far to be a simple and direct way, formed by series of consecutive barriers that the CO2 should cross to be finally assimilated in photosynthesis, known as the mesophyll conductance (gm). Therefore, the gm reflects the pathway through different air, water and biophysical barriers within the leaf tissues and cell structures. Currently, it is known that gm can impose the same level of limitation (or even higher depending of the conditions) to photosynthesis than the wider known stomata or biochemistry. In this mini-review, we are focused on each of the gm determinants to summarize the current knowledge on the mechanisms driving gm from anatomical to metabolic and biochemical perspectives. Special attention deserve the latest studies demonstrating the importance of the molecular mechanisms driving anatomical traits as cell wall and the chloroplast surface exposed to the mesophyll airspaces (Sc/S) that significantly constrain gm. However, even considering these recent discoveries, still is poorly understood the mechanisms about signaling pathways linking the environment a/biotic stressors with gm responses. Thus, considering the main role of gm as a major driver of the CO2 availability at the carboxylation sites, future studies into these aspects will help us to understand photosynthesis responses in a global change framework.

Emerging roles for carbonic anhydrase in mesophyll conductance and photosynthesis

Carbonic anhydrase (CA) is an abundant protein in most photosynthesizing organisms and higher plants. This review paper considers the physiological importance of the more abundant CA isoforms in photosynthesis, through their effects on CO₂ diffusion and other processes in photosynthetic organisms. In plants, CA has multiple isoforms in three different families (α, β and γ) and is mainly known to catalyze the CO₂↔HCO3- equilibrium. This reversible conversion has a clear role in photosynthesis, primarily through sustaining the CO₂ concentration at the site of ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase (Rubisco). Despite showing the same major reaction mechanism, the three main CA families are evolutionarily distinct. For different CA isoforms, cellular localization and total gene expression as a function of developmental stage are predicted to determine the role of each family in relation to the net assimilation rate. Reaction-diffusion modeling and observational evidence support a role for CA activity in reducing resistance to CO₂ diffusion inside mesophyll cells by facilitating CO₂ transfer in both gas and liquid phases. In addition, physical and/or biochemical interactions between CAs and other membrane-bound compartments, for example aquaporins, are suggested to trigger a CO₂ -sensing response by stomatal movement. In response to environmental stresses, changes in the expression level of CAs and/or stimulated deactivation of CAs may correspond with lower photosynthetic capacity. We suggest that further studies should focus on the dynamics of the relationship between the activity of CAs (with different subcellular localization, abundance and gene expression) and limitations due to CO₂ diffusivity through the mesophyll and supply of CO₂ to photosynthetic reactions.

Recent developments in mesophyll conductance in C3, C4, and crassulacean acid metabolism plants

The conductance of carbon dioxide (CO₂ ) from the substomatal cavities to the initial sites of CO₂ fixation (g_m ) can significantly reduce the availability of CO₂ for photosynthesis. There have been many recent reviews on: (i) the importance of g_m for accurately modelling net rates of CO₂ assimilation, (ii) on how leaf biochemical and anatomical factors influence g_m , (iii) the technical limitation of estimating g_m , which cannot be directly measured, and (iv) how g_m responds to long- and short-term changes in growth and measurement environmental conditions. Therefore, this review will highlight these previous publications but will attempt not to repeat what has already been published. We will instead initially focus on the recent developments on the two-resistance model of g_m that describe the potential of photorespiratory and respiratory CO₂ released within the mitochondria to diffuse directly into both the chloroplast and the cytosol. Subsequently, we summarize recent developments in the three-dimensional (3-D) reaction-diffusion models and 3-D image analysis that are providing new insights into how the complex structure and organization of the leaf influences g_m . Finally, because most of the reviews and literature on g_m have traditionally focused on C₃ plants we review in the final sections some of the recent developments, current understanding and measurement techniques of g_m in C₄ and crassulacean acid metabolism (CAM) plants. These plants have both specialized leaf anatomy and either a spatially or temporally separated CO₂ concentrating mechanisms (C₄ and CAM, respectively) that influence how we interpret and estimate g_m compared with a C₃ plants.

Cellular perspectives for improving mesophyll conductance

After entering the leaf, CO2 faces an intricate pathway to the site of photosynthetic fixation embedded within the chloroplasts. The efficiency of CO2 flux is hindered by a number of structural and biochemical barriers which, together, define the ease of flow of the gas within the leaf, termed mesophyll conductance. Previous authors have identified the key elements of this pathway, raising the prospect of engineering the system to improve CO2 flux and, thus, to increase leaf photosynthetic efficiency. In this review, we provide a perspective on the potential for improving the individual elements that contribute to this complex parameter. We lay particular emphasis on generation of the cellular architecture of the leaf which sets the initial boundaries of a number of mesophyll conductance parameters, incorporating an overview of the molecular transport processes which have been proposed as major facilitators of CO2 flux across structural boundaries along the pathway. The review highlights the research areas where future effort might be invested to increase our fundamental understanding of mesophyll conductance and leaf function and, consequently, to enable translation of these findings to improve the efficiency of crop photosynthesis.

Increased adaxial stomatal density is associated with greater mesophyll surface area exposed to intercellular air spaces and mesophyll conductance in diverse C4 grasses

Mesophyll conductance (g_m ) is the diffusion of CO₂ from intercellular air spaces (IAS) to the first site of carboxylation in the mesophyll cells. In C₃ species, g_m is influenced by diverse leaf structural and anatomical traits; however, little is known about traits affecting g_m in C₄ species. To address this knowledge gap, we used online oxygen isotope discrimination measurements to estimate g_m and microscopy techniques to measure leaf structural and anatomical traits potentially related to g_m in 18 C₄ grasses. In this study, g_m scaled positively with photosynthesis and intrinsic water-use efficiency (TE_i ), but not with stomatal conductance. Also, g_m was not determined by a single trait but was positively correlated with adaxial stomatal densities (SD_ada ), stomatal ratio (SR), mesophyll surface area exposed to IAS (S_mes ) and leaf thickness. However, g_m was not related to abaxial stomatal densities (SD_aba ) and mesophyll cell wall thickness (T_CW ). Our study suggests that greater SD_ada and SR increased g_m by increasing S_mes and creating additional parallel pathways for CO₂ diffusion inside mesophyll cells. Thus, SD_ada , SR and S_mes are important determinants of C₄ -g_m and could be the target traits selected or modified for achieving greater g_m and TE_i in C₄ species.

Effect of Vapor Pressure Deficit on Gas Exchange in Wild-Type and Abscisic Acid-Insensitive Plants

Stomata control the gas exchange of terrestrial plant leaves, and are therefore essential to plant growth and survival. We investigated gas exchange responses to vapor pressure deficit (VPD) in two gray poplar (Populus × canescens) lines: wild type and abscisic acid-insensitive (abi1) with functionally impaired stomata. Transpiration rate in abi1 increased linearly with VPD, up to about 2 kPa. Above this, sharply declining transpiration was followed by leaf death. In contrast, wild type showed a steady or slightly declining transpiration rate up to VPD of nearly 7 kPa, and fully recovered photosynthetic function afterward. There were marked differences in discrimination against 13CO2 (Δ13C) and C18OO (Δ18O) between abi1 and wild-type plants. The Δ13C indicated that intercellular CO2 concentrations decreased with VPD in wild-type plants, but not in abi1 plants. The Δ18O reflected progressive stomatal closure in wild type in response to increasing VPD; however, in abi1, stomata remained open and oxygen atoms of CO2 continued to exchange with 18O enriched leaf water. Coupled measurements of Δ18O and gas exchange were used to estimate intercellular vapor pressure, e i In wild-type leaves, there was no evidence of unsaturation of e i, even at VPD above 6 kPa. In abi1 leaves, e i approached 0.6 times saturation vapor pressure before the precipitous decline in transpiration rate. For wild type, a sensitive stomatal response to increasing VPD was pivotal in preventing unsaturation of e i In abi1, after taking unsaturation into account, stomatal conductance increased with increasing VPD, consistent with a disabled active response of guard cell osmotic pressure.

Two-Source δ18O Method to Validate the CO18O-Photosynthetic Discrimination Model: Implications for Mesophyll Conductance

Theoretical models of photosynthetic isotopic discrimination of CO2 (13C and 18O) are commonly used to estimate mesophyll conductance (g m). This requires making simplifying assumptions and assigning parameter values so that g m can be solved for as the residual term. Uncertainties in g m estimation occur due to measurement noise and assumptions not holding, including parameter uncertainty and model parametrization. Uncertainties in the 13C model have been explored previously, but there has been little testing undertaken to determine the reliability of g m estimates from the 18O model (g m18). In this study, we exploited the action of carbonic anhydrase in equilibrating CO2 with leaf water and manipulated the observed photosynthetic discrimination (Δ18O) by changing the oxygen isotopic composition of the source gas CO2 and water vapor. We developed a two-source δ18O method, whereby two measurements of Δ18O were obtained for a leaf with its gas-exchange characteristics otherwise unchanged. Measurements were performed in broad bean (Vicia faba) and Algerian oak (Quercus canariensis) in response to light and vapor pressure deficit. Despite manipulating the Δ18O by over 100‰, in most cases we observed consistency in the calculated g m18, providing confidence in the measurements and model theory. Where there were differences in g m18 estimates between source-gas measurements, we explored uncertainty associated with two model assumptions (the isotopic composition of water at the sites of CO2-water exchange, and the humidity of the leaf internal airspace) and found evidence for both. Finally, we provide experimental guidelines to minimize the sensitivity of g m18 estimates to measurement errors. The two-source δ18O method offers a flexible tool for model parameterization and provides an opportunity to refine our understanding of leaf water and CO2 fluxes.

The role of leaf width and conductances to CO2 in determining water use efficiency in C4 grasses

C₄ plants achieve higher photosynthesis (A_n ) and intrinsic water use efficiency (iWUE) than C₃ plants, but processes underpinning the variability in A_n and iWUE across the three C₄ subtypes remain unclear, partly because we lack an integrated framework for quantifying the contribution of diffusional and biochemical limitations to C₄ photosynthesis. We exploited the natural diversity among C₄ grasses to develop an original mathematical approach for estimating eight key processes of C₄ photosynthesis and their relative limitations to A_n . We also developed a new formulation to estimate mesophyll conductance (g_m ) based on actual hydration rates of CO₂ by carbonic anhydrases. We found a positive relationship between g_m and iWUE and an inverse correlation with g_sw among C₄ grasses. We also revealed subtype-specific regulatory processes of iWUE that may be related to known anatomical traits characterising each C₄ subtype. Leaf width was an important determinant of iWUE and showed significant correlations with key limitations of A_n , especially among NADP-ME species. In conclusion, incorporating leaf width in breeding trials may unlock new opportunities for C₄ crops because the revealed negative relationship between leaf width and iWUE may translate into higher crop and canopy WUE.

The temperature response of mesophyll conductance, and its component conductances, varies between species and genotypes

The temperature response of mesophyll conductance to CO₂ diffusion (g_m) has been shown to vary considerably between species but remains poorly understood. Here, we tested the hypothesis that increases in chloroplast surface area with increasing temperature, due to the formation of chloroplast protrusions, caused observed positive responses of g_m to temperature. We found no evidence of chloroplast protrusions. Using simultaneous measurements of carbon and oxygen isotope discrimination during photosynthesis to separate total g_m (g_m13) into cell wall and plasma membrane conductance (g_m18) and chloroplast membrane conductance (g_cm) components, we explored the temperature response in genotypes of soybean and barley, and sunflower plants grown at differing CO₂ concentrations. Differences in the temperature sensitivity of g_m18 were found between genotypes and between plants grown at differing CO₂ concentration but did not relate to measured anatomical features such as chloroplast surface area or cell wall thickness. The closest fit of modelled g_m13 to estimated values was found when cell wall thickness was allowed to decline at higher temperatures and transpiration rates, but it remains to be tested if this decline is realistic. The temperature response of g_cm (calculated from the difference between 1/g_m13 and 1/g_m18) varied between barley genotypes, and was best fitted by an optimal response in sunflower. Taken together, these results indicate that g_m is a highly complex trait with unpredictable sensitivity to temperature that varies between species, between genotypes within a single species, with growth environment, between replicate leaves, and even with age for an individual leaf.

Critical review: incorporating the arrangement of mitochondria and chloroplasts into models of photosynthesis and carbon isotope discrimination

The arrangement of mitochondria and chloroplasts, together with the relative resistances of cell wall and chloroplast, determine the path of diffusion out of the leaf for (photo)respired CO₂. Traditional photosynthesis models have assumed a tight arrangement of chloroplasts packed together against the cell wall with mitochondria located behind the chloroplasts, deep inside the cytosol. Accordingly, all (photo)respired CO₂ must cross the chloroplast before diffusing out of the leaf. Different arrangements have recently been considered, where all or part of the (photo)respired CO₂ diffuses through the cytosol without ever entering the chloroplast. Assumptions about the path for the (photo)respiratory flux are particularly relevant for the calculation of mesophyll conductance (g_m). If (photo)respired CO₂ can diffuse elsewhere besides the chloroplast, apparent g_m is no longer a mere physical resistance but a flux-weighted variable sensitive to the ratio of (photo)respiration to net CO₂ assimilation. We discuss existing photosynthesis models in conjunction with their treatment of the (photo)respiratory flux and present new equations applicable to the generalized case where (photo)respired CO₂ can diffuse both into the chloroplast and through the cytosol. Additionally, we present a new generalized Δ¹³C model that incorporates this dual diffusion pathway. We assess how assumptions about the fate of (photo)respired CO₂ affect the interpretation of photosynthetic data and the challenges it poses for the application of different models.